@@Ramzblood yea he spends the rest of the movie thinking that when he cursed God that day God tries to get him back or something. The cursing God is significant.
Everyone is praising Brad Pitt in this film - but Aidan Quinn stole the show for me. He was great. Sadly he has been mostly forgotten about in film these days. But between Legends of the Fall and Michael Collins - he is one of the greats.
I first saw him in An Early Frost--when it was really risky careerwise to play a gay man, especially one with AIDS. Good in everything he did, including the incredible Songcatcher.
Exactly. Aidan Quinn has been great in everything I've seen him in. He's good at playing these emotionally tortured, borderline villainous characters who you can sympathise with. Great actor.
Probably because it wasn’t that good, and just because you choose to be dramatic by going straight to the top shelf with your words doesn’t mean his acting was actually good.
@@dropkickirish4449 well, opinions are like assholes. I have my own, so I don't need yours. You are actually allowed to comment without being a douchebag. Wasn't being dramatic, just giving my opinion, like everyone else.
@@the-real-super-genius Tom Hanks has always been a part of the “system”. In with the higher ups, don’t get me wrong he is a great actor but he’s had a lot of mediocre and overrated movies too.
Might I suggest watching some more films? Is this heartbreaking? Absolutely? Is it the most heartbreaking scene in cinema? No... no no no... quantifiably no! I mean.... did you even see the ending to The Mist (2007)? I wouldn't even consider THAT the most heartbreaking ending in all of cinema, but holy smokes what a gut punch... Never...? NEVER?!? That's a strong word there, missy. Language matters... don't take your words for granted, please.
@@mattbrendlenPeople are allowed to have different opinions than you. No need to write entire paragraphs of drivel to try and prove them wrong. All you did is make an ass of yourself.
I have never actually seen an actor's pupils change while filming. What an actor... I can't even finish this scene...just leaves me devastated. The loss, the WASTE, Pitt delivers it all. Just staggering.
Brad Pitt is a highly acclaimed actor that is a household name in every country that gets Hollywood movies. Calling him underrated when almost everyone who's seen his films sings his praises means you've just come out from under a rock
@@beezzarro No, he’s the most underrated actor in all of human history! He’s literally a genius! Something, something Oscar, Academy Award. Plus, how is anyone going to know that OP is really smart unless he uses recycled rhetoric on TH-cam?
Gotta love beard pitts man bought my first one a year ago still fires up just fine paints fine it’s a good product. Merry Christmas Andrew Tate supporters!
I found it idiotic at the time, and still do now, that two Germans stopped, set up a machine gun, just too machine one guy caught in barbed wire, but dont shoot the guy running towards them with a weapon screaming like crazy. So ridiculously over dramatic.
So, none of you have heard about overkill? Maybe those two soldiers were just looking to merc tf outta someone, and were caught off guard? Its war, it brought out the ugly in many a man
This scene is pretty gut-wrenching when you think of this happening to your brother or son, but it never made sense to me that the Germans (I assume) would set up a machine gun to kill one guy. They would have just shot him with a pistol or rifle, or just held the machine gun and fired. It doesn't make any sense at all that they would take the time to place it on its tripod, load, and then fire... for one enemy soldier.
@@happybeingmiserable4668 Apparently they did some horrible shit to civilians, as many armies did, but yes, I agree. "Hey there's one guy! Quick! We need to get experience!" Laughing maniacally.
Anyone wondering why brad Pitt didn't get an Oscar for this is not up to speed on how the Oscars do not make their decisions based on quality, but rather politics
Different people vote every time. Sometimes there are surprise wins when quality does win out. Sometimes, lots of quality films come out at once, and only one can win. Which has been happening forever. Taxi Driver and Rocky were nominated at the same time. Pulp Fiction and Forrest Gump. Sometimes, the people voting just vote for whatever is popular or arbitrarily vote for a film for inexplicable reasons, though. Like how Saving Private Ryan didn't win best picture and lost to Shakespeare in Love of all films.
@@PandoraBear357 there's a little variation as to who votes because some newcomers are inducted while some abstain, but the voting committee of roughly 10k does not undergo any significant changes from year to year. It seems like you may not be aware of the egregious and profound amount of lobbying, campaigning, and outright bribing that studio execs conduct in order to manufacture a win for their films
I know it’s like it’s a Hollywood movie and it said set up a machine gun for one guy because the people watching the movie want to be entertained! Can you believe the audacity?
