黃河鋼琴協奏曲 The Yellow River Piano Concerto

[@lgyqchen5074]

这是一部凝聚力中华民族历史、文化、精神、苦难、奋斗和解放的伟大作品。

[@suechen4836]

李云迪弹得真有气吞山河之势，黄河的波涛汹涌、战士急行军的敏捷，以及对胜利抱有的信心的胸怀，都淋漓尽至的表现出来，画片感极强！太棒了！振奋人心！

[@forestsenlin]

弹得真好 把黄河磅礴气势充分地体现出来 非常棒👍👍👍❤❤❤

[@hingyuentsui4311]

不要比左比右啦，說一句好聽，彈得好，便是了。不要少看人家一生的勞力，我自己就真的比不上了。

[@forestsenlin]

不愧是钢琴王子 弹得太好了

[@alextjflorida]

今天再听依然怦然心动。

[@sgw3440]

赞赞赞李云迪！实力摆在那，一般人能拿肖钢赛冠军么？

[@weny8288]

I would imagine there are no other folks listening to piano solo anymore, particularly this one. That being said, I always get a goose bump whenever I listen to Heifetz, Horowitz, Rayburn, and let's not forget, Domingo and Jody Jiang's rendition of .Flower in the Rain.
Now this one. Fabulously interpreted and performed.
After wiping off my tears, I checked out this young musician's profile. I sincerely wish him the best towards his artistic pursuit, considering the broader environment that he is in.
God bless.

[@fangbinji6750]

一个殷承宗的文革版，一个就是李云迪的这个版本，其他人没有可比的。他们的好就在于理解原著的基础上的力度处理。听过几个老外演奏的，只有形，没有意。越有民族性的才越有世界性。就像斯美塔那的《我的祖国》只有捷克的指挥家来演绎，才有神韵。

[@cenpeng7937]

石叔诚弹的不比这个差的。

[@wanxiahao6795]

永遠的鋼琴王子！

[@jxia5060]

听了所有的版本，这是至今为止最好的，乐队的水平一级棒，李云迪在这里的表现是无与论比的。

[@familyten6061]

永遠支持李雲迪音樂世界

[@whitefieldngkambiu4570]

非常细腻情深的演绎，非常棒，很喜欢！而各名家演出是各自精彩，谁都不能抹杀谁。

[@rsho963]

This music brings me to tears again and again, no matter how many times I listen to it. It is music with a Chinese soul, an expression of determined patriotism in the face of national adversity. Inspiring!

[@woopiter7259]

这个版本真不错，李云迪得了殷承宗的真传，陈佐湟得了李德伦的真传，钢琴和乐队的配合，都是上乘绝佳的。殷承宗手指粗短（所以他的重音非常厚重震撼）、但手臂手腕手指非常灵活，弥补了把位的不足，但两人各处的轻重音艺术处理是一样的，连贯延绵和顿挫都高度一致。不足的地方在李云迪激情稍微欠缺，这里不做苛求，毕竟两人弹奏相差4、50年，时代的烙印各不相同。音色方面，乐器和录音设备现在都好于60年代，所以音效优于原来的唱片/电影版本。还有觉得弦乐群不如李德伦的浑厚，陈佐湟的好像弦乐配置少了点。可惜这个“视频”是个录音棚的音频作品，我们没有看到乐队、指挥和钢琴的精彩的表演。

[@xhs666]

写的好

[@thepianist7379]

2:53, 我听出了泪水。钢琴诗人，绝非浪得虚名。也许是千年传承下来的诗人气质，他迷失在烟花柳巷，只是他生错了时代。

[@kennethyeung5399]

藝術家大多風流，道德高潔只是你的想像

[@clementong6332]

It's an artist's job to produce great works of art, not to be a beacon of morality.

[@angvoigt1]

@@clementong6332 fully agree !

