Classical Musicians React: SNSD 'Gee' vs 'I Got a Boy'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 พ.ค. 2018
- For the 60th reaction video of season 2 of this series, classical music majors react to SNSD's 'Gee' MV vs 'I Got A Boy' MV.
Watch the Gee MV here: • Girls' Generation 소녀시대...
Watch I Got A Boy MV here: • Girls' Generation 소녀시대...
~Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
~ Complete to-react list:
• Playlist
~ Will not react to list: • Will not be reacting to
---------------------
Send us things!
P.O. BOX 14933
ROCHESTER, NY 14614-1119
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~ Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
~Support us on Patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram: @_emcha_
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(business manager) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
Nikki:
Insta: nlabontehorn
Henry:
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Tumblr: / pjohnzzz
Charlotte:
Instagram: charmander_97
Her cat’s instagram: monty_le_chat_noir
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Katie:
Instagram: @katieknudsvig
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
TH-cam: nerdymusicks
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
(Isaac & Stephen & James & Elizabeth N/A)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that. This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. On top of that, if you think that they aren't commenting enough on the music, it's because /nothing/ is happening IN the music to comment on. It may be a great song/bop/huge hit that they're listening to, but that does not mean there are actual complicated musical things happening that they'd be able to talk about. - บันเทิง
Gee vs IGAB individual, unedited pair reactions are now up on our patreon! Pledge $5 and choose 3 different playlists to gain access to or pledge $14.99 and gain access to over 100 reaction playlists: www.patreon.com/reacttothek
*Please do part 3 asap. Genie vs Mr. Mr. vs The Boys vs Run Devil Run. We already thirsty haha and ofc Lil' Touch also. Thanks! 😊*
ReacttotheK OH!GG Lil touch 🙏
Please react to SNSD YuRi's Into you and Illusion. I'll be waiting. i hope you can😄
Gee was realeased in 2009 and I got a boy was released in 2013!
ReacttotheK hey guys could you make reaction snsd mr mr vs snsd the boys
This is the famous "I GOT A BOY ON MY CHIN"
React Brasil aquiii
(last 2 lines in Gee chorus) I'LL CHARGE YOU NEWBIE, OH YEAH. A TROUBLED YANKEE, OH YEAH-EH-EH.
In their other song 'flower power' people misheard their first line in the chorus as 'butterfly pooped a spider' ~~ XD
VC AQUI
Salve Moreno
How to recognize musicians from the crowd?
Normal people: Ohh they jumped back to 1:40s in the MV, cool.
Musician: OMG she was referring to 140bpm I can’t take this anymore !!!
EXACTLY! I never knew what she meant.
I'm nowhere near a musician and I knew it meant bpm lol I do play a lot of rhythm games though
Alura White nice :3 those who are interested in music would possibly know what bpm is, but it’s the time reference that we would think of first instead of bpm :)))
I never realized it was also 1:40! I thought it was BPM. Clever.
#cantrelate
The most iconic k-pop song ever produced. Work of art. This song had me throw my chair before when we first watched it on January 1, 2013. Yeah I'm a SONE for almost a decade now and I am still.
Anj Mansilongan SAME!!!
Who's the producer???
Same 💖
THE ONLY KPOP SONG I LOVE lmaooo
I heard this on a make up tutorial from a girl called AHanhBarbie YEAAARS ago, I’m 24 now and I was like 11 back then
To this day, I love it 😂
I still remember how popular they were in 2013 @.@ that came in new year and became video of the year according to youtube :3 It was a mess but it works. Nowadays some songs are trying to be like that but only few of them actually work, mostly from SM: RV RBB, NCT Punch, RV LP... some tried but didn't work and ended up plain: BP Ice Cream...
14:30 Girl got mindblown over "140" references.. i savor that reaction..
When the brownies kick in lol
IGAB is probably the most exhausting song I've heard in kpop. Everytime I listen to it I imagine the girls dancing the full song on a live stage, like BREATHE GIRLS! xD
bosgotnojams aww yeah this is a hard girls choreo!
bosgotnojams excuse me? how about ring ding dong?
