If that’s your takeaway from these videos, perhaps this type of content is not for you. Which is fine. Some of us simply like a “different” sports story. Others are fascinated by statistical anamolies. Baseball history/stat buffs adore this type of content- outliers in a sea of the mundane.
This is what I love about Bois. Takes a player I don’t know in a sport I’m relatively unbothered by and he ends up painting a beautiful picture so you become emotionally attached in 15 short minutes.
Take an idea that isn't really interesting And then narrate it with details and precision till the point that Now Every person named Bob is special to me and I hope that everyone of them could be pro athletes
Oh man. Check out Summoning Salt, he'll tell you the history of speed running in a video game you've never heard of and you'll be cheering by the end. It's wild stuff.
couldn't agree more, summoning salt is great but Jon has such a unique style, he is undisputedly the best (maybe the best on the entire platform? i cant think of anyone better). just reading 17776/20020 confirms that for me@@gregorkorosec6131
"... started the game, threw exactly one pitch, hit a batter with it, and was ejected. The only time on record this has ever happened." Get ready for a lot more of it when the Astros season kicks off!
Nah, I expect players will be somewhat subtle in choosing when to hit them. Somewhere in the middle innings with nobody on base and an out or two, or something like that. Looks less suspicious.
@@BrandonA1 To avoid punishment. Just because you don't respect or like someone doesn't mean you are willing to get suspended over it. The MLB has basically said they're going to punish pitchers intentionally hitting batters this season. They're looking for an intentional hit. So you have to make it look unintentional. That's just common sense for someone that isn't looking for a suspension.
I kinda wish you had described how he was able to get hit by all these pitches. I mean, I assume he just kind of leaned in and refused to flinch back when a wild pitch came but it would still be interesting to know if he had any special strategies, where he preferred to take hits, did he wear a special elbow guard or whatever
It's a combination of crowding the plate (not as much as Rizzo, but close) and not bothering to avoid inside pitches. His HBP rate went down considerably after his move from the Rays to the Indians, indicating the Rays' heightened preference for Sabermetrics and OBP. Since he wasn't a starter, him getting injured from a HBP wasn't a big deal to the organization. I thought there was a rule that a batter must make a good-faith attempt to avoid getting hit by a pitch to count as a HBP. Clearly during Guyer's stint this rule was not enforced.
You can see what he does in the footage. Crowd the plate and then make zero effort to get out of the way or actively lean a leg in to get hit by the pitch. None of those should be HBP by rule and in most lower levels would not be tolerated. MLB tends to tolerate it maybe because the pitches are so hard that they serve as their own incentive to get out of the way. But watching the footage yes a ton of these are illegitimate by rule and just not called.
Something that immediately stood out to me is that his "ready" position is right in the center of the batter's box, but his stride places his foot on the chalk right at the front corner. this places his leg invitingly exactly where you'd expect to see an errant breaking ball end up. The other aspect of this is that by having a consistent, legal stride that brings his momentum right up to the side of the plate, it's harder for an umpire to rule that he leaned into the pitch, as opposed to ending up in the path of the ball as a result of his natural hitting mechanics. It could certainly be argued that - especially in slo-mo replay - there are examples of him making extra moves ever so slightly into the path of the ball, but he's able to get away with that BECAUSE of the stride he takes placing him in that area with momentum already going towards the plate. It's like Greg Maddux making a 90s umpire look silly by pitching a little wider, then a little wider, and a little more, until he's working with a double-wide strike zone by the 7th inning stretch. Another thing I noticed was that Guyer seemed to have a great knack for making the absolute smallest move necessary to get clipped by a ball that wasn't already hitting him. He reads the flight of the ball and makes the tiniest adjustment possible, so there's even less evidence tipping off the umpire as to what's happening. The whole thing is like a sleight of hand magic trick, using a big motion to cover a small motion. I think that's as in-depth as I'm going to get on this HBP breakdown.
@@pocklecodthat rule while on the books isn't really used at all in the majors, there's an understanding that standing still and getting hit is a fine way to take a base and not dishonest.
Locastro has too few at bats to be in it (224). With that said, Locastro gets hit by pitches slightly more per 162 games that Guyer. This might be skewed by sample size though
watching this right after the "what if bonds didnt have a bat" video, and I really think baseball's dark secret is that one of the best things to do as a batter is absolutely nothing if 2016 Guyer was able to combine his HBP ability with elite walk rate, we're talking about an MVP candidate. An MVP candidate, for a guy who is thoroughly mediocre at everything except letting things happen to him
What you don’t know, is that Guyer is one of the strongest people in the world. He knows he can’t hit. So he trains his leg muscles so hard they are like steel, and he can absorb 100mph pitches like they are like nothing.
