Lajwanti madam, your research and findings regarding Harrapan, Vedic age and status of Sarswati river status seems very logical and convincing and clearly establishing Vedic civilization far before 1500 BC. I think people like you should be more vocal and spread this knowledge.
When it comes to the origin of the Vedic people, there are linguistis with their own theories and proofs then there are ancient historians with their proofs and then we have archeologists but all these three don't common on a single platform to solve the mystery of the Vedic origins. That would be great.
@@argumentativeindians the most important being perhaps the geneticists. We need them on the show. Inevitably most of them will be foreign due to the techonological advances and studies done abroad
45:00 > both the speakers confidently assert that the Harrapan civilisation is Meluhha. Although as i understand there is no certainty on this. Most scholars think it to be the IVC but are not 100% confident about it. In which case why dont the speakers be more exact rather than being 100% confident and conveying a wrong (?) impression to the listeners?
The word Meluhha comes from Sumerian textual evidence with the other two trading entities being identified as Dilmun (Bahrain) and Magan (Oman). We have the same entities in archaeological evidence too. These two varied evidence types have corroborated and established the physical and textual findings beyond any doubt.
@@lajwantishahani1225 ok, my understanding based on the online articles i read or the few books i read, was that scholars are still not 100% confident about Meluhha being the IVC. But since you say that this is now established beyond any doubt, I will go with that. Pls advise on latest 1-2 books that one can read about the IVC and Harappan civilisation to update our knowledge
There is a Saraswati river in Siberia named in modern times as Ob, its ancient name was Saraswati. Sweta in Russian language is white. As Tilak wrote that ancient Aryans before the last ice age used to live in the arctic circle and Vedas were composed there.
The Steppe ancestry appears on the Indus Valley landscape only after 1500bc. So all cultural and linguitic actvity will have reference to a period only post 1500bc. The IVC dissppeared in 1900bc. No human remains found to suggest an invasion So, the IVC was evacuated safely and it appears they migrated east and south -mixed with the native hunter gatherers and became the ASI
The Saraswati is a non existent mystical river with Vedic reference. The gaggar hakra is a seasonal monsoon fed river that is part of the Indus river system.along with over 2000 other city sites. Science, Archeology and Genetic are the relevant evidence.
There is no such thing called indic horse, india had only ass. If IVC had horse definetly end up in sumer,akkad or egypt . But that never happened. More over fire worship not found in all ivc but only in kalibangana just like horse found only in surkotada. They might be BMAC or bought by anyother non-ivc ian.
Lajwanti madam, your research and findings regarding Harrapan, Vedic age and status of Sarswati river status seems very logical and convincing and clearly establishing Vedic civilization far before 1500 BC. I think people like you should be more vocal and spread this knowledge.
When it comes to the origin of the Vedic people, there are linguistis with their own theories and proofs then there are ancient historians with their proofs and then we have archeologists but all these three don't common on a single platform to solve the mystery of the Vedic origins. That would be great.
Thanks for the comment. We are aiming to achieve just that.
@@argumentativeindians the most important being perhaps the geneticists. We need them on the show. Inevitably most of them will be foreign due to the techonological advances and studies done abroad
45:00 > both the speakers confidently assert that the Harrapan civilisation is Meluhha. Although as i understand there is no certainty on this. Most scholars think it to be the IVC but are not 100% confident about it. In which case why dont the speakers be more exact rather than being 100% confident and conveying a wrong (?) impression to the listeners?
The word Meluhha comes from Sumerian textual evidence with the other two trading entities being identified as Dilmun (Bahrain) and Magan (Oman). We have the same entities in archaeological evidence too. These two varied evidence types have corroborated and established the physical and textual findings beyond any doubt.
@@lajwantishahani1225 ok, my understanding based on the online articles i read or the few books i read, was that scholars are still not 100% confident about Meluhha being the IVC. But since you say that this is now established beyond any doubt, I will go with that. Pls advise on latest 1-2 books that one can read about the IVC and Harappan civilisation to update our knowledge
There is a Saraswati river in Siberia named in modern times as Ob, its ancient name was Saraswati. Sweta in Russian language is white. As Tilak wrote that ancient Aryans before the last ice age used to live in the arctic circle and Vedas were composed there.
request further details on the river ob and its link to saraswati pls
Serious attempt to intertwine mythology and Archeology. Incredible.
Amazing. So much time can be spent on archeology/ mythology, without a shred of evidence.
Your website isnt working
We were undergoing a technical issue. It is fixed now. Thank you for pointing out. Are you looking for something specific?
'Meluha' or 'mel loka' means ' top world' in tamil and other south indian languages
Loka is sanskrit 😂
nomadic pastorolist, cattle herders on the move, a new landscape each day. In due course all horizons and all new feature look the Same.
The Steppe ancestry appears on the Indus Valley landscape only after 1500bc. So all cultural and linguitic actvity will have reference to a period only post 1500bc.
The IVC dissppeared in 1900bc. No human remains found to suggest an invasion So, the IVC was evacuated safely and it appears they migrated east and south -mixed with the native hunter gatherers and became the ASI
read David Reich dna study it's not 1500 it's 2100 bc
The Saraswati is a non existent mystical river with Vedic reference. The gaggar hakra is a seasonal monsoon fed river that is part of the Indus river system.along with over 2000 other city sites. Science, Archeology and Genetic are the relevant evidence.
There is no such thing called indic horse, india had only ass. If IVC had horse definetly end up in sumer,akkad or egypt . But that never happened. More over fire worship not found in all ivc but only in kalibangana just like horse found only in surkotada. They might be BMAC or bought by anyother non-ivc ian.