Glad you like the Crossover. I was closely involved with the development and agree with your assessment, I rarely play anything else. It may have been helpful to mention the differences in fine tuning between the different models. Marine Band 1896 & Special 20 use the traditional Hohner tuning, which gives nice sounding chords. The Golden Melody is best suited for single note playing due to the tempered tuning (12TET), the chords sound a little rough. The Crossover uses a compromise tuning between traditional Hohner and tempered tunings, it's how I've tuned my own harps for a long time and gives reasonably sweet chords while still sounding in tune with other instruments in most positions.
Oh wow, I did not know that about the Crossover Steve! Thank you so much for sharing this. And also thanks for helping to develop Hohner's most kick-ass harmonica! 😎🤘🏼
I love my Crossovers, they’re responsive and loud too, bending is relatively easy, and they have stayed in tune for the few years I’ve played them. I don’t do much overblowing other than holes 4,5 and 6 to get the minor third in 2nd position, but supposedly they are set up for that. I have not been able to get the 7 overdraw other than on my G crossover, but that’s likely due to my lack of technique, cheers!
Was playing the Golden Melody since the first came out. Saved a lot of misery from the Marine Band. Retired back in ‘94. Can’t believe how much they cost now. Stunning.
I'm glad I didn't already place my order for a set of Marine Band. Dig the Golden Melody sound. To my ear it's a toss-up between the GM and the Crossover. Price makes the GM the winner for my case. Thanks for the vids. I'm learning lots. I need a harmonica to distract everyone from my guitar playing.
I sure liked your Run Down. I have been playing since I was 13 years old and now I am in my mid 60's. For all of these years, I have had a bunch of Harps ! I have always came back to Hohner's period ! I had just recently purchased a couple of the Hohner Rocket Amp Harps. Got them in a odd ball key. (E and Low G) I like them ! I have 2 Lee Oskars one in E Flat and the other in High G that I have had for dang near 20 years and still ticking. I have a cheap Hohner that I had bought at Cracker Barrel 23 years ago that's in my Arsenal. Different Strokes for Different Folks. i also have a Case of Fender Blues Deluxe that just ROCK !
Like the Fender blues deluxe but love my crossovers have a C that was gifted to my from my Navy buddy 7yrs ago and recently bought a Crossover in G, next I'm getting an F,,,,,I really need lessons can you help me? I'm legally blind but I have a good ear
I have a set of Special 20's, love them. Bought a Rocket once, seems as good as the 20, just louder. Also, have a barely used Blues Harp with a bad reed, I'm really mad that it is riveted together. Not fixable at all.
Much better comparison video than we usually get for guitars - where everything is just GREAT!!!!! Understanding why you recommend one over another was really helpful.
Thank you, Luke! That was incredibly helpful. I love the rougher nasal tone of the MB 1896 but as you said - nails, wood, discomfort, no cleaning.... all dealbreakers. The Crossover is the old Marine Band new and improved version. They also have the Thunderbird in that line. Crossover it is, and da*mn the cost.
Well, in the mid 1960s when I started and then in the 1970s with Lee Oskar, Livin Blues etc. I can't judge the quality of the Hohner C etc. today, because I have neglected this harmonica playing with the technology - electronics of today. Today I prefer to listen to the many other talented harmonica players on TH-cam. But my favorite passion for harmonicas and harmonica players has never left me. It's nice that you can also follow the opinions about the newer harmonicas. Thank you.
Well i've began with the Fender you're showing here Luke.. and at the end i bought the Hohner golden melody and the Hohner Big river the Blues Harp MS i have was gifted to me because i built two cigar box guitar for a Guitar Shop .. thank you for your help Man .. Hi from Italy
This video is very helpful! Thank you for explaining this all so well, and for the great harmonica playing! I learned a lot from watching this and because you demonstrated those styles on each harmonica back-to back, I was able to make my choice on what to get. Also, mentioning who plays what harmonica helps me to distinguish between the sounds. Thanks again!!
I have a Hohner marineband theluxe and Special 20's in different keys. I have seen that a Hohner Special 20 is a little bit more wide then the Marineband TheLuxe. Because I have big hands the Special 20's feels more comfortable. I wonder if a Crossover has the same dimensions as the Marineband and the same width.
They all sound great to me - however, I like the ones that provide the rich, sweet, in-tune chords/double stops, tho ("Just" tuning). Great video - very thorough/helpful ! TY. 😊
Tengo ahora 28 armonicas todas son: Crossover, Deluxe y una Rocket. Las Special 20 y la PentaHarp A las vendí. Me gustan más y con diferencia las dos primeras
I ended up going with a Marine Band 1896 as my first harmonica, price was good and I do dig the sort of medium tone it has. I think if I end up advancing my playing enough to use it in music production I might upgrade to the Crossover.
For the studio, if you're not doing a distorted tone, Marine Band might actually be better. For acoustic sound in the studio, Crossover might be too bright.
Haha I have nine harps and luckily I have three of his five picks, special 20, golden melody and pentaharp among the mix to fill in keys (beginner and collector of various instrument wind and string, didge, accordion et al (mostly playing banjo recently) So glad to see at least some of my ... approved are in the mix, and if I could play them properly so much the better with any harp. Oh, yeah that metal protruding plate is hell and breaking them down for tuning I have thought of working with that problem if possible but I suppose coughing up the money for a better harp would be a better fix. Thanks
Bro this is a incredible video I don't think this video has got as much credit as it should you are well versed I'm going to share this video about 10 times until it gets more notoriety you did a great job constructing this
Don’t let him completely steer you away from the Marine Band ,personally I think he’s way over exaggerating, it’s a great harp,and does not cut your lips open I love his videos,but the Marine Band thing is just his opinion
True that! It did make it to my top 4 Hohner Harps, after all. It's maybe the best sounding harp of the 4, and really easy to bend. But it's not as comfy as the other 3. Adam Gussow's harp of choice, among many other amazing players who are way better than I'll ever be!
@@Harmonicacom agreed, I mainly follow you and Adam Gussow on here so it was definitely between the two. I'll own both as soon as I'm proficient. Just went with the Special 20 for now to learn the basics, bending, etc. It's the first of many, as I've finally found a new passion for it!
My first harmonica was Big river, because could't buy a desireable Marine band for the money i've got, studying at school... Now i have a crossover but often train in playing on a Big river. After few weeks of playing it became more responsive and warm. Not bad harmonica. PS Few days earlier i bought old version of Special 20 in a mint condition, soon will get it and suspect it will be my favourite everyday harmonica for it's ergonomic Aloha from Russia! Hawaii is a godloved place!
My first real harmonica was the Hohner Crossover. Bought it last year and im really lovin it. The bamboo looks, feels and sounds insane! I started playing harmonica on my own; training with a friend of mine, whenever possible. Even if i cant do bends really well, the harmonica fits my purposes really good. Mostly playing normal songs and old folk songs, but i gotta try blues in the future. I thought maybe buing the Golden Melody as my "secondary" harp. Also got a Hohner Echo Tremolo 48, cause i love the tremolo sound for songs. Greetings from Germany!
