Kaela 2 years ago: *panic because social anxiety* Kaela today: Beejoe this game we gonna play for our weekly collab I love this character development but in all seriousness I miss Sana. She so sweet and gentle helping our lil Blacksmith.
@@benhicks9481She's mostly active in X, rarely streams. She only streams Arknights, although no voice. But if you can see her X posts, you can see that she's kinda happy with her current status/job .
Although they’re very different, Shiori hits the same Sana spot for me. Their banter would’ve been great but yeah, Sana would’ve absolutely adored Fuwamoco.
I have been thinking that since Advent debut. She would have loved her kouhai. Imagine the sweetness of Sana with FuwaMoco or Biboo. Imagine the chaos of Sana with Nerissa or Shiori. Amazing.
I still remember the whole "Koala" bit Sana did with Kronii and Moona where she pretended she couldn't pronounce Kaela's name properly LOL. "Ka-ay-la" "Koh-wa-la"
Kaela has a good poker face; I always thought she took things in a more casual, aloof manner but turns out she’s more sensitive that her demeanor would suggest.
She silent laugh and she silent cry, but after you watch her long enough, you can tell. If you want a heavy dose of it, go find the ID server heart museum streams mentioned here.
Sana i will always remember that day when you got that shiny Rayquaza that was the moment i was drag into the rabbit hole "Sana Will truely be Forever Eternal"
Korone and Kaela are really a lot alike, I think. Which is why the story of them having a little "GO TO SLEEP" war when they met at Holofes really made me smile. ;)
Sana wasn't around for long, but she did deliver in quality what we never got in quantity. And i'm glad Kaela is more comfortable now, she's been showing up a lot lately and that's great.
I never knew much of Hololive two years ago. So i never got to be a viewer of a live Sana stream. But everything i have heard from other members about her, and the past streams with her i watched really moved me. That even in the wake of one journeys end, the legacy of love and joy still lives on. Sana is eternal
What I regret is not watching anything at all on purpose because I couldn't understand her accent... I'm not a native English speaker, fortunately I'm much better nowadays but being unable to watch Sana except for clips that had English subtitles is just so sad
Weird how things work out. For me Sana's graduation showed me that I was getting better. I had been stuck in a major depressive phase for a couple years by that point; decades of mental issues collapsing in on me. But I was getting professional help and slowly but surely getting back to being stable. And Sana's graduation for me was a milestone, because for the first time in ages I was a "normal" amount of sad. Yes, I cried. Quite a lot even. But it wasn't the extremes I had experience during depression, where I would either feel nothing at all or completely shut down and be unresponsive for days. It was a weird bittersweet feeling. But it made it easier to accept it. Sana was there when I needed her bubbly bright personality the most - but now I was functional enough to not have to be scared of every little bit of change. It's nice to see her do so well in her career these days. Was great to hear her voice again recently.
I’ve always said that Sana was like that type of character in movies/tv whose departure realigns the plot. Kind of like Agent Coulson in the first Avengers. I wish I knew what that trope is called. Basically, everyone likes them and they’re appreciated, but it takes them leaving to make people realize what really matters. Their departure changes people’s perspective and their legacy makes people stronger. She was one of the purest Holomems we’ve ever had, and evidence suggests she was incredibly supportive behind the scenes. Altare and Magni talked about how she gave them support and advocated for not delaying the Stars EN debut until after she graduated. Kaela and Kobo still occasionally talk about her almost two years later. Korone and other JPs regretted not collabing with her more when she left, and Watame built a monument to her in Minecraft. Before debut, she was the one who spoke first and broke the ice between Council in their first group chat. She really did touch everyone, whether she meant to or not, or even if it was just in a small way. Sometimes I wonder what other little things she did behind the scenes that people remember her for. Every single Holomem has an enduring legacy and noticeable impact on the company. But it really feels like Sana’s outsized the relative short time we had with her.
