When everyone talks about tiffany's voice, while i'm here feel so proud with wendy cause she's the only one who collab with a senior gg member while the rookies collab with a rookies too😌
Tiffany Lost her mom, and Wendy's is far away in Canada, I see all these comments saying that they should of picked a better song, but i feel the best performance should be with a song that makes you fall into it, and these two being so far away from their mothers, I think this was a great choice of song.
@@TwBelgi78 It's not innappropiate. Inappropriate songs are the ones sexualizing minors, racism or praising drugs. It's a love song...humans don't only feel love for a significant other. There are other kinds of love.
for wendy and tiffany this is a very hard song not because of vocal because of the lyrics tiffany's mom passed away and wendy's mom lives in canada so she can't see her everyday
Tiffany has proved numerous times how good she is (both as a singer and performer). She lost her mother at a reeally young age and is always really emotional when she sings that song. I don't get what people get from picking on every little mistake she made. You can argue all you want but she remains a talented, rich, unbothered queen. Also in many rookie girl groups nowadays she would be considered a main vocal lol
Tiffany tried her best. Plus, after her surgery to remove vocal nodules years ago, she can't sing as well as she used to back then, her vocal range was also affected as well. So please understand our bright mushroom fany :))
+XinYingg Neo She sang a lot better in 2013 and 2014 though, her voice has gotten a lot worse since GG's last album promotion started, ever since "Party", which worries me
+Mateja Savic Because Sica left and so fany had to move up from the vocal line. Even though we can't see much differences on the surface, i think she had more stuff to do vocally, which is why her voice sounds so tired.
Wendy started crying. I also feel the higher notes should have been given to Wendy because her technique would allow her hit them comfortably in comparison to Tiffany. I mean Wendy is a main vocal for a reason.
I don't understand why everyone is saying "Tiffany did really bad, Wendy sang it better" "This is really funny Tiffany can't sing Hahahaha" Wtf am i the only person who thinks she did good? Sure she nearly cracked a couple times but honestly she probably sings better than all of you.
wendys vocal techniques are obviously much more superior than Tiffanys. Tiffany does strain a lot and shes pushing her voice a lot and her voice is nasal while wendy could just hit all the notes very easily. wendy is actually even stronger than taeyeon because her lower register and head voice is more developed than taeyeon.
well not to be mean or anything but according to this video, her singing is so unprofessional. I dont understand why people can't admit that kind of comments, people say that isn't it because her singing not good ? seriously? do u think she sings well ? really?
She usually sings well. You can't really blame her for struggling with a song that is for and about mothers, when she lost her own mother. More importantly, she actually sounds hoarse (sick-hoarse, not overused-voice-hoarse), which isn't unprofessional so much as it is unavoidable, I think.
I dont care how they sound. all I care about is how fany gave it her best to sing this song with the memories of her mom. on this stage her emotions are more than enough to prove herself.
Fany has sung this song maybe for more than hundreds.. So she exactly knows how to hold her tears inside, which i'm sure she really misses her mother everyday, especially when she's singing this song.. :')
though i do agree Wendy did sang better, but i think Tiffany delivered the best emotional impact, since she can relate to the song the most. set who's better aside, they both did so well, this is really beautiful ♡
I love this duet here but i dont want Tiffany to sing it because i would see how much pain she would have about her mother and i would cry if she cries...
Tiffany successfully held back her tears must be because she had sung this song multiple times and I swore I saw Wendy's eyes glistened at the end of the song, but i wont blame them tho, i already hear this song for thousandth time already yet i still bawl like a baby
We know that Tiffany and Wendy are great at singing. It must be really hard for them to sing this song, but they have sung this song really well. 🎵 I'll be a kind-hearted person from now, I'll be more considerate person. I'll make you proud of me 🎵 *We know that Tiffany and Wendy have great personalities. They are also very talented. Their mothers must be proud of them
I like Tiffany's voice..not sure why people are so hard on her all the time!??!!! smh! She's beautiful and has a decent voice...I'm a fan. Wendy is amazing..that goes without saying.