Atención la Golden Melody tiene la embocadura bastante más alta...yo me acostumbre de tal modo a las Deluxe y Crossover que sin tocar un rato la Golden, me cuesta cerrar bien la embocadura
I heard harmonica teachers say that they are always pleased to see their students with a hohner special 20 in key of c. I had heard with there plastic comb they are comfortable to play. But I wondered how much in quality of sound and tune was lessened than that of a wood comb hohner marine band. Now I'm a ukulele player. I've never learned to play harmonica. But I want to learn how to play and get a harmonica neck holder so I can play with no hands while I play my Uke. Also I'm suffering with tennis elbow in both arms so I cant really play guitar right now without aggravating my tennis elbow. So i thought now is a great time for me to get a harmonica. I want even need my hands. I can rest my arms and still be able to play some form of music until I'm better. It takes months for tennis elbow to heal. So I came here looking for advice and your video did help me see some pros and cons in the different harmonicas. Now I had heard that hohner marine band was hard for beginners to bend notes on or even blow in 2 holes at the same time. But yet it's easier to do it on a Special 20. Can you explain what bending the notes is in more detail and is it possible to bend notes easily on the hohner crossover? Now speaking of the hohner crossover. It does have a good quality clear sound and tone to it like a marine band, and you said it was comfortable like a special 20. Yet its made out of bamboo. So my concern is, am I going to have the same worry of possibly ending up with bloody lips playing a crossover just like those other players on a marine band with a wood comb? I tell you now I would much rather pay more money on the crossover and have better quality of sound than a special 20 but not end up with bloody lips and still be able to bend notes easily like a special 20. So with that in mind, can you tell me if crossover would be best for me to reach my desires? Because I want the best, but I also want comfort and no bloody lips. Also, how are we suppose to clean the crossover harmonica with a bamboo comb? With womb combs I've seen people have to take the harmonica apart and wash the wood comb and let it air dry and they use a toothbrush and cut the brushes to make them shorter to clean their harmonica. They spoke about the wood swelling. That sounds annoying to deal with. I'm not sure how to wash with bamboo combs. I figure also take it apart. Now plastic comb harmonicas seemed much easier to clean. They didn't take it apart. The put it in unscented soapy water and used a tooth brush with brushes cut shorter to clean it then rinsed it out good and banged it against their hand to get water out them they dried it off on the outside and was done. So if I get a crossover, should I also buy a certain tool kit to take it apart when it needs washed or leave it together as I wash it? If so, what kind? I heard beginners should start on a diatonic harmonica. Because the tremolo harmonica requires more air to play, and because the chromatic harmonica requires that you have to learn a ton of music theory, the diatonic harmonica is undoubtedly the easiest harmonica to learn how to play they say. But this was news to me. And I don't know how to tell the difference between them in just looking at all the harmonicas out there. And what kind of music theory do we need to learn? My only other question for now is are there any helpful books and dvds on teaching harmonica and tutorials you or anybody would recommend? I do enjoy video tutorials so I can both see and hear what's going on. And could you share a link with me of the cheapest harmonics crossover in key of c and a link to the most comfortable adjustable neck holder for a harmonica you would also recommend. I figured it would hurt to ask and maybe you might help me find the best quality for the cheaper price even though it will still be more expensive than the others. What sites do you recommend?
Yes, definitely start with key of C. I'm sure you would be happy with the Crossover as it is very easy on the lips, and the triple lacquered bamboo comb won't swell if you wash it under warm tap water (which is how I recommend cleaning it if it starts performing less than desirable.) Although if you want to save money you could just go with the Special 20, also a phenomenal harp for the money. Here is my article on brands you might find helpful: www.harmonica.com/which-harmonica-to-buy/ Here's my vid on bending, which is not a beginner technique: th-cam.com/video/moVpn-mBFr8/w-d-xo.html You can go to Rockin Rons for a Crossover: rockinronsmusic.com/products/hohner-crossover-marine-band-crossover-m2009-with-free-usa-shipping?_pos=1&_sid=1100efd33&_ss=r&variant=35199872106658 Or we have them: www.harmonica.com/store/hohner-crossover-marine-band-key-of-c/ For a neck holder I recommend the Seydel Gecko or probably the Hohner Flexrack, though I haven't tried it yet, I've heard it's very comfy. You can just google each and see all the people who are selling them and find the cheapest. For learning aids, DEFINITELY the best thing is Beginner to Boss: www.harmonica.com/lessons/ (And I'm TOTALLY unbiased. 😉) Hope that helps. Happy New Year! Aloha, Luke
I don't play the harmonica.....But, I will. Between where I am now and where I want to be, I don't need any handicaps....... Over the years I have had to learn the hard way, and repeatedly, that cut rate tools are just too expensive to use. I am ordering the Crossover. As I play it, I will know the faults are all mine and something I can fix....... By the way, your video content is absolutely excellent! Really helped me with some basic information to make the beginner decisions we all start out with. I plan to hang around your channel.................................LIKED/SUBBED
I used to play Harp when I was a kid. Still have a few laying around, but seldom play ! But once I discovered the Golden Melody, there was no going back, for me ! Mind you, that's better than 50 year's ago, or so, as I'm now 66 ! That said, the prices from what I remember, are insane ! And seemingly new derivations , like the Horner Pinta, that brought me here ! You saved me $50.00 ! Not what I had hoped it was, so thank you for the demo, and comments ! 🤘😎
I’m just a player for fun. I’m 71 and played since I was 6. My dad played and that is how I started. Marine Band was my first and I played the first one for 40 years. I bought a new Marine Band and a Special 20 at the same time. A world of difference between the two. The Special 20 is a lot easier to play but I prefer the sound of my Marine Band(personnel preference)
Hey Geoff - the button on the side means it's a chromatic. Here's my article on the 3 main types of harmonicas: www.harmonica.com/exploring-the-3-types-of-harmonica/
What about the big river harp? I don’t play harmonica much, but this was my first when I was in maybe 5th grade? I’ve purchased a few special 20s since, but just found my old big river and it piqued my interest in the model again.
Dude, I'm addicted to guitar gear and now I'm getting addicter to harps. Thanks for feeding my new addiction, also congrats on almost hitting 100k subscribers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great vid, thanks. I've decided Id like to have a go at learning to play Harmonica, so been watching a lot of vids and advice. Just ordered myself a Hohner Rocket Amp in C and a Golden Melody (old version) in C. I've also ordered a couple of books for beginners and a Wittner Metronome. Excited to start learning. Best wishes from downunder. 🇦🇺
I love the Hohner Crossharp... it's the only harmonica I'll buy now. Sounds great out of the box, easy to adjust if necessary, easy to clean and maintain. You can swap out the reed plates if necessary at about 1/2 the price of a new harp.
Great reviews! The Crossover kind of reminds me of the Hohner Rocket Low F I bought a little while ago. Very warm and deep sound, and also comes with an identical zip up case, which gives it bonus points for me. Makes it feel a little bit safer to go outdoors with it!
Fantastic video! Really helped me to hear the differences between the harps. I have a Special 20 and I tended to like the tone of that one most on your video. I sorta wish you had tried the Rocket, but no problem.
Hey Luke , woke up today morning & got this videos notification . Please keep making this type of videos. One thing you could make a review video about marine band deluxe & I think it is a much better harp compare to the original one. Take care . Aloha ....😊😊😊
The Rocket is a great Harp. For some reason I find it slightly less responsive on the -2 -3 kinda area which is why it didn't make it here. But lots of people love it! It's definitely a great harp.
I've been playing harmonica since I was nine years old. I'm 71 and own about 80 harmonicas. Of Hohners, I totally agree with your breakdown. I did get a set of Marine Band Deluxes because they don't have sharp corners. I actually have a few basic Marine Band keys for setting into a holder so I can play while I drive. ( I like to play along with Bob Dylan songs that way). I have a full major key selection of them, Golden Melody, and Crossovers. I own other brands, however. I like to see what different versions sound like. BTW, never played in a band. I just play for pleasure.
@@Harmonicacom I'm harmonica crazy. Each one seems like a treasure to me BTW; I woke up early and found this video and picked up one of the several harmonicas I always keep on the stand next to the couch and started to play along. "I Walk the Line," nice way to start the day! Thanks! I like your videos a lot. I sample all of them. You all have something to teach and inspire.
Great video. My favorite one is the HOHNER ROCKET, the update of the Special 20. It´s a true pleasure to hold the ROCKET in my hands, every time i play it. Greetings from Munich, Germany.
AMAZING. because, for once, we have somebody who not only KNOWS what he's talking about, but also know HOW TO TALK about it, how to be clear. If politicians and teachers and doctors who "Know stuff" could only speak about it as clearly as this guy then I'd listen to them as well! Thanks a bunch. You should be coaching actors who come to me and wonder why they're not getting jobs! Thanks. John Windsor-Cunningham
Thanks for explaining the comparison of Hohner…I use Johnson Blues King for $9.99 and it works for me….but then again, I’m not Sonny Boy Williamson either.
What do you think about the blues harp? I learned blues harmonica on it by myself reading a tutorial on the internet 14 years ago and I always feel comfortable to use (maybe it is not the best for a beginner for bending)
Hi...recently received a Crossover. This Beautiful Harmonica has the look of "Ol Timey" about it...but the Tone and Playability in a Word is...Smooth. If you decide to go this way...you won't be disappointed. Highly Recommend. Cheers.
