Chinmay is not a physicist but says physicists are unreliable
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ต.ค. 2022
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @vimohlive
Support the show at / vimoh
Make a one-time donation at vimoh.stck.me/profile
Watch the full live stream recording here • Big bang, a conscious ...
Please read these rules before commenting. Follow them to the best of your ability. The rules are meant to keep the comment space clean and a safe space for anyone who wishes to participate in good faith.
1. No advocating violence of any kind against anyone for any reason. People doing so will get banned from the channel.
2. No praising or abusing any religion for any reason. Proselytising is not appreciated, nor is making generalised statements about the followers of any religion. People doing so will get banned.
3. No casteism, racism, or sexism. Discriminatory language will get you banned too.
4. Trolling, spamming, use of fake accounts to deceive people about your identity, will also get you banned.
This Chinmay guy is out there on a mission to debunk everything we know about physics and cosmology. If he doesn't get Nobel in next few years I'll be highly disappointed.
😂😂
Yeah 😂
That upgrade is not even worth the money vro
Bet he'll win a Nobel prize for that.
B M Hegde of Physics 😂
I am an actual physicist, and I can say that this Chinmay guy is a person who has read something from somewhere that agrees with his worldview and accepts it as an ultimate truth.
But are you from an Ivy League college or from IIT in India? Because it seems according to Chinmay that is where ‘real’ physicists are from.😂
Chinmay felt so secure when Vimoh said Islam is also oppressive. This is basically what most of the "Hindu Atheists" want to hear. Atheism for people like Chinmay is all about Islamophobia.
I have studied history from Age of Empires and now I am a Historian 😂 Don't dare challenge me, I know how heavy cavalry upgrades into Paladins. 😂
Only if you want to waste gold. Don't get Paladins; get arbalests and halberdiers instead
Fućk you man stop spreading propaganda.
Age of empires is real history.
🤡
😂😂😂wow, didnt expect to see someone who knows about aoe here.
And hey i also know that u can hit and run 100 men ar arms with 6 crossbowman,guess thats how mediveal armies worked .I am off to argue with every historian on how what they think about mediveal history is wrong
Bowmen are nerfed fyi
I dont think he felt secure. I think he was disappointed. That was his only comeback.
He's just a classic upper cast Hindu. Had wealthy parents, was privileged from birth, was good at memorising stuff and went through our education system smoothy and since he faced no problems in Hinduism, he feels that this is the best religion in the world, he is conveniently an atheist not because he questioned his beliefs but because he doesn't need God, when someone probe him about bitter ground realities of his religion, he can easily point to his scriptures which are vague enough to mean anything they want and can dodge the question and his delusion stays maintained.
He's not an atheist. He was trying hard to sway the emphasis to some physicists being religious and the same whataboutism to turn the attention away from hinduism. He is religious, he simply understands that in the rational world your credibility goes down if you depend on make-believe too much so he has assumed the identity of an atheist to double up as a trojan horse in atheistic discourse where he'll ascertain what we don't know about science (bcz obviously no one knows everything), purposely ask us questions on that to give an impression that we clueless as a way of insulting our intelligence and establishing some superiority for public entertainment. Turn rational conversations into some kind of reality tv.
First of all Upper caste people dont have smooth journey in Indian education system.
And obviously he is stupid 🤣he said he studied all cosmology models....
Physicist by training here, I am just amazed how these guys spout these stuff so nonchalantly. If you actually meet hotshot physicists of their fields, they are always very careful not to make blanket assertions. Indeed one of the few things my PhD supervisor always told me was that science was always evolving and growing and the stupidest thing one can do is to be sure that ones view of the world is the "correct" one. I know people who have papers in cosmology who have studied the stuff for years in reputed institutions (Indian and abroad) who would balk at the sentence "i have studied all the models of cosmology". Insane!
I agree with you. I am a mathematician. But unfortunately there are too many people who are very sure about their world view. Science can only be learnt as you know only by doing it.
Chinmay there is thing called Dunning-Kruger effect.
Bro can you please tell me what’s that effect?
@@user-hl9jq8iz4i noob have more confidence in their subject than experts
@@chickenlover42 😂 oh accha
Vimoh: Lets not get into describing religion…
Chinmay: (starts describing religion)
Vimoh: Lets talk like adults.
Chinmay: Lets talk like Children.
And then this guy has the audacity to say “Now we are on the same page.”
At 5:40, Chinmay complains that Vimoh does not talk (much) Islam or Christianity.
I would like to know whether Chinmay goes to TH-cam Channels such as the Atheist Experience and Rationality Rules, or to channels like The Apostate Prophet and Abdullah Sameer and asks them why they talk almost exclusively about Christianity and Islam, but not about Hinduism (SO-CALLED Sanatana Dharma).
