@@raymondlee8160 as I said. Its time to think big. Why don’t we build all of them at the same time ? With the right amount of interest and negotiation, every financial institution will be in front of our door ✌🏼
Masyarakat Kalimantan tetap akan diperhatikan Pemerintah krn pemindahan ibu kota juga bertujuan meningkatkan kesejahteraan masyarakat lokal di Kalimantan
Baru genap satu tahun semenjak dimulainya konstruksi pada tahun 2022 lalu tetapi progres pembangunan nya sudah sejauh itu, kayaknya pemerintah beneran niat buat pindah kesana, semoga semua pekerja lokal yang lembur demi menafkahi keluarganya bisa dapat gaji yang setimpal dengan kinerja mereka.
@@devauxcdv8556 200 ribu pendatang itu angka perkiraan yang akan datang ke ikn setelah kota nya jadi , dimana pekerja lokal nya? Banyak tuh orang lokal yang jadi buruh konstruksi proyek 😅
@@devauxcdv8556 semua warga negara indonesia.punya hak yang sma.bebas mencari rejeki di mana saja.di bagian indonesia. org kalimantan bebas menentukan nasipnya mau ke jakarta.mau kebelahan jawa.mau ke bali.mau ke sumatara mau kemana saja.bebas.begitu sebaliknya. Jadi ikn.pasti sagat terbuka buat org org kalimantan yang mau bekerja.di situ asal punya kemampuan.di bidangnya.
@@devauxcdv8556 semua warga negara indonesia.punya hak yang sma.bebas mencari rejeki di mana saja.di bagian indonesia. org kalimantan bebas menentukan nasipnya mau ke jakarta.mau kebelahan jawa.mau ke bali.mau ke sumatara mau kemana saja.bebas.begitu sebaliknya. Jadi ikn.pasti sagat terbuka buat org org kalimantan yang mau bekerja.di situ asal punya kemampuan.di bidangnya.
Media dan pemerintah singapura selalu berusaha menciptakan pertentangan dan perpecahan opini dan pemikiran rakyat indonesia, agar indonesia selalu berkelahi diantara komponen2 anak bangsa nya..tujuan akhirmya mereka dapat selalu mengambil keuntungan besar dari situasi indonesia yg selalu kisruh. Hati2 wahai bangsa indonesia terhadap gerakan ini.
Betul sekaliiii.. seperti yang pak luhut bilang.. tak ada satupun negara maju yang mau negara berkembang menjadi negara maju.. inilah contoh media press nya
I as a local community feel proud of this project because the economy will be evenly distributed and in this new mother many native Indonesian trees that are starting to become extinct will be replanted.
All the best to Indonesia! I hope the locals can benefit from the new capital, I hope all the complex processes will go on smoothly, I hope your country will prosper even more from this move
I really like the idea of new capital in kalimanatan, this will open new opportunity for us who live in kalimantan to get new development project and new way of life for us Indonesian kalimanatans. The people who disagree about the move and feels like its not the right move could cry for all I care, if we talking about the environment and land acquisition from local people/local tribe land is a legitamate concern, but Outside of that concern I only see people from jakarta whinning that their city will no longer be a capital city, who care if Nusantara has a mall or any of that stuff as long school, water, and hospital is available everything will be allright, if not balikpapan is just 2 hour drive from nusantara, a toll road is gonna be build and the drive hour ia gonna be cut down to serval minute. To jakarta residan who doesn't want to leave then that also okay, more job for us in here in kalimantan. Indonesian as a whole already had enough of more then 7 decade of java development, now its outaide java that need to be build. Jave could've all indonesian wealth but they can't keep getting the development forever if not we from kalimanatan are not Indonesian.
In fact, most of the people live in Jakarta fully support this Idea. We start to getting annoyed by all of those International forum, official visit and other state ceremony. It’s a business center that already having too much on its plate so this will create less political drama for us 🙈 Good luck with the new city brother 🙌🏽
I am from Java central full support for ours brothers & sisters in Kalimantan to be a city central of Indonesia IKN and full support which government do with all the projects to relocate city of Indonesia to Kalimantan. Salam brother’s..🙏
Im an indigenous from central java and fully totally absolutely support IKN strategically and spiritually as well. Good luck my fellow brother in kalimantan
THIS IS WHY CNA IS BEING BIASED HERE, their assumption that Nusantara only represent certain ethnic group is very narrow minded. You can see Malaysians once protest the naming of Nusantara as the new capital of Indonesia because they thought it would imply that territories of Malaysia to be under Nusantara's authority. And Malaysian Malay considered "Nusantara" to be part of their legacy because it symbolises the glory of "Alam Melayu" which they taught at education academics as "Mahawangsa Melayu". So actually Malays are proud and considered the word Nusantara as part of their legacy and civilization. We do know that Kalimantan has Huge population of Malay ethnic throughout the island.. hence Banjar Malays, Bruneian, Sabah, Sarawak, etc. Second, CNA also aired the conversation with the environmental activist about the effect of EV battery and so it implies that Nusantara is wholly blamed in this part... This is truly hypocritical and biased on CNA!! If the objection was because it exploit nature from nickel mining, then CNA should also blame and shame Singapore, America, Elon Musk, and other developed countries who also welcoming EV to be part of their green transformation!!! Despite that Nusantara already projected that 70%+ of the people mobility to be based on Public Transport, Walking, and Bicycle lane... CNA forgot to mention this Ratio!! Now you see how CNA is truly biased here.
AND NUSANTARA ITSELF CAME FROM THE MOUTH OF JAVANESE PRIME MINISTER OF MAJAPAHIT 😂😂 ALAM MELAYU ALAM MELAYU TAI ANJING LAH WKWK.. ORG MELAYU PEMALAS KOK BISA BISANYA JADI MAHAWANGSA MELAYU WKWK
There is also another side here, nusantara is actually native kutainese name. Sure its roots is javanese word but as local historian mentioned. The land was historically called nusantara before it was renamed in 1300s by aji batara agung dewa sakti, the first kutai king, though its meaning is 'tanah yg terpotong'. Because because the land was in the middle, divided between jahitan layar settlement and kutai lama settlement. At least this is what written in 'geneology of Kutai'.
This could either be a pure genius step or a total catastrophic disaster ..as a neibouring country member I truly hope that this project would bring something good for the people..
This seems like a hit piece rather than a fair journalism. Indonesia have the right to develop and improve their people’s lives. There is more Kalimantan population that support and excited over the project than what is presented.
CNA like to attack other countries. They want to do 'investigative journalism.' But they dare not do on their own country. So they do on other countries. So much for friendly ASEAN relationships
🙏 Best wishes to the New Capital of Indonesia : Nusantara! Hope the many important Flora , Fauna , Rivers & Lakes are protected & preserved while they planned & build-up the New Villages , Suburbia & their Megacity of Administration! Selamat Maju Indonesia! Thank You So Much CNA Insider for this informative & professionally done mini documentary of Indonesia's Nusantara! 🙏🕯🌷🌿🌍💜🕊
The old problem started by its people, moving to new place doesn't mean solving the problem because the same old people will still bring the same problem to the new place. Its the mind set the people needs to change to solve the problem of pollution and messes, not the place.
I observe the news media from Singapore as if it is going to provoke local residents with the Indonesian government and migrants who have long lived in harmony and peace on the island of Kalimantan. Be careful, my fellow countrymen and countrymen, so that we are not pitted against each other by outsiders.
Development is good, however, do not forget the indigenous peoples living in the site of developments. They simply asked for the government to communicate with them and discuss plans for their well-being. I'm for Indonesia's progress as they are one of our trusted partners in the ASEAN region 🇮🇩🇵🇭 Philippines is with you.❤❤
Sebagai orang java sangat mendukung for new capital Nusantara. Berharap dgn pindahnya ibukota semoga pembangunan semakin merata Dan semua rakyat indonesia secara fisik , mentally Dan financialy merdeka seutuhnya Dan merasakan hasil dari kemerdekaan bangsa ini .
@hackieagoncillo1557 You are not an indonesian so this doesn't concern you, so please keep your mouth shut ya? Go worry more about your Manila which is a slum. Who cares if a few indigenous people complain? It's more important to have more job opportunities and put food on the table. They certainly won't be complaining anymore when the money starts flowing in. :)
Let's be clear here: We Indonesian want to have a new capital and moving indonesian capital to other island is a very good idea because Java island is already populated with 150 Million people. So, if there are many challenges, problems, and obstacles, that is the thing that we have to address and solve. The point is, our government is on the track so that we can reach Indonesia vision 2045. As citizen of south kalimantan province, I highly support this project and I hope i will contribute to this development in the future.
@@gondala untuk ente ya. Lihat aja sejarah indonesia spt apa. Uda keliatan kok spt apa ikn nya nanti. Bukan soal pindahnya trus jadi bagus dan keren. Yg mesti di bangun itu SDM NYA. JANGAN TOLOL KAYAK ANDA INI. NEGARA KORUP GINI. NEGARA YG HUKUM NYA TAJAM KEBAWAH. MAU PINDAH KEMANA PUN UJUNG UJUNG NYA RUSAK. SAYA TANYA ANDA DEH. KENAPA JAKARTA BISA SERUSAK ITU? POLUSI UDARA . BANJIRNYA. KARENA SDMNYA. LALU ENTE KIRA DGN PINDAH TRUS SIM SALABIM WOW GITU? NGAK BAKALAN TERJADI HAL2 JELEK ? KASIHAN DEH ANDA BUTANYA PARAH.
Jakarta is not overpopulated, so much as it is under planned. It's low density sprawl with poor infrastructure, which is a very inefficient way to use the land.
@@ryerye9019 politic makes it inefficient. For example. In the Jokowi era, there was a plan to build a proper drinking infrastructure and MRT but by Anies those plans were stopped.
@@kebeleteeek4227 Amerika dan sekutu punya proyek ingin mengambil Papua dan menepis pengaruh China. Salah satunya lewat program pasifica utk semua bangsa2 di kawasan pacific islands termasuk ras Malenesia. Apalagi PNG sdh tanda tangani perjanjian dgn Amrik sehingga Amrik bisa buka military base dimanapun jg di PNG spt yg di ungkapkan oleh mantan dubes Indonesia di Selandia baru, Tantowi Yahya. Mayoritas penduduk Indonesia timur itu bangsa Malenesia. Jadi kalau Indonesia fokus cuma ke barat pembangunannya, ya sdh bisa lepas itu Indonesia timur. Kalau gak tau gak usah lah komentar.
@@MSDGroup-ez6zk Jaka sembung bawa golok ... Alasan loe dibikin2 .. Semua bisa melihat seperti apa proses study akademis IKN .. sosialisasi ...legislasi ...yg semuanya serba grasa-grusu ... Lihat sendiri UU IKN yg beberapa kali direvisi padahal baru kemarin disahkan .. IKN = tipical proyek ugal2an rezim ini ..seperti kereta cepat .. jalan tol ...lumbung pangan ..
Ada baiknya dimulai sekarang diberikan kesempatan beasiswa ikatan dinas/ pedidikan gratis sampai S1 bagi warga lokal di sekitar IKN, sehingga ketika lulus nanti mereka bisa langsung bekerja sebagai PNS di IKN
Nusantara itu skalanya nasional. Menurutku bukan hanya warga lokal yang diberi kesempatan, tetapi dari seluruh indonesia dari aceh sampai papua juga dilibatkan.
ANDA GAK SALAH, TAPI GAK TEPAT. LOKASI IKN ADALAH BEKAS LAHAN HTI (HUTAN TANAMAN INDUSTRI) ADALAH KESEMPATAN EMAS "MENGHILANGKAN" ISTILAH PENDUDUK ASLI, KARENA KETIKA ITU KITA KEMUKAKAN, MAKA AKAN ADA "SENTIMEN" KEDAERAHAN ATAU BAHKAN MENUJU KE "SARA". SESUATU YG LEKAT DENGAN "BETAWI" DI JAKARTA, YG TERUS AKAN DIGEMAKAN POLITISI2 UNTUK KAMPANYE POLITIK. IKN NUSANTARA HARUS MENJADI CERMIN "KEADILAN" TANPA ADA EMBEL2 YG MENYANGKUT "KEDAERAHAN" IKN HARUS JADI "CENTER OF EXCELENT" WARGA NKRI DARIMANAPUN , TERLEPAS EMBEL2 APAPUN. BIARLAH DAERAH DI LUAR IKN YG MENGANGKAT ISU KEDAERAHAN MASING2, TERMASUK PENGEMBANGAN DAN PELESTARIAN BUDAYANYA !!! 😊
Pendirian IKN saya yakin sudah di kaji oleh para ahli, tidak asal asalan pasti memikirkan yang terbaik untuk negeri ini, bila ada pendapat lain itulah negeri demokrasi. IKN lanjuuut....