Very helpful vid; thanks, Luke. I'm mainly a trumpet player who doubles on blues harp for some tunes. A comfortable harp of extremely important for me, as I can't have it messing up my trumpet chops. You mentioned that Howard Levy plays the Golden Melody, but he has them customized to the max. I don't have the time, skill or patience to work on harps, so I need something that'll sound good out of the box without tweaking. I've been playing exclusively Manji's for a few years; they last and take a lot of abuse. But they will crap out on occasion. I'm looking for something better that's not going to break the bank - probably a special 20 or a Cross Over (though it's pricy) Here's something I haven't come across: how do the flat key harps sound? Most guitar players play in the easier sharp keys. But as mainly a jazz player, I find there's something about the flat keys (F, Bb, Eb and Ab) that sound better to me when you're improvising; can't really explain it. But, I would like to hear what some more advanced players like. yourself have to say about the harps in flat keys. Anyway, thanks again for this vid.
Flat keys sound great! I love Bb (F blues) and Ab (Eb blues.) Db harp cool too (Ab blues) BUT the Eb harp (Bb blues) is a little bit high. Higher harps can be cool, but they can sound a little shrill. I recommend trying the Marine Band Deluxe it's like $65 from Rockin Rons. GREAT harp OOTB. Or your inclination for the Special 20 might be a good fit as well. Rock on! 😎
@@Harmonicacom Thanks for the "sound" advice, my man. I talked my 16 piece big band into giving me a couple solo spots on harp, one being George Benson's "On Broadway", a hit some years back. The solo vamp is in Eb, so I'll be on an Ab harp - or, I could get a Db and play in 3rd position. I seem to struggle more with the low keys like G and Ab - my bad; I don't practice harp enough in the low keys. So, it'll sound good in 3rd position. Anyway your work on these vids is appreciated.
I'm a bigginer and looking forward to the journey! The salesperson at the store said the Hohner Midnight blue was a great choice for a beginner ? I'm wish I would have started years ago .. didnt won't to waste time or money. Please advise
I've never played the Midnight Blue, but my understanding is that they're on par with the Special 20, so you're probably good to go with that! This is my article on Brands: www.harmonica.com/which-harmonica-to-buy/ The East Top 008k is also a good value. If you wanna fast-track your growth you might consider my Beginner to Boss course: www.harmonica.com/lessons/
Copying and pasting this from a reply I just made to someone else with same question: If you already own a Hohner Blues Harp harmonica, and you’re wondering if it’s a good harmonica to learn on: fear not, you’re in great shape. You’ve got a harmonica very suitable to learn on. If you've got a Hohner Blues Harp and your lips are hurting, consider a plastic-combed harmonica like a Special 20, Golden Melody, or a Lee Oskar. If you’re currently considering buying a Hohner Blues Harp, here’s my advice: The Hohner Blues Harp has a wooden comb. If you’re wanting to get a wooden-combed harmonica, I recommend that you just get the tried-and-true original, the Marine Band (or, if you can afford it, the Crossover which is much comfier on the lips with its triple-lacquered bamboo comb) I guess if you’re saving $20 getting a Blues Harp instead of a Marine Band, and you’re on a tight budget, go for it. But if you’re only saving $5 or $10, I’d say, just save up and get the Marine Band. In my opinion the Marine Band has superior tone, is more responsive, and is easier to bend and control bends on, and so I think it’s well worth the extra money. If money isn’t tight and you’re the kind of person who likes the best of the best, then go for the Crossover! Hope that helps!
Wow, outstanding video!! Thank you for the information. Can you let me know what type of harmonica Kim Wilson plays on “Looking for trouble”? On hohners site they say he plays the chromonica 64 and marine blues. Thanks
You've introduced me to the crossover. Bamboo combs you say - do those combs end up swelling and protruding like I remember the wood combs doing? Thanks!
*Awesome comparisons!* That Marine Band tone comes through each time. I'm gonna try a low key, E(?) and smooth the lips with sandpaper. I should probably research before posting foolish ideas, but inspiration from your video got the best of me.
I’ve been a player for 40 years now and my favorite has always been the standard marine band. I used to love the old style blues harp but not so much the ms series model. I’ve also used golden melodies and special 20s but keep coming back to the marine band. Thanks for the cool video! I’m also not a fan of the rocket models but I absolutely love the Pentaharp!
I had a Marine Band and I didn't really like it. This was like 20 years ago or something so I don't know if they changed it or something but I remember not liking the wooden comb. I guess I was spoiled by plastic but since I'm not that great I need whatever advantage I can take. Lol.
Thanks for this video, great overview! I’m taking your Beginner-To-Boss course now, using a Special 20 in C. Because I feel like I’m going to stick with it, I added Special 20s in G, A, D & E, and Lee Oskars in Bb and F, so I can try out different keys. Your course is a lot of fun, and it helps that I’ve played guitar for over 30 years so I know what blues licks should sound like. I haven’t gotten to bending yet, but I mess around with whatever sounds good. At some point, I’m definitely interested in trying out some different harps, especially the Crossover, and maybe some different versions of the Rocket. I guess I’m hesitant about the Crossover because I like rinsing my harps briefly under the tap after each time I play them to keep them clean, not sure that would work with a Crossover because of the bamboo comb. I guess that’s a silly reason not to get one, though! Anyway, thanks again!!
Hey there - right on my friend. Glad you're digging the course! Bamboo is the most water-resistant wood, and it's triple-lacquered, so I wouldn't let that stop you from trying one! Thanks for the note. Rock on!!
Hi, Luke: I LOVE your informative videos!!!! Which harmonica should I buy to play Dylan, Neil Young, and other folk-rock? I play acoustic guitar and I want to get a harmonica holder, too! Is the Special 20 too "dark" to play Dylan, Young, etc.? Or, would you recommend the Crossover-- which you say is "brighter?" Thanks!
The For Dummies books are such a great resource. Winslow is so knowledgeable about harmonicas, I've used harmonica for dummies as a resource. I love it.
@@Harmonicacom I have Dummies first edition. Are you familiar with their second edition, is there enough new material to make both worthwhile? Do you know anything about this book, "Masters of the Harmonica" Goldsmith, M. I cannot tell if it is mainly a tutorial or conversations about harp playing.
Thanks for this video. The harmonicas you are playing, do they sound and play like that out of the box? Or did you made some tuning or customization to them?
@@Harmonicacom Thanks for answering, good to know as I tried to improve my harmonica but got it worse instead. Also I wasn't really sure if it wass my lack of technique or the instrument that didn't play well. Now with your video and confirmation I'll buy a crossover and have no excuse.
I've always fancied getting one of the Crossover harps as I live on a bamboo farm. However, I don't have a lot of confidence that the humidity in the tropics will allow it to last very long. Sadly the comb my marine band harp is almost in pieces. For that reason I'm a Special 20 guy. Thanks for posting the video, all the best from Panama.
Hey Jim - bamboo is the most water resistant wood, AND it's TRIPLE lacquered (MB's are only double lacquered.) I'm in Hawaii - very similar climate to Panama. I've had a Crossover for 3 years, it's still rocking and rolling. GO FOR IT! 🙌🏼
@@sergehulne most of the tone comes from the player and embouchure, not the harp. Some harps, such as the special 20, disguise poor form and embouchure behind decent tone. Other models, don’t provide as much forgiveness.
I have played around with the harmonica in the past and even happen to own both a Special 20 and a Crossover. Both harmonicas are in the key of C. I would like to learn to play the harmonica. Question: what are the most popular or common keys used by musicians other than C?
Started out on Special 20 went through a lot of makes and models and some custom harmonica's till I found the Golden Melody, love the feel , look and play ability and easy maintenance.P.S. Great shot out.
@@Harmonicacom Rachelle Plas is a super player on the G.M.😎. Finding them good when playing along with horns but you do need to over blow and draw at times.
I have the special 20 I got it 45 years ago compared to the American ace is very smooth. But I got some American ace in the box but were the new style plastic and not metal and wood. The new ones play well. I got the American aces cus of Sonny played them . Thanks for the info.
