@@itzanopinion Just pointing that statistically, last year's OL was very much below-par as far as pass pro is concerned. Run blocking, sure, but passing, that was a rough spot esp. at guard. And it was one of their worse performance in the past couple years, so if anything Jimmy had *better* pass pro.
@@itzanopiniontrolls gonna troll. If you think Jimmy can be even mentioned in the same breath as Purdy, you need to stop pretending to watch football.
Jimmy g will be out of the league next season. It’s crazy Jimmy g never got the system qb bash. Was it because he played along side Tom Brady that they thought he was good? Or was it because Brock was the last pick of the draft? Brock ain’t no system qb, Jimmy g is a system qb.
@@roemellobellyou mean the defense that completely failed to show up several times, and never played to their potential as shown in recent years? So if you know so much about football, what does a good defense normally support - RB or QB? CMC is amazing, but let's not pretend like the game the D did play well helped the passing game more than the running game... For the first time in history. So which is it?
NFL pundits mix up physical gifts with talent. Trey Lance is physically gifted while Brock Purdy is talented. Physical gifts are potential, talent translates to wins. Physical gifts are more seductive than talent and get a QB drafted earlier than talent.
Yup, it’s doesn’t matter if your coach tells you exactly where to look if you can’t see what you’re supposed to. And even if you can see it that doesn’t mean you’ll find it in time. And if you find it in time you still have to accurately deliver the ball.
Physical gifts and talent are the same thing.. hard work, dedication, discipline, mental toughness and intelligence translate to wins.. “hard work beats talent when talent doesn’t work hard”..
I disagree, physical gifts is talent. Hard work and dedication is what translates to wins. I’d argue Kaepernick benefited from having talent and was schemed up behind talented players but didn’t dedicate himself to the craft of QB yet was more successful than Alex Smith. Ironically enough, Trey Lance was blessed with physical gifts yet lacked the intangibles. He constantly was trying to work on his craft but wasn’t schemed up the same way Brock and Garapolo. Trey had to play with Sanu and run up the gut more times than his own RB (not CMC btw). Also helps when you play 4 years in college.
Yeah, but Garoppolo couldn’t find BA in a phone booth. Snead knows what it takes to capitalize on Shanahan’s schemes. Im thinking Brees is the model for Purdy and then add massive quads
Bethard stunk and mullens had success in the offense but stunk at the end of the day. A lot of qb’s can succeed in this system with these weapon. They made it to the super bowl and 2 nfc championships with below average/trash jimmy g with less weapons lmao
@@ninerempire3398 Jimmy wasn't trash he just wasn't good. A good playcaller can if the pieces are in place make average QB's look above average. Brock has been elite in the system which tells me he'd be fine no matter what. I'd go a tad further and say Brock is making the system look better. In the games he's been "bad" outside of the Bal game it's been the defense that put them in bad situations.....Cincy, Cle and Minny. Those games were them just trying to claw back into a chance to win.
What makes Brock great is his ability to process progressions extremely quickly while not allowing the pass rush to affect his decision making. He has a gift of sensing when pass rushers are on top of him and typically bails at the perfect time to keep the play alive.
Well put. I was on the fence longer than anyone, but I realize he definitely has a gift. He has the gift of recognition and hard work and determination much like Drew Brees was not the most talented thrower in the world, but he works so goddamn hard he became one of the greatest passers in NFL history, I'm really hoping Brock going to take that trajectory as a 49er.
The whole system thing is way overblown. A good playcaller is a playcaller but no matter what the QB has to be able to execute. Never seen a QB be elite without good talent and a good playcaller. What makes Brock better than most think is he did it behind one of the worst pass blocking Olines. It seems an excuse for others but when it comes to Brock it's not even talked about like "this guy is successful despite his Oline." Weird times
The QB position is simultaneously the least plug and play position, and somehow, most of the QBs in the league are system QBs. The duality of sports commentating
I agree, because if thats the case CJ, trey, nick mullens would still be on the roster. Take more than just a “system QB” to get the job done. There is a reason why QB’s are paid the most.
John Madden said the most important position on an NFL team is the quarterback. The 2nd most important position is the backup quarterback. Now think of the game Purdy got hurt in the Eagles game and what happened to his backup Josh Johnson who lasted a couple of plays.
Ive always thought Purdy was like Drew Brees, same size , both good scramblers , both make plays with athleticism outside the pocket. Purdys scrambling has allowed them to succeed with poor blocking.
