That photo of Helen Blackwood was extraordinary. Truly haunting. Even though photography had been around for about twenty years in 1853, it was still in its primitive stages. The detail and expressiveness of the portrait is almost a masterpiece for its time. I'd love to know the circumstances of when and where the photo was taken.
The same occurred to me. For someone so poor, how would she afford it? Or is the photo not her at all, but a substitute (like in other channels)? Just thoughts.
What a sad story. Helen was defending herself by hitting him with a chamber pot. If they had just left it with that, they would've been ok. The young boys saw that she had hit him in self defense. But robbing him when he was down and throwing him out the window sealed their fates. And Ann getting a lighter sentence was not right at all, she was just as guilty. And marrying at the gallows, what a bizarre love story. And I would love a live stream video from you! I love the older mysteries that you bring to us, and would be fascinated to know how you found all these old stories. ❤
Yes, please! There are lots of us who really enjoy the historical aspect (literally why I subscribe) and there is definitely interest. I would love to learn and watch a different take!!
This has got to be one of the most bizarre love stories I've ever heard. Almost seems like Hollywood material. Thank you BC, for another Monday morn/Friday night story. Have a great week!!
5 Years!! It doesn't seem that long since I discovered this channel with a subscriber count just in the hundreds. It's been a pleasure to be part of this, as I'll continue to, looking forward to many more. Thanks for half a decade of interesting stories, told so well. All the best for the future of your channel, Mr Case 😃
The more I watch you, the more I realize how much humanity has always been attracted to the spectacle. Like moths to a flame. This is important work, Brief Case. Thanks. I'd be interested in watching a live stream with Q&A. I can imagine many of your viewers would like to know how to start doing their own historical research.
BriefCase, do whatever you want with your channel - we love your content and production values. And Happy Anniversary, have loved your channel (and CrimeReel's) since forever.
Hello!!! I love this channel so much as someone who has always adored history. It’s great that you tell the story as well as giving context and explaining customs of the time. Honestly, great work
I'm so glad u made this channel!! I think that past crimes are just as important as today's and most definitely should be just as much remembered!! So I truly thank you for doing these videos!!! U are so hard working and dedicated to your amazing channel and I think a live stream/ Q & A would be AWESOME!! **PLS consider doing it!! **Best wishes to ALL and much LOVE from PENNSYLVANIA!! 💜
BC, I would watch as much of your content as possible. Live streams are sometimes difficult for me depending on the timing, but if it would stay posted, I could definitely watch it later. A live stream would help us get to know you. I, for one, would love to know what inspired you to provide fascinating content such as this, and how you do your research. Either way, I will continue to be a fan of your channel, for sure!
Of course we would love a Q&A session. However if you are not comfortable with it you have no obligation to do so. Real fans and most people, i hope, should completely understand and respect that. Love your channel either way!!!
Id love to see a live play....my whole family appreciates the dark melodious tone you speak with .....relaxing morbid and interesting.....Thank You for finding these stories
Livestream? Q&A? Interviews? Well, of course we are interested but only in with what you, yourself, feel comfortable. I'm just super thrilled to see a new video! This one was especially tragic, and thank you so very much.
What a sad case... I've researched a bit on 19th century slum housing, as some of my great-grandparents grew up in housing like this. As far as I know they never fell foul of the law, but it was a very hard life that we cannot imagine. I would be interested in a live stream, though I'm not on YT all the time; I guess it would be posted up afterwards.
Great case! I must admit to being glad that they were able to marry at the last moment. When folks are forced to live like animals to survive, it's hard not to feel sorry for them when they act like an animal. Them marrying was like a last statement of dignity and humanity. And of course, I would enjoy a live stream to learn a bit about the only fellow on youtube who puts out shows that I never miss and always look forward to. I confess that I do enjoy thinking of you as Mr. Case, lol. Thanks for another great brief case!
That's very rude to animals. Wild animals keep their dens nice and clean (except for bears, which are very huminoid when you think about it) Overcrowding creates high stress. My neighbor wakes me up at 5:00 and 8:00 every single day. If I could hit her over the head with a chamber pot I would. Anyway, animals act much more fair and noble than humans
@@lazyhomebody1356 I do take your point about the wild animals, and I suppose that caged animals would be a better reference, which would apply to the overcrowding as well. That's really what I mean. You can't expect that people will hold themselves to your society's standard while living cheek by jowl in squalid conditions, struggling for daily survival. Your chamberpot line gave me laugh😸
@@cruisepaige Oh! I absolutely agree and am sorry if I gave that impression. I myself have been a poor, not-criminal my whole life, lol. Rural poor, though. I can only imagine how awful it was in Scotland at that time, but I'm sure the majority of people were law-abiding. I also think that there were a lot people who were treated so poorly over their entire lives that they lost a lot of their humanity. I can't stop thinking about those poor boys, parents dead, and the only one willing and able to house them was a thieving prostitute who let them sleep under her bed!!? I wish history told us how their lives turned out.
I've been listening religiously for 2 years since I found your channel during my drives to university so I'm happy with any content you upload! I think it would be super cool if you did a livestream so your fans can send tips and ask questions about you, if you're open to that sort of thing! But if you're not comfortable doing one then don't force yourself to do something you don't wanna do. ❤ Also, I imagine the logistics behind it would be tough to figure out.
