Indo-Pakistan War 71 - A Pakistani Submarine Fights Back
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 มิ.ย. 2023
- Thanks to GOAT GUNS for sponsoring this video. Go to goatguns.com for excellent quality die cast gun models.
Operation Python - The Indo-Pakistan War of 1971, the Indian Navy Western Fleet returns to Karachi to finish off the oil storage depots that were hit during Operation Trident. Later, Pakistani submarine PNS Hangor fights back against the Indian Navy.
Subscribe to our brand new channel The Intel Report now at: / @theintelreport
Our "Group Captain" tier Patreons vote on our next video subject. If you'd like to have your say on my next video, please check out my Patreon at the link below:
/ theoperationsroom
/ the_ops_room
Special thanks to my Patreons: Kelson Ball, Mark L., Wolfgang Seitz, Chris Roybal, Kristian Klibo, Johan West, e , bascommander , Matt Gonzales, Aaron Roberts, SkytechCEO , Tom Cho, Andrew Rodman, scott carson, Robby Gottesman, Nicole Johnson, Alex Pickworth, The Man They Call Asher, Shawn Heidrich, imfromthe808 , Gaute , Manfred Breuner, Bodo Nuber, Christopher Cardona, UnicornStampede, HT, Aaron, Bartosz Milewski, Floyd Rocker, omega21 , William Gage, Hunter Thor, Hanne Kortegaard Støchkel, Geir Morten Soerensen, Jack Mermod, Carlos Andino, Connor Kunihiro, Kurt Fox, Darius Cosby, Innominate , Flavio Ribeiro, Jackie Carson, Blitz the Durr, Bill Luster, Thomas Burton, Richard Woodard, Alexander K Leach, Michael C, Gregory DeMaria, TopiaSR, Jeffery Barnes, Alexey Guzey, Christopher Guilmette, Siddharth Ahuwalia, Richard Bejtlich, Kyle Hill, Eddy Gurge, Mark D, Aaron M Love, Lasse Pedersen, Arthur Morgan, Luke Graham, Tim Storey, carmakazi, Luis Martinez, ned hulton, Abusemtex , Bryant Miano, Dave Lombard, Brian Johnson, Thomas Wang, Eric Bolks, Blair Bunke, Colin Stachowski, Steven Leach, Christopher Vance, Will Coward, Dean Winger, LOVE, Doug Poland, Koko Sabre, Madm4nmaX, Warfare Mastery Institute, PBRstreetgang, Tactical_Jackal , big mike, Micah Falcon, Nate Graham, Tadwinks , Sami Koivuluoma, Tristan Sarles, Mike Wass, oscar johnson, Jcel4569 , Anthony Juan, Dan Ohlsen, Heavy Cruiser Takao, Joe Nobody, Eric Gagnon, Jeffrey Yen, William Sherlock, Halldór Friðrik, jiminyhopkins, Alan St (LowKeyTrickster), Sky, Doug Wait, Trever Braun, SpartacusDMR , Jaffacake239, David Schopfer, Gregory Martin, sebastian rasch, Ian Malik, s77n, Thomas Mulhern, Christian Paffhausen, Jason Dusek, Matt Busch, Salty Liquorice, Kallister, Daniel M., Cooper M, Matthew Brenner, KSARN, Russell Crew, High_Flyer, Barry Perkins, Grumpy Guy, Mohammed S, Mike Liow, Klaus Schmitzer, Tangent, Maximum Hats, Robert Miller, tom , Russel Not SCP, William Baumgartner , CL @ 仙女資本, HappySack , Dr.Cook, Jeff Le, Jordan Bell, SeveredAstronaut, David Pegno, Michal Miernowski, Angel , Ed Lim, John Rushing, devin locke, Ray Kueh, Pine_Forest, President Pedro, PendeBro , Josh , Alex6511 , Jeroen Delcour, bakkysak, KKazumai, Sam Hunt, GatitoMiau, Leon Venter, Patrick Brian Ragan, Al Rinaldi, Christian Jordan, VinceRebel, Brian Hall, M Z, Brendan Flynn, NinjaDrop0ut
Music: www.purple-planet.com
![[Full Episode] MasterChef Junior Thailand มาสเตอร์เชฟ จูเนียร์ ประเทศไทย Season 3 Episode 3](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A1XXYbV048k/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks to GOAT GUNS for sponsoring this video. Go to goatguns.com for excellent quality die cast gun models.
I really ant to but they’re so expensive
let us know about map. I laugh so hard when i saw that mail :)
I'd buy them If they would fire
Can you do a video on the indo-sino war?