Memesol Vernon Choi
Excuse me? How about this is *my* opinion in *my* comment and you're hijacking it with another group?
bosgotnojams it was a joke tho ._.
bosgotnojams I never meant to discredit GG
If you analyze it from its lyrics, actually the genre changes make sense! Bc the lyrics is about a conversation between a girl "who got a boy" and her friends, and they keep changing pov between the girl and her friends. I Got A Boy is like a mini musical drama - from the intro to closure. The genre and beat changes actually follow the lyrics along, and when they change pov/going to the next scene, the genre and beat change too. I Got A Boy is truly ahead of its time.
nadia Millati thank u for the input😍😍
nadja its like a musical if you pay attention to the lyrics everything has a purpose the beat changes urgh i love the song
i love how the narration goes from intro to ending as well... it reminds me of a sonnet somehow
nadja im so jealous you can analyse song structures
It's actually quite an Avant Garde in that era. I was also shookt that time. Haha. SM Ent like this types of songs. HAHA. Listen to Chill of EXO. The concept is similar to IGAB
I was today years old when I found out they were referring to the beat per minute when Jessica says "Let's bring it back to 140" and I am as mindblown as they are in the video. I never thought I would ever learn anything new about SNSD at this point anymore.
It's a double reference - time AND tempo. So you know it was planned. And the planning wouldn't have been easy around the weird structure. Pure and unadulterated genius from SM on this one.
Oh woahh
@@plasmakitten4261 hate or love SM they have some extremely talented people working for them
@@YourAllShort main difference between them and YG
@@plasmakitten4261 This song was released at SM's prime, when YG was also putting out the best stuff out there. Nowadays SM groups sound very much the same and when they don't the music is bought, never idealized at their house. YG on the other hand is still doing the same thing, the only groups lacking are the ones not in control of their music, aka Blackpink and Treasure so I really don't know what you're going on about.
12:53 probably the most iconic reaction in the series
i feel like i was there too, i know the song already but i was so hyped with them
That's why we call them "LEGEND" and "Nation's Girl Group"
that's riiiiiiighttttttt!!!!!!
I can't imagine how the others GG. In this generation can sing this song it's made for Legend only
queens
hello im the 1000 likers lmaoo
LOL. clam yo tits for a bit. These classical musicians was praising the song, not the girl's generation. Which means, unless the SNSD composed this song, then they have no means to be praised.
I got a boy is like a korean Bohemian Rapsody LOL
Leonardo Jr nope. It's like the Korean Paradise by the Dashboard Lights by Meatloaf.
i've always thought that! good to know i'm not the only one
Hahahaha xp
it IS!! I've been saying that for years 😂😂😂
This Hahahah
Kevin is a low-key sone.
When you've seen both reaction vids of SNSD, you can tell he's seen/listened to their songs before 🤣
Not the fact that he played and sang-ish "Into the new world" in the intro ? 😂😂😂
@@MissYellowGummibear They even included it as the outro of they're video.
IGAB IS THE BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY OF KPOP NO ONE COULD ARGUE SHOUT OUT TO HENRY SAYING THAT EVETHING IS A MESS. LIKE THS GUY MIGHT HAVE NOT HEART ABOUT BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY HAHAHHAA
Kuya Wilbert!!! ❤❤❤
@Niranjan Rajesh sry but there was an article abt it being the korean bohemian rhapsody
I actually agree with Henry because that’s what it felt to me when the song first came out. But to each its own, I guess. The song works for you, for some it doesn’t.
@@Unknown-uv8or that doesn't validate a shitty comparison
@Niranjan Rajesh The comparison isnt to the song itself, but to the amount of genres in it
This is why SNSD is the nation's girl group. They'll serve you with visuals, vocals and dance(and they are the funniest gg). They make everything work.
Yes!! True!!!😍😍😍
Isnt Twice the nation’s girl group? Or are they both?
@@bingbong8614 SNSD is the nation's girl group.
@@bingbong8614 both
Magma IyahB_ SNSD is the original. Guess like ur a new fan, but welcome :)
YOU KNOW IT'S INTENSE WHEN THEY SHOW YOU MULTIPLE REACTIONS FOR A SPECIFIC PART OF A SONG!
TintedRhythm the last time i remembered them doing it is the kwill's song HAHAHAHAHA
Their reaction to Spellbound by TVXQ is the perfect example for that I don't think anything can top that reaction tbh
I cant wait to see them react to Aespa's Next Level now.
Same 🤣🤣
out!!!
i reencountered this video after 2 years and the way that the musicians felt seen by "Let's bring it back to 140" still gets me
Sameeee
Kevin playing ITNW is the best thing ever.
