First I died from Geoff's gorgeous bass voice, and then I died watching Dave repeat the last note for 20 years. Excellent reaction and as soon as I watched Geoff's video I thought: Dave is gonna have a good time with this! 😆
Your reaction to that last note was the longest Bassgasm I‘ve ever seen, Jesus! 😂😂 But yeah, I can totally agree, Geoff‘s version of this song is phenomenal!
The great thing about Geoff Castellucci is he can hit "the shiver note" so effortlessly it just leaves you stunned. To anyone who isn't familiar with Geoff Castellucci the shiver note is a sub harmonic note that's so low it physically sends shivers up your spine.
@@mychaeldark1007 The Great Harry Styles once said: We’re all a little bit gay, aren’t we? HAHAHAHAHAHHA. There’s no heterosexual or homosexual when we’re talking about Geoff Castellucci. There’s just him and what his voice does to people. No gender is safe.
I am SO happy to see someone feels the same way as me about this song. I just cant get enough of this video. It's a great reaction! Ive watched it 3 times already & im not done yet😊❤️!
There was absolutely no chance that Geoff doing this song was going to be anything less than phenomenal. I still like the version by Peter Hollins and Tim Faust as well. It's a song that basically demands a low bass singer to do regardless of what other singers you have joining in.
Doing the standard bass singing parts of this are easy for a normal bass singer... then you have Geoff doing his insanity, lol. Even a skilled baritone can cover most of this -- Geoff is actually hanging out in the lower baritone register for the majority of this (other than his tenor harmony lines)... then he decides to drop into contrabass.
I think this is the closest to speechless we've ever seen you. You speak so much with facial expressions though we get it. Rip to the dragons who were sacrificed for this masterpiece.
Welcome to the group of us that have died listening to this. We have lost all words on how to describe this and why we feel so emotional with this. It truly hits your soul. I have listened to this since it came out on Patreon and I STILL can't explain in words
I’ve been waiting for someone to react to this all day, I know it just came out but I just wanted to see someone else love it as much as I did and it was a blast watching your reaction, thank you!
See, we never knew he had three big brothers, did we? And all as good at the deep stuff. :) It's awesome. And that's not a word I use lightly. Not sure whether you liked that or not LOL
The second or third time I heard this I couldn't get Dave's stank face out of my head. I just knew this one was going to slay you: while the bass notes are great the harmonies are gorgeous.
Yes! And as far as I'm concerned he's the only singer who truly does do it justice. There are other good versions of this, but Geoff's is, quite simply, the way this song was always meant to sound. Nobody else has hit that level.
*I still laugh at this reaction!!!🤣I truly believe that Geoff's low notes can either cause you to go into cardiac arrest, or bring you out of it!! One or the other!!😂*
So glad you got your reaction up so fast, I’ve been looking forward to it! This cover is so beautiful!!! I love the strings! Condolences to the dragons 😁
Quite beyond the vocals, the costumes, the hair, and facial hair were spectacular! And of course the vocals were (as usual) spectacular). And your reaction was priceless.
Dave, I am a pretty reserved guy.... you got me laughing hysterically with your reaction to that last note - if you knew me you'd know what an accomplishment that is! xD
The note so deep his glasses flew off🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I could tell you had the time of your life in this one, Dave! You never dissapoint!☺ And Dave, you have a rich deep voice too, you should sing something!🙂
What a great rendition! His voice is so perfect for this and the arrangement and his harmonies with himself with the instruments adding just a touch of the ancient Gaelic atmosphere. PS: Note Geoff retasked the costumes from My Mother Told Me. Look closely and figure which Geoff is wearing other VoicePlay's outfits. PPS - Who else thinks that it's Layne Stein on that violin?
That top with the rings sews on was very distinctive - the first time I saw this, before he started singing (and I couldn't think of anything but "oh good heavens!"), I definitely noticed that one.
@@welchbrice8303 While Layne absolutely has the skills to play that violin line, the fact that there's no credited violinist makes me think it's Geoff using a plugin.
