Why did we mess up game shows? Theyre a lot more enjoyable when we get to watch the host struggle to find the answers instead of struggling to provide them ourselves. This is the perfect format, (can't) change my mind.
Someone should integrate that into their video next time he announces a video collab. How long do you think it would be just chained together with no editing?
Nothing beats the incredible masterpiece that was Jack to the future. It was written beautifully, and it was so subtle, I barely realized that it was in and of itself an Ad.
Not at all. Beyblades have been around a long time, they would first have risen in popularity around the time he was in late elementary/early middle school
Reverse guess the question: Jack thinks of the question and make like 20 answers himself and we have to guess the question, he’s gonna have to work pretty hard but hey that’s not on us
i cant wait for the next game which is guess the question^2: the council chooses a question, picks answers, then other council members try to guess the question and based on that jack tries to guess the original question and the answers or something... either way John keeps giving the council more to do
My favorite thing about Jack is that he’s a true unproblematic fav. Been watching since middle school, been outta college so long I’ve forgotten it’s happened. massive thanks to jack for being a real one.
When Jack said “bucket list” for the first time I realized that was totally right cause I remembered I indeed saw this question asked in Discord like, months ago, or what feels like months ago.
the pros of this video format is that it's really engaging. the cons however is that there is zero incentive to rewatch it. unlike regular yiays that are very rewatchable
@@c0niine yes, that's what happens when you're a big fat loser with nothing better to do. it's the only way I'm able to escape the disappointment that is my life and the only thing I can do to ignore my shameful existence.
Honestly, your videos are the best when you yourself have fun. Since your having fun, we are having fun. Make more guess the questions. Make it a series. Yesterday I guessed you.
I love the bucket list episodes! And I did not guess bucket list, I was pretty stuck on it being something about "what would you do if you could do it consequence free?" and then something about "if you had a certain number of wishes."
saying this at 3:28 i think the question is like . what would you do if u were lucid dreaming bc it fits the “i’d wake up” thing too and if you’re lucid dreaming ur basically an immortal god too
I submitted one for this c: It was a good time, even if I didn’t show up in the vid lol. The editing in this one is incredible too! Kudos to the editors c:
I love these videos, please do more! Also, I always end up watching them twice, once trying to get the question alongside you and then to see how every answer fits.
I think the more fun thing to do is skipping to the end to find out what the answer is and then watching from the beginning to see Jack struggle to figure it out for himself.
I was close I thought it was "What do you want to do before you die?" Which is essentially asking for your bucket list but the fact that you got it word for word is insane.
ever since jack hurt his hand on that nail thingie coming out of the fireplace on that one YIAY, I keep getting anxious when his hand is near the left edge of the screen
@@TurretBot he put his hand with force on the bit that sticking out on the left part of the shelf, said "ow", commented on it and then carried on with the video. It was treated as a quick funny bit in the video, yet it stuck with me for some reason, just cannot unsee that sticking out bit anymore haha
spoilers I guessed Bucket list right after the cat girl answer but started to doubt myself (Or at least the wording) after the M&M and football team answers, then cheered when Jack came to the same conclusion and specifically revisited the cat girl answer.
The whole time i knew it had to be something along the lines of life goals, but I didn't think specifically of the term "bucket list" until Jack said it. But as soon as he said it I knew that was it.
But my issue with the bucket list guess is that literally every answer to a bucket list question would make sense as an answer to any "what would you do if _?".
GTQ= Game Theory Quirk "You can make the most random theory in a split and can create anything out of thin air as long it's merch." Weakness: *Fact Checkers and Haters* Special Power: *Delay people's attacks as if they were videos*
I stuck with the “If you could do/ have anything, what would you want?” answer, so I wasn’t really correct… I was going to ignore the answer “a blue one sounds cool” because it matched the other answers so little I thought it was a deliberate mislead.
it would be cool if John filmed an interview with a celebrity who has no idea what kind of TH-cam channel he has and during the interview he would ask questions from YIAY
Within a few answers I just thought it was, “If you could do anything what would it be?” Which is pretty much the same thing as a bucket list, so I consider myself a winner
Imagine a Group GTQ, just a small group “Working Together” to figure out the question but they inevitably just confuse Jack further. Maybe even have one person that actually knows the question and is just there to throw everyone off.