In anime terms, it’s the Kamina effect, from Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagaan, where the supposed main character dies six episodes in. He left behind a legacy. Sana has that similar effect.
I’m so glad that she at least tried to have fun with everyone before going, even playing with some for the first time it was so natural for her. I still get misty eyed when remembering the Kobo and Sana collab and Kobo realizing that this was going to be their last time together.
When I first discovered ID back in 2022, thanks to the zombie, the alogrithm constantly shoved Gen 3 in front of me. But i didn't want the algorithm to choose my oshi, I wanted to discover mine with my own deliberate intention. This is one of the big reasons why I chose the Keris from Gen 2. I barely knew a thing about her at that time. But she had a twin in HoloEN. Despite being quite familiar with this branch, I had completely overlooked Tsukumo Sana. I made a plan for November to secretly join the Sanallites because I wanted to see the Pokemon nerd in action. I was devastated when she announced her graduation before that. She was gone before I'd gotten a proper chance to known her. Its the only graduation that has moved me to tears, even my divorce a year prior didnt bring me to that. I watched Anya's playthrough instead, in the end. She still doesnt quite get the type match-ups 😅.
When I decided to stop ignoring the algorithm & looked into what was being recommended (actually found a probable why, even), I didn't click on the clip (don't remember what was recommended). I sought out the source, then chose a stream to watch. A game I'd not looked much into, but knew enough about to follow, & learn both about the girls & the game. Gura stood out. So, I found Gura, in a very backwards way, to everyone else. Most find Gura, then discover their oshi. I just found Hololive & gravitated to the shark, naturally. I didn't watch Sana, much. Even back then, EN just put out too much content, to even try to watch everyone. & she was a bit too bubbly for my taste. But when Sana joined collabs, or I did watch her stream, she was very unique. Often came off big sisterly, to EN.
@remus_lupin I'm very much a part of the norm, in that regard. I found the shark first and delved deeper until I found HoloID. Sana never took herself too seriously, truly living in the moment. I wish I possessed that type of energy. The few that match that carefree attitude, as far as I can think of, are Zeta, Kobo, and Biboo... Maybe a bit of Iofi, too!
O7! Thank you Astrogirl! You really made a huge impact in all the members you interacted with! May you be happy and have success anywhere you go! Sana is Eternal!
Sad but very happy memories. One door close and another opened. Didn't really get in vtubing till the last month just before she announced her graduation. Will miss her alot but glad because of her got to see so many talented members. Grateful for the good times and memories even if they hurt the most sometimes.
Puns intended But Sana literally Hammered and Tempered our Blacksmith from anxiety nervous idol to a perfect comedian We love the BEEG Space Bread Sana, even if her time in Holo is short
Interesting thing about Sana is despite being an adorable marshmallow, she could be genuinely intimidating at times. Like during her last collab with the council, when Mumei asked if she could take Sana's limiter, Sana flat out went "What do you think?"
As long Sana is happy and well somewhere. As a Sanallite, I'm happy for her and as I heard recently, she is doing well in her career. So I'm glad. Thank you Uffuff for the clip and adding the subs. English isn't my first language so having that helps me with my English. Thank you.
Kaela 2 years ago: *panic because social anxiety*
Kaela today: Beejoe this game we gonna play for our weekly collab
I love this character development
but in all seriousness I miss Sana. She so sweet and gentle helping our lil Blacksmith.
Bless grindstone. Those two are so great together.
Kaela, giving less than hours' notice: Bijou, no day off. Surprise collab!
Knowing kaela past life job, it's understandable that she got anxiety, she was rather famous in Indonesia eSports circle
Sana was special, her stay was short, but everyone fondly remembers her
She is great. She's the only one I felt compelled to call my oshi. Now I have Ela and Fauna. Blessings from the universe 🩵🤍🩷
she may not be in holo anymore but she's still doing real well as an artist, and that's pretty much all her fans can hope for.
she on TH-cam at another channel?