[@lchen3349]

在一個個人隱私不受尊重保護的國度，越是受到民眾關注的人物就越容易成為轉移政府臭事的犧牲品。

[@xhs666]

欧洲对这点要求低，许多顶级的艺术家都是同性恋😊

[@austincheung6061]

作为80后，每次听到结尾的东方红旋律时依然会被触动到想流泪，音乐的感染力太强大了。

[@davidwei5908]

非常用心，轮指弹奏模仿琵琶，音乐的起伏，把作曲家未能表达出的感情演绎的淋漓尽致。

[@smallfish2291]

聽咁多首，只有這首鋼琴同協奏曲配合得天衣無縫！鋼琴聲應大就大應細就細，音準無走音，音色靚，只可惜中途有廣告大煞風景！

[@mousehitscat]

音乐非常优美！

[@Jiaphrodite]

李云迪萧邦大赛出道，从琴技到演奏感情细节上的处理都能透露得出萧邦式浪漫派的特色。《黄协》无论是朗朗还是李云迪都不能也不很合适和当年殷承宗做比较，殷的演奏具有那个时代的特殊感情色彩，演奏方式，感情抒发都有那个年代特有的（当然还有当时录音设备和条件）

[@xiangtian5385]

新时代的人已经没有了那样的 “家仇国恨”

[@maxclida1429]

李云迪15岁弹的黄河，那时年轻，情感更简单，全力以赴地弹，相当有气势😁

[@terrybu435]

那石叔诚呢😄

[@alanwan7403]

@@xiangtian5385 贊頌中華民族的精神不需要恨
文革版才差勁呢，帶東方紅是幾個意思？中華文化就是在毛匪手中亡的

[@damaoriji]

第三乐章的黄水谣个人感觉是最好的，没有之一。。

[@m1h659]

音乐的力量，属性，历史性的作用，《黄河》，冼星海，永远镶進中国革命历史中。

[@m1h659]

我站在黄河之巅，望黄河滚滚------从眼泪中流出----

[@m1h659]

想起江青也曾走过黄河岸边，可能听着殷诚忠的弹奏她回忆起艰苦岁月----觉得她应该作为一个革命家而被纪念。

[@xiuhuagao6126]

Beautiful music n great performance. Very touched.

[@jackiecaprari6831]

Absolutely fantastic. I just love this piece of music,

[@pauldriver3755]

A brilliant pianist Yundi li and he plays The yellow river piano concerto to perfection. I find The yellow river piano concerto has a hint of the wild west in it. Well that's just me. Anyway congrats it's a excellent recording as well I just love it. Thank you Paul

[@user-tp8ez5zj9b]

摄人心魄，直接触人的心灵深贝！❤

[@sundoris2657]

喜欢这个版本，随机歌单一下子就被抓住耳朵的感觉，看介绍发现还是李云迪，个人真的是很吃他的风格。

[@martinlee5141]

Unbelievable, sooooooo beautiful!

[@uemiduram52]

indeed

[@user-mp6so9bm9t]

中国ジャーナルでユンディリさんのことを知りました。CDも買いました。

[@yalegusmle]

The National spirit belonging to Chinese history!!

[@winnieyuen6484]

非常好聽呀

[@suratpongpipatpanich5627]

All of my grand parents (both sides) emigrated from the southeastern China through Shantou in Quangdon near Fujian province about a century ago. While listening to this beautiful piece, I imagine myself to be one of them living in the south of China and thinking of their compatriots in the Huang He Basin. It's very inspiring indeed.

[@user-tp8ez5zj9b]

摄人心魄，直接触动了人的心灵深处！❤（ 這不，手都颤了！）

[@mylittlefish2010]

感谢，好音乐！so beautiful. Love ❤️

[@haroldmarshall4867]

Wonderful! Until now i knew nothing of the Yellow River. Thanks much!

[@otfried]

Excellent playing of staccato chords, clean and precise and energic.

[@changchen237]

Long live classical and Chinese music!!!!!!!!!!!!!l!!!!!

[@johnhuggins2873]

Beautiful music from a fan all of the way in Dallas, Texas, USA.

[@HiHi-ej7kw]

～ Huggins

[@HiHi-ej7kw]

：！

[@robertthomson9808]

Wonderful beautiful music.

[@chocorisu27]

中国の広大な大地、悠久の歴史を思わせる壮大な曲、力強いピアノ
全ての命を祝福したくなる演奏でした

[@PauloCesarMaiadeAguiar]

Amazing Dear Many thanks for to share this dear Fantastic

[@jamesm5462]

To the original chineses, they can enjoy this piece more because they can close their eyes listening to it while imagining the many things conveyed in it... the history, culture, etc, etc.