@@PiscesintheRain Left side Geoff is wearing Layne's coat (looks like some padding beneath to give him a larger body shape), lighter haired Geoff tankard is wearing Layne's ringed chest cover and the 3rd Geoff is wearing the faux fur shoulder throw that Geoff had on in My Mother Told Me
Thank you for such a great reaction! Got excited to watch it when I saw you tweeted back at Geoff that you couldn't wait for it to drop! You never disappoint. That is truly your best VP/Geoff reaction to date!
This is spectacular! I heard it first time yesterday and was blown away! Now watching it second time with your reaction and I'm double blown away! Your reaction is HILARIOUS!!🤣😂 especially to that incredible last bass note!!🤣😂🤣 Love it man. Seriously the more I hear Geoff the more I love his voice- he's soooo cool 💙 & this song was made for him!
This song gave goosebumps to my goosebumps! And yeah, just left me speechless. Loved that you kept replaying that last note 🤣 - not only that low note, but also the harmonies that come in.
As a former bass player(we of course loveee low notes),i can only say..this is insane.This version and Tim & Peter's version is a two equal side of a gold medal(for me)..
You’re so funny Dave!!! Geoff is an amazing bass!!! I think there are no more dragons left!!! I didn’t notice at first that all 4 of them are Geoff in disguise!! Great reaction brother!!🙌🏻
I adore you! When I first heard this, my tears flowed. Touched right into my soul. I felt like you and I were experiencing the same deep connection to the ethereal. Much love for sharing your true self.
It *is* beautiful, isn't it. Always more detail in the video than I expect. Always better harmonies than I could ever imagine. Only an expert can make things look easy the way Mr. Castellucci does. :) You crack me up. Someday, you need to go visit a large pipe organ and stand next to the pipes when they play the low notes. It makes you vibrate inside.
the absolute sustain on the growl note too,,, I can hit growl notes for a decent while but the breath support and fullness of this is amazing (even if some of the magic is in post-proudction)!
Dave - it is such a pleasure to watch you enjoying Geoff's creativity. Your expressions actually make me smile, and that's quite an accomplishment. Don't ever change what you are doing here.
It's just great, I can sing nearly every note of this, until he hits those crazy subharmonics. Singing along to it and then he decides to do a bass-drop and I am like, "You a$$hole, I hate you, lol!"
I really love how he replays the same clip over and over as he has a few seizures from the incredibly low notes which also BLEW MY MIND SO MUCH!! Yet it was so funny to watch and I enjoyed this reaction a lot!! XD PS: I saw a YT Shorts of this reaction and I wanted to find this video so I spent over 2 hours searching and using ur thumbnails and the artists by using the comments of that short JUST to find this one reaction which I ended up loving and was definitely invested in!!
Orc's and dragons bewear. Both Peter Hollens and Tim Foust and Geoff Castellucci versions are by far my favourites of this song. 👍🍻 I wonder if the three of them will do this song together (hmmmm)
Geoff is a rare talent. His range is just sick. His G1 low notes are the bomb and he uses different techniques - chest, harmonic, growl etc. There are lots of great bass singers but Geoff is the king in my book.
Hahaha! I have watched your reaction to this several times when I want to get a good laugh! It makes me so happy! You are TOO funny! But yes, Geoff has that effect on people! 🤣
Glad to see someone else doing what I do... Your expressions are priceless... Thank you... The rumble of a bass crescendo done blew you away... Alaska Dave
You said rest in peace at the beginning and then you mercilessly slayed those dragons over, and over and over and over and over and over and over and (one more time) over and over and over.
Brother the fact that you couldnt do a "reaction" is the best reaction you could have given for this beautiful piece of work!! People us nerd out when art like this is created! Keep up the great work..
I don't know what it is, man.. voices like these evoke some primal emotion that I don't feel from anything else. I wouldn't be surprised if listening to this had healing properties.
