@@PembuatKomentarHandal Sadly, the neurotypical was too limited in her cognition to consider any means of instantly verifying he was a doctor beyond, "Do you have an ID?" If she were less blinded by her instant judgement on his "weirdness," she might have adapted to the circumstance of his not having an ID, and asked a question only a surgeon would know - but ask it as a trick question, with a wrong detail in it. If he corrects the detail before answering the question, then she could ask him what she would need to convince the ER surgeon of the need for the appropriate tests.
@@jayp9881 Here, I'll translate: Never let your preconceived notions of "normal" prevent you from adapting productively to an unusual circumstance. Wariness is indeed adaptive. But any idiot can dismiss things that are out of the ordinary. More appropriately, truly *productive* scientific skepticism relies on asking the right question. "Do you have an ID?" is a reasonable 1st attempt, but, given the potential consequences of not following his advice if he is right, the need to prove he is a surgeon warrants asking a trick technical question and observing his response.
She also asked for identification which from context clues he didn't show. He's wearing plain clothes claiming to be a doctor and she should have just believed him??
He wasn’t only a savant he had a sixth sense. I worked for a doctor who, if the window was open and he got a glimpse of a new patient in the waiting room he would tell us a diagnosis before meeting the patient. He was always right. He had a sixth sense.
@@Kritin_Batish As a doctor you must be prepared to take into account any kind of factor in an emergency situation, ignoring one possibility makes you liable of everything that could happen after that. I never said that we can tell them what to do, but it is always good to take people's observations into consideration. That autolike doesn't save you from the amount of nonsense you say every day, little one, I felt like someone had to tell you.
I am a person with high functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder and a third generation carpenter with only a high school education. On several occasions I found mistakes that engineers or architects made on custom remodeling jobs in Dallas. Each time I was told to mine my on business since I had no formal higher education. Every time this happened it cost the builder lots of money and they had to sue them. One was that the engineer designed the 3 story home with 2x6 girders on a ten foot span. The floor sagged and after putting more wood, the builder had to have us take them out and replace them with steal. It was very costly and very difficult job as we had only 5 1/2 inches to work with. It took heavy I beams with brackets welded to them for each joist. It was all about ego.
@@AverageChaoshe doesn’t need fixing but you for sure need to fix your character 🙏I work with kids with autism you are the same as the people he described
When a person with high functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder tells you something from within their area of expertise, just listen. If you don’t listen to them, whatever happens is on you. Speaking as the mom of such a person.
People on the spectrum are able to see and pick up on things the average person cannot especially if it’s within their line of expertise, dosent matter if u are a collage kid with 100 master degrees in something or is a high school dropout don’t judge someone based on that nor should u judge someone that is on the spectrum
@@sora64444 You dont need to have a degree in psychology to recognize someone with autism. It's outwardly Obvious when someone has Autism, and the only way someone wouldn't recognize it, is because they've Never met an autist before.
I hate shows like these with the same plot every episode/season. Same with the flash fighting a faster speedster than him every season, or the numerous crime shows with a different bad guy getting caught at the end of the episode. It gets unbearable after a while.
Where I live EMTs don't get to know the fate of their patients. Well, unless they get called there again, obviously. Now, I don't know where you live, but assuming you live in the USA, you also wouldn't learn anything about the patient. The word "HIPAA" ringing a bell?
Just because he has a disability everyone thinks he can't be right and just do what they think is the right way. Guy is a genius. Having a disability doesn't mean that you should be ousted by society which is what pisses me off with the world nowadays
What does it mean when waves have a high amplitude or a low amplitude? Energy and Amplitude A wave caused by a disturbance with more energy has greater amplitude. Imagine dropping a small pebble into a pond of still water. Tiny ripples will move out from the disturbance in concentric circles. The ripples are low-amplitude waves with very little energy. It amazes me I googled it 😊
I loved the first episode, so true. Doctors dont listen to weird guy and then go look for weird guy and ask why and then ask where amd how did you know? Great show
@@AiOinc1 Yeah....suuurrrre. Blame your choices on some imaginary weird guy...(kidding😀👍) Actually, in reality, it's the ultra-charming ones you gotta watch out for: charm is a trait of psychopaths.
@@AG-yj1jvhis choices? You have some issues if that’s your response, assumptions when he isn’t wrong. The weird people will suggest dumb stuff that can get you in trouble. He wasn’t talking about people who will kill you or harm you
@@DJprofessorK Sorry I didn't use an emogi so you could recognize humor, will fix. However: If you are a real professor of psychology, you know that only a very few of those with psychopathic personality disorder are actually out to physically harm or kill. But, like Narcissists (only more charming because they are goal oriented), Psychopaths are highly skilled at manipulating. Thus, if one bases one's choices ONLY in the perception of weirdness or normalcy, then one puts one's self in grave danger of really bad decisions. HINT: It's not a "no ID so dismiss" situation. A more productive adaptation to the unusual, is always to question intelligently. Ask the right question, and you will have the information to better discern the person's actual expertise, their motives, and the details needed to either more effectively push for the needed tests or avoid being duped by someone pretending to be a doctor. HOW? Simple and quick: ask a trick question about somethingbonly a surgeon aoukd know, but ask it with wrong details. If they correct it first, then answer correctly? Mazeltov! You have a surgeon, likely offering sound advice, at least worthy of having some other staff member check.
@KH-tx6lg If it's not doing its job (giving an accurate reading), it's broken. It's like finding a chain link with a nick in it and thinking eh that's fine. It's not broken, right?