Kevin SINGING ITNW ... NOW THAT BEATS THE BEST THING EVER.
blacksiopao i died when he started singing, i need a full cover
The planet needs a piano version from React to the K, I'll put it along with the ballad version to my "Go Cry in a corner cuz SNSD is so legendary" playlist.
blacksiopao YESSSSSSS
blacksiopao BEEEEST THING I NEED A WHOLE COVER
14:17 here you can see how a kpop fan and a non kpop fan react to kpop
Kevin is too funny :')
Isaac Li but you will always be my bias #isaacinator
Too true XD
id say both are relevant lmao you dont HAVE to react excessively to be blown away
12:18 She was HOT!!!
The reactions to the 'Let's bring it back to 140' are the best.
Me a a simpleton: hey this song catchy
The music expert: THEY REVERTED THE BEATS EQUILIBRIUM OMGGGG!!
Highlight of the Reaction:
1.) Girls' Generation
2.) KEVIN'S REACTIONS
Fraulien Mercader Isaac was dope too
Insert Katie's reaction
Okay I've always believed that the reason Jessica said 1:40 was because of the exact time in the music. I never knew that it was also the bpm until now lol gosh dang it u guys 😂
Same though 😂
OMG! I thought it's just random. I'm shooketh!
Same...
saaaaameeeee hahhaahaha
eggsoo dont give a fck me eitherr
Fun fact 1: They hate Gee so much and they dont want to sing this song at first because its kinda embarrassed for them 😂
Fun fact 2: Gee is originally just a b-side track from the album and the main track was Dancing Queen. But, finally they make Gee as a main track.
Correct me if im wrong ✌🏼
was Dancing Queen originally from a song called Mercy by Duffy, but because of the similarities and SM's process of property rights. Gee would have to be their Main track.
Baby Drawz yup thats right 😊
Taeyeon hates Gee, not all of them. But after Gee became the national hit song and make them labelled as National Girl Group, she slowly likes it 😂😂😂😂😂
Only taeyeon hates gee because she dont like cute concepts
I really though this was my comment because of the same pfp 😭😭😭😭
"let's bring it to 140"
*iconic, still gets me everytime*
14:30 but like girl you okay?
*you look dead*
sameee
I got a boy took them on a trip!!!
THIS IS HILARIOUS 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Isaac and Kevin are just so freaking hilarious oml 😂😂😂
I got a boy는 한국에 나왔을때도 반응이 둘로 갈렸었음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ그만큼 전에 없던 센세이션...
근데 개 마성의 곡이었음 난리였지 오오에오 나의 왕자님~~
그뒤에 "풋"하고 나오는 비웃음 비스무리한게 킬포죠ㅋㅋ
처음들으면 : 혼.파.망
3번째들으면 : 같이추는 거울속 본인을 보게된다
아갓보 노래 조각조각 나눠져 있던 것들이 나중에 딱 합쳐졌을 때 그게 너무 좋으무ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠ 소름끼침
I really love their réaction its all about music and voices , not like " I love her hair " "her make up is on point "
react more for SNSD
And they all look tired after watching igab 😂😂😂
Pink Ocean That's the point of the channel. You can read on the channel description. That's why they pick the songs on which they can talk a lot musically - doesn't have to be popular/hit songs, but that doesn't mean the song itself necessarily good or bad -, so they won't have to fill the video talking about the visuals
Ihsan Tria Pramanda i have just read it now and they wrote "not to complain about boring reactions " not at all that s what we want Lol
Aren't the visuals the whole point of the MV? Although I get the appeal is of this channel is all about the music.
That’s why I live watching them over other reactors. It’s so much more interesting
"I Got a Boy" is officially my favorite reaction in this channel!
Outro Biscoito you should check K will's don't go! That one is gold!!!
Outro Biscoito Same
this one beside b.a.p´s one shot are my faves omg lol
me tooo been watching every reactions they have and this one is pretty hilarious especially the girl with the black jacket and the two dudes that have sunglasses.
Outro Biscoito same I love their reaction to the queens Girls Generation
i think IGAB is actually one of my favorite SNSD songs, and ive been a fan since debut. i have never heard a song quite like it before.
