Ranveer Allahbadia’s Controversial Comments | Censorship vs Free Speech | Faye's Take
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.พ. 2025
- Ranveer Allahbadia (BeerBiceps) has found himself in hot water after a shocking clip from his podcast surfaced online, triggering widespread outrage. His remarks, deemed voyeuristic and inappropriate, have led to a heated debate on the ethics of content creation, censorship, and freedom of expression.
In this video, Faye D’Souza discusses the responsibilities of social media influencers, and examines whether censorship is the solution or if open conversations are necessary.
What do you think? Should influencers be held accountable for their content, or is this a case of overreaction? Let us know in the comments.
🔔 Subscribe for more updates on media ethics, journalism, and current affairs!
#RanveerAllahbadia #BeerBiceps #FayeDSouza #FreedomOfSpeech #Controversy #ranveerallahbadia #beerbiceps #podcastcontroversy #socialmediaethics #contentcreation #mediaresponsibility #freedomofspeech #cancelculture #influenceraccountability #digitalmedia #contentethics #onlinebacklash #internetculture #podcastdrama #controversialstatements #publicoutrage #viralclip #socialmediadebate #criticalthinking #fayedsouza
Join my channel to get access to perks:
/ @fayedsouza
For more news and updates, download the Beatroot News App:
www.beatrootne...
Follow Faye D’Souza on Social Media
Instagram: / fayedsouza
Twitter: / fayedsouza
Facebook: / fayedsouzaofficial
![[Live] : ONE FIGHT NIGHT 28 วันนี้!! "พระจันทร์ฉาย vs เอลลิส"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LfImEQqfARc/mqdefault.jpg)
So well said. Decency is not being valued anymore.
in a country where there is no safety for women, rapists and murders walk freely, ppl really shouldnt be getting offended by an incest joke lol.
1. Air Quality at all time low
2. Water Quality at all time low
3. Rupee at all time low
4. Sensex also getting there
5. Our youth getting deported in a manner that is humiliating
6. Inflation at all time high
7. Unemployment at all time high
8. Infrastructure sucks and dusty roads (Personally vouching for Mumbai and Thane)
We are breathing poison, drinking something that resembles a poison.
Our media and politicians prioritize some "India's Got Latent" with the kind of urgency the above issues, especially of toxic air needs to be addressed.
Ofcourse, no short term incentives in solving those, it will take 10 to 15 years to see some tangible improvement.
Mera bharat mahaan. get well soon, India🌹
Sensex also getting there?😂 Our Youth? Bhai Illegal Immigrants hai wo Like Rohingyas. Unko ab Garlanding karke welcome kare? Inflation all time high? Inflation gone 10%+ for 3 times in UPA era. You need to study more than Just Blindly Hating. Aise Criticism karoge toh kaun sunega bhai tumhari. Atleast research karke aao bhai.
Are you high on something? How else should you treat illegal immigrants?
@@nikhilbhute07why do you even care to comment on half baked knowledge ppl 😂
I watch a lot of American stand up and you can see that they say a lot of things which many find icky. Watching parents doing it? Possibly. Joining in the said activity? NO. Jokes about r* pe and pedophelia? NO. So Western stand ups self censor and I expect this Alhabadi guy to do the same. On his channel someone mocked Deepika Padukone's depression. Now Meghan Markle has also claimed depression and suicide ideation. Many contest that but I haven't seen jokes by stand ups about either her depression or suicide ideation. Why? There's plenty to satirise about Markle without going into grey areas.
Oh you haven't watched the peak of US comedy , some have even made fun of nine 11. Only those societies which give its people freedom succeed in the long run. Giving more attention to what people say in a humour show rather than focusing on other core issues is tomfoolery @@cinnow
People have a lot of free time in India.
Like u
Tbh this is a non issue compared to the actual issues plaguing our country like air quality, education, economy.
But Ranveer pretends to be this ideal spiritual hindu podcaster while making jokes like these.
He'll shouldn't go to jail for this but he'll have a tough time recovering from this publically.
@@HarshvardhanKanthode the video was uploaded as appropriate for all age groups including children! Against TH-cam policy, come s*ck my d*ck was sexually explicit and outraging the modesty of that woman who was asked so, it was incestuous! Sexual assault exploitation and rape are key issues plaguing India! They, samqy and rqnveer have committed crime will face the consequences of law
@@HarshvardhanKanthode no bro its very important to teach them a lesson once
So they don't cross their limits again
@@HarshvardhanKanthode this is the only valid response
People should think before speaking on a public platform.
Our politicians too do the same. Have been watching this kind filth exchanged, name calling, humiliations by anchors, politicians, etc.
Yes moral responsibility and etiquette is required. Action to control these outbursts are required for all equally.
I have a 12 year old, I have seen their friends... they are truly impressionable at that age. We can say that if you dont like it don't watch it, but who will teach children what is right and what is wrong. We have an active discussion scene at home about everything, what is right, and what is wrong. What is acceptable and what can not be normalized. With content like this, it's just a lot of work for the parents on an everyday basis. What about those children whose parents are not that involved and can get access to such crass content?