This is a TV show about an autistic Doctor. Called Good Doctor, this was supposed to be his "first day" at the hospital they're taking the boy to. The hospital board was deciding if they will employ an autistic doctor or not. However, at the airport Shaun encountered a medical emergency and decided he has to help, basically manufactured a one way valve for his lungs from a bottle of whiskey and common objects that literally saved the boy. The female mixed doctor is in her residency (if that's the right word? Like they're first year residents, Shaun too). That's why the full fledged doctor, asks the question like that, because he's like their teacher doctor (fuck, I hate trying to remember proper terminology). But yeah, the pilot all ends well and he's employed. A bit funny how he keeps trying to get in the hospital because he's hyper focusing on helping "his" first patient. The security would keep throwing him out, then the hospital director (his old friend, kind of mentor) found him and he was allowed in the hospital and could make a case. Funny thing, the scene from the hospital where shaun saved the boy went viral and hospital board saw it and that helped with employing him.
Thank you very much for your genuine, clear, and funny explanation. This comment is the only one that's made me want to see the series. Thanks again and never change how you're because is great🙌😊
My son is autistic. I find they hyperfocus on the little things that we all take for granted. Unfortunately, this means they can sometimes miss the larger things.... like tact or social cues
House and Murphy would probably get on well together. House recognizes great things in others regardless of the window dressing. Dr Cox on the other hand😂
Drs have people's lives in their hands yet their arrogance and pride know no bounds. It only takes a second to listen, especially to someone that has been proven to be right all the time. Someone not capable of being prideful. 😢❤
The reason why some autistic people are incredibly smart is due to savant syndrome, which is usually connected to autism but not every autistic person has savant syndrome. It is a harmful stereotype that all autistic people are super intelligent.
Not all autistic people are smart, true. But those with Asperger’s syndrome are. Bill Gates has it and so did Steve Jobs. My son had it also and he was a computer wizard. My son could play chess when he was four and no one ever taught him how to. I showed him how to write Cody one time when he was four, and I never had to show him again.❤️
Agreed. The brain is a muscle the more you use it the better it is at it's job by the time and autistic person is able to maintain a fluent conversation with the humans their mental capacity is pretty advanced in comparison to their peers generally speaking of course, there are always exceptions.
Hey man, before i react and answer i really need some explanation for your comment, because it seems to me that you are just trying to validate and share the love for your family but misinformation gets on my nerves.
"He was really weird" Damn you really shouldn't be operating if that's the only reason you had to dismiss a doctor's opinion about a patient in such a dire situation
No, but the "doctor" not being able to prove his point or not having ID IS enough reason to dismiss him, imagine listening to every smartass that has watched an episode of House and is trying to tell you what to do in a hospital
Society is so judgemental and shallow; it doesn't mean that if someone speaks, dresses, or behaves differently but still shows intellect and compassion, we still brush them aside and do not take them seriously. I remember a man who wore shorts, a white shirt, and sandals to a car dealer. He wanted to buy a costly car, but because of his appearance, all the sales representatives ignored him and did not take him seriously. The man played it cool and was very professional despite his appearance. He bought the Porche in cash. Iyvturmed out that he is a judge and is purchasing a new car for his kid who passed the board. After he left, every single car sales representative was dumbfounded.
Look up Dr. Semmelweis. He discovered that doctors washing their hands between patients decreased mortality rates and got thrown in a mental institution for it.
@@JimMorrison-py6tf he has savant syndrome, he can see things and process information regular human brains can't. He can, in fact, record that slight change. That's why he's an amazing surgeon
He was ignored because he gave a claim, providing no evidence to the nurse and he provided no ID to prove that he knew what he was talking about. In this episode, they don't know who he is. The nurse has no idea if he was an actual doctor or not, if was he autistic or not, or anything about him.
Not necessarily My mom is gravely sick, COPD And I could tell a doctor alot of different treatments, examinations, whatever for the lungs or breathing ways And I am not a doctor
Or if we say shock he's in a fib or in an atypical pattern for said patient normally we have some inkling you may not. There has been twice I had to accompany my dad to the ER (one was over phone because I had called in a welfare check on my dad after he wasn't answering phone or door to neighbors for over a week. One officer had to go back route and I did hear him on the phone knock on back door before stating he was going in on my instructions to check on dad. They handed phone to me when EMS claimed he was unresponsive and dead. Told them to shock him and they didn't believe me, shocked my dad finally and he started to come too. It's not our first go around with the circus for this due to a genetic heart condition my dad has)
I like that guy. This doctor sees what others can’t see. That’s amazing. They try to save a life and close minded people once again tried to kill somebody.
To be completely fair, without any way of knowing he was a doctor she wouldn’t be sure in taking his medical advice. As far as she knew he really could just be a weirdo who was speaking nonsense, as he had no way to prove his identity and didn’t explain why he was suggesting what he did.
To be fair ...this is a fictional show ...people with autism (Asperger's to be precise) on average have high intelligence with the lack of social cues....that being said.....this is still a fictional show
@@speed3msp Fiction imitates life, and that’s true for this show especially. I could definitely see this scenario happening in real life. We can still take these lessons from these works of fiction (of not to judge a book by its cover), and additionally, Im sure the person commenting knows this is a fictional show, but responding to non-real things in a genuine way is relatively common thing for people to do.
I can tell you stuff like this don't happen in real life. Literally saw a neurology doctor who kept saying that a brain cyst was of no concern, only saying that it was benign. With only one discovery image. Not knowing how large it could extend or retract causing pressure on the brain and possible nerve issues. But only saying to the patient that since it was "non cancerous and non spreading " that it was the SAME as "asymptomatic". Which are not the same thing.😅
@@rosedblossom I've worked in the medical field for a decade.....and taught Special Ed for 4 years .... mainly autistic students.... fiction may imitate reality....but reality ISN'T like fiction....