it must be really hard for tiffany singing this song because we all know (wait...maybe not all ppl) hats tiffany's mom died because of a cancer (not sure but i saw a lot of comments about it) o don't judge tiffany that easily. you just know her name not her story
Actually Noisey recently published the truth, she said in a interview that her mother committed suicide when she was 12 years old, pretty sure she felt a knot in the throat the whole time.
instead of saying that "tiffany cant sing", why dont you say that shes still blessed even if her Mom died. she did her best all the time :) #StopTheHate
@@insidemagicworld dont say that she cant sing she had a surgery for her vocal nodules so her voice isnt so good now but atleast pay some respect her mother already passed away and lets see how youll feel when one your parents passed away.
@@insidemagicworld she lost her mom when her was very young. Her mom is take suicide. Is very hard to sing this song. And tiffany had a surgery for her vocal nodules
Tiffany who lost her mother but gained sisters and family as well thru them, she's a very strong woman and even if she's misunderstood lots of times by people, her love for snsd and her members never waivered .
I'm glad Tiffany became a stronger and better vocalist despite all the hate she got from these eras. She is truly a positive and delightful individual!
I was lucky to have VIP tickets to her show in San Francisco in fall 2019 and got to meet her there - she is indeed a sweetheart! This song is exhibit A as to how the kpop life isn't nearly as easy and glamorous as it can look on the surface - and also that it is still very much a genre where people get to express real emotions and heartache.
Wendy could definitely sing it but she was a little teary inside. Good thing she knows how to control her voice and emotion so it still sounded good for me.😍😍😍 Love yeah Wendy.
I want to applause to Tiffany. No matter how strong you’re but If u sing or heard a song remind u about someone so precious to you esp mother or father, u cant help it but to feel sad & want to cry.
lol am i the only one who enjoys this performance? this probably not tiffany's best performance but anyone who knows tiffany knew that mother is a very sensitive topic to her and even snsd. i really applaud her for singing this song tho. please check out her other songs too before you judge her vocals. she is one of the most hardworking person i have ever seen and as her fans for 10 years now, im proud to say that she has shown so much improvements =')
Wend without a doubt has a naturally awesome voice the same with Tiffany but Wendy can really reach high notes without difficulty. Tiffany on the other has good voice however, in this video I noticed that Tiffany's voice is kinda strained maybe because she is sick and it affects her voice. I mean whats with the hate people? Although Tiffany is suffering from whatever ails her while singing she still performs well as if nothings amiss. A true performer and idol. Kudos to Tiffany ❤
+Erika Hansol Hmm if singing hight notes doesn't suit her, I wonder why the composer or their manager keeps on giving her high key lines. I mean it would't be good to their reputation if Tiffany indeed can't sing such high notes, however, that's not the case. Tiffany was given a lot of high key lines to sing because the people behind such decision knows and saw the potential she has. We don't know the reason why, sometimes and not all the time her voice falter, maybe because of too much singing during music festivals or to much practice.. we can't say for sure. 🙇
I must commend wendy for trying so hard to not overpower her senior though we definitely know she's as good as Taeyeon but she's really a very humble and considerate one. God bless you Wendy. If in any case you chance upon this comment, please know that there are many people who are very proud of you and love you dearly.
The emotions are very well delivered. Both of them did a great job. I can see Wendy shed tears at the end and Tiffany, God knows what she had been through.