It's kinda weird, about a few months before I started seeing the ads I kept wondering why no one had done it yet. Was an idea I had as a kid but unfortunately never got into metalworking/CNC or firearm engineering. You know, the whole "I had the idea just not the capital/skills/tools/drive". Wonder how many other people had the idea until GOAT did it.
I was 5 years old in 1971 and living in Karachi. I clearly remember the attack on oil depot. The ground shook and sun did not come out in karachi for several days due to the thick smoke.
That means U are now 58?
Correct
@@SMAZVidoes Could you describe how people reacted when they learned war was lost?
Did they blame the Army or the government?
@@user-pm7fv9dt6j pakistani army has a diseases that called martial race ! They think that only martial race people are good in fighting 😂😂😂
@@user-pm7fv9dt6jno of course the ever truthful pakistani media will say its a victory and 1 million indian soldiers were killed 😹
This series on India and Pakistan has been an unexpected delight. Most channels focus on Western wars and we don’t hear enough about battles in the East that also use more modern weapons and tactics.
A Catholic is a pagan
An evangelical is a pagan
A Muslim is a pagan
A Buddhist is a pagan
An Adventist is a pagan
A Jehovah's Witness is a pagan
A Judaic is a pagan
#ProphetKacouPhilippe
@@kouamechristophe8601bro what
@@kouamechristophe8601Schizo mode
@@kouamechristophe8601yes I have to agree with you on this morden era.
@@kouamechristophe8601 Take your meds
Those old Soviet Styx missiles proved to be exceptionally effective. Pretty good for 60s/70s technology.
My Uncle's (My Dad's Older Brother) one-time commanding officer was the same guy who was the captain of the Khukri, he deliberately chose to go down with the Ship since some of his crew had been killed in the torpedo attack and he felt it wouldn't be right for him to escape when some of those under his command had died.
He went down the Khukri, apparently, he refused to be dragged off by his crew who wanted to save him and chose to go down with the ship. Apparently, he was last seen by his crew, reading a newspaper as the ship went down.
Mahendra Nath Mulla was a very colorful character, my Uncle had some interesting stories about him.
My father was Capt Mulla's coursemate and shared similar stories about him
Iam so proud of your uncle
What a Man. My Pranaam to him. Om Shanti.
@@ARIEZ208atleast read the whole thing
That was stupid. The Japanese commanders were infamous for that and Instead of learning from the experience for the next battle and improve. They simply just seppuku themselves ensuring the next officers will also be fresh out of school.
Glad you're continuing the Indian content even after what happened. Your videos are incredibly well researched and very entertaining to watch.
Uh, what happened to them?
Fr man. These vids are cool asf
@fuad6280 for the record I wasn't taken down and the maps were correct 😁
@@derrickstorm6976If I understood correctly certain viewers didn't like a certain frontier on a certain map in the previous video. So they activated their special turbo rage ability and tried to strike the video.
@@TheOperationsRoomjust use the UN approved maps like other TH-camrs.
My father was the coursemate of Capt Mulla, and had told me stories of his bravery and of his resolute decision to go down with the ship. Never imagined that I'd see this on a video. Thanks so much! Would love to see Kargil War
respect and salute from Taiwan
This decision does not serve any purpose. The country just lost a good captain for unnecessary ego.
@@dreadfulbodyguard7288it wasn't unnecessary. It was to set an example for the upcoming soldiers.
Besides there was noone to save him. Even INS Kripan had to go back due to the submarine.
@@dreadfulbodyguard7288read somewhere that there wasn't enough rescue vessels to rescue all the men aboard at that time. So some men definitely would have been left to die. And he didn't want to be the captain who leaves knowing some of his men would definitely sink while he flies away in a helicopter. So he supervised the rescue of many sailors.
@@HulgulChulchul-sy7obsets a bad example. If the war dragged on for 3-4 years instead of weeks. Loss of highly trained officers would be huge
The immediate shutdown of a vital port (Karachi) turning what would have been a relatively symmetrical war into a short and comparatively one-sided one reminds me of the Russo-Japanese war.
Make no mistake, Indian military performance in this war was freaking phenomenal
The russian ship sailed around the world, half of the crew died in the journey, the fleet made several enemies during its journey, and ended up getting destroyed by the Japanese.
@@aadixumThey had to make that journey, and suffer the consequences, because the Japanese initial strike was so effective.
Some highlights of the Indo-Pak War 1971
- World's best naval operations in peer-to-peer conflict since WW2
-World's largest Para drop since WW2 - tangail airdrop
-Some of the best Special operations and raids behind enemy lines by the PARA SF
- Largest surrender since WW2
-New country formation
- Almost WW3 with involvement of US and USSR
-One of the shortest wars in the history of Wars.