That is beautiful and amazing, so wonderfully put together and sang too but Geoff's not one to disappoint us when it comes to music 🎶🎵 though 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯😯😯😯😯😯
@whatitdodave I know I miss this cover but I'm trying to keep up. I have misty mountain cold as a ring tone,but when I Hear Thissss!! Even the dragons bow down 😱😱😱😱
Ur reactions are crazy.. Everytime Geoff releases a new song i hope u make a reaction video.. It is so much fun to watch ^^ Keep going :D Love ur vids :)
Dave, you crack me up! You do the best reactions ever. Seriously though, this song gives me goosebumps. Like you said “it’s so beautiful!” Thanks for the brilliant reaction :)
Um, Dave, I can't help but feel that we all witnessed a very private moment there, between you and Geoff's voice. LOL!! Entertaining as always, man!
I think he may have uh had too much fun on that last low note
Agreed
Dave .. I had to rewatch it too lol 😢
😳🤣😅
@@lelaine61 david had a moment that we all needed to experience together 😆
When Geoff hits that Low note Dave acts like the Crocodile hunter finding a Wild animal
"There it is!"
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 yeah he does! It’s hilarious 😂
@@welchbrice8303 im in the back and even i can feel the great vibrations 🌸🌹👆😳👆🌸🌹👆😳👆🌸🌹👆😳👆🌹🌸👆😳👆
First I died from Geoff's gorgeous bass voice, and then I died watching Dave repeat the last note for 20 years. Excellent reaction and as soon as I watched Geoff's video I thought: Dave is gonna have a good time with this! 😆
i had the same reaction my first time hearing the song tho and now im subbed to geoff
6:25-7:02: Man, I didn't know that Geoff can hold a breathy G1 for 37 seconds... that's impressive...
Hahahaha this is awesome
Jesus Christ, this comment is hilarious. Very underrated.
He could hold onto that note harder than I could hold onto me seat from hearing him hit that note. Imma need a bean bag seat now, thanks. 🤗
Your reaction to that last note was the longest Bassgasm I‘ve ever seen, Jesus! 😂😂
But yeah, I can totally agree, Geoff‘s version of this song is phenomenal!
The great thing about Geoff Castellucci is he can hit "the shiver note" so effortlessly it just leaves you stunned. To anyone who isn't familiar with Geoff Castellucci the shiver note is a sub harmonic note that's so low it physically sends shivers up your spine.
Geoff does that to me just by looking at him! 😂
@@dawnburris6412 I'm a straight heterosexual male and I feel the same way. :) lol
@@mychaeldark1007 Facts! I love a man that can appreciate the beauty and sheer talent of another man! Kudos to you sir! 🥰
@@mychaeldark1007 The Great Harry Styles once said: We’re all a little bit gay, aren’t we? HAHAHAHAHAHHA. There’s no heterosexual or homosexual when we’re talking about Geoff Castellucci. There’s just him and what his voice does to people. No gender is safe.
I am SO happy to see someone feels the same way as me about this song. I just cant get enough of this video. It's a great reaction! Ive watched it 3 times already & im not done yet😊❤️!
If you haven't heard it at least 20 times by now you haven't done the song or yourself any justice. 😜🍻👍
There was absolutely no chance that Geoff doing this song was going to be anything less than phenomenal. I still like the version by Peter Hollins and Tim Faust as well. It's a song that basically demands a low bass singer to do regardless of what other singers you have joining in.
Doing the standard bass singing parts of this are easy for a normal bass singer... then you have Geoff doing his insanity, lol. Even a skilled baritone can cover most of this -- Geoff is actually hanging out in the lower baritone register for the majority of this (other than his tenor harmony lines)... then he decides to drop into contrabass.
I think this is the closest to speechless we've ever seen you. You speak so much with facial expressions though we get it. Rip to the dragons who were sacrificed for this masterpiece.
I couldn’t wait for this to drop it’s an absolute banger
Welcome to the group of us that have died listening to this. We have lost all words on how to describe this and why we feel so emotional with this. It truly hits your soul.
I have listened to this since it came out on Patreon and I STILL can't explain in words
There is only one word that can explain the feeling this song gives.
AGAIN
hahahahaha that comment lol
Y'all thing that he's one of the dwarves, but that ain't true. Geoff's true name is Smaug, confirmed now.
If I ever heard him do the "I am Fire. I AM DEATH." bit, I would lose my tiny mind.
@@PiscesintheRain I KNEW he wasn't human!
