How does Israel’s military compare to its neighbors’ in the Middle East?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2024
- This video looks into the military balance of power in the Middle East. Namely, Binkov compares Israel with some of its neighboring countries. Manpower, equipment and other numbers are examined and put into context.
00:00 Intro
01:02 Manpower
02:58 Reservists & paramilitary
04:18 Combat vehicles
06:30 Artillery
08:13 Navy
09:25 Aircraft
11:20 Air defenses and missiles
14:24 Outro
Music by Matija Malatestinic www.malatestinic.com
If you want to watch our videos without ads, if you want quick replies to any questions you might have, if you want early access scripts and videos, monthly release schedules - become our Patron.
More here: / binkov
You can also browse for other Binkov merch, like T-Shirts, via the store at our website, binkov.com
Subscribe to Binkov's channel for more videos! / @binkov
Follow Binkov's news on Facebook! / binkovsbattlegrounds
Follow us on Twitter: / commissarbinkov
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D3 | Summer | มาร่วมเป็นพยาน กับวินาทีแชมป์!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JCYvEsFlwx8/mqdefault.jpg)
Kuwait: “if I stay really still no one will notice me.”
Iraqi : *heavy breathing*
@@OmakeRemen I know I was making a history joke
That is funny shit. And true
@@OmakeRemen that is the neat part , the gov doesn't.
😂 good one
As Binkov sat back, puffing away on his pipe, gazing into the chaos that routinely unfolds, he pours a glass and watches the show.
The fact that there is a missile named 'Popeye' is surreal
TURBO popeye
@@DwightEisenhower34 Popeye Turbo 200kt yield
There are missiles such Bruno and olive oyl
Turkey's mandatory military service time is 6 months, not 12 months. You are wrong there, my friend.
I am Turkish, but live in Germany. I had to join the military, otherwise it would have cost me a fortune! Most of the time we had to sit around, have no real training and the howitzer, or even tanks are so old and just stored in warehouses, most can't even be started, the engine had never been serviced! to your answer, it depends how much you pay, if you pay 10000euro you have only 3 months
Only 6 months? Most their service will be spent in training
@@Ezekiel903 becaeuse you were bedelli LoL. Also it is only one month.stop lying
@@fertilerevitilizer7833 yes conscripts are only 6 month. % 47 of turkish army is conscripts the other %53 is trained and paid professionals
@@fertilerevitilizer7833 yes conscripts are only 6 month. % 47 of turkish army is conscripts the other %53 is trained and paid professionals
Jesus, he just gives numbers on military stocks and reserves with few opinions and all the arabs are pressed in the comments for NO reason.
There is patriotism, and then there’s fanatic nationalism
The cope is real 😂
Oct 7 showed how useless the idf are till today their are proving how incompetent as a fighting force the only thing cause damage is US supplied jets & bombs
some arab simps here just pretend like the arab world didn't also get/buy weapons and ammo from russia and china for decades XD
like its Israel's fault for having the big brains to back the correct superpower back in the 70s, as opposed to backing the Soviets.
also, The IDF mopped the floor TWICE with the entire arab world before the US even started to get involved in their affairs.
or did they conveniently forgot that too already?
some armchair generals online just can't give credit where credit is due..
Lemme guess; racist?
Regarding Turkey, all numbers seem to be accurate except for the Army. Infantry is serious business there, they have a lot of them, and they are very capable. Turkish Gendarmerie (Jardarma) is almost a second land force, and does a lot of the fighting in the mountains of the south east. I'd put active land forces personnel of Turkey to be around 600k, with half of them being conscripts. They also have a large amount of reserves who have actually seen combat.
Turkey also have 25.000 police special forces who are trained for anti terror operations and actively fighting in cities and mountains againat seperatist terorism. They are well trained as any army’s special operation forces.
Also Turkey and Iran and Israel has indigenous defence industry while other middle east countries depend on import weapons.
What? Are you sure that Turkiye only has M60 tanks??? By no means it is correct for Turkiye which makes me think the other information on the other countries possibly also wrong.
Tank numbers are also incorrect since 2378 actually does not include old stored M48s, if it was; it should have been +3500.
@@darkprofilepolis özel harekatın sayısı artıyor da yunus çevik kuvvet birimleri de sıcak savaşa girecek düzeyde eğitimli birimler bence onlarda sıcak savaş esnasında çok iş yaparlar
@@Hibrahim1 O birimleri hesaba katarsan her ülkenin ordusu kadar polis teşkilatı var. Bizim özel harekarçılar kırsalda anti terör operasyonu yaptıkları için muharip eğitimleri var. Diğer polisler muharip eğitim almıyorlar meskun mahalde güvenlik için eğitiliyorlar. Yoksa her ülkenin silah kullanabilen polis birimleri var. Ama silah kullanabilmek demek muharebede hareket çatışma bilgisine sahip demek değil.
Bu videoda Jandarma da hesapta değil muhtemelen. Sadece kara kuvvetleri personel sayısı verilmiş. Buna 200 bin kişi Jandarmayı da eklemek lazım.