They totally would. They probably weren't sure who was on the other side of the slope across the fence. But yes Germans during WW1 had little to no remorse.
Exactly lmfao there's a soldier running and screaming from the bottom of his lungs behind us, let's just BOTH focus on the trapped guy there and ignore the armed man getting close to us from behind
@@Martha_My_Dear Also why bother wasting rounds from a heavy machine gun on one unarmed guy trapped in wire, if they really felt the need to kill him they could've just used a knife
@@ST19859yeah, I mean why didn't they leave the safety of cover with the machine gun and run out there and use a bloody knife to kill the guy? I mean, it makes no sense! Please. I can understand their using a pistol or something, but a knife would be stupid, with soldiers running around with guns, what good is a knife going to do!?
Such a sad and powerful scene.. Having to cut his own brother's heart 🫀out so he can take back with him to the family ranch. Then he goes all savage gets his revenge and wears them around his neck!! 👏🏼
I think everyone who comes here was affected by this scene in a deep way. Inside all of us we were screaming with Tristan. He knew he couldn't save his beloved brother, he knew he couldn't make it, he knew his brother was about to die, his heart bled as he tried to alter time and space to save his brother but deep down inside he knew. That scream is what makes actors great, what a scene, this is why the cinema era was beautiful.
The fact that Pulp Fiction and Forrest Gump one all the Oscars, and legends of the fall didn’t get anything is criminal. Those two movies were OK I guess, but Legends of the fall was great!
@@danielhicks4826 If you STILL believe in 2000 year old fairy tales of invisible men in the sky, you don't get it AT ALL and are holding humanity back.
I use that quote all the time whenever some shit happens. I'll be like "GODDAMN YOU GOD" and my friends will be like "aren't you religious?" And I'm like "yeah, but it's a Brad Pitt quote so 🤷♂️"
This is one of my favorite movies of all time. The cast is Amazing. The movie was excellent. Brad Pitt was robbed of an Oscar. Brilliant performance by Brad . THIS scene breaks my heart and I cry every time.
Poor Samuel. Tragically naïve about the brutality of life which led to his life being cut way too short without experiencing the joy of consummating his marriage.
I know it's a movie and all, but... a few things bother me here. First off, the machine gunners have sidearms of their own. They wouldn't have needed the Maxim gun to shoot Samuel. Second, they wouldn't have wasted that many bullets on 1 man. And third, in doing so, he would have been dead instantly. No tearjerking last moments between him and Tristan after that many bullets at such close range.
Great scene and movie however Im not sure they'd put all three brothers together like that in war. Their love for each other and trying to protect the youngest brother because hes engaged could have messed up the battle plans for their regimen. Tristan had a tough gig trying to watch Samuels back in a dangerous war 24/7.
In reality, a soldier serving with the Canadian Expeditionary Force would've been sporting a brush cut. Long hair was absolutely verboten & never, ever would've been allowed under any circumstances - even if he were Brad Pitt.
this movie is far more than just a Brad Pitt movie; it's a movie made for us to realize how horrific war is. this might be just a movie; but in reality we face wars beyond our imagination and on screens to see the pain, misery, sorrow, regrets, and hatred of those who we face and fight; for no reason at all. this is why; I hate politicians and don't care for them. I work as a chemical engineer; as a chemist and I've seen Hell's Furies. and they want nothing from humanity; except the love and compassion of life on earth without wars and hatred for others. we no nothing about. Thank you; Brad Pitt. You will always be Achilles to me!
I never understood why they set up a machine gun for one dude trapped in barbed wire... Like, they didn't even need to use a pistol! He was trapped! Just slap him a few times.
Nous avons essayé de nous retrouver mais voilà ce qu'ils ont fait c'est chien je compare notre séparation comme cela maintenant je pars mais je ne t'oublierai jamais parce que tu m'as sauvé la vie je t'aime Mirel Julian que j'ai baptisé JM 🥺😢😭
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
HE DESERVED THE OSCAR FOR THIS.
AWESOME ACTOR. GREAT FILM.