I think anything you decide to do with your channel, would be fabulous, you are just incredibly talented, your demeanor and narration are superb, and so comforting, and yours is the only channel that I lose myself in the story and imagine it as it would have been, and that's fascinating to me. It's what sets you apart from the rest, and the time and attention to detail, and research is also just fascinating, how you find details from so long ago, right down to the time and day, and the background of a city and the victim. So beautifully presented, and eloquently narrated. Thank-you, and please keep doing what you do, it's so very interesting and appreciated, thank-you Mr Brief Case!!! ☺️💞
I think it would be so cool if you did a live collab with either another historical channel or another crime channel so that more people could discover your really well put together, well researched, and interesting work. I know a lot of people would love it but just haven't come across it.❤
I think a livestream with you and other true crime You Tubers would be very interesting. Discussions of favorite tales, disturbing crimes, tales of research into such histories and overall how you all fell into true crime fandom and decision to share them on YT.
@@nicolad8822 I can write what I want. If I want to use Eire in an English sentence I will Is féidir liom a scríobh cad ba mhaith liom. Más mian liom Éire a úsáid in abairt Bhéarla déanfaidh mé
@@nicolad8822 can I remind you you’ve just used a Gaelic word in an English sentence. We spell it Gaeilge Hopefully there’s no bad blood between us? Grand health and happiness from baile átha Cliath (DUBLIN) 💚🇮🇪 P.S English is not my first language Irish Gaelic is,so I try to simplify things
Brilliant presentation, as always! Cheers for another fascinating case with a wicked twist at the end to boot. My great great grandparents left Glasgow for Belfast once it started getting more people, mid 1700’s. I’ve inherited the estate in Belfast and Glasgow, both are gorgeous but I couldn’t imagine that many living in such a small area. The Estates are outside the city on many hectares but my great Nana and papa would tell me stories of not going into the city for months at a time. Servants would go, find pleasant lodging and stay to collect what was needed. I wrote down all they’d tell me, I found each story so fascinating and intriguing. I’m all for a livestream BUT only if you’re comfortable with it and it doesn’t interfere with your daily life.
Brief case q & a? YES PLEASE. I've been following for almost 5 years and this is the best part of my Monday. I would be so so interested to hear an interview or watch a livestream by a channel that has been so much a part of my life. ❤
I would L❤VE to see a livestream!! Your voice is so hypnotic, and I get such pleasure listening to you as you do your amazing vids. I never much cared for history whilst I was in school, but you make learning about it so interesting. The care and love that you put into each video is amazing!! I live for your videos each and every Monday!! ❤❤❤❤ much love to you!!!
I think you and They Got Away With Murder have the most story telling talent. Your writing is on par with his works. I'm sure if he's seen your channel, he's enjoyed your work!!
Does anyone ever wake up in the morning and think "Today, I'll commit a murder" I don't believe they considered this thought To be publicly married on the gallows moments before your life is taken from you for your crime of murder is just overwhelming Thanks Again Great Story
Crazy case! Ann should have received the same punishment. Your description of the poverty in Glasgow reminds me of the description of poverty in the Easr End of London on the original episode of In Search Of ... about Jack the Ripper.
This channel has been my nightly routine for 4-ish years. I am not sure I could fall asleep without it at this point 😅 This channel is the best and cant wait for the years to come!
A livestream would be a great change of pace once in a while. But please it would have to start with the crashing sound that all your stories begin with and that I like so much.
I'd love to have a live chat while the case is on so I can ask you some historical questions while we are all watching it together, if not a live a Q&A world be grea. I love your channel your historical knowledge is wonderful and the cases are very detailed. Thanks for all of your hard work x
I love your voice and cadence…the stories themselves have the drama. I play these everyday and enjoy them thoroughly. I’d love to hear how this topic came to you, the research you obviously put in to each, and whether or not you feel crime is more prevalent now or then. Yes, please try some livestream ❤
His voice and delivery are what make the channel. I think those qualities are more important than the material themselves. Try to listen to other history channel and because of the presentation I just can't sit through it. Briefcase you are indeed a gem.
Livestream? Sure! As for this case, they got what they deserved. Self defense is one thing but robbing then throwing him out of the window is another. Excellent job narrating, as always!
I think robbing him was really the least of it though. He kind of walked into that one with his drunken behavior. Throwing him out the window was a terrible thing!
I think a Q&A with you would be fascinating. You are so knowledgeable in history of crime and history, it would be interesting to hear what really interests and excites you about all of the past cases and crime and mystery in general.
I like your channel just as it is, no need to change perfection. But of course, if you want to try new things, it's up to you. About today's case, I find it a little hard to believe that the teenage girl just happened to decide to follow them that day, to look through cracks in the door, and heard things the boys who was definitely in the room hadn't heard.
Yes, please - I would be very interested in hearing an interview/live-stream with you. Happy you're getting the recognition you deserve! This is a great channel.
I vote 'not'. I'm sure you are a lovely person, a decent human and a pleasure to talk to. If we were friends, or down the pub, I'd surely share a pint or 3 with you. But I'm not here to make a new friend (even in the parasocial sense that it would have to be), I'm here for your great content. I don't care if you are married or single, black or white, gay or straight, Liberal of Conservative, theist or atheist, or anything else. Whatever you are, that's great. I wish you all the best. But I'm just here to enjoy your great videos and any personal stuff will, for me, be Irrelevant - and for some, it might even be a distraction or a detraction. Stick to the good stuff, is my vote. But whatever you decide to do, I'll be here watching the content I came for all along. Cheers!