@@gj1234567899999Dang it Guyer, you're not fooling me. Everytime someone talks about you, you gotta load up a sock puppet and start pontificating on how strong your legs are and how "they feel like steel wrapped in leather" or how its like "walking on tree trunks." Brandon, you got a problem man. It's one thing to be proud - it's another to be so weird about your own legs.
That’s not really about the pitching, it’s more about hitting approach. Guys are more often than not going up to the plate looking for hard hits and a certain launch angle. When you’re more concerned about perfect home run environment than just making solid contact, you’re gonna strike out a lot more than you get hits.
ArmadilloLover99 what is interesting though is that the overall hit rate isn’t declining that much, which suggests that what’s declining in favour of strikeouts are fly outs and ground outs.
Sergeant Pickles That makes sense because ground balls in general are on the decline, especially since the strategy for beating infield shifts has become hitting the ball over the shift rather than through its holes. As far as fly outs, that can also be attributed to the launch angle revolution as due to that, a lot of the balls that used to be warning track outs have become homers or doubles off the wall.
@@PlaySA Turns out he didn't break any rule. He just sticks his elbow out until it sticks more than a third of the way into the strike zone. Dietrich is a weird player in his own right.
Thing with Dietrich is, Guyer takes his hit and goes to first base. Dietrich takes his hit (which is usually a strike anyway and shouldn't count as a HBP) and tries to fight half the other team. That's why Guyer is an amusing outlier, and Dietrich is a prick.
Fun fact, getting hit by a baseball was literally the only thing I was good at back in little league. Literally got hit by a pitch more often than I hit the goddamn ball lmao
I’m glad I’m not the only one with this experience. Although I was also a foot taller than everyone on my team (including the coaches), so that might’ve been a part of it.
One year, in my freshman year of high school, I was able to have a .400 OBP, many of them through HBP, without ever getting a hit that season. If that isn’t strange, I don’t what is. I couldn’t hit for my life, but I was still able to play baseball, because I could draw BBs, get HBP, and steal bases at will. I, in no exaggeration, had no other marketable baseball skills. I admit I was terrible, but it was my ability to get BBs and get hit, that allowed me to play longer than I should have.
You should do a video on home field advantage, and how much of an advantage it really is overall and/or on a per team basis. You could do it for any sport, or compare different sports home field advantages.
While I am indifferent to sports in general, I find these kinds of videos fascinating. You present a person or a thing that most people think is inconsequential, e.g., getting HBP or the "saddest punt in history", and use statistics and many charts and anecdotes to make it compelling.
When I saw the title to this video I was certain it was about Craig Biggio. He was Hit By Pitch 2nd most all time at 285, just 2 shy of the 1st held by Hughie Jennings at 287. They mention Jennings in this video, but his career ended in 1918, before the “live ball era”. Biggio is far and away the all time leader in the live ball era in his 20 year HOF career. I mean, he didn’t have to get hit by pitches, because he’s actually one of the greats! But, he still “took one for the team” because he wants to get on base at all costs & he’s tough as nails. He can’t even get a S/O or a mention? They mention Tommy Tucker who is 3rd on the all time list & his career ended in 1899. They mention Minnie Minoso who is 10th on the all time list with a 20 year career. smh. DO BETTER DORKTOWN!
I love the charts as always! I was kind of hoping you'd explain HOW Guyer gets hit by so many pitches, though? Like, the numbers make it likely that it's intentional, but how does he actually do it? (I mean, just putting himself in the way of the ball wouldn't do it. I remember trying to get hit intentionally in Little League - much less dangerous than with MLB pitchers! - but more often than not, the ump would call a strike or even an automatic out if they thought I'd gotten hit on purpose.)
I found an article called "bruises for bases" from MLB's own website. Essentially it's his stride before he swings, combined with an instinctual inability to get away from lower, inside pitches. He also states he doesn't want to change anything because it would affect his batting which is somewhat believable. I'd say it's 6 to one, half dozen to the other. Other than the bruises, it's not hurting anything, so why change?
This video reminds me of an early "Cheers" episode when Coach Ernie Pantuso brags about his ability to "lean in" and was also the reason why he had onset cte dementia. That would have been a cameo perfect clip for this vid.