What I’ve noticed about Brock is he keeps that line of scrimmage moving. There’s rarely a play where he’s not making the right decision to push the ball down field. It could be 5 yards or 25 yards that line is moving… he matriculates the ball down field. And also he has a deep ball the dude is really good
Look at how many QBs have been in Kyle's system and how many have been as successful as purdy ok yea we have alot of weapons but at the same time you still gotta go out there and make plays .. and what about when the play blows up and purdy makes it happen with his feet he's got great instincts aswell
You've clearly defended this point so much that you've lost some perspective. "safe" and "nurturing" aren't words I would use to describe a rookie being the last pick, 3rd string, starting mid season on a team with SB expectations, then executing about as well as anyone could. You care more about that Packers game than the other 20 starts. IS THE HILL YOU DIE ON? Plus for every centrist snead video you have, there's 100s of positive ones, so nice cherry picking
Oh he’s in a great system, he is a game manager, blah, blah, no kidding! What teams or QB’s that are winners aren’t running a great system? But Purdy has mastered this SF system. He’s smart! Put another QB in this system, and I’d bet they wouldn’t run it as efficiently as Brock does. Being in the perfect system doesn’t guarantee anything, you still have to execute it. And he does this consistently and to perfection.
if brock took u to the super bowl. then hes already great as he is right now, hes gonna be even better this year u guys watch out for our team cos we gonna take it all beat evey team out there brock been very good at his game tatics hes gon be balling everyone eles in the nfl league nfc/afc dont matter hes gonna win it all i promised u that ive been watching there practice camp its going good......god has a plan for his successes again.
I went back 4 years and watched 227 videos of coaches representing all 32 teams. It would seem EVERY team runs a "SYSTEM"! Please STOP with the system argument!!!
What team doesn't have a quarterback friendly offense that's not competing for championships? What am I missing? Reid's offense is a system that without someone like Mahomes, wouldn't be very good. We saw that with Garrapolo. I don't get some of these pundits who say Brock's just a game manager....I mean he's so good of a manager, they got to the Super Bowl. Go figure.
Your letting a wide receiver describe what it’s like being a qb but yet he only focuses on only their potion not making sure everyone is dialed into the play plus have 3.5 seconds to get the ball out that’s why a lot of first round qbs fail and you have players like dak, Russ Wilson, Brock, Matt Hasselbeck, Tom Brady, it takes skill and IQ of the game idk what Snead meant by that !
Julio Jones best season - Kyle Shanahan Andre Johnson - Kyle Shanahan WR coach 06' 1.1k yards (07' Andre had lest than 1k yards shanny QB coach) 08-10' Shanny O.C. Andre 1.5k yards Pierre Garcon Best season - Kyle Shanahan O.C. If BA leaves, it will be fine.
Kyle Shanahan Superbowl wins 0-3 I'm not for getting rid of Kyle but Kyle found ways to lose as he had the lead in each of those Superbowl visits. We won't be nearly as good without BA, especially if it's a trade with a lesser player. Devante Adams would be good.
@@forthesnowflakes7691 I can't fault Kyle for the offense walking off the field with the lead. The defense let the team down last season. And in 2019. The actual problem is Mahomes. He's only lost one superbowl. He's amazing. The superbowl he lost? To the greatest QB ever, TB12. Sorry, but the defense is gonna need to be better. They probably would have won is Dre Greenlaw doesnt get hurt. Then the conversation is completely different.
@@DR-ge8hp I can fault Kyle for the coin toss decision and the players not knowing the rules but i agree about Dre - he is a difference maker 💯 All I'm saying is Kyle isn't God and he has to learn to adapt. Andy Reid was where Kyle is now and got passed his stigma. Kyle needs to find a way to do better in the big games. This is just the reality of it until he proves it wrong.
@@DR-ge8hpI've been arguing non-stop that Dre blowing his Achilles was the difference. If Dre was healthy, Kelce would've never caught anything over the middle. Healthy Dre and a proper punt return instead of bouncing off Luter's leg, we win the SB 24-13.
I must be slow i heard system is what makes the QB that it’s basically scheme wide open receivers and he can do what brock can and do u pay 60m a year to a guy who is playing catch basically ok rewatched and im definitely slow he’s talking saints point of view
He is showing his stupidly. If the system so Quarter Back friendly then why did Jimmy and Brock were the only two QB who succeeded. Plus any good offense is Quarter Back friendly.
