ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Should The Hijab Be Enforced? | Ask Shaykh YQ - EP 267 | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2022
- Questions? Email Shaykh Dr. Yasir at: askyq@epicmasjid.org
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
► Credits:
Note: No musical instruments were used in this video, all background noise is human acapella.
Outro Nasheed
Artist: Ibraheem Bakeer
Produced by: MAQAMAT INSTITUTION
Copyright reserved and reproduced exclusively with permission for Yasir Qadhi's Official TH-cam Channel.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official TH-cam Channel
![เหนื่อยหน่อยนะ (SOMEONE LIKE ME) - GEMINI Prod. by URBOYTJ [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M55XjfhbrNw/mqdefault.jpg)
This is why it is so important for our religious scholars to have high level of secular understanding to connect the dots and draw the bigger picture, like it was done here.
You make me smile. Have not come across a better explanation throughout my life. Making duah to have more scholars like our sheikh in coming generation. Jazak Allah khair
Amern ameen ameen
I can't keep up the awesomeness of how quickly Shaikh YQ is churning out such high quality vids! Alhumdulillah!
Jazakallah sheykh even this is a sensitive topic you Give us a good explanation and it's also eye opening, may Allah reward you and protect you sheykh ameen.
th-cam.com/video/DsPlsFkPGYc/w-d-xo.html
Summa ameen
May Allah preserve Shaikh Yasir Qadhi among us for the longest time. His wisdom and knowledge is much needed for us in this dark and confusing times.
I am mind blown how wonderfully you have handled this sensitive topic. may Allah bless you for sharing this and increase you in your knowledge that benefits you.
What a beautiful way to talk about this timely topic. Mashaallah, Yasir Qadhi! And thank you
th-cam.com/video/DsPlsFkPGYc/w-d-xo.html
What an incredible reflection mashallah tabarakallah. Allah bless you sheikh
My favorite schooler Allah bless you and protect you
Please make time and continue the Stories of the Prophets series. Anxiously waiting for new episodes.
Yes me as well brother, I've been assuming that there would be no more stories of the Prophets by brother Yasir Qadhi. Hopefully inshAllah it will be back soon.
Sounds like he's going back to the regularly scheduled programming ☺
+1 but everyone should understand that it's a series that takes a lot of time to make.
waiting for prophet idris 'Alayhissalam
the legend ... barakallahu fik Shaykh Dr Yasir
th-cam.com/video/DsPlsFkPGYc/w-d-xo.html
It's unfortunate that so many groups who claim to be "establishing the sharia" focus so much on enforcing rules and punishment before laying the foundations of a working society. Like the saying goes, Rome wasn't built in a day, and neither was the entire sharia revealed all at once. These things take time.
After a long time, Q & A is back...
Jazakallah khair for such an enlightening and eye opening lecture. It has changed my viewpoint over this issue completely. All respect and love for you shaikh for sake of Allah. May Allah protect and bless you ameen sum ameen.
So, what I heard in the long winded answer was 2 things:
1. Western interests in highlighting this situation for geopolitical reasons and not from any concern for the citizens or women of that region.
2. Given the opportunity, he would also enforce hijab not as the first priority but eventually somewhere on his path from 0-100!!!! At least he is honest.
However, the question still remains, does Islam allow rulers to enforce personal worship? (not public decency standards). The answer would also apply to other questions of Fasting (not publicly consuming food in Ramadan) or Praying 5 times a day in the mosque.
When mullahs start assuming they have some kind of god given right to enforce standards of worship, they distort Islam and start enforcing a religion of their understanding.
The Prophet (pbuh) took a wide array of factors into consideration when asked for advice by the companions and others in his midst. Islam prioritizes and gives weight to certain principles, values and commandments over others. I believe YQ has studied the life of the Prophet (pbuh) and the Quran to the extent that he incorporates this beautiful sunnah of our beloved Prophet into his religious opinion. I really appreciate him for that. And it's not just on TH-cam, he was the imam at the mosque I attend in Memphis and his consideration was evident in the way he interacted with the community. Salaam.
MashaAllah Tabarakallah Shaikh. As usual I enjoyed your lecture esp when you don't care about USA political war in 3 countries. We need more speakers like you about the suffering of our ummah from American foreign policy
Priorities indeed; we have to build emaan first!! ..hypocrisy in media is obvious.-and the whole discussion is not about human rights, it suits their own narrative, it supports an illegitimate cause....Great analysis ..Alhamdulillah the current generation, sister Maha and alikes, have a huge advantage with the available extensive elaborations . InshaAllah the worth of such efforts will be reckoned. May Allah reward you and give you the strength to continue with the bright insights you are providing!
