ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Why Did My Fishing Rod Break, The Stress Test (High Sticking)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.พ. 2019
- What causes a fishing rod to break? Was it my fault that the Ugly Stik snapped when I was landing a fish the other night? In this video I use a Shimano brand rod and recreate the event of landing a fish while doing what is know as "high sticking". This experiment was really a lot of fun and the results really have caused me to wonder if I actually did something wrong while landing the Snook that broke my rod or was there a manufacture's defect that caused it to snap in two?
I’ve been high sticking my Medium Inshore Select 7’ Ugly Stik for about a year now and no issues. I always do that, drop the reel down and grab right by the first eyelet. Also when it comes to Ugly Stik, some people are just tackle snobs 🤷♂️
Although I'm a woman, I've been fishing for at least 60 years. My father was a stern teacher. He taught me to never hold a rod above the handle area. That was a cardinal since that I never committed. I've therefore only broken them in doors!! Never by high sticking! But he swore that's a surefire way to snap one. I didn't want to mention it though.
Thanks for commenting. Doors, ha ha...
Your father was wise. And you are the wiser bc of him. No one taught me this. I had to learn the hard way.. many times..
Wife divorces you, car breaks down, you receive an IRS audit notice...
You: 01:01
Very interesting video brother... I highstick fish in the boat all the time...and exclusively use ugly stick rods especially inshore and i haven't had one break yet...but i have broke many st Croix rods doing the same thing..think maybe there was a production issue with the rod you broke...absolutely a great subject ..
Thanks for sharing your experience. Sometimes subscribers put some good topics out there to create videos from.
It's due to the broken rod being made of graphite. Graphite rods are strong but the weight needs to be loaded differently. It appears the other rod you used was probably fibreglass. Check out this really good video for a demonstration of why graphite rods can break. m.th-cam.com/video/r5fqh2oHZ-E/w-d-xo.html
Lower end rods have a lower amount of graphite in them which makes them more flexible which is probably why the Shimano didn’t break but the ugly stick did
I have an early 50s classic fishing reel it's old and antique but I'm going to try it out on one of my fishing rods
You are a little off on what "high sticking" is. High sticking does not refer to where you grab the rod at. It refers to the angle you have your rod in relation to the water. When you raise it at a high angle close to 90 degrees and have a load on it the tip cannot act as the shock absorber it usually does. The rod will break closer tO where you are holding it. In the case of your ugly stick up higher on the rod. In the case of my $300 custom titanium skeleton rod it was down lower right above the handle, but I still "high sticked" it.
It's a good demonstration. One thing I'd like to comment is every stick has a spin and fish kicks sideways. Maybe it try shaking the rod tip to mimic the fish see how the rod tip holds up when the weight is shifting off it's spine.
Use whatever works! I broke a St. Croix a couple months ago trying to lift mother earth off the bottom. It was a cheaper St. Croix rod but the warranty had me covered. Walked into the tackle store I bought it from and they replaced it no questions asked for free!
Interesting experiment. Thanks for sharing. I will definitely be more aware of grabbing the rod above the cork.
Oh yeah, I'll be much more mindful of it now for sure.
High sticking usually happens on graphite rods
What was the action of the ugly stik rod? If it was fast then that would make sense why it broke.
That's a good question. I don't think Ugly Stik labels this particular rod like that. I'm pretty sure they just call it a medium heavy. It's a long an skinny rod though.
I was just wondering if ugly sticks have a lifetime warranty like they claim ?
May had a small crack in the rod from a past catch and that was the feather that broke the rods back.
Funny my man, the feather, ha ha...I love it!
Graphite is a wonderful thing. It allows for a lighter and much more sensitive rod. The downside is it also is much more prone to breakage. It’s a trade off. The Ugly Stick Select states that it has 35% more graphite than the GX2. Its still a composite rod but without knowing the total (proprietary) graphite content, you can’t compare. I expect the Shimano you tested had a much lower graphite content ($20). Additionally, there may have been some minor damage on your Select at the breaking point. All it would take would be a scratch. This is why I use a rod like a Shimano Teramar (or similar) for bridge/pier fishing. It has 2 layers of graphite and 2 of fiberglass. Slightly heavier but stands up better to minor damage. Absolutely nothing wrong with Ugly Stiks. I own one.
Great sharing. Thanks for watching and commenting. You know, I was hoping you were the Googan Squad Jon.
great video well demonstrated
Fun video. Good job keeping your cool when you wrapped the end starting the demo.
Ha ha...
you were still holding it past the cork, rods are normally only designed to be held were the grip is
I'm thankful for the interaction of subscribers on this channel. I've learned so much from input like yours. Thanks.
You beat me to it.