Not every offense has a good play caller but never seen a good QB succeed with a bad one. Take any good QB statistically I'd bet there's good talent and at worse a competent OC. It's for that reason these rankings and "system" attachments to Brock's success is stupid. Nobody talks about how bad the pass blocking is and how he still performed at elite level. But it's about narrative more than truth so I guess....
I don't care what others say against Purdy no more than I care about some of you exaggerating his abilities and or accomplishments. Nothing matters except for a Super Bowl win. Forget hos stats and others critical observations. If he doesn't win before the talent leaves it won't be my job to defend him
Most of these pundits fail to mention that Brock played behind a sub par O-line and still threw for over 4k yards.
calm down...he was only 300+/- yards better than JimmyG in his last full season healthy...and Jimmy's OL wasn't nearly as good as Purdy's OL!!!
@@itzanopinionJimmy was a check down merchant and isn’t anywhere close to the playmaker Brock is😂
@@itzanopinion Just pointing that statistically, last year's OL was very much below-par as far as pass pro is concerned. Run blocking, sure, but passing, that was a rough spot esp. at guard. And it was one of their worse performance in the past couple years, so if anything Jimmy had *better* pass pro.
@@itzanopiniontrolls gonna troll. If you think Jimmy can be even mentioned in the same breath as Purdy, you need to stop pretending to watch football.
Jimmy g will be out of the league next season. It’s crazy Jimmy g never got the system qb bash. Was it because he played along side Tom Brady that they thought he was good? Or was it because Brock was the last pick of the draft? Brock ain’t no system qb, Jimmy g is a system qb.
Look at all those qbs drafted ahead of Brock that are already gone. You can't just throw anybody in there and be successful.
Cj.BN.M.,B.H.,J.G.,T.L. none of those QBs came close to what Brock is doing in 1 an a half seasons.
None of them quarterbacks had Christian McCaffrey either stop
@@damonjohnson7044as a 49er fan they will never say that or that defense smh
@@damonjohnson7044the least amount of passyard in the league yet led in alot of the passing stats shut tf up
@@roemellobellyou mean the defense that completely failed to show up several times, and never played to their potential as shown in recent years?
So if you know so much about football, what does a good defense normally support - RB or QB? CMC is amazing, but let's not pretend like the game the D did play well helped the passing game more than the running game... For the first time in history. So which is it?
NFL pundits mix up physical gifts with talent. Trey Lance is physically gifted while Brock Purdy is talented. Physical gifts are potential, talent translates to wins. Physical gifts are more seductive than talent and get a QB drafted earlier than talent.
Yup, it’s doesn’t matter if your coach tells you exactly where to look if you can’t see what you’re supposed to. And even if you can see it that doesn’t mean you’ll find it in time. And if you find it in time you still have to accurately deliver the ball.
Physical gifts and talent are the same thing.. hard work, dedication, discipline, mental toughness and intelligence translate to wins.. “hard work beats talent when talent doesn’t work hard”..
A Trey Lance reference for why?
But there is also understanding the game and the intelligence behind concepts, theories etc
I disagree, physical gifts is talent. Hard work and dedication is what translates to wins. I’d argue Kaepernick benefited from having talent and was schemed up behind talented players but didn’t dedicate himself to the craft of QB yet was more successful than Alex Smith. Ironically enough, Trey Lance was blessed with physical gifts yet lacked the intangibles. He constantly was trying to work on his craft but wasn’t schemed up the same way Brock and Garapolo. Trey had to play with Sanu and run up the gut more times than his own RB (not CMC btw). Also helps when you play 4 years in college.
Yeah, but Garoppolo couldn’t find BA in a phone booth. Snead knows what it takes to capitalize on Shanahan’s schemes. Im thinking Brees is the model for Purdy and then add massive quads
And scrabbling
Very complimentary.
If anyone would be successful in Shanahan's offence, why isn't Beathard the starter? Or Mullins?
You shut your mouth speaking facts......lol
Bethard stunk and mullens had success in the offense but stunk at the end of the day. A lot of qb’s can succeed in this system with these weapon. They made it to the super bowl and 2 nfc championships with below average/trash jimmy g with less weapons lmao
they won in spite of Jimmy. He threw the ball 8 times in the NFCC@@ninerempire3398
@@ninerempire3398 Jimmy wasn't trash he just wasn't good. A good playcaller can if the pieces are in place make average QB's look above average. Brock has been elite in the system which tells me he'd be fine no matter what. I'd go a tad further and say Brock is making the system look better. In the games he's been "bad" outside of the Bal game it's been the defense that put them in bad situations.....Cincy, Cle and Minny. Those games were them just trying to claw back into a chance to win.
