Unfortunately, this video is made by someone who has not physically seen the camps. I can not comment on the Al Kabash camp since I had the unfortunate luck of landing in the Al Muaisim camp for our 2024 hajj with this Nusuk lottery. Good is a relative term. If you grew up in the slums of a third world country then yes this place is good. If you grew up in the suburbs of any American city this place is most like camping next to a waste management dump site. In the US the health dept would never allow people to live in this camp site. The streets smelled of garbage or feces. The AC in our tent was only for display. I was told that only about 30% of the AC's actually worked in the tents. There were six sections in our tent with about 40 people per section. Clearly a lot more than 50-100. The sofa/bed was 21 inch wide and about 66 inches long. there was about 2 inches between beds and about 6 inches between beds that were opposite each other. Most of us had no place to put our things except on the bed since only a few areas had a shelf above it. The bathroom comprised of a 2 foot by 3 foot stall with about 50% toilets and 50% holes in the ground that you were supposed to stool in. With the number of people using these stalls and the lack of cleaning by the 2nd day you were basically standing in other people feces attempting to use the stall yourself. I chose to do basically a liquid diet while in the camp so I would have to use the bathroom less. We did not get any bus ride to the Jamarat. it was a 2 hour walk there and a 2 hour walk back. There is no way my in laws could have made that trip on foot. I was able to do the stoning for them. While performing our Hajj Rituals I saw a total of 14 dead people. No medics. No ambulance. Just dead bodies laying on the road side or in the tunnel to Jamarat with sheets over their faces and police telling us to walk around. We were told that there would be bus service to take us to our hotels during the day and bring us back to the camp at night. That never happened. When my in laws finally got seriously sick by the third night in the camp I was able to find a public bus to take them back the hotel and provide them with medical help. The services provided compared to the amount of money charged make you feel like you were ripped off. It is very disappointing that so many of these Hajj Vloggers paint a non existent picture of what the al muaisim mina camp hajj experience is really like.
Aslam o alaicum borther, Thanks for sharing your insight and experience. I was at hajj 2024 as well and I went with Cat B (but not via Nusuk), I will be sharing those details as well . And as stated in my videos everyone will have different experience and many commitments won't be fulfilled and that is why Hajj requires lot of patience. May Allah bless the departed souls and give their relative saber.
For hajj, just remember 3 million ppl are there and Saudi management is still not best, if you are lucky all goes smooth but generally everyone will have one or other issues and challenges. I have videos made on expected issues
Sad to see you are monetizing off incorrect information. The pictures you share are not of al majar al kabsh. It’s off the vip camp that is Only given to Saudi nationals. The buffet pictures also are of the Saudi VIP camp not majar al kabsh. Do not give false information and gather gunnah for misleading. The pictures are all stolen from the Elana-Muslim Travel Girls’s page. Have the courtesy and manners to give credit. And take the time to see that she also explicitly states what camp it is. Sad, that desis are doing what they are known for the most- cheating and lying and stealing.
Jazakallah Kahir for your comment and review. I have constantly mentioned in this video that I am a student and wanted to find this information for myself and complied based on the research which I did and I am student of Islam and like to help others wanting to search for such information. If you have any reference that the information is incorrect please let me know and I am happy to rectify it, InshaAllah. Rest regarding the credit, I am happy to mention that I have mentioned in description as well.
@@pakistanivloggerinukirelan8583 if you would go back and see the original video and read the original video maker’s comments on her video: she clearly says that this is the Saudi VIP camp which if only for the nationals. You can also go “research” youtube Zubair Riaz’s hajj video where he also shows this same camp and tells that it’s only for Saudi residents and saudi nationals. You are misguiding people through your video. There are NO BEDS in majar al kabsh. Please stop misleading people. This false information just for the sake of views is gunnah.
@@pakistanivloggerinukirelan8583 sir, i have been to hajj multiple times and stayed at majar al kabsh. There are no beds there. There are only sofa beds there. Yes it’s not crowded but there are absolutely no beds there.
Jazakallahu Khairan.
This is the best video I came across, I wish I had seen this before I booked my package. Very informative and describes the difference’s very clearly.
thank you very much
Thank you thank you!!!! جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ خَيْرًا
Thank you from USA, Chicago, IL
Thank you, very helpful video
Glad it was helpful!