@@Harmonicacom I sorry but I believed it was a guy sonny boy nickname that played American ace I got them back in the 60s few years ago I could only get them in plastic they play well. But just after seeing this vid I just found the old wood and metal style made in Ireland, fir dirt cheap almost new, what a find cus these I can make it feedback like a amp feedback it's so cool. Just want to add I bought his book and two harmonicas tried and couldn't play at all , no blues that is . Put them away for years then one day I picked it up and started playing and iT all made sense to Mr. Weird
Hohner Rockets are great. They didn't make this vid because I find them to be slightly less responsive for my playing style. The Rocket Amps I do love though!
Hi Luke, do you know anything about the Hohner Blues harp? I'm considering buying it since I've already owned a marine band. If you have any idea, I would be really interested to hear it.
I used to prefer the Pro harp but that was before MS. Switched over to the Special 20. I'm not so careful about the care of my harps so I stay away from the traditional wood combs. They are too easily wrecked by moisture (beer and such). But I may try that Crossover at some point. Good video!
Hey Antonio - Just played my first Deluxe. LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT compared to the MB 1896. I don't ever wanna play an 1896 again! 🤣 Haven't compared it to Crossover yet...
Hi Luke, thanks for your answer, I have another question, can you tell me why we have so many 'C' Type harmonicas, example, low C, Major C, Blues C, can you tell my why we don't just have one C type?
Right now I have a Special 20, Golden Melody, and a Rocket that I just got. Right now I’m loving the Rocket. It’s like a better version of the Special 20. Rounded edges makes it really comfortable and the larger holes makes it really easy to play.
Thanks for the video Luke for me as a beginner I will go for special 20 a soon I learn more and more I will upgrade to the crossover thanks again u gain another subs also I’m a bass and guitar player 😊
Hi! I didn't find any video from you about the Hohner blues harp MS C. I did order it and after that I saw some comments that said bending could be a bit difficult. Well someone said that it's one of the easiest. I'm total beginner so what do you think? Can I go with it or prefer the special 20. Thanks!
I love my Special 20, but if you get a wild mustache hair in one of the comb holes, it's getting yanked out! I wish there was a way to mitigate that without trimming my stache
Over the years of playing and noise from the Job, my ears can't tell much of a difference in tone. I've tried this test on my own assortment harps, probably have about 20 different C's around. One can tell the difference in the Hohner and the cheap knockoffs. That said, I bought my grandsons a couple of Fenders to get them started. Good comparison on your video.
Hey, even with golden ears, the difference in tone is not as huge as some act like it is. The player makes a much bigger difference on the sound of harp than the harp itself! 🤣
I don't disagree with the results although I should qualify my response by adding I have never heard of the Pentaharp! However, I started playing at the age of seven (I'm 65 now!) and I found that my lips got used to playing the Marine Band 1896 and 'toughened up' much like a guitar player's fingers toughen up with constant practice. Nice video - and I am curious with the Pentaharp - although playing it would really confuse my subconscious and would wreck my normal harp play!
I don't recommend picking up the Pentaharp honestly. But I DO recommend treating yourself to a Crossover if you've never played one and it's in your budget.
@@Harmonicacom I recently bought a couple of the Thunderbirds - the Low D and the Low G. They are not built for bending, although they will with care, but they each have a super tone. They are excellent for slow ballads. I am at a loss to understand how, after owning at least forty harmonicas, how I still haven't yet bought a Crossover - but I can tell from listening to them online that they sound wonderfully flexible and I am sure when I do purchase one (an early Christmas present for myself!) it will soon become my favourite harp. I play all kinds of styles, including a great deal of single note tunes, so I am definitely going to get one of the Golden Melody harps you mentioned. I hate the key of C (too shrill for my tastes) so I'll probably buy an A or G. Keep up the good work.
Glad you like the Crossover. I was closely involved with the development and agree with your assessment, I rarely play anything else. It may have been helpful to mention the differences in fine tuning between the different models. Marine Band 1896 & Special 20 use the traditional Hohner tuning, which gives nice sounding chords. The Golden Melody is best suited for single note playing due to the tempered tuning (12TET), the chords sound a little rough. The Crossover uses a compromise tuning between traditional Hohner and tempered tunings, it's how I've tuned my own harps for a long time and gives reasonably sweet chords while still sounding in tune with other instruments in most positions.
Oh wow, I did not know that about the Crossover Steve! Thank you so much for sharing this. And also thanks for helping to develop Hohner's most kick-ass harmonica! 😎🤘🏼
I love my Crossovers, they’re responsive and loud too, bending is relatively easy, and they have stayed in tune for the few years I’ve played them. I don’t do much overblowing other than holes 4,5 and 6 to get the minor third in 2nd position, but supposedly they are set up for that. I have not been able to get the 7 overdraw other than on my G crossover, but that’s likely due to my lack of technique, cheers!
If you had to choose a crossover or super chromonica which one is better?
@@popscola2574 Better for what? They are completely different instruments made for different purposes.
Super interesting. Golden Melody sounds best to me
Was playing the Golden Melody since the first came out. Saved a lot of misery from the Marine Band. Retired back in ‘94. Can’t believe how much they cost now. Stunning.
Thank you for this video!! Especially the shootout section at the end. Playing the same songs the same way on different harps really helps!
Right on my man Joe. You got it. Rock on.
So I went for the Crossover. I had bought the Suzuki Hammond but your review of the crossover made me change my mind.
Good choice! Hope you love it!
I'm glad I didn't already place my order for a set of Marine Band. Dig the Golden Melody sound. To my ear it's a toss-up between the GM and the Crossover. Price makes the GM the winner for my case. Thanks for the vids. I'm learning lots. I need a harmonica to distract everyone from my guitar playing.
Ha! Right on Wade. I hope you love it! Yeah my harmonicas and guitars are always jealous of each other. 😉
I sure liked your Run Down. I have been playing since I was 13 years old and now I am in my mid 60's. For all of these years, I have had a bunch of Harps ! I have always came back to Hohner's period ! I had just recently purchased a couple of the Hohner Rocket Amp Harps. Got them in a odd ball key. (E and Low G) I like them ! I have 2 Lee Oskars one in E Flat and the other in High G that I have had for dang near 20 years and still ticking. I have a cheap Hohner that I had bought at Cracker Barrel 23 years ago that's in my Arsenal. Different Strokes for Different Folks. i also have a Case of Fender Blues Deluxe that just ROCK !
Like the Fender blues deluxe but love my crossovers have a C that was gifted to my from my Navy buddy 7yrs ago and recently bought a Crossover in G, next I'm getting an F,,,,,I really need lessons can you help me? I'm legally blind but I have a good ear
I have a set of Special 20's, love them. Bought a Rocket once, seems as good as the 20, just louder. Also, have a barely used Blues Harp with a bad reed, I'm really mad that it is riveted together. Not fixable at all.
Thanks for sharing!
Much better comparison video than we usually get for guitars - where everything is just GREAT!!!!! Understanding why you recommend one over another was really helpful.
Cool, thanks Alan!
i got Golden Melody, i've literally fallen in love with her
Woo hoo. Right on Stefano. She's a beauty!
Thank you, Luke! That was incredibly helpful. I love the rougher nasal tone of the MB 1896 but as you said - nails, wood, discomfort, no cleaning.... all dealbreakers. The Crossover is the old Marine Band new and improved version. They also have the Thunderbird in that line.
Crossover it is, and da*mn the cost.
Yeah, after shooting this vid, I discovered the Marine Band Deluxe over at Rockin' Rons. I like it even better than the Crossover, plus it's cheaper!!
Well, in the mid 1960s when I started and then in the 1970s with Lee Oskar, Livin Blues etc. I can't judge the quality of the Hohner C etc. today, because I have neglected this harmonica playing with the technology - electronics of today. Today I prefer to listen to the many other talented harmonica players on TH-cam. But my favorite passion for harmonicas and harmonica players has never left me. It's nice that you can also follow the opinions about the newer harmonicas. Thank you.
Absolutely agree! Crossover is the best sounding harmonica ever! Very deep and crisp sound. I’ve had mine for years and I love it.
Great to hear Martin!
Is yours in key of 'C' ? Thanks
Loving the marine Band Deluxe! Eight bucks more than the special 20, responsive as the crossover but the chords sound better!
💯 Dale. I discovered it after I made this video. Couldn't agree more! Rock on! 😎
Remember the tuning is slightly different between the MBD and Crossover.