Most people seem to be interested in how BC became interestd in crime and started the channel. I agree I don't want a detailed picture of the narrator of these stories!
BC never disappoints! Thank you for another fantastic video. Your storytelling is exceptional. Your writing and research thoughtful. Yes you are very appreciated Monday morning ❤🇺🇸
Hello Swedishpiggi a workhouse in England was a place that was an institution where the poor and sick were offered accomodations like a place to sleep and work.
You also have the ability to attract people’s curiosity to the historical context you deliver I definitely think there is an audience for a live stream If you need any sounding boards or to look over your skills for live feed i would be happy to help or support You are keeping history alive
First time commenting. I greatly enjoy this channel. Wanted to leave a quick thank you for your narration. As a blind person, I rely heavily on in-depth narration when watching videos. Again, thank you. This content is much appreciated.
Thankyou so much, your comment means a lot to me as I do get complaints that I put in too much background history, but I like doing that to set the scene, so do not plan to stop
She’s quite beautiful. Reminds me of my mom when she was younger. Strange their companion had her sentence overturned. It was a terrible life that none of us, with our many comforts, could begin to imagine. I cannot judge them so harshly for searching his person for valuables. These people were literally starving. So many years later, it’s impossible to say what killed the man; self defense or the fall. I’m not making excuses for the perpetrators. I’m only saying we are judging them from our phones or laptops, likely well-fed and not jammed 5-7 people in one small room. It’s sad that what was likely the best moment in both of their lives was followed in seconds by the worst.
Another beautifully and compassionately told story. Congratulations on 5 years Brief Case.🎉 I can't believe it's that long since you started... as the saying goes, time flies when you're having fun😊
Wow five years already!👏 It's absolutely been five years of excellent quality presentations Sir💯 One of my favorite channels, always well researched and compelling, and I love your voice and accent❤ As far as doing a live Q&A etc, of course that would be great, but it's up to you. I completely understand if you're the type of person who prefers a bit of privacy and doesn't want people to see their face, or just doesn't really feel comfortable being live on camera. Either way I will continue to be a loyal subscriber from the PacNW U.S.😊
Thanks BC! Another great story and Happy TH-cam Anniversary! There is no way that the story of the two children and the "girl" how watched them through the door aligned so perfectly without police dictating a narrative. More plausible to believe that she hit him with the chamber pot and he fell and hit his head on the rock which killed him. They freaked out and tossed him out the window. Still guilty but probably not have been sent to the gallows.
I am a nerd especially for history and so of course I absolutely LOVE your channel!!! I would love to get the opportunity to watch a livestream or watch someone interview, you or just anything, to figure why you're so passionate about these stories!!!! Anything exyra I would love to see you do anything extra!!!!
I don't know... I love the mystery of you...Your voice is so soothing, the tone and your accent... Love your storytelling... Imagining what you look like and what your body language would be is part of my enjoyment... The mystery of you...But if you decide to do it... I wouldn't miss it for the world...Many regards... No regrets❤️🌎❤️
Another excellent video; thank you for all your stories - they are so well researched! I would be interested in a Q and A to get to know you and why you started your channel. Well done - I look forward to many more!
Well now...I must say I'm in agreement with the jury's original decisions regarding guilt and that Ann getting away with what she did doesn't sit right with me. She was as culpable as the gentleman who told them to toss him off the balcony. The marriage reminds me that even back then, there were "crazy stunts" people would be involved in when infamous. It isn't only the rich who have their quirks and eccentricities! They sure did make a name for themselves! 😂 "You may now kiss the bride." THUD! Have a wonderful week, BC! (Resa)
I can’t wait to watch this one, actually just heard the comment if you want livestream/ other creators - I worked in psychiatry for a loooong time so I’m also always interested to see if it seems like anything related involved bc psych tx was not so hot, but some people are really just not good. Can’t wait !
@@BriefCaseOfficial It is funny 🤣 you should mention that "good with me" part lol 😜 I just got home from the hospital over the weekend I'm passing two kidney stones on the right. The male nurse said "Hun when you decide to do something you don't mess around!" 🤣🤣🤣 I'm sure I'll live! But I felt like I was dying. Well, I guess if you feel pain like that you're not dying, right? Thank you kindly for inquiring. 😊❤️ I'm just patiently waiting for this too shall "pass". 😜
I would love to see a Q and A and interview for your 5th anniversary!!! Please do it! I would sit forever listening to the sound of your beautiful voice!
Personally i can't get enough of you. I've listened to all you have on here and go back through when it's hard to sleep. I look forward to the new ones. You're doing an amazing job!
I think things are fine the way they are, the mystery of not knowing who the man behind the voice is is kind of like classic radio,it's just fine.👌It goes with the classic vibe.
A stream seems harder as you have so many fans from all over the world, and so many times zones, so how do you choose a time that works?!? Not that I wouldn't be all over the rewatch! So if you do a stream, maybe you could open a community page first and take questions there as well, so if we miss the stream we still have a way to submit questions or comments? But it's your channel, so you do you Brief Case, and however you choose to include us fans is a welcome prospect. Wishing all who may see this a radically positive, safe and healthy week.🙏🖤✌️
Thank you; very interesting case [as always]. I am not a fan of live streaming events as i find the unstructured nature boring, and i usually turn off after about 2 mins.