Haha No, no he did not.
Yes, he was great in this movie😊
@@dropkickirish4449WHY
@@emagus939 Because he gave a hammed up performance in this scene. “GODDAMN YOU GOD!” C’mon, you seriously think that wasn’t a wee bit over the top?
@@dropkickirish4449 I havent watched the movie yet all i can confirm is that Brad Pitt is a great actor
When Tristan removed his brothers heart. You knew, people were gonna pay for the death of his brother. What a scene.
No they wouldn't.
@@Gordon2022 Yes they would. He rides out that night and returns with lots of scalps!
yeah, but when he said, "God damn you, God" while stabbing his brother, it felt a bit satanic to me... just sayig
@@Ramzblood yea he spends the rest of the movie thinking that when he cursed God that day God tries to get him back or something. The cursing God is significant.
@@Ramzbloodsame
Brad Pitt took his vengeance on the Germans 25 years later in Inglorious Basterds.
and fury
✊
but at the end he become german spies in tibet.
Hell ya he did
Wann rächt sich die Welt an der USA?
NOOOOOOO!!!! U could hear the Anger and Pain in that scream..
samuel and tristan deserve oscar awards here..they both did great acting..
Everyone is praising Brad Pitt in this film - but Aidan Quinn stole the show for me. He was great. Sadly he has been mostly forgotten about in film these days. But between Legends of the Fall and Michael Collins - he is one of the greats.
I first saw him in An Early Frost--when it was really risky careerwise to play a gay man, especially one with AIDS. Good in everything he did, including the incredible Songcatcher.
Exactly. Aidan Quinn has been great in everything I've seen him in. He's good at playing these emotionally tortured, borderline villainous characters who you can sympathise with. Great actor.
Aidan Quinn is such an amazing actor. He has such a great, classic look for a period film like this.
He was great in the Assignment too
I so agree. I think Aiden's role was by far the hardest of all the actors as he had to convey loyalty and resentment convincingly, at the same time.
I never understood why Pitt didn't get an Oscar for this. This was one of the most amazing performances by any one not named Hanks in my lifetime.
Probably because it wasn’t that good, and just because you choose to be dramatic by going straight to the top shelf with your words doesn’t mean his acting was actually good.
@@dropkickirish4449 well, opinions are like assholes. I have my own, so I don't need yours. You are actually allowed to comment without being a douchebag. Wasn't being dramatic, just giving my opinion, like everyone else.
@@dropkickirish4449 I think it was a reference to the fact that the winner for Best Actor that year was, in fact, Tom Hanks (Forrest Gump) 😉
Tom Hanks is overrated imo.
@@the-real-super-genius Tom Hanks has always been a part of the “system”. In with the higher ups, don’t get me wrong he is a great actor but he’s had a lot of mediocre and overrated movies too.
Brad is phenomenal in this scene
The whole movie
As and older brother, it hurts that he couldnt save him.
There will never be a more heat breaking scene in cinema than this. No pun intended.
Might I suggest watching some more films? Is this heartbreaking? Absolutely? Is it the most heartbreaking scene in cinema? No... no no no... quantifiably no!
I mean.... did you even see the ending to The Mist (2007)? I wouldn't even consider THAT the most heartbreaking ending in all of cinema, but holy smokes what a gut punch...
Never...? NEVER?!? That's a strong word there, missy. Language matters... don't take your words for granted, please.
@@mattbrendlenPeople are allowed to have different opinions than you. No need to write entire paragraphs of drivel to try and prove them wrong. All you did is make an ass of yourself.
@@willm678 no I didn’t…
Hey, you were right, I DIDN’T need to write an entire paragraph to prove you wrong!
Thanks!
@@mattbrendlen No, thank *you* for proving my point.
@@willm678 No no... thank you for proving MY point...
HA... Uno reversed it, bud!
And thus, Aldo Raine was born.
One Of The Best Films Ever, Yet So Underrated ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I have never actually seen an actor's pupils change while filming. What an actor... I can't even finish this scene...just leaves me devastated. The loss, the WASTE, Pitt delivers it all. Just staggering.
This film deserve an Oscar..!!
It did win an Oscar for cinematography but it deserved more.