Hindutva goons
Did i hear him say "condom mechanics " 11:12!
Oh man....what sharp ears you've😂
Haa 😂😂😂 yeah it's a mistake but condom mechanics, sounds hilarious lol 😂
😂😂😂😂
Me too😂😂
Vimoh this interview is one of the funniest things I've watched all week. You going "what??" every time he bullshits is legendary
Hindus (SO-CALLED Sanatana Dharmists) INTENTIONALLY use the word 'dharma' to mean whatever they want it to mean in a particular conversation.
They do this so that they can expediently use whichever meaning they find useful in any given context.
A similar thing they do with their claims such as "Hindu Swarga is not the same as Christian heaven" (courtesy, charlatans like Rajiv Malhotra), as though just because Hindu Swarga is different from Christian Heaven, it demonstrates that Hindu Swarga actually exists.
Man create a yt channel you’re explaining really good 👏
@@Saitama..123
"Man create a yt channel you’re explaining really good 👏"
===========================
Thank you for the compliment.
The question is not Hindu Heaven exists or not The question is What is the Ultimate Goal of Dharmic Religions .. the Ultimate Goal is Mukthi or Moskha... Hindu Heaven and Hell are Just Metaphorical...
Kudos to Vimoh for withstanding this physicist-ish piece of S. I'd have melted with rage.
Man I would love to have Vimoh's patience level. It would help me so much in life
Aapke patience ko naman 🙏
Thumbnail ke liye 10 Mei se 10 for sure 🍻
This video is pure gold. I watched it twice rn. The level of patience vimoh has is commendable 15:53
11:55 this was a exact conversation in between Sam harris and dipak Chopra 🤣🤣
Look at the arrogance of this fellow. Despite not being able to support his own ideas he ends the conversation with suggestions on how others should improve.
I literally banged my head on the wall😅
This is embarassment. I think he is not from STEM field either.
Its irrelevant, even people with Phds in physics are capable of talking nonsense like this, I have met several, religious people keep aside everything they have studied when they are not in their professional role and revert back to their hard core irrational beliefs
@@user-hh5hs3zr5b I agree,I think vimoh should not ask whether someone is professional in that field or not,there are many professional people who are also very irrational and ignorant.
@@shreedharlohar9306 he asked him if he is a physicist to know that if he has a certain knowledge and backing in the field to claim that everything comes from a singularity
As a physics student, I think one does not have to be a physicist formally to speak about it, a formal degree does not necessarily mean someone knows about it either considering how bad our system is, and it is certainly possible to learn physics on your own. But yeah this guy is talking nonsense I think. also to be a materialist one doesn't need to have all the answers, one can be a materialist and still not know how matter came into being its perfectly reasonable in my opinion
Yeah i think with basic study we can learn or say what other scientists agree on or have general consensus about. But unless and until you are actively involved in specific field, its absurd to make claims that lie beyond the current understanding. Even in science there are limits to which something can be hypothesised beyond current knowledge.
@@warrior_of_liberation definitely but that is only those who do active research in that field, simply having a degree doesn't really make one qualified from my interaction with degree holders, as compared to that a laymen who is sufficiently interested and have trained himself/herself can study the results of research with or without degree
@@user-hh5hs3zr5b True. Degree is just a medium to know whether someone has knowledge in certain field, but it doesn't make them an authority about the knowledge of that field or that his words or ideas about the same shouldn't be challenged. Thats the beauty of science, anybody can question any idea on valid and reasonable grounds.
Why the professional credentials are asked is, it's unlikely that a professional physicist will use jargon to explain something and importantly they would be very careful on the thoughts they are expressing to avoid being ridiculed at some illogical ideas
@@ketannahar626 it is supposed to be unlikely in an ideal world but many do this
Love Vimoh's clarity of thought to repeatedly stop him from straying on random thoughts and holding on to particular words and broad definitions.
I'm feeling second hand embarrassment for this caller. Ughh
Now I know who you were talking about 😊
I heard that Chinmay said 'yes I'm a physicist, i study 'condom mechanics '😂😂😂😂
Most scientists agree that the axis of evil is an anomaly, but doesn't mean an earth centric universe in amy way
How did you tolerate him for so long😂😂😂😂accha hua naam pata chal gaya now we can avoid him kabhi mila toh🙌
That caller was from the highest of the horses I have ever seen.
Did Chinmay understand the common consensus?