Having recently learned about Minnie Miñoso I was glad to see he got a mention in this video, but kind of surprised since this was about HBPs you didn't mention he led "the AL in times hit by pitch a record ten times, and [held] the league mark for career times hit by pitch from 1959 to 1985." [per Wikipedia]
@@lovelessissimo if they never end up winning a world series it's kinda all for nothing though. If the braves never won a world series in the 90s that whole era would be looked at as a failure of sorts
@@westinmcclister1507 I see what you mean, but when a team is winning 106 games during the regular season, it's hard to call it a collapse. A choking marathon, yes. Collapse, not yet.
I love this, as the hit by pitch champion in my area when I was a kid. I had years averaging more than one per game. Why not, the safest way to get on base, and (at least with kids) definitely made the opposing pitcher reluctant to pitch inside to following hitters. Got a base on catcher’s interference once, I couldn’t figure out why my swing went wonky until the coach told me.
That's the difference between Foolish Baseball and Jon imo. Jon finds the interesting happenstances and shares them like they are, letting them tell the story on their own, whereas Foolish Baseball pursues and even "invents" them, sometimes exaggerating for storytelling effect. Both are fun and cool in their own way!
Biggio was hit on 2.3% of his regular season plate appearances in his career... look at the chart at 4:44 and see where that puts him. His highest single season percentage was 4.6%. See where that would land him on the chart at 6:38. The conclusion is that yes, Biggio got hit more than the average player and a huge number of times in total (because he played 20 seasons) but not at a high enough rate to get him into the totally outlandish tier that SB Nation loves to zero in on.
Great videos guys, the graphics really are a treat. Since we're all dorks, I've gotta jump in at 10:12, you say there are only two ways to reach first without swinging the bat, a BB and HBP. The batter could also get called out looking on a dropped third strike and reach base without swinging.
Would have been curious to see you guys break down his batting stance. I imagine the distance from the plate as well as the degree at which he bends his knees plays a huge factor in why he gets hit so often. Also where he gets hit the most might paint a better picture. Great video as always
I think it would be interesting to examine who pitched the most "difficult" no-hitter. One way to measure that could be examining no-hitters vs. incoming batting average over a period of time. Valid episode topic?
Fun Fact: In my youth, I was a decent player. I can hit, more for power than average, and was an average fielder. One thing I never experienced was getting hit by a pitch. This eventually got into my head and my back foot kept on bailing. I was still hitting the ball but I had nothing behind it. I worked on it for a while at the batting cages. When it came time for my first at bat against live pitching(scrimmage) I stepped to the plate, the first pitch came in and my back foot headed for the hills. I walked off the field and never played organized baseball again. In short, I got the yips and the yips is an incurable disease.
I played baseball that way. I typically had more HBP each season than the rest of my team combined. It was my job to get on base, so I got on base. Pitchers could either throw the ball out over the plate, giving me decent pitches to hit hard, or they could come inside and take a very real chance at hitting me. I never really considered it "weird," I guess...just how I played.
Hey! Minnie Minoso! The guy played pro ball for more years and in more countries than anyone in history. Met him in 2012 and he was such a sweet old man. Good to see him mentioned.
But how many time did he convert those HPB into RB? Was he a threat on the bases? It would be sad to conclude that his unique "talent" didnt contribute to the team's success...
I met Kelly Shoppach once, as part of a clinic the Pawtucket Red Sox put on for young fans. I remember this incident because he was describing how as a catcher, you had to wear a cup, when one of the kids cup-checked him. He was not wearing a cup.
I don't know if this would work better for Dorktown or Chart Party but I recommend a video about the best divisions in history. It could be interesting to look at past divisions where all the teams in it were good and how that went down.
My local collegiate wood bat summer team _excels_ at HBP. One of our players was plonked _twice in one game_ *four times* this season. (That’s right, four multi-HBP games in one 54-game season. He was HBP 20 times in 173 plate appearances. Hit more than 10% of the times he was at the plate.
Man, everything is becoming part of an extended interconnected universe, even dorktown episodes all exist in the same google earth file
Expecting a major DTCU crossover movie at some point
Memeo Supremo into the dorktown-verse
Jon Bois Cinematic Universe.
We live in a Dorktown Universe
This one probably should have been an episode of High Score though.
What if Brandon Guyer was Barry Bond's bat?
This is an underrated question
That would break baseball.
Jon Bois, do this episode. Right now.
I'm dead 😂😂
Barry Bonds would never strike out again.
9:19 At that point, I wouldn’t even call him an “on-base hitter…” he’s more like the on-base hittee.
I just watched a 14 minute video showing me a million different charts essentially saying "this guy gets hit by pitches a lot"
don't forget dick padden
@@cheesyrevenge lololol
If you don't know now ya know
Welcome to Dorktown. You've been added to the sign.