@@HarryLincoln-cd4wy bruh, cope
@@HarryLincoln-cd4wyadding to that - A Proud Indian! ❤😊🫡🇮🇳
th-cam.com/video/qYD0CKML_mc/w-d-xo.html
Peer to peer? Pakistan's navy was nowhere near parity with the Indian navy. All of what's written above conveniently ignore that this happened when Pakistan was embroiled in a bloody civil war where the country's majority population (Bengalis) was fighting the minority population (West Pakistanis did not constitute Pakistan's majority population). Being armed with the top of line Soviet war material (while Pakistan was reeling under the US military sanctions) and having a numerical advantage of 15:1 in the Eastern theatre (Manekshaw himself accepted), the conception of a country that was 1,000 km away from West Pakistan inhabited by the majority population of united Pakistan (Bengalis) and manned by a mere REGULAR military strength of 45,000.
Do also shed some light on 1962 when a region the size of Switzerland was liberated by the Chinese in a swift conflict where nothing was stopping the PLA from even whisking away Arunachal (South Tibet), not the Indian army at least.
@@muneebtahir9810 it wasn’t a civil war, it was a liberation war due to perpetrated genocide. There were more than 120,000 regulars in Bangladesh, along with some 100k collaborating razakars. You still got swamped by us, the Indians merely finished the job. Cope harder.
Good to see a person stick to his morals and not get oppressed by outside factors, keep these Indian content coming lad...i loved it
your saying this rn but if theres anything anti india shown in the video, you would go mad.
@@narzereth this channel purpose is to document military content based on facts...
there is absolutely no scope to anyone to push any agenda...
so stop this keyboard war
@@jewell1276 me? keyboard war? i'm not starting any keyboard war. What i am saying is that if any information is against india in any videos, you get an absolute swarm of indians typing away. for example, if there is a map shown which has POK as part of pakistan, every indian watching that video gets butthurt and then comments "report him for spreading misinformation!!!!"
@@narzerethhe's talking about the Ops room's latest community post, where the Survey of India threatened legal action because of "inaccurate maps" (they just want to claim a disputed territory)
Why would anti-indian content do anything?
@@narzereth you reply to the comments was kinda provoking for him to reply and the it goes on... blah blah....
i think you get what i meant...
he was also not pointing that op room should have used the map , hes just supporting the channel
Great work!
I would recommend looking into the battle of Longewala...how 120 men dominated the night against a Pakistani armored division with 40 tanks and 3000 men. At dawn the remaining forces were wiped out by the air force.
A war move equivalent to lone survivor could be made on this part.. But for that India will need new film industry
Those Chinese made Type-59 tanks still lie in Indian museums
the movie "Border" is about that, its a bit long but good movie
I remember a US army lieutenant telling me how inferior, pathetic & unfit for battle the Pakistani army were - that it was a disgrace that the USA was allied with Pakistan rather than India. He was exceptionally pained at seeing American equipment always ending on the losing side to Soviet weapons during all Pakistan-India clashes - which were also USA-Soviet clashes in the background.
@@PersonwithnousernamelolAnd a bit inaccurate also. If you start learning history from movies then good luck.
I must say that missile boat had quite an appropriate name, "Vinash" in the Hindi Language, means "Destruction"
In OP Trident, there were INS Nipat and Nirghat. 'Nipat' means damnation, and 'Nirghat' means certainty. Quite good wordplay.
Vinash is a Sanskrit word, Hindi is just a mix of Sanskrit, Farsi and Arabic.
@@SeahawkGaming-xp7bl hindustani is mix of hindi, urdu, farsi not hindi.
@@nekrose Hindi is also a mix of Prakrit, Sanskrit, Farsi and Arabic. Many Arabic and Persian words like Havildar, Amir, Sahib, Kanoon, Jahaz and Sarkar are used in Hindi.
@@SeahawkGaming-xp7blI think what you meant to say I kharboli which is primarily spoken in North which is influenced by Urdu and farsi words but that's not pure Hindi
That was the first submarine torpedo kill since 1945. The only other one was the royal navy putting one up the belgrano during the Falklands situation.
Forgetting the ROKS Cheonan?
@@well-blazeredman6187 First since 1945 means that between 1945 and 1971 there were no submarine torpedo kills. Why would an incident that happened in 2010 matter here?
@@MeguminIsWaifuthe second part of the comment says "the only other one", which makes it look like there have only been two ships sunk by submarines, so he points out another instance
2:46 the attack was so devastating that it removed a large part of thr landmass apparently
Sri Lankan here. I'm a sucker for content like these but most of the videos I've watched are on world wars or western wars. It's great to see conflicts that happened right at our doorstep for a change.