Wkwk warga lokal ikn. Orang area pembangunanya aja di bekas hutan produksi,bukan lingkup penduduk. Dan asal eluh tau warga sekitar juga ada yg kerja di pembangunan ikn ini, setidaknya sudah di berdayakan.
As an Indonesia, I highly support this project and looking forward to it. My concern is that the government should really consider about the human resource development with high standard of education. There should be the best elementary school, junior & high school, and also the best university that integrated with world-class standard. The government also have to consider about the future community there, what is going to be look like and feel like... is it a community like Singapore or Washington or other cities for example. A lot of considerations but I think if we can focus and plan it really well, I think we can make it... The human resource development in education can be a solution not to only to a green capital city but also the green sustainable Indonesia. We have to think how to solve the problems for long term and massive effect not only just whining and complaining without any solutions... this is my proposal to Indonesia government and any stakeholders
Pemindahan ibukota ini urusan internal negara kami Ngak ada urusannya sama media luar yang selalu menganggap buruk terhadap pembangunan Indonesia Jadi stop untuk menjelekkan negara kami Kami yang tahu situasi negara kami Ibukota dipindahkan bukan se olah olah hanya sebagai temeg politik tapi karena beban Jakarta yang sudah berat.
haha banyak media luar dan juga sekitar negara kita yang kritik masalah lingkungan padahal mungkin pemerintah nanti juga udah secara matang siapkan menjaga ekosistem alam yang di sana Padahal cape jakarta macet mulu jabodetabek mulu ya aneh orang luar
Saya sangat mendukung pembangunan di seluruh pelosok Indonesia untuk kemakmuran rakyat, mari kita kawal agar lancar dan juga kontrol, pengawasan agar alam di kalimantan tidak rusak dan tetap harmoni.
Betul negara maju menekan negara miskin untuk menjaga lingkungan tapi mereka diam2 mengambil mengekploitasi kekayaan alam negara miskin tanpa memperhatikan lingkungan sekitar. Negara mereka tetap terlihat bersih dan tanpa dosa
Indonesia for Indonesian... Jangan gaduh2 lagi yah.. Teruskan usahamu bersama2 sehingga berjaya.. InshaAllah terus bersama2 hinga ke Jannah juga... Aaminn
We indonesian people and kalimantan people and Goverment agree and support New Capital City of Indonesia Nusantara. This project plant since first president ir. Soekarno.
I observe the news media from Singapore as if it is going to provoke local residents with the Indonesian government and migrants who have long lived in harmony and peace on the island of Kalimantan. Be careful, my fellow countrymen and countrymen, so that we are not pitted against each other by outsiders.
As an Indonesian, I am proud and support the construction of the new capital of Indonesia by Indonesians, not the legacy of the Dutch colonialists. Keep the spirit of the workers who are building the new capital of Indonesia. 🧡🧡
U tell me what that's u not proud of in the context of Indonesia ? Ur make shift football team for the AFF tournament ini Thailand 2023 were hail as heros (after winning against Timor Leste) Lol, which in fact their assignments was only to tryout news players & formation & if the results does not goes to ur liking, then as usual a lot of excuses is ready at hand, from bad refereeing to god knows u guy can think of. My personal views is to take a look back of the idea put forward by ur previous presidents : that the new capital should be somewhere in jawa not too far from Jakarta which will not bring hardships to many govt employees moving & the price tag is not too big . The past president too did research on the issue but what to cap the price tag to manageable control. Now the money in thrown in like a dice & the whole country is holding the breath ? Anyhow good luck in this endeavour !
Are you proud that Indonesia is the coloniser of Borneo? Many endangered animals and undiscovered species were murdered by your government. Only 4% of wildlife is left on our planet. Without wildlife, we all die because we need animals to maintain life on earth. Your government has had more than 50 years to create their own legacy, but they chose to copy the West by creating an oil and plastic product economy. That's why Java is so filthy. Your government drills for oil in Sumatra and they make it into to cheap petrol and plastic products for people on Java. And then you all litter the ocean with it. And now you will colonize the 1 million year old island of Borneo and destroy it the same way you all destroyed Java. Is that something to be proud of?
Hi 👋🏻 I would like to ask Indonesians directly about potential existence slum areas (kawasan kumuh) dominated by non-Kalimantan people around/outside IKN (that might cause troubles to local Kalimantan villages/small towns). So, what’s government plans to prevent this situation happen in future just like what happened to Jakarta today?
Penglihatan masa depan seorang pemimpin dan warga biasa tentu bnyk bedanya, pemimpin melihat 10 bahkan 50 atau 100 tahun yg akan datang, sedang warga biasa umumnya hanya melihat satu sampai 5 tahun kedepannya. Menurut gw sdh saatnya ibukota pindah diluar Jawa, yg akan berimbas dgn pemerataan pembangunan diluar pulau Jawa. Konflik tetep ada, tapi dgn komunikasi yg baik, demi masa depan anak cucu kita jg, gw yakin, semua masalah akan teratasi. Ibukota yg bersatu dgn alam adalah ibukota yg sangat cocok temanya utk Indonesia kedepannya. Kota modern, tapi menyatu dgn alam... Btw, saran gw buat channel ini, ambil narasumber yg seimbang, antara yg menentang pembangunan ikn dgn yg mendukungnya, supaya terkesan lebih fair, klo gw lihat agak kurang, karena narasumber dari pemerintah akan terlihat hanya membela diri, beda klo diambil dari masyarakat umum. Jayalah Nusantara, jayalah Indonesia ku 🙏🇲🇨
benar. masyarakat ini hanya memikirkan jangka pendek saja, mereka tida tau masalah yang melanda ibu kota saat ini, pengamat2 juga sok2 an menilai ini terburu2, kalo bukan skarang kapan lagi ? nunggu Jakarta tenggelam baru bangun ibukota ? yang ada telat malah roda pemrintahan tidak berjalan. dan lucunya ini chanel ga ambil masyarakat yang mendukung. sebagai pembanding.
I hope that Mr. Bambang and the team will always be given health and enthusiasm and high dedication to achieve and realize the government's goals, but the needs and rights of the people around him should be given proper attention and attention to the impact of social culture
Its about time to spread the development evenly all over Indonesia.. so many years in some part Indonesia was left untouched..Hopefully what is start with good intention will end up with good result too
1:27: 💼 Indonesia is building a new capital city called New Santara, with the first phase expected to be completed by 2022 and the entire project by 2045. 6:35: 🏢 The construction of the new capital city, Nusantara, is progressing but not without controversy and concerns from local villagers. 15:28: 🏢 The construction of the new Indonesian capital, Nusantara, raises concerns about potential repressive actions, ethnic tensions, and lack of community representation. 25:09: ⚠ Construction of Indonesia's new capital, Nusantara, raises concerns about environmental damage and the implementation of green practices. 35:29: 🏙 Jakarta, the crowded and flood-prone capital of Indonesia, is sinking under its own weight, leading to plans to relocate the capital to New Santara by 2045. 43:25: 🏢 Indonesia's upcoming presidential election may determine the fate of the new capital project, with potential continuity under certain candidates and uncertainty under others. Recap by Tammy AI
Pastinya pemerintah sekarang maupun yang akan datang pasti akan melakukan yang terbaik untuk masyarakat kalimantan. Agar pembangunan merata dan seluruh rakyat Indonesia merasakan pembangunan. Pastinya ada negara2 tetangga yang merasa iri dan tidak mau melihat indonesia lebih maju. Apapun itu.......Kami rakyat Indonesia mendukung apapun yang pemerintah lakukan demi kemaslahatan seluruh rakyat Indonesia. Terutama bagi warga dan masyarakat kalimantan itu sendiri,agar tidak tersingkir dari daerahnya sendiri. Utamakan bagi kesejahteraan rakyat kalimantan dan seluruh rakyat Indonesia.
why Indonesia need new capital? it's already planned since the Independecen of Indonesia, Jakarta previously batavia was initially seaport build by dutch on marsh land, it never intended to last long for massive population is there any controversies? of course every mega project always have controversies, but they try to solve it together and always open to communication with many all of stakeholder. for those that think Indonesia government enslave the indigenous people there and relocate their ancestry land: we don't know for sure the real conflict but many times the conflict of relocation happened because they never register their own land to get ownership certificate and also not paying the land taxes, In Indonesia every inch of land is belong to Indonesia government for Indonesian so there's no pure ownership of the land, also Sampit Incident that mentioned at 15:49 happen in central kalimantan in 2001, meanwhile the location of IKN is in east kalimantan, two different place and not happened recently. the location of IKN itself is on production forest, back in 70-80s the 2nd president of Indonesia held transmigration program to populate island outside java, so basically most of people that have land there are people that join that program and not indigenous to that land either. so they can claim it's their ancestry land but they will never have evidence to backup their claims, but I don't believe Indonesia under Joko widodo will let the relocation happen without compensation even though they have no proof of ownership, instead many people from various land in Indonesia waiting to get relocation compensation because they usually give 3 times the price of their land if they have the certificate of ownership and plentiful compensation money for people that even don't have the certificate of ownership. FYI: most of Indonesian, if you ask them, I am sure 100% they never acknowledge green party of Indonesia existence, because I even just heard it from this video, so it's funny to include their opinion as the representation of Indonesia socio-politic situation in Indonesia new capital.
Every projects small or big will always have challenges, expect the unexpected. Impossible to make everyone happy...environmental issues happen everywhere in the world. How about reclamation project in SG for example. "Biarkan anjing menggonggong kafilah tetap berlalu".
yaaa begitulah mereka.. seolah2 takut dengan masa depan Nusantara yg bakal menarik banyak investor mengalahkan negaranya. soal merusak lingkungan sebenarnya mereka lebih parah.. lihat saja satu pulau mereka hutannya dibabat habis dibangun kilang minyak raksasa SHELL.. Bayangin sendiri betapa rusaknya ekosistem disana.
As an Indonesian, i am against this rushed capital moving for these reasons : 1. The scientific paper / assessment that was made as one of the legal prerequisite of moving the capital lack of comprehensive analysis. 2. The environmental impact assessment of moving the capital (we use to call it AMDAL in Indonesia) is not made available to public. An NGO once try to ask the said assessment on certain project within the new capital, but denied by the govt. under the pretext of state's secret 3. The plan of moving the capital was made top-down, from the president himself in 2018/19 without further consultation or public hearing. Since the parliament is ruled by a large coalition parties (85-90%) supporting the president, no significant critics was made on the plan to move the capital 4. The Law of the new Capital was made only in 42 days, fastest ever in Indonesia. The draft was not made public initially, and was not discussed properly. The Faculty of Law of Universitas Mulawarman in Kalimantan once protested this hasty public hearing, since the draft of Law governing the new capital was only made available for review only hours before a public discussion. The discussion itself was only "arranged" to fulfill the formalities, rather than a real public scrutiny
Well, people nowadays really take names (and naming) for granted. Name is not only about popularity of the name and its context. There is more behind the name, behind the letters. Who, do you think, create the word "Nusantara"? If "Nusantara" feels unifying, whose prespective are we using?
@@fcapcomjaka8546 Nusantara literally means islands in the middle of oceans. If that isn't unifying to you, Idk what is. I sense, this artificially made up problem behind the naming concern is raised just to show off to prove his/her existence or want to take advantage of racial conflict in Indonesia.