My notification NOT working again! Hello BC, and Happy Independence Day in advance to all American viewers here! Maybe you should do a Q&A session one day.
You always do such great work, I learn a lot from your videos. Not only about the crime itself, but the people living through the experience, and the place where it all took place. I look forward to every presentation, eager to learn new things. I think that a Livestream video, where possibly you take us to the place where a specific crime or crimes took place would be an added boost. I understand that Scotland yard has a crime museum. I think a tour there would be interesting. I love all of your videos. You have such a steady, calming voice that I can listen, and no matter how gruesome the story, there's no unnecessary sensationalism I appreciate your hard work. Keep 'em coming!
I'd love to learn more about you and your motivation for starting and continuing the channel. It need not be a live stream. You could even do it as a scripted episode, if you'd like. But above all, do what makes you feel comfortable. I realize that not every presenter is comfortable turning the spotlight on themselves.
I think the best of the best in telling stories of vintage crimes on You Tube are Brief Case, Obsolete Oddity, They got away with Murder, & Well, I Never ! You all are WONDERFUL! ❤❤❤❤
Thanks, but Bailey is a completely different level to me, though makeup isn't my thing, I have seen a few of her videos and I must say that she is brilliant, a very natural presenter and deserves all her success
To download Merge Restaurant click on the following link: pp.sng.link/Dvmml/r6wy/4ncz
Congrats on 5 years! I've been here from early on. You're my guy when chores are afoot 😊❤ And, Crime Reel👍
Thank you for another awesome story. I thank you for sharing.
@@karenhendrickson1424111
🫢🫢🫢🫢🫢🫢🫢🫢
this was amazing i live in glasgow
If you really think about it, you write an essay for every video. My goodness, you’re essentially a historical crime professor at this point 😂
Yup. I agree!
Exactly what I was thinking!!!🙏👍🧑🎓❣️
Not him. Chat gpt does it for him. All you n33d now is just a good voice tbf
@@ragoon7798 he’s had this channel for several years, long before chatgpt was even a thing lmao
Never thought about that before but your right he is 😊
That photo of Helen Blackwood was extraordinary. Truly haunting. Even though photography had been around for about twenty years in 1853, it was still in its primitive stages. The detail and expressiveness of the portrait is almost a masterpiece for its time. I'd love to know the circumstances of when and where the photo was taken.
I agree. It's a great photo.
The same occurred to me. For someone so poor, how would she afford it? Or is the photo not her at all, but a substitute (like in other channels)? Just thoughts.
I am thinking that this is actually an AI "portrait" -- look at the oddness in the shape of the eyes and inside of the eyes....
@@aengusmacnaughton1375 That very well could be.
Putting aside the crime for one minute...wasn't she pretty?
What a sad story. Helen was defending herself by hitting him with a chamber pot. If they had just left it with that, they would've been ok. The young boys saw that she had hit him in self defense. But robbing him when he was down and throwing him out the window sealed their fates. And Ann getting a lighter sentence was not right at all, she was just as guilty. And marrying at the gallows, what a bizarre love story.
And I would love a live stream video from you! I love the older mysteries that you bring to us, and would be fascinated to know how you found all these old stories. ❤
Yes, please! There are lots of us who really enjoy the historical aspect (literally why I subscribe) and there is definitely interest. I would love to learn and watch a different take!!
This has got to be one of the most bizarre love stories I've ever heard. Almost seems like Hollywood material. Thank you BC, for another Monday morn/Friday night story. Have a great week!!
Glad you enjoyed it
5 Years!! It doesn't seem that long since I discovered this channel with a subscriber count just in the hundreds. It's been a pleasure to be part of this, as I'll continue to, looking forward to many more. Thanks for half a decade of interesting stories, told so well. All the best for the future of your channel, Mr Case 😃
Yes. I found him 2.5 years ago but, never commented then. I just enjoyed the channel
Same ...
I too have been with BC since the early days and am happy every time I get on here! Truly amazing
I really enjoy your channel! Whether you do a live or not, wouldn't change that. ( and I'm quite particular)😊
The more I watch you, the more I realize how much humanity has always been attracted to the spectacle. Like moths to a flame. This is important work, Brief Case. Thanks. I'd be interested in watching a live stream with Q&A. I can imagine many of your viewers would like to know how to start doing their own historical research.
BriefCase, do whatever you want with your channel - we love your content and production values.
And Happy Anniversary, have loved your channel (and CrimeReel's) since forever.
Hello!!! I love this channel so much as someone who has always adored history. It’s great that you tell the story as well as giving context and explaining customs of the time. Honestly, great work
Thank you so much, You too :)
That's why I love this ch as well.
as a fellow history buff: exactly!
Capital punishment in 19th century England was no joke with the massive amount of public execution spectacles.
Would love to see you do a livestream and have a q&a.
I'm so glad u made this channel!! I think that past crimes are just as important as today's and most definitely should be just as much remembered!! So I truly thank you for doing these videos!!! U are so hard working and dedicated to your amazing channel and I think a live stream/ Q & A would be AWESOME!!
**PLS consider doing it!!
**Best wishes to ALL and much LOVE from PENNSYLVANIA!!
💜
Thanks
BC, I would watch as much of your content as possible. Live streams are sometimes difficult for me depending on the timing, but if it would stay posted, I could definitely watch it later. A live stream would help us get to know you. I, for one, would love to know what inspired you to provide fascinating content such as this, and how you do your research.
