Looking at the formula because it is a multiplication. The only way to increase the "cubes" is by increasing the IPM or by using a better tool that has more woc or doc
And making sure your fixturing can handle the MRR - and maybe multiple parts to the spindle keeps spinning instead of stopping to be loaded all the time. You can think or MRR over a day.
Well by the description. The most time is spent in a normal job is removing the bulk of material. Thus for most jobs if you can remove it faster them thats where you makenup time. So MRR is the key number. While you may be able to finish faster using a mill with more flutes, there's probably not as much to be gained on that. And it's time will be dictated largely by the tolerance and finish spec. Everyone will have to meet that so its not going to be hugely different unless somebody is rubbish or telling pokies. There may be unusual jobs where this doesn't apply bit he's talking about your bread and butter. Would be interesting to see how this is applied to lathe work. Never see much cnc stuff on lathes. The skill is in knowing how hard you can push either the tool or the machine. My little cnc hobby mill only has 360w on the motor. But that's a lot on a 3mm end mill. The only difference is scale. So even it once you are in to small parts you are looking at how hard you can push the tools. I'm actally quite shocked by what 360w can do. OK it's not ripping of material like these beasts. But a 10mm end mill taking a 10mm deep by 0.5mm step at 600mm/min is way more than I expected. Its a really strong little mill, and I'm loving it. Feel like I'm doing the wrong job.
As all your videos, Thanks Titan. You are someone to follow as model success. We use KOR5 1/2" with MRR:32 in3/min and that means a lot of productivity. Thanks again.
There are many factors in the overall time used to make a part but MRR is a piece of the puzzle for sure. One thing to remember is that it's great to save ≈1h in machine time however if it just sits on a pallet that gain is lost. You have to take this drive of improving the process and apply it as whole to the entire company. With that said; I would like to see more about how you inspect these parts. As a metrologist a and CMM programmer i think talking about how you machine to hit the specs would be cool. I.E machining to the Datums ext.
Titan formula for making outstanding Utube is the LOVE of creating Da Vinci meets his maker, Your tutorials are on another level. How is your 3D going? Can't wait for nxt vid
So the greater the WOC and deeper the DOC combined with fastest feed rate for the tool/machine/material is what youre looking for. To remove a said volume of material as quickly as possible to leave time to start on the next job and make more $. Did I get it right?
I notice you guys climb mill with the end mill. You can get a lot more meat off if your not and not have your work get snatched out of your vise or chuck. Love your vids.
(coming from somebody that doesn't know you) Unless you use a down-cut em, I don't see the difference a piece getting pulled up from the vice. Also, do you know about how much more of a chip load an em will take (climb vs conventional)? To my knowledge, any chip load recommendations from the tool manufacturer are based on climb milling. I'd appreciate any feedback.
I've realised in my case excessive time spent to accurately quote a job is a bit of a waste of time when the cycle time is short and quantity is very low like 1 off 2off or just a few.US is a big market not like here in oz.
So we have an Endmill in our Shop with nearly double the Mrr :) Kor5: 2.5mm x 50mm x 10000mm/min =1.250.000 mm³/min Our Tool: 7mm x 30mm x 11000mm/min = 2.310.000 mm³/min
@@christianbreu814 shorter tools can go harder. it doesn't help much if the wall of your part is 50mm, you would need to come back for a second op with a longer tool increasing machining time. also there are other metrics at play, how long do your tools last? you can always push them harder, but if you're looking for a reliable stable process it's best to run them less than full throttle.
Ok Titan Mrr is not the most important factor. I have been in this industry for 35 years. I manage a shop (small) and run 3 machines (one 4 axis and two 5 axis Mazaks) fixturing and programming is what brings in the dollars. We mainly run small lot Aerospace parts in all the materials you talk about. Killing it is about One and Done setups. I design complicated fixturing to complete a part in one setup. I dont care about MRR. I care about one setup for a part and ship it!
I'd argue it all is about equally important, however it all comes down to process reliability, doesn't matter how fast your going or how good your fixtures are, if your parts are taking inconsistent amounts of time your process isn't reliable. Whether it be becuase your going to fast and breaking tools, or your fixtures aren't as "idiot proof" as you'd hope. Tool paths can create unreliability as well.
@@Greg-ms4kk did you even read my response? How doesn't it make sense? I'm not saying MRR is the most important thing. I'm saying process reliability is. Regardless if your using castings or starting from raw bar, if your process isn't reliable your parts will all be taking inconsistent amounts of time.