There's hundreds of things over the internet that can have a bad influence on children. It ultimately is the parents' responsibility to monitor what the child is consuming. Apps like yt kids can help.
This is quite embarrassing for a parent to be saying this. Is it a comedians responsibility to be raising your 12 year old? If your child at this age can access such material under your guidance then you have failed as a parent. You might be shocked to know that this show is not worst thing on the internet. “Who will teach what is right or wrong?” Its YOU the parent that’s solely responsible. If this is “alot” of work for you well then i hold your hand when i say this…you’re not ready to be parent. Imagine not being able to guide your kid to watch age appropriate stuff but expecting a young comedian to do this for you. Lady gone are the days when all you had was doordarshan, smarten up and move with the times.
Social media is so bad these days. Better keep kids away
Nobody tried to save us from those famous daily soap operas, nobody is saving us from the current prime time "News" shows.
Our leaders are not even saving us from pollution and global warming but SaNsKaR gALaT nA pAd JaYE bachcho mein.
Try to inculcate critical thinking, rest will take care of itself.
What makes you think your kids aren’t one touch away from much worse things
I dont get the outrage over this joke just because it involved parents sex lives, i constantly hear people call each other mc/bc all the time, are those insults towards our mother and sisters on a daily constant basis also not just as vulgar? What makes this worse than that
So with your logic I can assume you agree to what he said and similar content, They are Influencers, would you allow your kids to get into such content?Using abusive language and creating a content based on incest , promoting suicide and murder are things libreds like yourself want to promote.
@@dhirajshetty6385 Or, u could get equally outraged about people calling each other MC/BC.
@@dhirajshetty6385 u clearly didnt understand what i said, and though im no "libred" atleast i am not whatever the hell u are
@@dhirajshetty6385 we use abusive language on regualr basis, children learn it from their adults, we learn it from our movies , we pay to watch celebrities wearing bikini etc, such conent has been going around for decades, i personally feel this is a distraction, to keep us looking in one direction while something else is happening somewhere else
@@dhirajshetty6385 man it's not about liberals or right anymore, it's about consistency whichever wing they are in, so called conservative trump publicized his wife's nudes and his followers not only american guys but folks including indian followers see him as a father figure and same indian trads who worship trump are loosing their shit over ranveer's statement, these so called indian trads who eulogize trump also look other way when trumpians like milo yiolopolous made similar statements like ranveer, now coming to indian left/liberals who are enjoying the "cheerharan of trads", these same indian liberal were suffering fevicol syndrome when mahua moitra showed her middle finger to arnab had it been vice versa all hell would have broken loose on arnab or any other male guy if he were to show a middle finger to a female panelist, so all in all don't take politics seriously, instead focus on behind the scenes, focus on whether these controversies are natural or artificial.
Responsibility and Samay Raina don't ever go with hand in hand.
He is Man Child whom everyone is hyping up for his own Downfall in reality too as Human
Chappriyon ka sardar
Samay Raina is not responsible for a joke made by someone in internet ,
@@Neelinmact He is the owner of the channel. He could have easily cut that part out. So yeah, he is equally responsible.
@ yeah he should have done that but I guess he thought that if Jimmy Carr can make that joke and put it in a public platform then why should he censor it , I guess he forgot where he lived
“There’s no incentive for decency” 💯
Freedom of speech must be used responsibly. It cannot hamper morality and decency.
Freedom of speech should be ammended
Their should be some rules what we can say what not
@@Aryanrajput-t5s That's already the case. The right to freedom of speech act was amended by Nehru just 1 or 2 years after the Constitution was adopted, and "reasonable restrictions" were added. These "reasonable restrictions" have been weaponized to imprison innocent people and people with political ideologies that don't align with the regime. For example, Nehru had jailed a very famous poet under these same "reasonable restrictions" simply because he'd written a poem which criticized Nehru.
if you don'tlike it, don't watch it
Who decides morality and decency? Because there are people who find even the most mundane condom ad indecent and immoral.
Define Morality
We as a society and young adults really need to be aware of what we are watching and normalising.
Lets normalize
in a country where there is no safety for women, rapists and murders walk freely, ppl really shouldnt be getting offended by an incest joke lol. rape is normalised in this country, is that ok?
It was stupid of Samay to not make it 18+
It was a member only video though
it was stupid and like Faye rightly said, highly indecent of him to even laugh and normalise that joke
Still doesn't make sense of the things he mentioned.
Lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 usse kya hota ?
Uska core fanbase hi 18 years ke age ke niche waale hai. Warna kaun dekhega yeh kachra woh bhi paisa de ke
Swami Vivekananda once said when something is lost nothing is lost but when Character is lost everything is lost
Did he say this before or after having sex with his parents ?
Yeah but I doubt he said all this in this context 🤣🤣 Character character kar kar ke gareeb hi reh liya country
@@jamaicansonnets1560Garib rehna pasad ha tumahre tahra faltu jam karne ka paisa kamane se accha.