@@fcapcomjaka8546 your assumption that Nusantara only represent certain ethnic group is very narrow minded. You can see Malaysians once protest the naming of Nusantara as the new capital of Indonesia because they thought it would imply that territories of Malaysia to be under Nusantara's authority. And Malaysian Malay considered "Nusantara" to be part of their legacy because it symbolises the glory of "Alam Melayu" which they taught at education academics as "Mahawangsa Melayu". So actually Malays are proud and considered the word Nusantara as part of their legacy and civilization. We do know that Kalimantan has Huge population of Malay ethnic throughout the island.. hence Banjar Malays, Bruneian, Sabah, Sarawak, etc. Second, CNA also aired the conversation with the environmental activist about the effect of EV battery and so it implies that Nusantara is wholly blamed in this part... This is truly hypocritical and biased on CNA!! If the objection was because it exploit nature from nickel mining, then CNA should also blame and shame Singapore, America, Elon Musk, and other developed countries who also welcoming EV to be part of their green transformation!!! Despite that Nusantara already projected that 70%+ of the people mobility to be based on Public Transport, Walking, and Bicycle lane... CNA forgot to mention this Ratio!! Now you see how CNA is truly biased here.
@@crysed7897 CNA is owned by Mediacord, a Singapore's state-owned entity. LOL ... And by nature, Singapore is very strict in censoring anything, leads to its sad position in Global Press Freedom index, far below Indonesia. What do you expect?
Dimana mana klo ada pembangunan pasti ada perubahan ekosistem tidak di Indonesia maupun di negara barat atau Eropa,..semua pasti berubah dan itu pasti, tp dibalik itu semua kedepan semua akan menikmati...karena pemerintah tidak memikirkan individu atau kelompok, pemerintah Indonesia memikirkan kelangsungan hidup seluruh rakyat Indonesia....media asing hanya meliput apa yang menjadi kekurangan dan dampak negatifnya, itu biasa dan pers juga mesti memberikan informasi yang balance....
Sudah sepantasnya uang orang kaya Indonesia tidak di simpan di bank Singapura ,tapi mengalir di pembanguna ibukota NUSANTARA,Tentu orang pintar Singapura dapat Andil di proyek ini,karna ibu kota ini tidak kekurangan lahan,seperti yang di Alami singapura. Ide ide besar pun dapat di terapkan di wujudkan Di ibukota NUSANTARA👏👏👏
@@cristianhan5325 Oh iyakah? baguslah kalo benar begitu, tapikan pengusaha kaya di Indonesia bukan cuma mereka. contoh kecil aja Indomaret sama Alfamart aja belum ada invest kesana.
dulu teriak jawa sentris kekayaan kalimantan di keruk untuk bangun jawa lalu kalimantan di tinggal, giliran kalimantan mau di bangun teriak jawa merusak kalimantan kami merusak hutan dan satwa, kan kamprett dengarnya🤣, terus sumpah dari dulu gue lihat orang2 aktfis adalah kumpulan orang2 sok, kalau bacotan mereka di denger negri ini ngak akan maju2 sebab yg ngak harusnya di bacotin masih aja bacot, kan jelas2 tuh lokasinya itu hutan produksi, orang utan jenis apa yg tinggal di hutan produksi wkwk
CNA, singapore, malaysia dn SJW itu EUROCENTRIST, di sponsori oleh barat, yg ga happy negara bekas jajahan maju, memproses sumber daya alamnya sendiri. Ga rela imdonesia itu non blok, makanya diskreditkan, krn ga nurut utk d jajah. Kolonialisme modern itu kalau bs mempengaruhi opini masyarakatnya spy ga percaya sama negara dn bangsa sendiri, hanya percaya dgn negara penjajah.
Kerusakan lingkungan gak bisa dihindari selama populasi dunia makin banyak, yang bisa manusia lakuin cuma pengendaliannya aja. Kalo manusia terus makin banyak, kita harus nyari planet baru supaya bumi gak makin rusak
People keep forgetting Indonesia is as wide as the USA. Outside Jakarta the rest of Indonesia is very rural. I'm glad there will be a new capital in Indo. Even Bali is just resorts & kampungs (villages). Borneo/Kalimantar is the worlds' third largest island yet the Indonesian side are only dirt roads & villages compared to the wealthy palaces of Brunei on the same island.
You call Surabaya, Bandung and Bekasi rural? Even Bali is just resorts? Bali is a very small island solely existing for tourism, ofcourse it’s mainly resorts. And still the capital Denpasar is bigger than Amsterdam for instance.
@@ct0332 it’s not about the size. It’s the lack of proper infrastructure. Sri Lanka is big and has a ghost airport but the lack of transits, clean water, & sewer/waste make me say it’s rural af too
@@kevinmanan1304 a place is rural when theres no cities. And by your standards, basically the whole world is rural, excepts the Netherlands and England. Because for as far as I know Indonesias infrastructure isn’t worse than your average Western country. Literally only England and the Netherlands stand out. But you had me questioning myself so I googled it. Nowhere is the word rural described in the same sentence with infrastructure. Nowhere.
I reckon we're facing a decision: whether to stick with Jakarta as our capital, even though it's sinking and super polluted, or shift to a different area nearer to other parts of Indonesia. The new capital could be much cleaner, with way less pollution and no crazy traffic jams. Of course, we can't make everyone happy. But it's worth noting that most Indonesians and even the local Kalimantan governments are backing this idea.
Borneo will be the same as Jakarta. There will be plastic trash, many cars, a lot of pollution, and a lot of crime. The only difference is that it will be bigger and new. If I'm wrong, what evidence is there that anything will be different? Also, what about climate change? The earth will be hotter and have stronger typhoons becuase your government killed millions of ancient trees which were taking carbon out of the air.
You guys destroying Borneo!....all these while the federal govt has been neglecting the native in Kalimantan. We are watching Jakarta 2.0 in the making... selfish ambition.
@@TeacherKenEnglish bruh, climate change just because Indonesia clear few "Forest" (actually is more of ex mining area) is too farfatch, people like overblown the impact of enviroment and climat change for the new capital. if you concern much, ask your goverment to replant those threes and forest that your country cleared during industrial revolution in 1900s, ist time for Indonesia to grow and industrialize, Climat change crisis is not only responsibility of Indonesia, YOUR COUNTRY MUST TAKE RESPONSIBILITY TOO !! Of course it will be diffrent, Jakarta is not suppose to be capital, its designed by dutch hundered years ago, IKN is planned ground up to be a modern better cities, you look at aother cities in Indonesia, is much better and more cleaner.
@@Noy201-i3p this is how you comment without thinking first. you just believe what media show you without critical thinking. 1. Building capital in Kalimantan is to improve native Kalimantan standards of living. 2. promote population distribution ,right now Java is too crowded, Kalimantan is much bigger and still have less population. 3. is to promote development on the eastern part of Indonesia that is neglected in favour of Java for many years, this time. Indonesia centric development, etaher then Java centric development.
We're already in the debt trap.e don't have enough money left, them said we're already on the edge of bankruptcy, so how you come up with the idea of, IKN, should we have to make a new debt. 😅
Well explained by the authority of IKN. Good job. Same things were also happenned in Singapore and elsewheres in the world dealing with social and environment. Maju!
This video from CNA Singapore sounds more like instigating dissent & discontent, when all avenues are open for dialog and compensation. At the end of the day, the benefits of #Nusantara outweigh the alleged downsides, remember this capital relocation project started many decades ago (more than half century), long before the critics were even born.
A similar question to Singapore, as the Kra isthmus Canal in Thailand is opened, is Singapore ready for bankruptcy? MYOB don't underestimate Indonesia.
betul sama awal indonesia merdeka😅 banyak yg ragukan apakan indonesia bisa berumur panjang? karna 1300 etnis suku😂😂😂 kenyataannya Mereka salah😂😂 justru yg etnisnya sedikit malah perang melolo😂😂 ada yg sibuk cari jatidiri😂😂
Nusantara name is not a Java-centric, its from Sansekerta (Sanskrit) languages originally from Indian-Hinduism and it was name of a place in Kutai Kingdom in East Kalimantan, one of the oldest Hindus kingdom in Indonesia, but then it become more popular when Gajah Mada (Majapahit) say it, even Malaysia also knows the Nusantara meaning. So Nusantara originally came from Kalimantan/ Borneo Island. Stop using google as your source of information CNA.
Nusantara.. Nusa means Island.. Antara means Between.. so Between Island.. NAJIS NUSANTARA DARI BORNEO WKWK NUSANTARA YG DIMAKSUD MAJAPAHIT ITU KEPULAUAN YG DISEBUT DALAM SUMPAH PALAPA GAJAH MADA.. BTW KERAJAAN KUTAI ITU KAGA ADA.. KERAJAAN KUTAI ITU NAMA ASLINYA TIDAK PERNAH DIKETAHUI.. INI FAKTA LO CEK SENDIRI.. DI PRASASTI MANAPUN KAGA PERNAH ADA YG NYEBUT TENTANG KERAJAAN KUTAI.. DINAMAKAN KERAJAAN KUTAI KARENA BUKTI BUKTI KERAJAAN DITEMUKAN DI DAERAH KUTAI KARTANEGARA DI ERA MODERN.. JAMAN DULU KUTAI SENDIRI BELOM ADA 😂😂 ELO NGARANG BAE..
Yes historically Nusantara (other than the javanese meaning) have also local kurai ese meaning its 'Tanah Jang Terpotong' (quoted directly from Salasilah Kutai) because when Aji batara Agung dewa sakti founded the new kutai settlement the land called nusentara (pronounced nusantara) is located in the middle and was divided by jahitan layar settlement and old kutai settlement.
@@riduanapplebeeKata ini kan dari sansekerta dari dwipantara yg pertama kali ditulis ada di parasasti Kertanegara tahun 1200san. Intinya jaman itu Kertanegara kan mau nantangin Yuan dinasti mongol di Cina dengan bikin bullwark/aliansi persatuan dengan kerajaan sekitar. Jadi bukan diluar dugaan ada kontak dari singasari dan Kutai. Sehingga org kutai juga tau kata nusantara/dwipantara itu. Ada banyak bahasa yg terpengaruh sansekerta bisa saja kata nusantara itu dimaknai berbeda dalam cerita cerita lokal. Majapahit dengan Gajah Mada cuma melakukan iterasi kedua dari dwipantara kertanegara jadi Nusantara. Makanya Negarakretagama juga tulis Kute kan karena ada kontak. Perubahan makna kata itu natural kok terjadi di bahasa manapun dan setiap hari. Intinya dari cerita lokal ya (kutipan salasilah kutai) namanya dulu nusantara artinya tanah yg terpotong, karena lokasinya diantara Jahitan Layar dan Kutai Lama. Malah itu bukti bagus bahwa memang Nusantara itu ada di masa lampau dan menjangkau wilayah Kalimantan disini. Itu malah memperkaya sejarah bangsa kita.
As someone from the deep part of Borneo. You might not know how happy my people is when we heard this was going to happen. Wealth distribution should be evenly distributed.
Siapkan SDM Kalimantan. Jika SDM Kalimantan rendah bagaimana bisa bersaing dengan orang" luar pulau Kalimantan. Lulus an SMA tidak berlaku. Semoga anda mengerti apa yang saya bicarakan 😊😊
The name of Nusantara is from java, yeah that's right. But lets open the history book of Indonesia. The name of "Indonesia" itself is come from outside, not from local. Indonesia means Archipelago that placed in Indian Ocean. At least Nusantara is come from local name. Not from outside.
"Java" also means barley in Sanskrit, which Indonesians no longer eat. The island should be called rice. 😅 There is a lot of enthno nationalism in Indonesia from people who never studied history. They think it's like a football team. People here suffer from an inferiority complex. Everyone is their enemy... so they never learn and adapt.