Well i've began with the Fender you're showing here Luke.. and at the end i bought the Hohner golden melody and the Hohner Big river the Blues Harp MS i have was gifted to me because i built two cigar box guitar for a Guitar Shop .. thank you for your help Man .. Hi from Italy
Right on. Aloha from Hawaii. So which is your favorite?
@@Harmonicacom I think I like the most.. the hohner golden melody..
This video is very helpful! Thank you for explaining this all so well, and for the great harmonica playing! I learned a lot from watching this and because you demonstrated those styles on each harmonica back-to back, I was able to make my choice on what to get. Also, mentioning who plays what harmonica helps me to distinguish between the sounds. Thanks again!!
Sweet. Glad it helped. Rock on! 😎
I have a Hohner marineband theluxe and Special 20's in different keys. I have seen that a Hohner Special 20 is a little bit more wide then the Marineband TheLuxe. Because I have big hands the Special 20's feels more comfortable. I wonder if a Crossover has the same dimensions as the Marineband and the same width.
They all sound great to me - however, I like the ones that provide the rich, sweet, in-tune chords/double stops, tho ("Just" tuning). Great video - very thorough/helpful ! TY. 😊
You're welcome. It's my pleasure. Yeah I like the in-tune chords/double stops too!!! Rock on! 😎
Incredible quality content lol tossing the harmonicas was classic mate. Good job
LOL. Right on Dan! Thanks for watching.
Tengo ahora 28 armonicas todas son: Crossover, Deluxe y una Rocket. Las Special 20 y la PentaHarp A las vendí. Me gustan más y con diferencia las dos primeras
I ended up going with a Marine Band 1896 as my first harmonica, price was good and I do dig the sort of medium tone it has. I think if I end up advancing my playing enough to use it in music production I might upgrade to the Crossover.
For the studio, if you're not doing a distorted tone, Marine Band might actually be better. For acoustic sound in the studio, Crossover might be too bright.
how’s it been?
edit: punctuation
Haha I have nine harps and luckily I have three of his five picks, special 20, golden melody and pentaharp among the mix to fill in keys (beginner and collector of various instrument wind and string, didge, accordion et al (mostly playing banjo recently) So glad to see at least some of my ... approved are in the mix, and if I could play them properly so much the better with any harp. Oh, yeah that metal protruding plate is hell and breaking them down for tuning I have thought of working with that problem if possible but I suppose coughing up the money for a better harp would be a better fix. Thanks
Bro this is a incredible video I don't think this video has got as much credit as it should you are well versed I'm going to share this video about 10 times until it gets more notoriety you did a great job constructing this
Aww thanks @Mojo27564. I really appreciate you kind words my friend. 👊🏼
I'm looking to buy my first harmonica this week to truly start learning on something more then a kids toy, so this video is greatly appreciated!
Don’t let him completely steer you away from the Marine Band ,personally I think he’s way over exaggerating, it’s a great harp,and does not cut your lips open
I love his videos,but the Marine Band thing is just his opinion
True that! It did make it to my top 4 Hohner Harps, after all. It's maybe the best sounding harp of the 4, and really easy to bend. But it's not as comfy as the other 3. Adam Gussow's harp of choice, among many other amazing players who are way better than I'll ever be!
Glad it was helpful. 👊🏼
@@Harmonicacom agreed, I mainly follow you and Adam Gussow on here so it was definitely between the two. I'll own both as soon as I'm proficient. Just went with the Special 20 for now to learn the basics, bending, etc. It's the first of many, as I've finally found a new passion for it!
Everyone should at least try the 1896.
Bought my first Marine Band Crossover yesterday after a year of learning on Big River Harp, can't wait to get most of it!
Ooooh. Niiiiice. Keep us posted how you like it!
My first harmonica was Big river, because could't buy a desireable Marine band for the money i've got, studying at school... Now i have a crossover but often train in playing on a Big river. After few weeks of playing it became more responsive and warm. Not bad harmonica.
PS Few days earlier i bought old version of Special 20 in a mint condition, soon will get it and suspect it will be my favourite everyday harmonica for it's ergonomic
Aloha from Russia!
Hawaii is a godloved place!
My first real harmonica was the Hohner Crossover. Bought it last year and im really lovin it. The bamboo looks, feels and sounds insane! I started playing harmonica on my own; training with a friend of mine, whenever possible. Even if i cant do bends really well, the harmonica fits my purposes really good. Mostly playing normal songs and old folk songs, but i gotta try blues in the future. I thought maybe buing the Golden Melody as my "secondary" harp. Also got a Hohner Echo Tremolo 48, cause i love the tremolo sound for songs.
Greetings from Germany!
When you wanna learn bending, you can check out this lesson:
www.harmonica.com/how-to-bend-harmonica/
Aloha form Hawaii!
Luke
Atención la Golden Melody tiene la embocadura bastante más alta...yo me acostumbre de tal modo a las Deluxe y Crossover que sin tocar un rato la Golden, me cuesta cerrar bien la embocadura
I heard harmonica teachers say that they are always pleased to see their students with a hohner special 20 in key of c.
I had heard with there plastic comb they are comfortable to play.
But I wondered how much in quality of sound and tune was lessened than that of a wood comb hohner marine band.
Now I'm a ukulele player. I've never learned to play harmonica. But I want to learn how to play and get a harmonica neck holder so I can play with no hands while I play my Uke.
Also I'm suffering with tennis elbow in both arms so I cant really play guitar right now without aggravating my tennis elbow.
So i thought now is a great time for me to get a harmonica. I want even need my hands. I can rest my arms and still be able to play some form of music until I'm better. It takes months for tennis elbow to heal.
So I came here looking for advice and your video did help me see some pros and cons in the different harmonicas.
Now I had heard that hohner marine band was hard for beginners to bend notes on or even blow in 2 holes at the same time. But yet it's easier to do it on a Special 20.
Can you explain what bending the notes is in more detail and is it possible to bend notes easily on the hohner crossover?
Now speaking of the hohner crossover. It does have a good quality clear sound and tone to it like a marine band, and you said it was comfortable like a special 20. Yet its made out of bamboo.
So my concern is, am I going to have the same worry of possibly ending up with bloody lips playing a crossover just like those other players on a marine band with a wood comb?
I tell you now I would much rather pay more money on the crossover and have better quality of sound than a special 20 but not end up with bloody lips and still be able to bend notes easily like a special 20.
So with that in mind, can you tell me if crossover would be best for me to reach my desires?
Because I want the best, but I also want comfort and no bloody lips.
Also, how are we suppose to clean the crossover harmonica with a bamboo comb?
With womb combs I've seen people have to take the harmonica apart and wash the wood comb and let it air dry and they use a toothbrush and cut the brushes to make them shorter to clean their harmonica. They spoke about the wood swelling. That sounds annoying to deal with.
I'm not sure how to wash with bamboo combs. I figure also take it apart.
Now plastic comb harmonicas seemed much easier to clean. They didn't take it apart. The put it in unscented soapy water and used a tooth brush with brushes cut shorter to clean it then rinsed it out good and banged it against their hand to get water out them they dried it off on the outside and was done. So if I get a crossover, should I also buy a certain tool kit to take it apart when it needs washed or leave it together as I wash it? If so, what kind?
I heard beginners should start on a diatonic harmonica.
Because the tremolo harmonica requires more air to play, and because the chromatic harmonica requires that you have to learn a ton of music theory, the diatonic harmonica is undoubtedly the easiest harmonica to learn how to play they say.
But this was news to me.
And I don't know how to tell the difference between them in just looking at all the harmonicas out there. And what kind of music theory do we need to learn?
My only other question for now is are there any helpful books and dvds on teaching harmonica and tutorials you or anybody would recommend? I do enjoy video tutorials so I can both see and hear what's going on.
And could you share a link with me of the cheapest harmonics crossover in key of c and a link to the most comfortable adjustable neck holder for a harmonica you would also recommend.
I figured it would hurt to ask and maybe you might help me find the best quality for the cheaper price even though it will still be more expensive than the others.
What sites do you recommend?
Yes, definitely start with key of C.
I'm sure you would be happy with the Crossover as it is very easy on the lips, and the triple lacquered bamboo comb won't swell if you wash it under warm tap water (which is how I recommend cleaning it if it starts performing less than desirable.)