May Allah bless you Shaikh and increase in knowledge.
If they care so much, they should grant all of the people who don't want to wear hijab, refuge in their countries.
...More than the hijab!
Timely topic explained brilliantly!
Educational, extensive and informative...one to keep as a point of reference!
Forever wearing my burka
May Allah bless you
th-cam.com/video/DsPlsFkPGYc/w-d-xo.html
I am envious of your strength, may Allah protect and preserve you. Ameen ❤
@@Chawaonga
Allah swt who we rely on, knowing that I will be Him whatever happens, bad or good, makes everything worth while...keep the eye on the Prize
Jazak Allah Khair Sheikh Saheb. Really shocked to the core, after your explicit explanation. Nothing is simple anymore.
Allah Tallah, guide and save us.
Alhamdulillah. Excellent lecture. Knowledge with great wisdom to put it in a dynamic way. Love & salam from Bangladesh.
Thank you so much sheikh for this amazing explanation. May Allah continue to bless you.
This was very extensive and at the same time succint mashAllah.
Words of wisdom from our Sheikh - Mashaa Allah.
jazakallah khair
Wear your burka my dear sisters. Lower your gaze my dear brothers.
Maa Sha Allah,,,this lecture is a masterpiece 👌 May Allah protect and increase ur wisdom...Aameen
JazakAllah for guiding our thoughts and helping to judge the situation more objectively.
This is way beyond awesome!! We need this kind of education among Muslims.
"It is not our job to have an opnion about something happening 5000 miles away"
Does that also hold true for the occupation of Palestine?
I agree. Keep that same energy. It makes me sad that many in the Islamic community selectively support causes. I support the Palestinian cause as well, but that is also 5,000 miles away, and my voice and sentiments will not make an immediate difference so are you saying I should stop? The Iranian people want freedom to live and practice religion on their own terms. What happened to there is no compulsion in religion? Is he saying it’s OK to beat people to death for being out of dress code? I need help to understand this justification of murder in “Islamic” regime…Islam…which also says that killing one person is like killing all of humanity. I can’t believe it….
Oh Sheikh sleeping pijamas are so super comfortable with those bunny soft carpet slippers I'd actually wear them to work 😂😂. Side effects of work from home because of the pandemic 😂.
This is so true. So much wisdom in this
Jazak Allah khair. Beautifully explained
Brilliant talk..well explained. Most islamic regimes failed to cater for diverse cultural inhabitants leading to rebellion in the name of religion. We shall never attain the status we lost but divert further..away from din...
Protect women first
I really dont understand why some of the great Ulamas say Ustad Yasir Qadi a controversial lecturer. I think they dont really understand the context of his lectures or maybe they are suffering from the poison of secterianism.
So let me get this straight: the issue of hijab in an Islamic government (as Iran is) has nothing to do with our religion (Islam)? That is rich. Mental gymnastics. Whatever works for you, shaykh!
maa sha Allah bless you Shiekh
JazakAllah khairan
So true pray Allah bless you and your family
AlhmduliLLAH for such a good explanation. JazakaLLAH khair
Jazakum Allahu Khairan. Very needed, comprehensive and beneficial
Allahamdulilah that there are some real inheritor and representative of Rasullullah PBUH such as you that are able to represent his religion according to the needs of people in the 21st century.
Expected this topic and Thank you
I was gone from the US for all of the pandemic and came back after three years. I was so shocked with the amount of women that basically walk around in bras now.
Steven bro are u muslim?
Nicely answered with a lot of clarification.
Allah ❤
Jazakallah khair Sheikh
jazakaAllah khayran Shaykna
Thank you brother for your help
Assalamu Alykum WRWB from Nottingham Uk
Jazakallah khairaan for Q&A
I don't know why sheikh doesn't want to be head of an Islamic land... I feel we need to have people like him to be heads of our lands.
I’m bit confused by the statement of our respected Shaykh, when he says that if he was in charge, the maqasid of the shariah comes first, meaning safety and security, and with a process of incremental changes and tarbiyah then you will reach a stage to legislate morality and religiosity.
However he then brings the example of a country in the Middle East, that spent generations preaching tawheed, and proper tarbiyah, but has changed trajectory in a diametrically opposite direction and the Awam have embraced the Fahisha, doesn’t this just prove the point that we are fighting a loosing battle against western hegemony and their influence? And the only way to push back is to legislate morality and religiosity.
MashaAllah, very well said !
love this Q&A section
Do we appreciate the blessings in our life?