[@fco.javiercareagam4138]

Beautiful, peaceful, profound music perceived by a fan in Mexico City.

[@wpoon1]

Music is an art only if it can refresh one's heart and blind. Of course, it does all depend on the cultivation of the listeners.

[@agilukacs4487]

Beautiful!

[@robertcohn8858]

An interesting composition. Has elements of American West type sounds, mixed with classical patterns from European composers as well as Chinese melodies. Quite a medley of styles. Nice performance.

[@jingyin5274]

@@suoyintanwei Nothing related to Russian style. The composer, Xian Xinghai received his senior music composition in Paris, France.

[@anphan141]

@@suoyintanwei : agree! The 2nd movement sounds very Tchaikovsky to me.

[@epicaunleashed8764]

@@suoyintanwei you people will never admit that the west is better than you, eh.

[@rainbowartca6331]

I like his playing.

[@blancayolanda3424]

这是我听过最好的黄河之一，钢琴家和乐队相得益彰，配合非常精彩，无论节奏还是情绪都恰到好处，澎湃处引人振奋，缓慢处自有庄严。至于郎朗的版本，听了感觉像是黄河决堤了似的发疯，吓死人，一点没有节奏分寸，更不用说感情了，商业化的产物。

[@alanluo6141]

哈哈，是的

[@sho2sho2sho]

真的不喜歡朗朗, 太做作了.

[@sindyli6]

有同感, 很舒服。

[@Nana-vt7if]

李云迪 比朗朗好太多了

[@howcallyuudsagfeetrccbj8963]

关键是动作誇张幅度太大，有时候真不好意思😅接着看下去………

[@chenlianlian6742]

Soooo beautiful!

[@em8714]

If he composes more pieces like this he could become one of the greats like chopin or rach.

[@limitlessbianca]

he didn't compose this. this song was composed during the war between China and Japan, I believe.

[@em8714]

@@limitlessbianca do you know who composed it?

[@limitlessbianca]

@@em8714 here i literally copy pasted it from wikipedia. "...arranged by a collaboration between Chinese composers, including Yin Chengzong and Chu Wanghua, and based on the Yellow River Cantata by composer Xian Xinghai."

[@em8714]

@@limitlessbianca thanks

[@ravell193992]

NO!!! How dare you mention Chopin or Rachmaninoff? This immature and novice concerto is mediocre at best, maybe even less interesting than Kalkbrenner. Listen to Rachmaninoff's very first concerto which he composed when he was 18. It has more virtuosity, romanticism, complexity, philosophy, and artistic craft. As a musician, I can't believe this Yellow River concerto was composed in the 70s by a composer who studied many classical works. It's a retrogression.

[@ycdouble1]

老泪纵横。先行者们如您所愿！

[@kathng8354]

Amazing

[@Kiss_MyAss]

You can feel the emotions! Great piece of music!

[@user-mz1iw3gv4e]

绝响！云迪余生大概不会在公开场合演奏此曲了~

[@jcheung3133]

excellent. very well presented.

[@hellocheung2230]

good

[@xavierbordes1373]

Pas mal, le pianiste a du boulot ! Assez surprenant...

[@user-um3qn4fk9g]

中华民族的命运交响曲

[@cassiuscyparissus5567]

Has some rich soaring melodies, sounds very european yet so chinese. definitely has some Rachmaninoff influence.

[@TheButterMinecart1]

Yeah I was thinking that there was some strong Russian influence.

[@wwjsun]

‘冼’ 星海，孩子呀。

[@fanyang73]

笑尿了，洗星海。。。。

[@elvazhou9229]

And for those who don’t know, it’s ”xiǎn”

[@ccei638]

This is the best version on TH-cam. The sound quality is superb.