Ever since binkovs failed analysis of Armenia vs Azerbaijan , I wouldn’t take this seriously
There are errors in the video. There are 17 frigates in Turkey with the latest TCG Istanbul and the number of corvettes is 10, the number of them will be increased to 14. Also, the Turkish army has decommissioned the F5s, there are 2 fleets of F4s, there are F4s in Ankara and Konya, their fleets are still active, definitely. They are not in number like 19. If they were that few, we would not try to buy 40 Eurofighters. Moreover, there are plenty of Su24s in Syria. You did not include them in the list. In fact, planes like the MIG 21 Su22 are in active use.Hİsar-O Hisar-A systems have been added to the inventory of the Turkish army. Official accounts have videos showing their use in air defense units.
i guess the 15 F-5 are of the Türk Yıldızları, which shouldn't really count. And quick correction, we are not buying Eurofighters. Well, we thought about it but the F-16 deal happened so no Eurofighters. Also, isn't TCG İstanbul (and the remaining 3 İ-class frigates) replacing the Yavuz-class? So it would be 16 anyhow.
General Aladdin
No, they haven't taken it yet because even the Knox class ships, known as the Tepe class in our country, were removed from the inventory much later, so the Yavuz class will remain for 5 more years, but the stacks +4 island class +4 more will be built, that is, there will be 8 stacks and 8 island classes, then they will remove the Yavuz class from the inventory and the Burak class. together with
@@arcaipekyun4232
The Eurofighter request has not been cancelled, it is still ongoing and will probably be purchased to replace the F4s.
@@arcaipekyun4232
@@bordobereli-fu4gfİngilizcen bok gibi.
From my experience training allies from that region, the biggest advantage that Israel has is competence. Most militaries in that region are appointed because of family ties/loyalty. Competence and qualification are not a factor. The Saudi, Egyptian and Iraqi military personnel that I trained were all woefully incompetent with poor attitudes that were unreceptive to training
Arabs cant fight, they never had to fight for something, most countries are Dictatorships, people are more focused on religion as to be a warrior! since they never learned to fight for their freedom but only for their leaders, they lack motivation too!
@@Ezekiel903 I wonder how you fight for your countries freedom from your apartment in Germany. Big words for someone living comfortably in Germany. Didnt you embarass yourself enough already?
can you give examples of the poor attitude and incompetence?
@nazeem8680 they were routinely late for class, uninterested/unengaged, and would just walk out whenever they wanted. When it came time for practical applications they would not listen to correction or coaching even when they were doing literally nothing correct. They would not listen to any debrief and were just generally disrespectful
Lamo what advantage? Look at what's happening with you only having aks and bombs to complete tacticaly defeat a competent army? With tanks jets and a navy while being sieged by them. Nice joke
Türkiye have
S400 km
Hisar 25 km
Hisar+ 50km
Siper 1 100km
Siper 2 170km
You don’t have enough information about Turkiye.
Yeah Yeah, we understand you fan of Turkey, but you don't have enough information about Israel's power either, wanna check this out?
@@King_DavidSolomon I am Turkish by the way. Believe me we have enough information about your terrorist organization with name İsrail
@@King_DavidSolomon we know everything about İsrail terrorist country
@@King_DavidSolomon Check out the 1985 South Lebanon War first lil bro 😭🙏
First of all, all attack helicopters of the air forces in Turkey are T129 attack helicopters because Cobra helicopters were transferred to the naval forces.
Also does not have old AH-1P variants like Iran etc, Turkish Navy only has AH-1W twin engine modernised Super Cobra
Not stronger than Turkey's in absolute terms, yet stronger than all neighbours, except Saudi Arabia in certain areas.
turks are nato, US wont allow it.
Saudis buying weapons from us they are nthng
Turkey only has a stronger Navy.
Israeli Army, Air Force and Air Defense is superior
If you take this video as a source Turkish Armed Forces couldn't make even higher than 30 on top armies list 🤣 you ignored too much equipment in their inventory and portrayed it as TurAF relying on the US for all it's A2A missiles in inventory. But still an important work 👍🏻
I am Turkish, but live in Germany. I had to join the military, otherwise it would have cost me a fortune! Most of the time we had to sit around, have no real training and the howitzer, or even tanks are so old and just stored in warehouses, most can't even be started, the engine had never been serviced! I can imagine that's not the case in Israel bcz they have always to be ready for war!
@@Ezekiel903You're a kurd living in Germany, mate, and you were expecting them to give you a leopard tank in Turkey?Hahaha
@@Ezekiel903 And who do you think improved tanks for Turkey
Yes, Israel
Israel does not always use the newest tools
But maintained to a high standard
I am proof that I moved Hammer from the warehouse on October 7th
4 months in the mud of Gaza, he traveled very well
@@86makso yes, but Israel invest far more money as Türkiye
The numbers are not correct Egypt and turkey have about 500 multiple rocket launchers.
President Jimmy Carter while in office stated Israel has "somewhere north" of 150 nuclear weapons...years ago.
This video is missing A LOT of factors.
Wrong info regarding the man power stats. Turkiye has around 450k military personnel and a small portion of this number are conscripts. Turkiye had a high precentage of conscripts at beginning of 2000s however they gradually switched to professional army completely. However the conscription law still on but the conscripts do not engage in operational activities. There are other mistakes too but i do not want to keep it long. Tank numbers and modernity level of them are wrong, armoured vehicle numbers and models are not accurate either. Rocket launchers/missile systems numbers are also wrong. In short, all numbers are wrong. How do I know? Because I have made extensive research on this topic some time ago out of personal interests. Forth coming from Turkiye example, I think such mistakes are made for the militaries of other countries included in this video as well so I do not find this video informative but disinformative. Sorry Binkov, bad work this time.