Istilah Nusantara memang terkenal di masa majapahit. Tp sebenarnya kata itu berusia lebih tua lagi yakni di era kutai kartanegara sebuah kerajaan besar di kalimantan
^Maybe Indonesia can adopt some of the practices other nations had done when there was a mass migration of new settlers. e.g 14:15 Taiwan provided multiple support in education for indigenous citizens - in both fund and fixed spots for top-tier education (that are usually reserved for the top % from university exams) In short; so while this won't bring any immediate benefits, their next generation will be able to successfully benefit from the nation's development which in term will also improve living standard as a whole. What I am more concerned about is... a large portion of the development fund > AKA the PIE will be eaten up by the construction developer (and those who engaged with them which includes real estate and house/land flippers). It's best to have a price regulation earlier on > e.g House/land cannot be sold for more than 2-5% above the price it was brought if the initial transaction was within a year. House can not be flipped by more than 5-8 or 10 percent if the land/house hasn't been owned for more than 3 years and so on. > Aka don't present a similar mistake (despite its good for government revenue) that many major cities of other developed/developing nations made where it became inaccessible for most of the actual settlers. Prohibit transactions for those who may take advantage of old settlers for their land too (many might not be aware of their land value in 5-10 years and sold them off cheaply since they may be economically distressed due to 2020-2023 global events. There has been more than x example where contracts are made and massive profits is given to developers... and they vanish x years later when problems manifest (or had already rebranded). Gov needs to make sure the developer already have sufficient funding to finish the projects on its own before collecting fund from new home buyer (there is also the example of a Korean who owns over 100 home despite his actual fund being... and when interest rate raise = bankrupt)
Apakah ini bentuk kecemburuan Singapura atas kemajuan ekonomi Indonesia sehingga mereka membangun narasi seperti ini lewat media mereka? 😂, negara kecil tidak akan pernah mengerti bagaimana mengelola negara sebesar indonesia
Sepertinya iya, isi dari video ini hanya kritik yang menjurus ke provokasi memberitakan pembangunan IKN mesrusak lingkungan di tempat lain, apakabar reklamasi besar-besaran di Singapura mengeruk pasir dari negara lain yg juga merusak ekologi asalnya, Lawak.
@@roniarwandi385Banyak banget yg kritik dari banyak yg katanya antivis lingkungan sampa partai ecek-ecek, partai hijau apaan coba di Indonesia. LOInya udh ada 200san, lebih banyak domestik kalo g salah. Tapi dari yg international ada 20an dari Singapur knapa ga tanya mereka. Itu emg masih loi tapi yg mau bangun juga udh ada 7 investor lokal ada pakubuwono, rs hermina etc kenapa ga diwawancara. Ini emg cuma hit piece engga netral.
@@abcddef2112 haha banyak media luar dan juga sekitar negara kita yang kritik masalah lingkungan padahal mungkin pemerintah nanti juga udah secara matang siapkan menjaga ekosistem alam yang di sana
tak akan ada negara yng akan membantu Indonesia untuk maju kalo bukan kita sendiri,yang ada mereka akan mengganggu.kita lah yng menentukan nasib kita sendiri bukan orang lain!!!
Percayalah Pemerintah tdk akan menyingkirkan Masyarakat lokal begitu aja,,, Ambil positifnya/ tetap berpikir positif,,, demi kebaikan bagi kita Semua sebagai sebuah bangsa dan juga bagi pembangunan lokal/ pembangunan pulau Kalimantan secara umum termasuk di dalamnya Masyarakat lokal. Apapun yg akan terjadi ke depan'nya,,, yakinlah Pemerintah tdk akan merugikan Masyarakat lokal.
Kesel deh sama yg cuma bs kasih masalah dan pesimis aja kerjaannya, tp gak ada solusi dan seolah olah kita sebagai bangsa gak akan mampu mewujudkan karya karya besar. Inget gak tuh pas dl tahun 1990 an mau bangun MRT di Jakarta, gak jd jd dibangun karena orang orang yg katanya pakar cuma bs kasih masalah masalah dan bersifat pesimis kita bisa ngerjain. Skrg udah ada MRT di Jakarta, semua orang hepi dan gak ada masalah masalah itu, bahkan MRT kita itu gak kalah sm Singapura dan Tokyo. Ayolah guys, jgn pesimis, dan cuma bs ngasih masalah tanpa kasih solusi. Ini bangsa lg ngebangun, kl isi nya kita selalu khawatir, dan gak optimis, gak akan pernah maju lah kita ini.
CNA always focus on negative angles. Remember when pandemic happen? CNA made video about how bad and mismanaged indonesia gov. in handling the pandemic.
i know CNA tried to 'cover both sides' for this topic, but me as Indonesian would like to confirm that MAJORITY of indonesian people and experts are supportive about this new capital. Funny enough that the Jakarta's sinking is a narrative dominating in foreign medias, while the most concerning issue for Indonesians are multidimensional inequality between Java (and to some degree, the whole western Indonesia) vs eastern Indonesia. Seeing the climate and resources, there's ABSOLUTELY NO reason for our population to be concentrated on Java only: Freshwater is abundant in most of the archipelago except eastern nusa tenggara. Weather is nice everywhere throughout the year. All coasts are suitable for seaport. Natural resources are abundant everywhere, etc. Even geologically, Java is the worst option to build a capital. It's right at the volcanic ring of fire. the reasons people gathered in Java are all caused by human: politics, history, and economy. These are the problem our president try to solve by 'forcing' all the attention from Java to other islands. And East Borneo fits all the requirements.
Just like the narrator always said throughout this video “Building a NEW city from scratch” Of course it will bring some damage to the environment and indigenous people surroundings. However, the current bad impact of this new capital won’t be that long lasting as long as the government commit to give fair compensation for the evicted people and continue to preserve the ecosystem around the new capital. But if Indonesia keep on waiting for God knows how long to actually move the capital from Jakarta, the future bad impact will be even more catasthropic. Jakarta is now over populated, over polluted, and it’s sinking every single day. And I don’t think most of Indonesians want to see it happen in the next few years. So, from my point of view, I agree that this capital movement is crucial for Indonesia’s future.
since lam just ordinary citizen, I would like just say give them the goverment another Chance to prove their planning. I know there ane so many bad experience,track record concerning how the governmen dealing with such environmentally issue.but I believe there are also transforming moves and efforts to achieve the ideal condition where all parties Involved get their decent Right
The more people say negative things, the more they fear the progress of this great country. Let the dogs bark, the caravan continues to pass... keep moving forward, don't mind the barking dogs... Glory to Greater Indonesia !
Don't assume this project is always negative. These negative thoughts continue to be expressed by people who don't like Indonesia becoming a developed country. We certainly hope that we can go through the stages and continuity of moving the capital city smoothly and that we can synergize the energy of various components of the nation into a powerful force in supporting the realization of a future city that acts as a catalyst for Indonesia's progress. By realizing an environmentally friendly smart city, IKN is expected to be able to become a magnet for new economic growth and a center for innovation in accelerating Advanced Indonesia 2045. Hopefully. 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
With all its struggles, this country has been independent for a considerable period of time; it is also the largest country in Southeast Asia and it has one of the largest populations, but the way they navigate this project is like having the brain of a newborn child.
I support this moving project. Jakarta is overpopulated and flood-prone. After all, it is for greater good. Looking forward to visit Nusantara when it's finished. Bring on eco city!
I wonder those that say Jakarta is over polluted, if they actually will move to Nusantara or not. I think To be fully functional as a capital on 2024 will not be possible, not till at least 2026. And the new capital also need decades of developments after that. Almost all infrastructure developments in Indonesia built not on schedule. This is a huge project, not just building a tower or a bridge, this is actually building a new capital city
I observe the news media from Singapore as if it is going to provoke local residents with the Indonesian government and migrants who have long lived in harmony and peace on the island of Kalimantan. Be careful, my fellow countrymen and countrymen, so that we are not pitted against each other by outsiders.
"EQUITABLE DEVELOPMENT/INFRASTRUCTURE" This is INDONESIA, not JAVA/JAKARTA only. Infrastructure development must be evenly distributed throughout the Indonesian island because this country is so vast, and Nusantara may be the first step for developing a metropolitan city, so that not only everything is centered on JAVA, especially in JAKARTA.
i hope this project succesfull. Proud as Indonesian. Same like Jakarta native-Betawi Malay, Nusantara native is Kutai Paser Penajam Malay, relatively peacefull ethnic.
I’m native Jakarta and I support this as an Idea and as a real project. Indonesia is a large country, Its about time to think big as well.
Should building Sunda Strait Bridge first not New Capital...
@@raymondlee8160 as I said. Its time to think big. Why don’t we build all of them at the same time ? With the right amount of interest and negotiation, every financial institution will be in front of our door ✌🏼
@@Arset93I had stayed Kemayoran and Bogor in 15 years of my life. I foresee moving capital would fail... We see how the things will go.
Moving the palace to a nicer scenery isn't thinking big. It's small selfish thinking.
Shud reduce the poverty is more important…… this is wasting money on the expense of the poorest
Masyarakat Kalimantan tetap akan diperhatikan Pemerintah krn pemindahan ibu kota juga bertujuan meningkatkan kesejahteraan masyarakat lokal di Kalimantan
Go Indonesia rise higher full support from Philippines 🇵🇭🇮🇩
mabuhay, our beloved neighbour
Let's rise together, neighbour 🙂
ASEAN can make it 💪
Go go go Pres . Widodo, the new capital will make the Phil . and Indonesia fell closer together.
2045 IKN will be 💯 completed. and I will grow old and enjoy the splendor of IKN☺️☺️
Let Indonesia builds their country wisely and sustainable in a better future. So why worry.
Because Chinese are involved!
Because they're doing the exact opposite.
@@Christinebanks11 By whose standard? this report really doesn't speak the truth.. its neat picking what they want to told..
@@Christinebanks11 Lets just bet... in 10 years
#IndonesiaDiatasSegalanya #IndonesiaUberAlles
Iam from Bandung West Java, i really support and apreciate to our govt for moving forward
#IndonesiaDiatasSegalanya #IndonesiaUberAlles
Baru genap satu tahun semenjak dimulainya konstruksi pada tahun 2022 lalu tetapi progres pembangunan nya sudah sejauh itu, kayaknya pemerintah beneran niat buat pindah kesana, semoga semua pekerja lokal yang lembur demi menafkahi keluarganya bisa dapat gaji yang setimpal dengan kinerja mereka.
di mana pekerja local nya 🤣 terang2 di video beritahu 200k pendatang dibawa masuk, harap orang asal dayak bangkit melawan
@@devauxcdv8556Apasi cil, mending tidur aja lu sana
@@devauxcdv8556 200 ribu pendatang itu angka perkiraan yang akan datang ke ikn setelah kota nya jadi , dimana pekerja lokal nya? Banyak tuh orang lokal yang jadi buruh konstruksi proyek 😅
@@devauxcdv8556 semua warga negara indonesia.punya hak yang sma.bebas mencari rejeki di mana saja.di bagian indonesia. org kalimantan bebas menentukan nasipnya mau ke jakarta.mau kebelahan jawa.mau ke bali.mau ke sumatara mau kemana saja.bebas.begitu sebaliknya. Jadi ikn.pasti sagat terbuka buat org org kalimantan yang mau bekerja.di situ asal punya kemampuan.di bidangnya.
@@devauxcdv8556 semua warga negara indonesia.punya hak yang sma.bebas mencari rejeki di mana saja.di bagian indonesia. org kalimantan bebas menentukan nasipnya mau ke jakarta.mau kebelahan jawa.mau ke bali.mau ke sumatara mau kemana saja.bebas.begitu sebaliknya. Jadi ikn.pasti sagat terbuka buat org org kalimantan yang mau bekerja.di situ asal punya kemampuan.di bidangnya.
Media dan pemerintah singapura selalu berusaha menciptakan pertentangan dan perpecahan opini dan pemikiran rakyat indonesia, agar indonesia selalu berkelahi diantara komponen2 anak bangsa nya..tujuan akhirmya mereka dapat selalu mengambil keuntungan besar dari situasi indonesia yg selalu kisruh. Hati2 wahai bangsa indonesia terhadap gerakan ini.
That's right opionion. Singapore like not agree for Indonesia to be better in the future
Iya..anda benar....tetangga kita yg satu ini harus di waspadai..
Betul sekaliiii.. seperti yang pak luhut bilang.. tak ada satupun negara maju yang mau negara berkembang menjadi negara maju.. inilah contoh media press nya
Gk ada sejarah nya orang luar suka lihat negara luar maju. Kalu bukan kita siapa lagi.
wah iya ini chanel milik orang Singapura ya. pantas saja yang diambil adalah orang2 yang g suka sama proyek ini
I as a local community feel proud of this project because the economy will be evenly distributed and in this new mother many native Indonesian trees that are starting to become extinct will be replanted.