If that’s your takeaway from these videos, perhaps this type of content is not for you.
Which is fine. Some of us simply like a “different” sports story. Others are fascinated by statistical anamolies. Baseball history/stat buffs adore this type of content- outliers in a sea of the mundane.
Ok but Tim Locastro is faster.
Foolish Baseball no respect for my boy Tim
My new favorite weird baseball player
That's some amazing timing
Foolish Baseball and Jon Bois collab?
@@SDW03 I've never wanted anything more, then get Jomboy to do a breakdown of the collab
This is what I love about Bois. Takes a player I don’t know in a sport I’m relatively unbothered by and he ends up painting a beautiful picture so you become emotionally attached in 15 short minutes.
Take an idea that isn't really interesting
And then narrate it with details and precision till the point that
Now Every person named Bob is special to me and I hope that everyone of them could be pro athletes
Thanongrit Suriyarungka I feel Bob in my veins now
Oh man. Check out Summoning Salt, he'll tell you the history of speed running in a video game you've never heard of and you'll be cheering by the end. It's wild stuff.
@@LeoStaley Watched a lot of Summoning Salt and Bois is on a different level from that
couldn't agree more, summoning salt is great but Jon has such a unique style, he is undisputedly the best (maybe the best on the entire platform? i cant think of anyone better). just reading 17776/20020 confirms that for me@@gregorkorosec6131
Yo they’re gonna build a freaking city out of the charts.
It’s gonna be an actual dork town.
4 years later and you are correct, it’s beautiful.
Jonah Hill: He gets on base.
Top quality comment
💀😂🙌
BONEYMALL!
You mean Peter Brand
Scout: Alright, so he gets hit a lot.
Billy: He gets on base a lot, do I care if he gets hit or gets a hit?
These clowns have never heard of TIM LOCASTRO
Gah, you beat me to it!
Just wait until he plays a full season
Foolish BB!
@@hiimemily Tim Locastro already beat you to it.
Matthew “we interrupt this to show you Tim Locastro racing Albert Pujols again…”
BRB removing my window-mounted AC unit
I... damn it. Yeah, need to do it too.
You'll be glad you did.
Jon Bois truly is a man of the people
Mista! Mista!
How'd it go?
"... started the game, threw exactly one pitch, hit a batter with it, and was ejected. The only time on record this has ever happened."
Get ready for a lot more of it when the Astros season kicks off!
Nah, I expect players will be somewhat subtle in choosing when to hit them. Somewhere in the middle innings with nobody on base and an out or two, or something like that. Looks less suspicious.
@@kyletucker3811 why would they ve subtle? Nobody, including the MLB, has any respect for the Astros whatsoever
@@BrandonA1 To avoid punishment. Just because you don't respect or like someone doesn't mean you are willing to get suspended over it. The MLB has basically said they're going to punish pitchers intentionally hitting batters this season. They're looking for an intentional hit. So you have to make it look unintentional. That's just common sense for someone that isn't looking for a suspension.
When?
Nah, I think the umps will overlook the first dozen, every game.
I kinda wish you had described how he was able to get hit by all these pitches. I mean, I assume he just kind of leaned in and refused to flinch back when a wild pitch came but it would still be interesting to know if he had any special strategies, where he preferred to take hits, did he wear a special elbow guard or whatever
It's a combination of crowding the plate (not as much as Rizzo, but close) and not bothering to avoid inside pitches. His HBP rate went down considerably after his move from the Rays to the Indians, indicating the Rays' heightened preference for Sabermetrics and OBP. Since he wasn't a starter, him getting injured from a HBP wasn't a big deal to the organization.
I thought there was a rule that a batter must make a good-faith attempt to avoid getting hit by a pitch to count as a HBP. Clearly during Guyer's stint this rule was not enforced.
You can see what he does in the footage. Crowd the plate and then make zero effort to get out of the way or actively lean a leg in to get hit by the pitch.
None of those should be HBP by rule and in most lower levels would not be tolerated. MLB tends to tolerate it maybe because the pitches are so hard that they serve as their own incentive to get out of the way.
But watching the footage yes a ton of these are illegitimate by rule and just not called.