Either way, I will continue to be a fan of your channel, for sure!
Of course we would love a Q&A session. However if you are not comfortable with it you have no obligation to do so. Real fans and most people, i hope, should completely understand and respect that. Love your channel either way!!!
Id love to see a live play....my whole family appreciates the dark melodious tone you speak with .....relaxing morbid and interesting.....Thank You for finding these stories
Livestream? Q&A? Interviews? Well, of course we are interested but only in with what you, yourself, feel comfortable. I'm just super thrilled to see a new video! This one was especially tragic, and thank you so very much.
What a sad case... I've researched a bit on 19th century slum housing, as some of my great-grandparents grew up in housing like this. As far as I know they never fell foul of the law, but it was a very hard life that we cannot imagine. I would be interested in a live stream, though I'm not on YT all the time; I guess it would be posted up afterwards.
Great case! I must admit to being glad that they were able to marry at the last moment. When folks are forced to live like animals to survive, it's hard not to feel sorry for them when they act like an animal. Them marrying was like a last statement of dignity and humanity. And of course, I would enjoy a live stream to learn a bit about the only fellow on youtube who puts out shows that I never miss and always look forward to. I confess that I do enjoy thinking of you as Mr. Case, lol. Thanks for another great brief case!
Thanks Holly
That's very rude to animals. Wild animals keep their dens nice and clean (except for bears, which are very huminoid when you think about it) Overcrowding creates high stress. My neighbor wakes me up at 5:00 and 8:00 every single day. If I could hit her over the head with a chamber pot I would. Anyway, animals act much more fair and noble than humans
@@lazyhomebody1356 I do take your point about the wild animals, and I suppose that caged animals would be a better reference, which would apply to the overcrowding as well. That's really what I mean. You can't expect that people will hold themselves to your society's standard while living cheek by jowl in squalid conditions, struggling for daily survival. Your chamberpot line gave me laugh😸
There are plenty of poor people who are not thieving criminals.
@@cruisepaige Oh! I absolutely agree and am sorry if I gave that impression. I myself have been a poor, not-criminal my whole life, lol. Rural poor, though. I can only imagine how awful it was in Scotland at that time, but I'm sure the majority of people were law-abiding. I also think that there were a lot people who were treated so poorly over their entire lives that they lost a lot of their humanity. I can't stop thinking about those poor boys, parents dead, and the only one willing and able to house them was a thieving prostitute who let them sleep under her bed!!? I wish history told us how their lives turned out.
I've been listening religiously for 2 years since I found your channel during my drives to university so I'm happy with any content you upload! I think it would be super cool if you did a livestream so your fans can send tips and ask questions about you, if you're open to that sort of thing! But if you're not comfortable doing one then don't force yourself to do something you don't wanna do. ❤ Also, I imagine the logistics behind it would be tough to figure out.
Thanks
A whirlwind of a story. Can't believe they were that careless. Whew! Times must have been tough. Thanks for sharing this in a brilliant manner
I think anything you decide to do with your channel, would be fabulous, you are just incredibly talented, your demeanor and narration are superb, and so comforting, and yours is the only channel that I lose myself in the story and imagine it as it would have been, and that's fascinating to me. It's what sets you apart from the rest, and the time and attention to detail, and research is also just fascinating, how you find details from so long ago, right down to the time and day, and the background of a city and the victim. So beautifully presented, and eloquently narrated. Thank-you, and please keep doing what you do, it's so very interesting and appreciated, thank-you Mr Brief Case!!! ☺️💞
Thanks so much :)
I think it would be so cool if you did a live collab with either another historical channel or another crime channel so that more people could discover your really well put together, well researched, and interesting work. I know a lot of people would love it but just haven't come across it.❤
I think a livestream with you and other true crime You Tubers would be very interesting. Discussions of favorite tales, disturbing crimes, tales of research into such histories and overall how you all fell into true crime fandom and decision to share them on YT.
From ring to swing 😳 You did it again! Another fascinating,high quality video. Many thanks from Dublin Eire 💚🇮🇪
Didn’t think Irish people tended to use Éire or the word gaelic for Irish when writing in English?
@@nicolad8822 I can write what I want. If I want to use Eire in an English sentence I will
Is féidir liom a scríobh cad ba mhaith liom. Más mian liom Éire a úsáid in abairt Bhéarla déanfaidh mé
@@nicolad8822 can I remind you you’ve just used a Gaelic word in an English sentence. We spell it Gaeilge
Hopefully there’s no bad blood between us?
Grand health and happiness from baile átha Cliath (DUBLIN) 💚🇮🇪
P.S English is not my first language Irish Gaelic is,so I try to simplify things
I'm off to Dublin on Monday, oddly enough. Greetings from your Celtic neighbour in Scotland 😁
@@carolannemckenzie3849 I lived in Edinburgh,great time 🏴🏴🇮🇪🇮🇪💚
Brilliant presentation, as always! Cheers for another fascinating case with a wicked twist at the end to boot. My great great grandparents left Glasgow for Belfast once it started getting more people, mid 1700’s. I’ve inherited the estate in Belfast and Glasgow, both are gorgeous but I couldn’t imagine that many living in such a small area. The Estates are outside the city on many hectares but my great Nana and papa would tell me stories of not going into the city for months at a time. Servants would go, find pleasant lodging and stay to collect what was needed. I wrote down all they’d tell me, I found each story so fascinating and intriguing. I’m all for a livestream BUT only if you’re comfortable with it and it doesn’t interfere with your daily life.