@@insidemagicworld Tiffany outclassed Jessica and actually has a self-made career, get over it. I'm sure your queen has some new ghostwritten books and lip-synced stages to catch up on🙅🏿♀
Wendy such a good singer..both of them ofcourse, Tiffany tried her best to sing it properly and I dont really get why people saying 'Tiffany sing bad'. My question is, are you a good singer?
i cried watching this. they are both some of my favorite vocalists and to see how successful they are must really make their mothers proud, even though tiffany's mom is no longer with her. during this performance, i thought about myself. my mom is my best friend. she supports me in everything i do and she's always there for me when i need her. but i have plans of becoming a performer and everyday after i finish practice, i worry that im not good enough to make my mom proud. even if i do make it big and i don't get to see her as often, i want nothing more than to make her proud. it would definitely be hard to leave my mom since we're so close, but living up to her expectations and having her look at me with warm, kind, teary eyes while saying "bear, i'm so proud of you" would be enough.
OMG Wendy is almost crying on this and Fany was really awesome. I wish a could sing with her hehehehehe. Also, this song is very important for both since they are far from their families
This video has one of the worst comment section with the most haters, Imagine hating in a song about a missing mother, and they call themselves kpop fans? Just, yikes
The song is actually written by a female singer, Ivy, who wrote it under her pen name not using her real name, she used the pseudonym "The Lighthouse" instead for the composer name. Ivy wrote the lyrics and Kim Taesong composed the song. its a really nice song.
Don't forget that Tiffany lost her mother at a young age. *Dear Mom* is an emotional song with a lot of meaning, especially for those that have lost theirs. Instead of being pricks and attacking Tiffany go hug your loved ones.
Tiffany tried her best guys. And besides, imagine what her thoughts might be while singing the song. We all know what happened to her mom. And kuddos to Wendy! :D
Guys, how abt instead of talking abt how well thy did, we talk abt how emotional this song is. Esp for these two. Tiffany's mom passed away from a very young age while Wendy's mom lives far away overseas. 😭😭😭
I really cried at the lyrics cause my mom is sick and she's a the hospital right now.I realized how much my mom means to me.This song was emotionally wonderful.Tiffany,you did real great. I know how it feels to be empty without a mom.I hope you'd remain strong and healthy all throughout the year.Wendy,you were SO amazing there.We are proud to have that RV has a vocalist like you.Overall this song is the best song for Mother's day.I love it333333
Even Jyp recognizes how nice Tiffany's voice is. Do you think sm will hire her if not? she has been singing for 10 years with snsd and has trained enough in her trainee days. So who the hell are you to judge her as a singer?
I feel sad for Tiffany.. she's been through much... ever since her surgery her voice just ain't the same anymore. when I hear the audio version I envy her voice but when it's live and she strains.. I just feel so sad for my Tiffany.. she needs rest and she shouldnt force herself.. she can sing!! I feel like she's been trying to prove her position as a Singer since ppl criticized her for being unable to hit notes and with the less of one main vocal in snsd she had to take some lines with maknae.. TIFFANY GWS GIRL GOOD LUCK FOR UR SOLO!!"
Fat Pineapple lack of emotion , srsly, u noe how hard is this when she tried holding back her tears thinking of her mom who passed away.Lack of emotion? Get ur emotions right.
daehyun bap well yeah, that does makes sense , but in the real world , Tiffany's voice isn't made for ballads or OST's........ Taeyeon would've been a better person for this, but it makes more sense if Tiffany is performing , due to her mom that passed.
Ppl said "Tiffany can't sing", well she is part of girls generation. Well, that means she is one of the 8 legends that paved K-pop to go international, hope ppl don't forget GG's effort and sacrifice that made them reach this level by comparing SNSD's level to other ngg
![[COMPILATION] Tiffany (of Girls' Generation) talks to/about her parents.](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/K6oP2jMtlOs/mqdefault.jpg)
![All Artist - As Much Love As All There Is [2015 KBS Song Festival / 2016.01.23]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VWFHuh-DBD8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] EP12-1. I Bumped Into a Celebrity in Cheongdam ! (with Tiffany&??)](/img/n.gif)
When everyone talks about tiffany's voice, while i'm here feel so proud with wendy cause she's the only one who collab with a senior gg member while the rookies collab with a rookies too😌
Potato Wedges me too. Her voice is so dreamy
Tiffany Lost her mom, and Wendy's is far away in Canada, I see all these comments saying that they should of picked a better song, but i feel the best performance should be with a song that makes you fall into it, and these two being so far away from their mothers, I think this was a great choice of song.
