The only reason the old one sounds too 'disney' is because you grew up associating it with Disney. Lea Salonga's voice is crystal clear and effortlessly beautiful without any autotune. She has tons of chemistry with the male singer here who I personally think sounds way better than the guy in the remake. The remake couple doesnt sound good together and it has autotune.
Yea the chemistry is better in the original. The dude in the remake is not as strong a singer and thus they tone him down in the mix compared to Naomi who is a strong singer.
and i watch the behind the scene of the original leah's voice is pure and with pronunciation of each word and they dont use auto tune so i agree with you completely
I love both versions! Lea definitely has the more Disney princess sound, and Naomi has more of the pop sound, not so much head/falsetto/breathy sound that Lea had. But I love both just the same! The original animated, nothing beats an original, but live action is still awesome! The music is fire in both!
The major problem with the new version for me is that the tone was changed into a one-sided power balled or something. Aladdin is supposed to be serenading Jasmine. His part actually still sounds like it but with a different approach, but (and here's the main problem I have) Jasmine sounds like she's trying to one-up Aladdin's performance which takes away from the romantic intentions of the scene. They needed to pick a lane. Go all out with power vocals for both characters, OR go with the more causal approach for both characters. It just doesn't feel like a love song anymore. >_>
no it’s better, he’s exited to show her the world and finally getting her out that palace while he’s exited the moment is happening. the vocals add to that. and their excited that their doing that together: way better then the original which has no flavor. pls look at the bright side of things.
@@theboricuaboy @1g0cr8zy8 I was looking at the bright side. They're both very talented and skilled performers. Either approach would have been a great cover of a beautiful song. But I'm also being realistic. Jasmine and Aladdin sound like they're singing two very different versions of the song. It's okay if you prefer the newer version, but I don't like it. I just see missed potential. 😔
I kinda disagree. Jasmine (the new version) was so happy that she finally see the world, she poured her emotions in the song, hence she was belting, to show how happy she was. It's still feel like a serenading song though, with Jasmine responding with enthusiasm
@@moreandmore7962 It's okay you feel that way. And I'm glad you like it. But for me, Aladdin and Jasmine were presented as equals from different walks of life in the original Disney version. They had a duet rather than a lead singer and supporting singer. This change demonstrates to me (along with other changes made) that Jasmine is the primary focus of the film, with Aladdin being recast as a supporting role. This is fine if the story were re-written to support this change, but it wasn't. This song just becomes another moment of Jasmine demonstrating that she's selfish even though the movie tries to say she isn't. But that's just my opinion. 🙄
i completely agree. Naomi is singing her heart out and Mena sounds like hes holding backs sometimes "dont-you-dare-close-your-eyes". and the way he says "decide" is kind flat, just because its different doesnt mean its better, idk why Audrey was so impressed. Mena is also competing with the added bass track. the music is so much more commanding in the remake, kinda drowns him out. other than that his singing is fine. for me, the context/visuals of the song (2019) is my biggest problem. 1992 aladdin forgot to be "Prince Ali" and was genuinely interacting with jasmine on the carpet. its where jasmine saw the real him. it was fake-confidence turned genuine. 2019 aladdin was fake-awkward turned confident. his "prince Ali" was awkward, but then he rolled up as aladdin like, "girl, ive got a magic carpet. let me show you a good time." and any interactions on the carpet were obscured by bad visuals (and Naomi being preoccupied with her song). And theyre not actually seeing the world. they just fly around Agrabah. all they really see is the desert and the river, and its too cloudy for an "endless diamond sky" which couldve been extra beautiful with cgi (imo).
Let's face the fact the old one is more magical specially in 'Unbelievable sights, Indescribable feeling Soaring, tumbling, freewheeling Through an endless diamond sky' it's so magical bro you feels you're part in the movie.
I sort of like how in the original they don’t blend super well? I think Aladdin makes sense as a more brash voice as he himself is pretending to be a prince, and Lea does a great job at adding a soft side to an otherwise angsty character.