Edit: Fixed some typos
Yeah and China has 50 million soldiers. Lmao
@@chaosXP3RT Whatever you are on, I want some
Excellent and impartial video. Israel's secret weapon is the fact that any major conflict for the Jewish State is an existential conflict. When the conflict is not existential, as with the 2006 Lebanon war, then Israeli forces are much less motivated.
We need not be surprised that Israel has a small navy. In Old Testament times the Israelites often had a powerful army but never a powerful navy. King Solomon's fleet was mainly manned by Tyrian sailors.
This video is a perfect example of "say a lot of wrong or outdated information online and watch the chaos unfold."
Is a lot of the information he is giving incorrect?
@@yoyolebg3748 Just look at the long list of angry replies in the comments.
The analysis he's giving is based warfare from 25 years ago. Today's wars have changed completely. This video is very surface level in terms of analysis.
No one has real data on Turkiye. It's an old tradition. Turkish army has more than thousand years history. And in this tradition, they never show what or how much they really have, until they really need it.
I’m sure these comments won’t turn into a hot mess that relates nothing to the video
all these angry Arabs in chat bruv
Bros racism
i'm not an arab.
but it's obvious that the juice will be better armed.
usakistan has been providing them with all the money, weapons, training, military support and diplomatic support they could possibly want.
@@sabin97 its not usakistan.
Its Usasteinbergia
so you support genocide?
@HR4_ if it is justified, sure. Maybe those idiots should have left Isreal alone...
Israel power ??
US tax $
No babe
@@user-qs7gm7wn7yniggas playing with our taxes
garpmonkey.d9589 - U.S. tax dollars do not defend Israel. Rather, the well trained and effective fighting capabilities of the Israeli military defends Israel. So, stop distorting facts.
@@user-bq8rq8cv4g You are not well trained but well equiped with us tax and protected by them as we saw with the iranian fight back.
A military is based on some degree by the amount of arms....but usually it is based on ability, training and competency. Which Israel has in spades compared to it's neighbors.
... but not compared to the Wehrmacht.
as an Iranian I hope we can have peace in the future and become the next union ( just like Eu or Nato) indeed all wars not last forever. God bless everyone ❤
You want peace with invader jews ?
@manofwar2354 yes because Jews are not "invaders" they ate ethereal part of this regin and its history
Hahahahhaa@@humimimimi901
@@humimimimi901there were zero jews in Palestine before 1917
How does it stack up against Hamas who are armed with tunnels ?
They are ineffective.
Most Hamas tunnels have been destroyed or captured
@@ilansimon3962 far from it apparently
Thanks for putting these together @binkov!!!
In Türkiye conscription is 6-12 months depending on your choice to stay and get paid for the rest or after finishing compulsory 6 months you can leave. Also %75 is a highly incorrect percentage since conscription was shortened critically 5 years ago
I assume many systems of Turkey just outdated systems from basic web-search. just an example they have their own domestic sam's called hisar class and siper class, plus they have their own advanced radars, attack helicopters, ballistic/cruise missile's, whole domestic navy structure including complex domestic sub systems, Im not gonna dive into aerial unmanned systems and variety of precision guided ammunitions. Because basically they have huge inventory of domestic precision guidance kits, bunker busters, etc. The fact is Turkey is the only nato member country in this video, so I believe their military standarts are so much higher and precise compare to the other countries. So from the perspective of Israel, there is only Turkey has chance to ruin their country completely, plus Iran can cause huge damage either to Israel in terms of military escalation and plus World Economy via the gulf blockade.
I don't think the information about Turkey is correct. They have more than what you say in the video. Showing Nato's 2nd biggest army as a syria not makes sense at all. Research better new turkish systems
Syria has a sht ton of tanks, more than Türkiye but they are very old and those numbers probably dwindling as the war continues in Syria.
@@ThisAlias he meant putting Turkey in cup of syria while describing. Not particularly talking about tanks. Turkey’s recent domestic military presence doubled their power.
yeah, and although turkey does have a lot of m60s, most of them are upgraded to modern tank standards with the original 105mm gun replaced with a 120mm gun, APS, and modern electronics, so I wouldn't label them as mediocre. they also have a decent number of leopard 2s
"M60TM" is probably better than Leopard 2A4's by now. Low profile Altay turret, Modular Armor, Engine, Active protection systems all have changed. If you ask me I 'd go for altay turrent + 8x8 apc combination. Age of tanks is coming to an end.
Are those M60s ‘Sabras’?
I mean, not mentioning about drones is weird IMO
It’s interesting how the focus in the news is about Israel, Iran, Turkey and Saudi as influential powers in the region. Yet, typically Egypt is overlooked.
Given its military, political and cultural power/influence, I think it’s the sleeping giant in the region.
It's certainly sleeping on the Gazans.
Hamas who is an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood is the enemy of the government of Egypt, so there is no reason for Egypt to be part of the conflict with Hamas. Everyone else bordering Israel are irrelevant because in the real world they are weak, Turkey and Iran is far away with no ability to invade Israel, Saudi Arabia is not a military power in the real world. So Israel has no real risk of Invasion.
Egypt is facing too much internal crises and an Army top brass too busy trying to grift money from the economy than run a competent military.
How influential can you be when you rely on US and Gulf Arab handouts?