Fascinating series. It's great to have some military history content that isn't just focused on WW2 or Vietnam. I hope we get to hear about what happened next.
Agreed 100%. It’s also nice to learn about military history outside of the Anglo sphere.
This video is dedicated to the International Boundary Directorate Survey of India x
LOLOLOOLLOLOL
Bless your soul man! As a Pakistani, I appreciate you being neutral and just showing what both sides possess rather than what both sides claim. Don't ever stop the Indo-Pak wars series, they're great to watch! :D
Me being an Indian knows some Indians are unnecessarily too sensitive
*Emotional damage*
@@generaliized4710you won't be able to cope if he shows the reality of all wars 😂😂😂
You should look into the tank battles in indo-pak wars. They are some of the best.
Or the use of artillery during kargil war at heights.
300 plus artillery guns, launchers fired around 250k shells, rockets etc.
The 1971 War is an incredibly interesting conflict. Within a week, the Indian military was able to beat back a large Pakistani army and saved Bangladesh from further genocide and rape. The tank battles and air war of 1971 are also incredibly interesting. The 1965 war is also an intresting conflict, including some large tank battles.
13 days, not a week. 3rd to 16th December
@prestallar4339actually no. The Indian Army attacking east Pakistan was quite small as compared to the 93000+ strong pak army. But due to miscommunication, Gen Niazi thought the size of the attacking forces was too large to handle and surrendered without a fight lol
@prestallar4339india was defending itself from 3 other front and army was deployed to defend those fronts
1st front - West Pakistan
2nd front - North and north east from china
3rd front - the indian coastline from the west - UK, USA, ARABS
@droomankaas5904 how?
@@patbateman9473 There was nowhere near 90,000 Pakistani troops in East Pakistan. The whole force was around 30,000 and only one or two squadrons of Sabres were there
To summarize, the Pakistani sub captain was skillful the Indian frigate captain was brave.
In wars skillfulness of militaries usually win over bravery
@@iridium8341 that's it you are right
I was just making my point
From pooing in the streets to being a poor but fierce military power in central asia
@@WimsicleStranger hmm I guess it is the Indians who have a long tradition of "pooing" in the streets
Forgot the movement named "khule mein hagna band karo" ???
@@WimsicleStrangeryour grammar is just your thinking... poopie
Admiral! My PNS is exploding!
Hey mate, just wanted to say, keep making these cool vids.
Please cover the Kargil War next!!!
Also, a recommendation, when you're mentioning people in the video, please add their photo and name if possible! It just looks more aesthetically pleasing and makes the content more understandable.
Seconded, lots of naval history channels does this and gives them human characters
@@jermasusxactly a good one is the Pacific series of kings and general where they show real people!
You guys lost to china
@@liloistheendiahater And you guys to Vietnam and the Talibs.
@@liloistheendiahater India lost to China in 1962 but won a ferocious victory against China in 1967 war. The Chinese military in 1967 simply ran away from the battle field with their tails between their legs.
Fucking loved this channel for years and now you're doing another Indo-Pak video despite the shitstorm of last time. Fucking love you more man
Calm down bro
Shitstorm ? Seriously
@@zeeraxa9671yeah, Indian nationals got real mad he used the internationally recognized maps, and not theirs.
@@kirbyball97but whats wrong in asking correct maps ?
UN still shows crimea as part of Ukraine in thought russia controls it then why not kashmir?
The state of Jammu and Kashmir was acceded to india through legal process which india used for every 564 princely state in india.
It was illegally occupied by Pakistan.
UN also approved in UN article 48, that Pakistan was an aggressor and they broked the stand still agreement they made with kashmir.
@@kirbyball97 all three countries involve in Kashmir will object in some from or the other , we don't have any land claims apart from POK since it's legally ours, it's a complicated situation
Thank you, Operations Room Channel. You, folks, make detailed history fun
Operations Room: Gets threatened by literal India
Op Room: Who cares
Not by india ...by TH-cam
@@durgeshsss I guess I got confused by the post then
@@JPhelpsNo, you were right. TH-cam merely informed him of the complained.
One of my relatives knew Mahendra Nath Mulla because he hailed from the same town of Lucknow, a very passionate charismatic naval officer who sacrificed himself in the line of the duty in the highest traditions of navy.Salute to the braveheart.
A near perfect operational excellence achieved by Indian navy in 1971 by sinking half of the enemy's navy just for a loss of 1 frigate ( that too when the outcome of the war was pretty much settled).
As a Pakistani I always knew our Navy was a mess. The Weakest of all three Forces. It's interesting to get information from unbiased neutral sources. Please continue your work and make more videos on other Indo Pak conflicts, regards.