Do we understand the creator that gave us all our blessings (such as our 5 senses)?
Isn’t Allah the most merciful?
Isn’t He generous?
Isn’t He the greatest?
Haven’t you thought about these thing?
Haven’t you felt love for Allah?
And would you love Allah to love you back?
Here’s a Hadith where Allah says he loves his slave who perform obligatory acts!
Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "Allah, the Exalted, has said: 'I will declare war against him who treats with hostility a pious worshipper of Mine. And the most beloved thing with which My slave comes nearer to Me, is what I have enjoined upon him; and My slave keeps on coming closer to Me through performing Nawafil (voluntary prayers or doing extra deeds besides what is obligatory) until I love him, (so much so that) I become his hearing with which he hears, and his sight with which he sees, and his hand with which he strikes, and his leg with which he walks; and if he asks Me something, I will surely give him, and if he seeks My Protection (refuge), I will surely protect him".
[Al-Bukhari]
THE HIJAB IS AN OBLIGATORY ACT!
If you truly love Allah then obey Him and He will love you back. Do optional good deeds (Nawafil) and Allah will have a close relationship with you!
Isn’t HE sufficient enough!?
Stop pleasing the people, and start pleasing the one who created you!
clarity
Brilliant answer and one to keep as a point of reference
Another point is that tarbiyah goes out the window if you have unfiltered satellite and internet. It would be like teaching to eat healthy but only providing fast food!
Really appreciate the lecture, especially in the milieu that it's been delivered.
One thing that I feel should have been elaborated a little more is the no of people (including women) killed & economy destroyed in Iran/Iraq/Afgh due to the sanctions/policies of the terrorist state of America.
Or mismanagement of the country by its leaders.
What would you do to de-secularise the minds of muslims who are otherwise perceived by others and themselves as devout Muslims. That is they fast and pray, but decry the very idea of a (Muslim) authority enforcing Islam. This includes many shaykhs and shaykhas.
Very well said.
Assalaamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatuh
I am İranian myself converted to Islam over 10 years ago. Thank you for the lecture but I dont agree on what you Said about the problems Not being against Islam and Hijab but being against the Regime only. I dont think thats true at all. Maybe you Dont know many iranians but My folk is extremely anti islamic
They hate Islam so actually all the Protests are against Islam and mostly "Hijab"
Iranians See Islam as opression
They want to be "free"
And freedom in their opinion is doing everthing they like
And they like being naked and partying and zina and all the evil stuff
I know all this from My own Family
Some of Them wont even Talk to me anymore because of My Islam subhanallah
@26:04
you are future shaykh yusuf qardawi
Someone put this man in charge already. His hate towards holding leadership is the best sign that he is the most fit for the position.
Ameen
It seems you are suggesting that’s Muslims have no responsibility to to other Muslims and have no responsibility in the world. We can just sit in our own little corner and not worry about other Muslims
Is that why I have not heard any out cry about the Saudis limiting Hajj
Appreciate all the extra info but YQ seemed extremely hesitant to actually answer the question in the title clearly
Listen from 28:00 again.
He handled it there.
Yes it should be in the law, but not something that would lead to persecution (killing, torture, and all that)
@@abdullahiidris937 so Qadhi also supports France forcing wonen to take the hijab off?
Yasir is a hypocrite for saying governments should force hijab.
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi sahab says that the ayat of Surah At Tauba about mushrakeen e makka that if they accept Islam, perform salah and give zakah, then leave their way, this ayah proves that in a islamic state the government can only enforce these 3 things on muslims, Iman, Salah and Zakah. And after this, everything, like hijaab and other things will be addressed via tableegh and talkeen. What is your opinion Dr Qadhi?
The irony is that the royalty dress the most conservative. Yet, the colonized lands are heading towards nudity. 🤨🤨
Great lecture. I disagree with one aspect, where you pointed out at ulemas way of preaching is not correct as people are welcoming modern changes opposed to religion. We can find this in the time of prophets. Just after the death of Prophet, his followers believed in false prophets, denied giving zakah, and just after crossing the red sea miraculously followers of musa worshipped cow idol. That doesnt prophet muhammed, prophet musa methodology of preaching is wrong, thats how people are, their desires take over spirituality except few.
May Allah guides to that which He loves.
I really enjoyed listening to this may Allah reward you for your good deeds & forgive your sins same as all Muslims ameen
Just 1 question if I'm understanding correctly you mentioned how the sharia shouldn't have harsh punishments for people not following it then what do we do with the references in the quran & sunnah that talk about this e.g. chopping your hands off if you steal?