@@PlinkingLePew Yes i read your response..... Your parts cant take an inconsistent amount of time. Toolpath is Toolpath. Every part you run is the same exact time. If you are breaking tools to slow that process down then your programming is off. And yes my fixtures are idiot proof..... Every single time....Perfection is my Mantra....
@@Greg-ms4kk first off I'm not speaking of you in particular. Second, your missing my point, for example If your going to fast and tool life isn't consistent then your parts machine times aren't consistent becuase your forced to change out tools....making the process unreliable. If you alter the program to reduce feed and make tool life more consistent, well guess what, you just made the process more reliable. So again. Process reliability is king.
Does your academy provide direct education and training services on CNC machines? I am from Saudi Arabia and I would like to train with you. Your channel helped me a lot, thank you.
i can't speak for titan but i'm my shop depth of cut is always the flute length of the tool, width of cut is the maximum i can get away with before the tool starts deflecting or reaching full load on the spindle. whichever comes first.
Not working with Titan, but I used to be a machinist. It really depends on the tool, the horsepower, and the job. For example, with a 6 flute tool it's usually better to put max speed in terms of ipm, and see after what's the width you can take. With a 3/4 flute I prefer to go full diameter and the push it to see how far we can go. So the differebce is excentially on the application. I prefer using a 6 flute mill, for the exterior roughing, for the ineterior, i use to use a 4 flute if it's someting big, and a 3 flute if it's someting smaller, because the second one can also drill very fast without using cirular interpolation, that slowes down the speed pretty much. The rest is all about the machine, so how far can you push it, and in bigger machine you can take bigger depth or width of cut, in smaller it's better to speed up in terms of rpm, go full speed in terms of ipm, and the take a little depth or width of cut, in stronger machine you can take bigger asportation. I'm from Italy so I don't know if my grammar is quite correct, but i hope this will help
I mean, i understand MRR and all that but i still hate plunging a custom internal cutter straight into the piece in the way the companies i have worked at do I just dont like the sound or the vibrations coming from it but it removes upward of 16kg of steel per minute on some machines I think 16.7 kg was on a makino mag 3 where we plunged a custom 8-stepped in-house cutter about 600 mm into a block of steel at ~1500 mm/min, hitting about 95 KW and putting the fear of god into all the workers nearby
@@themattrixrevolution If they are consistently expecting the impossible due to other employees short comings and poor decisions, and you aren't getting paid to finsh the engineers job or allowed the time. It's time for greener pastures. It depends on the shop.
@@themattrixrevolution I was in the exact same position at my last shop. I'd get handed travelers that were printed 3 weeks ago, now the job is due in 4 days. Meanwhile all of the machines in my department are booked up with all of the other jobs that sat on somebodies desk (not mine) for 3 weeks before I ever saw them. Then management bitches about OT and late jobs. I was in a production meeting one time and the shops "president" asks why the shop schedule shows that over 1/3 of the jobs on the floor are late. He says "That can't be right." My supervisor steps up and says "Yeah that sounds about right" I have a stack of travelers with me at the time. I showed him the dates on them and what I have currently running in my department. His jaw hit the table. Not only was it more then 1/3 it was over 50% of the jobs were currently late. I had jobs that were due at the customer BEFORE I even had the traveler in my hands. It got to the point where I kept a spread sheet of the dates of when I was handed jobs and the dates the traveler was printed. It was that bad. To make matter worse less than 3 weeks after that meeting all of the supervisors and department leads get an email from the "president" saying that we needed to make sure our jobs were "on schedule" and to "keep OT in check". That was the last straw for me. To me it just showed that he had ZERO clue as to how to effectively manage a shop or how to actually fix the issues that made us constantly late. I got a job a t a better shop MUCH closer to home for a shit load more money with people that actually understand how to run a shop. Last I heard not only the "president", but the shop's GM had gotten shit canned for poor performance.
@@brandons9138 same but it was a wait time of over a year. I quit because I was just getting low balled. 3 CNC machine for $16/hr. For 10+hrs. I had to put my 2 weeks. I had no small break in-between. I just jumped machine to machine in a big triangle.
Great video. The answer to the kids who ask why do I need to learn geometry and math? Well, because the other guy who knows math can outbid you. I’m curious do you also take in the costs of the wasted material? I imagine in cast iron that wanted material is cheap (easy to recycle and dispose of, versus Ti or inconel Cost a lot and you don’t get that material cost back in recycling.
