@@Zacharysandilands locrian mode is not more complicated than the major mode, it's just different so, if that person hears that as a D locrian then what's wrong with that ? If you hear it as a Eb major good for you but it's not the same for everyone
What is special about improvisation, specially good improvisation is that you don't know when they make a mistake. Because they find a way out of it through (you guessed it) improvisation. You can see at the beginning, he's gone in the wrong chord progressing direction 0:34 (went up, instead of down't and couldn't resolve), but altered the whole partition of the song the way it sounded even better. then later at 0:43 you can see again him searching for a resolve, but couldn't find it, so he slipped in a filler to rearange the chords in order to sing again in tune. Then at 1:08 when he says kisses, you hear that he first sings the tone, then finds a supporting chord. That means he first feels, then sings, and follows with hand accordingly. There are many instances from where you can pick up that he's improvising and that what he sings and plays sometimes doesn't go together, but he plays his way out of it and just makes a whole that is great to listen to.
Lovely theory, but I genuinely don't believe any of these were mistakes, because they are so perfectly in accordance with the kind of style and techniques that Jacob employs.
My take is that he catches himself almost starting to play something cliche and says to himself "OK, play something off the wall to force myself to find the way back to the song." It's as if playing a standard resolution is a trap to be avoided at all costs. Think of Brer Rabbit -- a cliche is like the tar baby and a random chord, etc. is like the briar bush.
Trust me. Jacob Collier does not make mistakes. From Kung Fu Panda... Oogway: There are no accidents. Shifu: [sighs] Yes, I know. You've already said that twice. Oogway: That was no accident either.
I like your analysis. It's as if he believes he can perform anything and find his way, same with his vocal, the consequence is a directionless, unfocused, scrappy, at times ridiculous and more importantly, tasteless performance.
His voice and playing’! Jesus! A perfect fusion of Nat KC timbre, Stevie Wonder vocal dynamics. He plays every note and elaborates every harmony with the naturalness with which I beak coffee in the morning. true genius!
Absolutely gorgeous! How effortless he sings no matter what range! Then he accompanying himself with incredible reharms that are so fresh for this tune. He is something else! Thanks for posting!
it represents for me the absolute musicality, highly remerci to be the greatest representative of an intelligent youth who loves art in general. thousand congratulations to you Jacob réelement you're great.
lol. I am surprised he posted in spite of that. Great lyrics count! "When I fall in love it will be forever Or I'll never fall in love In a restless world like this is Love is ended before it's begun And too many moonlight kisses Seem to cool in the warmth of the sun"
He was definitely under the influence of Kenny Rankin on this one. That's not Jacob's style, COMPLETELY Kenny Rankin. Thanks for reminding of that artist to the tee!
I don't like the word "monster" but engels. In last 8 years we have got three young engels : Jacob Collier and two guitar players from south Italy : Matteo Mancuso (24) from Sicily and Pasquale Grasso (32) from Avellino ( near Neaples) . Please , listen ti the them. Steve vai, Pat methney , Pat martino and other greats agree . Ciao. Raffaele aus neaples
I'm already totally wiped out by the brilliance of this astonishing musician. But, this is not one of my favourites. (Sorry, guys!) I hope Jacob will revisit this song one day and bring us a new interpretation. See - the words of the song are famously MAGNIFICENT. They need to be shown as much respect as the melody. "AND THE MOMENT THAT I FEEL THAT - YOU FEEL THAT WAY TOO" is such a perfect line it really shouldn't be altered. "feel that" and "feel that" are a matching pair.
He tried to wing it with the lyrics and he ended up kinda butchering them lol. Probably would’ve been better if he wasn’t thinking about getting them right the whole time.
You are one of the best musician and artist I have ever seen. But you are not able to sing. It's too much. With your hands you do miracles, but the voice is not ok
Probably the most 'standard' performance by Jacob on youtube. Stunning.
Watch him with Jamie Cullum. It's superb.
I love the D locrian scale resolving to an F major chord at the end. Its so warm
@@sophiafake-virus2456 it's not random and it's not tasteless. he's got an incredible ear and I think he uses harmony to suit his taste perfectly.
@Siobhan Fagan Well winning or losing in Britain’s got talents doesn’t mean anything at all, it’s all scripted
@@sophiafake-virus2456 If you're going to critic, make it specific. I want to learn, not to hate.
pff its Eb major my guy. People love to over complicate things. Negative 5-1 cadence is the clearest way of viewing it.