We know that no society would in future or (had in the past, not even the sahabas society, coz they also had sinners and munafiqoons ) ever reached the hundred percent with it's full strength. There would always be number of people who either don't want to move beyond 5 or 10 level, or who are disbelievers. What would you do as a ruler of such a society? Keep waiting till eternity to have a full strength (or majority) reach to the 100 level?
or
implement the Sharia despite vehement & violent opposition from those people of that territory and the meddling of external forces (such as the terrorist state of America today).
It's appalling the lack of compassion so much of our Ummah has about a woman being tortured and killed over something so menial.
This Ummah is truly lost and embarrassing.
Killing an innocent soul is one of the most detestable things mentioned by Allah swt and yet so many of you will let that pass over the most minor offense committed by this young lady. Huge shame on such ugly-hearted people. Our religion was meant as a mercy for mankind, not whatever so many of you have turned it into.
glad u realize
Who is justifying what happend to her and letting it pass?
FIRST COMMENT..
The bigger issue is should a women be murdered for not wearing it or not wearing it properly? Beaten for it? Abused for it?
This is not Islam..
Exactly. They love to cry when another country does something to Muslims yet when our own Ummah does appalling things the topic is always diverted.
30:00
One thing that people always miss is that all these "freedoms" with the bikini etc comes with the caveat that the woman must have a totally bald body, can't show a SINGLE grey hair on their head and can't have moustaches or facial hair. That in no way shape or form sounds like any sort of freedom. Especially considering the labour, expense and pain one has to go through to fit this standard.
There is no "total freedom"
You cannot just allow a forbidden for "we living in western nation" as prophet clearly told whatever forbidden stay away 100%, there wouldn't be an excuse for doing it and living a luxury life in western kufr nation while you have opportunity to migrate a better place to any muslim country where you can stay away from those acts..
Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said, “What I have forbidden you, stay away from. What I have ordered you [to do], do as much of it as you can. Verily, the people before you were destroyed only because of their excessive questioning and their disagreeing with their Prophets.” [Recorded by al-Bukhari and Muslim.]
Summary of the Hadith
If something is prohibited, one must stay away from it completely. The only exception to that is the true cases of necessity. Due to necessity, an act may no longer be considered prohibited.
If something is ordered, one must perform it to the best of his ability. It is not possible to completely and excellently perform everything that one is ordered to do. Hence, the Prophet (peace be upon him) has stated the cases of prohibition and order in different tones.
Asking too many questions, beyond what is needed and not with the real intent of application, is blameworthy. It was one of the reasons that prior peoples were destroyed.
Similarly, differing with any prophet is completely blameworthy. Instead of accepting and submitting, prior peoples showed some form of opposition to what their prophets requested of them. This was the second major cause for their destruction.
booksofmuslims.wordpress.com/40-hadiths/hadith-9/
the muslim countries like Saudi and the middle east have to make it easy for people to migrate fitst
th-cam.com/video/DsPlsFkPGYc/w-d-xo.html
You need to learn more about the religion, brother. There are ahadith that state that migration is not compulsory after the original hijrah as long as you are free to practice your religion without persecution. These are authentic. If you are in the extreme cult I'd advise you to distance from it and learn properly. Salam.
Allahu akbar
Thank you sheikh, very based
13:00
Finally a Q/A. Jazakallah Shaikh
Dr Qadhi, you say we can’t go from 0-100 right away and must focus on the first steps. That’s why you didn’t answer the question of what the ideal Muslim state/society in today’s context would be. But how can we take any step if we don’t know what and where 100 is? How can we take any step without knowing what the ultimate goal is? How can we shoot without aiming?
The goal is Allah.
@@deedeee6271 The goal is to worship Allah. And one of the ways to worship is to do the wajib. Which establishing and striving for Muslim independence and an Islamic state is one of.
Dr.yasir sahab give a speech about syed adnan
sir is email copy writting Haram?
Can someone please summarize all 9 points?
Still, we did not get the answer to the question, "In an ideal Islamic government, can the Hijab still be enforced?" Many scholars have opined that even in an ideal state, the Hijab cannot be enforced and it is upto the individual. However, a minimum dress code can be enforced but not the headcovering. That is the question our Sheikh seems to have avoided. Nevertheless, this does not apply to other matters such as alcohol, drugs, abortion, homosexuality, fornication, adultery, pornography, marijuana and other matters which may seemingly only involve the self. In an ideal Islamic government, these matters will be enforced but still not the Hijab. The important distinction or point to make is that not all spiritual mandates were intended to be made legal mandates even in an ideal Islamic government. That point is a very important one to make. You cannot force your way into someone's house or legally enforce someone to pray or fast or harass them for not doing so even in an ideal Islamic government. The value of understanding this compass as to where we may be headed (usually practically only an utopia) is still relevant. Sheikh has avoided his usual style of going into various scholarly opinions as to whether the Hijab can be enforced in an ideal Islamic government and what Islamic theory says on the matter. I wish that could have been the 10th point.