Unfortunately, this video is made by someone who has not physically seen the camps. I can not comment on the Al Kabash camp since I had the unfortunate luck of landing in the Al Muaisim camp for our 2024 hajj with this Nusuk lottery. Good is a relative term. If you grew up in the slums of a third world country then yes this place is good. If you grew up in the suburbs of any American city this place is most like camping next to a waste management dump site. In the US the health dept would never allow people to live in this camp site. The streets smelled of garbage or feces. The AC in our tent was only for display. I was told that only about 30% of the AC's actually worked in the tents. There were six sections in our tent with about 40 people per section. Clearly a lot more than 50-100. The sofa/bed was 21 inch wide and about 66 inches long. there was about 2 inches between beds and about 6 inches between beds that were opposite each other. Most of us had no place to put our things except on the bed since only a few areas had a shelf above it. The bathroom comprised of a 2 foot by 3 foot stall with about 50% toilets and 50% holes in the ground that you were supposed to stool in. With the number of people using these stalls and the lack of cleaning by the 2nd day you were basically standing in other people feces attempting to use the stall yourself. I chose to do basically a liquid diet while in the camp so I would have to use the bathroom less. We did not get any bus ride to the Jamarat. it was a 2 hour walk there and a 2 hour walk back. There is no way my in laws could have made that trip on foot. I was able to do the stoning for them. While performing our Hajj Rituals I saw a total of 14 dead people. No medics. No ambulance. Just dead bodies laying on the road side or in the tunnel to Jamarat with sheets over their faces and police telling us to walk around. We were told that there would be bus service to take us to our hotels during the day and bring us back to the camp at night. That never happened. When my in laws finally got seriously sick by the third night in the camp I was able to find a public bus to take them back the hotel and provide them with medical help. The services provided compared to the amount of money charged make you feel like you were ripped off. It is very disappointing that so many of these Hajj Vloggers paint a non existent picture of what the al muaisim mina camp hajj experience is really like.
Aslam o alaicum borther, Thanks for sharing your insight and experience. I was at hajj 2024 as well and I went with Cat B (but not via Nusuk), I will be sharing those details as well . And as stated in my videos everyone will have different experience and many commitments won't be fulfilled and that is why Hajj requires lot of patience. May Allah bless the departed souls and give their relative saber.
This is a great comments that people needs to take into considerations.
For hajj, just remember 3 million ppl are there and Saudi management is still not best, if you are lucky all goes smooth but generally everyone will have one or other issues and challenges. I have videos made on expected issues
What is C category camp can you make video on it
I already have a video on that. Check here
th-cam.com/video/BKPSGZT_FHQ/w-d-xo.html
Sad to see you are monetizing off incorrect information. The pictures you share are not of al majar al kabsh. It’s off the vip camp that is Only given to Saudi nationals. The buffet pictures also are of the Saudi VIP camp not majar al kabsh. Do not give false information and gather gunnah for misleading. The pictures are all stolen from the Elana-Muslim Travel Girls’s page. Have the courtesy and manners to give credit. And take the time to see that she also explicitly states what camp it is. Sad, that desis are doing what they are known for the most- cheating and lying and stealing.
Jazakallah Kahir for your comment and review. I have constantly mentioned in this video that I am a student and wanted to find this information for myself and complied based on the research which I did and I am student of Islam and like to help others wanting to search for such information. If you have any reference that the information is incorrect please let me know and I am happy to rectify it, InshaAllah. Rest regarding the credit, I am happy to mention that I have mentioned in description as well.
@@pakistanivloggerinukirelan8583 if you would go back and see the original video and read the original video maker’s comments on her video: she clearly says that this is the Saudi VIP camp which if only for the nationals. You can also go “research” youtube Zubair Riaz’s hajj video where he also shows this same camp and tells that it’s only for Saudi residents and saudi nationals. You are misguiding people through your video. There are NO BEDS in majar al kabsh. Please stop misleading people. This false information just for the sake of views is gunnah.
Thanks again. Can you please confirm where you read no beds in al kabash?
@@pakistanivloggerinukirelan8583 sir, i have been to hajj multiple times and stayed at majar al kabsh. There are no beds there. There are only sofa beds there. Yes it’s not crowded but there are absolutely no beds there.
You really don’t need to be condescending and judgemental. Fear Allah.