Although if you want to save money you could just go with the Special 20, also a phenomenal harp for the money. Here is my article on brands you might find helpful: www.harmonica.com/which-harmonica-to-buy/
Here's my vid on bending, which is not a beginner technique: th-cam.com/video/moVpn-mBFr8/w-d-xo.html
You can go to Rockin Rons for a Crossover:
rockinronsmusic.com/products/hohner-crossover-marine-band-crossover-m2009-with-free-usa-shipping?_pos=1&_sid=1100efd33&_ss=r&variant=35199872106658
Or we have them: www.harmonica.com/store/hohner-crossover-marine-band-key-of-c/
For a neck holder I recommend the Seydel Gecko or probably the Hohner Flexrack, though I haven't tried it yet, I've heard it's very comfy. You can just google each and see all the people who are selling them and find the cheapest.
For learning aids, DEFINITELY the best thing is Beginner to Boss: www.harmonica.com/lessons/
(And I'm TOTALLY unbiased. 😉)
Hope that helps. Happy New Year!
Aloha,
Luke
I don't play the harmonica.....But, I will. Between where I am now and where I want to be, I don't need any handicaps....... Over the years I have had to learn the hard way, and repeatedly, that cut rate tools are just too expensive to use.
I am ordering the Crossover. As I play it, I will know the faults are all mine and something I can fix.......
By the way, your video content is absolutely excellent! Really helped me with some basic information to make the beginner decisions we all start out with. I plan to hang around your channel.................................LIKED/SUBBED
I used to play Harp when I was a kid.
Still have a few laying around, but seldom play !
But once I discovered the Golden Melody, there was no going back, for me !
Mind you, that's better than 50 year's ago, or so, as I'm now 66 !
That said, the prices from what I remember, are insane !
And seemingly new derivations , like the Horner Pinta, that brought me here !
You saved me $50.00 !
Not what I had hoped it was, so thank you for the demo, and comments !
🤘😎
Ha! Love it! 🤘🏼😎
I’m just a player for fun. I’m 71 and played since I was 6. My dad played and that is how I started. Marine Band was my first and I played the first one for 40 years. I bought a new Marine Band and a Special 20 at the same time. A world of difference between the two. The Special 20 is a lot easier to play but I prefer the sound of my Marine Band(personnel preference)
I love harmonicas, I used to have an old Hohner, it had a button on the side, I can't remember it's model name I think it was in the key of C
Hey Geoff - the button on the side means it's a chromatic. Here's my article on the 3 main types of harmonicas:
www.harmonica.com/exploring-the-3-types-of-harmonica/
I find this channel very informative especially since I am new to harmonica. I never knew about the pentaharps.
Right on. Glad it's helping. 👍🏼
What about the big river harp?
I don’t play harmonica much, but this was my first when I was in maybe 5th grade?
I’ve purchased a few special 20s since, but just found my old big river and it piqued my interest in the model again.
The golden melody really did stand out on those melodies with single notes. I need to pick one of those up
Love the Golden Melodies. Lee Oskar have the same tuning as Golden Melodies.
@@Harmonicacom is there a lee Oskar in that 50usd price range that you'd recommend over the golden melody?
Dude, I'm addicted to guitar gear and now I'm getting addicter to harps. Thanks for feeding my new addiction, also congrats on almost hitting 100k subscribers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hey thanks all around! Happy to be adding to your G.A.S (gear acquisition syndrome)
Rock on!
Thanks , Luke. I will by from you because I appreciate these videos
Great vid, thanks. I've decided Id like to have a go at learning to play Harmonica, so been watching a lot of vids and advice. Just ordered myself a Hohner Rocket Amp in C and a Golden Melody (old version) in C. I've also ordered a couple of books for beginners and a Wittner Metronome. Excited to start learning. Best wishes from downunder. 🇦🇺
Right on! Sounds like you're all ready to go!! You got this! 👊🏼🎶
I love the Hohner Crossharp... it's the only harmonica I'll buy now. Sounds great out of the box, easy to adjust if necessary, easy to clean and maintain. You can swap out the reed plates if necessary at about 1/2 the price of a new harp.
Crossharp? Never heard of it!
@@Harmonicacom I got my crosses crossed. Oops.
What harmonica is best for Folk music? Loved this review very sharp and on point. Much love!
Probably Hohner Marine Band Deluxe
Thanks for putting these videos out. It takes work and talent, and it is appreciated.
I appreciate that at ton, Ron! 👊🏼
Great reviews! The Crossover kind of reminds me of the Hohner Rocket Low F I bought a little while ago. Very warm and deep sound, and also comes with an identical zip up case, which gives it bonus points for me. Makes it feel a little bit safer to go outdoors with it!
Yes! Both great harps!
Fantastic video! Really helped me to hear the differences between the harps. I have a Special 20 and I tended to like the tone of that one most on your video. I sorta wish you had tried the Rocket, but no problem.
Yeah Rockets are great too. I prefer the Rocket Amps.
I use the special 20, to play in a band, open to other brands to play classic rock/ blues
You sound great! I purchased many years ago and tried to play about 6 times. I have a Super ..Honner 270.
I'd like to sell it.
Thanks Kathleen! reverb.com.
S20 sounds griddy while crossover sounds cheerfull, I like them both.
Hey Luke , woke up today morning & got this videos notification . Please keep making this type of videos. One thing you could make a review video about marine band deluxe & I think it is a much better harp compare to the original one. Take care . Aloha ....😊😊😊
Hey Ananda - yeah I've never played the Marine Band Deluxe! Glad you're liking the vids. Aloha.
Glad I started on a hohner blues band when they were cheap. Got me started then I got some marine bands later on
Hey coach what do you think about the rocket
The Rocket is a great Harp. For some reason I find it slightly less responsive on the -2 -3 kinda area which is why it didn't make it here. But lots of people love it! It's definitely a great harp.
I've been playing harmonica since I was nine years old. I'm 71 and own about 80 harmonicas. Of Hohners, I totally agree with your breakdown. I did get a set of Marine Band Deluxes because they don't have sharp corners. I actually have a few basic Marine Band keys for setting into a holder so I can play while I drive. ( I like to play along with Bob Dylan songs that way). I have a full major key selection of them, Golden Melody, and Crossovers. I own other brands, however. I like to see what different versions sound like. BTW, never played in a band. I just play for pleasure.
Hey thanks for watching and for leaving this comment. Wow you have a collection to envy for sure!!! ROCK ON! 😎
@@Harmonicacom I'm harmonica crazy. Each one seems like a treasure to me BTW; I woke up early and found this video and picked up one of the several harmonicas I always keep on the stand next to the couch and started to play along. "I Walk the Line," nice way to start the day! Thanks! I like your videos a lot. I sample all of them. You all have something to teach and inspire.
Great video. My favorite one is the HOHNER ROCKET, the update of the Special 20. It´s a true pleasure to hold the ROCKET in my hands, every time i play it. Greetings from Munich, Germany.
Right on Oliver! I love the Rocket Amps.
AMAZING. because, for once, we have somebody who not only KNOWS what he's talking about, but also know HOW TO TALK about it, how to be clear. If politicians and teachers and doctors who "Know stuff" could only speak about it as clearly as this guy then I'd listen to them as well! Thanks a bunch. You should be coaching actors who come to me and wonder why they're not getting jobs! Thanks. John Windsor-Cunningham
LOL! Thanks a bunch John!
I want to get a crossover but i am confused , I see crossover Harmonica (M2009BX-C) or Hohner M2009016X Marine Band Crossover , whats the differance?
Same thing.
Thanks for explaining the comparison of Hohner…I use Johnson Blues King for $9.99 and it works for me….but then again, I’m not Sonny Boy Williamson either.
I always liked the Hohner Polyphonia and Tremolo harmonicas. Suzuki's baritone harmonica is also fabulous.
I ADORED MY "MEISTER CLASSE" LOW TONE HARP TUNED IN G DIATONIC MAJOR!OH WHAT A HARP!(WITH THE ALUMINUM COMB.JA!)
Right on. I've never played one yet.