One thing I found interesting was that in the animated original, Aladdin is showing Jasmine the world, while in the live action remake, Aladdin is showing Jasmine her home country.
Aladdin is my second favorite Disney animated film and I think Mena Massoud and Naomi Scott filled those shoes beautifully, especially Naomi. Her voice is so beautiful. I’d love to see more Aladdin stuff
I personally prefer the original, but then that probably is nostalgia playing a big part, as the animated Aladdin was the very first film I ever saw in the cinema! My Godmother took me for my birthday and I left the cinema absolutely in love with the film, with my Godmother buying me a sticker book of the story in the cinema lobby! I do feel that the newer version is all about "look how well I can sing" rather than focusing on the lyrics or the character development going on in the song. But I am biased. I can enjoy the newer version in a playlist of songs, but it can never replace the love I have for the original.
I didn't quite feel the same way about the live action version like the original animated song. Mostly because I'm not a huge fan of the instrumentals in the new one (despite the singing being almost just as good). The pure and light orchestral tones in the original make it more magical for me.
Aladdin is my favorite Disney movie, while "A whole new world" is my favorite somg from the movie😍. I prefer the original, because I think that their voices make the song more romantic, but the new version is good too!
It's funny that you talk about how deep the OG Aladdin's singing voice was, when Brad Kane (Aladdin's singing voice) was only 18-19 when the movie was being made and came out in 1992, and Lea Salonga, who did Jasmine's singing voice was 20-21.
Aladdin was the first movie i saw on theatres when i was a kid and the live action one has a lot o differences but i can asure you it made my memory fly. I was in love again with the movie and the moment.
The live action sounds a lot better than what I remember when I first saw it. I think the only thing that lessens it for me is the background and CGI are too dark and artificial. I don't feel like the characters are really flying in that environment.
it’s at night… and their in a place where city lights don’t exist cus it isn’t a city.. the CGI did look real, you try editing a hole movie like that and let’s see how you do since you like to critique. 🤷🏾♂️
@@theboricuaboy So I can only have an opinion on something if I've done it too? It's just an opinion. If you like this movie...fine. If you love the CGI... great. It is merely an opinion. Take a breath and like what you like, and let me do the same.
I was the magic carpet in my school play lol, thank god jasmine and Aladdin didn't have to sit on me, they were on this table that was covered in the same fabric my costume was made from and my teacher had me doing ballet during this song.
Both versions are great but the OG Animated version will always have the number 1 spot in my heart i grew up with it and the new version had to live up to the legacy and it sure did but OG for the W
Hi! This song is so beautiful! I remember watching the live action in theatres when it first came out, and I was obsessed! I was really sad to hear that Phantom of the Opera closed on Broadway recently, after 35 years...would you please consider doing more videos on Phantom? I loved the last 2. I first got introduced to Phantom during covid year and it introduced me to your amazing channel!
Aladdin is my all time fav movie after lion king....I can not wait until my daughter is older so we can sing together....my wife and I sing it to her now but I cannot wait until she is older.....best duet song period.....part of your world best solo ballad....tell me different....I loved Lea and Brad voices, and naomi and Mena did great as well 100%
Nothing compares to the original voices imo!l Edit: well when you put it back to back like this though… maybe it’s just the nostalgia that I like! 😂 😅❤
The original is unmistakably better because they have singers who are trained in their profession. This is what Disney deliberately does with these remakes: Uses them to cash in by coasting on the talent of the classics while NEVER outshining them ... or living up to them.
Exactly, they have professional singers doing the singing part and not actors with autotune. This is also the reason why I’m disappointed with beauty and the beast live action
I tend to be a purist when it comes to my Disney so I like the original better. Naomi was phenomenal tho. Speechless was a great addition to the movie.