You can break any rod . Funny thing is I just broke mine. But I got it 15 yrs ago on the boat fresh salt Jamed in cars truck beds. This rod was abused broke 12 inches from tip. But I have seen ugly sticks left on sea walls and rough surfaces break . Don't know the use or storage .or age but. But for the price for what you get I bought more . I have broken 100 and 200 rods faster. You probley got a defective one . But keep us posted if you do it again . Nice videos 👍 one of your fans keep fishing Kap
Another outstanding video... I'm always learning something new.. Thanks Sy...
Thanks for the encouraging words.
First one which broke easily maybe that was cheaper rod. But experiment on shimano is showing better performance than previous. Graphite rod is always sensitive so we sould Never hold the rod above the rod grip......
My best guess is that the Ugly Stik rod had a very small compromise in manufacturing or it was minimally scratched or damaged over time and compromised. J.C. you using Ugly Stik and Penn Pursuit II is what gives you that "everyday man" relatability. I see guys fishing online with Van Staals and just can't relate. Way out of my league. With that said, you should really check out the Penn Spinfisher VI. The drag is strong and it is a super durable reel. You can get combo's online for not too much. You could get a better drag and a sized down reel. Keep up the great videos!
Thanks for watching and sharing your insight. Eventually I'll upgrade. I purchased a Spinfish at the beginning of this year.
@@RadReelingFishing I was watching your "Another Giant Snook..." video and thought you might be using the Spinfisher VI 7500. Is my guess right? Strong drag on that reel! 35lb! Nice!!!
@@snookcatcher1 This vid had the 7500 in it, love that reel! th-cam.com/video/QUr5lMBtD3E/w-d-xo.html
It might just be a mass produced rod issue. I've seen over the years Ugly Stik has decreased their warranty consistently and due to their price point I feel as though they arent concerned about quality anymore with their newer models. I also love the ugly stik brand and find that my older models seem to be the better rods overall.
thanks for sharing your experience with with this brand, excellent points!
I agree. I think Ugly Sticks are good rods. I’ve caught good size bass with mine using a keitech lure. 👍
The more graphite in the rod it become more brittle it becomes more sensitive and the cost is higher. The more fiberglass in the rod it becomes more durable (flexible) less sensitive and usually cost less.
Thanks for sharing your knowledge, greatly appreciated.
IMO I think it was an imperfection in the rod, just like you I’ve fished with ugly stick rods for many years and never had one break. Thanks for the info! 👍🏻
Mark that's what i was thinking. I saw the same rod at Walmart and most of them didn't even have straight eyes...
Robert Burke Unfortunately, over the years they have cheapened their product and weakened their quality control, but even still the rod shouldn’t have snapped like that. After watching this I will never high stick a rod!
I hope I've learned my lesson. It usually takes me some practice to finally create a lifetime habit.
Great vid. JC..yes high sticking is possible but I think it was just a stress point that finally gave up. we put a lot of pressure on those rods a lot more than the average fisherman and they don't last forever, but I also own numerous ugly sticks because they do hold up to all the bumps and punishment I put them thru. I've broke more High end full graphite rods than Ugly sticks that's for sure ...Tight lines brother
Thanks for sharing your experience, greatly appreciated.
I think this is the answer for sure !!! The Ugly Stick rods are not great for sensitivity with lures or feel fishing but tough as nails for for fishing of other types where all that flexibility is not an issue. J.C has been doing this so long his hands are well calibrated to small bites on an unsensitive rod. Wish I was half the fisherman he is.
Hi JC. More graphite = more snaps. Thanks, Mickey
In that last snook clip ... even when you were bringing up the snook in the net you still had a fair amount of tension on the line - may need to ease up on that rod grip ... just say'n ...
Yeah, I'm going to really pay more attention once i get in some more big snook catching practice. Thanks for commenting.
Can’t wait to see more remodeled rods ! Haha, great video
That's funny!
Great video, I would’ve liked to see you apply the same pressure holding it normally from the grip though. Maybe upping the weight instead of shaking it too just to see how much of a difference it really made. But again great video you may have just saved my rods 👍
Thanks for watching.
I have been high sticking my fishing rod for multiple times and it ended up breaking and breaking and breaking into multiple pieces and the first eyelet came off
The channels doing great!!!!!!
I agree. I had never thought it would grow this fast.
I have 20 lb braided Power Pro Line
my friend, who is new to fishing, broke his rod tip the other day by accidentally high sticking it. his line got snagged...he stuck the rod firmly under his arm pit to keep it from falling...didnt ensure there was enough slack on the line, pulled on the line without keeping the bail open....POP.....i've seen many people break their rod like this hehe...
Thanks for sharing. this was a fun video to make.