What do you think about the blues harp? I learned blues harmonica on it by myself reading a tutorial on the internet 14 years ago and I always feel comfortable to use (maybe it is not the best for a beginner for bending)
I prefer the Marine Band Deluxe - more comfy, more responsive, easier to bend
I like my Suzuki pro master 350! I can’t play but it looks cool. My Hohner big river is my favorite. I can’t play it either
Hi...recently received a Crossover. This Beautiful Harmonica has the look of "Ol Timey" about it...but the Tone and Playability in a Word is...Smooth. If you decide to go this way...you won't be disappointed. Highly Recommend. Cheers.
Thanks Norman!
Very helpful vid; thanks, Luke. I'm mainly a trumpet player who doubles on blues harp for some tunes. A comfortable harp of extremely important for me, as I can't have it messing up my trumpet chops. You mentioned that Howard Levy plays the Golden Melody, but he has them customized to the max. I don't have the time, skill or patience to work on harps, so I need something that'll sound good out of the box without tweaking.
I've been playing exclusively Manji's for a few years; they last and take a lot of abuse. But they will crap out on occasion. I'm looking for something better that's not going to break the bank - probably a special 20 or a Cross Over (though it's pricy)
Here's something I haven't come across: how do the flat key harps sound? Most guitar players play in the easier sharp keys. But as mainly a jazz player, I find there's something about the flat keys (F, Bb, Eb and Ab) that sound better to me when you're improvising; can't really explain it. But, I would like to hear what some more advanced players like. yourself have to say about the harps in flat keys. Anyway, thanks again for this vid.
Flat keys sound great! I love Bb (F blues) and Ab (Eb blues.) Db harp cool too (Ab blues) BUT the Eb harp (Bb blues) is a little bit high. Higher harps can be cool, but they can sound a little shrill. I recommend trying the Marine Band Deluxe it's like $65 from Rockin Rons. GREAT harp OOTB. Or your inclination for the Special 20 might be a good fit as well. Rock on! 😎
@@Harmonicacom Thanks for the "sound" advice, my man. I talked my 16 piece big band into giving me a couple solo spots on harp, one being George Benson's "On Broadway", a hit some years back. The solo vamp is in Eb, so I'll be on an Ab harp - or, I could get a Db and play in 3rd position. I seem to struggle more with the low keys like G and Ab - my bad; I don't practice harp enough in the low keys. So, it'll sound good in 3rd position. Anyway your work on these vids is appreciated.
I'm a bigginer and looking forward to the journey! The salesperson at the store said the Hohner Midnight blue was a great choice for a beginner ? I'm wish I would have started years ago .. didnt won't to waste time or money. Please advise
I've never played the Midnight Blue, but my understanding is that they're on par with the Special 20, so you're probably good to go with that! This is my article on Brands:
www.harmonica.com/which-harmonica-to-buy/
The East Top 008k is also a good value. If you wanna fast-track your growth you might consider my Beginner to Boss course:
www.harmonica.com/lessons/
@@Harmonicacom thank you !! 😊 I'm going to check out the B2B course !
I'd love to see what your thoughts are on a Hohner Blues Harp
Copying and pasting this from a reply I just made to someone else with same question:
If you already own a Hohner Blues Harp harmonica, and you’re wondering if it’s a good harmonica to learn on: fear not, you’re in great shape. You’ve got a harmonica very suitable to learn on. If you've got a Hohner Blues Harp and your lips are hurting, consider a plastic-combed harmonica like a Special 20, Golden Melody, or a Lee Oskar.
If you’re currently considering buying a Hohner Blues Harp, here’s my advice:
The Hohner Blues Harp has a wooden comb. If you’re wanting to get a wooden-combed harmonica, I recommend that you just get the tried-and-true original, the Marine Band (or, if you can afford it, the Crossover which is much comfier on the lips with its triple-lacquered bamboo comb)
I guess if you’re saving $20 getting a Blues Harp instead of a Marine Band, and you’re on a tight budget, go for it. But if you’re only saving $5 or $10, I’d say, just save up and get the Marine Band. In my opinion the Marine Band has superior tone, is more responsive, and is easier to bend and control bends on, and so I think it’s well worth the extra money.
If money isn’t tight and you’re the kind of person who likes the best of the best, then go for the Crossover!
Hope that helps!
Wow, outstanding video!! Thank you for the information. Can you let me know what type of harmonica Kim Wilson plays on “Looking for trouble”? On hohners site they say he plays the chromonica 64 and marine blues.
Thanks
Great review! If one is just starting out, and decides to buy a Special 20, what key should one start with?
C!
I love my set of Crossovers. A little lacking in volume played acoustically but an amplifier takes care of all the problems.
Yes!! CROSSOVERS ROCK!!! 😎
Very good video,thanks! 09:16 Why does it looks like you played most effortlessly on the Marine Band, on Special20 you seem to struggle more...
Just watched it and see I what you're saying. Marine Band Deluxe is my favorite brand to play that style on.
What is best Horner to use with a harmonica holder like Bob Dylan and Neil Young? Thanks!
If you're playing a folk style like Bob Dylan and Neil Young I'd probably go with the Hohner Special 20.
Wow! Great video, great comments. I really like how he dismisses the cheap harmonicas right of the bat.😁
🤣 Glad you liked it!
You've introduced me to the crossover. Bamboo combs you say - do those combs end up swelling and protruding like I remember the wood combs doing? Thanks!
Nope, never had a Crossover triple-lacquered bamboo comb swell or splinter.
*Awesome comparisons!* That Marine Band tone comes through each time. I'm gonna try a low key, E(?) and smooth the lips with sandpaper. I should probably research before posting foolish ideas, but inspiration from your video got the best of me.
Nice. Let me know how it works out for ya. Rock on!
I’ve been a player for 40 years now and my favorite has always been the standard marine band. I used to love the old style blues harp but not so much the ms series model. I’ve also used golden melodies and special 20s but keep coming back to the marine band. Thanks for the cool video! I’m also not a fan of the rocket models but I absolutely love the Pentaharp!
Very cool! Yeah Adam Gussow is Marine Band guy too. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.😎
I had a Marine Band and I didn't really like it. This was like 20 years ago or something so I don't know if they changed it or something but I remember not liking the wooden comb. I guess I was spoiled by plastic but since I'm not that great I need whatever advantage I can take. Lol.
Thanks for this video, great overview! I’m taking your Beginner-To-Boss course now, using a Special 20 in C. Because I feel like I’m going to stick with it, I added Special 20s in G, A, D & E, and Lee Oskars in Bb and F, so I can try out different keys. Your course is a lot of fun, and it helps that I’ve played guitar for over 30 years so I know what blues licks should sound like. I haven’t gotten to bending yet, but I mess around with whatever sounds good. At some point, I’m definitely interested in trying out some different harps, especially the Crossover, and maybe some different versions of the Rocket. I guess I’m hesitant about the Crossover because I like rinsing my harps briefly under the tap after each time I play them to keep them clean, not sure that would work with a Crossover because of the bamboo comb. I guess that’s a silly reason not to get one, though! Anyway, thanks again!!
Hey there - right on my friend. Glad you're digging the course! Bamboo is the most water-resistant wood, and it's triple-lacquered, so I wouldn't let that stop you from trying one! Thanks for the note. Rock on!!
Hi, Luke: I LOVE your informative videos!!!! Which harmonica should I buy to play Dylan, Neil Young, and other folk-rock? I play acoustic guitar and I want to get a harmonica holder, too!
Is the Special 20 too "dark" to play Dylan, Young, etc.? Or, would you recommend the Crossover-- which you say is "brighter?" Thanks!
Right on. I think the Special 20 will be great. 👍🏼
I'd be glad to see a count down video reviewing tutorial books, For Dummies, Mel Bay, Everything Harmonica and such.
The For Dummies books are such a great resource. Winslow is so knowledgeable about harmonicas, I've used harmonica for dummies as a resource. I love it.
@@Harmonicacom I have Dummies first edition. Are you familiar with their second edition, is there enough new material to make both worthwhile? Do you know anything about this book, "Masters of the Harmonica" Goldsmith, M. I cannot tell if it is mainly a tutorial or conversations about harp playing.
I've read it too
@@ecalzo Which?
@@soslothful first edition by Winslow Yerxa found in pdf
The cross over that you played sounds similar. My husband was a drummer. And my granddaughter sings.
Awesome!