I'm liking the new format of the videos and the more detailed content. thank you.
i’ll never be a CNC Machinist, but i certainly enjoy the education.
You can manifest anything you want king! Never too late
You could absolutely be a teacher man! If only there were more like you. So many more people would be interested in the field
This is the videos I need as an aspiring shop owner, I need these moments.
Your shop is amazing. Clean, well lit and organized. A machinists dream.
Looking at the formula because it is a multiplication. The only way to increase the "cubes" is by increasing the IPM or by using a better tool that has more woc or doc
And making sure your fixturing can handle the MRR - and maybe multiple parts to the spindle keeps spinning instead of stopping to be loaded all the time. You can think or MRR over a day.
Im not even a machinist,im an electrician,dude im so stoked to watch you talk about machining stuff
excellent explanation Titan, going to the fundamentals so we can build strong from there, more vids like this! thanks
I love how much you just give and give. Thank you.
Mr. Miyagi of machining right here I love it!
The most important measure is TIME , because you charge your customers based on total time needed to make and inspect the product
MRR is based on the most cubes of material taken off in a certain amount of time…
Well by the description. The most time is spent in a normal job is removing the bulk of material.
Thus for most jobs if you can remove it faster them thats where you makenup time. So MRR is the key number.
While you may be able to finish faster using a mill with more flutes, there's probably not as much to be gained on that. And it's time will be dictated largely by the tolerance and finish spec. Everyone will have to meet that so its not going to be hugely different unless somebody is rubbish or telling pokies.
There may be unusual jobs where this doesn't apply bit he's talking about your bread and butter.
Would be interesting to see how this is applied to lathe work. Never see much cnc stuff on lathes.
The skill is in knowing how hard you can push either the tool or the machine.
My little cnc hobby mill only has 360w on the motor. But that's a lot on a 3mm end mill. The only difference is scale. So even it once you are in to small parts you are looking at how hard you can push the tools.
I'm actally quite shocked by what 360w can do. OK it's not ripping of material like these beasts. But a 10mm end mill taking a 10mm deep by 0.5mm step at 600mm/min is way more than I expected. Its a really strong little mill, and I'm loving it.
Feel like I'm doing the wrong job.
As all your videos, Thanks Titan.
You are someone to follow as model success. We use KOR5 1/2" with MRR:32 in3/min and that means a lot of productivity. Thanks again.
"Kiss that baby right into tolerance" lol
with his physical illustrations 😂
It means just a light touch.
😁
There are many factors in the overall time used to make a part but MRR is a piece of the puzzle for sure. One thing to remember is that it's great to save ≈1h in machine time however if it just sits on a pallet that gain is lost. You have to take this drive of improving the process and apply it as whole to the entire company.
With that said; I would like to see more about how you inspect these parts. As a metrologist a and CMM programmer i think talking about how you machine to hit the specs would be cool. I.E machining to the Datums ext.
Titan formula for making outstanding Utube is the LOVE of creating
Da Vinci meets his maker, Your tutorials are on another level. How is your 3D going? Can't wait for nxt vid
Awesome info, good to use even if our shops are small and tooling is old school, thx Titan.
I wish the shop I worked at taught us stuff.... they just want button pushers and parts catchers. 😔 Thanks for the upload. Just subscribed! 🛠🇺🇸
Great straight to the point video .
Never touched a CNC machine but I understand the class.
Thank you for your professional knowledge that ur sharing
I am interested in this field and want to work with you guys. You guys are awesome.
So the greater the WOC and deeper the DOC combined with fastest feed rate for the tool/machine/material is what youre looking for. To remove a said volume of material as quickly as possible to leave time to start on the next job and make more $.
Did I get it right?
Yea! More metrics videos please!!!
The end is Epic! :-D
I notice you guys climb mill with the end mill. You can get a lot more meat off if your not and not have your work get snatched out of your vise or chuck. Love your vids.
(coming from somebody that doesn't know you) Unless you use a down-cut em, I don't see the difference a piece getting pulled up from the vice. Also, do you know about how much more of a chip load an em will take (climb vs conventional)? To my knowledge, any chip load recommendations from the tool manufacturer are based on climb milling. I'd appreciate any feedback.
Wow knowledge is empowering.