아갓보 비트만 들어보면 진짜 사기임ㅜㅠ작곡가의 대담함에 감탄,, 사실 지금 케이팝에도 아갓보를 뛰어넘는 곡은 없지만 아갓보 이후에 분위기 반전되는 멜로디를 사용하는 아이돌이 많아진건 확실한듯
배경 의상 헤어 안무까지 완벽하다
아갓보는 진짜 전에도 없었고 미래에도 없을 노래...
스엠 정말 배운 변태...💗
아갓보 처음 나올 당시 타그룹빠들과 기획사들까지 총동원으로 아갓보 까댔던거 기억나네 ㅋ
만약 소녀시대가 그렇게 계속 잘나가지만 않았어도 아갓보는 나오자마자 극찬 받으면서 레전드 곡으로 평가 됐을텐데 ... 노알못들과 타빠들 공세에 초반엔 부진하다가 결국 후중독으로 연간 탑 음원순위 성적을 남겼었지
음반도 30만장 넘게 팔았었고
이제 넥스트레벨이 바통을 이음
3절 후렴에 메인과 함께 벌스부분이 코러스로 들어가는게 압권인듯
I Got A Boy was and IS still ahead of its time. Starting from the song itself, down to the lyrics and music video. Everything about it was so perfectly well done. As one of them said, it’s SO MUCH in a way that’s not overwhelming. And that’s something only Girls’ Generation could’ve done, I’m so glad SME got this song for them. It’s been showcasing how much on top of the competition they are.
Carlos B And it’s still SNSD’s best song ever :)
yoo youngjin (the song writer) did it before with boa's "do you love me" back in 2005 so..................no boo boo they are not the only ones who could have done it lol. welcome to the past
not even close! star star star, dear mom, gee, my mistake, promise, yuri ai, do i really need to name them all????????? waaaaaaay better than this. cant pick one as my fave but nothing tops a good ballad
serenityq26 Well that's why it's your fav and not mine! Cheers :)
Carlos B no hun you’re just trying to makeup excuses for that terrible songs lol
Their reactions to I Got A Boy were hilarious! I remember everyone (including me) not liking the song when it first came out because it's so messy. But compared to the songs that groups releases now, I realized that I Got A Boy is indeed unique and I don't think we're going to have another song like it.
My name is Hatred Listen to Chill of EXO. It also has transitions liks IGAB. Haha. SM Ent got a thing for this concept. Haha
Art_Int Ace Thank you for your suggestion! I will listen to it :)
I'm actually a little afraid of another group doing something like this. Unless it is very deliberately transitioned into, I feel like a group simply coming out with something like this (especially a non SM girl group) would be automatically labeled as plagiarism.
It’s the mayhem that makes it their best ever song!
I also did not like this song when it first came out, it wasnt until almost a year later that I truly appreciated it
평가를 보면서 들으니까 악기나 리듬에 집중하게되는듯. 평소에 SM 노래를 들으면서도 느꼈지만 이렇게 보니까 진짜 음악을 평범하지않은, 다양한 시도에 디테일을 더해서 만드는 음악적으로 대단한 회사라고 느껴짐
Gee is that one timeless song where everyone would enjoy listening to regardless of era
Authentic reactions to IGAB!! Damn!! As a sone, IGAB blew off the roof! No one expected that! Not even us sone. At first, the song was all over the place! It was a complete mess! But come to think of it, it was actually somewhat an "organized chaos". Messy at the right place. Honestly, up to this day, IGAB is still ahead of its time. No one could ever duplicate the impact of IGAB. Props to the composers, songwriters, production staff, and to all the people behind the song for creating a MESS!! The most beautiful MESS ever!
AND also thanks to the girls for delivering it so WELL! i don't think other girl groups would make it sound as good, if a cover of this song is ever attempted.
John Vincent Armada *the composer duo who created this mess was the responsible also for the Genie masterpiece 💕*
agreed!
I died when Kevin started playing "Into the New World" on the piano.
OT9 though. :3
The reactions for I Got A Boy. Same, guys, same.
I resurrected when HE SANG
I started tearing up lol
Goosebump already when kevin play itnw :)
이 곡 노래방에서 부르면 한 다섯곡은 부른듯한 피로감이 느껴짐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
넥스트레벨이랑 같이 가성비 굳
The IGAB reaction is trending on Tiktok so i came back here to watch again. Although I don't understand a thing every time they talk about in their music language😅 one more thing 14:30 that's literally my reaction when I found out that 140 part.
