DID IT SUCK? - Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2024
- If you see any of your artwork or would like an acknowledgement made, please let me know in the comments section below!
Thanks for watching, would you kindly leave a like? Don't forget to Subscribe!
+ Support me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/harrysmovingc...
+ Like me on Facebook: / harrysmovingcastle
+ Follow Me On Twitter: / hmc_tweets
+ Follow Me On Instagram: / hmc_instant - บันเทิง
![DID IT SUCK? - Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix [PART 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q0jix6sS0x0/mqdefault.jpg)
![DID IT SUCK? - Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix [PART 1]](/img/tr.png)
![DID IT SUCK? - Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince [PART 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8gOaWst-xj4/mqdefault.jpg)
Let's not forget the most laughable scene in the entire movie:
Book: "Harry, did you put your name in the Goblet of Fire?" Dumbledore asked calmly.
Movie: "HARRY, DID YOU PUTCHUR NAME IN THE GARBLAFAR!?"
did not want to capitalize guy. wlack with you.
*tackles Harry and shoves him up against the wall XD
garblafar
TallManVanitas and when that death eater in the penseive says, Barty Crouch junior.
TallManVanitas yeah I. Couldn't imagine dumbledoor losing his cool and freaking out and getting angry especially at harry.
I wonder, could Harry report a ghost for sexual harassment?
Don’t you mean....”spectral” harassment?
Kill me.
@@Double-R-Nothing Alan Rickman from Die hard: Ok. 🔫. (Jk)
😂
Reverse necrophilia?
A real teen would have said yes
@@Double-R-Nothing Later.
Harry Potter and The Year Nobody got A Haircut :P
I cant say for everyone but there was a year in my high school were we all just became beetle lookalikes, maybe its a British thing
I remember for like a year and a half that was just the style young teens had, I had hair like that as well when the movie came out
@@TheReconRacoon yea I can relate
I think Cedrics dad's reaction is great. What appears to be his only lasting family is dead and he shows it well
I couldn't keep a straight face when Dumbledore got out the floating Karaoke Parchment out!
lol yea
Actually the Hogwarts song was originally in the first book. Dumbledore had the students sing it at the start of Harry's first year at Hogwarts.
I was your 100th like
@@NileSWPhotography thank you
@@slandersir7255 ❤️
until the reveal i assumed moody was a drunk
Tom Williams Productions He seems like a meth addict
"Mad eye moody never acts like barty crouch apart from the tongue thing"
Ten seconds later:
"Mad eye moody enjoying using unforgivable curses and being an asshole to students doesn't fit his character"
In the first film with the snake. we are hearing what Harry hears..hence why he wasnt aware he speaks another lanuage in the second film.but from that point on we hear what everyone else hears
I have to agree with you. Before I read all seven books my senior year of high school, Goblet Of Fire was probably my favorite HP film. That changed drastically after I read the book and noticed how clunky the film really was and exactly how much depth and plot it left out. Kinda weird to say, but I honestly thought the second film was the best, though I'm sure I'm the one percent on that. I did appreciate your input though and watching your book vs film videos on this one as well. Good job.
TallManVanitas same my fave film is 2nd n fave books r 4 and 6
I loved the 2nd when I was a kid but the 3rd one is the best film for me. It is directed, performed, shot, and adapted so well that it is one of the best fantasy films of all time, among my top ten.
I just dont understand how the books should have any value on the quality of the movie...
@@Lasmelan Honestly, watching the movies now is difficult compared to when I was a child. The acting is so bad, just low quality in general that makes me wonder why the movies where ever seen in a positive way...
Cedric has to save Cho, the girl he loves. Krum has to save Hermione, the girl he loves.
Harry has to save Ron. lol.
In the books Myrtle does imply she peaked at both Harry and Cedric through the plughole in the bath.
Agreed. I actually think the movie version of Myrtle is more believable and realistic if you consider she was banished to the toilet for stalking.
