Orlinski. His ornamentation is very natural, his emotions are fluid without exaggeration. He structured the song best ouf the 3... In my opinion. I do not understand the intense "accelerando" in Scholl's rendition. I am a fan of Scholl too but here Orlinski sounds more natural, even hypnotising. Yaroussky is a great singer but out of my personal taste.
Les trois artistes sont excellents ; mais concernant cette pièce de Caccini que j'affectionne tout particulièrement, ma préférence va à Philippe Jarousski qui l'interprète merveilleusement bien, ici. "Flow my tears" de Dowland est à Scholl ce qu' "Amarilli" est à Jarousski.
Nemohu se rozhodnout. Všichni mají krásný a jedinečný zpěv. Nikdy jsem si nemyslela,že v mém pokročilém věku podlehnu kontratenoru. Je to krása, které znovu a znovu podléhám.❤
I can't possibly choose! Each one is spectacular for different reasons. BUT, the arrangement and playing of theorbo (?) in Jaroussky's takes it to a whole new level. Never underestimate the importance of the accompanist!
Qui est thé Big Boss incontestablement monsieur ANdreas Scholl voix de tête d une clarté et d une justesse jamais inégalée. Ich liebe dich. Puis son dauphin Philippe Jaroussky. En dernier le petit dernier qui a encore des progrès a faire pour égaler ces deux maîtres.
You missed the fact that Jakub has a completely different voice and singing style. For sure, he is not going to copy either Scholl nor Jaroussky. Saying it I have to admit that I am a fan of Andreas Scholl. Jaroussky's feminine singing is out of my personal taste. Orlinski will, for sure, proceed his own career in his own unique way. He will utilise his masculine and very rare(unique) countertenor voice finding his own paths. He has already done a lot to promote Baroque music amongst younger generations and seems to have been successful in doing it. I admire his determination in creating and proceeding his own vision, incorporating his voice in a few other music genres too which shows his flexibility. I would say his musical interests are very wide and I think he does not find himself a typical opera or Baroque music singer. He can communicate with the audience very easily which seems to be very promising for the years to come. A great, unconventional artist!
Tahle píseň mě zasahuje intenzivně. Miluji ji, miluji kontratenor. Miluji italstinu, Miluji život. Už mohu zemřít. Všichni tři to zpívají nádherně. Pri poslechu pláču.
Commençons inévitablement ce "radio-crochet" par : toujours le même. L'ineffable J.J.O., dans la plus pure équité, sans aucune idée préconçue, sans parti-pris, sans propagande et sans aucune volonté d'influencer... Moi, ça me fait marrer, mais j'espère que les autres vrais chanteurs qui sont mis en concurrence auront mon sens de l'humour. Une claque d'Andréas Scholl ça doit faire mal. Andréas, si tu m'écoutes... Reste calme stp, reste calme...
Orlinski. His ornamentation is very natural, his emotions are fluid without exaggeration. He structured the song best ouf the 3... In my opinion. I do not understand the intense "accelerando" in Scholl's rendition.
I am a fan of Scholl too but here Orlinski sounds more natural, even hypnotising.
Yaroussky is a great singer but out of my personal taste.
I agree 100% .
Orliński's interpretation is the most captivating here.
Great to see you back. I’ve missed your compilations.
Les trois artistes sont excellents ; mais concernant cette pièce de Caccini que j'affectionne tout particulièrement, ma préférence va à Philippe Jarousski qui l'interprète merveilleusement bien, ici. "Flow my tears" de Dowland est à Scholl ce qu' "Amarilli" est à Jarousski.
Scholl, tellement doux et touchant...Jarousski un petit peu trop maniéré, mais les 3 sont complètement possédés par leur rôle. Magnifiques.
... In my opinion, these are now the three greatest countertenors that it is impossible to compare or single out which of them is better....
Orlinski and Scholl, both wonderful🙏👏👏👏
Andreas sings like a god , Phillipe sings like an angel.
A. Scholl est le meilleur contretenor des 20 dernières années, suivi de près par quelques autres mais jamais egalé
Andreas Scholl
Orlinsky y Scholl son los elegantísimos
Beautiful. They are all wonderful interpretations.