"Sorry your son died. Oh, you want to know why? Well actually a doctor knew this was going to happen but I didnt listen to him bc I thought he was weird" Thats a totally acceptable reason to ignore him.
Complement: they did that eco and they did find something wrong which was a little glass shard that entered through his blood veins into his heart and they managed to save him the series is called "good doctor" this clip is from S1 E1
@SilverThorn.-nl1dmthe meaning of the quote is that the man who has wisdom doesn't relate with fools. In that case it's Sean explaining an issue while being ignored by others. The psalms quote has no relation to what you said whatsoever.
@@thesinofthefather. yes that’s exactly what I meant. Scoffers are all around. and to address the earlier commenter on a religious note, read Romans ch. 1. Obey God’s command to believe his Son, Jesus. Don’t scoff at God’s Word. Flee God’s wrath to come while you have the life that the goodness of God patiently allots to you.
He didn’t have his ID on him and didn’t work at that hospital. As far as they knew he could’ve been some random person spewing nonsense, although obviously that would be wrong
@@jamesherb4384 She still has no way of verifying his identity or if he actually has a medical license or knows what he’s talking about, especially because he didn’t provide his reasoning and from what data they (the hospital staff) had, the kid most definitely wouldn’t have needed one.
@rosedblossom no random person is gonna come in telling you someone needs an echocardiogram unless they know what they are talking about. I doubt most people outside the medical field even know what an echocardiogram is. she should have asked questions. specially why he thought he needed one.
Someone saying that another person is WEIRD when that person has AUTISM, they don't know how much words like that hurt. My daughter has a very mild touch of AUTISM, and it killed me as a parent listening & watching other kids make fun of her or not include her in their activities. My daughter now as an adult, has a Bachelors DEGREE. She does very well in life and on her own. I am SUPER PROUD of my daughter. 😃😃😃
ECGs like this one actually continuously rescale the plot to match the signal amplitude because tiny changes in skin resistivity can change the measured voltage. That's why there is no scale of voltage on the y-axis. So the EMT was right that he's over-interpreting results beyond what the equipment is capable of measuring.
But watch how later in the same episode it turns out he was right and the ECG was 100% needed, and if not then the patient would’ve died as a result of medical malpractice
No he wasn't! And neither are you! It is not voltage, it is beats per minute. Hence why the EMT stated mentioned BPM. Also, there is no signal amplitude as it ISN"T MEASURING voltage! Further, rescaling would render the display invalid and unusable. Without a label on the rescaled axis the data would be worthless so no it doesn't rescale. Additionally, only the horizontal (x) axis is even relevant.
@@protoborg Did you even watch the clip? The whole point is that there is a misunderstanding between the EMT and the doctor. The EMT only looks at the frequency (bpm) while he talks about the amplitude (which is usually measuring mV). He explicitly states "lower amplitude means lower voltage" in the video to make his point. Rescaling the plot makes the features easier to analyze. From the shape of the waves, you can tell a lot about a patient's condition. That's the whole point of an ECG. Otherwise, it wouldn't make sense to even display a plot.
In the automotive field the height is called the sparkline and it works exactly the same way you have a spark line and fire line it's amazing when you can see all each individual cylinder on a scope it gives you set precise information so very many shops don't even use
Low voltage on ECG indicates a pericardial effusion. Looks like it was getting worse in real time so when was getting sicker it looks like it turned to cardiac tamponade.
@@Lifes_GreatHe’s been making awful financial decisions lately though so I don’t think he’s the best example XD, also all forms of autism has been merged into ASD (autism spectrum disorder) so that’s no longer an accurate term
Pericardial effusion or cardiac tamponade. Thats what he means by lower voltage. The echo helps to look at the sac around the heart and see if its filled with water or expanded outside of the normal range. The kid got glass on his chest so makes a little sense. Im just a recent graduate but thats my opinion
The Very First Episode Of The Good Doctor & That Little Boy Had A Piece Of Glass Going In His Heart From When It Fell At The Airport Where Shawn Saved Him At The First Time.
House is kind when he needs to be. When he is dealing with someone traumatized or fragile. He would not bully Shaun. But I think Shaun would call him out for being mean to other people. I think a crossover show would be good; I'd watch it.
This is a constant in the show. He picks up the weak signal (literally in most cases). Finding out late I'm on the spectrum and now interested in complexity science/theory/philosopy - one of the core tenets is the seeing these important signs out of the noise (doubt like old machine, 40mph, no credentials, odd behavior). The real world will do what is shown here - marginalise the outlier.
![[FULL EP.13] เซียนหรั่ง พา ไททศมิตร ลงเรือฝึกสกิลหว่านแห | เฮ็ดอย่างเซียนหรั่ง | One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EWFuf2Av0K0/mqdefault.jpg)
He’s been correct so many times yet everyone refuses to believe him 😭😭
That's what having Autism does with people around you, they think you're weird and crazy
This is like episode one they dont know him
It can be 100 million successes but only 1 can ruin your reputation permanently
First time meeting it’s not like she watched the show you fingus
because HE IS A SURGEON!!!
Never judge “weird” as synonymous with being incorrect.
I can name a few situations where weird claims are not in fact correct. I'm not sure this statement holds up.
Most of the time, weird means inccorect. Also this Is emergency, they did not have time to try advice from a weird guy
@@PembuatKomentarHandal Sadly, the neurotypical was too limited in her cognition to consider any means of instantly verifying he was a doctor beyond, "Do you have an ID?"