Estates in Belfast and Glasgow, sounds really nice
I personally am just very happy with all your very interesting stories, don't feel you need to do anything you are not comfortable with.
I would love to see the crime reel an brief case on everyone’s crime channel, show. just makes the day so much better
Brief case q & a? YES PLEASE.
I've been following for almost 5 years and this is the best part of my Monday. I would be so so interested to hear an interview or watch a livestream by a channel that has been so much a part of my life. ❤
Thank you!
I would L❤VE to see a livestream!! Your voice is so hypnotic, and I get such pleasure listening to you as you do your amazing vids. I never much cared for history whilst I was in school, but you make learning about it so interesting. The care and love that you put into each video is amazing!! I live for your videos each and every Monday!! ❤❤❤❤ much love to you!!!
Thank you so much!!
You are very welcome love!!! You completely draw me in with every video that you do. I’m invested from beginning to end. ♥️♥️♥️♥️
I think you and They Got Away With Murder have the most story telling talent. Your writing is on par with his works.
I'm sure if he's seen your channel, he's enjoyed your work!!
Does anyone ever wake up in the morning and think "Today, I'll commit a murder"
I don't believe they considered this thought To be publicly married on the gallows moments before your life is taken from you for your crime of murder is just overwhelming
Thanks Again
Great Story
Crazy case! Ann should have received the same punishment. Your description of the poverty in Glasgow reminds me of the description of poverty in the Easr End of London on the original episode of In Search Of ... about Jack the Ripper.
Poor Ann, you wanted her dead as well??
This channel has been my nightly routine for 4-ish years. I am not sure I could fall asleep without it at this point 😅
This channel is the best and cant wait for the years to come!
Thankyou so much
I like this channel's interesting stories and your style of story telling. A livestream Q and A would be nice. Good work!
A livestream would be a great change of pace once in a while. But please it would have to start with the crashing sound that all your stories begin with and that I like so much.
Hi James, It would not be instead of a monday video, it would be in addition at another time, I will think about what best to do - Thanks :)
A Brief Case live stream?!?!? YES, PLEASE!!!!🥰😻😋🦋🎧🔍🌞🐱🐶🤗🥐🍫☕🥞🥓🍳
Good morning Meems! 😊❤️
@@resarm5007good morning!😻😋🦋🌞🐱🐶🤗🥐🍫☕🥞🥓🍳🍩
No, thank you.
❤
That would be cool 😊!
Congratulations, this is a great Sponsor! Thank you B.C. I love to be here and listen to you. Always amazing stories :)
Thanks Elke
@@BriefCaseOfficial
Welcome!
0:43 yes yes I would love to see you and be part of a q&a session that would be awesome
Congratulations on 5 years! I only just found you a few months ago but I love your videos. It's awesome having a crime channel that does older cases.
Thankyou :)
Love your older crime stories and your beautiful voice
Thanks
I'd love to have a live chat while the case is on so I can ask you some historical questions while we are all watching it together, if not a live a Q&A world be grea. I love your channel your historical knowledge is wonderful and the cases are very detailed. Thanks for all of your hard work x
I really really love these stories. Thank you so much for all your hard work putting them together for us.
Glad you like them!
Such horrible living conditions. Sad.
Hi Agapy!
Another Monday evening and BC to watch. Thanks for another brilliant episode i love to watch and listen to you narrate so soothing x
I love your voice and cadence…the stories themselves have the drama. I play these everyday and enjoy them thoroughly. I’d love to hear how this topic came to you, the research you obviously put in to each, and whether or not you feel crime is more prevalent now or then. Yes, please try some livestream ❤
His voice and delivery are what make the channel. I think those qualities are more important than the material themselves. Try to listen to other history channel and because of the presentation I just can't sit through it.
Briefcase you are indeed a gem.
This is my favorite channel!
Thankyou so much Tammy
Livestream? Sure!
As for this case, they got what they deserved. Self defense is one thing but robbing then throwing him out of the window is another. Excellent job narrating, as always!
I think robbing him was really the least of it though. He kind of walked into that one with his drunken behavior. Throwing him out the window was a terrible thing!
I think a Q&A with you would be fascinating. You are so knowledgeable in history of crime and history, it would be interesting to hear what really interests and excites you about all of the past cases and crime and mystery in general.
I'm not big on livestreams. Too much time. But you do whatever feels good for yourself. I've enjoyed your channel as is for years now.❤
This was an excellent episode, thank you so much.
Thankyou
I like your channel just as it is, no need to change perfection. But of course, if you want to try new things, it's up to you.
About today's case, I find it a little hard to believe that the teenage girl just happened to decide to follow them that day, to look through cracks in the door, and heard things the boys who was definitely in the room hadn't heard.
Yes, please - I would be very interested in hearing an interview/live-stream with you. Happy you're getting the recognition you deserve! This is a great channel.
Thankyou
I vote 'not'. I'm sure you are a lovely person, a decent human and a pleasure to talk to. If we were friends, or down the pub, I'd surely share a pint or 3 with you. But I'm not here to make a new friend (even in the parasocial sense that it would have to be), I'm here for your great content. I don't care if you are married or single, black or white, gay or straight, Liberal of Conservative, theist or atheist, or anything else. Whatever you are, that's great. I wish you all the best. But I'm just here to enjoy your great videos and any personal stuff will, for me, be Irrelevant - and for some, it might even be a distraction or a detraction. Stick to the good stuff, is my vote. But whatever you decide to do, I'll be here watching the content I came for all along. Cheers!