@@benhicks9481She's mostly active in X, rarely streams.
She only streams Arknights, although no voice. But if you can see her X posts, you can see that she's kinda happy with her current status/job .
@@Minalinsky can you point me in the right direction? whats her new name
@@benhicks9481She is the "Navigator" searching for treasure left by the pirate king....
@@benhicks9481 namiee i guess im not suree I don’t quite remember
Sanana ETERNAL
We know
Yep
always
Man, i feel like Sana would have had so much fun collabing with Advent.
I can see her having a lot of fun trying to tease Biboo and Mococo. I miss the Astro Girl so much.
Although they’re very different, Shiori hits the same Sana spot for me. Their banter would’ve been great but yeah, Sana would’ve absolutely adored Fuwamoco.
I have been thinking that since Advent debut. She would have loved her kouhai. Imagine the sweetness of Sana with FuwaMoco or Biboo. Imagine the chaos of Sana with Nerissa or Shiori. Amazing.
She would've had her own cute nicknames for the Advent girls.
@@Tarkus_H imagine sana calling biboo as "bibooboo"
I still remember the whole "Koala" bit Sana did with Kronii and Moona where she pretended she couldn't pronounce Kaela's name properly LOL.
"Ka-ay-la" "Koh-wa-la"
the first and the last they collab
and the first audible Kaela's laugh 😂
Kaela has a good poker face; I always thought she took things in a more casual, aloof manner but turns out she’s more sensitive that her demeanor would suggest.
She silent laugh and she silent cry, but after you watch her long enough, you can tell. If you want a heavy dose of it, go find the ID server heart museum streams mentioned here.
Sana i will always remember that day when you got that shiny Rayquaza that was the moment i was drag into the rabbit hole
"Sana Will truely be Forever Eternal"
Man, I miss Sana
Korone got thru this kind of development as well..
Past korone : shy little doggo
Korone now : ORAYO !
Korone and Kaela are really a lot alike, I think. Which is why the story of them having a little "GO TO SLEEP" war when they met at Holofes really made me smile. ;)
And let's not forget Coco
You forgor the DOOG Arc
Seeing all the clips of everyone finding korone very likeable and super fun to be around with really warms the heart ❤
Sana wasn't around for long, but she did deliver in quality what we never got in quantity. And i'm glad Kaela is more comfortable now, she's been showing up a lot lately and that's great.
Sana may have graduated 2 years ago but it's funny to still hear some new stories pop up about her from other members.
Her graduation was 2 years ago? Man I feel old...
I never knew much of Hololive two years ago. So i never got to be a viewer of a live Sana stream.
But everything i have heard from other members about her, and the past streams with her i watched really moved me. That even in the wake of one journeys end, the legacy of love and joy still lives on.
Sana is eternal
You should watch Sana’s first and last collab with Kobo. Bro I swear I’m grown ass man and I was crying like a little kid 🙃
What I regret is not watching anything at all on purpose because I couldn't understand her accent... I'm not a native English speaker, fortunately I'm much better nowadays but being unable to watch Sana except for clips that had English subtitles is just so sad
I miss Sana, orphan Sanalites 😢
Its true, before almost 1 year Kaela never doing any collab, but now from id she are the most has collab espesially with EN,,
Weird how things work out.
For me Sana's graduation showed me that I was getting better. I had been stuck in a major depressive phase for a couple years by that point; decades of mental issues collapsing in on me. But I was getting professional help and slowly but surely getting back to being stable. And Sana's graduation for me was a milestone, because for the first time in ages I was a "normal" amount of sad. Yes, I cried. Quite a lot even. But it wasn't the extremes I had experience during depression, where I would either feel nothing at all or completely shut down and be unresponsive for days.
It was a weird bittersweet feeling. But it made it easier to accept it. Sana was there when I needed her bubbly bright personality the most - but now I was functional enough to not have to be scared of every little bit of change.