Its so hurting ...
Well the lyrics is about waking up and seeing your mother everyday and hearing her voice which is kinda inappropriate then
@@TwBelgi78 I guess it depends on if they don't want to remember her or not?
@@TwBelgi78 It's not innappropiate. Inappropriate songs are the ones sexualizing minors, racism or praising drugs. It's a love song...humans don't only feel love for a significant other. There are other kinds of love.
The song that is sang with soul ❤
for wendy and tiffany this is a very hard song not because of vocal because of the lyrics tiffany's mom passed away and wendy's mom lives in canada so she can't see her everyday
Tiffany has proved numerous times how good she is (both as a singer and performer).
She lost her mother at a reeally young age and is always really emotional when she sings that song. I don't get what people get from picking on every little mistake she made. You can argue all you want but she remains a talented, rich, unbothered queen.
Also in many rookie girl groups nowadays she would be considered a main vocal lol
Manh Cam Nguyen Gurl! Her mom suicide so this a new news for you!
Latata Kpop Trash really? How you know?
BTS BurnTheStage it’s everywhere Koreaboo also posted an articel about it.
Latata Kpop Trash i read it but tiffany never say by herself
Manh Cam Nguyen what’s your problem 😂 leave Tiffany alone god damn
it must be hard for tiffany to sing this song, but she knows her mum is in heaven listening to her daughter happily
tiffany mom is dead?
+MyFaceToo yes when she was young :(
+MyFaceToo please respect her mother don't say dead her mother passed away when she was only 14...
I did not think she was dead. I didnt say it any bad way. I just didn't think her mother was dead because on snap chat I saw her family.
+MyFaceToo Oh im sorry if I misunderstood u
Tiffany tried her best. Plus, after her surgery to remove vocal nodules years ago, she can't sing as well as she used to back then, her vocal range was also affected as well. So please understand our bright mushroom fany :))
what surgery?
+apett zein she underwent treatments and surgery for her vocal nodules.
ah thx for the information♡ still love her tho
+XinYingg Neo She sang a lot better in 2013 and 2014 though, her voice has gotten a lot worse since GG's last album promotion started, ever since "Party", which worries me
+Mateja Savic Because Sica left and so fany had to move up from the vocal line. Even though we can't see much differences on the surface, i think she had more stuff to do vocally, which is why her voice sounds so tired.
I think Tiffany related to this song very well.. Because her mom passed away :/
When?
+SuperKawaiiSarah ** when she was young
+SuperKawaiiSarah ** her mom passed when she was 11
+kurintosan well I can relate because mine passed when I was 10 :(
+SuperKawaiiSarah ** awww :(
Wendy started crying. I also feel the higher notes should have been given to Wendy because her technique would allow her hit them comfortably in comparison to Tiffany. I mean Wendy is a main vocal for a reason.
Tiffany didn't fell well 😔
Maxi
Tiffany was sick asf and also her surgery
zipozapii which is why Wendy should have got the high notes.......
Tiffany went through a surgery
@@nivs5877 That's why some folks said Wendy should get the high notes. Tiff wasn't able to cope well. I reckon she needs more time to adjust.
I don't understand why everyone is saying "Tiffany did really bad, Wendy sang it better" "This is really funny Tiffany can't sing Hahahaha" Wtf am i the only person who thinks she did good? Sure she nearly cracked a couple times but honestly she probably sings better than all of you.
SAME!!!!! SHE SINGS SO WELL
I agree
wendys vocal techniques are obviously much more superior than Tiffanys. Tiffany does strain a lot and shes pushing her voice a lot and her voice is nasal while wendy could just hit all the notes very easily. wendy is actually even stronger than taeyeon because her lower register and head voice is more developed than taeyeon.
well not to be mean or anything but according to this video, her singing is so unprofessional. I dont understand why people can't admit that kind of comments, people say that isn't it because her singing not good ? seriously? do u think she sings well ? really?