Nobody forced Samuel to join up. He had NO idea what he was getting himself into.
Brad Pitt the most underrated actor ever. He's a different level
Agreed! His range as an actor is limitless.
Brad Pitt is a highly acclaimed actor that is a household name in every country that gets Hollywood movies. Calling him underrated when almost everyone who's seen his films sings his praises means you've just come out from under a rock
@@beezzarro No, he’s the most underrated actor in all of human history! He’s literally a genius! Something, something Oscar, Academy Award. Plus, how is anyone going to know that OP is really smart unless he uses recycled rhetoric on TH-cam?
@@the-real-super-genius Jealous of what? Oh do please explain.
@@the-real-super-genius I like Brad Pitt. He’s great.
I’m naming my son after the youngest brother cause I hope Brad Pitt Will always protect him
😀
Oscar, derp, derp, literally genius acting, Academy Award, underrated. Right guys?
@@the-real-super-genius It’s one of my favorite films, actually. My comment clearly rubbed you the wrong way, though. Haha I’m curious to know why.
@@the-real-super-genius k
My favorite Brad Pitt movie. His best acting in my opinion.
Gotta love beard pitts man bought my first one a year ago still fires up just fine paints fine it’s a good product. Merry Christmas Andrew Tate supporters!
Agree
@ wildyunr mine 2
Absolutely great camera work at 1:51, with the sunshine highlighting the scene. So beautiful.
I love this movie so much, I cry everytime
This stil make me cry every. Time I see this. Thinking of my brother 😢 powerful scene
I hate my brother.
@@katierojas8066 Why? What did he do?
I’m really annoyed that his woman ended up getting with both brothers after. So disrespectful and easy.
For me anthony hopkins deserved the praise for this masterpiece
‘Tis at this moment Tristan realized that German scalps were in the wrong place. For his belt was bare, and needed accoutrements
What about Stalingrad veterans?
I found it idiotic at the time, and still do now, that two Germans stopped, set up a machine gun, just too machine one guy caught in barbed wire, but dont shoot the guy running towards them with a weapon screaming like crazy. So ridiculously over dramatic.
Besides, they wouldn't waste so many bullets for one guy who was already dying and was completely harmless to them.
So, none of you have heard about overkill? Maybe those two soldiers were just looking to merc tf outta someone, and were caught off guard? Its war, it brought out the ugly in many a man
Was just thinking that myself my friend
Well, it was in the script you know.
That's the point. This makes for better emotional cinema
Henry Thomas is such an underrated actor man. Yeah Brad Pitt is great but Thomas is too
This scene is pretty gut-wrenching when you think of this happening to your brother or son, but it never made sense to me that the Germans (I assume) would set up a machine gun to kill one guy. They would have just shot him with a pistol or rifle, or just held the machine gun and fired. It doesn't make any sense at all that they would take the time to place it on its tripod, load, and then fire... for one enemy soldier.
It doesn’t. But this movie is melodramatic AF.
Or they would’ve taken him prisoner most likely since nobody else was around! I hate how movies make WW1 Germans out to be like WW2 SS Soldiers
Or the fact that they didn’t hear the brothers talking to one another while setting up inbetween them
I first saw this movie at Age 14 and have wondered about this ever since... It'd've been such a waste of ammo, my god
@@happybeingmiserable4668 Apparently they did some horrible shit to civilians, as many armies did, but yes, I agree.
"Hey there's one guy! Quick! We need to get experience!" Laughing maniacally.
Anyone wondering why brad Pitt didn't get an Oscar for this is not up to speed on how the Oscars do not make their decisions based on quality, but rather politics
Not even politics....it's your position on the Luciferian scale at the time.
@@mikejohn0088 please elaborate. Sounds fascinating
Different people vote every time. Sometimes there are surprise wins when quality does win out. Sometimes, lots of quality films come out at once, and only one can win. Which has been happening forever. Taxi Driver and Rocky were nominated at the same time. Pulp Fiction and Forrest Gump.
Sometimes, the people voting just vote for whatever is popular or arbitrarily vote for a film for inexplicable reasons, though. Like how Saving Private Ryan didn't win best picture and lost to Shakespeare in Love of all films.