Thanks for this video. The harmonicas you are playing, do they sound and play like that out of the box? Or did you made some tuning or customization to them?
Hey Edgard - out of the box. I'm to lazy to customize them! ;-)
@@Harmonicacom Thanks for answering, good to know as I tried to improve my harmonica but got it worse instead. Also I wasn't really sure if it wass my lack of technique or the instrument that didn't play well. Now with your video and confirmation I'll buy a crossover and have no excuse.
I've always fancied getting one of the Crossover harps as I live on a bamboo farm. However, I don't have a lot of confidence that the humidity in the tropics will allow it to last very long. Sadly the comb my marine band harp is almost in pieces. For that reason I'm a Special 20 guy. Thanks for posting the video, all the best from Panama.
Hey Jim - bamboo is the most water resistant wood, AND it's TRIPLE lacquered (MB's are only double lacquered.) I'm in Hawaii - very similar climate to Panama. I've had a Crossover for 3 years, it's still rocking and rolling. GO FOR IT! 🙌🏼
@@Harmonicacom Good to hear. Perhaps I'll pull the trigger after all. Thanks for the advice. (and the videos)
great content always gets me thinking on how to improve my playing thank you for sharing
Happy to help, James! Rock on! 🤘🏼
I agree, specially when it comes the special 20: It’s the easiest to bend.
Hey Serge - right? Every time I play one I'm like, MAN this thing is easy to bend!
The LO’s are even easier to bend. So much so, that a lot of folks don’t stick with them because they bend too far and it’ll buzz or squeal.
@@norfolknwhey4787 I tried the Lee Oskar Blues harmonicas a long time ago. I was not impressed by the tone or the quality….
@@sergehulne most of the tone comes from the player and embouchure, not the harp. Some harps, such as the special 20, disguise poor form and embouchure behind decent tone. Other models, don’t provide as much forgiveness.
I have played around with the harmonica in the past and even happen to own both a Special 20 and a Crossover. Both harmonicas are in the key of C. I would like to learn to play the harmonica. Question: what are the most popular or common keys used by musicians other than C?
G, A, and D are very common.
Started out on Special 20 went through a lot of makes and models and some custom harmonica's till I found the Golden Melody, love the feel , look and play ability and easy maintenance.P.S. Great shot out.
YES RAYMOND! 💯 Another great harp player who I just realized plays Golden Melodies is Terry McMillan. Great stuff, bro. Rock on. 🤘🏼
@@Harmonicacom Rachelle Plas is a super player on the G.M.😎.
Finding them good when playing along with horns but you do need to over blow and draw at times.
Golden Melody all the way but man that crossover sounds crisp on the high end
I have the special 20 I got it 45 years ago compared to the American ace is very smooth. But I got some American ace in the box but were the new style plastic and not metal and wood. The new ones play well. I got the American aces cus of Sonny played them . Thanks for the info.
Hey Neil thanks for sharing. Never heard of American ace. Sonny who?
@@Harmonicacom I sorry but I believed it was a guy sonny boy nickname that played American ace I got them back in the 60s few years ago I could only get them in plastic they play well. But just after seeing this vid I just found the old wood and metal style made in Ireland, fir dirt cheap almost new, what a find cus these I can make it feedback like a amp feedback it's so cool. Just want to add I bought his book and two harmonicas tried and couldn't play at all , no blues that is . Put them away for years then one day I picked it up and started playing and iT all made sense to Mr. Weird
Thank you for the thorough review!
What do you think of the Hohner Rocket ?
Hohner Rockets are great. They didn't make this vid because I find them to be slightly less responsive for my playing style. The Rocket Amps I do love though!
Hi, I have a Big River Harp Hohner. What do you think of her?
Hi Luke, do you know anything about the Hohner Blues harp?
I'm considering buying it since I've already owned a marine band. If you have any idea, I would be really interested to hear it.
I wouldn't recommend. Have you tried the Marine Band Deluxe? Much better harp! Available at Rockin Rons in the States.
If I do some grinding would that make marine-band more confortable ? sound great and more bright than special 20.
Get the Marine Band Deluxe form Rockin' Rons. Super comfy. Didn't know about it when I made this vid.
I used to prefer the Pro harp but that was before MS. Switched over to the Special 20. I'm not so careful about the care of my harps so I stay away from the traditional wood combs. They are too easily wrecked by moisture (beer and such). But I may try that Crossover at some point. Good video!
I'm just like you William. Yeah, Crossover is definitely a great harp. Rock on!
thnx for the info and demo, i have a nice collection too of diatonics and several chromatics.
Thanks for watching!
What do you think about the pro harp and cross harp non ms series.
Sorry, I have not played them.
Always on the TOP !!! Congrats man !
Right on Antonio!
Hi, Luke. I realy love the crossover but where would you put the Deluxe?
Hey Antonio - Just played my first Deluxe. LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT compared to the MB 1896. I don't ever wanna play an 1896 again! 🤣 Haven't compared it to Crossover yet...
Thanks. That's what I think. Great...
All I can say is, Thank you Luke❤
Right on Felix. You're most welcome my man. 👊🏼
you are great Luke and thank you...
You are most welcome, Tonaas! Thanks for your kind words. 🙏🏼
Hi Luke, thanks for your answer, I have another question, can you tell me why we have so many 'C' Type harmonicas, example, low C, Major C, Blues C, can you tell my why we don't just have one C type?
Hey Geoff - "Blues" is the same as standard. There's just C and the one an octave lower "Low C"
Right now I have a Special 20, Golden Melody, and a Rocket that I just got. Right now I’m loving the Rocket. It’s like a better version of the Special 20. Rounded edges makes it really comfortable and the larger holes makes it really easy to play.
Awesome. Thank you so much for sharing!
Thank you Luke.
Very welcome Bob!
Thanks for the video Luke for me as a beginner I will go for special 20 a soon I learn more and more I will upgrade to the crossover thanks again u gain another subs also I’m a bass and guitar player 😊
Great to hear, thanks! That sounds like a solid plan. That bass and guitar playing is gonna help you a TON with learning harmonica!
Hi! I didn't find any video from you about the Hohner blues harp MS C. I did order it and after that I saw some comments that said bending could be a bit difficult. Well someone said that it's one of the easiest. I'm total beginner so what do you think? Can I go with it or prefer the special 20. Thanks!
If you already have the blues harp and you're a beginner, you're good to go! No need buy the SP20 if money is tight. Is that helpful?
I love my Special 20, but if you get a wild mustache hair in one of the comb holes, it's getting yanked out! I wish there was a way to mitigate that without trimming my stache
#priorities. 😉 Or, you could try a Golden Melody and keep the whiskers. Of course, pain is good for playing the blues. 😎
Over the years of playing and noise from the Job, my ears can't tell much of a difference in tone. I've tried this test on my own assortment harps, probably have about 20 different C's around. One can tell the difference in the Hohner and the cheap knockoffs. That said, I bought my grandsons a couple of Fenders to get them started. Good comparison on your video.
Hey, even with golden ears, the difference in tone is not as huge as some act like it is. The player makes a much bigger difference on the sound of harp than the harp itself! 🤣
I don't disagree with the results although I should qualify my response by adding I have never heard of the Pentaharp! However, I started playing at the age of seven (I'm 65 now!) and I found that my lips got used to playing the Marine Band 1896 and 'toughened up' much like a guitar player's fingers toughen up with constant practice.
Nice video - and I am curious with the Pentaharp - although playing it would really confuse my subconscious and would wreck my normal harp play!
I don't recommend picking up the Pentaharp honestly. But I DO recommend treating yourself to a Crossover if you've never played one and it's in your budget.
@@Harmonicacom I recently bought a couple of the Thunderbirds - the Low D and the Low G. They are not built for bending, although they will with care, but they each have a super tone. They are excellent for slow ballads. I am at a loss to understand how, after owning at least forty harmonicas, how I still haven't yet bought a Crossover - but I can tell from listening to them online that they sound wonderfully flexible and I am sure when I do purchase one (an early Christmas present for myself!) it will soon become my favourite harp. I play all kinds of styles, including a great deal of single note tunes, so I am definitely going to get one of the Golden Melody harps you mentioned. I hate the key of C (too shrill for my tastes) so I'll probably buy an A or G. Keep up the good work.