THEY WERE SHOOKT WITH THE 1:40 OMG
yarsm because it music term. normal youtubers reactor or fans thought it about timing of the song
do_nut what?
do_nut its about timing and the beat.
yup it’s the beats per minute
why?
"this song takes you on a journey" yea u right bro
I can't even count how many times i listened to IGAB. It still stuns me everytime. SNSD just never gets old. The first ever GG i stan. 😍
진짜 아갓보는 3개 비트 나눠쓰다가 마지막에 비트 합칠때 개지림
The feels in jessica's let's bring it to 140 😍🔥
SM likes harmonies in their songs. That’s why you hear the main vocals or almost all members harmonizing in most songs.
Kaye Musume the edge of sm's songs over other companies.
wolfgang Yeah, they produce some of the best vocalists in kpop too. It’s why I mostly am a stan for many SM groups haha. Taeyeon, Jonghyun, Kyuhyun, Luna, Lina, Chen, Kyungsoo, Baekhyun, Wendy... hell I can name all of them but that would take too long. I guess I stan groups that are vocally well-rounded.
Kaye Musume wait who's lina?
zherol xan Justice for CSJH haha. Lina is from the group The Grace, one of SM’s unsuccessful girl group:/ Lina is deemed as better than Taeyeon and Luna so it’s sad how CSJH did not make it.
Kaye Musume oh I see~ I've heard of The Grace, just never knew any of the members. So none of the members are active?
songs like IGAB and red light by f(x) were considered "weird" and were polarizing in Korea, didn't chart as well as their other songs, but they were legit some of the most interesting, exciting songs in kpop. and it was good for the industry that they came out
But IGAB is still a hit right?
@@jaydie986 it was an snsd song so yeah, it was a hit haha
@@caramelcoffeesthis comment is so real lol
Have you heard the recent attempt of JYP to re-create I Got A Boy? Yeah. That was so...
...Disaster
ah yes whOOk shOOg and zero coke... truly... historical...
..mmmhmmm..
It's like litteral HURRICANE of Music (or whatever it is) .. I think J¥p OVERDID IT..😶
I like "I got a boy" on my first listened but the tried to do experimental music made me O.O. My brain blank and confused. The tradition was messy unlike IGAB.
Still remember when Suju and SNSD was all the rage from middle school to high school, and everyone singing "I got a boy in my chin"
And still remember the 9:06 part was used a lot in some online game community because it sounds like "Ey yoooo G G"
Y-E-S.
when i was in middle school, many of my teachers know 'sorry sorry' including the keypoint of the choreo(the hands rub thingy). i remember when my friends & I got scolded bcs we didnt finish our homework. then my english teacher told us to stood in front of the class & sing sorry2 while doing the hands thingy. so basically almost everyone knows sorry sorry in my school back then lol
Middle school? I was in college 😂 Gee was high school for me. Golden age of kpop!
That's magical SNSD's song. A song released 6 years ago still can make you stunned.
I Got A Boy was the best SNSD song for me, I remember that this was the first SNSD song I heard because of my friends telling me to join them, memorize and danced IGAB at our school, lol. Good ol' days, I hope that there was a recording of our cover then but I'm just so happy SNSD is getting recognition still
I always comeback to their IGAB reactions 😂
everyone thinks that GG are this cute girl group when they see GEE but there is a reason why they are the true queens of Korea and thats cuz they can do every single concept and they actually do it, but not many people notice that cuz since day 1 GG have this unique style, and every concept they do they convert it in that style ... so at the end of the day no matter if ur listening to Oh! or You Think u still know its Girls Generation cuz of that unique identity they have created for their music
Everyone looks so exhausted after listening to IGAB 😂
THmusicismylife xD
하 리액션 영상중에 이거 진짜 탑임
아갓보를 이렇게 해석해가면서 보는 사람들이 어딨겠냐구요...... .........
국뽕 느끼고 싶을때 옴
한국어 자막을 만들었어요!
감사합니다
xoffany 감사합니다!! 덕분에 영상을 더 즐겁게 즐길 수 있었어요😊👍🏼
감사합니다...정말....너무 감사해요 어디사세요 그쪽으로 절할게요
흑ㅎ.ㄱ 너무 감사합니자ㅠㅡㅠ
복받으실겁니다 적게일하고 많이버시길
12:18 shes shookt!!
i keep repeating that part as well
12:30 she's even more shooketh! LOL 😂
Imo she looks more angry than shocked XD like "omg stop bringing new songs to this song" (if that makes sense)
Enrique Araujo LOL 😂 I feel like she was just done with the change but she still liked it 🤣
Lol, I think she was DONE at that point XD
I cannot believe the amount of people who didn't know that "let's bring it back to 140" was referring to BOTH the time stamp and the BPM, we were talking about it since day 1! WHERE MY OLDIE SONE HOMIES AT?!?!?!