It's puppet state with a slave military, corrupt leadership, incompetent commanders (who are only good at doing coups and parades), lack of military training, no resource sustainability, and weak economy. Nothing about it is promising. Just an overpopulated hellhole ruled by a warlord
this is the first time ever that i don't agree with a video you put in your channel !!! Egypt navy is stronger. Turkey navy is much much much stronger and where did you take the numbers of Israel's tanks and armored vehicles ???
Can you do a Europe or NATO comparison one. Mainly 🇫🇷 🇺🇸 🇬🇧 🇩🇪 🇵🇱 🇮🇹 🇸🇪 🇫🇮
Remember guys. The Industrial Military Complex loves it when nations fight each other. It makes the rich, richer.
We’re all brothers and sisters. War is terrible. I wish our mindsets changed and held our leaders accountable.
bro forgot about Turkey's UAVs
Sorry binkov but unlike others i guess you made a cursory video by working on so many countries at once since many numbers are incorrect and data is unreliable
Would suggest "Why Arabs lose Wars" by Col. Norville de Atkine (ret.). The equipment would tell you one story, but the training would tell you something completely different.
Those are just symptoms of the governing structures
Right like in 2 of the 3 was they had a pretty big tech edge over iserial but constant coup meab there officers are garbage
Crazy lie
Since 1948, Israel has not faced anyone
The Arab countries are completely disintegrated until now, and Britain handed Israel the easy cake.
The only confrontation between Israel (America and Europe) was in 1973.
Even then, Egypt expelled the Russians years before the war for cooperating with and deceiving Israel, and they were one of the founders of Israel.
Everything else, whether before or after 1973, is toys and movies
@@historyisawesome6399
Israel is the most failed project that is supported by fabulous and unlimited support from 99% of the countries of the world. Despite this, it fails miserably in achieving the goals of the fifth phase of the Western occupation of the region
if I am from the West, I would search for an alternative that would implement my goals in the region immediately and successfully
@@historyisawesome6399
@@heshamabdou5259 >> You don’t mention 1967 and the loss of the Sinai. Israeli troops could easily have taken Cairo. They didn’t want to stop; they were pressured by the U.S.
Very nice idea for a video. I was always wondering!
If you have a shitty maintenance and logistics… then all these numbers mean nothing
You know there is a difference between countries like Israel that started begging America for ammunition after 1 week in Gaza and a country with standalone army...
Hamas also begged from Hizbollah, Hizbollah also begged from Iran and Qatar, and Iran also begged from Russia and China. I would say it's fair enough
Turkey has domestic Hisar A short range aur defence system and Medium range in service. Working om long range one too .
My Good friend Binkov is basically the Janes of the 2020's! great stuff well laid out!!!!!!
So overall turkey is top on list
Except they dont have top weapon
@@Speedkam top weapon ?
He meant nukes i guess @@Jessie46
nukes are useless@@cudas4n
@@cudas4n actually turks have nuclear weapons I think they were hosting them for NATO
Arabs going nuts in comments and staging fictitous victory parades😂😂😂😂
Weaker countries don’t remain weak for ever.
of course they do
@@user-ij7rb2wu9owith that attituide they do
@@apsoypike1956 your future will look like gaza 😄
china was very poor and weak country in the 40s 50s...... but today they are on there way to be the global super power number1.@@user-ij7rb2wu9o
These people really think that what happened 57 years ago will happen again 😂 weird dreamers
Failed to mention the biggest change in military warfare of the 21st century.
Drones.
Bothe Iran and Turkey are probably the worlds leaders in combat drone production now.
on the one hand it looks today in the 'old battlefields' such as ukraine, russia you are correct. on the second hand - none of the anti-drones from the west had been ever used or known. drones are still laser / 1 precise bullet / GPS disruptive from dropping even in a huge scale. i do believe that the west has solutions that will suprise even a mass drops attack without any problem
Israel is a world leader in drone technology. Israel taught Turkey how to build drones.
Before Russia was buying drones from Iran, Russia was importing Israeli made drones until the US pressured Israel to stop exporting to Russia.
The world saw Iran's Shahed 136 in 2022, little did anyone know Israel had this technology in the 1990s. Israel sold China Harpy drones in the 1990s. Again the US pressured Israel to stop exporting to China.
America's famous predator UAV is made by an Israeli Jew regarded as the founding father of UAV (drone) technology.
Binkov you're the BESTEST unbiased military nerd on the internet ❤❤
"unbiased" is quite the stretch.
4:49 wrong info binkov, this number for Türkiye does not include old stored M48's. If you check the numbers some years ago it was 3500+ since it was including the M48s you mentioned but number 2378 shown here does not.
The guy things Turkiye only has M60's HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA
Also the guy don't count DRONES as a whole...
Turkish Tank Forces still inferior to that of ISraeli
The largest and strongest army in the Middle East is the Turkish military
And Turkey is not even a middle eastern country.
Turkey has the second strongest army in NATO and is ranked 8th in the world. In the Middle East, Turkey is the largest and strongest army and Turkey builds its own weapons and everything from drones to tanks to airplanes, Their history also makes a lot of difference. Turkey is a country that acts on its own and does everything itself. No country has developed Turkey in the Middle East. The Turks are known for their fighting spirit and national pride. Don't talk if you have no idea.
Turkey is not a Middle eastern country. These are Middle eastern countries (Cyprus, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Iran, Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, Oman, Yemen.) You may say Turkey has the strongest military among the Muslim nations.