It's nice to see her do so well in her career these days. Was great to hear her voice again recently.
Still wishing Sana would guest collab, even just in a birthday call for any of the EN members.
Neighbula to the moon with yagoo
One day, Ina will play Splatoon...and a teammate will join in to support her... One day...
she's probably too busy birthing gacha children
Sadly it don’t work like that.
Even in cases of reincarnation there hasn’t been any collabs. Kson for example.
i see haachama give a happy birthday vid to kson iirc, but only that interaction i guess @@acow1385
biboo really brought kaela out of her shell, easily my fav duo in all of hololive
Sana will always makes us feel happy
Sana would never be forgotten.
A real man not cry
*Talking about sana
😭😭😭😭
Goddammit, right....
JP member : Kaela Shin
EN member : Kaela
ID member : Ela
Beejoe : KAELAAAAA!!!!!
Sana : Koala 😅
I miss our AstroGirl. Im so glad Hololive released the BigSmoll Plushis as I got my Sana and Kronii Plushi and just seeing her big smile 😢😊
💛💛💛💛💛
Sana is Eternal.
💛💛💛💛💛
sana : BATOT~
kobo : NOOOOOOOOO!
its blessing for me, hope she is succesfull!
NO BATOTTTT
JOTTTTT !!!!!
I like to see the evolution of livers with social anxiety, it encourages me to improve too with my anxiety 😊
*liver*...
just look at aqua, she's waaaaay different from when she started
@@zeroanimation3956 cross pollination is fine. Livers or holomems, by any name, most of them are just trying their best to make their audience happy.
Liver will never not be the dumbest term. Please call talents anything but that lmfao
Roberu was such a quiet boy back then...
I’ve always said that Sana was like that type of character in movies/tv whose departure realigns the plot. Kind of like Agent Coulson in the first Avengers. I wish I knew what that trope is called. Basically, everyone likes them and they’re appreciated, but it takes them leaving to make people realize what really matters. Their departure changes people’s perspective and their legacy makes people stronger.
She was one of the purest Holomems we’ve ever had, and evidence suggests she was incredibly supportive behind the scenes. Altare and Magni talked about how she gave them support and advocated for not delaying the Stars EN debut until after she graduated. Kaela and Kobo still occasionally talk about her almost two years later. Korone and other JPs regretted not collabing with her more when she left, and Watame built a monument to her in Minecraft. Before debut, she was the one who spoke first and broke the ice between Council in their first group chat. She really did touch everyone, whether she meant to or not, or even if it was just in a small way.
Sometimes I wonder what other little things she did behind the scenes that people remember her for. Every single Holomem has an enduring legacy and noticeable impact on the company. But it really feels like Sana’s outsized the relative short time we had with her.
In anime terms, it’s the Kamina effect, from Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagaan, where the supposed main character dies six episodes in. He left behind a legacy. Sana has that similar effect.
That outro *FRENCH KISS* perfection
...wat??
I’m so glad that she at least tried to have fun with everyone before going, even playing with some for the first time it was so natural for her. I still get misty eyed when remembering the Kobo and Sana collab and Kobo realizing that this was going to be their last time together.
Man, I miss Sana...
Man I miss Sana. Sometimes I would rewatch her vods on her channel.
Sana is truly Eternal.
When I first discovered ID back in 2022, thanks to the zombie, the alogrithm constantly shoved Gen 3 in front of me. But i didn't want the algorithm to choose my oshi, I wanted to discover mine with my own deliberate intention. This is one of the big reasons why I chose the Keris from Gen 2. I barely knew a thing about her at that time.
But she had a twin in HoloEN. Despite being quite familiar with this branch, I had completely overlooked Tsukumo Sana. I made a plan for November to secretly join the Sanallites because I wanted to see the Pokemon nerd in action.
I was devastated when she announced her graduation before that. She was gone before I'd gotten a proper chance to known her. Its the only graduation that has moved me to tears, even my divorce a year prior didnt bring me to that.