Kim here🙋♀️I knew it since day 1^^
LOL. OLD SONE HERE. I got a boy was my first comeback being sone, so it has a very special place in my heart ♥
not everyone studies music so............................i still dont know what they are talking about. 140 bpm!!!!!!! yeah thats great and all but that means nothing to me. its just a time stamp
its like me telling you "sarah graduated" you dont know sarah so what the fuck
YESSSS this came out on New Year’s Eve for me and I was drunk and LOSING MY MIND over that lil fact lmao
dmelissag beats per minute
when Jess did "Don't stop, let's bring it back to 140" everyone would think that the time in this mv while all of the musicians think that's 140BPM which means we all are not wrong! XD
bring it here again bcz i miss this gurl so much
I remember listening this song for the first time. It was New Year's Day, I was excited for GG's comeback, and when I listened to it, I was like, 'are u doing bohemian rhapsody now?' BUT I FUCKING ATE THE SONG. People called me a weirdo for being obsessed with this song.
Kevin's Piano version of Into the New World, damn he knows how to hit right on the feelings.
Carlos Montoya TRUE
0:20 Gee was actually released in January 2009, not 2010
More facts: Gee was the most popular song of the 2000s in S. Korea, according to music chart Melon.
IGAB won 'Video of the Year' at the 2013 TH-cam Music Awards, beating One Direction, Lady Gaga, Justin Bieber and Psy, among others.
Agreeee
That's right
SNSD is literally a group of 9 badass, confident, powerful, successful Stars, istg new kpop fans should all be educated on how and why Snsd is and always will be the best girl group ever💖
I love how nerded out everyone gets about the “Let’s bring it back to 140” BPM reference XD
Man, I always thought 140 is only referring to the minute of the vid. I didn't know about the bpm. Is this a music pun or something? Lol you learn something new everyday.
The ironical thing is: the beatdrop also happens at 140 but I knew the bpm was also 140 so I was shocked whn last week I found out it was also the minutes!!!
140 refers to the BPM (beats per minute) of IGAB at the chorus. Usually, a song has a constant BPM throughout, but this is not the case for IGAB.
BPM is a number that musicians use to gauge how fast the beat of a song is. The higher the number, the faster the beat. Sad songs have low BPM, happy songs have high BPM.
When you listen to the official audio version of IGAB, when Jessica says "Let's go back to 140", she's also referring to the part when the fast chorus kicked in (which is at 1 min and 40 secs). In the same time, she's referring to the BPM which is actually a really cool detail this song has.
Yeah me too!
Really? My mind instantly went to the bpm 😂
I was smiling like an idiot through out IGAB. This was so hilarious and thoroughly satisfied my sone heart. Thank you😁
Jessimi Jone sameee
?? uh they didn't like it though. They said it's a mess
I got a boy가 확실히 가사를 이해 못하면 여러 장르로 휙휙 변하는게 불편할 수 있지만 가사자체가 흔히 말하는(?) Girl's talk느낌으로 서로 다른 친구들이 모여 서로의 연애담을 나누는 느낌인만큼 다양하게 치고 빠지는 여러 음악들이 난 개인적으로 좋았음...그리고 그와 동시에 마지막에는 서로 다른 이야기를 하고있는것같지만 하나로 통일성있게 끝나는 느낌...띵곡이다...
우선 공연장에서 같이 부르면 이거만큼 신나는 노래가 없쥬
I love the fact this reaction video of Girls' Generation has the highest I think? or one of the highest views, where the musicians went crazy over the iconic 'Gee' and 'I Got A Boy'. Queen things! HAPPY 14TH ANNIVERSARY, LEGENDARY NATION'S GIRL GROUP!
from the comments i can just see how deprived (and i forgot to add, jobless of course) all SONEs are, we literally waiting for a video related to them to be released since like a year ago lol
Andy Ong HAHAAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA omfg yes that hit home bruh HAHAHAHHAHA
Andy Ong WE ARE JOBLESS. But not hopeless. Await the comeback, support the solos, fight the Antis!
i remember seeing the reaction schedule before Christmas break thinking "Girls Gen in may start the count down"
Yes literally! 😂😂😂😂😂😂
We Sones are so jobless right now, but we dont know, SM might drop a surprise teaser for SNSD
And im freaking hoping for it
That 140 for tempo and also for the song part in 1:40 always amaze me from the start until now.