It is as certain as death and taxes that someone in that shop is dying to stick a firecracker in that yodeling chipmunk and light the fuse!! LMAO!!
I've realised in my case excessive time spent to accurately quote a job is a bit of a waste of time when the cycle time is short and quantity is very low like 1 off 2off or just a few.US is a big market not like here in oz.
Great detailing sir, i am looking forward to learn more from you 😘
So we have an Endmill in our Shop with nearly double the Mrr :)
Kor5: 2.5mm x 50mm x 10000mm/min =1.250.000 mm³/min
Our Tool: 7mm x 30mm x 11000mm/min = 2.310.000 mm³/min
Same material being cut? Can't really compare machining something like 4140 to say 718 inconel.
Yes, same material. Aluminum, maybe a little bit diffrent but not a lot.
@@christianbreu814 shorter tools can go harder. it doesn't help much if the wall of your part is 50mm, you would need to come back for a second op with a longer tool increasing machining time.
also there are other metrics at play, how long do your tools last? you can always push them harder, but if you're looking for a reliable stable process it's best to run them less than full throttle.
@@christianbreu814 what endmill? I use a gwstool alumigator ART for all my roughing, it's capable of doing some pretty serious MRR.
You need to compare a 7mm Kor5. No way to compare a much smaller tool to a bigger one.
Ok Titan Mrr is not the most important factor. I have been in this industry for 35 years. I manage a shop (small) and run 3 machines (one 4 axis and two 5 axis Mazaks) fixturing and programming is what brings in the dollars. We mainly run small lot Aerospace parts in all the materials you talk about. Killing it is about One and Done setups. I design complicated fixturing to complete a part in one setup. I dont care about MRR. I care about one setup for a part and ship it!
I'd argue it all is about equally important, however it all comes down to process reliability, doesn't matter how fast your going or how good your fixtures are, if your parts are taking inconsistent amounts of time your process isn't reliable. Whether it be becuase your going to fast and breaking tools, or your fixtures aren't as "idiot proof" as you'd hope. Tool paths can create unreliability as well.
@@PlinkingLePew Your response doesn't even make sense! WTF? what if it is a casting! MRR? I dont think so..........
@@Greg-ms4kk did you even read my response? How doesn't it make sense? I'm not saying MRR is the most important thing. I'm saying process reliability is. Regardless if your using castings or starting from raw bar, if your process isn't reliable your parts will all be taking inconsistent amounts of time.
@@PlinkingLePew Yes i read your response..... Your parts cant take an inconsistent amount of time. Toolpath is Toolpath. Every part you run is the same exact time. If you are breaking tools to slow that process down then your programming is off. And yes my fixtures are idiot proof..... Every single time....Perfection is my Mantra....
@@Greg-ms4kk first off I'm not speaking of you in particular.
Second, your missing my point, for example If your going to fast and tool life isn't consistent then your parts machine times aren't consistent becuase your forced to change out tools....making the process unreliable. If you alter the program to reduce feed and make tool life more consistent, well guess what, you just made the process more reliable.
So again. Process reliability is king.
good video titan
Thanks Titan.
Does your academy provide direct education and training services on CNC machines? I am from Saudi Arabia and I would like to train with you. Your channel helped me a lot, thank you.
Academy.titansofcnc.com
Free for All
this are amzing vidoes keep em up
Love your videos man. I'm not in the cnc biz. But I love your additude and positivity.
Please up load the video in.... Unit mm.
Wiha Tools
13 Piece Torx® Ball End Hex L-Key Set....🔥
Ball end torx
How do you determine your max width and depth of cut for various materials? is that a spec of the bit?
i can't speak for titan but i'm my shop depth of cut is always the flute length of the tool, width of cut is the maximum i can get away with before the tool starts deflecting or reaching full load on the spindle. whichever comes first.
Ah ok, that makes sense. Do you do test passes to check for deflection or how do you know when you’re reaching your max spindle load?