The original is way better, in the new one they take away the little pauses that add mood to the scene like ‘don’t you dare close your eyes’. In the original she puts her hands over her eyes and the pause gives him a chance to open them back up for her. In the new one they’re just going down hill and he just says it like he just presumes she’s going to. It’s little details like that that take away chemistry between the characters and making them just read the lyrics and seem like they’re just going through the motions
I agree that Naomi kills the song. But I prefer Aladdin's deeper voice way more in the original animated film. It was so much richer. Clearly had more vocal training. The singer in the live action might have been playing the song safe to speak most of it lightly.
Original lends itself better. Animation is just far more full of life and fun and beauty, whereas the action is very dark, very bland, very little happening. They did try with the dolphins at the end but it was such little done. Also if I recall correctly (I only saw the remake once because it was so uninteresting to me) they travel the kingdom but nowhere else, whereas in the animated "show you the world" takes on a new meaning as they literally seem to travel different places, Greece, China, Egypt, etc. I like that take more, its more fantastical.
I much prefer the original. But I always like the originals over the new versions. Please react to be prepared from the animated lion king. One of the best Disney songs ever created. The vocals are so powerful.
Common.. . I'm a pinoy... And I love how Ms leah sang it.. . She's like day dreaming while singing.. But both version of the song is great.. . . The new one style is what we hear in todays most songs. .
Hey Audrey! Great reaction. Love both for different reasons. So good to be able to watch again. Back to Backstage soon. Thanks for doing this song! ~Gary
The guy who sings Aladdin's parts in the animated "Aladdin" was in BtVS as the character Tucker Wells and voiced Jonathan Levinson's songs in the BtVS episode "Superstar".
It felt as if you were criticizing the original for being “too Disney”, compared to the live-action movie. Which is baffling to me, as you’re watching a Disney movie. 🤨
You should hear the song Desert Moon. They recorded it but unfortunately did not include it in the new Aladdin film. Would LOVE to know your thoughts on it. 😄😄😄
I can’t compare them really, because sequence in original Aladdin is stuck in my memory core forever dew amazing animation, colors, song and just how it bring feels of soaring in the night full of stars on magic carpet. And then we have live action sequence, which is so bland boring shot, nothing interesting happens that we didn’t see and by the way, you can’t see barely anything because they figure its clever to use only moon lighting in this scene and magic is gone and even this iconic masterpiece song can’t bring the same feels. Ok. I’m annoyed again. Oh, those live actions 🙄 Actors are good cast tho. Two main characters anyway
Naomi is clearly the better vocalist between her and Mena. Plus she is well connected to Disney since she was in the DCOM Lemonade Mouth and had the best solo song on the soundtrack, “She’s So Gone”.
My favorite line in the new version is the harmony between Aladdin and Jasmine when Jasmine sings, "indescribable FEELING". In the original Aladdin does not sing a harmony with the word FEELING.
It can't be a Titanic reference since Aladdin came out first lol, maybe Titanic was making an Aladdin reference. I like the singing in the new one, obviously, but the visuals are AWFUL. It's so dark, you can't see anything. It's supposed to be a MAGIC CARPET RIDE and there's nothing magical about it because it's so dark. There's no real way to tell what new things Jasmine is even getting to see and you can barely even see their faces during this moment when they're supposed to be falling in love. For that reason I think the original is still better overall.
Hola, vídeo muy rico con muchas observaciones interesantes. Gracias! Sin dudas, creo que sea una excelente profe. Cuanto las versiones, creo que para un diseno , la version antigua es bíen apropriada y mas teatral, asi como la version para la película live action hizo un gran trabajo con esta increible y emocionante canción.
I haven’t been able to bring myself to watch the live action version because I love the original so much. This was my first time hearing the live action version of this song. I felt like I was being shouted at, not serenaded on a magical adventure. Jasmine drowns out Aladdin and their styles don’t match each other one bit. The beginning of the song sounded so 2 dimensional where the original was more rich. There is a huge nostalgia factor for me but I’m not just hating on the live action films. I actually liked some of the live action songs from Beauty and the Beast - different but still keeping to the spirit of the original. This one just totally missed the mark for me.