He shown his real skin .
His skin was visible from the beginning. People were too blind to see it.
People NAHI Modiji rewarded such vulgar influencers.@@pranavchaudhari5828
He's incest btw
He had said this earlier
But that clip was removed
App bhi dikha do bihari
Bro talk about sex is bad . But insisting rape on girls. Hindu Muslim hate by news channel. What the fuck ، actually these news channel are dangerous. It destroy a whole society and it's life completely. Talk shit is not bad , doing shit is bad . What the samay Rayna man did was not acceptable and he must appoligize from his parents and from his followers and no other then that . But those people who are today talking about him was once spreading hate against minorities which always results in shaming, racism and lynching . 😢😢😢😢
Freedom of speech should be available to everyone. It cannot be that the politicians can utter any nonsense, even in parliament but others stand the risk of prosecution.
They are made responsible so stop talking nonsense
@@sb853547 Where are they made responsible? The son of Tamil Nadu's Chief Minister literally called Sanatan Dharma dengue and malaria and publicly made calls for a Hindu genocide. Rahul Gandhi insulted Shiv Bhagawan and called all Hindus in this country "extremists" on the literal floor of the Parliament. Avadesh Prasad of the Samajwadi Party calls himself the Emperor of Ayodhya, Ayodhya Naresh in his own words (which he is not, only Bhagwan Ram is the Naresh of Ayodhya) after he defeated the BJP on that Lok Sabha seat in the 2024 general elections. All of these are extremely serious offences and literally nothing has happened to them. It seems only all the rules are regulations exist only for the common man. Politicians, especially the leftist politicians have always been kept above the law by our Nehruvian "Socialist Secular" system. Fuck that.
@sb853547 how are they made responsible?
@@SilentTraveller21 they are held accountable every 5 years during elections. That Bidhuri guy who used crass language didn’t get elected even during BJP wave. Absolute freedom of expression is necessary in parliament otherwise tyranny of executive will destroy what little is left of our institutions.
@@ExquisiteKorpseoh shut up.
❤ you are wonderful Faye. Thank you. Thank you.
Agree with freedom of speech and that the problem lies with these “influencers”. They’ve forgotten it all and just destroying freedom for others, for people who may speak sense, for the real activists and critics as well…
But they aren’t activists. They are comedians and the theme is dark humour. Why are you looking at them from the lens of an activist ?
I am a Absolutist when it comes to FOS..Pushing morality is nobodies duty..Although I consider everything that Samay Raina and BEER guy does as cringe,I still do not think its governments business.Actually this is exactly what the state want.Public talking about stupid non important issue and fight over it.I think this issue gives them the perfect stage to bring a law that will affect everyone..So wake up
Sadly majority of the people will favour "regulation". In the long run this leads to mediocrity in every sphere- from creative to scientific.
yeah , raucous jokes and judging people ( especially men 's ) masculinity on the basis of how many women these have pursued or copulated with ?? Yeah thanks degenerate 😂😂😂😂
I agree. This deserves a societal reaction, not a legal one. Society should collectively get together and boycott that pos, there's no need to criminalize speech though.
Very interesting take. Thanks for sharing this .
This type of content shapes the psychology of the vulnerable who are prone to participate in the actions being discussed giving rise to criminal mentality so I believe it IS an issue that needs to be addressed much as other major concerns in our society.
The show and their content being heavily criticized is great and is what we need, but people asking for police complaints and politicians being involved is just as embarrassing. We need to learn to filter and criticize the low tier content we get without getting as touchy as we do.
1. India is YOUNG. The YOUTH mostly doesn't know what not to consume. They WILL watch it because they will like this garbage. Good food is often unexciting. Junk is often tasty. Dontlikeitdontwatchit is such a poor and unthought through argument in this context.
Great point
People will consume what they like. Just because you don't like it doesn't make it junk.
@ People watch what gets made. They like or dislike later. Quality consciousness comes from consuming high end content. It’s not about freedom. It’s about standards.
Really ? People watch all the content in the world being made ? Stop talking nonsense. Nobody needs to watch this content if they don't want to.
Especially considering its behind a paywall. People are paying for that content so you are not in a position to set the standards.
Don't like it ? Don't pay for it and watch it.
@ Yes people watch content that’s available. You eat what’s available. You drink what’s available. It’s a simple idea. You can’t consume what’s not in supply Sammy shit Raina shouldn’t be in supply. End of story.
yeah, well said Faye. was speaking to my mother the other day - was telling her that for a country like india, where the internet is pretty much unrestricted and wrong-doers mostly go unpunished, the internet is a far bigger bane than it is a boon. india isn't a country that can handle their rights coz most people don't remember their duties/ responsibilities. who we are, as a people - those who love to create filth and consume filth. that's the sorry state of affairs (and yes there are exceptions, but those are the minority)
@@Juss169 it’s probably the same in america and Britain as this joke was made by Jimmy Carr , i wonder if he has created a society of perverted monsters by making such a joke ? We indians should definitely avoid travelling to such countries with decadent societies 😅 , ours is quite closer to pak afg where such jokes would get similar reaction
@@Neelinmact this is the standard excuse i've seen when anything bad happens in india - oh it also happens in xyz countries. it's like saying 'so what if i murdered one person? the neighbour murdered two people'. really unacceptable excuse and if indians have any self respect, they'll introspect as indiciduals and as a society instead of singing about what happens in new york or london or saudi arabia
No one ever got outraged by Parliamentarians and prime time tv debates using derogatory language
Yes we do. We do get outraged. Whataboutary isn't logic. Both are equally unacceptable.