@@Zacharysandilands locrian mode is not more complicated than the major mode, it's just different so, if that person hears that as a D locrian then what's wrong with that ? If you hear it as a Eb major good for you but it's not the same for everyone
I'm my third life, I'm coming back as Jacob Collier. He's such a monster.
+onealmusicgroup I'm planning it for my second life.
I wonder why you said your third life, where were you on your first two?
+TuxSax Well I'm just me in this here second life but I dream I was Johnny Costa prior to this one lol
IM THERE WITH YOU BROTHER. THIS SO FUCCKKIN INSANE.
Just discovered who he was tonight.....me tooo....ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL
What is special about improvisation, specially good improvisation is that you don't know when they make a mistake. Because they find a way out of it through (you guessed it) improvisation.
You can see at the beginning, he's gone in the wrong chord progressing direction 0:34 (went up, instead of down't and couldn't resolve), but altered the whole partition of the song the way it sounded even better. then later at 0:43 you can see again him searching for a resolve, but couldn't find it, so he slipped in a filler to rearange the chords in order to sing again in tune. Then at 1:08 when he says kisses, you hear that he first sings the tone, then finds a supporting chord. That means he first feels, then sings, and follows with hand accordingly.
There are many instances from where you can pick up that he's improvising and that what he sings and plays sometimes doesn't go together, but he plays his way out of it and just makes a whole that is great to listen to.
i appreciated reading this.
Lovely theory, but I genuinely don't believe any of these were mistakes, because they are so perfectly in accordance with the kind of style and techniques that Jacob employs.
My take is that he catches himself almost starting to play something cliche and says to himself "OK, play something off the wall to force myself to find the way back to the song." It's as if playing a standard resolution is a trap to be avoided at all costs. Think of Brer Rabbit -- a cliche is like the tar baby and a random chord, etc. is like the briar bush.
Trust me. Jacob Collier does not make mistakes.
From Kung Fu Panda...
Oogway: There are no accidents.
Shifu: [sighs] Yes, I know. You've already said that twice.
Oogway: That was no accident either.
I like your analysis.
It's as if he believes he can perform anything and find his way, same with his vocal, the consequence is a directionless, unfocused, scrappy, at times ridiculous and more importantly, tasteless performance.
I-hi-hi-HIiiT will be foreverr
Beautiful. His voice and his piano ease my mind.
His voice and playing’! Jesus! A perfect fusion of Nat KC timbre, Stevie Wonder vocal dynamics. He plays every note and elaborates every harmony with the naturalness with which I beak coffee in the morning. true genius!
Nope
Absolutely gorgeous! How effortless he sings no matter what range! Then he accompanying himself with incredible reharms that are so fresh for this tune. He is something else! Thanks for posting!
it represents for me the absolute musicality, highly remerci to be the greatest representative of an intelligent youth who loves art in general. thousand congratulations to you Jacob réelement you're great.
lol i love his vintage hippie style as well.. how can a man like him still be so grounded
Jacob’s beautiful
voice takes me to heaven,
When I FELL in love (lol) - Jacob is superb here as per usual.
How can anyone not stop and just listen to this?
Jacob, you are an inspiration ☺ I do love this song and you gave justice to it ☺☺☺
1:21 MY G O D
I had to listen to that run about 10 times before going on...
+luvche3 ikr
you're everywhere on this guys videos lol
Mats Hilmer LOL sorry, when I found out about him I kind of binge watched all of his vids, and I have a habit on commenting on every vid LOL
Mats Hilmer yeah true lol... I had to stop myself from saying "sorry" again XD
this is the type of music I live for
Yes!
Nat King would be so proud of this
Incredibly Proud
@@sophiafake-virus2456 sure about that?
June Lee, your services are needed
I sure could use a tall, cold glass of delicious Henry's Sparkling Cider right now.
Love this young man!
Ele, realmente, existe neste mundo? 😍
Existe e já esteve no Brasil!!!
E eu perdi? 😭😭😭😭😭
I'm so done OMG THE TALENT crying
Wonderful, just wonderful.
This put me to sleep. I woke up in the morning and it was still looping
There is something so lovely about this ♡
Kenzie everything is so lovely about this 😂😂
I forget how awesome the line up at Cheltenham is
Awesome piano chops!!!
Beautiful! 💗
So beautiful
Me encanta esta canción y tu forma de hacer música me fascina, genio
Wow, love this!