Tapi calon urut 1 nolak ikn emang aneh pasangan ini
All the best to Indonesia! I hope the locals can benefit from the new capital, I hope all the complex processes will go on smoothly, I hope your country will prosper even more from this move
I really like the idea of new capital in kalimanatan, this will open new opportunity for us who live in kalimantan to get new development project and new way of life for us Indonesian kalimanatans. The people who disagree about the move and feels like its not the right move could cry for all I care, if we talking about the environment and land acquisition from local people/local tribe land is a legitamate concern, but Outside of that concern I only see people from jakarta whinning that their city will no longer be a capital city, who care if Nusantara has a mall or any of that stuff as long school, water, and hospital is available everything will be allright, if not balikpapan is just 2 hour drive from nusantara, a toll road is gonna be build and the drive hour ia gonna be cut down to serval minute. To jakarta residan who doesn't want to leave then that also okay, more job for us in here in kalimantan. Indonesian as a whole already had enough of more then 7 decade of java development, now its outaide java that need to be build. Jave could've all indonesian wealth but they can't keep getting the development forever if not we from kalimanatan are not Indonesian.
I stay in jakarta and fully support capital move to Nusantara. Hopefully jakarta less traffic and less polluted. Now pollution is crazy
Well said
In fact, most of the people live in Jakarta fully support this Idea. We start to getting annoyed by all of those International forum, official visit and other state ceremony. It’s a business center that already having too much on its plate so this will create less political drama for us 🙈 Good luck with the new city brother 🙌🏽
I am from Java central full support for ours brothers & sisters in Kalimantan to be a city central of Indonesia IKN and full support which government do with all the projects to relocate city of Indonesia to Kalimantan.
Salam brother’s..🙏
Agree
Im an indigenous from central java and fully totally absolutely support IKN strategically and spiritually as well. Good luck my fellow brother in kalimantan
THIS IS WHY CNA IS BEING BIASED HERE, their assumption that Nusantara only represent certain ethnic group is very narrow minded. You can see Malaysians once protest the naming of Nusantara as the new capital of Indonesia because they thought it would imply that territories of Malaysia to be under Nusantara's authority. And Malaysian Malay considered "Nusantara" to be part of their legacy because it symbolises the glory of "Alam Melayu" which they taught at education academics as "Mahawangsa Melayu". So actually Malays are proud and considered the word Nusantara as part of their legacy and civilization. We do know that Kalimantan has Huge population of Malay ethnic throughout the island.. hence Banjar Malays, Bruneian, Sabah, Sarawak, etc.
Second, CNA also aired the conversation with the environmental activist about the effect of EV battery and so it implies that Nusantara is wholly blamed in this part... This is truly hypocritical and biased on CNA!! If the objection was because it exploit nature from nickel mining, then CNA should also blame and shame Singapore, America, Elon Musk, and other developed countries who also welcoming EV to be part of their green transformation!!! Despite that Nusantara already projected that 70%+ of the people mobility to be based on Public Transport, Walking, and Bicycle lane... CNA forgot to mention this Ratio!!
Now you see how CNA is truly biased here.
AGREE, and THEY ONLY WARN ABOUT NUSANTARA ENVIROMENTAL, BUT THEY DO OFTEN RECLAMATION THAT HARM THE SEA!
ISTILAHNYA, TIDAK MENGACA PADA CERMIN
AND NUSANTARA ITSELF CAME FROM THE MOUTH OF JAVANESE PRIME MINISTER OF MAJAPAHIT 😂😂 ALAM MELAYU ALAM MELAYU TAI ANJING LAH WKWK.. ORG MELAYU PEMALAS KOK BISA BISANYA JADI MAHAWANGSA MELAYU WKWK
There is also another side here, nusantara is actually native kutainese name. Sure its roots is javanese word but as local historian mentioned. The land was historically called nusantara before it was renamed in 1300s by aji batara agung dewa sakti, the first kutai king, though its meaning is 'tanah yg terpotong'. Because because the land was in the middle, divided between jahitan layar settlement and kutai lama settlement. At least this is what written in 'geneology of Kutai'.
@@abcddef2112 mantap infonya brooh... salam utk saudara2 ku di kalimantan sana ya dari kami di pelosok jawa tengah
Agree....you are very very smart
This could either be a pure genius step or a total catastrophic disaster ..as a neibouring country member I truly hope that this project would bring something good for the people..
This seems like a hit piece rather than a fair journalism. Indonesia have the right to develop and improve their people’s lives. There is more Kalimantan population that support and excited over the project than what is presented.
What do you expect from a singaporean news ?
@@agnostikisbetter1893Not much I guess.
sg can only hope this megaproject will fail..
CNA like to attack other countries. They want to do 'investigative journalism.' But they dare not do on their own country. So they do on other countries. So much for friendly ASEAN relationships
Singapore takut klo indo maju. Itu fakta.
🙏 Best wishes to the New Capital of Indonesia : Nusantara! Hope the many important Flora , Fauna , Rivers & Lakes are protected & preserved while they planned & build-up the New Villages , Suburbia & their Megacity of Administration! Selamat Maju Indonesia! Thank You So Much CNA Insider for this informative & professionally done mini documentary of Indonesia's Nusantara! 🙏🕯🌷🌿🌍💜🕊
Lol u dreaming
@@alvink1164it's that so?
@@MRezkySyaifullah only dumb people believes that
@@alvink1164 Myanmar Citizen trying to talk about another country moreover the strongest country in the region?? Bro pls, mind ur business first XD
The old problem started by its people, moving to new place doesn't mean solving the problem because the same old people will still bring the same problem to the new place. Its the mind set the people needs to change to solve the problem of pollution and messes, not the place.
The media always highlights the negative side for their own interests. this video is the sample :)
I observe the news media from Singapore as if it is going to provoke local residents with the Indonesian government and migrants who have long lived in harmony and peace on the island of Kalimantan. Be careful, my fellow countrymen and countrymen, so that we are not pitted against each other by outsiders.
that's right opinion 😂
Iyaa betul ini media mana ya?, liputannya kok tendensius sekali
Finally you are realizing it
Development is good, however, do not forget the indigenous peoples living in the site of developments. They simply asked for the government to communicate with them and discuss plans for their well-being. I'm for Indonesia's progress as they are one of our trusted partners in the ASEAN region 🇮🇩🇵🇭 Philippines is with you.❤❤
Sebagai orang java sangat mendukung for new capital Nusantara. Berharap dgn pindahnya ibukota semoga pembangunan semakin merata Dan semua rakyat indonesia secara fisik , mentally Dan financialy merdeka seutuhnya Dan merasakan hasil dari kemerdekaan bangsa ini .
@hackieagoncillo1557
You are not an indonesian so this doesn't concern you, so please keep your mouth shut ya? Go worry more about your Manila which is a slum. Who cares if a few indigenous people complain? It's more important to have more job opportunities and put food on the table. They certainly won't be complaining anymore when the money starts flowing in. :)
This is life, sometimes other think they know better than WE ourselves but they are TOTALLY wrong. GO... IKN...!!!
Let's be clear here: We Indonesian want to have a new capital and moving indonesian capital to other island is a very good idea because Java island is already populated with 150 Million people. So, if there are many challenges, problems, and obstacles, that is the thing that we have to address and solve. The point is, our government is on the track so that we can reach Indonesia vision 2045. As citizen of south kalimantan province, I highly support this project and I hope i will contribute to this development in the future.
Kok nga ke meikarta aja klo gitu
@@alvink1164 berpuluh2 kali sdh dijelaskan jokowi. silakan cari infonya kenapa harus di luar pulau Jawa.
@@gondala ya udah saya tunggu anda dan keluarga anda semuanya pindah ke ikn.
@@gondala ntar one day klo kalimantanya penuh pindah kmn lagi? Papua ya? Hahahaahaa. Aduh aduh otak anda rusak
@@gondala untuk ente ya. Lihat aja sejarah indonesia spt apa. Uda keliatan kok spt apa ikn nya nanti. Bukan soal pindahnya trus jadi bagus dan keren. Yg mesti di bangun itu SDM NYA. JANGAN TOLOL KAYAK ANDA INI. NEGARA KORUP GINI. NEGARA YG HUKUM NYA TAJAM KEBAWAH. MAU PINDAH KEMANA PUN UJUNG UJUNG NYA RUSAK. SAYA TANYA ANDA DEH. KENAPA JAKARTA BISA SERUSAK ITU? POLUSI UDARA . BANJIRNYA. KARENA SDMNYA. LALU ENTE KIRA DGN PINDAH TRUS SIM SALABIM WOW GITU? NGAK BAKALAN TERJADI HAL2 JELEK ? KASIHAN DEH ANDA BUTANYA PARAH.
Jakarta land has been in consolidating stage for years. The Jakarta itself is over populated. The movement is good for the future of capital city.
Jakarta is not overpopulated, so much as it is under planned. It's low density sprawl with poor infrastructure, which is a very inefficient way to use the land.
@@ryerye9019 politic makes it inefficient. For example. In the Jokowi era, there was a plan to build a proper drinking infrastructure and MRT but by Anies those plans were stopped.
IKN = Proyek ugal-ugalan Jokowi ..
@@kebeleteeek4227 Amerika dan sekutu punya proyek ingin mengambil Papua dan menepis pengaruh China. Salah satunya lewat program pasifica utk semua bangsa2 di kawasan pacific islands termasuk ras Malenesia. Apalagi PNG sdh tanda tangani perjanjian dgn Amrik sehingga Amrik bisa buka military base dimanapun jg di PNG spt yg di ungkapkan oleh mantan dubes Indonesia di Selandia baru, Tantowi Yahya.
Mayoritas penduduk Indonesia timur itu bangsa Malenesia. Jadi kalau Indonesia fokus cuma ke barat pembangunannya, ya sdh bisa lepas itu Indonesia timur.
Kalau gak tau gak usah lah komentar.
@@MSDGroup-ez6zk Jaka sembung bawa golok ... Alasan loe dibikin2 ..
Semua bisa melihat seperti apa proses study akademis IKN .. sosialisasi ...legislasi ...yg semuanya serba grasa-grusu ... Lihat sendiri UU IKN yg beberapa kali direvisi padahal baru kemarin disahkan ..
IKN = tipical proyek ugal2an rezim ini ..seperti kereta cepat .. jalan tol ...lumbung pangan ..
Love Indonesia from Turkiye 👍❤️❤️❤️👍
If u see the polutions on jakarta , this past year, its top urgent to move the capital 😊
Plus Jakarta is sinking due to borewell/groundwater extraction
jakarta is like hell now......because of the pollution you can't see the building from the sky
Ada baiknya dimulai sekarang diberikan kesempatan beasiswa ikatan dinas/ pedidikan gratis sampai S1 bagi warga lokal di sekitar IKN, sehingga ketika lulus nanti mereka bisa langsung bekerja sebagai PNS di IKN
Nah,itu ide brilian...Sebelum mereka merasa termarginisasikan...Lebih baik Pemda Prepare dri Skrg...klo Perguruan tinggi Pemerintah pusat bagianya...
Nusantara itu skalanya nasional. Menurutku bukan hanya warga lokal yang diberi kesempatan, tetapi dari seluruh indonesia dari aceh sampai papua juga dilibatkan.
ANDA GAK SALAH, TAPI GAK TEPAT. LOKASI IKN ADALAH BEKAS LAHAN HTI (HUTAN TANAMAN INDUSTRI) ADALAH KESEMPATAN EMAS "MENGHILANGKAN" ISTILAH PENDUDUK ASLI, KARENA KETIKA ITU KITA KEMUKAKAN, MAKA AKAN ADA "SENTIMEN" KEDAERAHAN ATAU BAHKAN MENUJU KE "SARA". SESUATU YG LEKAT DENGAN "BETAWI" DI JAKARTA, YG TERUS AKAN DIGEMAKAN POLITISI2 UNTUK KAMPANYE POLITIK.
IKN NUSANTARA HARUS MENJADI CERMIN "KEADILAN" TANPA ADA EMBEL2 YG MENYANGKUT "KEDAERAHAN" IKN HARUS JADI "CENTER OF EXCELENT" WARGA NKRI DARIMANAPUN , TERLEPAS EMBEL2 APAPUN.
BIARLAH DAERAH DI LUAR IKN YG MENGANGKAT ISU KEDAERAHAN MASING2, TERMASUK PENGEMBANGAN DAN PELESTARIAN BUDAYANYA !!! 😊
Pendirian IKN saya yakin sudah di kaji oleh para ahli, tidak asal asalan pasti memikirkan yang terbaik untuk negeri ini, bila ada pendapat lain itulah negeri demokrasi. IKN lanjuuut....