Not working with Titan, but I used to be a machinist. It really depends on the tool, the horsepower, and the job. For example, with a 6 flute tool it's usually better to put max speed in terms of ipm, and see after what's the width you can take. With a 3/4 flute I prefer to go full diameter and the push it to see how far we can go. So the differebce is excentially on the application. I prefer using a 6 flute mill, for the exterior roughing, for the ineterior, i use to use a 4 flute if it's someting big, and a 3 flute if it's someting smaller, because the second one can also drill very fast without using cirular interpolation, that slowes down the speed pretty much. The rest is all about the machine, so how far can you push it, and in bigger machine you can take bigger depth or width of cut, in smaller it's better to speed up in terms of rpm, go full speed in terms of ipm, and the take a little depth or width of cut, in stronger machine you can take bigger asportation. I'm from Italy so I don't know if my grammar is quite correct, but i hope this will help
Thanks to you both for your answers!
good, also BOOM
I mean, i understand MRR and all that but i still hate plunging a custom internal cutter straight into the piece in the way the companies i have worked at do
I just dont like the sound or the vibrations coming from it but it removes upward of 16kg of steel per minute on some machines
I think 16.7 kg was on a makino mag 3 where we plunged a custom 8-stepped in-house cutter about 600 mm into a block of steel at ~1500 mm/min, hitting about 95 KW and putting the fear of god into all the workers nearby
@@elanjacobs1 i havent worked at the place with the makino for nearly 2 years now, sadly
and there was a strict no filming policy anyway
LOVE IT...BOOOOMMM!!!
Haimer bear says....! :D Charles
Converting to metric would be a nightmare for you
Good Job :) #DuplexCNC
I like leaving my parts .015 big because some of these programmer aren't that great at making fixtures or the program. Then I'll go to size
.....but after the first time you set up and run the job, you don't have to go through that again, right ?
@@5oclockshadowbanned154 right. Except my last job. They liked to rush everything. I couldn't deal with it. So I quit.
@@themattrixrevolution
If they are consistently expecting the impossible due to other employees short comings and poor decisions, and you aren't getting paid to finsh the engineers job or allowed the time. It's time for greener pastures. It depends on the shop.
@@themattrixrevolution I was in the exact same position at my last shop. I'd get handed travelers that were printed 3 weeks ago, now the job is due in 4 days. Meanwhile all of the machines in my department are booked up with all of the other jobs that sat on somebodies desk (not mine) for 3 weeks before I ever saw them. Then management bitches about OT and late jobs. I was in a production meeting one time and the shops "president" asks why the shop schedule shows that over 1/3 of the jobs on the floor are late. He says "That can't be right." My supervisor steps up and says "Yeah that sounds about right" I have a stack of travelers with me at the time. I showed him the dates on them and what I have currently running in my department. His jaw hit the table. Not only was it more then 1/3 it was over 50% of the jobs were currently late. I had jobs that were due at the customer BEFORE I even had the traveler in my hands. It got to the point where I kept a spread sheet of the dates of when I was handed jobs and the dates the traveler was printed. It was that bad. To make matter worse less than 3 weeks after that meeting all of the supervisors and department leads get an email from the "president" saying that we needed to make sure our jobs were "on schedule" and to "keep OT in check". That was the last straw for me. To me it just showed that he had ZERO clue as to how to effectively manage a shop or how to actually fix the issues that made us constantly late. I got a job a t a better shop MUCH closer to home for a shit load more money with people that actually understand how to run a shop. Last I heard not only the "president", but the shop's GM had gotten shit canned for poor performance.
@@brandons9138 same but it was a wait time of over a year. I quit because I was just getting low balled. 3 CNC machine for $16/hr. For 10+hrs. I had to put my 2 weeks. I had no small break in-between. I just jumped machine to machine in a big triangle.
How is your health my friend?Are you okay?You have lost weight?
Feeling great! New diet, I’m happy with it. Thanks
Great video. The answer to the kids who ask why do I need to learn geometry and math? Well, because the other guy who knows math can outbid you. I’m curious do you also take in the costs of the wasted material? I imagine in cast iron that wanted material is cheap (easy to recycle and dispose of, versus Ti or inconel Cost a lot and you don’t get that material cost back in recycling.
Genius
Why dont you Americans start using the metric sistem already... Those Inches are the past...
You gotta spell system properly if you’re demanding someone use it 😂
They love challenges thous,1/16,33/64's,21"15/16 just a head fuck I reckon.Metric is too simple.
It's all just numbers to me. I work in both inches and metric. It's not that difficult.
Legacy systems are hard to change especially when productive young males use them because it was what they were taught.
Ничего не понятно, но очень интересно (ц)
#Basics
Boom
#Love
100% rigid
Lmao. Why not just do a test run to find the time and be completely accurate.
I believe I said that in the video😂😂😂
LET'S GO BRANDON!