If she were less blinded by her instant judgement on his "weirdness," she might have adapted to the circumstance of his not having an ID, and asked a question only a surgeon would know - but ask it as a trick question, with a wrong detail in it. If he corrects the detail before answering the question, then she could ask him what she would need to convince the ER surgeon of the need for the appropriate tests.
@@jayp9881 Here, I'll translate:
Never let your preconceived notions of "normal" prevent you from adapting productively to an unusual circumstance. Wariness is indeed adaptive. But any idiot can dismiss things that are out of the ordinary. More appropriately, truly *productive* scientific skepticism relies on asking the right question. "Do you have an ID?" is a reasonable 1st attempt, but, given the potential consequences of not following his advice if he is right, the need to prove he is a surgeon warrants asking a trick technical question and observing his response.
@@AG-yj1jv Surgeons can be idiots too. And everyone can have some knowledge a professional can have. Where's your point?
This show is basically: "he's a genius but everyone misses it" over and over again with different situations
The almost polar opposite of House where he's the genius who misses it over and over again until he gets it right.
Lol truth
The Korean version was better. Probably because it wasn’t set up to be episodic or have multiple seasons
The same thing happened with House MD
He's autistic, and if you don't notice or realize it comes off a bit different than the average person
"The boy was really weird. He even claimed to be a doctor."
I'm astonished how unlike a hospital all these hospitals have to be in order to make this doctor's struggles into actual drama.
You think it’s overdramatized but I can assure you it’s not doctors aren’t as smart as they think they are just full ego driven people
@@danjbundrick so you’re pertaining to the wavelengths? And that it wouldn’t make sense for the wavelength to change?
Theater comes from life
@@dionmoviesclipsnot anymore hollywood writers are far removed from reality. Everytime I watch anything I'm screaming "this would never happen"
@@gabrielmoore4233 this is a copy from a Korean Drama that Daniel Kim pitched to be done in the US
he literally told the female nurse he was a doctor LMAO
She was a doctor also
So we just gonna believe anyone who claims to be a doctor
@@lucasgarcia7755there’s no reason for him to lie. You & the nurse……fools
She also asked for identification which from context clues he didn't show. He's wearing plain clothes claiming to be a doctor and she should have just believed him??
Doctors don't always have to be in doctors clothes!!!!
Bro everytime he just looks so innocent
He wasn’t only a savant he had a sixth sense. I worked for a doctor who, if the window was open and he got a glimpse of a new patient in the waiting room he would tell us a diagnosis before meeting the patient. He was always right. He had a sixth sense.
some people have cat like senses its crazy.
After years of paying attention in practical work during medical school and any experience in his own practice after surely had no part to play......
My grampa simply calls it a "professional eye".
Doesn't belong in a hospital.
He's not weird. HE'S A SURGEON !!!
EDIT: Gyatt damn my first ever 30k 😮
And if they never saw him, they could know how-?
Well they certainly found out
A Strugeon?!
First impressions of emergencies feel different when duty calls.
And a great 1 @ that 💞❤️🥰😍🤩💕
so being weird is an excuse to not take seriously the life of a patient?
No, she asked for his I.D and he said he had none so all she had was a stranger saying they were a doctor telling her what to do without evidence
@@felidari3963 aaand that's an excuse to not take seriously the life of a patient
@@felidari3963he created a mini ventilator using paper cups in an airport, he is a freaking genius. The chick is dumb.
@@SprayInk-And-CritGlitch Bro thinks he can enter any hospital and tell a professional doctor what to do with a patient 😂
@@Kritin_Batish As a doctor you must be prepared to take into account any kind of factor in an emergency situation, ignoring one possibility makes you liable of everything that could happen after that. I never said that we can tell them what to do, but it is always good to take people's observations into consideration.
That autolike doesn't save you from the amount of nonsense you say every day, little one, I felt like someone had to tell you.
He hyperfixated on the monitor so even the slightest change was noticeable to him where everyone else was focusing on the paperwork.
I am a person with high functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder and a third generation carpenter with only a high school education. On several occasions I found mistakes that engineers or architects made on custom remodeling jobs in Dallas. Each time I was told to mine my on business since I had no formal higher education. Every time this happened it cost the builder lots of money and they had to sue them.
One was that the engineer designed the 3 story home with 2x6 girders on a ten foot span. The floor sagged and after putting more wood, the builder had to have us take them out and replace them with steal. It was very costly and very difficult job as we had only 5 1/2 inches to work with. It took heavy I beams with brackets welded to them for each joist. It was all about ego.
if you find mistakes so easily how come you havent fixed yourself
@@AverageChaosthat's so messed up bro 😂
@@AverageChaoshe doesn’t need fixing but you for sure need to fix your character 🙏I work with kids with autism you are the same as the people he described
When a person with high functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder tells you something from within their area of expertise, just listen. If you don’t listen to them, whatever happens is on you. Speaking as the mom of such a person.
People on the spectrum are able to see and pick up on things the average person cannot especially if it’s within their line of expertise, dosent matter if u are a collage kid with 100 master degrees in something or is a high school dropout don’t judge someone based on that nor should u judge someone that is on the spectrum
A doctor calling an autistic person weird?what university did she finish?
I mean, she's not wrong. By definition being autistic IS being weird.
@@Choryrthbitchass answer that’s what I’ll call it
@@Choryrth it's not being weird, it's being different. to ab autistic person you're probably weird
@@Choryrth Its not it just means your brain produces differently than others do your research
mutual understanding
A ‘surgeon’ that can’t recognize textbook autism?!?! She got her liscense from google for sure.