@@mainmain5303exactly exactly.. I wanted to say same 🫡
Yes it has happened. Also, the comments are about parents and sex
You are right. Such debates are also condemnable.
However, chances of those speeches reaching teenagers/kids is very less compared to the videos of these famous influencers.
Please watch here.. @7:40
Who said we don't...we do and we should...the amount of Hate Speech went around is disgusting
Really well put... Something to ponder about for all of us... Thanks Faye.. You never fail to live up to your high standards of journlism... A rarity in today's society...
Very good insight!!! Decency has no incentive today!! Question is how do you form laws that doesn’t look draconian in a society that has made vulgar comments a regular phenomenon and more importantly how do you ensure government machineries not taking advantage to quell freedom of expression by formulating laws siting these examples.
in a country where there is no safety for women, rapists and murders walk freely, ppl really shouldnt be getting offended by an incest joke lol.
The freedom of speech is a fundamental right but it’s always outweighed over the fundamental responsibilities. Sigh creators of liberal arts forget their responsibilities not just legally but also socially. They are either driven by profit incentives or with a moto of generalisation of likewise mindset. Personally I’ve heard majority of my friends watch his show and that’s their freedom to watch anything but it’s also the moral responsibility of such “influencers” to actually supplement a positive impact to the viewer along with entertainment, crossing the limits of decency in the name of freedom is just diabolical.
MIB should take actions, not to harm anyone’s freedom but to tech a lesson of responsibility to such filthy creators.
Distraction from Manipur. CM Biren Singh has finally resigned after 21 months of crisis.
I hope not...if samay is working hand in gloves with digusting politicians now he is doomed....he definitely earning brownie point by playing kashmir card
@@SmilenJoy007 "Kashmir card" man the Internet has some genuinely disgusting people holy shit.
Only took him 21 months to acknowledge his incompetency. He deserves an applause 👏
Popular content reflects people's choices-if garbage content gets views, creators will keep making it. The real issue isn’t just TH-cam but the country’s broader lack of discipline-poor civic sense, disregard for rules, and hypocrisy of it all. People complain about online trash but ignore the literal garbage on the streets. At least a bad video can be turned off, but stepping outside means facing a mess with no escape. The country needs strict enforcement, heavy fines, and zero tolerance for civic disruptions.
Freedom of speech that should be used responsibly...
What a beautiful episode hope each influencer watches this.
Just for your argument on content available to non adults. Maybe you want to check that this is a members only episode so it is behind a paywall ideally not accessible to non adults. Some of the clips have been made viral on non official accounts. I may be wrong but you can verify that. Thank you.
So what?? It's still disgusting
@sb853547 agreed. My point was only on what I have mentioned about content availability.
So what a child cannot get paid content. Do you think so.
No. You are absolutely wrong. All his videos on IGL can be watched free without any membership by anyone.
I think I saw the exact same question/joke on Yeahmad's OG crew which is now a popular TH-cam Australian comedy show. Literally, no one gave a sh*t. Life moves on in Australia as well as other countries consuming the content. And no, I don't think people from those countries can be labeled as degenerate.
India's got latent is not meant for kids and it's their parent's responsibility to monitor the content they consume.
You forgot cultural differences. Decency varies on the culture of the land. Just because in the west somethings are OK doesn't mean it automatically becomes OK in the east. There are a lot of things to learn from the west, not this filth. Stop this insecure mindset that you see Western nations as a benchmark on what should be considered normal and what's not. West itself have become modest compared to 70s and 80s. Does that mean they are backsliding or what?
@@mandokiin-k9h Cultures exist but they are not static. Cultures evolve over time, and nothing is set in stone. That being said, I did not like the content. It was cringe and pretty sick to talk about. However, the level of outrage over this is ridiculous. Demanding heavy censorship of media or filing charges undermines the maturity and self-control of adult Indians. Are we suggesting that Indians lack the ability to think critically for themselves? It's time to grow up. Vulgar jokes exist globally, not just in the West. Take it or leave it. We have far more pressing issues to fix in this country. Also, I’m unsure what data you have to support that the West are becoming more modest. And what aspect of modesty you are referring to as well.
@@rohitvaishnav25 "cultures evolve over time" evolve is not the word, it's the change. Making an incest joke freely and society happily normalizing it isn't "evolution" it's just change. About modesty I'm talking about media and films which had more liberty in 70s, 80 and even 90s, now immediately gets cancelled because of wokeness. In Hollywood there are popular actors who view nudity as a bad trait because it objectifies woman! That's why I said there is no such thing as "evolve" it's only change not necessarily good or bad. Things must be respected based on majority views of the land, culture which they belong.