First of all you are not pakistani cuz had you been you would not have called this shit neutral and unbiased cuz it fails to cover PAF's counter attak on indian ports. Second i would love to see the indians getting their asses smacked in 65 and kargil when Musharaf landed in india and conducted raids.
oh the same '65 war when india captured lahore and made pakistanis retreat out of delhi by cutting all their supply lines XDDDD@@kashifriaz3958
Been binging 1971 war content lately, and this came out at the perfectly time.
Great presentation. I look forward to seeing more. I understand why Captains want to go down with the ship, but I would think there’d be standing orders against it. Loosing some crew in battle in wartime is going to happen. However, career Naval Captains don’t just appear. They are trained for 20-30 decades, and have a wealth of experience. Standing orders should be against such a decision
Nowadays there are orders against that. But in 71 things were different.
There ARE such orders. A captain is supposed to be the last person off the ship. That doesn't mean you have to go down with the ship. It means that as the captain of a sinking ship you are responsible for getting people off of that ship until it's no longer possible to rescue anyone else. You are then entitled to save yourself.
Who needs to watch war movies when we have people like you making such incredibly fine videos.....can you please suggest some reading?
Just don't use Google as a source.
Great vid as always, never really looked much into this war but this has definitely peaked my interest.
Im a Pakistani and im just laughing on the defeates of Pakistani forces which is quite opposite to what we are told in our books
Now in age of internet, its hard to keep the truth hidden. 10 years ago, most of the pakistanis would have called this propaganda.
dont know which books u reading, textbooks explicitly state we lost the 71 war quite badly
Yet, another Indian trying to identify himself as Pakistani.
You are wrong, Pakistani army successfully defeated pak people since 75 years, and defeated their aspirations, happiness, economy, and successfully saved Pakistan from becoming Singapore, Japan, and hongkong😢,
@@kingrichards9295 😂😂😂 well put and to also mention kept the spirit of business and entrepreneurship alive. by themselves getting into business
Brilliant video, can you make a full series on the 1999 kargil war between India and Pakistan 😅
Just imagine the map strikes from that
I am more concerned about the war in the comments section lol 😂
+1
The wobbly animation on the submarine to make it look like underwater was a really nice touch
Glad to see the continuous videos on the Naval engagement of Indo-Pak war of 1971 , i hope the actions of INS vikrant would be highlighted with her Naval aircrafts
my school teacher's father in law fought in the 71 war. I remember him telling that they had orders to go on the attack, it was during the speech for the declaration of war that the attack happened. So even though the pakistani army knew that the attack was inevitable they expected a bit of delay after the declaration and where caught of guard.
Them Pakistani’s have a horrid KD ratio in this one.
In all wars tbh
If you combine all wars Pakistan has a 1:3 KD ratio against India.
@@HarryLincoln-cd4wy
These are the casualties in all Indo-Pakistani conflicts according to neutral sources
1947-48 Kashmir War
India and J&K - 6000 Casualties
Pakistan - 20000 Casualties
1965 War
India -
3000 men
150-190 tanks
60-75 aircraft
Pakistan -
3800 men
250-3000 tanks
20-25 aircraft
1971 war
India -
2300-3800 men
1 naval frigate
46 aircraft
83 tanks
Pakistan-
9000-10000 men
13 Naval vessels
75 aircraft
200-250 tanks
Siachen Conflict
India - 36 casualties
Pakistan - 200 casualties
Kargil War of 1999
India -
527 men
3 aircraft
Pakistan -
1000 - 4000 men
@@HarryLincoln-cd4wy Go ahead. Check the numbers and do the math. The data is public anyway.
Appreciate you're still continuing the series after the lawsuit threat bro, continue the good work!!!
Glad to see someone making a video on indian- Pakistan war
TOR: A featureless blue sea
The Indian Government: Map's wrong, complaint filed
Btw that wasn't Indian govt, its the survey of India, and I will urge u to read the advisory from the google again before making any statements on behalf of the channel.
Keep up the good work man, love that you are covering Indian military history.
the accuracy of Soviet cold war era anti ship missiles is shockingly good
Can you cover the battle of Longewala? It's part of the 1971 war and a legendary battle of 120 soldiers vs 3000 soldiers and 40 tanks.
You're making great content. I am glad you did not let yourself be detered!
I remember this war, but know almost nothing about it. Glad you're doing videos on it.
When The Operations Room uploads, everything else stops.
Sorry about your earlier video and comments from my Indian brethren. Portrayal of Indian Map is a bit sensitive for us, Just like Falklands is for Brits, Crimea is for Ukrainians etc. Still taking down an amazing video is uncalled.