I have been high sticking one of my fishing rods and it end up breaking into multiple pieces
Graphite rods just feel very weak compared to fibre glass, idk that it is
My buddy bought that rod used it for 2 days snapped it flipping a 36 inch snook.
Why would he try to flip a 36"? I'd expect any inshore rod on the market to snap doing that lol.
Ha ha ha... I was wondering the same thing???
Sorry for the late reply boys. He was at one of our spots over about a 4 foot tall rail and a 7 foot drop to deep water. Couldn’t jump in or hang off the wall lol. He should’ve pulled it up by the leader but shit happens lol.
Brother get two 6'9" uglystik tiger elite to make up for those 2 they are super light strong sensitive, iv had my SPINFISHER V 4500 , DAIWA BG30, PENN SARGUS 5000 it goes good with all them
Thanks for the tips. I think the tiger is the only one i don't own.
This offshore fishing rod in stronger than a original jigging Pole
I saw what happened. The fish before you dropped the rod. It was scraped or chipped. And that’s why it broke so easy. Replay it you’ll see what I am saying.
Oh, I'll have to review that footage. Good point. Thanks for watching and commenting.
A Savage fishing rod that was purchased from BCF three months ago has gone back for a warranty review after its third use. Whilst casting the rod snapped . Not happy with the sales person telling me it had been high sticked. Yes Mr sales person I might be a female,but I know how to handle a rod or two . It wasn't high sticked. Let's see what the assessment says .
I have had a 6' M st. Croix with about 3 hours of fishing time on it. Was cast a little 5/16 oz jig with a 4" fine-s plastic and my rod broke in half, just from casting. It's a $130 rod and it snapped for no reason. Only takes a tiny imperfection for a rod to snap IMO! Shit happens!!
Thanks for sharing. My replacement should be here next week.
Maybe wear n tear on it since u carry in you car i know mine at times get messed up plus all the fish uve caught i have seversl UGLY STICKS..but yeah i once broke one of my 1st 2 rods ugly stick on over sized red lol...just angler error on that one still have it saved lol
Thanks for commenting. Your channel name is totally awesome.
I have actually heard bad reviews about the select man, but just like you I'm a Ugly Stick guy.
There's a replacement on the way. Hopefully I won't wear this one out like the other one by catching too many fish before it was broke in really good.
I was just typing to ask if you wanted to sell your $9 find for 15 bucks when it snapped. LOL
I know right! While I was bending the heck out of the rod I was thinking I shouldn't really break this rod because it's really good, ha ha...
I'm also a big fan of Ugly Sticks; been fishing with them for years and have always been happy with their performance in spite of their quite low price tag. Haven't had the luxury of hearing much flack about using them though--probably because I'm a woman; people just assume I'm clueless anyway! LOL I'm interested to hear if they handle your refund well.
wear and tear on the rod, nothing you can really do about it.
Good point, too many Snook caught in a month probably ha ha...Thanks for commenting.
Graphite rods tend to break very easy
is this ugly stik gx2?
Inshore Select
The reason your good rod broke and the cheap one wont, is your good rod was carbon fibre, The cheap rod will bend almost in a circle.
Right! It's all graphite for sure. Ugly Stik on my new Carbon Inshore rod made an improvement and made the tip solid graphite instead of hollow. The Inshore Select is hollow and breaks rather easily. I actually don't use that rod any more. This is a good video of my Ugly Stik rods th-cam.com/video/OzwxxXfH-cY/w-d-xo.html
@@RadReelingFishing The biggest problem with modern rods is everyone is obsessed with how light they can get them, everything has to carbon fibre and be weighed by the gram. I can remember when men were strong enough to hold a Whole kilo for the day while fishing, now they are telling me my reel is to big because it weighs 700grams. 🤣😂
Lol I bought a $19. Rod & reel from Walmart my 26 year old son saw it & said oh you got another new pole I said yep I said how much do you think it was he said $50. I said nope $19. He then says why don’t you buy a expensive set up nothing under $80-$100. I told him why bother cause if I break it it doesn’t break me to go buy another (just for the record we do have 4 nice Penn combos) but he thinks you gotta spend big money, NOT me lol
Thanks for watching. Yeah, I'm all about finding reasonably priced fishing gear that does the job!
There are better rods on the market, but none that do the job for the price of an Ugly Stik.
Thanks for sharing your views!
buy another shimano sonora rod ...
Lmfknao Hahaha! Can't break the $9 Pawnshop rod! Lesson learned CHEAPER rod is BETTER! Lmfknao Hahaha!
Yeah, don't you know that rod would have been a great smallmouth/sauger rod! RIP, sniff. Ha!
high sticking is not smart.. lol..
Ha ha...