There president is a big actor who is talking against Isreal and doing also business with lsreal Turkey president is a manafaq man
@@TheBR911
دول الشرق الأوسط هي
مصر/السعوديه/تركيا /الشام بما في ذلك الأردن لبنان سوريا فلسطين
دول الخليج /العراق
I love binkovs comment section lol
One easy answer, and real answer is AMERICA
You left out a lot of Turkey's equipment. Don't you think it's absurd for a country with the 8th most powerful army to have so little equipment. we have a lot of locally made equipment. i suggest you do more detailed research next time. it's still a good video.
Because of being a part of NATO is why and other military alliances also didn't help either it's not that they can't produce they just haven't
telling the truth doesn't mean support's Israel's action. I'am Turkish, but live in Germany. I had to join the military, otherwise it would have cost me a fortune! Most of the time we had to sit around, have no real training and the howitzer, or even tanks are so old and just stored in warehouses, most can't even be started, the engine had never been serviced! And how said we are 8 strongest nation?? Erdogan?? Italy is building up our weapons, from T129 to the Gogtürk Projects and Meltem3. Without the help from them we would still be far back
8th most powerfull army ? its up there but probably not 8.. and you have a pretty terrible air force probably rank 25 or so its very low tech. i would put it equal or worse then Brazil today that is also very low tech... there are many countries that have about the same Army power as Turkey or close to it.......... Japan, Poland, Egypt, Pakistan, Taiwan, Indonesia, Algeria, Uk, France, Iran I would say all those countries are about equal in Army power, its very hard to pick a winner, Uk France will be a bit smaller in numbers but make up for it in quality , while Taiwan Iran etc have huge numbers of out of date but still effective equipment ( 1980s) stuff . Army wise it would be so hard to pick a winner if all those countries fought in a 1 vs 1. India South Korea USA Russia China North Korea are still stronger though and would rank ahead in Army so Turkey really could be rank 14 Army to be honest, rank 13 navy ( Australia , Taiwan, Spain, Brazil are slightly ahead of it in my opinion but still very close) and rank 24 or so in Air force. Australia does well there and would be rank 10 air force as the quality is equal to the US and the numbers are still high enough to do a lot , over 110 combat planes. I would pick any air force with 110 F35s and super hornets vs 250 F16 block 15/30/52 any day . That comparison is like a Chinese J-20 vs a mig 29 from 1987 it would not be close
@@user-tz2ch1im3r I'am Turkish, but live in Germany. I had to join the military, otherwise it would have cost me a fortune! Most of the time we had to sit around, have no real training and the howitzer, or even tanks are so old and just stored in warehouses, most can't even be started, the engine had never been serviced! France, UK, Italy and of course Japan are far stronger as Turkey, alone their investment are 3 times higher, how will you maintain a strong army with so less money? they have only big numbers like Russia, but that means nothing!
@@user-tz2ch1im3r yes, but you can compare it also with the budget, France, UK, have nearly double higher budget as Türkiye, so how can they maintain all this tanks, planes et cetera? like Russia, doublé amount of Weapons but have very high losses bcz of a weaker technology!
The only countries that are producing those weapons in the video are Turkey and Israel. While Iran is trying to produce stuff they lack the technology and expertise. Turkey lacks a lot growth and familiarity for now but I think Turkish Armed Forces will be indisputably far superior in the area and more importantly almost fully independent in 2040's at worst. As a Turk myself I hope we have better relations with Israel.
Most of the turkish hardware is getting online prior the 2030th. Fighters are going into serial production by the end of this decade. Altay next year. So by the 2030th Turkey is already going to stand as the military powerhouse in the region.
Turkey even Can't Proudact Bicycle Alone !!
Iran Built His First Drones in 1982
Turkey Built Hid Drone First Drone in 2010
@@justsefa1843
Are You Drunk?
All Turkish Drones Targeted in Ukraine in first weeks of the War !!!
Except the Arabs and some Eastern European countries, no one buys drones from Turkey when Iran exports drones to 40 countries and Super Power's. All the weapons that Turkey claims to be indigenous have foreign partners or are designed and produced by foreign companies For example, Atak 129 helicopter which is Augusta A129 from Italy. Or the Andlu helicopter carrier, which is a copy of the Spanish Juan Carlos Helicopter Carrier!!!
Turks are not smart people, you can't even name 5 inventions of Turks !!!
Lol because Erdo said so?
They already are late for some parts like an engine for the jet.
I bet it will be over time, cost more and some projects even half-backed as its mostly the case with such a budget and newer in building more domestic, that will have many problems in the beginning years + still reliance on imported parts as we see also with turkeys hardware .
Also Turkey just don't have the Economy of Scale in the production at the moment.
@@justsefa1843
@@PatriotOfPersiayou are just ignorant. :)
Turkish conscription is wrong. It's not 12 months anymore (6 actually) and conscript percentage is lower than %75. According to a source I found as of 2021, the Turkish Armed Forces had a total of 390 thousand 960 military personnel under the umbrella of the Turkish Armed Forces, 174 thousand 916 of whom were obliged. In other words, as of 2021, 55.2% of the Turkish Armed Forces' combat force will consist of professional soldiers.
You forgot to mention Israeli LORA, Gabriel, Sea/Ice Breaker, Arrow 2 and Delilah missiles
and the Jericho 1-3 ICBMs
@@kfireven he mentioned those when talking about Israel’s nukes
and that its navy is 3X the size mentiond here...