Something that immediately stood out to me is that his "ready" position is right in the center of the batter's box, but his stride places his foot on the chalk right at the front corner. this places his leg invitingly exactly where you'd expect to see an errant breaking ball end up. The other aspect of this is that by having a consistent, legal stride that brings his momentum right up to the side of the plate, it's harder for an umpire to rule that he leaned into the pitch, as opposed to ending up in the path of the ball as a result of his natural hitting mechanics. It could certainly be argued that - especially in slo-mo replay - there are examples of him making extra moves ever so slightly into the path of the ball, but he's able to get away with that BECAUSE of the stride he takes placing him in that area with momentum already going towards the plate. It's like Greg Maddux making a 90s umpire look silly by pitching a little wider, then a little wider, and a little more, until he's working with a double-wide strike zone by the 7th inning stretch.
Another thing I noticed was that Guyer seemed to have a great knack for making the absolute smallest move necessary to get clipped by a ball that wasn't already hitting him. He reads the flight of the ball and makes the tiniest adjustment possible, so there's even less evidence tipping off the umpire as to what's happening. The whole thing is like a sleight of hand magic trick, using a big motion to cover a small motion.
I think that's as in-depth as I'm going to get on this HBP breakdown.
@@pocklecodthat rule while on the books isn't really used at all in the majors, there's an understanding that standing still and getting hit is a fine way to take a base and not dishonest.
Better have Tim Locastro in this video
foolish baseball and jon bois collab?
Hmmmmm?
Locastro has too few at bats to be in it (224). With that said, Locastro gets hit by pitches slightly more per 162 games that Guyer. This might be skewed by sample size though
He better be.
Exactly my thoughts when I got this notification.
*Guyer walks up to home plate*
Guyer: "Ah shit, here we go again."
Guyer's body*
watching this right after the "what if bonds didnt have a bat" video, and I really think baseball's dark secret is that one of the best things to do as a batter is absolutely nothing
if 2016 Guyer was able to combine his HBP ability with elite walk rate, we're talking about an MVP candidate. An MVP candidate, for a guy who is thoroughly mediocre at everything except letting things happen to him
Luigi wins by doing absolutely nothing? Wait that doesn't work here.
ya but u dont just get walked, you draw walks by being a good hitter and pitch reader
Hey, Guyer did hit a double off Aroldis Chapman in Game 7 of the World Series.
What you don’t know, is that Guyer is one of the strongest people in the world. He knows he can’t hit. So he trains his leg muscles so hard they are like steel, and he can absorb 100mph pitches like they are like nothing.
@@gj1234567899999Dang it Guyer, you're not fooling me. Everytime someone talks about you, you gotta load up a sock puppet and start pontificating on how strong your legs are and how "they feel like steel wrapped in leather" or how its like "walking on tree trunks."
Brandon, you got a problem man. It's one thing to be proud - it's another to be so weird about your own legs.
“There are now more strikeouts than hits”
Damn that’s impressive, goes to show how great modern pitching can be
Yeah but it's boring
Also the way no hitters hit for contact any more because it statistically isn't worthwhile
That’s not really about the pitching, it’s more about hitting approach. Guys are more often than not going up to the plate looking for hard hits and a certain launch angle. When you’re more concerned about perfect home run environment than just making solid contact, you’re gonna strike out a lot more than you get hits.
ArmadilloLover99 what is interesting though is that the overall hit rate isn’t declining that much, which suggests that what’s declining in favour of strikeouts are fly outs and ground outs.
Sergeant Pickles That makes sense because ground balls in general are on the decline, especially since the strategy for beating infield shifts has become hitting the ball over the shift rather than through its holes. As far as fly outs, that can also be attributed to the launch angle revolution as due to that, a lot of the balls that used to be warning track outs have become homers or doubles off the wall.
Derek Dietrich got hit by 4 pitches in one game in 2019 and had more HBP then singles, doubles, and HR’s
I think I remember that game. The announcers were so steamed up about it and were trying to figure out what rule he broke
@@PlaySA Turns out he didn't break any rule. He just sticks his elbow out until it sticks more than a third of the way into the strike zone. Dietrich is a weird player in his own right.
according to baseball reference, he was HBP in 8.17% of his 306 PA this year, too. Not sure why he wasn't included in that graph
Nick Wagner same thing with Tim locastro
Thing with Dietrich is, Guyer takes his hit and goes to first base. Dietrich takes his hit (which is usually a strike anyway and shouldn't count as a HBP) and tries to fight half the other team. That's why Guyer is an amusing outlier, and Dietrich is a prick.
Jon Bois presents: Man Getting Hit By Baseball
Give Acuña the $10,000
This sounds like a title made by the onion
@@traberburns It's a Simpsons reference...
*doink* Ooooooh!!
Ow! My balls!
Bois: What is his name?