It's a show.
why on earth would a surgeon know about psychology
Yet Google has a spell check system and you refuse to use it... Bravo.
@@sora64444 You dont need to have a degree in psychology to recognize someone with autism. It's outwardly Obvious when someone has Autism, and the only way someone wouldn't recognize it, is because they've Never met an autist before.
@@sora64444"why would a medical professional know about one of the most common illnesses" 😂
Bro has the coldest “I told you so”
if someone who clearly has autism says something with incredibly significant importance, take the time to listen to them
for real
bro i swear, all these episodes are just the autistic guy being right and the other doctors being wrong and realizing the doctor with autism was right
I hate shows like these with the same plot every episode/season. Same with the flash fighting a faster speedster than him every season, or the numerous crime shows with a different bad guy getting caught at the end of the episode. It gets unbearable after a while.
Because “watching neurodivergent person repeatedly fail in life” doesn’t make for good television 😂
theres a few episodes when he wasnt right
That's why it should be called autism house.
@@tamas9402 I'd watch it
I'm a retired firefighter and EMT. I don't know how many times I seen this happen and the patient died.
Quit lying
@@ja-makin-me-fit7335what were you stalking him
Where I live EMTs don't get to know the fate of their patients. Well, unless they get called there again, obviously.
Now, I don't know where you live, but assuming you live in the USA, you also wouldn't learn anything about the patient. The word "HIPAA" ringing a bell?
If you live in a small town you know everyone and therefore you can know about patient
@ja-makin-me-fit7335 Maybe he lives in a small town like me where being a EMS worker you know everyone so it's not impossible you can know
Freddie Highmore, always a great actor!
Just because he has a disability everyone thinks he can't be right and just do what they think is the right way. Guy is a genius. Having a disability doesn't mean that you should be ousted by society which is what pisses me off with the world nowadays
Autism isnt a disability, theyre just different but most of them are much more talented than normal people
He did say why his heart was failing
Cardiac tamponade,low amplitude low voltage is pulsus alternans and hypotension clasical becks triad.
Yes, but people don't believe him.
@@dionmoviesclipsi cant believe after all that happened they still think he's crazy
Can be picked up in eFAST. There's no way they are taking him to surgery without eFAST. Are they?
@@dionmoviesclips Which is SUPER dumb because medics know how to read an ECG lol
That's the smoothest ambulance ride I've ever seen.
Why?
@@sarahbarenstark9953not as many bumps. Believe me, I’ve ridden in one. It’s not as smooth as that
@@EliteChoice77 I see 😂
I had a ride as well, but properly in a different country 😅
This is really a wonderful series. It had 3 seasons. He’s a very good actor.
It has wayyy more than 3 seasons
What does it mean when waves have a high amplitude or a low amplitude?
Energy and Amplitude
A wave caused by a disturbance with more energy has greater amplitude. Imagine dropping a small pebble into a pond of still water. Tiny ripples will move out from the disturbance in concentric circles. The ripples are low-amplitude waves with very little energy.
It amazes me I googled it 😊
I loved the first episode, so true. Doctors dont listen to weird guy and then go look for weird guy and ask why and then ask where amd how did you know? Great show
Theater comes from life
Often times listening to weird guy gets you arrested
@@AiOinc1 Yeah....suuurrrre.
Blame your choices on some imaginary weird guy...(kidding😀👍)
Actually, in reality, it's the ultra-charming ones you gotta watch out for: charm is a trait of psychopaths.
@@AG-yj1jvhis choices? You have some issues if that’s your response, assumptions when he isn’t wrong. The weird people will suggest dumb stuff that can get you in trouble. He wasn’t talking about people who will kill you or harm you
@@DJprofessorK Sorry I didn't use an emogi so you could recognize humor, will fix.
However: If you are a real professor of psychology, you know that only a very few of those with psychopathic personality disorder are actually out to physically harm or kill. But, like Narcissists (only more charming because they are goal oriented), Psychopaths are highly skilled at manipulating. Thus, if one bases one's choices ONLY in the perception of weirdness or normalcy, then one puts one's self in grave danger of really bad decisions. HINT: It's not a "no ID so dismiss" situation. A more productive adaptation to the unusual, is always to question intelligently. Ask the right question, and you will have the information to better discern the person's actual expertise, their motives, and the details needed to either more effectively push for the needed tests or avoid being duped by someone pretending to be a doctor. HOW?
Simple and quick: ask a trick question about somethingbonly a surgeon aoukd know, but ask it with wrong details. If they correct it first, then answer correctly? Mazeltov! You have a surgeon, likely offering sound advice, at least worthy of having some other staff member check.
The real question is why are they still using 20 year old equipment on the ambulance?
serious? there is no reason to upgrade equipment that works!
if your stupid you would also fall in that fallacy
Because if it's not broken they don't need to buy a new one 🤨
@KH-tx6lg but why use old technology when new technology is 100xs better. It's better to be safe than sorry.
@KH-tx6lg If it's not doing its job (giving an accurate reading), it's broken.
It's like finding a chain link with a nick in it and thinking eh that's fine. It's not broken, right?
Especially with what they charge people. I much rather call a cab
It means you should listen to other people instead of assuming your right when dealing with life and death any chance is better then none.