Suggestion from my side
Battle of Longevala
120 men held back 2 Pakistani infantry brigade (2k-3k men) and 40 tanks all night till IAF CAS comes in.
Watch Recommendation just for you:
Sons of Vikrant (15mins long documentary)
It's beautifully made
Dude!! Cringe. Who are you to represent anyone?
It was a video showing Indian triumph and victory. Why are you guys so sensitive and insecure? Completely ridiculous.
I would understand if it was a video disparaging India from a Pakistani but it wasn't.
@@amogusenjoyer It is a battle of perception. World seeing PoK as India will immensely simplify our PR campaign when we liberate it.
Just look at what is happening with China, Taiwan has carved it's own separate identity now and the rest of the world is no longer ok with China invading it.
@@amogusenjoyer It's not insecurity but projection of our territorial integrity.
I don't think Falklands shown as part of Argentina would be taken lightly by a Brit Or Donbas shown as part of Russia would be taken lightly by NAFO fanbois.
I don't know why you guys are going Gaga over this simple fact.
Falkland Islands belong to Argentina, they are nowhere close to UK. Kashmir is attached to India by Hindu religion, Hindu history & Hindustani land.
holy shit those early soviet missiles are pretty good ...
What did you think they were?
Those missiles were great for their time
@@AshanBhatoa well they can barely make better missiles 70 years later sooo
Great content and all new history to me, great to learn new details in such a clear way. thanks, keep up the quality work.
You're doing great
Thanks for uploading
On the topic of 1971 war , a rare Airborne op was conducted with success . A Parachute Bn Group was dropped in East Pakistan to capture a bridge for advancing ground forces and in the event 2 PARA once having captured the bridge without waiting for a full link up went on and were the first to enter the capital,Dacca . In a world full of heroic Airborne disasters this one could stand out as a major success. Thankfully this wasn't a Bridge too far. An interesting topic for future which is generally not adequately covered in the Military history world.
Its interesting to see some palces remain militarily important throughout history. In this case Diu is the same place where the Portuguese fought with the Gujrat sultanate supported by mamluks in 15 th century to control the north Arabian sea trade.
Glad to learn about a little-taught conflict (in the West), especially from such an incredible documentary channel!
Keep up the good fight! Much needed content.
Great content, i knew little or nothing about this conflict.
An Iraqi Captain and I were once talking about why the military of Muslim countries were.....lets admit it.....bad.
"From the day a Muslim boy is born he is pitted against his brothers. He and his brothers are against his cousins. His clan against other clans in the tribe. Our tribe against all the world."
Loyalty to of these familial ties are held high above the good of the nation as a whole.
Keep in mind they also didn't want to be a country for the most part. Large swaths of land were cut up in weird places taking in no regard for cultural differences and ethnic differences. The groups that were still killing each other were told they were a nation now and to get along. Went about as well as you would expect.
The irony is that that was the very reason the Muhammad (Pbuh) brought Islam… to unite the tribes… unfortunately they let their traditions dominate over the religious teachings and a great civilization that could have united the world, fell apart, and with it Islam itself.
You do understand that it isn’t a Muslim thing. It’s a dictatorial thing. Muslim Bengali forces were also routing the Pakistanis in 71 and in 1965 Muslim Bengalis defended Lahore from india with gallantry. The problem is there is no rule of law in Pakistan
That would imply they don’t fight bravely or together against enemy countries, but they do
@@Sea-qv4sd It does not. It implies exactly what I said. Their cohesion as a nation is impeded by these outlooks you just don't find in other parts of the world
I’d love to see more regional conflicts from around this time period
Maybe a battle or series of battle from the Rodhesian bush war? They had devastating tactics
You failed to mention 2 of events in PNS Hangor's records:
Hangor fired a torpedo towards Kirpan when it was coming for rescue of Kukri, a loud explosion was heard which indicated the torpedo has strucked but later it was found that the ship did not sank.
Immediately after this engagement the Indian Navy launched a massive hunting mission against Hangor and dropped depth charges indiscriminately. Hangor had to remain submerged for a week to escape this Indian mission.
This could be verified by personal interviews of Cdr Tasneem.
My father was on Kirpan. Nothing hit his ship.
@@incubusk8rand I dropped nuclear bombs on Japan on August 6 1945.
who believes in Pakistani Military or Pakistani people. They're all liers. Only Indian side of sources are truthful and credible.
Keep the content on this war coming!
It's a good way to start the morning with an Operations Room video!
I remember trying to repeat this success in Command: Modern Air/Naval Operations. Efforts were fairly hampered by the fact that the Indian frigates were just as fast as the Pakistani torpedoes but they kept trying to dodge side-to-side allowing the torpedoes to catch up eventually.