She usually sings well. You can't really blame her for struggling with a song that is for and about mothers, when she lost her own mother. More importantly, she actually sounds hoarse (sick-hoarse, not overused-voice-hoarse), which isn't unprofessional so much as it is unavoidable, I think.
I love how Wendy treasures and respects her sunbaes and Tiffany adores and takes care of her hoobaes. Such a wonderful relationship between SM family
I dont care how they sound. all I care about is how fany gave it her best to sing this song with the memories of her mom. on this stage her emotions are more than enough to prove herself.
Fany has sung this song maybe for more than hundreds.. So she exactly knows how to hold her tears inside, which i'm sure she really misses her mother everyday, especially when she's singing this song.. :')
Wendy looked like she might cry near the end, I even teared up a bit reading the lyrics. Makes me appreciate and love my mum more.
Oh no
though i do agree Wendy did sang better, but i think Tiffany delivered the best emotional impact, since she can relate to the song the most. set who's better aside, they both did so well, this is really beautiful ♡
She didn't. She was really our of tone for some reason
I love this duet here but i dont want Tiffany to sing it because i would see how much pain she would have about her mother and i would cry if she cries...
Ysa Marinas what happen to her mom ?
pika chan her mom died of cancer, sadly 😭😭
feelingabitwoozi when did that happen?
Jasmine Sun idk the details, but I think it was after Tiffany was in Korea, and before she debuted.
actually her mom died before tiffany went to korea.
They are so beautiful! So are their voices!
Tiffany successfully held back her tears must be because she had sung this song multiple times and I swore I saw Wendy's eyes glistened at the end of the song, but i wont blame them tho, i already hear this song for thousandth time already yet i still bawl like a baby
We know that Tiffany and Wendy are great at singing. It must be really hard for them to sing this song, but they have sung this song really well.
🎵 I'll be a kind-hearted person from now, I'll be more considerate person.
I'll make you proud of me 🎵
*We know that Tiffany and Wendy have great personalities. They are also very talented. Their mothers must be proud of them
I like Tiffany's voice..not sure why people are so hard on her all the time!??!!! smh! She's beautiful and has a decent voice...I'm a fan. Wendy is amazing..that goes without saying.
YAS WENDY. Tiffany did her best
up to you :) i love tiffany and her voice her inner beauty and i smile
I see tear in Wendy eyes!!!~
One person whose mom is passed way and one is far away from her family:(((
Wendy ASHHH!! How can I not love you? You have such a beautiful voice😍❤ you're so talented my beautiful olaf😍
it must be really hard for tiffany singing this song because we all know (wait...maybe not all ppl) hats tiffany's mom died because of a cancer (not sure but i saw a lot of comments about it) o don't judge tiffany that easily. you just know her name not her story
*that
*so
Those guys are heartless...
Actually Noisey recently published the truth, she said in a interview that her mother committed suicide when she was 12 years old, pretty sure she felt a knot in the throat the whole time.
No her mother killed herself when she was 12 years old.
lets support tiffany for her upcoming solo album
seriously? ....친차?
+Queen Anonymous It's 진짜* not 친차.
+Frosty Winter 미안해 .... im not that good at hanggul .... but thanks :) ㅉ✅ ㅊ❌ .... 감사함니다
+Queen Anonymous 감사합니다* haha :)
Queen Anonymous It's okay hahaha u can always learn ㅋㅋ
Tiffany's mom would be proud of her
instead of saying that "tiffany cant sing", why dont you say that shes still blessed even if her Mom died. she did her best all the time :) #StopTheHate
she cant sing
@@insidemagicworld Can you not read or something?? And besides, I'd like to see you do better after losing a parent.
@@insidemagicworld dont say that she cant sing she had a surgery for her vocal nodules so her voice isnt so good now but atleast pay some respect her mother already passed away and lets see how youll feel when one your parents passed away.