This is filth. Should b stopped immediately
What about the filth of untouchability... by upar kast Aryan invaders.. 😅
@sumitarai6243 Freedom of speech. You should get to decide what filth is and what it is not.
"If you don't like it, don't watch it."... is a valid and just argument.
1. The episode was Members only.
2. One needs to understand the context to get the jokes.
3. Yes the jokes are crass and abusive, but it is also a genre and is a part of dark comedy.
4. Samay didn't ask you to watch his show. If you don't have the kind of taste. Stay away from it.
5. If your child gets affected by the show, then teach your kids. You can't expect the whole world to straighten themselves up, as per your whims and fancies.
6. Samay's show is popular because it cracks jokes on things we all crack up or enjoy behind the closed doors. Now if your own acts are vulgar then you and your society needs to discipline themselves, not Samay or his shows.
As an absolutist, I Support Samay and his Show. It's a great show and is really funny.
Bhai bolne mey vi sharam ati hey
Nhi chahiye iss desh ko dark humour tu chalaga western desh
@ShivanandaNayak-i2u Tumhe nahi chahiye, to koi bola nahi hai dekhne ko.
Mat dekho.
Bahut se logo ko pasand hai, wo to dekhenge.
Bahot se logo ko Big Boss pasand hai, bahuto ko nahi. Par jinhe nahi pasand wo usey ban ya western nation nahi bhejne ki baat karte ya dekhne walo ki parvarish par question nahi raise karte.
Kisi ko force nahi kiya gya India's Got Latent dekhne ko. Show ka format aisa hai, to show bhi aisa hi rhega. Roasting mein gaaliya hoti hai. Format hi wahi hai. Nahi pasand hai to mat dekho.
Simple. India mein Dictatorship nahi hai jo kisi ko roka jayega show dekhne se.
I always had an opinion about him, now it's evident!
True
I never like any of them including that carryminati
So did I...I always knew there's a demon behind his podcasts with all the astrologers, etc....he needs to be taught a lesson...the hard way!
@@talkingtochapri wo.itna aage ka kuch nai bolega
“With great power comes great responsibility.”
-uncle Ben.
we should be ashamed of ourselves!! They must be held accountable...else it will only spur more such vulgar content!!
Free speech, freedom of speech, freedom of expression comes with responsibilities. Boundaries are being pushed someone rightly said ‘If you want to destroy any nation without war, just normalise nudity and adultery to the youth’, we are witnessing it.
The country with kamasutra has a problem with nudity ? Or maybe it was when outside influence came and interfered with the societal fabric.
@ O you think all nudity is same? That’s what I thought. Simpleton. News for you: There’s tasteful nudity and there’s vulgar nudity. The difference is in tone context intent. What’s the tone context and intent of Samay shitbag?
@ The Kamasutra and other ancient texts reflect an era when sensuality was viewed as a natural and integral part of life. However, societal norms change over time due to various influences, including colonial rule, socio-political shifts, and cultural evolution. So, while historical India had a different outlook, modern India has developed its own set of norms regarding nudity and modesty.
Today’s youth are more impressionable and easily influenced compared to earlier generations, who were more grounded in moral values. In contrast, the youth of that era, despite being exposed to texts like the Kamasutra, had a deeper understanding of sensuality within a structured moral and cultural framework, rather than being led astray by external influences.
@@imanmalik5631 Due to various influence like abrahamic religions forcing their view point on indians ?
@imanmalik5631 freedom of speech with boundaries is not really freedom of speech.
4:20 It was ‘a members only content’, not a publicly available video. People have to pay for it, in order to get access to that video. Please correct it.
Brother only a few videos are members only featuring raftaar and all. This video wasn’t. Please correct yourself first
No it was
@roohanshrana43 I had to renew my subscription just to watch this episode. it was a copy of a ‘would you rather’ joke from ‘an Aussie podcast’ 🤦🏻♂️
@@Vishal-Is this Australia?
@@DarkNight-w4m no, ‘Australia’ has a per capita of 61340.71 USD and india has a per capita of $2,940 because they don’t have misplaced priorities.
This guy has even received an award from our PM. Maybe it’s deliberate. Govt needed a reason to pass laws to gain control.
The awards from PM were given to people who got voted maximum in that category. It was not PM's choice of any committee's choice. So we should stop blaming PM, it's we who voted for these people to be awarded.
@@joysonb1 nooo that's not the case
@@arunakalyango n check modis comment and second he is hidden bjp it cell member
wow, what a twisted logic, kaam nahi hein govt ko?
@SudheendraRao26 ha hai for the longest time MIB IS TRYING TO CRUSH INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM, THIS THING WILL GIVE THEM THE MOMENTUM
Yes hold these men responsible but first and foremost when will we hold politicians responsible on their comments about women,rape,etc which is a bigger problem
We as a nation seem to have lost our soul...
when people lose their moral courage, the evils take over.