I think this is one of the only things I’ve disagreed with you on, the original was 100 times better in every way. The live action is good don’t get me wrong but it’s not a patch on the OG. robin Williams genie cants be beaten, will smith is awesome but is not on par with Williams. Singing voices sound better and nicer in the animated version.
The original one is better. It's not the nostalgia they simply did it better. The version at the end with Peebo Bryson and Regina King is also better. 🤷🏾♀️
Im not a music guy but it sounds like two singers in the original complimenting each other and in the new one the guy doesnt sound like hes a singer and she does. The music hides a lot of his flaws and it doesnt gel with jasmines performance
I’m not sure if u should keep using that as a Disney example Disney has changed so much over the years That hasn’t really been the Disney style for over a decade Audrey you should probably update how you view Disney’s style imo
My problem with this film is the lack of chemistry between the two actors. The movie as a whole fell flat for me. And I think the acting had a lot to do with it.
📌PATREON: Watch THE FULL MOVIE w/screen! Get EARLY ACCESS to videos!
👉bit.ly/ALADDINNEWWORLD2
To me, the original sounds more soft and romantic while the new version sounds more exciting and adventurous. I think they both work well personally.
Nope the new version is better
@@Keepgoing42lmao hell nah 😭
@@bummypolaris3035 i agree the new one better the original is and there voices in the original one blends way better
Which works with the concept of “a whole new world”
The only reason the old one sounds too 'disney' is because you grew up associating it with Disney.
Lea Salonga's voice is crystal clear and effortlessly beautiful without any autotune. She has tons of chemistry with the male singer here who I personally think sounds way better than the guy in the remake. The remake couple doesnt sound good together and it has autotune.
Yea the chemistry is better in the original. The dude in the remake is not as strong a singer and thus they tone him down in the mix compared to Naomi who is a strong singer.
and i watch the behind the scene of the original leah's voice is pure and with pronunciation of each word and they dont use auto tune so i agree with you completely
I prefer the original because I think it makes both of their voices just as good while the new one makes jasmines quite louder to be honest
cause its ...."contemporary"
I concur
Because she is a singer and Aladdin is not
@@arnav_gupta_1004 Exactly, he's not a great singer (and quite frankly not a great actor either. They might as well called the movie "Jasmine")
@@anthonyanderson9303 🤣🤣lol ......he was okay ..... But yes the movie should be called Jasmine and the geine : it's aladdinin time 🤯💀
I absolutely adore Naomi’s voice. The growth since lemonade mouth is astounding.
i love how magical the tones in the original.
I love both versions! Lea definitely has the more Disney princess sound, and Naomi has more of the pop sound, not so much head/falsetto/breathy sound that Lea had. But I love both just the same! The original animated, nothing beats an original, but live action is still awesome! The music is fire in both!
The major problem with the new version for me is that the tone was changed into a one-sided power balled or something. Aladdin is supposed to be serenading Jasmine. His part actually still sounds like it but with a different approach, but (and here's the main problem I have) Jasmine sounds like she's trying to one-up Aladdin's performance which takes away from the romantic intentions of the scene. They needed to pick a lane. Go all out with power vocals for both characters, OR go with the more causal approach for both characters. It just doesn't feel like a love song anymore. >_>
no it’s better, he’s exited to show her the world and finally getting her out that palace while he’s exited the moment is happening. the vocals add to that. and their excited that their doing that together: way better then the original which has no flavor. pls look at the bright side of things.
@@theboricuaboy @1g0cr8zy8 I was looking at the bright side. They're both very talented and skilled performers. Either approach would have been a great cover of a beautiful song. But I'm also being realistic. Jasmine and Aladdin sound like they're singing two very different versions of the song. It's okay if you prefer the newer version, but I don't like it. I just see missed potential. 😔
I kinda disagree. Jasmine (the new version) was so happy that she finally see the world, she poured her emotions in the song, hence she was belting, to show how happy she was. It's still feel like a serenading song though, with Jasmine responding with enthusiasm
@@moreandmore7962 It's okay you feel that way. And I'm glad you like it.