Most people seem to be interested in how BC became interestd in crime and started the channel. I agree I don't want a detailed picture of the narrator of these stories!
Thank you for all your efforts and hard work 😊
My pleasure!
BC never disappoints! Thank you for another fantastic video. Your storytelling is exceptional. Your writing and research thoughtful. Yes you are very appreciated Monday morning ❤🇺🇸
Wow, thank you!
@@BriefCaseOfficial it’s the truth !
Love the channel, a live stream will be a perfect way to get to hear more about your knowledge, can't wait, because I know we will all say please do.
My goodness Briefy is it 5 years!
Ive been enjoying your cases in 5 years, cant belive how the time fly and all the great job you done
Thankyou my Swedish Friend, hope everything is good, I know you have been with me since the start and it is very much appreciated :)
Hello Swedishpiggi a workhouse in England was a place that was an institution where the poor and sick were offered accomodations like a place to sleep and work.
@@BriefCaseOfficialCannot believe it is 5 years! Congratulations! 🎉 I've enjoyed many years with you! ❤ (Resa)
@@BriefCaseOfficial Aww thank you! You do such a great work and I appreciate it very much. So thank you once again
@@resarm5007 Thank you so much for explaining that to me. I have always wondred what that meant so thank you so much
Yes. A live stream would be wonderful. Thanks
You also have the ability to attract people’s curiosity to the historical context you deliver
I definitely think there is an audience for a live stream
If you need any sounding boards or to look over your skills for live feed i would be happy to help or support
You are keeping history alive
First time commenting. I greatly enjoy this channel. Wanted to leave a quick thank you for your narration. As a blind person, I rely heavily on in-depth narration when watching videos. Again, thank you. This content is much appreciated.
Thankyou so much, your comment means a lot to me as I do get complaints that I put in too much background history, but I like doing that to set the scene, so do not plan to stop
She’s quite beautiful. Reminds me of my mom when she was younger.
Strange their companion had her sentence overturned. It was a terrible life that none of us, with our many comforts, could begin to imagine. I cannot judge them so harshly for searching his person for valuables. These people were literally starving.
So many years later, it’s impossible to say what killed the man; self defense or the fall.
I’m not making excuses for the perpetrators. I’m only saying we are judging them from our phones or laptops, likely well-fed and not jammed 5-7 people in one small room. It’s sad that what was likely the best moment in both of their lives was followed in seconds by the worst.
Another beautifully and compassionately told story. Congratulations on 5 years Brief Case.🎉 I can't believe it's that long since you started... as the saying goes, time flies when you're having fun😊
Thank you so much!
@@BriefCaseOfficial 💕
Wow five years already!👏 It's absolutely been five years of excellent quality presentations Sir💯 One of my favorite channels, always well researched and compelling, and I love your voice and accent❤
As far as doing a live Q&A etc, of course that would be great, but it's up to you. I completely understand if you're the type of person who prefers a bit of privacy and doesn't want people to see their face, or just doesn't really feel comfortable being live on camera. Either way I will continue to be a loyal subscriber from the PacNW U.S.😊
Thankyou
Thanks!Yes, a live stream, I'd be there no matter the time of day 🥰❤️
Thanks Dixie
You have a great voice love listning to your videos as i work .
Thanks for listening :)
One of the best parts of my Monday. A new Brief...Case!!
Thanks BC! Another great story and Happy TH-cam Anniversary!
There is no way that the story of the two children and the "girl" how watched them through the door aligned so perfectly without police dictating a narrative. More plausible to believe that she hit him with the chamber pot and he fell and hit his head on the rock which killed him. They freaked out and tossed him out the window. Still guilty but probably not have been sent to the gallows.
Never heard of this one either BC. Thank you very much for all your work, God bless.
Thanks for listening
I am a nerd especially for history and so of course I absolutely LOVE your channel!!! I would love to get the opportunity to watch a livestream or watch someone interview, you or just anything, to figure why you're so passionate about these stories!!!! Anything exyra I would love to see you do anything extra!!!!
Thanks
I like this channel and the detail of each case is first class, please take a bow for your work.
Thankyou so much :)
Am I the only one to find this girl eerily beautiful? 💚💚💚🍀🍀🍀
Thanks
She's stunning. And NO ONE looks that good in old photos
I've listened to your channel for years now. I love your stories and your narration. A live stream would be great.. do it!
Thank you for a wonderful start to my day. Happy 4th of July to all my fellow Americans. ❤
You said the Independence Day greetings on a British- based crime channel 😅😅😅😅 The irony....😂😂
Happy Independence Day to you too. ❤
@@StacyL. Aren't you glad we left,lol
Yes, a LIVE STREAM would be GREAT!
What a time to be a child. And the marriage!
Another excelent narration 10/10
Thank you kindly!
I don't know... I love the mystery of you...Your voice is so soothing, the tone and your accent... Love your storytelling... Imagining what you look like and what your body language would be is part of my enjoyment... The mystery of you...But if you decide to do it... I wouldn't miss it for the world...Many regards... No regrets❤️🌎❤️
Thanks Karen :)
That's exactly the way I feel :)
Another excellent video; thank you for all your stories - they are so well researched! I would be interested in a Q and A to get to know you and why you started your channel. Well done - I look forward to many more!