Wkwk warga lokal ikn. Orang area pembangunanya aja di bekas hutan produksi,bukan lingkup penduduk. Dan asal eluh tau warga sekitar juga ada yg kerja di pembangunan ikn ini, setidaknya sudah di berdayakan.
As an Indonesia, I highly support this project and looking forward to it. My concern is that the government should really consider about the human resource development with high standard of education. There should be the best elementary school, junior & high school, and also the best university that integrated with world-class standard. The government also have to consider about the future community there, what is going to be look like and feel like... is it a community like Singapore or Washington or other cities for example. A lot of considerations but I think if we can focus and plan it really well, I think we can make it...
The human resource development in education can be a solution not to only to a green capital city but also the green sustainable Indonesia. We have to think how to solve the problems for long term and massive effect not only just whining and complaining without any solutions... this is my proposal to Indonesia government and any stakeholders
Is time for Indonesia move the capital, so not all will be centered in Java Island.
Pemindahan ibukota ini urusan internal negara kami
Ngak ada urusannya sama media luar yang selalu menganggap buruk terhadap pembangunan Indonesia
Jadi stop untuk menjelekkan negara kami
Kami yang tahu situasi negara kami
Ibukota dipindahkan bukan se olah olah hanya sebagai temeg politik tapi karena beban Jakarta yang sudah berat.
haha banyak media luar dan juga sekitar negara kita yang kritik masalah lingkungan padahal mungkin pemerintah nanti juga udah secara matang siapkan menjaga ekosistem alam yang di sana
Padahal cape jakarta macet mulu jabodetabek mulu ya aneh orang luar
Saya sangat mendukung pembangunan di seluruh pelosok Indonesia untuk kemakmuran rakyat, mari kita kawal agar lancar dan juga kontrol, pengawasan agar alam di kalimantan tidak rusak dan tetap harmoni.
Betul negara maju menekan negara miskin untuk menjaga lingkungan tapi mereka diam2 mengambil mengekploitasi kekayaan alam negara miskin tanpa memperhatikan lingkungan sekitar. Negara mereka tetap terlihat bersih dan tanpa dosa
Indonesia for Indonesian... Jangan gaduh2 lagi yah.. Teruskan usahamu bersama2 sehingga berjaya.. InshaAllah terus bersama2 hinga ke Jannah juga... Aaminn
Semoga projek berjaya dan menjadi tempat pelancongan baru Indonesia
We indonesian people and kalimantan people and Goverment agree and support New Capital City of Indonesia Nusantara. This project plant since first president ir. Soekarno.
I observe the news media from Singapore as if it is going to provoke local residents with the Indonesian government and migrants who have long lived in harmony and peace on the island of Kalimantan. Be careful, my fellow countrymen and countrymen, so that we are not pitted against each other by outsiders.
All Indonesian people support the new capital of IKN
We Indonesian support these project!
If you not contribute, at least dont disturb😮
As an Indonesian, I am proud and support the construction of the new capital of Indonesia by Indonesians, not the legacy of the Dutch colonialists. Keep the spirit of the workers who are building the new capital of Indonesia. 🧡🧡
U tell me what that's u not proud of in the context of Indonesia ? Ur make shift football team for the AFF tournament ini Thailand 2023 were hail as heros (after winning against Timor Leste) Lol, which in fact their assignments was only to tryout news players & formation & if the results does not goes to ur liking, then as usual a lot of excuses is ready at hand, from bad refereeing to god knows u guy can think of. My personal views is to take a look back of the idea put forward by ur previous presidents : that the new capital should be somewhere in jawa not too far from Jakarta which will not bring hardships to many govt employees moving & the price tag is not too big . The past president too did research on the issue but what to cap the price tag to manageable control. Now the money in thrown in like a dice & the whole country is holding the breath ? Anyhow good luck in this endeavour !
Are you proud that Indonesia is the coloniser of Borneo? Many endangered animals and undiscovered species were murdered by your government. Only 4% of wildlife is left on our planet. Without wildlife, we all die because we need animals to maintain life on earth.
Your government has had more than 50 years to create their own legacy, but they chose to copy the West by creating an oil and plastic product economy. That's why Java is so filthy.
Your government drills for oil in Sumatra and they make it into to cheap petrol and plastic products for people on Java.
And then you all litter the ocean with it. And now you will colonize the 1 million year old island of Borneo and destroy it the same way you all destroyed Java. Is that something to be proud of?
Just just proud...will it actually solve the issue??
Hi 👋🏻 I would like to ask Indonesians directly about potential existence slum areas (kawasan kumuh) dominated by non-Kalimantan people around/outside IKN (that might cause troubles to local Kalimantan villages/small towns). So, what’s government plans to prevent this situation happen in future just like what happened to Jakarta today?
what it football have to do with indonesia new capital ? lol, stop wasting your time troll.@@orgkampong
Penglihatan masa depan seorang pemimpin dan warga biasa tentu bnyk bedanya, pemimpin melihat 10 bahkan 50 atau 100 tahun yg akan datang, sedang warga biasa umumnya hanya melihat satu sampai 5 tahun kedepannya. Menurut gw sdh saatnya ibukota pindah diluar Jawa, yg akan berimbas dgn pemerataan pembangunan diluar pulau Jawa. Konflik tetep ada, tapi dgn komunikasi yg baik, demi masa depan anak cucu kita jg, gw yakin, semua masalah akan teratasi. Ibukota yg bersatu dgn alam adalah ibukota yg sangat cocok temanya utk Indonesia kedepannya. Kota modern, tapi menyatu dgn alam... Btw, saran gw buat channel ini, ambil narasumber yg seimbang, antara yg menentang pembangunan ikn dgn yg mendukungnya, supaya terkesan lebih fair, klo gw lihat agak kurang, karena narasumber dari pemerintah akan terlihat hanya membela diri, beda klo diambil dari masyarakat umum. Jayalah Nusantara, jayalah Indonesia ku 🙏🇲🇨
benar. masyarakat ini hanya memikirkan jangka pendek saja, mereka tida tau masalah yang melanda ibu kota saat ini, pengamat2 juga sok2 an menilai ini terburu2, kalo bukan skarang kapan lagi ? nunggu Jakarta tenggelam baru bangun ibukota ? yang ada telat malah roda pemrintahan tidak berjalan. dan lucunya ini chanel ga ambil masyarakat yang mendukung. sebagai pembanding.
@@egarmaulana5892biasa bang media singapura bukannya selalu cari jeleknya
Setiap kemajuan pasti ada harga nya. Support dari sarawak malaysia.
Small country can never understand it, coz they can never ever move their capital city.
I hope that Mr. Bambang and the team will always be given health and enthusiasm and high dedication to achieve and realize the government's goals, but the needs and rights of the people around him should be given proper attention and attention to the impact of social culture
Its about time to spread the development evenly all over Indonesia.. so many years in some part Indonesia was left untouched..Hopefully what is start with good intention will end up with good result too
Karawang Jawa Barat mendukung IKN Nusantara, semoga pembangunan berjalan lancar sesuai target
Semangat Indonesia🇮🇩
Yes everything will be ready. Indonesia and her people is ready to rise.
Indonesia we did it 🇮🇩🥰
1:27: 💼 Indonesia is building a new capital city called New Santara, with the first phase expected to be completed by 2022 and the entire project by 2045.
6:35: 🏢 The construction of the new capital city, Nusantara, is progressing but not without controversy and concerns from local villagers.
15:28: 🏢 The construction of the new Indonesian capital, Nusantara, raises concerns about potential repressive actions, ethnic tensions, and lack of community representation.
25:09: ⚠ Construction of Indonesia's new capital, Nusantara, raises concerns about environmental damage and the implementation of green practices.
35:29: 🏙 Jakarta, the crowded and flood-prone capital of Indonesia, is sinking under its own weight, leading to plans to relocate the capital to New Santara by 2045.
43:25: 🏢 Indonesia's upcoming presidential election may determine the fate of the new capital project, with potential continuity under certain candidates and uncertainty under others.
Recap by Tammy AI
New Santara, i like the spelling!
New Santara is cool, but the right name is Nusantara
Seems New Santara will become the international name instead of Nusantara... Like Jawa = Java, or Krakatau = Krakatoa.
New santara wrong name but good to hear tho🤣
If the project fail will be call Nisantara
Pastinya pemerintah sekarang maupun yang akan datang pasti akan melakukan yang terbaik untuk masyarakat kalimantan.
Agar pembangunan merata dan seluruh rakyat Indonesia merasakan pembangunan.
Pastinya ada negara2 tetangga yang merasa iri dan tidak mau melihat indonesia lebih maju.
Apapun itu.......Kami rakyat Indonesia mendukung apapun yang pemerintah lakukan demi kemaslahatan seluruh rakyat Indonesia.
Terutama bagi warga dan masyarakat kalimantan itu sendiri,agar tidak tersingkir dari daerahnya sendiri.
Utamakan bagi kesejahteraan rakyat kalimantan dan seluruh rakyat Indonesia.
why Indonesia need new capital?
it's already planned since the Independecen of Indonesia, Jakarta previously batavia was initially seaport build by dutch on marsh land, it never intended to last long for massive population
is there any controversies?
of course every mega project always have controversies, but they try to solve it together and always open to communication with many all of stakeholder.
for those that think Indonesia government enslave the indigenous people there and relocate their ancestry land:
we don't know for sure the real conflict but many times the conflict of relocation happened because they never register their own land to get ownership certificate and also not paying the land taxes, In Indonesia every inch of land is belong to Indonesia government for Indonesian so there's no pure ownership of the land, also Sampit Incident that mentioned at 15:49 happen in central kalimantan in 2001, meanwhile the location of IKN is in east kalimantan, two different place and not happened recently.
the location of IKN itself is on production forest, back in 70-80s the 2nd president of Indonesia held transmigration program to populate island outside java, so basically most of people that have land there are people that join that program and not indigenous to that land either. so they can claim it's their ancestry land but they will never have evidence to backup their claims, but I don't believe Indonesia under Joko widodo will let the relocation happen without compensation even though they have no proof of ownership, instead many people from various land in Indonesia waiting to get relocation compensation because they usually give 3 times the price of their land if they have the certificate of ownership and plentiful compensation money for people that even don't have the certificate of ownership.
FYI: most of Indonesian, if you ask them, I am sure 100% they never acknowledge green party of Indonesia existence, because I even just heard it from this video, so it's funny to include their opinion as the representation of Indonesia socio-politic situation in Indonesia new capital.
Yeahh....i'm wondering about that too...what exactly is green party, never heard of it 🤔
Every projects small or big will always have challenges, expect the unexpected. Impossible to make everyone happy...environmental issues happen everywhere in the world. How about reclamation project in SG for example. "Biarkan anjing menggonggong kafilah tetap berlalu".
yaaa begitulah mereka.. seolah2 takut dengan masa depan Nusantara yg bakal menarik banyak investor mengalahkan negaranya. soal merusak lingkungan sebenarnya mereka lebih parah.. lihat saja satu pulau mereka hutannya dibabat habis dibangun kilang minyak raksasa SHELL.. Bayangin sendiri betapa rusaknya ekosistem disana.
Agreed...some of neighbors just don't want INA to move forward..they want status quo...
As an Indonesian, i am against this rushed capital moving for these reasons :
1. The scientific paper / assessment that was made as one of the legal prerequisite of moving the capital lack of comprehensive analysis.
2. The environmental impact assessment of moving the capital (we use to call it AMDAL in Indonesia) is not made available to public. An NGO once try to ask the said assessment on certain project within the new capital, but denied by the govt. under the pretext of state's secret
3. The plan of moving the capital was made top-down, from the president himself in 2018/19 without further consultation or public hearing. Since the parliament is ruled by a large coalition parties (85-90%) supporting the president, no significant critics was made on the plan to move the capital
4. The Law of the new Capital was made only in 42 days, fastest ever in Indonesia. The draft was not made public initially, and was not discussed properly. The Faculty of Law of Universitas Mulawarman in Kalimantan once protested this hasty public hearing, since the draft of Law governing the new capital was only made available for review only hours before a public discussion. The discussion itself was only "arranged" to fulfill the formalities, rather than a real public scrutiny
it is weird that CNA raises concerns about Nusantara naming... It is very unifying already.