@@redriverscout4404 that's a bad place to banish someone to for that reason lol
@@nighpaw4651 Thanks for the laugh. ^^
best ship lmao
at 17:10 you say that harry is seen falling head first and this is a continuity error. but he isnt falling head first. (probably just due to the frame rate)
You are indeed right! It's probably not the frame rate though, it's that the tiles are flying by so fast I just assumed him falling the other way
God I was watching this whilst high and got sooo confused man lol
Harry's Haunted House no, the frame rate is part of it.
The scene when everyone realises Cedric died is absolutely heart breaking. That is the best part of the film and also shows us the change between a kids story to a dark YA story.
"I love magic"
*Dies of cringe*
*dies in why*
*dies in I'm late to this video*
My favourite part is though the whole book's "harry did you put your name into the goblet of fire?" Dumbledore asked *calmly*
vs
and Movies: "HARRY DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME INTO T HE FIREEEABHSDUH
I think if people had not read the book they would have enjoyed the movies more
yes but the books are a way better.... there are so many missed details in the movie
I enjoyed the movies cus i watched em first, end uo enjoying both the movies and books
True
Nah if you just have a critical eye the movies make no sense, I haven't read the books since I was a kid but I rewatched the first 3 movies recently and the scripts are so bad they explain nothing about what's going on and are full of plot holes and contrivances
2:30 The snake in the first movie spoke English because we were seeing it from Harry's POV and it spoke Hissywissyese in this film because we were seeing it from Frank Bryce's POV.
Simples.
finnaly someone telling how cringy the introduction of the other schools was
They do break dancing for no reason. I think blowing fire is fine, everything else is way to silly.
David Tennant's performance in the court room is worse.
Their intro were MAD fire
@@sharpaycutie2 *ridicoulous and pretty misogynistic.
@@mariebourgot4949 and just completly bizarre that both of the schools have been made into single gender schools? Seemingly just for this entrance
This was my favorite movie when it came out but watching it now... I think it's the worst Harry Potter movie. Also Prisoner of Azkaban was my least favorite for a long time. Now that movie is my favorite, just beautiful cinema.
But the book is absolutely brilliant.
Goblet of Fire was always my least favourite movie, so I was pleasantly surprised when I reread the book after god knows how many years and LOVED it.
8:05 Harry Potter and the Goblet of fire: singalong edition by disney
I totally agree. One thing I'd like to add is that this film manages to somehow drag horrifically while simultaneously rushing everything. This is particularly jarring if you read the book first, which despite being longer and far more detailed, manages to maintain a far more reasonable pace (relatively speaking).
This is all amazing work. I'm going to make a short video shouting you out and hopefully I can bring some more people to your channel.
JackWolf Thanks so much man!
JackWolf no offence but 10 months later...
I love JackWolf. Up there with Nerdwriter for me
I could've sworn that there was an introduction for the teams involving a firework leprechaun at the match in the beginning
"melodramatic reaction to his son dying" ...wut?
Yeah, I thought it was quite realistic... I think if I had a son, and he died suddenly and without warning, I would probably scream myself senseless for at least an hour...
For years and the mass amounts of times I've seen this film I always swore that he was trying to steal from the trolley, but you make me doubt myself, goodness gracious this needs to be cleared up
Thoroughly enjoyed your commentary on this one, I was dying with laughter! 😂😂😂 I really hated this movie, such a shame because this was my favourite book (except for S.P.E.W.).
One thing I'll add about the colours of the spells during the graveyard duel, Expelliarmus is red like Gryffindor and Avada Kedavra is green like Slytherin. Additionally, as was stated in the books, Harry's eyes are green whilst Voldemort's are red. So its interesting that the colours the spells give off, are the opposites of the casters' eye colours.