@@meddown7035 he did say that they were only talking about major surface combatants and submarines, emphasizing that patrol units are too numerous to mention
@@meddown7035 admittedly, he did leave out Egypt’s two Mistral class assault carriers
Most of the information given regarding Turkey is completely wrong.
The comparison is also a disaster.
We are not buying missiles, we are producing them.
2 Altay tanks are produced and currently they are getting tested by TAF.
Turkish Armed Forces consists Leopard 2’s.
I’m not even mentioning our UAV power and newly produced Aircraft(Helicopter?) carrier.
Even if you type with broken English you can easily gather information regarding the conscription duration which is 6 months.
Quality vs Quantity is what this video about and only Turkey and Saudi Arabia can match with Israel under these circumstances.
A person with no knowledge could say Egypt is the strongest military in Middle East by looking at this video, yet which is completely wrong 😂
Unsubscribed.
bu-bye...
Finally we got a OG style Binkov video. And a good one at that.
I’d like to see something like this or even a full on hypothetical war scenario on Chile vs Peru, Bolivia, and Argentina.
This should be interesting, especially since Argentina may finally modernize its Airforce and Bolivia is looking into buying Iranian drones including the famous Shahed Suicide drones.
great vid
You wrong at Türkiye's manpover according tonsurveys turkey has 520 k people active 400 spare
You cannot think of a modern battlefield without UAV systems. Also your information may be very.. VERY flawed.
At least one of them, i am pretty sure of.
Hi there! I'm interested in knowing what software was used to create this video. Could you please let me know which software you used for making it
For maps, it is Adobe after effects with Geolayers plug-ins.
For video-editing, it is any video editing software.
Well seeing as how America is their golem, it really doesn't matter how their military stacks up.
Lmao true
It does, because soon America is going to be unwilling/unable to project power in the region. Then, they are on their own, and things get interesting.
@@jakemocci3953As long as there are Chosenites in Congress with loyal Zionist stooges, the safety of Israel will ALWAYS be more important than that of America's. Kind of funny that a culture of fifth columnists will do so much to weaken their protector while doing everything possible to give a middle finger to their creator.
Biden bipassed congress to give Israel an additional fifteen billion dollars of aid. Israel is basically an American military base with its own flag.
Funny, but untrue. They had no issue triumphing in 1948 and 1967 when Western weapons were mostly embargoed.
I don't know much about other countries, but very wrong information has been given for Türkiye.
I have to correct you , Israel has infantry fighting veichels , they are Called "Eithan AFV" . and they are amazing next gen. AFV .
Excellent and Outstanding!!!
I remember Henry Kissinger once the Egyptian army is the only army in the world that could use tactical lessons from the South Vietnamese army.
People really are ignorant about what US aid to israel is actually. Yes, artillery has been provided, especially in this war, but a big part has been in the form of grants where the US outsources some R&D and gets to have a major say in the successes, like iron dome
The us give the wepone because of egypt peace one of the promise that the us give to israel if the pull out from sini was that in any defensive war they gonna bring israel whatever they need...
So israel just active this and on the way buy a lot of wepone.
Iron dome is mostly Israeli technology, US only partially funded the program to obtain some technology.
The Turkish military is incredably tough and dedicated, (or it was before Erdegon who had to undermine it for fear of being overthrown) Poland, out of self defense (and fear that another Trump presidency) spends a significant (for the EU) part of it;s total spending. Israel is losing it's effectiveness under Netanyahu as many of it's nieghbors are ramping up training, logistics and discipline.
Whats the difference between a ship and a boat? "Sir, you can fit a boat on a ship. You cannot fit a ship on a boat." A classmate in a county college science class responded to what we all thought was a rhetorical qusetion from the prof.
Poland is one of the European countries that actually pays its fair share on its military according to NATO's rules, they don't have anything to fear from another Trump presidency. If only all the other Europeans were so sensible.
Thanks to all who make Binkov's awesome video's.....
Old F-4 2 Shoe🇺🇸
do not underestimate the professonalism of turkish soldiers It has been on active war since 1970. Even it is small terror groups it made the army keep in form. In the region only some countries have this experience. Also, army have nato standards. Lastly the manpower is much more than that number.
Careful Binkov all the trolls from the weaker countries are here 😬
What’s there to brag about Israel ? Any country could thrive with 4 extra billion US dollars a year. The U.S doesn’t even have health care but Israel does.
I’d love to see Israel survive without foreign aid. Their weapons industry isn’t enough for export
October 7th proves Israel’s military is extremely overrated they couldn’t even secure the borders of the worlds smallest nation
@@newbeginning1510 research it’s early history (state of Israel)
@@softdrink-0the early history where the czeck republic and Britain armed and trained the early isreal settlers to fight basically farmers?
Yeah read on it you didn’t clearly.
@@newbeginning1510 From 1947-1970, they didn't have any US support and they wacked Arab countries in days. So you already seen Israel survive without foreign aid
Any country could thrive with 4 extra billion US dollars a year? With all of its neighbors try to destroy it? Name me a country that could do what Israel did.
Their weapons industry is far more enough to export. Their air defense systems are very good like SPYDER , Iron Dome, David's Sling. Their cybersecurity is pretty good. My country VIetnam bought a lot of weapons from it. Can any Arab countries did like what Israel did? Doubt it
Tanks are not losing importance
But sometimes they loose their turrets ...