But for me, Aladdin and Jasmine were presented as equals from different walks of life in the original Disney version. They had a duet rather than a lead singer and supporting singer. This change demonstrates to me (along with other changes made) that Jasmine is the primary focus of the film, with Aladdin being recast as a supporting role. This is fine if the story were re-written to support this change, but it wasn't. This song just becomes another moment of Jasmine demonstrating that she's selfish even though the movie tries to say she isn't. But that's just my opinion. 🙄
i completely agree. Naomi is singing her heart out and Mena sounds like hes holding backs sometimes "dont-you-dare-close-your-eyes". and the way he says "decide" is kind flat, just because its different doesnt mean its better, idk why Audrey was so impressed. Mena is also competing with the added bass track. the music is so much more commanding in the remake, kinda drowns him out. other than that his singing is fine.
for me, the context/visuals of the song (2019) is my biggest problem.
1992 aladdin forgot to be "Prince Ali" and was genuinely interacting with jasmine on the carpet. its where jasmine saw the real him. it was fake-confidence turned genuine.
2019 aladdin was fake-awkward turned confident. his "prince Ali" was awkward, but then he rolled up as aladdin like, "girl, ive got a magic carpet. let me show you a good time." and any interactions on the carpet were obscured by bad visuals (and Naomi being preoccupied with her song). And theyre not actually seeing the world. they just fly around Agrabah. all they really see is the desert and the river, and its too cloudy for an "endless diamond sky" which couldve been extra beautiful with cgi (imo).
Let's face the fact the old one is more magical specially in 'Unbelievable sights, Indescribable feeling
Soaring, tumbling, freewheeling
Through an endless diamond sky' it's so magical bro you feels you're part in the movie.
I sort of like how in the original they don’t blend super well? I think Aladdin makes sense as a more brash voice as he himself is pretending to be a prince, and Lea does a great job at adding a soft side to an otherwise angsty character.
Also Titanic stole that move from Aladdin since Aladdin came out 6 years prior. 😂
I like the nostalgic one cause of how lea's voice is crystal clear and more Disney like
One thing I found interesting was that in the animated original, Aladdin is showing Jasmine the world, while in the live action remake, Aladdin is showing Jasmine her home country.
It’s actually wild to think Mena (Aladdin) had never sung before this and only got vocal training while making the movie.he sounds good
ehhh...he's okay at best.
Aladdin is my second favorite Disney animated film and I think Mena Massoud and Naomi Scott filled those shoes beautifully, especially Naomi. Her voice is so beautiful. I’d love to see more Aladdin stuff
I personally prefer the original, but then that probably is nostalgia playing a big part, as the animated Aladdin was the very first film I ever saw in the cinema! My Godmother took me for my birthday and I left the cinema absolutely in love with the film, with my Godmother buying me a sticker book of the story in the cinema lobby! I do feel that the newer version is all about "look how well I can sing" rather than focusing on the lyrics or the character development going on in the song. But I am biased. I can enjoy the newer version in a playlist of songs, but it can never replace the love I have for the original.
I didn't quite feel the same way about the live action version like the original animated song. Mostly because I'm not a huge fan of the instrumentals in the new one (despite the singing being almost just as good). The pure and light orchestral tones in the original make it more magical for me.
Aladdin is my favorite Disney movie, while "A whole new world" is my favorite somg from the movie😍. I prefer the original, because I think that their voices make the song more romantic, but the new version is good too!
It's funny that you talk about how deep the OG Aladdin's singing voice was, when Brad Kane (Aladdin's singing voice) was only 18-19 when the movie was being made and came out in 1992, and Lea Salonga, who did Jasmine's singing voice was 20-21.