A work colleague and good friend of mine (we worked together in Dubai) was on the Kirpan when the Kukri was torpedoed , he was only 16 or 17 at the time, and thought his time was up!.
Even my father was on Kirpan
That young in the military?
Love the videos man. I’d love to see a video on the whole of the Falklands as my uncle fought there, or on the battle of Khe San or Long Tan!
Fantastic video, as always!
It really well researched and very entertaining to watch.
If possible, might you do a video of the Battle of Longewala?
Keep up with the great content... Love from India
Submarines content is very fitting with current Submarine news
lmao
You did a Part II? Yeeeeeee! Well done.
My grand uncle late E Chandy Admiral Kuruvilla would be extremely amazed on how well you explained this
Why INS Kukri was not manoeuvring in any way for so long in light of a known sub attack on INS Kirpan is mind-boggling. Were the two ships out of comms/LOS and it didn't know, or was the Captain simply that negligent?
Ins Kirpan also Dodged the Torpedo Just by Hard maneuvering the Ship.
The Khukri had Sonar issue and I think one of its Boiler also didn't worked well.
After the attack on INS kirpan, INS khukri changed course, increased speed and came rushing towards the last known position of PNS hangor to press for an attack but PNS hangor had a sonar that outranged INS khukri's own sonar, which resulted in PNS hangor detecting INS khukri first and they knew it's heading towards them so they changed mode and fired torpedo towards the incoming but unsuspecting khukri, INS khukri's sonar was technologically inferior to the sonar of PNS hangor, couple it with the fact that khukri's sonar required it to move slowly for it to work properly and it resulted in INS khukri detecting the incoming torpedo too late and with such short range the ship failed to maneuver and avoid the torpedo, Later the Indian Navy's inquiry also found that the ship had not followed the Indian Navy's anti submarine doctrine properly
The Indian frigate had sonar range of only 5 km. That too effective while slowing the ship.
Pak sub was latest one with modern sonar of its time range of 25 km.
Both Indian frigates were of no match to the pak sub
@@soumyaranjanmohapatra4862 That would be a more reasonable reaction/outcome than was was depicted here.
INS Khukri definitely made mistakes...
Lots of submarine content today huh
nahhhhh
6:15 awesome fireball graphics!
I am Happy that You are Making Content on Our History SO that New Generation can Know What Happend. Thank you sooo much . love the content also.
Regrettable to see what has happened to you. You are an incredible content creator. I wish you nothing but best of luck.
PNS Hangor was crewed by a very good crew. Indian Navy was right to assess Pak submarines were the biggest threat to them.
What happened to the creator?
@@durgeshsss Mass-whining by Indian ultra-nationalists and legal threats from the Indian government because he's using the standard & internationally recognised UN maps instead of their own maps which enforce Indian territorial claims over the disputed Kashmir region.
@@Ozraptor4Kashmir and Balochistan is an integral part of India and we will take it back on our own chosen time and we don't give a sh** about what UN thinks or what you think in the matter of fact.
@@AryaEZAF Thankyou for illustrating my point.
@@AryaEZAFso you can turn them into designated shitting areas?
CANT WAIT FOR KARGIL WAR SERIES, ALL THE YOUNG OFFICERS AND THEIR TALES
This is awesome. Would love to see a video on the battle of Latakia.
Top notch content. Earned a sub👍
11:18 ..thats just pure respect
Very nice to see post-WW2 conflicts covered. I suggest you to also cover the 1974 Cyprus invasion at some point.
Kings and Generals have done a series on the conflict already
@@DomCombatVids Kings and Generals are kinda biast and also not the most accurate at times.
@@ArenBerberian you mean they're not rabid Turk supporters?
@@DomCombatVids What have Turks got to do with anything?
@@ArenBerberianProve it.
Intervention of a real picture at 6:08 is very nice.
This is awesome! would love to see the ground attack covered by TOR as well
Discovering this channel and binge watching it is like opening present on Christmas Day...
Your videos made me and what I believe to be a lot of people aware of Indian accolades. It's a shame that some ultra nationalists were trying to sabotage what's essentially a free PR campaign for them
The free PR campaign can be gotten ANYTIME, but the world cannot be allowed to normalize wrong maps of India.
@@SodiumSyndicatestop this non sense!! You are just making a fool of yourself.
If everyone started to use maps based on claims then taiwan will be shown in China.
And go and ask residents of POK if they even want to be in India. You act like these palces are just barren lands with no people. These maps are what the government controls and administeres. Let the governments do this cartograohic advocacy and focus on what is more important here.