Chinmay has a belief system, if he finds anything that corroborates that belief he proceeds to add that to his dictionary and conveniently ignores the rest that opposes his beliefs.. This is representative of rigid thinking that limits his ability to perceive reality as it is and instead leads him to perceive the world in a way that conforms to his beliefs.
i wonder what stopped chinmay from becoming a physicist..
himself
Wow, complete diffrent side of you Vimoh !! Glad to see it. The level of patient you have is unreal to me :D
The amount of logical fallacies of this caller are enough to write textbook...
Growing up in Pune, I’ve met so many guys like Chinmay, arrogant with only rote learning credentials to back them up
Mann, I’d like to see this Chinmay guy’s face once and get a good laugh . 😂😂
I do not mean to make anyone feel bad, but this is the funniest thing i've watched in a long time
11:55 CHINMAY BRUHHH.... IV LEAGUE EDUCATION SAB NAALE MEI BEH GAYA TUMHARA IDHAR XDXD
A small story...a very small story of a man-child and his Ivy League education. This man-child on his wanderings to gather Ivy league knowledge travelled far and wide, until he met up with someone called David Dunning. He was an old man, wise and perceptive, with a Phd from Stanford no less. But it took far more to satisfy our man-child. Our princess would only be satisfied with Ivy League. Ivy League or bust was his motto. So poor David, Stanford only that he was, asked him to meet someone else. A certain Justin Kruger who indeed had an Ivy League Phd from Cornell this time. So our prima donna most happily meets Justin Kruger and tells him all about himself, of his prospective Ivy League learnings, of his impending earth shattering, ground breaking, paradigm altering, shape shifting, heart stopping breakthrus in knowledge that would make almost every other scientific advancement right from the very first light of civilization look like half sucked lollies in the dirt on a melting hot summer day. And the best part of this was that he claimed he could do the same for subjects he actually did not even have any apparent expertise in! So Kruger in disbelief asks him again.... you mean even the ones you know nothing about? Really?!!!!!!
And he goes ESPECIALLY the ones I know nothing about. So Kruger immediately rings Dunning up. And goes....listen we must get together immediately. We may have something extraordinary here. So Dunning says.....whadya mean (remember he wasn't Ivy League)? So Kruger goes.....look at this laddie (he was dumbing it down for Dunning knowing he didn't have an Ivy League education like him)!!!!!
Have you ever seen anyone, ANYONE who, the lesser and lesser he knew about something was more and more confident about how he was right about the very same thing?
So Dunning goes...you mean A COGNITIVE BIAS IN WHICH PEOPLE WITH LIMITED CONFIDENCE IN A PARTICULAR DOMAIN OVERESTIMATE THEIR CAPABILITIES!!!!!!!??????
And Kruger goes.....Praise the Lord!!! We found Ivy League Gold!!!!! And that's how was the Dunning Kruger Effect born.
Always ask them for peer reviewed papers! If they claim that so and so happened. Ask them for a peer reviewed paper, if there are none then its all fancy opinion!
our Hinduism is not religion, it is dharma. It sounds like Indians drink jal and Europeans water. Om shanti
You are the perfect Bro❤❤❤
22:55 HC Verma is physicist ,he has TH-cam channel, he teach physics for free, he also do live streams
Isn't HC Verma retired?
@@battlerushiromiya651 yes he is retired
@@battlerushiromiya651 so what?
@@battlerushiromiya651retire hone see bhul jate hai kya log .....ye kaun sa logic hai
Chinmay has created a wonderful fantasy world.
Vimoh:I don't reason behind big Bang
Chinnu:I also don't know, but I don't agree..but still we are same page..please agreed that sciencist are fools they don't no nothing then we will be on same page.. actually I was checking my English here..
The guy sounds super arrogant
I know I am so late to comment on this video. I just watched and found out that Chinmay just believe in Indian scientists not other countries' scientists. Bro when you survey something globally, you have to visit all countries' scientists.
where do some of these guys come from...
I like how he uses words like "arrogant" (17:07) when describing people he doesn't agree with it. There is an underlying hatred he has for people who think differently from him. The arrogance he shows is so off the charts, dude doesn't even answer a single question in a proper way.
24:38 best part of the video!😂
I'm new here, is this like a members only engagement Vimoh does?
Their feeling is so bullshit when brahma pregnant her own daughter they don’t get hurt but when we speak simple truth they always get hurt with the truth kyun ki sach kadwa hota h ✅💯 and yes how you’re controlling your anger from this bullshit Vimoh !😐
A very important point that people like Chinmay seem to misunderstand is how scientific method actually works.
If something is unknown doesn't mean it's unknowable. Scientific knowledge of incremental in nature depending on the incoming data.
And what is not known or properly understood at present is clearly defined with a big question mark art the end of it.
Science doesn't make up answers. It waits for the data. That question mark is it's bigger strength.