Well, people nowadays really take names (and naming) for granted. Name is not only about popularity of the name and its context. There is more behind the name, behind the letters. Who, do you think, create the word "Nusantara"? If "Nusantara" feels unifying, whose prespective are we using?
@@fcapcomjaka8546 Nusantara literally means islands in the middle of oceans. If that isn't unifying to you, Idk what is. I sense, this artificially made up problem behind the naming concern is raised just to show off to prove his/her existence or want to take advantage of racial conflict in Indonesia.
@@fcapcomjaka8546 your assumption that Nusantara only represent certain ethnic group is very narrow minded. You can see Malaysians once protest the naming of Nusantara as the new capital of Indonesia because they thought it would imply that territories of Malaysia to be under Nusantara's authority. And Malaysian Malay considered "Nusantara" to be part of their legacy because it symbolises the glory of "Alam Melayu" which they taught at education academics as "Mahawangsa Melayu". So actually Malays are proud and considered the word Nusantara as part of their legacy and civilization. We do know that Kalimantan has Huge population of Malay ethnic throughout the island.. hence Banjar Malays, Bruneian, Sabah, Sarawak, etc.
Second, CNA also aired the conversation with the environmental activist about the effect of EV battery and so it implies that Nusantara is wholly blamed in this part... This is truly hypocritical and biased on CNA!! If the objection was because it exploit nature from nickel mining, then CNA should also blame and shame Singapore, America, Elon Musk, and other developed countries who also welcoming EV to be part of their green transformation!!! Despite that Nusantara already projected that 70%+ of the people mobility to be based on Public Transport, Walking, and Bicycle lane... CNA forgot to mention this Ratio!!
Now you see how CNA is truly biased here.
@@crysed7897 CNA is owned by Mediacord, a Singapore's state-owned entity. LOL ... And by nature, Singapore is very strict in censoring anything, leads to its sad position in Global Press Freedom index, far below Indonesia.
What do you expect?
@@fcapcomjaka8546Nusantara originally came from Kutai Kingdom lol, have you even know where’s Kutai Kingdom was?
I'm an Indo-Malay and this is a Big step for us.
Dimana mana klo ada pembangunan pasti ada perubahan ekosistem tidak di Indonesia maupun di negara barat atau Eropa,..semua pasti berubah dan itu pasti, tp dibalik itu semua kedepan semua akan menikmati...karena pemerintah tidak memikirkan individu atau kelompok, pemerintah Indonesia memikirkan kelangsungan hidup seluruh rakyat Indonesia....media asing hanya meliput apa yang menjadi kekurangan dan dampak negatifnya, itu biasa dan pers juga mesti memberikan informasi yang balance....
Sabahan here, happy to see Mr Susantono wore Bornean motived batik.
Sudah sepantasnya uang orang kaya Indonesia tidak di simpan di bank Singapura ,tapi mengalir di pembanguna ibukota NUSANTARA,Tentu orang pintar Singapura dapat Andil di proyek ini,karna ibu kota ini tidak kekurangan lahan,seperti yang di Alami singapura.
Ide ide besar pun dapat di terapkan di wujudkan Di ibukota NUSANTARA👏👏👏
Be careful, they will hunt you, they don't like when Indo spill the truth
para pengusaha belum yakin buat invest kekayaan mereka di IKN karena takut nanti setelah presiden ganti proyek besar ini tidak lanjut
@@XiaoYan72 bukannya Salim, Sedayu, sama Sinarmas invest 40T ya?
@@cristianhan5325 Oh iyakah? baguslah kalo benar begitu, tapikan pengusaha kaya di Indonesia bukan cuma mereka. contoh kecil aja Indomaret sama Alfamart aja belum ada invest kesana.
@@XiaoYan72orang mau investasi gak semudah itu mas
Indonesia Centris, we are ready for the new era of Indonesia.
dulu teriak jawa sentris kekayaan kalimantan di keruk untuk bangun jawa lalu kalimantan di tinggal, giliran kalimantan mau di bangun teriak jawa merusak kalimantan kami merusak hutan dan satwa, kan kamprett dengarnya🤣, terus sumpah dari dulu gue lihat orang2 aktfis adalah kumpulan orang2 sok, kalau bacotan mereka di denger negri ini ngak akan maju2 sebab yg ngak harusnya di bacotin masih aja bacot, kan jelas2 tuh lokasinya itu hutan produksi, orang utan jenis apa yg tinggal di hutan produksi wkwk
CNA, singapore, malaysia dn SJW itu EUROCENTRIST, di sponsori oleh barat, yg ga happy negara bekas jajahan maju, memproses sumber daya alamnya sendiri. Ga rela imdonesia itu non blok, makanya diskreditkan, krn ga nurut utk d jajah.
Kolonialisme modern itu kalau bs mempengaruhi opini masyarakatnya spy ga percaya sama negara dn bangsa sendiri, hanya percaya dgn negara penjajah.
Agree with your opinion
Maklum bang, kadrun kan suka begitu
Kerusakan lingkungan gak bisa dihindari selama populasi dunia makin banyak, yang bisa manusia lakuin cuma pengendaliannya aja. Kalo manusia terus makin banyak, kita harus nyari planet baru supaya bumi gak makin rusak
yea, this activist is an Idiot. CNA capitalize on it.
A tiny village called singapore bubling about Indonesian capital is the most beautiful thing on youtube
No one see your success other than yourself ❤
Only until they see it ,
Then the only then they start to believe in you
YES, ANY GOOD PLAN FOR OUR FUTURE, WE ARE ALWAYS READY
People keep forgetting Indonesia is as wide as the USA. Outside Jakarta the rest of Indonesia is very rural. I'm glad there will be a new capital in Indo. Even Bali is just resorts & kampungs (villages). Borneo/Kalimantar is the worlds' third largest island yet the Indonesian side are only dirt roads & villages compared to the wealthy palaces of Brunei on the same island.
You call Surabaya, Bandung and Bekasi rural? Even Bali is just resorts? Bali is a very small island solely existing for tourism, ofcourse it’s mainly resorts. And still the capital Denpasar is bigger than Amsterdam for instance.
@@ct0332 it’s not about the size. It’s the lack of proper infrastructure. Sri Lanka is big and has a ghost airport but the lack of transits, clean water, & sewer/waste make me say it’s rural af too
@@kevinmanan1304 no, you said rural. You didn’t say proper infrastructure. Your comment was incorrect, that’s it.
@@ct0332 what makes a place rural? Lack of infrastructure. When roads aren’t paved & water causes cholera I say that’s pretty rural.
@@kevinmanan1304 a place is rural when theres no cities. And by your standards, basically the whole world is rural, excepts the Netherlands and England. Because for as far as I know Indonesias infrastructure isn’t worse than your average Western country. Literally only England and the Netherlands stand out.
But you had me questioning myself so I googled it. Nowhere is the word rural described in the same sentence with infrastructure. Nowhere.
Go Indonesia! Take care of your little people please.
I reckon we're facing a decision: whether to stick with Jakarta as our capital, even though it's sinking and super polluted, or shift to a different area nearer to other parts of Indonesia. The new capital could be much cleaner, with way less pollution and no crazy traffic jams. Of course, we can't make everyone happy. But it's worth noting that most Indonesians and even the local Kalimantan governments are backing this idea.
Borneo will be the same as Jakarta. There will be plastic trash, many cars, a lot of pollution, and a lot of crime. The only difference is that it will be bigger and new. If I'm wrong, what evidence is there that anything will be different? Also, what about climate change? The earth will be hotter and have stronger typhoons becuase your government killed millions of ancient trees which were taking carbon out of the air.
You guys destroying Borneo!....all these while the federal govt has been neglecting the native in Kalimantan. We are watching Jakarta 2.0 in the making... selfish ambition.
@@TeacherKenEnglish bruh, climate change just because Indonesia clear few "Forest" (actually is more of ex mining area) is too farfatch, people like overblown the impact of enviroment and climat change for the new capital.
if you concern much, ask your goverment to replant those threes and forest that your country cleared during industrial revolution in 1900s,
ist time for Indonesia to grow and industrialize, Climat change crisis is not only responsibility of Indonesia, YOUR COUNTRY MUST TAKE RESPONSIBILITY TOO !!
Of course it will be diffrent, Jakarta is not suppose to be capital, its designed by dutch hundered years ago, IKN is planned ground up to be a modern better cities, you look at aother cities in Indonesia, is much better and more cleaner.
@@Noy201-i3p this is how you comment without thinking first.
you just believe what media show you without critical thinking.
1. Building capital in Kalimantan is to improve native Kalimantan standards of living.
2. promote population distribution ,right now Java is too crowded, Kalimantan is much bigger and still have less population.
3. is to promote development on the eastern part of Indonesia that is neglected in favour of Java for many years, this time. Indonesia centric development, etaher then Java centric development.
We're already in the debt trap.e don't have enough money left, them said we're already on the edge of bankruptcy, so how you come up with the idea of, IKN, should we have to make a new debt. 😅
Good job Indonesia from your brother in Malaysia
Well explained by the authority of IKN. Good job. Same things were also happenned in Singapore and elsewheres in the world dealing with social and environment. Maju!
MOGA SEMUA WARGA INDONESIA MENDAPAT KEBAIKAN DAN KEUNTUNGAN DARI PROJEK MEGA INI.👍
NUSANTARA , KALIMANTAN 🙏🇮🇩❤
Iam from Lombok , i really support and appreciate to our govt for moving forward ❤
❤ Nusantara 🇮🇩
indonesia really needs this new capital
This video from CNA Singapore sounds more like instigating dissent & discontent, when all avenues are open for dialog and compensation. At the end of the day, the benefits of #Nusantara outweigh the alleged downsides, remember this capital relocation project started many decades ago (more than half century), long before the critics were even born.
A similar question to Singapore, as the Kra isthmus Canal in Thailand is opened, is Singapore ready for bankruptcy? MYOB don't underestimate Indonesia.
Biasalaah.. Media luar tidak suka melihat krmajuan kita.. Yg ditonjolkan cuma konflik2 sosial
betul sama awal indonesia merdeka😅 banyak yg ragukan apakan indonesia bisa berumur panjang? karna 1300 etnis suku😂😂😂 kenyataannya Mereka salah😂😂 justru yg etnisnya sedikit malah perang melolo😂😂 ada yg sibuk cari jatidiri😂😂
I hope everyone is supporting this
Nusantara name is not a Java-centric, its from Sansekerta (Sanskrit) languages originally from Indian-Hinduism and it was name of a place in Kutai Kingdom in East Kalimantan, one of the oldest Hindus kingdom in Indonesia, but then it become more popular when Gajah Mada (Majapahit) say it, even Malaysia also knows the Nusantara meaning. So Nusantara originally came from Kalimantan/ Borneo Island. Stop using google as your source of information CNA.
Nusantara.. Nusa means Island.. Antara means Between.. so Between Island.. NAJIS NUSANTARA DARI BORNEO WKWK NUSANTARA YG DIMAKSUD MAJAPAHIT ITU KEPULAUAN YG DISEBUT DALAM SUMPAH PALAPA GAJAH MADA.. BTW KERAJAAN KUTAI ITU KAGA ADA.. KERAJAAN KUTAI ITU NAMA ASLINYA TIDAK PERNAH DIKETAHUI.. INI FAKTA LO CEK SENDIRI.. DI PRASASTI MANAPUN KAGA PERNAH ADA YG NYEBUT TENTANG KERAJAAN KUTAI.. DINAMAKAN KERAJAAN KUTAI KARENA BUKTI BUKTI KERAJAAN DITEMUKAN DI DAERAH KUTAI KARTANEGARA DI ERA MODERN.. JAMAN DULU KUTAI SENDIRI BELOM ADA 😂😂 ELO NGARANG BAE..
@@riduanapplebee Sorry, use English pls, you looks a person come from villages.
Yes historically Nusantara (other than the javanese meaning) have also local kurai ese meaning its 'Tanah Jang Terpotong' (quoted directly from Salasilah Kutai) because when Aji batara Agung dewa sakti founded the new kutai settlement the land called nusentara (pronounced nusantara) is located in the middle and was divided by jahitan layar settlement and old kutai settlement.