😂😂😂😂😂 King Smaug
@@welchbrice8303 HAIL!
I’ve been waiting for someone to react to this all day, I know it just came out but I just wanted to see someone else love it as much as I did and it was a blast watching your reaction, thank you!
Dave! So glad you got to this one so fast, I heard it earlier today when it premiered. Brace for the dragon.
Edit: the Dragon slew Dave.
I would love to hear Geoff, Tim, Avi and Peter do this song together! That would be awesome 💥🎉🎊
Thing about Geoff is he doesn't need anyone else.
Geoff, Tim and Peter together would test the foundations of reality, adding Avi to the mix is truely testing fate 😜👍🍻
@@draygontaygen677 IKR it would be so awesome!!
@@annewandering 100 💯% but they would sound super awesome
This would go into Smaug territory (with a hint of Bilbo) I'm afraid.
The harmony on the first "we must away" was AWESOME. And your reaction was AMAZING❗️❗️❗️But you're going to OD on those basement notes.
See, we never knew he had three big brothers, did we? And all as good at the deep stuff. :) It's awesome. And that's not a word I use lightly. Not sure whether you liked that or not LOL
The second or third time I heard this I couldn't get Dave's stank face out of my head. I just knew this one was going to slay you: while the bass notes are great the harmonies are gorgeous.
Geoff does this song justice
Yes! And as far as I'm concerned he's the only singer who truly does do it justice. There are other good versions of this, but Geoff's is, quite simply, the way this song was always meant to sound. Nobody else has hit that level.
I love your reactions. Once I've listened to a voice play or Geoff song, I can not wait for your reaction video. You give so much emotion
5:58 - Welp, Dave's dead. Rest In Peace with that beautiful sound forever my friend.
Bruuuh 😭🤣
They killed my boi 😂😂
*I still laugh at this reaction!!!🤣I truly believe that Geoff's low notes can either cause you to go into cardiac arrest, or bring you out of it!! One or the other!!😂*
Happy that you was the first on this.
Yey, you melted just like we did here, me and my sister. So awsome.
Hope you catched your breath again. 🤩❤
Loved the reaction Dave. Was definitely anticipating this reaction. You did not disappoint. Hope everything is going well with you!
Geoff has the best deep, rumbling voice for a dwarven song.
So glad you got your reaction up so fast, I’ve been looking forward to it!
This cover is so beautiful!!! I love the strings! Condolences to the dragons 😁
Quite beyond the vocals, the costumes, the hair, and facial hair were spectacular! And of course the vocals were (as usual) spectacular). And your reaction was priceless.
now don't quote me on this but i think he liked the last note XD
Dave, I am a pretty reserved guy.... you got me laughing hysterically with your reaction to that last note - if you knew me you'd know what an accomplishment that is! xD
This guy who singing should be a beatboxer. What a deep bass maan. So full. I really like it.
Slow down, Dave. You're going to have a heart attack. Love your reaction 💘
The note so deep his glasses flew off🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I could tell you had the time of your life in this one, Dave! You never dissapoint!☺
And Dave, you have a rich deep voice too, you should sing something!🙂
Are we not gonna talk about 2:34? How he just casually breaks out an overtone with a slight subharmonic? No? Ok.
Dave, it looks like Geoff is ripping the emotion straight out of your soul man. This was a powerful one
What a great rendition! His voice is so perfect for this and the arrangement and his harmonies with himself with the instruments adding just a touch of the ancient Gaelic atmosphere.
PS: Note Geoff retasked the costumes from My Mother Told Me. Look closely and figure which Geoff is wearing other VoicePlay's outfits.
PPS - Who else thinks that it's Layne Stein on that violin?
That top with the rings sews on was very distinctive - the first time I saw this, before he started singing (and I couldn't think of anything but "oh good heavens!"), I definitely noticed that one.
I was thinking that it was Layne on violin too. The costumes are awesome on him 💜🥰
@@welchbrice8303 While Layne absolutely has the skills to play that violin line, the fact that there's no credited violinist makes me think it's Geoff using a plugin.
@@PiscesintheRain A possibility as I also noted the lack of credits.