It's incredible how beautiful these voices are. Their singing would melt the coldest heart. Thank you, Daniel.
Andreas Scholl в данном случае оказался лучшим, на мой взгляд.
Но самый одаренный конечно Orlinski.
Oh, thank you sir for this delicate beautiful presentation. My prejudice: I'm a fan of School. I'm liking Orliński performance and voice...
Me too. I'm Orlinski fan
Jaroussky is best, second Orliński.
Andreas Scholl!
Nemohu se rozhodnout. Všichni mají krásný a jedinečný zpěv.
Nikdy jsem si nemyslela,že v mém pokročilém věku podlehnu kontratenoru.
Je to krása, které znovu a znovu podléhám.❤
Andreas Scholl ❤
SCHOLL.
I mean, is there even a debate here?
Of course, there is! It all depends on a personal preference and taste. As you can see, opinions and tastes differ...
J.J.orlinski
Orlinski
Des Frissons avec Jarousski.
I cannot choose, i love different aspects of them all the best
Jaroussky, como jalea para mis oidos
Phoebe Jevtovic :)
Jaroussky and Scholl.
Jaroussky! Splendide!
I can't possibly choose! Each one is spectacular for different reasons. BUT, the arrangement and playing of theorbo (?) in Jaroussky's takes it to a whole new level. Never underestimate the importance of the accompanist!
Qui est thé Big Boss incontestablement monsieur ANdreas Scholl voix de tête d une clarté et d une justesse jamais inégalée. Ich liebe dich. Puis son dauphin Philippe Jaroussky. En dernier le petit dernier qui a encore des progrès a faire pour égaler ces deux maîtres.
You missed the fact that Jakub has a completely different voice and singing style. For sure, he is not going to copy either Scholl nor Jaroussky. Saying it I have to admit that I am a fan of Andreas Scholl. Jaroussky's feminine singing is out of my personal taste. Orlinski will, for sure, proceed his own career in his own unique way. He will utilise his masculine and very rare(unique) countertenor voice finding his own paths. He has already done a lot to promote Baroque music amongst younger generations and seems to have been successful in doing it. I admire his determination in creating and proceeding his own vision, incorporating his voice in a few other music genres too which shows his flexibility. I would say his musical interests are very wide and I think he does not find himself a typical opera or Baroque music singer. He can communicate with the audience very easily which seems to be very promising for the years to come. A great, unconventional artist!
Nous verrons s il progresse. Mais son grain de voix ne me plaît pas et je ne pense pas changer d avis. Désolée
@@ClaudineFranco-u1p You do not have to change your mind. Stick to your personal preference.
Me encantan los tres pero la voz de Phillipe además me conmueve profundamente. Muchas gracias por sus selecciones
I ❤ Jacob !
Tahle píseň mě zasahuje intenzivně. Miluji ji, miluji kontratenor. Miluji italstinu, Miluji život. Už mohu zemřít.
Všichni tři to zpívají nádherně. Pri poslechu pláču.
Ah, no. Es como escoger que perfección es más perfecta😊
Великолепны все трое, но лучшая, несомненно, Чечилия Бартоли! :)
Jaroussky es magnífico!!!
Commençons inévitablement ce "radio-crochet" par : toujours le même. L'ineffable J.J.O., dans la plus pure équité, sans aucune idée préconçue, sans parti-pris, sans propagande et sans aucune volonté d'influencer... Moi, ça me fait marrer, mais j'espère que les autres vrais chanteurs qui sont mis en concurrence auront mon sens de l'humour. Une claque d'Andréas Scholl ça doit faire mal. Andréas, si tu m'écoutes... Reste calme stp, reste calme...
You must be paid for writing this nonsense... For undermining Jakub Orlinski.
@@RelaxingSloth-qu7sdNo! He's just a bad singer... That's all
@@sheldonbazinga3985 Maybe your ear or taste is not good enough...? Have you ever considered this possibility?
Jozek
cecilia bartoli
La voz de Andreas es bella y encantadora, pero en el momento que canta Jaroussky es como escuchar ángeles, impresionantemente hermosa. Es sublime.
Scholl!!!