I really HATED the stupid introductions they gave the Hungarians and the French ladies. I nearly wanted to vomit in the movie theater, all that teenage angst bullshit ruined this movie and Order of the Phoenix for me. I definitely did vomit during the horrible concert during the Yule Ball. I even remember the film strip of the projector burned and we had to leave the theater and be relocated to another one. We were also given the choice of a refund... I would have accepted the refund, but hardly anyone listens to a 13-year-old who went to see the film with his easily impressionable family.
i agree so strongly with u... i hated this movie so freaking much
Yes
but the french girls had great bums lol
There Bulgarians aren’t they?
Order of the Phoenix is much better than this dross
Bro your video is so damn good I could not stop laughing throughout it all 😆 looking forward to the rest!
Thanks so much man, I appreciate it!
All I can imagine is when durmstrang came in and blow fire out of there wand and dumbledoor just standing there like that ain't shit I can make a giant dragon out of water.
I remember reading the book just before the movie came out, I thoroughly enjoyed both then and I do now. 3\10 seems harsh but your videos are entertaining nonetheless. Can't wait for your video on book/movie 5.
3?? I mean, yeah it's the worst adaptation but still.
It's funny that you praise the dragon scene, I thought it was the worst bullshit in the entire movie.
27:14 couldn't contain my laughter at the dramatic zoon and music crescendo LOL
This film was pretty poor but I don't think as poor as HBP or CoS
Wow! I mean, I've never liked this film as much as a lot of other people and have always kind of resented that so many great things from the book were missed out, but even I think giving it a 3 is a little savage!😝
At 17:08 it's pretty clear to me he's still falling legs first... is this some optical illusion or something where he looks like he's falling in reverse or something?
This is the only hp film I rewatch
This is my favourite of the films...
The snake in the first movie doesn’t speak English Harry just perceives it that way.
12:05 "Driving him up the bend"?
Have you been taking metaphor lessons from Biff Tannen?
LOL I love your behind the scenes stats cards at the end.
All the deleted scenes were included TV cut version. I don’t know why 🤔
What all boils down to the biggest issue with the 4th installment is it's *SCRIPT*:
When a studio hires a director who's not familiar with the books' source material, a lot of integral contents of the main story is going to be left out, it's great to make changes going from Childlike Wonder to Dark Fantasy, but the pacing from its writing does come off as uneventful and rushed, plus the characters become way too mean spirited.
The only two good things that ever come out of this cluttered mess is Cedric's Death and Voldemort's Return, setting a much grittier tone for the rest of the franchise.
As a Story Overall, we are better off reading the novel to gain more visual perspective. 😑👎👎
Brilliant video.....finally! Also, when you were wondering why the paper catches first despite missing the flame.....MAAAAAGIIIIIC!
24:29 is hilarious I am crying, nice spot Harry :)
I've been rewatching the films for the first time since I was a kid seeing them in the cinema. I absolutely loved re watching the first 3 so far and this hit and I felt like I was watching a bad parody of the story, all character and story was gone, it was awful, I didn't even finish the film.
The tone was so off, the characters were unrecognisable and everyone felt like a joke. Does it get better again? Is it worth waste my time time movie 5 onwards?
This is actually the last Harry Potter movie I liked. It struck a perfect chord between being dark and dramatic while also having a sense of fun and lightheartedness. Even though some of the humour was silly and unnecessary, I personally liked it since it made Hogwarts feel like a real high school and really captured well the feeling of carefree fun that people feel while at high school. I also liked the visuals of this film; it felt very immersive with the dark gothic style the third film had but without feeling monotonous and flat like the Yates films. I'd say this is my fourth favourite HP film, behind the first three but way ahead of the next four.
WheresWallace4883 I’m glad someone else feels it too. While this is the biggest mixed bag of the series, its highs far exceed anything from the Yates films. They’re far from bad but are so drab and forgettable I’m hard struck to remember anything about them. They’re also a real chore to watch
A very interesting review, I must say! Whilst this is probably my favourite of the Harry Potter movies (it's up there at least), I find it very difficult to disagree with the vast majority of points raised here. Perhaps it's because I try to view the books and the movies as entirely seperate entities in order to avoid disappointment when things are different between the two, however there's not a lot I can fault you on here! I'll be rewatching the films later next month as I'm going to visit the studio tour in Watford, I'll see if your reviews wind up changing my perspective at all :D
I have never read the books so I can say the movies by themselves are brilliant. I love all of them. I do not wish to read the books because I do not want to be disappointed. There great movies and they should be judged on there own merits.