@@insidemagicworld she lost her mom when her was very young. Her mom is take suicide. Is very hard to sing this song. And tiffany had a surgery for her vocal nodules
Daniel Player Tiffany living rent free in your mind , just care about the business women you Stan
Both Tiffany and Wendy did so well! i nearly bursted into tears! the emotions are so clear, it's so touching.
Wendy effortlessly sang this song.
She messed up
😍
She did ! I mean she's 3rd gen best vocalist for a reason and that is her emotional singing ... she can literally make u feel what she's singing
i mean Tiffany at least had her throat operated 3 times and still recovering plus her emotion there. What do you expect?
wendy's voice is worth♥
Imagine lost your mother in a very young age but still give the best performance without crying yes Tiffany you are the best
both of them is on the verge of crying .. but they did well ! i love both of them !
Tiffany who lost her mother but gained sisters and family as well thru them, she's a very strong woman and even if she's misunderstood lots of times by people, her love for snsd and her members never waivered .
Tiffany's voice is very IDENTITY
SHE sang so good, she is pro singer 100% cause she'd stood to sing the songs with many stage in worldwide
Just the beginning of the song, I had goosebumps. I miss this song. ㅠㅠ
I'm glad Tiffany became a stronger and better vocalist despite all the hate she got from these eras. She is truly a positive and delightful individual!
I was lucky to have VIP tickets to her show in San Francisco in fall 2019 and got to meet her there - she is indeed a sweetheart!
This song is exhibit A as to how the kpop life isn't nearly as easy and glamorous as it can look on the surface - and also that it is still very much a genre where people get to express real emotions and heartache.
@@csampang1 I bet she is. I adore her positivity
@animecookies8784 tiffany deciding as a teenager to leave home and try kpop is so daring and I am so happy it has worked out for her
Wendy is really good !!!
Tiffany is so professional, I will cry if I were her
Wendy could definitely sing it but she was a little teary inside. Good thing she knows how to control her voice and emotion so it still sounded good for me.😍😍😍 Love yeah Wendy.
OMG,,Wendy is so pretty♥
Fluffy wendy 🤗
YASS KYOOT FLUFFY WENDY ❤👌
I want to applause to Tiffany. No matter how strong you’re but If u sing or heard a song remind u about someone so precious to you esp mother or father, u cant help it but to feel sad & want to cry.
Tiffany voice is very unique
lol am i the only one who enjoys this performance? this probably not tiffany's best performance but anyone who knows tiffany knew that mother is a very sensitive topic to her and even snsd. i really applaud her for singing this song tho. please check out her other songs too before you judge her vocals. she is one of the most hardworking person i have ever seen and as her fans for 10 years now, im proud to say that she has shown so much improvements =')
I just love Fany's voice 💕 don't understand why you have to hate her, she's always doing her best
Vocal nodules survivor queens 😭👑💘
One's far away from her mom
The other one's sooooo far away from her mom
💔
wendy so talented
I might cried out on stage .. if I were them 😭😭
Sour.s.d.l me too:( wendy looks like about to cry tho
+nct got7 rv tiff too
Sally Devina me too
Wend without a doubt has a naturally awesome voice the same with Tiffany but Wendy can really reach high notes without difficulty. Tiffany on the other has good voice however, in this video I noticed that Tiffany's voice is kinda strained maybe because she is sick and it affects her voice. I mean whats with the hate people? Although Tiffany is suffering from whatever ails her while singing she still performs well as if nothings amiss. A true performer and idol. Kudos to Tiffany ❤
*Wendy
+Lrainez SR her mom passed away when she was younger that's why her voice is not in the best condition singing about moms
+Jesikah Encarnacion actually her voice always in not good condition when she sings high notes. sorry to say that, but high note doesn't suit her.