@Vorname_Nachnahme when they aren't properly utilized, Russia sends tanks in like Lone wolves. They must be integrated into combined arms warfare using infantry support, active protection and aerial/surveillance units. At least that's what the US/NATO does.
Man all these people hating on Israel kind of justified Israel’s existence lol
exactly
The zionist entity is a illegitimate entity who stole land from the Palestinians their actions only further confirm they don't have any so called right to exist
@@buyaj7693 Saying someone doesn't have a right to exist is a little genocidal don't you think?
arabs only started identifying as palestinian in 1964 in the country of transjordan, youve been scammed@@buyaj7693
@FishWithAquaphobia maybe it's the same as nazi occupied Europe and their puppet regimes didn't have a right to exist on other people's land... zionist just need to go back to europe or wherever they came from and the non-zionist real jews are more than welcome to stay and live in peace side by side with the Palestinians
It`s not accurate to say the least - IDF in full capacity is 930,000.
Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev said:
We have offered them (the Arabs) a sensible way for so many years. But no, they wanted to fight. Fine! We gave them technology, the latest, the kind even Vietnam didn't have. They had double superiority in tanks and aircraft, triple in artillery, and in air defense and anti-tank weapons they had absolute supremacy. And what? Once again they were beaten. Once again they scrammed [sic]. Once again they screamed for us to come save them. Sadat woke me up in the middle of the night twice over the phone, "Save me!" He demanded to send Soviet troops, and immediately! No! We are not going to fight for them
That’s because of the terrible command structure of most Arab armies, and also the corrvption and dishonest intentions of the leaders.
@@Handle0108 Sounds like excuses 🤷🏼♂️
@@rees5714 that is literally the objective reasons for their failure. They had the means but they had incompetent systems and corrupt leadership.
@@Handle0108Bottom line - they lost to the Jews, and they failed to destroy Israel
@@rees5714 No, he is actually right. Arab leaders have massive distrust for their armies, because they are the one who attain power through coup. Arab leaders don't want combined arms training because they afraid of generals plotting coup. High Ranking Postions are given to the most loyal, not the most talented one. Command structure is extremely centralized ( due to fear of coup), thus officers and soldiers cannot improvise on the battlefield.
It's a bit funny because the Turkish army controls an area almost twice as large as Israel in Libya and Syria, using very little of its capacity. Israel cannot control Gaza by using all its power :)
False
Lol did you actually fight or only entered like police or parade army?Also when we compare with fights let's compare with other URBAN environments Mosul(read about it),Raqqa,Aleppo,taking over dense urban environments is harder/longer then taking desert/rural areas(The ironic thing is that Gaza militias got tens of Billions and decades to prepare and were more heavily armed then many of the world militaries,most definitely more then people in "Syria and Libya" you invaded)this is exactly why Americans and Israelis were terrified of Gaza invasion pre Oc7,and the Americans even after came to prevent ground invasion(saying thousands will die,which didn't happend).Second thing is that Israel already broke Hamas rule and controls 90% of Gaza(3 to 4 month the main war with 20 out 24 battalions destroyed),the reason why IDF do not move to the kill in Rafah/Dier Al Balah is political not military...I will summarize by saying all those who military know IDF abilities,I don't ANY NATO army that would have done this even comparable with low losses and fast movements much less world Army but again this is only my opnion.
Israel will occupy Gaza for years to come just like it has before 🤔 Also how do you think the Turkish army will perform in Gaza? No doubt it will beat Hamas, but with less casualties/time than Israel?
@@100500daniel Turkey would perform better without droping bomb on all the buildings. You guys fight with Hamas, Turkey is other hand fight with PKK. They have enough rural combat experiment.
"israel cant control gaza using all its power" -turkey cant contro the north eastern region of turkey with the kurds and couldnt stop the terror reign in the 1970s and 1980s without moving into a military dictatorship. and they didnt hand over the control over this parcel of land to someone else like israel handed gaza to the palestinian authority iin 2005. if israel was using half its arsenal like assad or ardugan were using their weapons recently(And of course civilians died,without cocerning the un and muslim nations too much ) gaza would have been razed by now.
"Saudi reportedly bought DF-3 missiles"
>Shows a Saudi MoD public picture of DF-3s on Parade
There's a great story on how ksa bought those df3s.
If the IDF is so powerful why the Western support then? 😊
IDF is a very powerful military. That's an objective fact.
Running such a technologically advanced military is very expensive and largely dependent on specialized imports overseas.
Israel never fights alone. It's largely dependent on Western powers' support in every conflict it had. Satellites, intelligence, spare parts, munitions, etc.
But there lies its greatest weakness. Such an advanced military is very expensive to maintain. Israeli society is overworked and overtaxed in order to maintain it. Just fighting an unarmed people (Palestinian) dropped its economy by 20%.
Imagine what would happen if it got into a war with its northern neighbors?
By comparison, Egypt is also an incredibly powerful Military. It terms of raw power probably stronger than Israel itself. But Egypt is incredibly poor relative to its size. So it fields a very powerful but simpler military.
This type of army isn't advanced, but isn't dependent on US mood to supply advanced munitions and technology.
Having the most advanced air defense system in the world wont matter when thousands of cheap rockets and drones are aimed at it. Having the most advanced vehicles wont matter if the supplier wont give you the spare parts to continue operating it.