True, that's why we elected same PM for 3rd consecutive times.
@@Gaurav.P0tumse se to accha hai😂
But that was a great question to trigger people! Loved it! ❤ sorry for Ranveer that tarak mehta audience is also watching latent.
A FILM has "characters". Just because there's a killer in the film, doesn't mean the film is normalising killing. What braindead conversation is this!
Seriously dude bas teri hi kami thi yahan pe. Example toh sahi de de
@ Yeah? Faye talks about films and freedom of speech. It’s not relevant. If you don’t get it, the you don’t get it. Films Are not the right parallel to junk TH-cam content because films are enactments through characters.
👌👍
And such maturity comes with age..
Bro , jo bhi hua hai real life mein hua hai so your comment is absolutely irrelevant here !!
@@SwarajBawankar My comment is reaction to this video where Faye talks about films. Watch the full video. Why are you so confident and confused?
I believe no law was broken. Some unruly and immoral things were spoken. But that is all. People have to log in to this to watch it. It is their choice to continue to watch. And when it comes to children, it is a good reminder to all the parents to talk to their kids and speak and assess what are the right and wrongs of the content of any video. Because internet is a big pool, we can flag these videos but something or the other will pop in, may be from international content creators. We can't switch off. We need to educate.
Absolutely!
Technically speaking, there ARE laws in place that are meant to penalize speech deemed "vulgar" or "outraging modesty", but they're old archaic laws that belong in the bin. But yeah I agree with you.
And it was a Members only Episode. Soo people willingly watch that type of content and paying for it.
What he did was very wrong but he has apologised for it and owned it.There are worse things that happen in the country and no action is taken.The content on AIB wasnt civil either , not defending Ranveer but we are humans and we can make mistakes and blunders.As a nation I don’t think we should be focusing so much on this , can we please focus on the air quality instead.We are all being posioned and I don’t see people make a hue and cry about that as much as this incident today.
Why was the comedian who also made vulgar jokes on hindoo diety , some time ago not arrested and no backlash on him , as is being done now ??
Faye....this was enlightening.....even though I never seen the aforementioned show and also not a fan of Samay raina and his " dark comedy". And I do miss Doordarshan days...life was simple and every form of entertainment on DD was of quality , within moderation, no vulgarity , no excess of anything.Used to wait for the show or movie for a week but that wait felt worthwhile. May be I am being nostalgic being a millennial....I don't know.
Totally agree with views stated, society needs to support freedom of speech but within moral boundaries even if law doesn’t prescribe each incident clearly line by line
Here is a guy who is platforming and giving stage to disabled people.. making them mainstream.. normalising them.. n ur saying the show makes jokes on disability?
I understand you don't want to watch such shows . But atleast don't mislabel it?
and teaching teens to do oral sex ?? How are old are you by the way??
Even the show is not an original concept… it’s a copy of kill tony
@@amangupta-ll3rs how did you learn about oral sex ? Through jokes or by watching it directly ?
@amangupta-ll3rs teens? Did you even watch ?
Obviously some jokes don't land period.. but most don't when you remove context entirely.
@@amangupta-ll3rsHaan bhai Agar Samay Raina nhi hota toh Indians ko Oral Sex ka Pata he nhi chalta. Aj tak koi India mei Abuse karta he nahi tha friendly way mei. Sab Sanskrit mei he Baat karte the
Freedom of speech has its boundaries too.
Thank you for articulating it perfectly! You are a beacon of hope
Beautifully put and excellent pertinent points made..
This 10mns summarizer the issue so well, and using powerful but the most decent language.
Kudos.. & best wishes
This content is not available in his TH-cam channel free content. Its was supposed to be in his members only content. Some people took screen recording and posted it publicly. I don't think he broken any law or so called any other things you mentioned. People are paying for his content. So he should be delivering to those people who paid for it. As for as member only content concerned, only paid subscribers have access. Just my POV.
The content is easily available to view on his Instagram channel.
i believe that justifying everything by saying "which law does it violate" is actually frivolous and senseless since human beings are considered rational creatures , one should not require law to guide each and every step of us, since the whole idea of rights which are basically powers in a democracy is based on the assumption that human beings are capable of using it responsibly. however this particular incident goes onto to show that we are not, and a neutral overwatch mechanism is required in this case.
‘India’s Got Latent’ is garbage and should be called out when it makes disparaging comments BUT ALSO Mumbai’s authorities already have a lot on their plate that they need to address.
Most of the indian comedians including female comedians should be banned and called out.
I honestly feel we have had our freedom of speech curtailed for way important issues, and journalists and minorities have been through worse for lesser ‘issues’, i’m not gonna be defending those losers for something we have been losing for a while now. It’s only an issue rn coz incels are bothered
Those numbers are so scary!
He may not be wrong legally but ethically it was lowest to gutter. Freedom of speech doesn't oblige to speak anything immoral, there is a thin line between what to be said and what not to which should always be carefully considered. I don't feel any normal person would go that far thinking or even joking about it unless there is some mental issue underlying his personality.