@@PandoraBear357 there's a little variation as to who votes because some newcomers are inducted while some abstain, but the voting committee of roughly 10k does not undergo any significant changes from year to year.
It seems like you may not be aware of the egregious and profound amount of lobbying, campaigning, and outright bribing that studio execs conduct in order to manufacture a win for their films
I watched this film on a flight to the US when I was 8 years old, I was absolutely traumatised 😧
Welcome
The Germans wouldn't have set up a machine gun for one guy stuck in barbed wire lmao
Got to have that dramatic death
I know it’s like it’s a Hollywood movie and it said set up a machine gun for one guy because the people watching the movie want to be entertained! Can you believe the audacity?
Yes TF they would have!
@@Phat_336 no dummy, they wouldn't have
They totally would. They probably weren't sure who was on the other side of the slope across the fence. But yes Germans during WW1 had little to no remorse.
i can't help but laugh at this scene, dude doesn't try to help himself and the enemy ignoring the screams of the enemy just to blast one person
Lol
Exactly lmfao there's a soldier running and screaming from the bottom of his lungs behind us, let's just BOTH focus on the trapped guy there and ignore the armed man getting close to us from behind
@@Martha_My_Dear Also why bother wasting rounds from a heavy machine gun on one unarmed guy trapped in wire, if they really felt the need to kill him they could've just used a knife
Or a pistol. Scene is indeed unrealistic and over the top in a lot of ways.@@ST19859
@@ST19859yeah, I mean why didn't they leave the safety of cover with the machine gun and run out there and use a bloody knife to kill the guy? I mean, it makes no sense! Please. I can understand their using a pistol or something, but a knife would be stupid, with soldiers running around with guns, what good is a knife going to do!?
The most beautiful film in the world
Such a sad and powerful scene.. Having to cut his own brother's heart 🫀out so he can take back with him to the family ranch. Then he goes all savage gets his revenge and wears them around his neck!! 👏🏼
To think Samuel is Elliot from ET always shocks me 😅
What a movie...
I think everyone who comes here was affected by this scene in a deep way. Inside all of us we were screaming with Tristan. He knew he couldn't save his beloved brother, he knew he couldn't make it, he knew his brother was about to die, his heart bled as he tried to alter time and space to save his brother but deep down inside he knew. That scream is what makes actors great, what a scene, this is why the cinema era was beautiful.
The fact that Pulp Fiction and Forrest Gump one all the Oscars, and legends of the fall didn’t get anything is criminal. Those two movies were OK I guess, but Legends of the fall was great!
forrest gump was better tho, pulp fiction was pretty good i would put legends over pulp tho.
@@vincenthammons6705 there are lots of movies like pulp fiction. Forget gump too.
There was never a movie like Legends of the Fall.
Legends 💯
Forest Gump great movie but Legends was amazing 2
The cost of war..
You don't know God if you've never cursed him with that kind of rage
you dont know earth if u know god
Curse man, god's creator, for the evil in the world.
Yah I get it.....some blasphemous crap though I dont like it....
@@danielhicks4826 If you STILL believe in 2000 year old fairy tales of invisible men in the sky, you don't get it AT ALL and are holding humanity back.
Tristán freaks out when he sees Samuel die
My favorite Actor.
I use that quote all the time whenever some shit happens. I'll be like "GODDAMN YOU GOD" and my friends will be like "aren't you religious?" And I'm like "yeah, but it's a Brad Pitt quote so 🤷♂️"
I love how the German soldiers took their sweet time and had a cup of coffee while they set up that machine gun.
Oh well it is what it is😢
BRAD SHOULD HAVE WON AN OSCAR FOR THIS MOVIE 🌹
E.T., please freaking come home! 😂🎉
This is one of my favorite movies of all time. The cast is Amazing. The movie was excellent. Brad Pitt was robbed of an Oscar. Brilliant performance by Brad . THIS scene breaks my heart and I cry every time.
1:52 the greatest/saddest scene in cinematography.
You took my Life Breathe Away
La mejor película que he visto en mi vida
This movie and Troy are Brad Pitt's best.
Very cruel and emotive scene but if Samuel wouldnt have died in the war he would had been a cheated husband.
Brad Pitts acting in this is superb
Poor Samuel. Tragically naïve about the brutality of life which led to his life being cut way too short without experiencing the joy of consummating his marriage.