HOLY COW SO AWESOME
I was so taken aback the first time I heard this that I didn't even notice that he messes up on the lyrics a little.
Mr. Master forever and completely... yeah I caught that but he's a fuckin genius
And with the music as well, but he goes through with his mistakes and makes it sound even better
I love your singing style. I also uploaded this song on TH-cam and thought about it, there are nice versions and I've found yours. Many thanks
Jacob is so beautiful - in about eight different ways.
So beautiful!
1:37 : "but i'll never fall in love....with you"
lol
lol. I am surprised he posted in spite of that. Great lyrics count! "When I fall in love it will be forever
Or I'll never fall in love
In a restless world like this is
Love is ended before it's begun
And too many moonlight kisses
Seem to cool in the warmth of the sun"
extraordinario
This is amazing.. So talented..
AMAZING.
1:29 just lost me there.. im still waiting at the road's side for you to come back for me!
Que genio!!!
Awesome!
Genius!!!
I liked this before I heard it:)
Fans of Jacob Collier's music in a nutshell
@@cabal4171 why are you here then lol
Everything I listen 1:51. It's gives me chills
Superb.
I'm really fall in love!!! 😍 😍 😍
WOW!!!!!!!!!! That's all I can say !!!!!!!!!!!!
promoting beer & festival ayyyy nice.. oooh !!
what kind of music genre is this? idk but i love it.
Contemporary jazz
are u serious lol
JaaaaaaaZzzzzzzzzZzzzz
Welcome to the club bro
No genre. Jacob Collier.
Meraviglioso!!! Un super genio!!!!
He was definitely under the influence of Kenny Rankin on this one. That's not Jacob's style, COMPLETELY Kenny Rankin. Thanks for reminding of that artist to the tee!
There is Darknet and there is BrightNet, your talent define BrightNet mate!!
GRAZIE Mille TH-cam 📚🎼🌍🌹
I have fallen in love with you, and you don't have to feel that way too!
that vocal range
Freedom
"Henry Westons: Exceptional Cider".
How about "Jacob Collier: Exceptional Human"
Nice
😍
😀💙🌱🌺
크
I don't like the word "monster" but engels. In last 8 years we have got three young engels : Jacob Collier and two guitar players from south Italy : Matteo Mancuso (24) from Sicily and Pasquale Grasso (32) from Avellino ( near Neaples) . Please , listen ti the them. Steve vai, Pat methney , Pat martino and other greats agree . Ciao. Raffaele aus neaples
What kind of keyboard is this? I love the sound.
roland rd800
thanks!
what kind of scale is that at the end?
F minor starting from d,e,f.... resolves to F major in the end
In the left hand 3rd and 6th of every note that is played.
nice. thanks!
SpectralChicken ...how
Woahhh why does his hair look so normal in this? this can't be the real jacob.
great. much better on this than on his own material.
Joke its cider's mod sry ;) like it .
Those 11 thumbs-down should have their thumbs cut off. Just saying.
진짜..........
haha, I love him, he's the most unbelievable genius, but he murdered my favorite song
"but I'll never fall in lvoe with youu" hahahha forgot some lyrics there... what a sweetheart, though. Wonderful.
Kinda wish he'd gone for a more Bill Evans style approach but hey, I can barely read sheet music and play piano, what do I know.
He kinda reminds me of Keir Gilchrist
my god is it not a Jeff Buckey style???... so beautifull
Who came from June Lee's video ?
That’s some “subtle” product placement. I’m ok with it though because it’s Jacob Collier
I'm already totally wiped out by the brilliance of this astonishing musician. But, this is not one of my favourites. (Sorry, guys!) I hope Jacob will revisit this song one day and bring us a new interpretation. See - the words of the song are famously MAGNIFICENT. They need to be shown as much respect as the melody. "AND THE MOMENT THAT I FEEL THAT - YOU FEEL THAT WAY TOO" is such a perfect line it really shouldn't be altered. "feel that" and "feel that" are a matching pair.
10 people who watched this video are jealous
He tried to wing it with the lyrics and he ended up kinda butchering them lol. Probably would’ve been better if he wasn’t thinking about getting them right the whole time.
Nice until he went into Falsetto and did the stupid "runs" just ruined it for me...
i thought it was charming
You are one of the best musician and artist I have ever seen. But you are not able to sing. It's too much. With your hands you do miracles, but the voice is not ok
Awful
He's ok. I guess.
far to much going on in his poor head! talented in a way though.
Oh boy, that was a stinker.
(no taste)