![F.HERO Ft. JSPKK x ลำไย ไหทองคำ x M-PEE - ไม่สนิทบิดหมด (Thai Riders Anthem) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kPJZ0UihBfk/mqdefault.jpg)
Watching Jack's mental process is legitimately interesting, he's done so much YIAY that he thinks in nothing but YIAY questions.
Get bot’d lol
It also helps as a brainstorming sesion for more yiay
Isnt it supposed to be a yiay question he has to guess tho
It really is!! I was avidly waiting for a second one after the first was as fun as it was, here's hoping we get more!!
The video is he guesses a hypothetical YAIY question.
My favorite parts of these are when Jack is totally confident in what the question is and then the immediate next question is a complete curveball.
“win the lottery”
get rich 😐
Lets forever recognize that the answer “Luigi” made Jack get “What’s on your bucket list?”
That’s because it’s on his bucket list too
This is a monumental thing in history, what a time to be alive.
luigi
I don't even know how it happened or what happens in that brain. But it's legit interesting, indeed.
@@johnfran3218 Luigi
There's something so powerful about the answer "Gorilla fistfight"
*Receives a question*
*"golira fistfight"*
@@saulgoodmanKAZAKHgojira??
I just love the amount of times he's like "That's my answer. Lock it in!" and then the next answer completely demolishes his confidence.
"'Get rich'...
**brain slowly reboots**
...Sh%t."
This should be a regular series, its very fun and theres audience participation by figuring out the puzzle
It should be its own series.
i'm to dumb to do so
audi audi . . . . .buy alice v neck
Wdym audience participation? That’s all he does!
@@TheTiredPhrog or to use the correct form of to/too/two, apparently. Lol.
Why did we mess up game shows? Theyre a lot more enjoyable when we get to watch the host struggle to find the answers instead of struggling to provide them ourselves. This is the perfect format, (can't) change my mind.
I mean they're already replacing the host of Jeopardy. New format wouldn't hurt 3:D
I want Jack to keep doing these, but he needs to get one wrong before his ego expands past the point of no return
E
@@EEEEEEEE E
I'm honestly wondering if it's too late already... 😂
What about a yes or no question?
@@jacobc9221 thats evil
We need a compilation of Jack putting his hand on the wall
Someone should integrate that into their video next time he announces a video collab.
How long do you think it would be just chained together with no editing?
First, great idea, second, even better profile pic.
@@Mr_Original it's a him, Gun Mario
@@GrumpyTy34er
Ayyy!
Klavier Gavin
You should do a variation of this called “guess the bio” where people fix Twitter bios and you have to guess who’s bio they fixed
Yes
This sounds really good
thing is they could literally just fix a bio of some random person and he wouldn't be able to guess that
Alternatively just take an existing bio and he has to guess who it is. All accounts must be verified to ensure its more fair.
Good to see Jack has found an activity to keep his mind active in his old age.
E
@@EEEEEEEE F
@@das.krishi g
@@iminyourbasement2426 h
@@iminyourbasement2426 h
I love that "dying your pubes" stumped Jack a lot
@@arienn2665 thanks, very cool
@@arienn2665 FUCK THERE ARE BOTS ON JACKSFILMS VIDEOS
We truly are living in the immaculate Renaissance of Jacksfilms. True creative concepts, and even the ads are funny
E
@@EEEEEEEE this is a bit I agree with
E
E
Nothing beats the incredible masterpiece that was Jack to the future. It was written beautifully, and it was so subtle, I barely realized that it was in and of itself an Ad.
E
This video summed up:
- Jack reads answer
- "Maybe the question is this"
- Jack reads answer that doesnt work with that question
- "Damnit"
jack saying poggers with such a genuine tone made me piss laughing
I fuckin’ wheezed
its become part of day to day vocabulary lmao. just like "lol" and "peeposad"
“What does ARG stand for?”
Very subtle, Jack.
Huh. I definitely wouldn't have guessed that ARG stands for that.
@@arienn2665 honey, what?