Agree! True fans will understand that fany might be feeling sick or she has a problem with her voice instead of saying that she is a bad singer
+Erika Hansol Hmm if singing hight notes doesn't suit her, I wonder why the composer or their manager keeps on giving her high key lines. I mean it would't be good to their reputation if Tiffany indeed can't sing such high notes, however, that's not the case. Tiffany was given a lot of high key lines to sing because the people behind such decision knows and saw the potential she has. We don't know the reason why, sometimes and not all the time her voice falter, maybe because of too much singing during music festivals or to much practice.. we can't say for sure. 🙇
Damn it I cry every time I hear this song 😭 Tiffany seemed to have a soar throat here....hope she is better ❤️
RoséAngel1004 Me too... I'm crying right now irl
I must commend wendy for trying so hard to not overpower her senior though we definitely know she's as good as Taeyeon but she's really a very humble and considerate one. God bless you Wendy. If in any case you chance upon this comment, please know that there are many people who are very proud of you and love you dearly.
Next time i want to see taeyeon and seulgi too😀
The emotions are very well delivered. Both of them did a great job. I can see Wendy shed tears at the end and Tiffany, God knows what she had been through.
Tiffany voice wow perfect vocalist queen of highnote
Tiffany can also be the main vocal, and Tiffany's vocal is strong so I like it
@@kartunanimasi7440 yes you are right
1:10 lmao, such a horrible vocal
@@insidemagicworld Tiffany outclassed Jessica and actually has a self-made career, get over it. I'm sure your queen has some new ghostwritten books and lip-synced stages to catch up on🙅🏿♀
@@insidemagicworld she had nodules she couldnt hit the notes. go check her now. 7 years later
Cant wait for another special stage of Wendy!!!
Wendy such a good singer..both of them ofcourse, Tiffany tried her best to sing it properly and I dont really get why people saying 'Tiffany sing bad'. My question is, are you a good singer?
Mak tipani cantik banget hu😍❤
Mbk Wendoy Juga😍
Tiffany crunchy voice is so good:(((
Wendy my baby always sounds good💙
i cried watching this. they are both some of my favorite vocalists and to see how successful they are must really make their mothers proud, even though tiffany's mom is no longer with her.
during this performance, i thought about myself. my mom is my best friend. she supports me in everything i do and she's always there for me when i need her. but i have plans of becoming a performer and everyday after i finish practice, i worry that im not good enough to make my mom proud. even if i do make it big and i don't get to see her as often, i want nothing more than to make her proud. it would definitely be hard to leave my mom since we're so close, but living up to her expectations and having her look at me with warm, kind, teary eyes while saying "bear, i'm so proud of you" would be enough.
They're Angels ❤️
We can see in their eyes... they are crying
no matter how long tiffany being artist. but i think wendy better. bcs she can hit high note without difficult. but, tiff good too💕
OMG Wendy is almost crying on this and Fany was really awesome. I wish a could sing with her hehehehehe. Also, this song is very important for both since they are far from their families
This video has one of the worst comment section with the most haters, Imagine hating in a song about a missing mother, and they call themselves kpop fans?
Just, yikes
เห็นเวนดี้น้ำตาล กูร้องไห้เลย คือรู้ความหมายเพลงไง ละแบบ อืม..ร้องไห้😭
The song is actually written by a female singer, Ivy, who wrote it under her pen name not using her real name, she used the pseudonym "The Lighthouse" instead for the composer name. Ivy wrote the lyrics and Kim Taesong composed the song.
its a really nice song.
Don't forget that Tiffany lost her mother at a young age. *Dear Mom* is an emotional song with a lot of meaning, especially for those that have lost theirs. Instead of being pricks and attacking Tiffany go hug your loved ones.
Wendy my sweet baby was crying at the end 🥺😭
Tiffany tried her best guys. And besides, imagine what her thoughts might be while singing the song. We all know what happened to her mom. And kuddos to Wendy! :D
I'm in love with Wendy and Tiffany. I'm a Tiffany American Pop star Stan. Knowing that she was so unhappy as an Idol, it just makes me so sad.