I am super confused when you say stuff about the deleted scenes cause whenever I see the moves on the those scenes are played in the US
I go can sleep with your voice in the background its so chilled :D Are u gonna do next movie. What do you think of audio book, might help you get through them faster
I've finished reading Order, I will be doing a video like this one on that too. I'm pretty rubbish with audiobooks as my mind tends to be distracted on thoughts so I miss out the fine details so unfortunately I'm a bit allergic to them in that case. But thanks for the comment on my voice, I appreciate it.
I felt that this film was sooo boring. I couldn't stand the way Barty Crouch Sr. was portrayed. I also feel that the film was lazily adapted. I love Prisoner because the transitions and just everything was done smoothly and felt magical. Here, even the final task felt anticlimactic. I completely agree with you.
In the beginning of the movie, when the old man caretaker was killed, did baby Voldemort do it? And if so, did he have a wand, or not? Or did he just _say_ the killing curse?
The books are obviously a thousand times better, and the biggest problem with Goblet of Fire is they didn't split this one into two films. Deathly Hallows was a cash grab prt1 and prt 2 with no real need to separate it as most of the book is camping.
The details you say it missed would have worked with a prt1 prt2. Part1 Quidditch World Cup, Task 1, Part 2 Tasks 2 and 3. It's a shallow film 6/10, but I think film 5 and 6 are considerably worst!
Can somebody tell me what the piece of music that starts playing in the background at 5:23 is? Sounds like a clarinet or something
"The snake speaking English"
In the first movie, it is from Harry's perspective. So it sounds like English. In this movie it's from someone else's perspective. So it sounds like hissing.
Did the elves just pop into tessco 😂 I'm dying
After you've done with Harry Potter: Did it Sucks, could you maybe do Lord of the Rings: Did it Suck?
I'll think about it.
Oh you definitely should! You don't need to compare them over much to the books, or even do the extended cuts, but you should do it!
I would definitely juggle the medium and deleted scenes, I would feel my time wasted if I didn't...
... even if the video ends up being like an hour long per video
*****
Well, in all fairness, the movies are three hours long each. Personally I've only ever seen the extended cuts.
I haven't watched the original cuts in soooooooo long
FUN FACT: When old Fred and George fight in the hall the book Hermione was reading was the goblet of fire
how does the parseltongue bit confuse you? The reason we hear the snake speak english in the 1st film is because we're hearing what harry was hearing. he didn't realize he was speaking another language and he simply understood what the snake was saying and thought he was speaking english with it. in goblet of fire we don't hear the snake speak in english because we are hearing the old man's point of view and he's a muggle who doesn't speak the language, so he just hears hissing noises
Why do all the teenage boys have 70s hair in this movie?
I have to say I love that Harry wakes up from his bad dream at the Burrow instead of the Dursleys in the movie, though the unfortunate thing is that it leaves out the bit of Dudley’s large tongue. So if they had been in the movie, I would have it be the morning with the Dursleys and then the receiving of the letter to the Quidditch World Cup, the Weasley men picking Harry up, Dudley’s large tongue, bed before the Quidditch World Cup and then Frank Bryce’s murder and Harry waking up at the Burrow.
I also wish it was like this in the book.
17:14 do you know what falling head first is? Because it isn't that, that is leg first.
The snake in the first one started talking and it was showing from the point of view from Harry, in the other movies it is showing what other people are hearing and seeing with regards to the snake.
That duel is Priori Incantartem, where two wands with a core from the same source (i.e. feather from the same phoenix) will not be used to attack each other and instead shows the spell history of the wands. In the book it is shown after the Quiddich match when they investigate which wand cast the dark mark, funnily enough Barty Crouch Jr stole Harry's wand during the match and used it before dropping it.