@@PiscesintheRain Left side Geoff is wearing Layne's coat (looks like some padding beneath to give him a larger body shape), lighter haired Geoff tankard is wearing Layne's ringed chest cover and the 3rd Geoff is wearing the faux fur shoulder throw that Geoff had on in My Mother Told Me
Thank you for such a great reaction! Got excited to watch it when I saw you tweeted back at Geoff that you couldn't wait for it to drop! You never disappoint. That is truly your best VP/Geoff reaction to date!
This totally new to me, I LOVE THIS ! Thanks for the introduction Dave
This is spectacular! I heard it first time yesterday and was blown away! Now watching it second time with your reaction and I'm double blown away! Your reaction is HILARIOUS!!🤣😂 especially to that incredible last bass note!!🤣😂🤣 Love it man.
Seriously the more I hear Geoff the more I love his voice- he's soooo cool 💙 & this song was made for him!
Dave’s reaction to Geoff’s voice reminds me of that scene in “Monster’s Inc.” where Sully watches the trash compactor lol
Loved your reacting to that last note lol. I was the same way! Hard to believe that was a chest note too!
Daaayumm Geoff done blown Dave’s glasses off...
love your reactions
*I love how you kept revisiting his low note at the end, which put you in a near-coma, then brought you back!*
Thanks brother for that reaction. I too can hit those notes and it's nice to see someone who appreciates the lows as well as the highs.
THE VIBRATIONS FROM THAT LAST NOTE!
This song gave goosebumps to my goosebumps! And yeah, just left me speechless. Loved that you kept replaying that last note 🤣 - not only that low note, but also the harmonies that come in.
This was a spiritual experience. Glad to see someone else reacting the way I did.
As a former bass player(we of course loveee low notes),i can only say..this is insane.This version and Tim & Peter's version is a two equal side of a gold medal(for me)..
You gotta be the first reactor to do this. This dropped 16 hours ago. Loved it.
I'll give a like to substitute for that one dislike. But my man repeated that last note...we all needed that😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You’re so funny Dave!!! Geoff is an amazing bass!!! I think there are no more dragons left!!! I didn’t notice at first that all 4 of them are Geoff in disguise!! Great reaction brother!!🙌🏻
Homeboy dug so deep into his vocal chords that he unwittingly released the Balrog.
I adore you! When I first heard this, my tears flowed. Touched right into my soul. I felt like you and I were experiencing the same deep connection to the ethereal. Much love for sharing your true self.
Yeah that last notes always gonna get you, great cover and you can tell it gets to you.
His Gravest Note tears us all to pieces ... it's great
It *is* beautiful, isn't it. Always more detail in the video than I expect. Always better harmonies than I could ever imagine. Only an expert can make things look easy the way Mr. Castellucci does. :) You crack me up. Someday, you need to go visit a large pipe organ and stand next to the pipes when they play the low notes. It makes you vibrate inside.
I love it. I just love Geoff's performances. Your reactions are just the best.!!
Dave, your face when the "Dragon notes" hit is peerless! Thanks for doing this one. Go Geoff!
the absolute sustain on the growl note too,,, I can hit growl notes for a decent while but the breath support and fullness of this is amazing (even if some of the magic is in post-proudction)!
I think Dave got slayed instead by this one 😅seriously though man your reactions are priceless. Love your work 👍
it is the best version off FAR OVER THE MISTY MOUNTAINS were made
Can I also add, this is the first version I’ve heard-including the original-where I can understand all the words!
It’s deep and clear!
@@whatitdodave Clear as a mountain stream!
Geoff hits that last low note, Dave looks like he needs a cigarette! XD
Dave - it is such a pleasure to watch you enjoying Geoff's creativity. Your expressions actually make me smile, and that's quite an accomplishment. Don't ever change what you are doing here.
I appreciate you, Dave. You the man. Your voice play, Geoff, and Dan Vasc reactions are the best!
I love the reaction of such a good singer and such a good song
I absolutely love these reactions. The face gets me everytime man😂
It's just great, I can sing nearly every note of this, until he hits those crazy subharmonics. Singing along to it and then he decides to do a bass-drop and I am like, "You a$$hole, I hate you, lol!"