Alex: Brandon GUY-r
Bois: lolz
The only HBP god I accept is Craig Biggio
Look up Foolish Baseball on TH-cam and watch his most recent video and his whole channel is worth while if you enjoy baseball content
And here I am talking Ron Hunt and that one terrible Cubs manager.
@@chriswalkey2050 Already do actually he's great!
You took the words outta my mouth... Go ASTROS
@C R yeah in his later years. But unlike this guy he also had tons of 1B, 2B, 3B, and HR while still amassing 3 shy of the dead ball era record.
I played some baseball in my day, I played a 6 game season.
1 base hit
2 walks
7 hit by pitch
I led my team in hits
This story begins with me getting hyped about the fact that there's a Bois video up.
A couple weeks ago, Jorge Soler (KC) reached base on Catcher’s Interference twice. The first time in MLB history that had happened
Fun fact, getting hit by a baseball was literally the only thing I was good at back in little league. Literally got hit by a pitch more often than I hit the goddamn ball lmao
#MeToo
Same I led the league in on base percentage with only like 10 hits
I’m glad I’m not the only one with this experience. Although I was also a foot taller than everyone on my team (including the coaches), so that might’ve been a part of it.
I was better at beaning kids back than got thrown out in 3 pitches once with 2 beans
One year, in my freshman year of high school, I was able to have a .400 OBP, many of them through HBP, without ever getting a hit that season. If that isn’t strange, I don’t what is. I couldn’t hit for my life, but I was still able to play baseball, because I could draw BBs, get HBP, and steal bases at will. I, in no exaggeration, had no other marketable baseball skills. I admit I was terrible, but it was my ability to get BBs and get hit, that allowed me to play longer than I should have.
You should do a video on home field advantage, and how much of an advantage it really is overall and/or on a per team basis. You could do it for any sport, or compare different sports home field advantages.
Just waiting for that Dorktown/Foolish Baseball crossover.
We aint ready
While I am indifferent to sports in general, I find these kinds of videos fascinating. You present a person or a thing that most people think is inconsequential, e.g., getting HBP or the "saddest punt in history", and use statistics and many charts and anecdotes to make it compelling.
Brutus: *noble*
Tim lecastro and Brandon guyer: *the most noble*
Brandon Guyer?
I’ve never heard Craig Biggio’s name pronounced that way before. Seems pretty odd.
Same. I expected to see a lot of ground covered on Biggio and Rizzo.
When I saw the title to this video I was certain it was about Craig Biggio. He was Hit By Pitch 2nd most all time at 285, just 2 shy of the 1st held by Hughie Jennings at 287. They mention Jennings in this video, but his career ended in 1918, before the “live ball era”. Biggio is far and away the all time leader in the live ball era in his 20 year HOF career. I mean, he didn’t have to get hit by pitches, because he’s actually one of the greats! But, he still “took one for the team” because he wants to get on base at all costs & he’s tough as nails. He can’t even get a S/O or a mention? They mention Tommy Tucker who is 3rd on the all time list & his career ended in 1899. They mention Minnie Minoso who is 10th on the all time list with a 20 year career. smh.
DO BETTER DORKTOWN!
“The triple, the two dollar bill of baseball” 😂😂
I love the charts as always! I was kind of hoping you'd explain HOW Guyer gets hit by so many pitches, though? Like, the numbers make it likely that it's intentional, but how does he actually do it? (I mean, just putting himself in the way of the ball wouldn't do it. I remember trying to get hit intentionally in Little League - much less dangerous than with MLB pitchers! - but more often than not, the ump would call a strike or even an automatic out if they thought I'd gotten hit on purpose.)
I found an article called "bruises for bases" from MLB's own website. Essentially it's his stride before he swings, combined with an instinctual inability to get away from lower, inside pitches. He also states he doesn't want to change anything because it would affect his batting which is somewhat believable. I'd say it's 6 to one, half dozen to the other. Other than the bruises, it's not hurting anything, so why change?
@@motherhorsefucker Everything you just said plus I suspect he was bad at hitting inside pitches, so pitchers tried to pitch him inside a lot.
You’re crazy if you think I’m not gonna now put Brandon Guyer in all my starting lineups in The Show. Thanks Jon for this helpful tip
13:50 Thanks for the reminder Jon, this is why you're the best
TH-cam algorithm: since you been watching hit by a pitch videos
Recommend:
Enjoy your freshly found Jon Bois addiction
Same here.. Funny how that works out.
I’m surprised you guys didn’t even mention the real HBP god Tim Locastro.