I watched Anya's playthrough instead, in the end. She still doesnt quite get the type match-ups 😅.
When I decided to stop ignoring the algorithm & looked into what was being recommended (actually found a probable why, even), I didn't click on the clip (don't remember what was recommended). I sought out the source, then chose a stream to watch. A game I'd not looked much into, but knew enough about to follow, & learn both about the girls & the game.
Gura stood out. So, I found Gura, in a very backwards way, to everyone else. Most find Gura, then discover their oshi. I just found Hololive & gravitated to the shark, naturally.
I didn't watch Sana, much. Even back then, EN just put out too much content, to even try to watch everyone. & she was a bit too bubbly for my taste. But when Sana joined collabs, or I did watch her stream, she was very unique. Often came off big sisterly, to EN.
@remus_lupin I'm very much a part of the norm, in that regard. I found the shark first and delved deeper until I found HoloID.
Sana never took herself too seriously, truly living in the moment. I wish I possessed that type of energy. The few that match that carefree attitude, as far as I can think of, are Zeta, Kobo, and Biboo... Maybe a bit of Iofi, too!
O7! Thank you Astrogirl! You really made a huge impact in all the members you interacted with! May you be happy and have success anywhere you go! Sana is Eternal!
Salute for Hololive's One and Only AstroGirl o7
Man 😭 great times in the past and more yet to come, the growth in all of them us amazing 👏.
SANA is ETERNAL 🧡🧡🧡.
Miko: "Sana bed NOW!"
Sana: "YES SIR!!"
Sad but very happy memories. One door close and another opened. Didn't really get in vtubing till the last month just before she announced her graduation. Will miss her alot but glad because of her got to see so many talented members. Grateful for the good times and memories even if they hurt the most sometimes.
I am happy to be a Sanallite, and I am glad to know Sana even if it was short.
Sana is eternal o7 🧡
Wherever she is, I can only hope she's happy and healthy.
That stream was my introduction to Kaela.
Koala's a good penguin. 💛💛
i miss sana too
KOALA ❤😂
Sana 💛💛
SANA IS ETERNAL!!!
Man i miss Sana
Puns intended
But Sana literally Hammered and Tempered our Blacksmith from anxiety nervous idol to a perfect comedian
We love the BEEG Space Bread Sana, even if her time in Holo is short
WE ARE NOT ALONE
sweetness&light. G,non-jazz fellow
KOALA will be with us
❣❣❣❣❣❣❣❣
(I'm save this video for future moments)
Biboo and Sana collab would have been great. Sadly
big sanana
Sana was my Council oshi, so even now I'm still coming to terms with it.
Man I miss our BEEG Astrogirl🧡🧡🧡, I found out about her like two months after she graduated.
Interesting thing about Sana is despite being an adorable marshmallow, she could be genuinely intimidating at times. Like during her last collab with the council, when Mumei asked if she could take Sana's limiter, Sana flat out went "What do you think?"
That collab got me exposed to kaela, so i'm very thankful for it
K-O-A-L-A!
I miss Sana.
ok I don't know why but I was sure Kaela debuted last year, my timeline was so messed up
I remember Holoh3ro debut because they're debutted one month after the green shinigami incident and about 3 months before Sana graduated
💫🌛
Jesus i thought Sana left LONG before ID.3 debuted''
Nah i remember it with Kobo being kinda sad too
As long Sana is happy and well somewhere. As a Sanallite, I'm happy for her and as I heard recently, she is doing well in her career. So I'm glad.
Thank you Uffuff for the clip and adding the subs. English isn't my first language so having that helps me with my English. Thank you.
By time I knew of hololive, she was already gone 😔
o7
I wonder what she is doing right now, is she still streaming somewhere out there?
She is doing really well in her artist career right now. She has youtube channel but she super rarely streams.
Sana forever beeg and forever in our hearts