Named my son Tristan bc of this movie
The beginning of "Inglourious basterds" "Aldo The Apace" Rage , revenge & fury pays back in WW2.
I know it's a movie and all, but... a few things bother me here. First off, the machine gunners have sidearms of their own. They wouldn't have needed the Maxim gun to shoot Samuel. Second, they wouldn't have wasted that many bullets on 1 man. And third, in doing so, he would have been dead instantly. No tearjerking last moments between him and Tristan after that many bullets at such close range.
Great scene and movie however Im not sure they'd put all three brothers together like that in war. Their love for each other and trying to protect the youngest brother because hes engaged could have messed up the battle plans for their regimen.
Tristan had a tough gig trying to watch Samuels back in a dangerous war 24/7.
Damn u god❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
No way a Machine gun team would’ve wasted so much time just to kill 1 soldier trapped by barbed wire
2:56 One Stab sensed a disturbance in the Force
Actually, he ate a bad burrito before going to bed and shit himself, but tried to play it off as Indian magic in case anyone was watching him.
Очень сильная сцена,до слёз. Бред Питт- ЛУЧШИЙ актёр, достойный всех Оскаров
In reality, a soldier serving with the Canadian Expeditionary Force would've been sporting a brush cut. Long hair was absolutely verboten & never, ever would've been allowed under any circumstances - even if he were Brad Pitt.
My mom watch this movie before I was born she inspired to call me Tristan
this movie is far more than just a Brad Pitt movie; it's a movie made for us to realize how horrific war is. this might be just a movie; but in reality we face wars beyond our imagination and on screens to see the pain, misery, sorrow, regrets, and hatred of those who we face and fight; for no reason at all. this is why; I hate politicians and don't care for them. I work as a chemical engineer; as a chemist and I've seen Hell's Furies. and they want nothing from humanity; except the love and compassion of life on earth without wars and hatred for others. we no nothing about. Thank you; Brad Pitt. You will always be Achilles to me!
20 years later Tristan change his name into Aldo Raine
I lost my younger brother as well and I sometimes want to curse God even though I know I shouldn't....
Why would you take the time to set up a machine gun to shoot one man when one bullet would do
for the camera OBVIOUSLY
Dan, Dan, Dan, Dan Daaaaan
I never understood why they set up a machine gun for one dude trapped in barbed wire... Like, they didn't even need to use a pistol! He was trapped! Just slap him a few times.
Tristan got Samuel killed because he was screaming his name out loud
Fire the continuity girl.
Yeah. In reality, those machine guns were used purely for holding the trench lines. He'd more than likely die from a snipers bullet.
Last call
I know some people who never proved it.
If my brother died,I'd have an endless Thurst for blood
Very Sad brother your doing good
I can't save you
Therapy 😢
Now we know the backstory on why the Central Powers lost to the Allies of WWI.
Thank the guys on the gatling gun.
When u realize the video is only half way done & he got get native on his bro.
Samuel!
Samuels execution!The most satisfying death of a war fan in film history :)
I would like more context for this comment
Very nice from the Germans; they stopped firing when Tristan arrived, taking care of his brother. Very nice!
He killed them
What life I smile
He takes his heart. Why😨
Good performance of Brad Pitt
Steven Spielberg go home 😤😤😤 Saving Private Ryan can't compete with this 👏👏👏
21 to my life I don't know ❤❤
28 my pistol s hahaha in my way 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Como é nome desse filme alguem poder me falar?
Legends of fall
38 this sounds never ends 😂😂❤❤❤
Man to man fight
Ok
I have this six sense that i am going to die soon and when i have them they always come true but i am not afraid of death
サミュエル😢戦争に行かなければ、良かったのに、、トリスタンの大事な弟、
愛する人、待っていたのに、😢
Look me handfast 😢😢
You're doing good! You got thirty holes in you but we're going home!
Nous avons essayé de nous retrouver mais voilà ce qu'ils ont fait c'est chien je compare notre séparation comme cela maintenant je pars mais je ne t'oublierai jamais parce que tu m'as sauvé la vie je t'aime Mirel Julian que j'ai baptisé JM 🥺😢😭