Tiffany being emotional every dear mom live 😢😢 you can do it tiffany ❤❤
Guys, how abt instead of talking abt how well thy did, we talk abt how emotional this song is. Esp for these two. Tiffany's mom passed away from a very young age while Wendy's mom lives far away overseas. 😭😭😭
Wendy sounds like an Ángel, and looks it too
Fany Fany Tiffany😍😍😘
Tiffany is a very strong and admirable woman. I would be crying seas while singing that song~💔
I like Wendy in this era.. so healthy.. people, she is not fat wtf!!
Tiffany's feeling in this song is wonderful. It smelt my heart because I really know how she feels with a song about mom..😢😢
OMG i love wendy 😍😍😍
I really cried at the lyrics cause my mom is sick and she's a the hospital right now.I realized how much my mom means to me.This song was emotionally wonderful.Tiffany,you did real great. I know how it feels to be empty without a mom.I hope you'd remain strong and healthy all throughout the year.Wendy,you were SO amazing there.We are proud to have that RV has a vocalist like you.Overall this song is the best song for Mother's day.I love it333333
WENDY IS THE TRUE.
No one talks about the song or the performance. Can we not compares their voice
Poor Wendy with teary eyes. She is the only one who can't visit her parents during the holidays during that time.
Even Jyp recognizes how nice Tiffany's voice is. Do you think sm will hire her if not? she has been singing for 10 years with snsd and has trained enough in her trainee days. So who the hell are you to judge her as a singer?
Wendy teared up :"")))) during this time she hasnt met her parents for 4/5 years :(
I mean they are so strong, especially tiffany who has been lost her mom. If this is me i will cried the whole performance
In middle notes, fany sings so so well💪but there is a improvement in high notes
This just randomly popped up in my recommendations. Both Wendy and Tiffany sound great and put a lot of emotion into it
I feel sad for Tiffany.. she's been through much... ever since her surgery her voice just ain't the same anymore. when I hear the audio version I envy her voice but when it's live and she strains.. I just feel so sad for my Tiffany.. she needs rest and she shouldnt force herself.. she can sing!! I feel like she's been trying to prove her position as a Singer since ppl criticized her for being unable to hit notes and with the less of one main vocal in snsd she had to take some lines with maknae.. TIFFANY GWS GIRL GOOD LUCK FOR UR SOLO!!"
I cant even imagine what Tiffany is feeling when singing this......If I was her I would have cried all the time....Its okay unnie! fighting~~~
You guys said 'Tiffany voice is so bad' but the reality is her voice is still better than a lot of kpop girlgroup nowadays 😂
Next time I want to see Wendy and Taeyeon
Fat Pineapple lack of emotion , srsly, u noe how hard is this when she tried holding back her tears thinking of her mom who passed away.Lack of emotion? Get ur emotions right.
daehyun bap well yeah, that does makes sense , but in the real world , Tiffany's voice isn't made for ballads or OST's........ Taeyeon would've been a better person for this, but it makes more sense if Tiffany is performing , due to her mom
that passed.
Karen Luo FUCK YOU
jessica too
I can feel Tiffany. My girl she's so strong ♡
Tiffany and Wendy’s voices are just the most beautiful thing I’ve heard. This songs makes me cry
omg this must have felt like hell to Tiffany :( Poor girl, who made her sing this song?
Wendy is just......amazing
now that wenfany has happened i want wenyeon to happen!
Ppl said "Tiffany can't sing", well she is part of girls generation. Well, that means she is one of the 8 legends that paved K-pop to go international, hope ppl don't forget GG's effort and sacrifice that made them reach this level by comparing SNSD's level to other ngg
9 legends* don't forget Jessica pls
Wendy was indeed better but Tiffany really tried her best.
Wendy Collab with legendary Tiffany
Love both of them
Our English speakers who both had vocal nodules 💘
WenFany we are sooooo proud of you 💘💘💘