As an Indian I am embarrassed that illogical and senseless people like you are my countrymen.
@@SodiumSyndicateIts not a wrong map. Be silent instead of embarressing your country.
@@SodiumSyndicate Claiming territory that we don't control is just lying to ourselves. Instead of crying about maps, we should be preparing to take back actual ground. The current administration, however, is only interested in burning our own country to the ground before any such thing can materialize.
@@SodiumSyndicateit is the defacto map.....you can claim whatever you want, you can claim entire china belongs to you, but the world will recognise only what is in your control, not your claim.
Otherwise Pakistan also claims entire kashmir, should they show kashmir belongs to Pakistan on the map?
The timing is beautiful
Thnx for focusing post ww2 wars.
Wow
This is better content than Netflix and I am addicted to the it.
Also great to see you didn't cared about governments propaganda and problems.
Did you.. did your team just break your upload schedule and worked overtime to upload another India video just to get back at that legal team?
They should've never messed with a group who do their research lol
I thought I should watch this quick, before the powers that be issue a cease and desist order!
Great production as always.
Keep up the work man...Can you also do some battle plannings and explanations of famous battles...
What an interesting choice for an upload considering the recent events and also considering what happened the last video. Keep it up, man.
What recent events are you talking about?
@@NoMustang273 The Titanic submarine and the other one being some Indians getting mad over Ops Room using a UN map not used by India
@@Big_E_Soul_Fragmentnot some Indian but "Survey of India" an government entity which launch official maps in India...no country in the world will digest its wrong map
LOL that's not how any of this works!
No government entity gets to make up their own borders as they please, borders are negotiated and then universally agreed upon and approved.
If the UN says that your border is such and such and you don't like it, then you either litigate the issue with them and see if you can make them change their mind or you shut it and accept the fact that you didn't own that piece of land.
Either way, you don't get to make up your own borders, so stop all of this nonsense, you just look stupid.
@xenocrates7 I'm pretty sure he was using the defacto map which shows POK under Pakistan and Aksei Chin under China. It's literally the defacto map irrespective of what the govt. claims. Should Pakistan be allowed to strike videos because it doesn't show it controlling Kashmir?
Me: *_is about to sleep_*
Operations Room: "And I took that personally"
I love to see this channel dissecting conflicts from all over the world!
I'm not so sure. I think his best videos focus on western battles and wars. Not many people understand these countries or their complex history, which makes the videos confusing.
Thanks to THE GOAT TH-camr for continueing the series on India 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Captain Mahendra Nath Mulla was from my city . He refused to evacuate himself and decided to go down with the ship.
I really don't like this type of thing. In a war every man is vital and he was a captain at that. Won't it be much better if he came back and shared his experience with fighting pak subs to the high command? The Japanese also did the same
@@mayukhbasak163 that's what we want from him but warriors think differently, they are greedy of glory.
If I were the captain, I'll do the same but hope others don't do it. It takes years to train a commander.
@@mayukhbasak163 You can view it as like a responsibility thing and to just purely warrior's honor
A captain failed their duty as a captain and got people killed and the ship sunk. The least they can do is go down with the ship.
@@PanzerIVAEmore like the captain did not want to face the humiliation and possible charges, for allowing his crew to be in such a relaxed state during a war.
Idk much about these wars and have seen documentry on these Wars of indo-Pak but its documented by people on both sides so theres loads of bias and Propaganda but good to see a neutral big channel like this covering this War and telling what truly happened and also telling all the major Battles that happened, I didnt even know there was a Naval battle in 1972 until today.
Hope you make video about 1945, 1965, and 1999 indo-pak Wars
That's how history works - documentation by people who were actually there.
Indians are told that PNS Hangor was sank by a Kukri. Truly Entertaining😂
@@shani2847No...INS Khukri's loss was felt by Sam Manekshah. He was under a lot stress post the loss of Khukri...
@@shani2847no one in india tell this, Indians accept everything, unlike Pakistan studies, even till 16 the Dec, 1971, all leading newspapers in Pakistan were reporting the wins if pak army against india, and how Indian army was being defeated everywhere, then suddenly it was BBC who first brought the news of pak army defeat and surrender🙄
Very accurate shooting.
Terrific video! Your animations have become truly superb and all your works are well researched and fascinating.
Can you do a series about the Falklands? I’m sure I’m not the only one who would be interested
Damn I'm very surprised you're still uploading Indian stuff despite the overblown government takedown notice! Good on ya
STAY STRONG BROTHER. THE KNOWLEDGE MUST BE FREE AND FOR THE PEOPLE!!! LOVE YOU MAN💛💛
Great content as always. Do you plan to do the Battle of Longewala as well?