This video reminds me of an early "Cheers" episode when Coach Ernie Pantuso brags about his ability to "lean in" and was also the reason why he had onset cte dementia. That would have been a cameo perfect clip for this vid.
The whole reason I watched this! th-cam.com/video/xUqDEO2Hlxk/w-d-xo.html
I probably scrolled 3 minutes to try and find someone else who wanted to talk about pantuso
Yeeeeah I'm really gonna need a tie-breaking breakdown video of Tim Locastro vs. Brandon Guyer
Having recently learned about Minnie Miñoso I was glad to see he got a mention in this video, but kind of surprised since this was about HBPs you didn't mention he led "the AL in times hit by pitch a record ten times, and [held] the league mark for career times hit by pitch from 1959 to 1985." [per Wikipedia]
You know after this season you could make a Collapse episode about the 2010s Dodgers.
Their best players would need to leave for that to happen.
@@Ofallthings089 if like 2 more leave I'm all for it. The Howie section is gonna be godly
They are still in the midst of a 7-peat division winning streak.
@@lovelessissimo if they never end up winning a world series it's kinda all for nothing though. If the braves never won a world series in the 90s that whole era would be looked at as a failure of sorts
@@westinmcclister1507 I see what you mean, but when a team is winning 106 games during the regular season, it's hard to call it a collapse.
A choking marathon, yes.
Collapse, not yet.
I love this, as the hit by pitch champion in my area when I was a kid. I had years averaging more than one per game.
Why not, the safest way to get on base, and (at least with kids) definitely made the opposing pitcher reluctant to pitch inside to following hitters.
Got a base on catcher’s interference once, I couldn’t figure out why my swing went wonky until the coach told me.
To the people talking about Tim Locastro: He has 224 career at bats. There's this thing called "sample size"..
That's a large sample size
That's the difference between Foolish Baseball and Jon imo. Jon finds the interesting happenstances and shares them like they are, letting them tell the story on their own, whereas Foolish Baseball pursues and even "invents" them, sometimes exaggerating for storytelling effect.
Both are fun and cool in their own way!
@@rebeccatrishel considering a full season is 162 games and an average player has multiple at bats per game.. no it's not
@@solsticelacer We're calculating the percentage of at bats that he's been hit by pitch, right? We could math this
Solstice is 100% correct. See what small sample size did to Jeff Francoeur.
Watch Altuve break that record this season
I have a feeling Altuve and Bregman are about to break this record in 2020.
Not likely, now...because of things.
There's always 2021
@@woods1one yeah that didn’t work out either
I love this these dork town and chart party videos. The 80s motif to them just gets me everytime
Brandon Guyer really does it all. Saw him hit an inside the parker vs my Royals in 2015 too
Welcome back Jon! (Also, no mention of Craig Biggio who was one of the most hit players ever? Strange.)
Biggio was hit on 2.3% of his regular season plate appearances in his career... look at the chart at 4:44 and see where that puts him. His highest single season percentage was 4.6%. See where that would land him on the chart at 6:38.
The conclusion is that yes, Biggio got hit more than the average player and a huge number of times in total (because he played 20 seasons) but not at a high enough rate to get him into the totally outlandish tier that SB Nation loves to zero in on.
Ernie Pantuso was a legend for his ability to be able to get hit by a pitch. No matter where you threw it, he’d be able to get the pitch to hit him
Great videos guys, the graphics really are a treat. Since we're all dorks, I've gotta jump in at 10:12, you say there are only two ways to reach first without swinging the bat, a BB and HBP. The batter could also get called out looking on a dropped third strike and reach base without swinging.
2020: Enter Jose Altuve
The hit by pitch god is literally my trainer now and he’s such a great guy man. Coach guyer is such a god
has he seen this video?
Would have been curious to see you guys break down his batting stance. I imagine the distance from the plate as well as the degree at which he bends his knees plays a huge factor in why he gets hit so often. Also where he gets hit the most might paint a better picture. Great video as always
13:07 _"Kelly Shoppach vs. himself"_
*this is why I love jon bois*
Whenever Jon Bois uploads a video, my day is made ❤️
Craig Biggio: **Oh, so you’re approaching me?**
Lol when you mentioned Vina, I was like "PLEASE mention the St. Lunatics remix" haha
Please make more!!! This is literally heaven for sports nerds. You guys also have very nice soothing voices ;)
I think it would be interesting to examine who pitched the most "difficult" no-hitter. One way to measure that could be examining no-hitters vs. incoming batting average over a period of time. Valid episode topic?