@@riduanapplebeeKata ini kan dari sansekerta dari dwipantara yg pertama kali ditulis ada di parasasti Kertanegara tahun 1200san. Intinya jaman itu Kertanegara kan mau nantangin Yuan dinasti mongol di Cina dengan bikin bullwark/aliansi persatuan dengan kerajaan sekitar. Jadi bukan diluar dugaan ada kontak dari singasari dan Kutai. Sehingga org kutai juga tau kata nusantara/dwipantara itu. Ada banyak bahasa yg terpengaruh sansekerta bisa saja kata nusantara itu dimaknai berbeda dalam cerita cerita lokal. Majapahit dengan Gajah Mada cuma melakukan iterasi kedua dari dwipantara kertanegara jadi Nusantara. Makanya Negarakretagama juga tulis Kute kan karena ada kontak. Perubahan makna kata itu natural kok terjadi di bahasa manapun dan setiap hari. Intinya dari cerita lokal ya (kutipan salasilah kutai) namanya dulu nusantara artinya tanah yg terpotong, karena lokasinya diantara Jahitan Layar dan Kutai Lama. Malah itu bukti bagus bahwa memang Nusantara itu ada di masa lampau dan menjangkau wilayah Kalimantan disini. Itu malah memperkaya sejarah bangsa kita.
Kok bisa kata nusantara dari borneo 😂😂 kalau gak tau sejarah gak usah ngawur 😂😂
We are ready and we are capable. We are a big country, not a small city
Yeay .. Big move for Indonesia Raya❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
As someone from the deep part of Borneo. You might not know how happy my people is when we heard this was going to happen. Wealth distribution should be evenly distributed.
Siapkan SDM Kalimantan. Jika SDM Kalimantan rendah bagaimana bisa bersaing dengan orang" luar pulau Kalimantan.
Lulus an SMA tidak berlaku. Semoga anda mengerti apa yang saya bicarakan 😊😊
@@OtenBenaluIndonesia do you even listen to yourself? Or you’re just being sarcastic?
@@NICH12 entahlah terserah anda 🤷🤷
The name of Nusantara is from java, yeah that's right. But lets open the history book of Indonesia. The name of "Indonesia" itself is come from outside, not from local. Indonesia means Archipelago that placed in Indian Ocean. At least Nusantara is come from local name. Not from outside.
Nusantara come from sanskrit, which is borrowed word from foreign land too😂
"Java" also means barley in Sanskrit, which Indonesians no longer eat. The island should be called rice. 😅
There is a lot of enthno nationalism in Indonesia from people who never studied history. They think it's like a football team. People here suffer from an inferiority complex. Everyone is their enemy... so they never learn and adapt.
Yeah, our people do need to read and learn first before say something.
@@chvhndrtntlr3482no its NOT. NUSANTARA is OLD JAVANESE not SANSKIRT!
Istilah Nusantara memang terkenal di masa majapahit. Tp sebenarnya kata itu berusia lebih tua lagi yakni di era kutai kartanegara sebuah kerajaan besar di kalimantan
^Maybe Indonesia can adopt some of the practices other nations had done when there was a mass migration of new settlers.
e.g 14:15 Taiwan provided multiple support in education for indigenous citizens - in both fund and fixed spots for top-tier education (that are usually reserved for the top % from university exams) In short; so while this won't bring any immediate benefits, their next generation will be able to successfully benefit from the nation's development which in term will also improve living standard as a whole.
What I am more concerned about is... a large portion of the development fund > AKA the PIE will be eaten up by the construction developer (and those who engaged with them which includes real estate and house/land flippers).
It's best to have a price regulation earlier on > e.g House/land cannot be sold for more than 2-5% above the price it was brought if the initial transaction was within a year.
House can not be flipped by more than 5-8 or 10 percent if the land/house hasn't been owned for more than 3 years and so on.
> Aka don't present a similar mistake (despite its good for government revenue) that many major cities of other developed/developing nations made where it became inaccessible for most of the actual settlers. Prohibit transactions for those who may take advantage of old settlers for their land too (many might not be aware of their land value in 5-10 years and sold them off cheaply since they may be economically distressed due to 2020-2023 global events.
There has been more than x example where contracts are made and massive profits is given to developers... and they vanish x years later when problems manifest (or had already rebranded). Gov needs to make sure the developer already have sufficient funding to finish the projects on its own before collecting fund from new home buyer (there is also the example of a Korean who owns over 100 home despite his actual fund being... and when interest rate raise = bankrupt)
Hopefully will benefit Sabah and Sarawak her close neighbors!!!
Wow! Nusantara is 3 time bigger than Singapore our southern neighbors!!!
they will bring haze to sabah and sarawak.
@@fktaufik9252malay
Indonesia it's the time to show them that we are big and bold..
Apakah ini bentuk kecemburuan Singapura atas kemajuan ekonomi Indonesia sehingga mereka membangun narasi seperti ini lewat media mereka? 😂, negara kecil tidak akan pernah mengerti bagaimana mengelola negara sebesar indonesia
Sepertinya iya, isi dari video ini hanya kritik yang menjurus ke provokasi memberitakan pembangunan IKN mesrusak lingkungan di tempat lain, apakabar reklamasi besar-besaran di Singapura mengeruk pasir dari negara lain yg juga merusak ekologi asalnya, Lawak.
@@roniarwandi385Banyak banget yg kritik dari banyak yg katanya antivis lingkungan sampa partai ecek-ecek, partai hijau apaan coba di Indonesia. LOInya udh ada 200san, lebih banyak domestik kalo g salah. Tapi dari yg international ada 20an dari Singapur knapa ga tanya mereka. Itu emg masih loi tapi yg mau bangun juga udh ada 7 investor lokal ada pakubuwono, rs hermina etc kenapa ga diwawancara. Ini emg cuma hit piece engga netral.
@@abcddef2112 haha banyak media luar dan juga sekitar negara kita yang kritik masalah lingkungan padahal mungkin pemerintah nanti juga udah secara matang siapkan menjaga ekosistem alam yang di sana
tak akan ada negara yng akan membantu Indonesia untuk maju kalo bukan kita sendiri,yang ada mereka akan mengganggu.kita lah yng menentukan nasib kita sendiri bukan orang lain!!!
@@1_2_tiga nah
Percayalah Pemerintah tdk akan menyingkirkan Masyarakat lokal begitu aja,,, Ambil positifnya/ tetap berpikir positif,,, demi kebaikan bagi kita Semua sebagai sebuah bangsa dan juga bagi pembangunan lokal/ pembangunan pulau Kalimantan secara umum termasuk di dalamnya Masyarakat lokal.
Apapun yg akan terjadi ke depan'nya,,, yakinlah Pemerintah tdk akan merugikan Masyarakat lokal.
Kesel deh sama yg cuma bs kasih masalah dan pesimis aja kerjaannya, tp gak ada solusi dan seolah olah kita sebagai bangsa gak akan mampu mewujudkan karya karya besar. Inget gak tuh pas dl tahun 1990 an mau bangun MRT di Jakarta, gak jd jd dibangun karena orang orang yg katanya pakar cuma bs kasih masalah masalah dan bersifat pesimis kita bisa ngerjain. Skrg udah ada MRT di Jakarta, semua orang hepi dan gak ada masalah masalah itu, bahkan MRT kita itu gak kalah sm Singapura dan Tokyo. Ayolah guys, jgn pesimis, dan cuma bs ngasih masalah tanpa kasih solusi. Ini bangsa lg ngebangun, kl isi nya kita selalu khawatir, dan gak optimis, gak akan pernah maju lah kita ini.
Kumpulan anjing yang sedang menggonggong.gak usah didengarkan.
This is how CNA always do, they focus and overblow the negative,
and make "Bitching Documentary" about it.
CNA always focus on negative angles. Remember when pandemic happen? CNA made video about how bad and mismanaged indonesia gov. in handling the pandemic.
i know CNA tried to 'cover both sides' for this topic, but me as Indonesian would like to confirm that MAJORITY of indonesian people and experts are supportive about this new capital. Funny enough that the Jakarta's sinking is a narrative dominating in foreign medias, while the most concerning issue for Indonesians are multidimensional inequality between Java (and to some degree, the whole western Indonesia) vs eastern Indonesia. Seeing the climate and resources, there's ABSOLUTELY NO reason for our population to be concentrated on Java only: Freshwater is abundant in most of the archipelago except eastern nusa tenggara. Weather is nice everywhere throughout the year. All coasts are suitable for seaport. Natural resources are abundant everywhere, etc. Even geologically, Java is the worst option to build a capital. It's right at the volcanic ring of fire. the reasons people gathered in Java are all caused by human: politics, history, and economy. These are the problem our president try to solve by 'forcing' all the attention from Java to other islands. And East Borneo fits all the requirements.
IKN country is the best for asia,, surprise to world..✔️
selalu optimis dan mendukung IKN sebagai warga kalimantan timur
Just like the narrator always said throughout this video “Building a NEW city from scratch”
Of course it will bring some damage to the environment and indigenous people surroundings.
However, the current bad impact of this new capital won’t be that long lasting as long as the government commit to give fair compensation for the evicted people and continue to preserve the ecosystem around the new capital.
But if Indonesia keep on waiting for God knows how long to actually move the capital from Jakarta, the future bad impact will be even more catasthropic.
Jakarta is now over populated, over polluted, and it’s sinking every single day. And I don’t think most of Indonesians want to see it happen in the next few years.
So, from my point of view, I agree that this capital movement is crucial for Indonesia’s future.
Good luck Indonesia..im ao excited ans i cant wait to witness this new city ....i hope it will solve many problems in Jakarta ...
since lam just ordinary citizen, I would like just say give them the goverment another Chance to prove their planning. I know there ane so many bad experience,track record concerning how the governmen dealing with such environmentally issue.but I believe there are also transforming moves and efforts to achieve the ideal condition where all parties Involved get their decent Right
The more people say negative things, the more they fear the progress of this great country. Let the dogs bark, the caravan continues to pass... keep moving forward, don't mind the barking dogs... Glory to Greater Indonesia !
Don't assume this project is always negative. These negative thoughts continue to be expressed by people who don't like Indonesia becoming a developed country. We certainly hope that we can go through the stages and continuity of moving the capital city smoothly and that we can synergize the energy of various components of the nation into a powerful force in supporting the realization of a future city that acts as a catalyst for Indonesia's progress. By realizing an environmentally friendly smart city, IKN is expected to be able to become a magnet for new economic growth and a center for innovation in accelerating Advanced Indonesia 2045. Hopefully. 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
This project will have an overarching effect on the economy as well as the country's prestige amongst other countries
Love from India ❤
With all its struggles, this country has been independent for a considerable period of time; it is also the largest country in Southeast Asia and it has one of the largest populations, but the way they navigate this project is like having the brain of a newborn child.
I support this moving project. Jakarta is overpopulated and flood-prone. After all, it is for greater good. Looking forward to visit Nusantara when it's finished. Bring on eco city!
I wonder those that say Jakarta is over polluted, if they actually will move to Nusantara or not. I think To be fully functional as a capital on 2024 will not be possible, not till at least 2026. And the new capital also need decades of developments after that. Almost all infrastructure developments in Indonesia built not on schedule. This is a huge project, not just building a tower or a bridge, this is actually building a new capital city
The future of Indonesia!!
With a large population, it is impossible for all parties to speak and be heard by the government. The Indonesian government is doing well
They can make referendum but they don't, the name of the city itself government that who are choose it while in other society it would be referendum.
I observe the news media from Singapore as if it is going to provoke local residents with the Indonesian government and migrants who have long lived in harmony and peace on the island of Kalimantan. Be careful, my fellow countrymen and countrymen, so that we are not pitted against each other by outsiders.
Selamat maju jaya kepada Indonesia! Salam persahabatan dari Sarawak.
Jakarta will later become a city of history, a city of economy and trade while Nusantara will be the capital
Luar biasa presiden indonesia semoga terwujud ❤❤❤
"EQUITABLE DEVELOPMENT/INFRASTRUCTURE" This is INDONESIA, not JAVA/JAKARTA only.
Infrastructure development must be evenly distributed throughout the Indonesian island because this country is so vast, and Nusantara may be the first step for developing a metropolitan city, so that not only everything is centered on JAVA, especially in JAKARTA.
i hope this project succesfull. Proud as Indonesian. Same like Jakarta native-Betawi Malay, Nusantara native is Kutai Paser Penajam Malay, relatively peacefull ethnic.