Man, I lost patience listening to that.
people get their sentiments hurt and then come on live stream to have a debate. amazing.
11:11 condom mechanics?😂
Please bring this guy again sometime just for fun😂
It is funny when somebody criticises Hinduism their immediate retort is mulle, ricebag convert etc. Chimnay was trying to label Vimoh somewhat in that category. Failed miserably😭😭
I don't think anybody can win an argument against an Atheist😂😂
Wow Vimoh Bhau kia roast kia hain !
I think this chinmay guy is secret zakir nayak fanboi, he doesn't understand what theory really means, big bang theory is widely accepted with huge evidence to support it, but no one can discard it without extraordinary evidence against it, and not this chinmay guys, a hypothesis which he also didn't know.
We did get matter out of energy some time ago.
the only thing to learn from this conversation is the last remark from vimoh
I like how you dealt with his nonsensical sophistry and shut him down. But it was still sort of a waste of 24 minutes of your life and he'll probably waste years of his and others. He is a product of his environment. When you grow up in such higher income group environments detached from ground realities and the everyday issues of common people and have never had much experience with it, this is what you become. He'll only change with some dhakkas in his life or maybe never if that does not happen.
23:04
Vimoh: have you attended lectures of physicists at Oxford etc and asked them questions?
Chinmay: yes
Vimoh: to whom you have asked questions?
Chinmay: Why would ask them questions about physics? I would ask non-physicist like you 😂😂😂😂
Worst caller I have ever heard
Just ask him anything about statistical mechanics, actual physics students went through that hell
BSc in in Entire Physics Science
What a huge poser. Frankly, he doesn't have a good framework for rational thinking, and he's trying to use Ivy League as a certificate for his intelligence. Honestly, I think he's lying about the Ivy League bit just as he lied about being a physicist.
Me who wants to be a physicist in future: ok.
Jeez he was so butthurt over being called out, and now he got called out again.
Why both are not listening, only focusing on proving without proofs.
11:12 Hahahahahaha. He used a “D” in Quantum. Hahahahahahahaha. It actually sounds like a prophylactic. Hahahahahahahaha.
LTB FRW both clearly show big bang and expanding universe.
well, i am guy with physics degree, and i believe everyone shoud be welcomed to discuss science and join the field, but this guy should be kept away😂
22:23 vimoh bhai nailed it...
hah are bura maan jayega wo.. IVY wale report kar denge ye video ko
Why did the Big Bang happen? This question is so loaded
It's not loaded it just bare layes the epsitemological logjam which superciliciouness laden materialist like you indulge in.
Own religious superiority that’s what he’s just talking blah blah 😑
Kaha se kaha chala gay discussion 🤦♂️🤦♂️
And the readon why bing bang is taken as yhe best model is because we havr a lot of evidence backing it up. And we know exactly what happened after yhe big bang until some microseconds after it. Just because it doesn't make sense for some random guy doesn't make it wrong
Vimoh’s patience on tolerating such people is phenomenal.
I can't get over how condesending he was with Vimoh
I V Y L E A G U E ☠
Jio University😂
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Who is on whose podcast 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
5:26
Islam is largely irrelevant for vast number of INDIAN Hindus. Its certainly very relevant for Pakistani, Bangladeshi Hindus, no dispute in that. So basically insistence to talk about Islam by these folks is a way to avoid discussion on Hinduism.
Oh bhai 😂😂😂😂 in other videos what vimoh shared abt sanghi shenanigans can all be observed here 😆😆😆😆
Chinmay wants islam bashing ans vimoh will give all religion bashing. Bas itna hi diff hai
24:38 HAHAHAAHAHAAHAHA!
you are awesome sir Vimoh !
bhaiya yeh toh aap ironically dharmik nikle
"condom mechanics" WTF Chinmay 😭
Isn't he going to come next time and say you qre being unfair?
19:00 false. Big bang doesn't tell origin of space time and matter
Bro came in extremely bad faith. You don't have to be a physicist to speak on physics but you have to have some academic credibility to debunk any hypothesis.
It's a well known fact that we know nothing about the big bang and therefore it's a hypothesis but to come here and grill someone on something that no one knows to show them they don't know is redundant and motivated. And what did he accomplish with this? Absolutely nothing.
Einstein's theory of relativity.....condom mechanics...😱 Oodi baba! what's that?
This guy definetly not Ivy League
Condom mechanics 🤣
To answer him
Is Buddhism not oppressive?
It isn’t. Where is it oppressive? Come with receipts. Don’t quote this Govt that country. Within Buddhism, show where it is oppressive. Show.
It is
Real ID se aao Deepak Chopra 😂