Why not support them??
You dont support your friends that are strong in a fight? You just watch like a girl??😂😂😂
ZOG
What about the average brain IQ factor of the soldiers ?
It's in the negative for djouws
Turkey's army consists mostly of professional soldiers, reform has been made, the information is incorrect
If it really was a strong army, then already in October the Turkish army was in front of Israel's shores and threatening the Israeli army not to continue fighting. But Turkey did not do this because it has a very weak army and will not be able to stand against the Israeli army.
@@TheSmi1ey i dont know the exact of the turkish army but if they did that they would make the US an enemy witch as a NATO member defeats their own goals
Turkish Military active personal = 40 Million
Every Turk gets born as a Soldier !
Btw: Turkiye reduced Army from 650 to 355 thousand but now all of them are professional soldiers, one of them is equal to 3 standard soldiers.
You know what else? Turkey is NATO member :D
1121.
1918.
also they have very small country which their military factories and other factories exposed and can be hit easly
NATO boş natodan Türkiye ye zarar gelir ancak natodan çıkacağız@@sharonishere
youtube coments are one of the d9mbe5t place on earth
Here is some popcorns before you enter the comment section:🍿🍿🍿
Can you do a video like this on Europe ?
Huh, you got so many things wrong on turkey
Too many muslims in here salty they havent won a single war against a tiny nation state. Nothing's changed since 1948, still getting thrashed on the battlefield in 2023 lmao
Isreal's military is not the same as they once were, they're struggling to deal with Hamas.
@@Hao-fp9mt As well as that.. Israeli Military are no longer dominated by conservatives like back in the 60's and 70's.
at least Israel has weak enemies in mind and body.. just many in their cult
Wonder how long that would last without their sugardaddy subsidizing their military
@@ThisRandomGuy3 US aid is 3.3 bln while Israeli military budget is 24 bln. Even if they lost 12% of their budget they'd still probably shit on Hamas lmao
Many important stuff are not mentioned but good video overall
Israel winning card was not it's military advantage - despite how huge the gap was at several times in the history - but the lack of fighting will by the political leadership of its rivals.
Which rivals?
Who is going to risk their country for a bunch of marshes on the Tel Aviv coast and the Negev desert? Israel is unlucky at having the worst real estate in the region, it is also lucky to have the worst real estate in the region.
@@danielheckel2755it's not about the economic value of the land, but the spiritual one.
Many would like to be remembered as the modern day Salahuddin, but their thrones were more important.
@@ammarlakis Because the Al Aqsa mosque is already administered by the King of Jordan, a different King would gain little from conquering Jerusalem.
@@danielheckel2755that's not how it works.
Jordan's king can't even let his officials into the mosque without Israeli approval .But most importantly, Jerusalem is still considered occupied and needs to be liberated. It's not only about the Aqsa mosque.
I see the Doll is still alive and kicking ! Nice.
Omg a video about Israel! Help my feelinga are hurt!
MY FEELINGA TOO
Holofrost! My feelings hurt!
One criticism of Zionism or Israel and you’re charged for racism. Even Jews against Israel are called racist! Waaaa
@@MrSpeedy99 Maybe you should find a new hobby instead of "Zionism critic" it would make your life so much easier :)
Life isn't worth living with your head in the sand when there are injustices in the world. I'd rather speak out and correct people like you, than pretend the world is perfect.@@fir3drag0n1984
Turkey leopards have been forgotten
You forgot to mention aircraft drones. That's the future of warfare.
More Israel enemies underestimate them and think they depend on foreign technology and imports is better for them
Nice subject ... it could use further development. The raw numbers doesn't tell much, it would interesting to see more elaborate analysis compiling all factors into comparable scores.
1:36 The conscript service in Turkiye/Turkey is 6 months, not a year.
Israel won its protracted air war against the USSR, based in Egypt in the 1970s and 1980s. Russian pilots and ground crews were active in 1973 fighting under the guise of Egypt, and lost. Israel's air war over Lebanon resulted in 100 kills vs 2 (one Israeli airplane crashed and one was shot down.)
@@youtubecensorship5544 Ask any librarian about the USSR's protracted air war against Israel, c1970+. They will help you gain educational materials. Hint, the USSR lost a great many aircraft. Israeli pilots are the world's best. They actually provided the USA with the Russian aircraft used in the Top Gun training program (they went out and captured them, then presented them as a gift.) Again, any librarian can get you the reference information about this. Your city library is a great resource. You could also contact the Brooklyn Library, as they have an unparalleled research assistance program.
@@youtubecensorship5544Sounds like someone is uneducated on the conflict
@@youtubecensorship5544 - After Israel declared its allegiance to the U.S.A. around 1949, Russia quickly became an enemy of Israel and fully supported the Arab nations with military equipment, which was ultimately used against Israel in the Arab/Israeli conflicts of 1956, 1967, 1970, and 1973. Russian pilots also engaged in an aerial dog fight with Israeli pilots in August 1970 in which five Russian fighter jet pilots were shot down by the Israeli pilots. You should learn some history on the subject before spewing out your misinformation online.
@@youtubecensorship5544 Russians hate Jews
I dont know man.. These are very very rough estimations. Some numbers feel off
Repackaging older videos as an audio-only podcast is a great idea. Maybe also think about adding some kind of update for older content to make it more "value added."
I'd listen to your podcasts on Spotify.