Something I hate about the movies is they keep doing this when they want to show "duels", the movies think it's the equivalent of sabers clashing but it isn't. I wanted the duels to be like people shooting each other with fireworks etc.
For this scene it was well rendered. The reason the colours are red and green are because Harry uses Expelliarmus and Voldemort uses Avada Kedavra, and these spells' colours also reflect the colour of the houses the two characters were in at Hogwarts. It also reflects their philophy on fighting. One likes killing, the other prefers non-violently disarming people.
The opening soundtrack was great, but could've been better if Barty Crouch Jr was removed and followed the book to an extent.
27:15 SAME REACTION! OH MY GOODNESS THEY ALMOST PUT THAT IN A HP FILM??? ROTFLOL!!!
That god damn KSP background music you used just has me thinking about rockets for the whole video.
30:12 or Voldemort just really excited about finally duelling Harry
THANK YOU for pointing out the randomness of that scene when they're studying/working/revising/??? in the Great Hall for some reason while Snape assaults them. What was that???
This dvd's menu bugs me so much! I guess this was a worldwide release. I'm from Brazil and here it looks the same
I will say, as someone who read the books extensively as a kid ((to the point that I read them multiple times from the library before getting my own copies)), and Goblet of Fire was one of my favorites... I do like that the book covers Harry's reaction and trauma of the whole Cedric dying thing as near silent shock and going with the motions after coming back to Hogwarts, while the movie just has him just screaming and crying unintelligibly while trying to cling to Cedric's body because he hasn't processed that he's safe now.
Like, both ways fit well in thier respective medium.
The Moody plot is SO much better in the book. In the movie they just had to give not-so-subtle implications there was something suspicious about him. In the book you likely wouldn't guess there's anything off about him, making the twist at the end very effective.
Love these reviews. Thorough spiced with humour :) xD
To me Prisoner of Azkaban is the worst of the early movies. Sure it looks pretty, However it makes completely random and pointless changes to characters for no other reason they Alfonzo was looking to put his mark on things, and so much was cut from the story that it comes off confused and disjointed. It is also the only one I have had people who did not read the novels comment that they had no idea what was going on.
The Great Hall always seemed so small to me in this movie. Like they're shooting in a set two thirds the size of the first three movies. It's weird... am I the only one?
My dad never read the hp books cause he hasnct read a single book, but he had watched the movies. I know it's not the same bit he's still kind of a fan. He doesn't understand a lot of things and he's very annoying when he asks for 100 time why did Snape killed Dumbledore (the most common question). Still he likes the movies and his favorite part is the 4th, so I donct think the movie is bad and my dad definitely doesn't... he watched a 100 times. Btw my favorite book is the 4th as well😂
Did the Goblet of Fire movie suck?
Yes.
*everyone starts to crucify me in the comments*
Agreed.
You like Border of the Phoenix and Half Awake Prince?
MALayhee700 Hahahahaha no.
Order of the Phoenix was...okay. Half-Blood Piece of Slag however...was the worst Potter flick.
Thank god I'm not the only one. Well for me it didn't suck but Goblet of Fire is my least favorite movie
Andres Acosta THIS DOES NOT SUCK I LOVE ALL THE VIDEOS BOOKS MOVIES AND ACTORS OF HARRY POTTER!
To be honest, Hermione being annoyed that nobody is being quiet when she picks dumb places to study feels in character. I was definitely petty like that when I was younger
I think that because in the first film it’s in Harry’s perspective so we can understand it and from this film it’s not in a parcle tongues perspective if u get wat I mean then we can’t understand it
isn't Barty Chrouch snr, john lumic from doctor who?
this is the first appearance i have seen David Tennant. i see him everywhere.
because i hadn't known him before i saw doctor who Tennant era i always think that he is the doctor just covering for historical scenes or something etc
I missed quite a lot of the Tenant era when it was first out. About a year ago I watched a few Doctor Who episodes I hadn't seen and was surprised to see Barty Crouch Snr there. All I could think of was: "The Chinese Fireball ooooooh."