Well they don't have this team smh
What makes Brock great is his ability to process progressions extremely quickly while not allowing the pass rush to affect his decision making. He has a gift of sensing when pass rushers are on top of him and typically bails at the perfect time to keep the play alive.
Well put. I was on the fence longer than anyone, but I realize he definitely has a gift. He has the gift of recognition and hard work and determination much like Drew Brees was not the most talented thrower in the world, but he works so goddamn hard he became one of the greatest passers in NFL history, I'm really hoping Brock going to take that trajectory as a 49er.
@@metaldefender49He’s also a very underrated playmaker
The whole system thing is way overblown. A good playcaller is a playcaller but no matter what the QB has to be able to execute. Never seen a QB be elite without good talent and a good playcaller. What makes Brock better than most think is he did it behind one of the worst pass blocking Olines. It seems an excuse for others but when it comes to Brock it's not even talked about like "this guy is successful despite his Oline." Weird times
The QB position is simultaneously the least plug and play position, and somehow, most of the QBs in the league are system QBs. The duality of sports commentating
I agree, because if thats the case CJ, trey, nick mullens would still be on the roster. Take more than just a “system QB” to get the job done. There is a reason why QB’s are paid the most.
John Madden said the most important position on an NFL team is the quarterback.
The 2nd most important position is the backup quarterback.
Now think of the game Purdy got hurt in the Eagles game and what happened to his backup Josh Johnson who lasted a couple of plays.
@GoldTau-t1b Pretty much all QB are system QB.. It's all about finding the right guy to run it..
Ive always thought Purdy was like Drew Brees, same size , both good scramblers , both make plays with athleticism outside the pocket. Purdys scrambling has allowed them to succeed with poor blocking.
What I’ve noticed about Brock is he keeps that line of scrimmage moving. There’s rarely a play where he’s not making the right decision to push the ball down field. It could be 5 yards or 25 yards that line is moving… he matriculates the ball down field. And also he has a deep ball the dude is really good
A talent so gifted to such a good person, 'Rockin Brock' Purdy. His time is now.
Brock can layer a throw very nice, though.
So kyle ended up getting his half brees half jackson it was just a year later and with the last pick 😂
Look at how many QBs have been in Kyle's system and how many have been as successful as purdy ok yea we have alot of weapons but at the same time you still gotta go out there and make plays .. and what about when the play blows up and purdy makes it happen with his feet he's got great instincts aswell
You've clearly defended this point so much that you've lost some perspective. "safe" and "nurturing" aren't words I would use to describe a rookie being the last pick, 3rd string, starting mid season on a team with SB expectations, then executing about as well as anyone could. You care more about that Packers game than the other 20 starts. IS THE HILL YOU DIE ON?
Plus for every centrist snead video you have, there's 100s of positive ones, so nice cherry picking
True that.
When things go so far in both directions, its those who never changed that become "centrists"
Brock Purdy is as physically and mentally tough as it gets.
All those words and Snead said nothing at all
Oh he’s in a great system, he is a game manager, blah, blah, no kidding! What teams or QB’s that are winners aren’t running a great system? But Purdy has mastered this SF system. He’s smart! Put another QB in this system, and I’d bet they wouldn’t run it as efficiently as Brock does. Being in the perfect system doesn’t guarantee anything, you still have to execute it. And he does this consistently and to perfection.
Facts
So sick of this Brock talk he’s a great QB if you can’t see it or need validation then you are just a casual fan
Where can I get that 262 hat behind you
Not for sale yet but sign up to be notified www.heyguy.co
Fact is that if Brock never got the chance to show what he could do. HE would have washed out by this year.
Not because he isn't good but because the decision makers can be stupid
if brock took u to the super bowl. then hes already great as he is right now, hes gonna be even better this year u guys watch out for our team cos we gonna take it all beat evey team out there brock been very good at his game tatics hes gon be balling everyone eles in the nfl league nfc/afc dont matter hes gonna win it all i promised u that ive been watching there practice camp its going good......god has a plan for his successes again.
Every team has a system but you still have to be a good QB to execute the system.