Little factoid for ya Taeyeon has hated virtually every one of their title tracks. Apparently she cried when she found is Gee was gonna be their comeback song.
Edit: IGAB was a fucking game changer
*Are you back here too waiting for them to react to Aespa's Next Level? Yes same.*
heyooooo i've always thought gee was an incredibly well produced track, it's awesome hearing actual musically trained people having the same thoughts
I think the highs are a bit too prominent, but it's not a bad song.
i can't enjoy "I Got a Boy" as easy as "Gee" without its MV
Yani Yong, with the MV for I Got a Boy, it blows Gee away entirely for me... I love the visuals too much.
Gee was amazing
yasss their visuals in I Got a Boy are no joke indeed, way much better than Gee, if I Got a Boy is kind of food the MV is a bowl patbingsoo, then coating it with edible gold sheets it WOWs me more, but when i heard the audio only.. its like eating a bowl of hot ramyeon sprinkled with chocolate mint flavor and chopped sugary cinnamon churros I LOVE 'EM ALL but i wish i could eat those yumms separately
*Too bad they changed Gee instead of Genie. I NEED A PART 3 SNSD REACTION, GENIE vs THE BOYS vs Mr. Mr. I WILL BE LIT PROMISE! 💕*
KennethSNSDSone SMTOWN BRING THIS ON TOP.
honestly, i want them to react to snsd' jp songs. like karma butterfly or other bops
YES WE NEED MR.MR AND THE BOYS
Yaaaasssss please @reacttothek make it happen! 💕
YESSSSS!!!!!!! A Genie and the boys would be iconic... and some Japanese songs too
you know they’re some real musicians when they got so excited and hyped when sica said “don’t stop let’s bring it back to 140” cause they know she’s referring to the bpm of the song😆 sis i got yalls reaction i relate
the thing is you cant compare this song to next level or house party because those songs have 2-3 different sections and the transitions are abrubt. i got a boy has like 5 different sections and the transitions work so perfectly. next levels sections all sound electronic and have the same feel at least but house party for me doesnt work at all.
I'm not even a SONE but heeeeeyyyy who wouldn't click fast for Gee??
i like how in their early videos they don't say much when reacting to kpop, now they're so good in reacting to kpop. all the experiences they got from reacting to almost all big groups i guess
ㄹㅇ 아가러보이는 듣는 재미가있는 곡임.. 너무 잘만들었어..
여러분 저분들 거의 다 음악적 이론만 얘기해요ㅋㅋㅋ진짜 이렇게 이론만 말하는 리뷰 처음 봤네ㅋㅋ
Legend said if you only can hear 1 song for the rest of your life, you better choose IGAB, its like listening to 5 different genre in 1 song
galah gilang uppppp
Definitely
Ooo been waiting for this one! I've never clicked on anything so fast. I Got a Boy is one of my favorite pop songs and their visual in the MV is so iconic for me ♥
Lmao kevin in the beginning singing to into the new world is me
Came back after your latest shorts on Song that Shook the reactors lol. After 10 years, IGAB still gives me thrills. A trendsetter indeed.
I DID NOT EXPECT KEVIN TO PLAY INTO THE NEW WORLD SUDDENLY LMAO WE LOVE AN INTELLECTUAL!!!!!
ok I know they're all shookt but can we get Kevin's full piano cover of ITNW, yes? YES
alys앨리스 Yes. Please.
alys앨리스 I SUPPORT THIS! Hi Umu! Hope you'd notice this. @ReacttotheK
alys앨리스 Yes please
아갓어보이 들을때 몇몇은 진짜 개빡쳐보인다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ하긴 본인들도 싫어햇어요
뮤비보면 다끝나고 다들 헐떡이고있는데 어지간하면 멤버들이 헐떡이는거 컷소리까지 참으려고하는데 이곡은 그들도 참을수가없음
근데 이런격렬한난이도가 또 나오고 말았으니...