Did you watch the video? He did not avoid it at all.
@@DeitritusFillamore At which part did the Sheikh address the part regarding whether the Hijab can be legally enforced in an ideal Islamic Government and the various scholarly opinions regarding it? Can you please point it? And if that is there, I can remove this comment or post a more relevant response.
@@yasirahmed9975 he said it was part of our sharia and that Muslim lands should strive for it. However he made the caveat that the people need to be made to have iman in their hearts first. I mean come on he was as blunt as possible
@@DeitritusFillamore Salaam bro, that is exactly the vagueness I am referring to. Praying 5 times is part of the Shariah. Doing ghusl after sexual activity is part of the Shariah. Fasting is part of the Shariah. And yes, we should strive for them in an Islamic land. Now the question is the scope of Shariah and 'striving' in political/legal life. You cannot punish someone from not praying 5 times a day nor can you enforce legally someone to do ghusl. The real question is whether and what spiritual mandates were intended to be legal mandates in an ideal Islamic government. We can all strive to spread the Hijab culture, but if ultimately people do not choose to wear, what is the legal consequence for it? Is there a hudud or tazir punishment? If yes, what is the basis for that conclusion? Do all Islamic scholars agree on the legal consequences of not wearing the Hijab. Did the Prophet (pbuh) explicitly intend it to be applied legally, meaning that there were going to be legal consequences for not wearing them or was it an emphasized recommendation. There is no doubt that it is spiritually mandatory, but the question is whether the state can impose it on an individual even in ideal circumstances. That is the answer that Sheikh has not gone into which is actually the crux of the debate.
th-cam.com/video/DsPlsFkPGYc/w-d-xo.html
Who is reciting Quran in the start
Can someone give a summary
‘Prioritise your own life not something 5,000 miles away’
Great advice. Does it also hold true for useless Palestinian activism in the West amongst some Muslims? Or only to stop people discussing difficult issues of self reflection eg governments forcing hijab?
Good angle, but You should quote the entire thing.
"If whatever you do wouldn't amount to anything..." Remember?
If the activism has no effect, then yes it applies.
I agree. Keep that same energy. It makes me sad that many in the Islamic community selectively support causes. I support the Palestinian cause as well, but that is also 5,000 miles away, and my voice and sentiments will not make an immediate difference so are you saying I should stop? The Iranian people want freedom to live and practice religion on their own terms. What happened to there is no compulsion in religion? Is he saying it’s OK to beat people to death for being out of dress code? I need help to understand this justification of murder in “Islamic” regime…Islam…which also says that killing one person is like killing all of humanity. I can’t believe it….
@@melaniemendez3960 Who says that it's ok to beat people to death for not following the dress code? 28:47
You make it seem like a small matter to enforce hijab, but this is a huge issue for women. Even as I happily wear hijab, I do so knowing I did so myself, I feel empowered that it's my choice. How can a Muslim nation enforce that which is between her and God? Do they enforce men's sports uniforms? Or beards? Or no because there are opinions that men's awrah is literally only their genitals and beards are only optional? Well then you see the problem - that women are restricted and policed for SO much. And what if the government says that hijab consists of chador and niqab and that she shouldn't be seen or heard and should stay home in the kitchen? Ridiculous rules I'm glad we don't have such a system. I disagree that Muslim nations should enforce hijab unless 100% of the Muslim women are happy by themselves to wear it...
The same argument can be applied for drugs , alcohol , pornography , in many Muslim nations during Ramadan eating in public (for both Muslims and non muslims) is prohibited.......... Even these things are just between you and Allah, what are you gonna say about this?
I understand you can't force someone to do something but again in between the hijab issue you have to consider them as well
Following Deen is itself between you and Allah, so what do you say about this ?
Read surah Araf and one can know the hidden agenda of puppets of iblees jumping on bandwagon with all these protests.
Then Satan tempted them in order to expose what was hidden of their nakedness. [7:20]
O children of Adam! We have provided for you clothing to cover your nakedness and as an adornment. However, the best clothing is righteousness. This is one of Allah’s bounties, so perhaps you will be mindful. [7:26]
😥Afghanistan
I hope the Taliban is listening carefully. It's time to learn from political history. Be tactful in your approach and stop being harsh.