@@arienn2665 stands for agnes is ready g
@@arienn2665 cool
@I self promote I write comments myself ... Wtf
Why of course John, ARG stands for Anthropomorphically Rotund Garfield, quite like your dear alter ego Furvius!
Its not a dear alter ego it's a cat alter ego
@@hjyeager9877 Considering the comment's been hearted, I think he, or his council, saw it.
www.youtubeuis.com/watch?v=qiXHJzvo3Pn8
Jack is scarily good at this
Cool to see you here
He has been doing YIAY for a long time.
Almost as good as he was when he sent Erin into a rage when she was Kidz Bop quizzing him last week.
Honestly tho, It’s incredible how he just…gets it.
www.youtubeuis.com/watch?v=deRHlcbwuucQ
Stands for the best 3 compliments you can give someone:
Awesome
Radical
Garfield
Use the hashtag
"Wake up, destroy my haters, zumba" is a winning yiay live answer!
I only know that because I was another finalist that day
Jack's mods are now forever envisioned as ominous black silhouettes.
E
The C3 council
The O-5 council
As they should be. Their hubris is underestimating Jack and his age-old wisdom obtained by endlessly scrolling through YIAY comments.
bold of you to assume that isn't a completely accurate visualization of their work meetings
I love this concept, seeing Jack's train of thought is extremely entertaining to me
www.youtubeuis.com/watch?v=iAV1tQaJOw6s
Jack not knowing what beyblades are really shows his age.
I think the bideo format does that
A lot of people his age know what Beyblades are. He's just sheltered.
Not at all. Beyblades have been around a long time, they would first have risen in popularity around the time he was in late elementary/early middle school
@@stopthisatonce He's never seen Sponge Bob, so that tracks
The wording of this is straight-up brutal, like god damn
Me like-y
Reverse guess the question: Jack thinks of the question and make like 20 answers himself and we have to guess the question, he’s gonna have to work pretty hard but hey that’s not on us
this feels like a murder mystery movie where you watch the detective piece together all the clues! super fun to watch lol
i cant wait for the next game which is guess the question^2: the council chooses a question, picks answers, then other council members try to guess the question and based on that jack tries to guess the original question and the answers or something... either way John keeps giving the council more to do
Make it a contest to see who guesses it first, like YIAYlive.
That's a mouthful
So like “people also ask -“…?
But if the council gets it right then there’s no challenge
Yeah, let's keep getting him more and more degrees removed from the original question until no one knows the answer anymore.
My favorite thing about Jack is that he’s a true unproblematic fav. Been watching since middle school, been outta college so long I’ve forgotten it’s happened. massive thanks to jack for being a real one.
Even his early content when being "edgy" was all the rage online didn't dip into "haha saying hateful things is funny"
Dad...?
You're problematic.
@@luciouspateramoris706 you’re mom
I really, really, *really* hope this doesn't age poorly.
I'm confident, though, given how long Jack's been on the platform.
This is definitely my favorite format of yours. I'm sure it would get stale if you did it often, but I'd love if you did this once a month.
+
“What does ARG stand for?” alright jack is just fucking with us at this point
plz give me context, is he trying to do an ARG???
@@calentinestrider8368 yeah. have you noticed all the glitches in his videos?
@@kaocat9547 nooo im bigboy dumb...
AllRight Gack
More Guess the questions. Absolutely.
The insanity is incredible.
Also its so fun to watch you actually be right
i love this concept lol. can he be 3 for 3 though?? 🤔
E
Can he?
I can’t believe Jack would do such a thing 😭😭😭😭😭😭
You spoiled it smh
6?
Edit/Ok sorry I was not paying attention
When Jack said that Beyblades are basically fidget spinners, it hurt my soul because he's technically not wrong
He is tho
They're PVP fidget spinners.
@@negatvecreep you're just too mad to accept the truth
@@golduck7495 nah
@@negatvecreep yes
When Jack said “bucket list” for the first time I realized that was totally right cause I remembered I indeed saw this question asked in Discord like, months ago, or what feels like months ago.
sick bot collection broski
@@biggie2chainz I’m so done with them. I immediately report them as spam every time.
www.youtubeuis.com/watch?v=wsgakbVoaZgg
Jack's so genuinely happy to get it on point I love it.
a new series would be hella refreshing please absolutely make this a thing
Editor is killing it! The shower head at 6:53 is top tier
Thanks for pointing that out; I missed it the first time.