@@robertbrookes2000 nice.
In both scenes he's falling leg first on his back?
I've seen this movie 4 times before I read the book and I had no idea that the cup at the end was a Port Key. I kinda needed a little more explanation about it.
Lol. Cedric literally says "Harry the cup is a portkey" like 2 times before he dies.
Has anyone told you that you have an awesome voice
Nope! Thank you very much, I personally think it's very inconsistent but each to their own.
I almost forgot these were a thing.
Sorryyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
I can't be mad at you :)
13:20 The subtext of that scene is to eventually reveal that Ron really did care about Harry and he was just being a moody dick on the surface. Agree that the dialogue was horrifically bad though.
I remember going to see this movie when I must have been 6-7 years old at the cinema and it completely killed any interest I’d have in Harry Potter until the last year or so (I’m now 21).
Great review, this one wasn't potters best hour. I've been meaning to ask, how do you make/ edit your videos because my friends and I have been thinking of making a similar reviews of shows and movies.
That sounds really interesting mate, I'd love to check that out. My process is long and complex but basically it's write script, record myself reading script, download footage I need and edit voice, music and footage together. Then create thumbnail and upload.
***** awesome thanks for the help
Let me know how it goes and I'll check it out if you guys make anything of interest!
1:33 Someone should make a fanmade DVD opening to Goblet of Fire, with the Arrival of Baby Harry music (like the DVDs of parts 1 and 3) and the footage of flying over clouds with the footage of the movie, then some freeze-frame of a scene a la Chamber of Secrets DVD.
yass please contact me if this had been done
Man! I really need to watch the film's with the deleted scenes added back in!
Could you make a Did It Suck video of The Empire Stikes Back or The Half Blood Prince?
I will be, don't worry. Half blood will be around in October, no idea when I'm going to do Empire though, probably around the release of Rogue One...
I thought that The Goblet Of Fire was pretty good. I don’t care if it’s inaccurate.
I've just realized the dragon Harry goes up against isn't a Dragon. It's actually a wivern, dragons traditionally have four legs. But it's okay because it kind of looks like Paarthunax :)
dragons don't exist
I really like your videos though I disagree on some points. For example, I actually liked it when they sang the hoggy warty Hogwarts song its a silly song that almost makes you cringe but I think it really is a good way of sort of briefly comparing the differences in these very refined, strict, selective schools and the all-accepting Hogwarts and while it's not so much something the typical movie interpretation of Dumbledore would do it totally seems like something book dumbledore would do
I think you're mistaken about the falling of the broom continuity error 17:15
He definitely is not sliding headfirst...
I like these videos a lot and you make a lot of great points but I have to point out a couple things - Moody's "Any questions" line is intentionally contradictory. That's the joke. He's daring the kids to question him after he declares "end of story, goodbye, the end." I'm not saying the joke worked, but it WAS intentional.
Secondly, you're wrong about the continuity error with Harry falling down the roof. He's falling feet-first in both shots. I can see how the shot of his torso might be misleading, but if you re-watch it carefully, the shingles are moving *upward*.
Regardless, great analyses and I look forward to watching the others! The bit with Madam Maxime looking over the miniature dragon had me in tears XD
Im not usually the one to scream Mandela Effect but wtf is with Madime Maxine's hair?
also I completely agree with you about the look of voldermort. yes the books describe him as snake like, but in the movie it was WAY overdone. the voldemort from philosephers stone was WAYYYY BETTER. still kind of snake like and had lots of scars and a mean old face like an evil dude should have
I know this video is ancient and I wanna thank you foryour work, but can we talk about the height difference between Matthew Lynch and Daniel Radcliffe in this movie?! @22:56
Dude It's all well and good pointing out that Greenwood is on guitar
But did you know that the vocalist is LITERALLY Jarvis Cocker from Pulp?
I love this movie. Favourite Harry Potter