[@jimmysiu7063]

👍🏻👍🏻

[@MrKaokarl]

除了殷承宗，只有他能彈出黃河的“怨”。

[@hepickly9733]

殷承宗我也只觉得首演版本的音乐是最对味的

[@daphneiris8016]

poetic

[@jasonng0211]

18:10 這段跑句的和聲處理有改編過，比較好聽。

[@jinzhang2914]

跟朗朗的版本比，觉得感情更加细腻温柔，尤其是黄水谣。但是该激动高亢的地方处理没有朗朗那么有力。论最佳版本还是1970的殷承宗版。听过后来的殷承宗2000年以后的现场版本，真是可惜了。自古美人如名将不许人间见白头。

[@angvoigt1]

70年的殷當然最好、其實連最高端的鋼琴指勁(發音)也是殷最好、近貼世界級、李是典型的詩意抒情式、細膩之處還有可取；朗的所謂力度是做作出來的
即虛火、跑江湖式、現今社會較易討好幕觀眾是綽頭(SHOWMANSHIP)+
做作(FACIAL EXP)、朗最聰明的是一早拍上猶太碼頭、跟上個超爛教師(把倫幫
Bareniom)、其實在B裡學不了多少、卻能有效打開美國市場、別以為猶太人只
管金融政治經濟、--玩音樂的要走紅、要董泊碼頭啊！

[@hepickly9733]

相当赞同，美国所谓的音乐家都是音乐美国有意识树立起来的。就拿钢琴来说，二战前活到二战后的极端优秀钢琴家不少，到美国的也不少，为什么偏偏为什么霍洛维茨、A·鲁宾斯坦起来了？

[@cenpeng7937]

赞同。小时候曾买过殷承宗版的和石叔诚版的CD，我自己也是习琴25年，其实感觉《黄河钢琴协奏曲》李和郎都没有超过殷和石。李和郎可能在技巧上比石更强，但是乐感和整体处理上还是略逊一筹。说殷是中国第一人，应该不为过吧。

[@user-md4bj8mo6r]

Jin Zhang ？

[@xhs666]

还是很棒，殷很有才

[@nissianding4877]

到呢刻我都是喜歡殷承宗1970那個氣勢山河的演奏，指工深厚，可惜我再找不到呢只CD了，何解我要找呢只CD呢？在晚上用擴音機，關了燈聽，別有風味！在電腦是聽不到最好的效果！

[@cteo1835]

th-cam.com/video/39qxrNhJdbE/w-d-xo.html

[@medviation]

Love the internationale ending!

[@Brainwashed101]

Yundi Li's interpretation far surpasses that of the composer. I'll lose social credit over that statement, I'm sure, lol.

[@daniellac7102]

👏🏻👍🏻

[@eusi1133]

李雲迪

[@luyisu6880]

17分48秒应该有琵琶。这版本把琵琶都给省略了。琵琶在这个作品里是色彩乐器，非常个性化。没有琵琶不能不说是一个遗憾

[@user-cd7uc7dq8p]

没有刘德海了

[@luyisu6880]

@@user-cd7uc7dq8p RIP

[@mikkel2c]

李云迪的这个版本是除了殷诚宗1970年版之外，表现力最好的一个，当然还远远比不上殷诚宗的气吞山河，一气呵成的气概。但确实将郎朗远远抛于脑后，郎朗的版本除了表情造作之外，非常粗糙，一副玩世不恭的样子。

[@MrTalikakas]

Brialliant performance by Yundi, the 2nd movement is so full of tenderness it made me cry, cry of joy. What a wonderful sound this concerto is made of! Other moments its so powerful & full of wrath! Like the Yellow River itself that cannot be contain. All in all, in music, everything is in harmony!

[@cocoyeung1291]

气吞山河 好

[@terrybu435]

石叔诚更好！

[@HugoFernandezLanguasco]

No salgo de mi asombro por tan grata sorpresa: hasta hoy no conocía esta maravilla.- Y la "responsable" de este feliz encuentro ha sido la Filatelia.- En efecto: soy coleccionista de sellos, me especializo en temas de MUSICA EN EL MUNDO.- Investigando...encontré un sello de Xiang Xianghai...Feliz coincidencia de hechos!.- Magnífica obra musical!

[@robert-skibelo]

Impressive performance. But since you haven't got any video to show us it would have been better to display the score rather than a few odd photos.

[@ngmr8097]

看不见影片
想看弹鋼琴
只听音乐，不
过隐。

[@user-cr1vw5sz6n]

Anny Lai 这是我见过的最专业中肯的评论。评论的内容完全是一个客观的事实。

[@chanlaptak]

真他妈贼好听的

[@gretareinarsson7461]

I have tried so many times to find something to really like about this concerto, apart from that it’s always good to hear music from different countries, but I find it really just boring. But of course I don’t have connections to context or any sort of reminisce that people in China probably have to it. However it’s a good showpiece for the pianist.