I didn't even notice that! Lmao
I would just like to point out that the submission that finally got Jack to guess the right answer was just “Luigi”.
Luigi is Jack’s fursona confirmed :p
@@GubbiGap
**X Files theme plays**
Honestly, the editing makes this way more entertaining than it should be. I say more!
You should do a YIAY with the question “what does throw it back mean?”
jack is so smart that he has an IQ of 250, 350, 450, 550, 600 AND 700, all at the same time
He's like Toast in Amogus
No, his IQ is multiplying over the period of 13 and a half minutes.
Jack being so excited when he wins feels just like a kid winning heads up 7 up in their 2nd grade class
the pros of this video format is that it's really engaging.
the cons however is that there is zero incentive to rewatch it. unlike regular yiays that are very rewatchable
I think there is incentive to rewatch at least once, now that you know the question, you can actively laugh at all the answers
Bold of you to believe i won't forget the answer to the last guess the question and be able to watch it just like the first time
You rewatch youtube videos??
@@c0niine yes, that's what happens when you're a big fat loser with nothing better to do. it's the only way I'm able to escape the disappointment that is my life and the only thing I can do to ignore my shameful existence.
@@hamham4994 well you can do that by watching more content, there's enough of it, that's what I do
i absolutely love this format, Jack actually has to do work and we get to watch the cogs turn and smoke
Next 100 episode Jack series right here. I love this.
I just love this because it’s entirely just “can I figure out what joke these people are trying to make”
The one that kept bugging me was the first one 'eating a can of beans'. So I came up with bucket list after like 4 minutes (around the listed one).
Honestly, your videos are the best when you yourself have fun. Since your having fun, we are having fun. Make more guess the questions. Make it a series. Yesterday I guessed you.
his what is having fun?🤔🤔🤔
Oh Jack, ARG stands for
A - 100%
R - Totally
G - Subtle
#yiayarg
This was so much more fascinating and suspenseful to watch than I would have expected it to be!
I’m in love with this! It’s so great when Jack is all in on an idea and then one answer completely throws him off.
My guess was "What is your perfect first date?" which kinda matches so many of these so well in a funnier way.
@@Medahlian hot
I love the bucket list episodes! And I did not guess bucket list, I was pretty stuck on it being something about "what would you do if you could do it consequence free?" and then something about "if you had a certain number of wishes."
Me too, I was thinking it was something along the lines of “what is your weirdest desire?”
I thought it was gonna be "what will you do once quarantine is over?"
saying this at 3:28
i think the question is like . what would you do if u were lucid dreaming bc it fits the “i’d wake up” thing too and if you’re lucid dreaming ur basically an immortal god too
I submitted one for this c: It was a good time, even if I didn’t show up in the vid lol. The editing in this one is incredible too! Kudos to the editors c:
Jack went from 550 IQ to 700 IQ within the timeframe of this video. What an inspiration, what a legend!
350 IQ*
seeing how excited he gets is proof it's not fake
This should be its own series, maybe like an every other week thing so it doesn’t get too repetitive.
Yeah so that didn’t happen
These are the best recent YIAY vids and you should definitely make more!
I love these videos, please do more! Also, I always end up watching them twice, once trying to get the question alongside you and then to see how every answer fits.
I think the more fun thing to do is skipping to the end to find out what the answer is and then watching from the beginning to see Jack struggle to figure it out for himself.
He should just put it in the description if people want to know before
but then you spoil yourself
It's like he's our little monkey part of some experiment
Pretty sure I did this last time, and it was so painful
@@supershinigami1 you have a choice to spoil yourself.
To be honest, I got too enthralled with jack's enthusiasm and excitement, and forgot to try and guess the answer.
9:56 AYEEEE THAT REFERENCE THOUGH
Jack, this would be an amazing recurring series
“What does arg stand for?” Alright I’m convinced jack is doing an arg.