Well now...I must say I'm in agreement with the jury's original decisions regarding guilt and that Ann getting away with what she did doesn't sit right with me. She was as culpable as the gentleman who told them to toss him off the balcony. The marriage reminds me that even back then, there were "crazy stunts" people would be involved in when infamous. It isn't only the rich who have their quirks and eccentricities! They sure did make a name for themselves! 😂 "You may now kiss the bride." THUD!
Have a wonderful week, BC! (Resa)
Thanks Resa, hope all is good with you :)
I can’t wait to watch this one, actually just heard the comment if you want livestream/ other creators - I worked in psychiatry for a loooong time so I’m also always interested to see if it seems like anything related involved bc psych tx was not so hot, but some people are really just not good. Can’t wait !
@@BriefCaseOfficial It is funny 🤣 you should mention that "good with me" part lol 😜 I just got home from the hospital over the weekend I'm passing two kidney stones on the right. The male nurse said "Hun when you decide to do something you don't mess around!" 🤣🤣🤣 I'm sure I'll live! But I felt like I was dying. Well, I guess if you feel pain like that you're not dying, right? Thank you kindly for inquiring. 😊❤️ I'm just patiently waiting for this too shall "pass". 😜
Kiss her quick! lol
Transportation is hardly getting off easy. Even if you survived the journey, the conditions awaiting were awful.
I love waking up to a new Brief Case in the morning. ❤
Thanks!
You may now kiss the bride. Picks up the heads... Smoochy smoochy 😂
I would love to see a Q and A and interview for your 5th anniversary!!! Please do it! I would sit forever listening to the sound of your beautiful voice!
Thankyou
Helen Blackwood has a haunting stare. This story should be made into a movie, forget all that superhero crap.
Thanks for the feedback
Personally i can't get enough of you. I've listened to all you have on here and go back through when it's hard to sleep.
I look forward to the new ones.
You're doing an amazing job!
Thankyou so much
I think things are fine the way they are, the mystery of not knowing who the man behind the voice is is kind of like classic radio,it's just fine.👌It goes with the classic vibe.
Thankyou
That is just how I feel, as well!
Thanks for the upload! I enjoy the historical aspect!
Glad you enjoyed it!
@@BriefCaseOfficial I did! Thank you again!
Hi Flamsterette! How are you doing?
@@bettyjames4155 Hi, Betty! I'm not bad. Had some Thai food yesterday. How are you doing?
@@Flamsterette I'm doing well!
A stream seems harder as you have so many fans from all over the world, and so many times zones, so how do you choose a time that works?!? Not that I wouldn't be all over the rewatch! So if you do a stream, maybe you could open a community page first and take questions there as well, so if we miss the stream we still have a way to submit questions or comments? But it's your channel, so you do you Brief Case, and however you choose to include us fans is a welcome prospect. Wishing all who may see this a radically positive, safe and healthy week.🙏🖤✌️
Thanks Laura
Ive watched/ listened to every one of these stories, it's like a dive into history such tragedy, praying 🙏
Thank you; very interesting case [as always]. I am not a fan of live streaming events as i find the unstructured nature boring, and i usually turn off after about 2 mins.
Thanks Ruth, I appreciate the feedback :)
Yesssss!! Live stream or an interview would be so cool!!
Sadly there remains a strong correlation between poverty and alcohol (and similar soul numbing substances).
The rich drink like fish
Great video!
Thanks!
My notification NOT working again! Hello BC, and Happy Independence Day in advance to all American viewers here! Maybe you should do a Q&A session one day.
That happens sometimesDee, Sorry :(
@@BriefCaseOfficial Nevermind, maybe an interview with the Crime Reel or Forgotten Lives!! 😃🤗
You always do such great work, I learn a lot from your videos. Not only about the crime itself, but the people living through the experience, and the place where it all took place. I look forward to every presentation, eager to learn new things.
I think that a Livestream video, where possibly you take us to the place where a specific crime or crimes took place would be an added boost.
I understand that Scotland yard has a crime museum. I think a tour there would be interesting.
I love all of your videos. You have such a steady, calming voice that I can listen, and no matter how gruesome the story, there's no unnecessary sensationalism I appreciate your hard work. Keep 'em coming!
Yes Crime Museum would be interesting, thanks for the suggestion
I'd love to learn more about you and your motivation for starting and continuing the channel. It need not be a live stream. You could even do it as a scripted episode, if you'd like. But above all, do what makes you feel comfortable. I realize that not every presenter is comfortable turning the spotlight on themselves.
Thanks
I think the best of the best in telling stories of vintage crimes on You Tube are Brief Case, Obsolete Oddity, They got away with Murder, & Well, I Never ! You all are WONDERFUL! ❤❤❤❤
Thankyou
I think a live stream is an absolute must! I'd also love to see you link up with Bailey Sarian and do like an old vs new murder case thing
Thanks, but Bailey is a completely different level to me, though makeup isn't my thing, I have seen a few of her videos and I must say that she is brilliant, a very natural presenter and deserves all her success
One of the Best historical/crime/TH-cam channels.. no doubt!!! 🎉❤
Thanks
What happened to the two boys? I certainly hope someone took pity on them and took them in. Orphanages were awful and I hope they weren't sent there.
Nah, if they were 10 or over they would have gone to a workhouse!
they snitched on the last people who took pity on them and took them in