I love watching you react to Geoff. It's just so wholesome.
The Dragon kill someone in the depths of mountains with his chest note LMAOOOO I've watched 7 times your reaction lolllll
It's like he had an eargasm off the last part lol I can't 😆 😂 🤣
This dude looking like he crying and having a heart attack at the same time. GEOFF YOU BRINGING A GROWN MAN TO TEARS
I really love how he replays the same clip over and over as he has a few seizures from the incredibly low notes which also BLEW MY MIND SO MUCH!! Yet it was so funny to watch and I enjoyed this reaction a lot!! XD
PS: I saw a YT Shorts of this reaction and I wanted to find this video so I spent over 2 hours searching and using ur thumbnails and the artists by using the comments of that short JUST to find this one reaction which I ended up loving and was definitely invested in!!
Orc's and dragons bewear.
Both Peter Hollens and Tim Foust and Geoff Castellucci versions are by far my favourites of this song. 👍🍻
I wonder if the three of them will do this song together (hmmmm)
Geoff is a rare talent. His range is just sick. His G1 low notes are the bomb and he uses different techniques - chest, harmonic, growl etc. There are lots of great bass singers but Geoff is the king in my book.
Hahaha! I have watched your reaction to this several times when I want to get a good laugh! It makes me so happy! You are TOO funny! But yes, Geoff has that effect on people! 🤣
Glad to see you've got your channel back!! I'm celebrating that with another binge of your videos cause they always put me in a good mood 😁
Dave, Dave, Dave nobody, but NOBODY, does the full body reaction like you do my friend.....
Everyone's talking about Goeff and stuff, but was that a subharmonic from you at 2:43, Dave? Because that sounded exactly like a subharmonic.
Geoff hits last note: Dave.exe has stopped. Great reaction!!
I just love watching this guys reactions! He is a hoot!!
I love this guy. 😂
Glad to see someone else doing what I do...
Your expressions are priceless...
Thank you...
The rumble of a bass crescendo done blew you away...
Alaska Dave
You said rest in peace at the beginning and then you mercilessly slayed those dragons over, and over and over and over and over and over and over and (one more time) over and over and over.
Love the reaction, bassgasm! The best reaction so far 😅😅😅
Brother the fact that you couldnt do a "reaction" is the best reaction you could have given for this beautiful piece of work!! People us nerd out when art like this is created! Keep up the great work..
LOL, OMFG... love the repeat at the end... you're 'dead' in your chair after Geoff slayed you.....
I don't know what it is, man.. voices like these evoke some primal emotion that I don't feel from anything else. I wouldn't be surprised if listening to this had healing properties.
That man is a beast.i love geoff.he did that song justice.much love Geoff,keep up the great work.
Goeff on the far left looks very Thorin like! Great costuming... amazing song.
Every time he hit that low note, you look like you were getting tazed and weren’t sure if you liked it or not.🤣🤣🤣
That is beautiful and amazing, so wonderfully put together and sang too but Geoff's not one to disappoint us when it comes to music 🎶🎵 though 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯😯😯😯😯😯
Loved you reaction on this video truly made fantastic to watch. Take it easy Dave and keep up the good work 😊.
This cracked me up 😜 I am glad I am not the only one getting slain by Geoff's voice! This song had me in tears!
@whatitdodave I know I miss this cover but I'm trying to keep up. I have misty mountain cold as a ring tone,but when I Hear Thissss!! Even the dragons bow down 😱😱😱😱
With the last word so low. My mans just trembled the gates of hell.
Ur reactions are crazy.. Everytime Geoff releases a new song i hope u make a reaction video.. It is so much fun to watch ^^
Keep going :D
Love ur vids :)
Dave, you crack me up! You do the best reactions ever. Seriously though, this song gives me goosebumps. Like you said “it’s so beautiful!” Thanks for the brilliant reaction :)
My new favorite reaction video and DAVE--- it was because of you. Thanks!
The stank face was totally on point! Love your reaction, love this version! I agree, new peak with this one brother!
Great reaction as always!