Jack has “cool substitute teacher” energy
I was close I thought it was "What do you want to do before you die?"
Which is essentially asking for your bucket list but the fact that you got it word for word is insane.
The fact that I got bucket list at 4 minutes means that my IQ is infinity. I am supreme. Jack has nothing on me, I am god.
I got it in 2 B)
Shoutout to the editor on this video. Super entertaining, definitely make this into a series.
Jack this was a lot of fun. Please do another one.
Yeah, these are great. Maybe not a weekly series but definitely something you could do once a month.
ever since jack hurt his hand on that nail thingie coming out of the fireplace on that one YIAY, I keep getting anxious when his hand is near the left edge of the screen
Wait what
@@TurretBot he put his hand with force on the bit that sticking out on the left part of the shelf, said "ow", commented on it and then carried on with the video. It was treated as a quick funny bit in the video, yet it stuck with me for some reason, just cannot unsee that sticking out bit anymore haha
spoilers
I guessed Bucket list right after the cat girl answer but started to doubt myself (Or at least the wording) after the M&M and football team answers, then cheered when Jack came to the same conclusion and specifically revisited the cat girl answer.
I too would make furries real.
thanks for the spoiler warning. And good job!
I had almost the exact same though process
The whole time i knew it had to be something along the lines of life goals, but I didn't think specifically of the term "bucket list" until Jack said it. But as soon as he said it I knew that was it.
dude this is such a great series u need to keep doing these
“Finally escape” definitely gave it away for me.
These videos are SO FUN!!! I got so invested in trying to figure this out with you. Please make more!
The editing in this was absolutely on point.
Haven't tuned into jacksfilms for years but this video hit my radar and was funny, so it's probably a good idea to do it again sometime.
PLEASE keep doing these! This should become a series within the YIAY series!
0:05 Hell yeah, it's my favorite anime, Great Teacher Qnizuka!
But my issue with the bucket list guess is that literally every answer to a bucket list question would make sense as an answer to any "what would you do if _?".
Yea this is why it's impressive he guessed it before "a blue one"
@@loyael I get that, I'm saying his reasoning is flawed.
I didn't get it on my own, but that 300 Megaton Brain Blast at the realization was incredible. More of these please!
10:15 jack comes to a conclusion everyone else got to half way through the video
He needs to go back to earlier questions to help develop his answer
Definitely fun for me. Love watching your mental process in real time. At least once a month please!
GTQ= Game Theory Quirk
"You can make the most random theory in a split and can create anything out of thin air as long it's merch."
Weakness: *Fact Checkers and Haters*
Special Power: *Delay people's attacks as if they were videos*
GTQ? More like Get That Quesadilla!! Am I right?
...
This is fun to watch, really impressive how you put it together
Seeing Jack freak out after thinking of a good answer delights me
I love these, watching Jack struggle with all the answers will never get old.
I stuck with the “If you could do/ have anything, what would you want?” answer, so I wasn’t really correct… I was going to ignore the answer “a blue one sounds cool” because it matched the other answers so little I thought it was a deliberate mislead.
12:45 I just skipped to the end, John. That way I knew the question even before seeing the answers.
I recommend y'all put this on 1.5x speed. Sounds like Jack's spiralling into madness
Such a good suggestion
The way he gets focused on depression out of the blue…
Jack, buddy, is there something that you want to talk about?
bruh, you been on the internet for the past 4 years?
it would be cool if John filmed an interview with a celebrity who has no idea what kind of TH-cam channel he has and during the interview he would ask questions from YIAY
When she wont stop giving u that gawk gawk 3000 and u just 10:51
Ah yes the two-frames where john turns into megamind is truly delightful
timestamp
@@Sheila_Chu 11:54
Within a few answers I just thought it was, “If you could do anything what would it be?” Which is pretty much the same thing as a bucket list, so I consider myself a winner
Imagine a Group GTQ, just a small group “Working Together” to figure out the question but they inevitably just confuse Jack further.
Maybe even have one person that actually knows the question and is just there to throw everyone off.
"Stop time" genuinely freaked me out for a second
#YIAYarg ARG stands for:
Awesome
Round
Grandma