See his mind is so sick even all the indivituals including the Lady was laughing and nodding this implies how much sick our society went down
Let's not blame the whole society it is just people who watch such derogatory content are to be blamed.. They made that show famous is what I would say..
C'mon black spidey, are you really going to judge the whole society based on the audience present in that show ?
We all have rights .....but we all.more importantly we have duties also.....People shud be responsible on public platform and on the internet...
That show should be shut down, it is so toxic and just seems to be a platform where you gain notoriety based on how low you can get insulting the person in front of you
Ya, cause remember that red dress girl (the one who was getting her dress designed onstage)? I thought it was completely fine, why would her husband (the one who married her at a very young age btw) mind her work as long as she gets money home, these two people were performers (it's done in other countries also and it was completely normal). But Samay Raina completely villianised her past! So yeah, that show has been very problematic.
Freedom of speech has been disrespected. Responsible content creation is of utmost importance in this time and it will be unfortunate if there's no action taken and rules put down.
"men" of culture.
This is shameful in name of freedom. It’s depraved even to hear it. How can you let it pass
4:29 you are wrong ! It was member only ep so don't say anything
He defended his question under the guise of free speech, forgetting that speech is free, but respect is earned ironically proving that freedom of speech comes with the responsibility of respect…
2. Do you have the right to be outraged if I knock on your door and fart when you open and go?
Totally agree. Well mentioned pointers . As a parent , citizen and as a professional who works closely with 13yo+ I am concerned about the low end 'humour' being pushed as content on the internet ... Regulations must come to play . Young minds shouldn't be exposed to such filth .
He started thinking too much abt himself 😡
India needs to decide whether thry want freedom of speech or no. Freedom of speech should not have any restrictions.
Loved this Faye, more power to you ❤
Makes some of us hopeful. That such perversion is noticed and condemned.
No wonder our younger generation has no boundaries of public and private anymore. Society and parents with younger ones are waking up to this.
Well, it's not at all about 18 plus censorship and that cheap raina forgetting a few settings. It's about our values, culture, and ethos. This sort of moral depravity in guise of jokes spread like termites and lead to massive social problems later. Call out the wrong faye, liberal does not mean permisivenes and being valueless
Yes it's a responsibility of the society to point out that it is morally wrong. I feel good that it's been done now.
It is actually disturbing content and the bigger problem is the fact that there were people who actually laughed at those lines.
Faye ❤ Keep up the good work
Disturbing? How old are you? 5?
Many people in India use mother n sister swear words multiple times a day but that is somehow acceptable? Doesn’t that pretty much mean the same thing? Yet people have accepted that in daily lingo. Strange!
Backlash from people against the comedians is understandable but legal case doesn’t make sense. Social backlash is bad enough
I strongly support what Faye is saying. Free speech is a slipery slope. If you dont like it, unsubscribe and change the channel. Content creaters have every tool available to them to limit reach to adults.
What about all the hate speech by BJP lackeys? These people's speeches have provoked violence against minorities. Where is the outcry over this?
Complete rubbish talk by you. This is what we call half truths. Problem is that you guys pin point bjp but not a word on hypocrisy of congress and other parties.
@@732anoopwhats the other half of truth?
Can we give same reasoning as freedom of speech to sell Drugs that whoever wants to consume can do it above age 21. Also sell alcohol without license and make Gun laws like US saying who do not want it to stay away.
btw bjp is not the alone party to make communal sensitive statements. look at what aimim, dmk, congress, SP etc say in jist also. evryrone is wooing thr vote banks. btw thr are role of conduct that is governing these statements and speeches as well unlike and can be challenged to Ec or taken to court. the content on You tube or OTT currently are unregulated wrt these kind of jokes. do not bring politics to justify this freedom
only bjp hate speech ? all political parties say like that .
Correct, there's no incentive in decency. As a society we need to pause and take a hard look where the social discourse is headed.
Freedom of expression isn't absolute.
i had been waiting for so long for someone to call this out!
"What terrible avengers you will make, because these are the examples you are setting" contemporary articulation at its best
The argument is very simple , the video was members only and all the outrage is coming from pirated content. If you don't like it , dont subscribe.
Freedom of speech, without govt intervention! Cancelled/ridiculed/unsubscribed by public? Sure; BUT govt bodies intervening? I say NO
I always wonder why people do not show this kind of outrage on politicians not delivering on their promises and not doing basic work for their constituencies.
💯
From a spiritual perspective, none of us came into existence in this physical body without witnessing our parents engaging in s*x. So, don’t criticize a person who, mistakenly identifying with certain defects, got into trouble-none of us are pure jewels.
One must disintegrate their own defects, "I's," and egos. Many have identified with certain defects that caused them to suffer. So, don’t judge them. If we criticize someone, let’s not forget the law of karma-it may happen to us as well.
We are not pure jewels. We also carry many defects within us that can manifest at any time if we are not aware. So, criticize the defect, not the person.