나만 이댓글 이해안감? ㅠㅠ 누가 설명좀 부탁드려요.
Back when IGAB was released I read a theory that said the song was a conversation between the girls which is why it changes so much, each rithm is like the "voice" of each one of them
0:45 - others performing kpop
0:51 - me performing kpop
Sunny.bias can't even do the piano part tho lol
Wait what song was that
skinny legend SNSD - into the new world (their debut song)
Sunny.bias thanks
HAHAHAHA
IGAB killed Katie 😭😭😭
powerpuff4ever 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
powerpuff4ever : agree😂😂
아갓보야말로 시대를 앞서간... 넥스트레벨이 2021년에 다양한 변조를 가진 노래라고 좋은 평받은걸보면 ㅋㅋㅋ
This is the best reaction!! Ever!! Like I got goosebump whenever I watched this video. Their reactions is very hilarious and smart.
I was grinning during the whole IGAB part omg hahaha
SNSD paved the way for kpop
Andrew Tran FACT!!!
True!
Andrew Tran hahahahah no
Dont act like they were the only good group back than
@@arturogaona5284 I decided to show some proof and not just expect you to believe me. Please understand that when people say this they aren't saying GG was the only good group. GG's extreme virality and popularity really changed how kpop was viewed. They truly changed the future of Kpop. They opened alot of doors and brought ALOT of attention back to female groups. After Gee hit it was INCREDIBLY viral. They barely had any attention from 2007 to 2009 until they dropped Gee.
"On January 7, the group released their debut extended play (EP) Gee, which has sold over 100,000 copies in South Korea. Its title track occupied the number-one position on KBS's Music Bank after a week of release and remained on the top spot for a record-breaking nine consecutive weeks, becoming the longest running number-one song on Music Bank until 2012, when Psy's "Gangnam Style" claimed the top spot for ten consecutive weeks."
They had the longest running number one song on Music bank for 3 years....
"In South Korea, they are credited as the lead female group that shifted the public's focus back to female idols after the Korean music industry experienced an influx of male idol groups from 2002 to 2007"
"Tyler Brûlé of the Financial Times selected the group as the seventh most recognizable figure of Korean culture, the only musical act to make the list.Japanese magazine Nikkei Business suggested the group's international expansion and success was the musical equivalent to Samsung's global trend. Hoai-Tran Bui from USA Today also wrote: "Girls Generation remains the popular girl group in Korea, and their continued success as one of the main purveyors of classic, saccharine retro pop showcases the lasting strength of K-pop."
"Their immense popularity in South Korea has earned the group the titles "The Nation's Singers" and "The Nation's Girl Group" Their image and long-running success for nearly ten years have influenced many K-pop girl groups of the new generation, including GFriend,Melody Day, and Apink.The New York Daily News selected them as one of the prominent girl groups of the 2010s along with Fifth Harmony and Little Mix.They were named among the most powerful and influential people in their native country: the Sisa Journal named the group as the most influential entertainers of 2011 and 2012."
"The group also consistently appeared on the top ten of Forbes Korea Power Celebrity from 2010 to 2016, topping the list in 2011, 2012, and 2014, and placing second in 2010 and 2013. In 2011, the Korean Institute for Industrial Policy Studies named the group as one of South Korea's "super brands." In 2012, Girls' Generation became the first Korean celebrity to have official postage stamps distributed by the Korea Post.*The group was among the five South Korean acts that best represent K-pop during the past two decades according to a 2015 poll by Korea Creative Content Agency*"
Can you see now? They reached another level of popularity. Again no one ever said they were the only good group back then. But they *literally did pave the way for kpop.* Its indisputable.
And this is why IGAB will forever be SM’s masterpiece
Never knew I needed to watch this vid, I love it.
KATIE LOOKS SO DONE WHEN TIFFANY STARTED SINGING AND WHEN THE GIRL EXPLAINED WHAT 1:40 MEANS
I'd suggest
- Lion Heart vs. Genie
- Catch Me if You can vs. Oh!
- Run Devil Run vs. Party
- You Think vs. Hoot
- Holiday vs. The Boys
- Mr. Mr. vs Dancing Queen
Sona True. We need it. Now!
OMG PLEASEEEE I NEED THIS VIDEOOOOO!!!
We need more
yASSSSSSS PLSS
Sona yesss plezzz!!!!!
I love that people who actually have knowledge of music can appreciate all genres and not be pretentious