I get that, but she's saying the composition of the song should have been different, instead of making him to sing it that way.
they really did pick the best people for Aladdin and jasmine
I think the older one showcased Aladdin’s voice more while the newer one main jasmines voice louder
Aladdin was the first movie i saw on theatres when i was a kid and the live action one has a lot o differences but i can asure you it made my memory fly. I was in love again with the movie and the moment.
I love the two versions from start to finish. Aladdin is the only liveaction that I came to love like the original.
I love this comparison format! You should definitely do more!
The live action sounds a lot better than what I remember when I first saw it. I think the only thing that lessens it for me is the background and CGI are too dark and artificial. I don't feel like the characters are really flying in that environment.
Cgi is artificial
No
Really
For real
@@madnessarcade7447 CGI didn't stop Star Wars, Harry Potter, Avatar, or Lord of the Rings from feeling immersive.
it’s at night… and their in a place where city lights don’t exist cus it isn’t a city.. the CGI did look real, you try editing a hole movie like that and let’s see how you do since you like to critique. 🤷🏾♂️
@@theboricuaboy So I can only have an opinion on something if I've done it too? It's just an opinion. If you like this movie...fine. If you love the CGI... great. It is merely an opinion. Take a breath and like what you like, and let me do the same.
I was the magic carpet in my school play lol, thank god jasmine and Aladdin didn't have to sit on me, they were on this table that was covered in the same fabric my costume was made from and my teacher had me doing ballet during this song.
Both versions are great but the OG Animated version will always have the number 1 spot in my heart i grew up with it and the new version had to live up to the legacy and it sure did but OG for the W
Hi! This song is so beautiful! I remember watching the live action in theatres when it first came out, and I was obsessed!
I was really sad to hear that Phantom of the Opera closed on Broadway recently, after 35 years...would you please consider doing more videos on Phantom? I loved the last 2. I first got introduced to Phantom during covid year and it introduced me to your amazing channel!
Ooh maybe some reactions to the Phantom 25th Anniversary recording? I'm down for anything that involves more Ramin, haha
Lol the "Titanic moment"... Titanic came out like 5 years after the animated Aladdin so technically Titanic stole the move from Disney 😅😂🤣.
Aladdin is my all time fav movie after lion king....I can not wait until my daughter is older so we can sing together....my wife and I sing it to her now but I cannot wait until she is older.....best duet song period.....part of your world best solo ballad....tell me different....I loved Lea and Brad voices, and naomi and Mena did great as well 100%
How come you still haven't watched it? I watched in 7 times in cinema, including 5 times Imax, it gives me the best satisfaction ever
Nothing compares to the original voices imo!l
Edit: well when you put it back to back like this though… maybe it’s just the nostalgia that I like! 😂 😅❤
its not nostalgia I've showed both to a younger family member and asked which they liked more and they said the animated version
The original is unmistakably better because they have singers who are trained in their profession. This is what Disney deliberately does with these remakes: Uses them to cash in by coasting on the talent of the classics while NEVER outshining them ... or living up to them.
Yepp, too much truth
Exactly, they have professional singers doing the singing part and not actors with autotune. This is also the reason why I’m disappointed with beauty and the beast live action
Sorry, but that take reeks of nostalgia. As someone who grew up with The Jungle Book and Aladdin...the live actions were just better
I tend to be a purist when it comes to my Disney so I like the original better. Naomi was phenomenal tho. Speechless was a great addition to the movie.
The original is way better, in the new one they take away the little pauses that add mood to the scene like ‘don’t you dare close your eyes’. In the original she puts her hands over her eyes and the pause gives him a chance to open them back up for her. In the new one they’re just going down hill and he just says it like he just presumes she’s going to. It’s little details like that that take away chemistry between the characters and making them just read the lyrics and seem like they’re just going through the motions
Both versions are awesome
I agree that Naomi kills the song. But I prefer Aladdin's deeper voice way more in the original animated film. It was so much richer. Clearly had more vocal training.
The singer in the live action might have been playing the song safe to speak most of it lightly.
Naomi's voice is a bit deep i thought she is a male the first time she sang her part..😂😂😂
This is my favorite Live action Disney movie.