[@brianyip611]

第一樂章: 黃河船夫曲
李雲迪在某些地方可以再鏗鏘點，郎郎在這方面較好
第二樂章:黃河頌
李雲迪表現很精彩，音色非常配合，與樂隊很夾，郎郎彈得很硬，沒feel，有些地方也很急

[@hangkin927]

+brianyip611 同感

[@MrKaokarl]

+hangkin927 同感

[@Bang2010]

+brianyip611 李云迪是文臣，朗朗是武将。

[@angvoigt1]

70年的殷當然最好、其實連最高端的鋼琴指勁(發音)也是殷最好、近貼世界級、李是典型的詩意抒情式、細膩之處還有可取；朗的所謂力度是做作出來的
即虛火、跑江湖式、現今社會較易討好幕觀眾是綽頭(SHOWMANSHIP)+
做作(FACIAL EXP)、朗最聰明的是一早拍上猶太碼頭、跟上個超爛教師(把倫幫
Bareniom)、其實在B裡學不了多少、卻能有效打開美國市場、別以為猶太人只
管金融政治經濟、--玩音樂的要走紅、要董泊碼頭啊！

[@angvoigt1]

70年的殷當然最好、其實連最高端的鋼琴指勁(發音)也是殷最好、近貼世界級、李是典型的詩意抒情式、細膩之處還有可取；朗的所謂力度是做作出來的
即虛火、跑江湖式、現今社會較易討好幕觀眾是綽頭(SHOWMANSHIP)+
做作(FACIAL EXP)、朗最聰明的是一早拍上猶太碼頭、跟上個超爛教師(把倫幫
Bareniom)、其實在B裡學不了多少、卻能有效打開美國市場、別以為猶太人只
管金融政治經濟、--玩音樂的要走紅、要董泊碼頭啊！

[@MyTroubadour]

Une oeuvre de toute beauté qui malheureusement en France reste bien trop négligée des médias et ce n'est pas la seule.

[@jean-pierrevenembre8458]

Je viens de découvrir cette merveille !

[@shibo4349]

cool

[@Pookie1-q2w]

Very liszt-like

[@Verili88]

¿A que clase de persona falta de oído y sentimiento puede no gustarle esta pieza?

[@derong9865]

15:05

[@Bang2010]

8:05 开始是黄水谣啊

[@johnyang7810]

推薦张昊辰的版本：th-cam.com/video/dRozgrmEfHw/w-d-xo.html
個人認為樂句處理覺得更為細膩。更令人感動。

[@philg4116]

it's almost random with a certain aimlessness

[@bensonzhang7331]

You certainly don't know that this is an adaptation of a much larger composition known as the Yellow River Cantata, right? The piano concerto contains 4 themes from it, and if you're not familiar with those themes, then obviously you wouldn't comprehend it the right way.

[@chelsyma3926]

有人说云迪版黄河比朗朗版的好太多，我怎么觉得云迪的只有悲没有壮呢？

[@joshlorenzo7195]

YOU GUYS WHATS THE FIRST SONG IDK WHAT IT IS

[@joshlorenzo7195]

thanks

[@babicz89]

Liszt:
I wrote a new piece, "Chinese Rhapsody" for piano and orchestra.

[@tomchan2917]

1

[@fandreas556]

乐队伴奏令人失望。个人觉得下面这个版本更好一些： th-cam.com/video/YNn9zKwp934/w-d-xo.html

[@yliang1688]

黃河鋼琴協奏曲 The Yellow River Piano Concerto
th-cam.com/video/YPF1FOuxVQw/w-d-xo.html
15:05 4.《保衛黃河》Defend the Yellow River

[@gaoyongfu]

不过是宣传而已。

[@seantzeng1849]

,

[@tonywai7909]

后期制作水平不行，把钢琴变成了背景音乐，缺乏层次感

[@wwhuang3196]

朗朗的版本可能是现场的原因，加之指挥也表现欠缺，李的版本不是现场录音，所以远比朗朗的好。不过，我觉得石叔诚的黄河比所有的都要好，也远比殷承宗的好

[@user-um3qn4fk9g]

不会吧 我怎么听石叔诚的觉得有点乱

[@2000sunshine]

挺好的曲子最后加上东方红就是败笔