"I'm The doctor" BOY YOU'RE NOT IN DOCTOR WHO
This is a TV show about an autistic Doctor. Called Good Doctor, this was supposed to be his "first day" at the hospital they're taking the boy to. The hospital board was deciding if they will employ an autistic doctor or not. However, at the airport Shaun encountered a medical emergency and decided he has to help, basically manufactured a one way valve for his lungs from a bottle of whiskey and common objects that literally saved the boy. The female mixed doctor is in her residency (if that's the right word? Like they're first year residents, Shaun too). That's why the full fledged doctor, asks the question like that, because he's like their teacher doctor (fuck, I hate trying to remember proper terminology). But yeah, the pilot all ends well and he's employed. A bit funny how he keeps trying to get in the hospital because he's hyper focusing on helping "his" first patient. The security would keep throwing him out, then the hospital director (his old friend, kind of mentor) found him and he was allowed in the hospital and could make a case. Funny thing, the scene from the hospital where shaun saved the boy went viral and hospital board saw it and that helped with employing him.
Thank you very much for your genuine, clear, and funny explanation. This comment is the only one that's made me want to see the series. Thanks again and never change how you're because is great🙌😊
You need more likes! Thank you for his explanation.
Yo yo yo yo yo dude stop the cussing words not necessary
@@user-ih9xq7tv5z dude let me be, my brain was STRUGGLING
Need more like you thank you
As a parent of an autistic child they can see any small change a lot more different than anybody else can that's actually really cool
My son is autistic. I find they hyperfocus on the little things that we all take for granted. Unfortunately, this means they can sometimes miss the larger things.... like tact or social cues
@@illusionist1430this is also true. I’m autistic myself
"did he say why?"
"He was a relly weird"
Menwhile Shaun: IT'S HIS FREAKING HEART!!!
My boy Shawn Murphy
Imagine dr house, dr cox and dr Murphy running a hospital wing.
100 percent success rate be like
None of them would get along 😂
Everyone with health challenge will pay all they can to go to that hospital for treatment
Would be the best show EVER!
House and Murphy would probably get on well together. House recognizes great things in others regardless of the window dressing. Dr Cox on the other hand😂
He’s not weird he cares and is giving you crucial information in a time of distress
Drs have people's lives in their hands yet their arrogance and pride know no bounds. It only takes a second to listen, especially to someone that has been proven to be right all the time. Someone not capable of being prideful. 😢❤
Shaun is the type of guy in a horror movie that tells his friends what to do and defend themselves but they just hide instead of listening
Autistic ppl are some of the most smartest ppl in the world. My dad phd , my son advanced student. Dont judge!
Well not really. Most of the time they just get ton of benefits in school and teachers sit with autists and literally tell them answers to everything
The reason why some autistic people are incredibly smart is due to savant syndrome, which is usually connected to autism but not every autistic person has savant syndrome. It is a harmful stereotype that all autistic people are super intelligent.
Not all autistic people are smart, true. But those with Asperger’s syndrome are. Bill Gates has it and so did Steve Jobs. My son had it also and he was a computer wizard. My son could play chess when he was four and no one ever taught him how to. I showed him how to write Cody one time when he was four, and I never had to show him again.❤️
Agreed. The brain is a muscle the more you use it the better it is at it's job by the time and autistic person is able to maintain a fluent conversation with the humans their mental capacity is pretty advanced in comparison to their peers generally speaking of course, there are always exceptions.
Hey man, before i react and answer i really need some explanation for your comment, because it seems to me that you are just trying to validate and share the love for your family but misinformation gets on my nerves.
"He was really weird"
Damn you really shouldn't be operating if that's the only reason you had to dismiss a doctor's opinion about a patient in such a dire situation
No, but the "doctor" not being able to prove his point or not having ID IS enough reason to dismiss him, imagine listening to every smartass that has watched an episode of House and is trying to tell you what to do in a hospital
Society is so judgemental and shallow; it doesn't mean that if someone speaks, dresses, or behaves differently but still shows intellect and compassion, we still brush them aside and do not take them seriously.
I remember a man who wore shorts, a white shirt, and sandals to a car dealer. He wanted to buy a costly car, but because of his appearance, all the sales representatives ignored him and did not take him seriously. The man played it cool and was very professional despite his appearance. He bought the Porche in cash. Iyvturmed out that he is a judge and is purchasing a new car for his kid who passed the board. After he left, every single car sales representative was dumbfounded.
In a world where people can not stand to admit they were wrong.
Look up Dr. Semmelweis. He discovered that doctors washing their hands between patients decreased mortality rates and got thrown in a mental institution for it.
As an aunt who has an autistic nephew, their dismissive attitude really annoys me
Because in real life you couldn’t catch a minute increase in amplitude on the screen , you would need to print . It’s not real
I have a high functioning adult autistic son. I am amazed at how often people catch on that he's different. Women are the most likely to notice
@@JimMorrison-py6tf he has savant syndrome, he can see things and process information regular human brains can't. He can, in fact, record that slight change. That's why he's an amazing surgeon
@@hypnoticrobotgaming and that’s why it’s fiction!
They found a piece of glass in his heart.
"Do an echo"
I'M SO SATISFIED!! She was underestimating Shaun just because he acts weird
IMO this show had so much potential and they just never delivered.
When I did EMS, I actually knew a paramedic who could notice the difference while in a moving ambulance. Crazy stuff
Welcome to knowing how to interpret a heart rhythm, learning how to interpret a heart rhythm made me wanna die but later it became second nature.
@@DaniellaMorten They never taught us as EMT's how to read the EKG. So still impressive from where I stood anyways XD
Wise people are often ignored at first
Very well said. i will put this phrase on my social status❤
He was ignored because he gave a claim, providing no evidence to the nurse and he provided no ID to prove that he knew what he was talking about.
In this episode, they don't know who he is. The nurse has no idea if he was an actual doctor or not, if was he autistic or not, or anything about him.