I'd love to see you react to Nick Pitera's rendition of the Aladdin medley. He is definitely worth watching!! So good! ♥️
Definitely!!!!
Original lends itself better. Animation is just far more full of life and fun and beauty, whereas the action is very dark, very bland, very little happening. They did try with the dolphins at the end but it was such little done. Also if I recall correctly (I only saw the remake once because it was so uninteresting to me) they travel the kingdom but nowhere else, whereas in the animated "show you the world" takes on a new meaning as they literally seem to travel different places, Greece, China, Egypt, etc. I like that take more, its more fantastical.
I much prefer the original. But I always like the originals over the new versions. Please react to be prepared from the animated lion king. One of the best Disney songs ever created. The vocals are so powerful.
Naomi’s voice!!!🔥🔥🔥
Btw in the live action I love their chemistry.
I like the old version better
Common.. . I'm a pinoy... And I love how Ms leah sang it.. . She's like day dreaming while singing.. But both version of the song is great.. . . The new one style is what we hear in todays most songs. .
Personally, I love the old one for sounding cuter and the new one for sounding more powerful.
Hey Audrey! Great reaction. Love both for different reasons. So good to be able to watch again. Back to Backstage soon. Thanks for doing this song! ~Gary
The guy who sings Aladdin's parts in the animated "Aladdin" was in BtVS as the character Tucker Wells and voiced Jonathan Levinson's songs in the BtVS episode "Superstar".
Nobody sings better than Lea.
I love both version but naomi has my heart!
Lea's voice is so high and she effortlessly delivers it..
It felt as if you were criticizing the original for being “too Disney”, compared to the live-action movie. Which is baffling to me, as you’re watching a Disney movie. 🤨
I don't think the new version holds a candle to the original. Original Aladdin was WAY better.
You should hear the song Desert Moon. They recorded it but unfortunately did not include it in the new Aladdin film. Would LOVE to know your thoughts on it. 😄😄😄
The original is so much better I think, the instruméntala are better in the new but the original voices are so much better❤
The voice of Aladdin sounds different because the voice actor lied about being able to sing so they had to get a separate singing voice for him.
Brad Kane ❤
Animated or live?
@@leanaschnoor9072 animated
@@leanaschnoor9072 Animated
That’s hilarious actually
Animated > Live Action. Always.
Interesting that you call it a "Titanic moment" - because Aladdin came out 5 years BEFORE Titanic.
Can we like both not everything has to be a competition
I prefer the original. I dont hate the live action but the original cartoon singing was always better in my opinion.
Leah's voice is magical suited to her character
I can’t compare them really, because sequence in original Aladdin is stuck in my memory core forever dew amazing animation, colors, song and just how it bring feels of soaring in the night full of stars on magic carpet. And then we have live action sequence, which is so bland boring shot, nothing interesting happens that we didn’t see and by the way, you can’t see barely anything because they figure its clever to use only moon lighting in this scene and magic is gone and even this iconic masterpiece song can’t bring the same feels. Ok. I’m annoyed again. Oh, those live actions 🙄 Actors are good cast tho. Two main characters anyway
Watching the teens sing in the studio video was amazing!
The live action version sounds slowerer, looks darker, and just seems more boring of a magic carpet ride than the animated version.
Izzy Mccalla was Jasmine for the tour (also Alyssa Greene in The Prom) she’s fantastic.
Where is "a whole new world" which Naomi sings live? I do not find it. Lea sings it live as good as the recorded version.
Naomi is clearly the better vocalist between her and Mena. Plus she is well connected to Disney since she was in the DCOM Lemonade Mouth and had the best solo song on the soundtrack, “She’s So Gone”.
I think Animated Aladdin’s voice is better but Naomi did amazing with Jasmine, I think she slightly surpassed the animated Jasmine.
I still love the original song.
I didnt expect for a vocal coach to prefer heavily autotuned singing. 😅
My name same movie! I love both the new and the old version of this song love it love it!