Okay Jon Bois, this was a good start. But I’m gonna need several more hours of content from you
NEW DORKTOWN HELL YEAH
Can't wait for the Ty France episode
As an engineer and a baseball fan I absolutely love this videos. Thanks guys!
This guy will be surpassed handily by Tim Locastro once he gets to 1K PAs
In what HBP video can you not mention Craig Biggio?
Went to high school with this dude, crazy to see an SB Nation video on him!
WE LIKE SPORTS AND WE DONT CARE WHO KNOWS
Stupid question, but where is this quote from. Is it from a movie or show, or is it just a meme in the comments section of all jon bois' videos?
Tylersaurand it’s a lonely island song
@@kaminsod4077 Just 2 Guys - We Like Sports
Football, football, football, tennis, hockey, golf
Fun Fact: In my youth, I was a decent player. I can hit, more for power than average, and was an average fielder. One thing I never experienced was getting hit by a pitch. This eventually got into my head and my back foot kept on bailing. I was still hitting the ball but I had nothing behind it. I worked on it for a while at the batting cages. When it came time for my first at bat against live pitching(scrimmage) I stepped to the plate, the first pitch came in and my back foot headed for the hills. I walked off the field and never played organized baseball again. In short, I got the yips and the yips is an incurable disease.
Dbacks player Tim Locastro got hit by 22 pitches in the 2019 season and 22 stolen bases and 2 walkoffs.
I played baseball that way. I typically had more HBP each season than the rest of my team combined. It was my job to get on base, so I got on base. Pitchers could either throw the ball out over the plate, giving me decent pitches to hit hard, or they could come inside and take a very real chance at hitting me. I never really considered it "weird," I guess...just how I played.
Nobody:
Dorktown: Here's a video about Brandon Guyer
Hatchett.XYZ yikes bro. Crimge
@@justinw3403 super cringe
Hey! Minnie Minoso! The guy played pro ball for more years and in more countries than anyone in history.
Met him in 2012 and he was such a sweet old man. Good to see him mentioned.
But how many time did he convert those HPB into RB? Was he a threat on the bases?
It would be sad to conclude that his unique "talent" didnt contribute to the team's success...
Probably not, as he was on the Rays
That’s irrelevant to the videos point
@@felizkodie5328 Like your comment..
TEQ Snukka how dumbass
I met Kelly Shoppach once, as part of a clinic the Pawtucket Red Sox put on for young fans. I remember this incident because he was describing how as a catcher, you had to wear a cup, when one of the kids cup-checked him.
He was not wearing a cup.
Someone should do "the creation of SB nation deserves a deep rewind"
This is the quality content I come here for.
A little disappointing there’s nothing on Tim Locastro, Your Favorite Weird Baseball Player 😔
I just want you both to know how much I love these. And thanks for the tip about the window air-conditioners. Doing your part to save the world.
What if Brandon Guyer was Barry Bonds's bat?
Thanks for the tip about the window-mounted A/C unit! Gonna save me hundreds.
You are not even going to mention Biggio...okay
I love your stuff. Look into Superbowl 40 and the statistical improbabilities for all the crazy bad calls all on one team.
He was my favorite player on the Rays, he was so fun to watch
Seriously the best use of infographics on TH-cam! #subscribed
So now we're building New Dork City?
Thanks for the heads up Jon, but I recalled my window a/c unit from its perch last weekend.
"Do I care how he gets on base?"
"You do not."
Nick Cipollone nice reference
Live for these videos, man that’s sad
Thank you for Jon Bois, we are not worthy
Inject new Dorktown into my afternoon veins
Here after another pitcher got ejected after the first pitch of the game
A tear of joy rolled down my eye when I saw this video pop up.
Where is Craig Biggio on this list?
"King of Getting Hit by Pitch...Pffft....hold my beer." -- Don Baylor
I started watching these videos cause I was baked, and liked the music and images. Now I also like sports!
I don't know if this would work better for Dorktown or Chart Party but I recommend a video about the best divisions in history. It could be interesting to look at past divisions where all the teams in it were good and how that went down.
Craig Biggio?
These videos are the best videos on this platform
PRETTY GOOD STORIES THAT ARE PRETTY GOOD... oh it's dorktown ok w/e
My local collegiate wood bat summer team _excels_ at HBP. One of our players was plonked _twice in one game_ *four times* this season. (That’s right, four multi-HBP games in one 54-game season. He was HBP 20 times in 173 plate appearances. Hit more than 10% of the times he was at the plate.
Tim Locastro died for this.
Loved the PSA at the end of the video. You’re right! Those things do leak a lot of heat.