@@cozmik30though one should also consider his claims because not just anyone knows about Echocardiogram (Looked it up myself a little)
The Cassandra effect
@@cozmik30Medical license
you know they are good actors when they actually stress you out
The way I get so pissed when they ignore him
This happens for real but instead of them saving the patient because the TV show they just die 💀
When people say "he needs an echocardiogram" THEY PROLLY KNOW WHAT THE FUCK THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT
Ar ar ar ar ar ar ar ar
Not necessarily
My mom is gravely sick, COPD
And I could tell a doctor alot of different treatments, examinations, whatever for the lungs or breathing ways
And I am not a doctor
Or if we say shock he's in a fib or in an atypical pattern for said patient normally we have some inkling you may not. There has been twice I had to accompany my dad to the ER (one was over phone because I had called in a welfare check on my dad after he wasn't answering phone or door to neighbors for over a week. One officer had to go back route and I did hear him on the phone knock on back door before stating he was going in on my instructions to check on dad. They handed phone to me when EMS claimed he was unresponsive and dead. Told them to shock him and they didn't believe me, shocked my dad finally and he started to come too. It's not our first go around with the circus for this due to a genetic heart condition my dad has)
There are Drs. Now who deny& ignore symptoms cause they don’t want to acknowledge someone is suffering. 😮😢
the fact they disregarded him 💀
I like that guy. This doctor sees what others can’t see. That’s amazing. They try to save a life and close minded people once again tried to kill somebody.
He’s autistic
Not that that makes any difference
they call him dumb and get proven wrong every single time
That usually happens when people are full of themselves, but actually don't know anything.
Most geniuses are considered weird
I like how the one doctor who Knowles who Sean is just goes “do what he says”
The weirdo is a doctor smarter than you. Never judge a person by their cover.
To be completely fair, without any way of knowing he was a doctor she wouldn’t be sure in taking his medical advice. As far as she knew he really could just be a weirdo who was speaking nonsense, as he had no way to prove his identity and didn’t explain why he was suggesting what he did.
To be fair ...this is a fictional show ...people with autism (Asperger's to be precise) on average have high intelligence with the lack of social cues....that being said.....this is still a fictional show
@@speed3msp Fiction imitates life, and that’s true for this show especially. I could definitely see this scenario happening in real life. We can still take these lessons from these works of fiction (of not to judge a book by its cover), and additionally, Im sure the person commenting knows this is a fictional show, but responding to non-real things in a genuine way is relatively common thing for people to do.
I can tell you stuff like this don't happen in real life. Literally saw a neurology doctor who kept saying that a brain cyst was of no concern, only saying that it was benign. With only one discovery image. Not knowing how large it could extend or retract causing pressure on the brain and possible nerve issues. But only saying to the patient that since it was "non cancerous and non spreading " that it was the SAME as "asymptomatic". Which are not the same thing.😅
@@rosedblossom I've worked in the medical field for a decade.....and taught Special Ed for 4 years .... mainly autistic students.... fiction may imitate reality....but reality ISN'T like fiction....
He's so weird. Literally describes all the smartest people in history 😂
This guy is a damn genius.
The Good Doctor.
Dr. Sean Murphy. Autistic, brilliant and brutally honest.
Is that the name of the show?
@@DavidKrout yes, but it's a series. Search for The Good Doctor
@@DavidKrout yep
"Sorry your son died. Oh, you want to know why?
Well actually a doctor knew this was going to happen but I didnt listen to him bc I thought he was weird"
Thats a totally acceptable reason to ignore him.
Remember he was really weird.😂
@@legendHezeyTHR3 hes autistic
To be fair, this was the first or second episode and he wasn't a doctor at this point
not a doctor but a random weird guy
At this point, it’s just annoying seeing so many of the doctors overconfidently be incorrect
Complement: they did that eco and they did find something wrong which was a little glass shard that entered through his blood veins into his heart and they managed to save him the series is called "good doctor" this clip is from S1 E1
Where can I watch this?
@@notvera I guess Netflix or smth I don't really know I use Arabic app
He isn't weird, he has autism and he is very smart and the fact they wouldn't listen, shows what kind of hospital they are
Imagine
You work as something for 20+ years
Would you listen to some random guy on the street, you don't know, how to do your work?
rather than confirming the information they ignored it. it could be wrong or right but still information is information
And yet he told her that he was a doctor!.@@ladycipher9783
@@ladycipher9783 Not normal guy of the street, she knew he was a doctor in the (dude who did the tube thing), isnt it? :)
@@madwicked3545 Then why did she ask for ID?
Psalm 1: Blessed is the man who … doesn’t sit in the seat of scoffers!
@SilverThorn.-nl1dmthe meaning of the quote is that the man who has wisdom doesn't relate with fools. In that case it's Sean explaining an issue while being ignored by others. The psalms quote has no relation to what you said whatsoever.
@@thesinofthefather. yes that’s exactly what I meant. Scoffers are all around. and to address the earlier commenter on a religious note, read Romans ch. 1. Obey God’s command to believe his Son, Jesus. Don’t scoff at God’s Word. Flee God’s wrath to come while you have the life that the goodness of God patiently allots to you.
WTF he is not weird he is an amazing surgeon that knows what he's doing!
This freaking ego
Blinds Everyone from thinking straight
If that is really weird you haven't seen much. A clear informative observation articulated well but with a tense body language.