Why are we rehashing nonsense?
I went back 4 years and watched 227 videos of coaches representing all 32 teams. It would seem EVERY team runs a "SYSTEM"! Please STOP with the system argument!!!
Yo all I gotta say is the hating needs to stop
Why is this still a question?
If BA sits out the regular season, they should try to trade him for Devante Adams and a 2nd or 3rd.
Sounds like the Bill Walsh system
Ya know, like, I can barely, ya know, figure out what in the Hell, ya know, he is, like, saying...
Progressive Education at it's finest.
Brock wouldnt have overthrown Kittle wide open deep down the middle like Jimmy did.....
What team doesn't have a quarterback friendly offense that's not competing for championships? What am I missing? Reid's offense is a system that without someone like Mahomes, wouldn't be very good. We saw that with Garrapolo. I don't get some of these pundits who say Brock's just a game manager....I mean he's so good of a manager, they got to the Super Bowl. Go figure.
Your letting a wide receiver describe what it’s like being a qb but yet he only focuses on only their potion not making sure everyone is dialed into the play plus have 3.5 seconds to get the ball out that’s why a lot of first round qbs fail and you have players like dak, Russ Wilson, Brock, Matt Hasselbeck, Tom Brady, it takes skill and IQ of the game idk what Snead meant by that !
Julio Jones best season - Kyle Shanahan
Andre Johnson - Kyle Shanahan WR coach 06' 1.1k yards (07' Andre had lest than 1k yards shanny QB coach) 08-10' Shanny O.C. Andre 1.5k yards
Pierre Garcon Best season - Kyle Shanahan O.C.
If BA leaves, it will be fine.
Kyle Shanahan Superbowl wins 0-3
I'm not for getting rid of Kyle but Kyle found ways to lose as he had the lead in each of those Superbowl visits.
We won't be nearly as good without BA, especially if it's a trade with a lesser player. Devante Adams would be good.
@@forthesnowflakes7691 I can't fault Kyle for the offense walking off the field with the lead. The defense let the team down last season. And in 2019. The actual problem is Mahomes. He's only lost one superbowl. He's amazing. The superbowl he lost? To the greatest QB ever, TB12. Sorry, but the defense is gonna need to be better. They probably would have won is Dre Greenlaw doesnt get hurt. Then the conversation is completely different.
@@DR-ge8hp I can fault Kyle for the coin toss decision and the players not knowing the rules but i agree about Dre - he is a difference maker 💯
All I'm saying is Kyle isn't God and he has to learn to adapt. Andy Reid was where Kyle is now and got passed his stigma. Kyle needs to find a way to do better in the big games. This is just the reality of it until he proves it wrong.
@@DR-ge8hpI've been arguing non-stop that Dre blowing his Achilles was the difference. If Dre was healthy, Kelce would've never caught anything over the middle. Healthy Dre and a proper punt return instead of bouncing off Luter's leg, we win the SB 24-13.
@@forthesnowflakes7691why blame Kyle for the atlanta game? That’s like blaming mike McDaniel for sb54😂
Yeah lets see Patrick without Andy. Probably good but as good?
Bro thinks he’s relevant 😂
I must be slow i heard system is what makes the QB that it’s basically scheme wide open receivers and he can do what brock can and do u pay 60m a year to a guy who is playing catch basically ok rewatched and im definitely slow he’s talking saints point of view
He doesn’t know what he’s talking about
Sneed is a nobody thou. Who cares what a 5th string guy has to say? He can’t even get on the field
He is showing his stupidly. If the system so Quarter Back friendly then why did Jimmy and Brock were the only two QB who succeeded.
Plus any good offense is Quarter Back friendly.
Not every offense has a good play caller but never seen a good QB succeed with a bad one. Take any good QB statistically I'd bet there's good talent and at worse a competent OC. It's for that reason these rankings and "system" attachments to Brock's success is stupid. Nobody talks about how bad the pass blocking is and how he still performed at elite level. But it's about narrative more than truth so I guess....
I don't care what others say against Purdy no more than I care about some of you exaggerating his abilities and or accomplishments. Nothing matters except for a Super Bowl win. Forget hos stats and others critical observations. If he doesn't win before the talent leaves it won't be my job to defend him
Aiyuk to the raiders for Devante Adams and a 3rd! Confirmed🚨
🧢
Stop it
Bring it!
Ew
Not happening 😢
Why does he look like a dope head?