It was hard back then when the actors and singers were two different people
My favorite line in the new version is the harmony between Aladdin and Jasmine when Jasmine sings, "indescribable FEELING". In the original Aladdin does not sing a harmony with the word FEELING.
I like both versions
@04:50 ALADDIN (1992) came out 5 years before TITANIC (1997)
In the original, the speaking voices are different actors than the singing ones. That's why they sound odd.
The original Aladdin is Scott weinger
But the singing voice is Brad Kane
It can't be a Titanic reference since Aladdin came out first lol, maybe Titanic was making an Aladdin reference.
I like the singing in the new one, obviously, but the visuals are AWFUL. It's so dark, you can't see anything. It's supposed to be a MAGIC CARPET RIDE and there's nothing magical about it because it's so dark. There's no real way to tell what new things Jasmine is even getting to see and you can barely even see their faces during this moment when they're supposed to be falling in love. For that reason I think the original is still better overall.
Hola, vídeo muy rico con muchas observaciones interesantes. Gracias! Sin dudas, creo que sea una excelente profe. Cuanto las versiones, creo que para un diseno , la version antigua es bíen apropriada y mas teatral, asi como la version para la película live action hizo un gran trabajo con esta increible y emocionante canción.
I haven’t been able to bring myself to watch the live action version because I love the original so much. This was my first time hearing the live action version of this song. I felt like I was being shouted at, not serenaded on a magical adventure. Jasmine drowns out Aladdin and their styles don’t match each other one bit. The beginning of the song sounded so 2 dimensional where the original was more rich.
There is a huge nostalgia factor for me but I’m not just hating on the live action films. I actually liked some of the live action songs from Beauty and the Beast - different but still keeping to the spirit of the original. This one just totally missed the mark for me.
I think this is one of the only things I’ve disagreed with you on, the original was 100 times better in every way. The live action is good don’t get me wrong but it’s not a patch on the OG. robin Williams genie cants be beaten, will smith is awesome but is not on par with Williams. Singing voices sound better and nicer in the animated version.
you should do the Zayn version too
It's nice for Naomi scott to give her backup singer a moment to shine
There is no comparison to Lea Solange . She's a legend. Period.
The original one is better. It's not the nostalgia they simply did it better. The version at the end with Peebo Bryson and Regina King is also better. 🤷🏾♀️
I'm 36, I prefer the original. However, both of these wonderful actor/actress did a beautiful job.
You should react to songs from epic the musical! They are seriously talented and i think you’d enjoy hearing it!!
Keep it up baby 😊
I like Aladdin’s voice more in the original. It’s very charming. But Jasmine sounds great in both, I can’t choose
I prefer the original.
Im not a music guy but it sounds like two singers in the original complimenting each other and in the new one the guy doesnt sound like hes a singer and she does. The music hides a lot of his flaws and it doesnt gel with jasmines performance
Nothing will compare to the original the remake is 100% more edited and layered and is obvious
Awww man you tell Steve from Full House. You are right though.
I’m not sure if u should keep using that as a Disney example Disney has changed so much over the years
That hasn’t really been the Disney style for over a decade
Audrey you should probably update how you view Disney’s style imo
Please I need a HSM 2 reaction 🥰
My problem with this film is the lack of chemistry between the two actors. The movie as a whole fell flat for me. And I think the acting had a lot to do with it.
In case anyone didn’t know the voice actor for the animated movie couldn’t sing so they had someone sing his parts
There's a video of the recording session for the animated version:
th-cam.com/video/pi_Ocd9IALc/w-d-xo.html
That’s magical, I felt like I was flying with them
I like the live action version better. Something about it just gives me chills every time. I do love the cartoon too though.
Yeah me too but I’m afraid to say that 😅
have to say the original is way better for me. new one lacks heart to me.
Original all day erry day
I like the Original Better than the live action because the Original Sounded more Romantic and happy also I just looks and sounds just way better