Love these types of shows everyone doubts the doctors valid findings and wonder why the patient is getting worse
For the love of god if your a nurse or a doctor please for the love of fucking god listen to your patients and everyone connected to them
We becoming a doctor with this one🔥🔥
Just shows how ignorant people are
A nurse or a paramedic would never contradict a doctor unless they want to loose their job
At the time, he didn't showed his I.d
He didn’t have his ID on him and didn’t work at that hospital. As far as they knew he could’ve been some random person spewing nonsense, although obviously that would be wrong
@@rosedblossomI don't know. not many random people would know what an echocardiogram is
@@jamesherb4384 She still has no way of verifying his identity or if he actually has a medical license or knows what he’s talking about, especially because he didn’t provide his reasoning and from what data they (the hospital staff) had, the kid most definitely wouldn’t have needed one.
@rosedblossom no random person is gonna come in telling you someone needs an echocardiogram unless they know what they are talking about. I doubt most people outside the medical field even know what an echocardiogram is. she should have asked questions. specially why he thought he needed one.
I love this Surgeon he is really dedicated he is Hero
He had a piece of glass in his heart
damn she really called him “weird” 🤔
yeah cause people like us are so weird wow
@@RYUisMEnotYOUdefinitely
Someone saying that another person is WEIRD when that person has AUTISM, they don't know how much words like that hurt. My daughter has a very mild touch of AUTISM, and it killed me as a parent listening & watching other kids make fun of her or not include her in their activities. My daughter now as an adult, has a Bachelors DEGREE. She does very well in life and on her own. I am SUPER PROUD of my daughter. 😃😃😃
Same with my son, he now has a masters,but I still worry about him as his social skills are so different from neuro typical people.
Well not everyone walk with a autism radar, weird people exist too
People hate to accept truth when they find a crown on their heads
Show is called "The Good Doctor". On Hulu or Disney +.
ECGs like this one actually continuously rescale the plot to match the signal amplitude because tiny changes in skin resistivity can change the measured voltage. That's why there is no scale of voltage on the y-axis. So the EMT was right that he's over-interpreting results beyond what the equipment is capable of measuring.
But watch how later in the same episode it turns out he was right and the ECG was 100% needed, and if not then the patient would’ve died as a result of medical malpractice
@@jareddiamond7392 But that's fiction. I'm talking about the real world.
No he wasn't! And neither are you! It is not voltage, it is beats per minute. Hence why the EMT stated mentioned BPM. Also, there is no signal amplitude as it ISN"T MEASURING voltage! Further, rescaling would render the display invalid and unusable. Without a label on the rescaled axis the data would be worthless so no it doesn't rescale. Additionally, only the horizontal (x) axis is even relevant.
@@protoborg Did you even watch the clip? The whole point is that there is a misunderstanding between the EMT and the doctor. The EMT only looks at the frequency (bpm) while he talks about the amplitude (which is usually measuring mV). He explicitly states "lower amplitude means lower voltage" in the video to make his point.
Rescaling the plot makes the features easier to analyze. From the shape of the waves, you can tell a lot about a patient's condition. That's the whole point of an ECG. Otherwise, it wouldn't make sense to even display a plot.
it clearly shows that we cant just rely to machine like the ecg. sometimes you have to believe what a bold eyes can see to save someone elses life.
In the automotive field the height is called the sparkline and it works exactly the same way you have a spark line and fire line it's amazing when you can see all each individual cylinder on a scope it gives you set precise information so very many shops don't even use
This is how people treat autistic people. Talking to them with contempt. Smh
He said I'm a doctor, shes like "he was really weird" 🙄 what a b word
did u mean b*tch? word?
Want this show back
Low voltage on ECG indicates a pericardial effusion. Looks like it was getting worse in real time so when was getting sicker it looks like it turned to cardiac tamponade.
Same thing everytime. He’s right, no one listens and does what he says at the end
I just know that person with autism can be very smart.
Make sense to you I suppose..
Just kidding.
Most people who are on the neurodivergent spectrum are, Elon Musk is a billionaire, he has aspergers which is a more mild form of autism.
@@Lifes_Greathe hates it tho so ig that's something
@@Lifes_GreatHe’s been making awful financial decisions lately though so I don’t think he’s the best example XD, also all forms of autism has been merged into ASD (autism spectrum disorder) so that’s no longer an accurate term
Love his acting. He is wonderful.
You know the actor is good when you want to punch the character 😂😂
Pericardial effusion or cardiac tamponade. Thats what he means by lower voltage. The echo helps to look at the sac around the heart and see if its filled with water or expanded outside of the normal range. The kid got glass on his chest so makes a little sense. Im just a recent graduate but thats my opinion
Congrats on graduating! The info was great!😊
PE!!
The Very First Episode Of The Good Doctor & That Little Boy Had A Piece Of Glass Going In His Heart From When It Fell At The Airport Where Shawn Saved Him At The First Time.
What movie is this??
Weird is something that should not be ignore
Imagine Dr house working with Dr Shawn
I just hope then House don't bully Shaun then 😢
@itsmerayaha8118 ...I do believe they would have mutual respect for each other.
House is kind when he needs to be. When he is dealing with someone traumatized or fragile. He would not bully Shaun. But I think Shaun would call him out for being mean to other people. I think a crossover show would be good; I'd watch it.
Nobody who ain't a doctor even knows how to say echocardiogram man just listen to the guy
Name of show??
It’s easy to dismiss someone as a fool.
This is a constant in the show. He picks up the weak signal (literally in most cases).
Finding out late I'm on the spectrum and now interested in complexity science/theory/philosopy - one of the core tenets is the seeing these important signs out of the noise (doubt like old machine, 40mph, no credentials, odd behavior). The real world will do what is shown here - marginalise the outlier.