Hope you all understand. Thank you 🙏❤️
Education is needed in life for so called .....
Well, they are educated so I still don't get your point ?
Do you mean to say 'Common Sense' ?
Dont forget Allah badia has nearly 1 crore subscribers .. añd he has influenced many young lives. He has an international audience.
Sad too late we come to know his dark side . He runs channels under the name of ranveer show,!.. beer biceps.. TRS CLIPS . he has hosted intellectuals religious heads entrepreneur s and people from a wide field . In those shows hechas a calm subdued humble demenour . He conducts shows with Hinduism as cover for the darknside of his mind. He's got split personality
Excellent way to put out the pros and cons of freedom of speech, i have unsubscribed TRS, law has been broken if we consider the morality part of it.
I feel Ranveer was under influence of a truth serum drug where you actually speak, what exactly is always going on in your mind.
Sincerely
Disappointed
I dont care about Ranveer or his content. But I am going to make an argument that will appeal to the intelligence of rational people. What is 'decency'? Can it be described in absolute terms? What I think is decent maybe indecent to someone else. Decency and vulgarity are concepts that are subjective. And there are bigger issues on social media than lewd jokes. This sort of content doesnt harm the mental or physical health of the masses, yes it is in bad taste, and that is all it is. But it doesnt harm anyone. There is much more dangerous and divisive content on social media that is affecting the physical and mental health of people in India. There is plenty of misinformation, disinformation that is spread via social media and noone is worried about that. Instead we are making a big deal over some lewd joke. Speaking of children gaining access to this content, the RESPONSIBILITY of monitoring how children under 18 years use social media is on the parent. In India however, parents dont think it is their job and provide children with free access to social media and the internet, often without any adult supervision. Regulating what children have access to is the job of the parent. Please read the age restrictions and the terms of usage for social media sites such as TH-cam. It specifically says under 18 with parental constent, which means the parent needs to monitor. Calling for government intervention and censoring is not the way for a so called modern liberal society. PS: If you want to speak about issues with social media platforms, lets talk about how fact checking has been removed and India doesnt have any laws regulating AI. Which means deepfake videos can easily be circulated. Videos that look so real, that they can potentially incite religious uprisal, videos that can result in financial frauds, videos that can be used for blackmail and defamation. Lets talk about that, instead of some silly lewd joke that doesnt affect anyone.
People be giving maa behen ki gaaliyan and still getting offended on Ranveer Allahbadia's ❤comment 😅.. seriously
those gaaliyans arent watched by 13 millions overnight .. tho both are wrong,, here the main factor is the medium used
@@ritikkothari2787 Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hoti hai 💯👌🏼
Yeah, so I can say use those words when public is not watching me. Having one persona in public and another in private is hipocracy
@FayeDsouza, I believe we are stuck in our generation and don’t understand the sensibilities of today’s youngsters!
1. Youngsters have accessibility to too much information. Should we stop that?
2. They have the flexibility to choose how they can earn money and are financial independent at a young age. Should we stop giving the monetary support to pursue their freedom?
3. We need to reflect that if we as society are so touched by these comments, rape and parading women in Manipur shouldn’t happen.
These kids are showing us mirrors and we as society see ourselves ugly. So stop going after these kids and do something meaningful!
"With great power comes great responsibility" a timeless truth that resonates deeply today. I wholeheartedly welcome recent efforts to curb the misuse of free speech as a shield for vulgarity and indecency. It’s disheartening to see much of contemporary Indian standup comedy reduced to derogatory remarks about women, explicit references to body parts, and crude humor disguised as edginess. This shift toward shock value over substance reflects a concerning decline in artistic integrity. Let’s hope this moment sparks a return to wit that respects dignity while still challenging norms.
Law is broken and action should be taken against Samay raina for his channel.
@@angelajai murderers and rapists are roaming freely, and you want law to punish a comedian and a stupid podcast host.
Totally agree with you Faye D'Souza. Certainly punishment for such gravity of irresponsibility needs to be taken. However, let's not forget the lesson to be learnt by each one in this case. Freedom of speech with responsibility needs to be implied.
There should be no vulgarity in the name of freedom of speech.
I watch beer biceps and Ranveer’s podcasts never found anything disrespectful however never watched Raina samays vlogs and if they are found to be disgraceful content repeatedly then needs to shut down
Unfollow him immediately.
Very well said Faye !! Responsible speech is very very important especially when you are an influencer.
Love how well you've put this, Faye! They have all the power to make a meaningful difference, yet they choose to stoop so low, all for a few laughs.
Was burhani wani a freedom fighter or a terrorist or Bhagat Singh a freedom fighter or a terrorist ? Now what Ranveer said Was it perversion or was it freedom of speech? Just take your stand. For me it was perversion and that makes Ranveer a pervert
Freedom speech doesn’t mean filthy talk !!
People talking about real issues. How many of you have asked these guys to talk on those issues? As fans and followers defending them now. 😂 I see a comment above air quality index and shit.
Freedom of speech should be backed by accountability and responsibility of speech.