Thx so much for synchronizing this score with the rendition by Yehudi Menuhin, GR8 work you have done! 5* :) ...and it's so helpful for studying this masterpiece! I still admire the effort by Yehudi who did interprete the incredibly complex score for the first time.
In one of Menuhin's recorded performances, he changes the score in the first movement (this is not the famous change he made which so irritated Kolisch). I asked about it, and he remarked, "You have a good ear." I still don't know of anyone else who has noticed it. He said he did it for thematic reasons.
@@marzannaclassics3347 Gitlis’s is not quite the same, it’s nice, but not like Menuhin‘s. Menuhin‘s is on another level speaking of musicality and understanding
The best version is by Barnabas Kelemen hands down. He follows all the performance and tempo directions (no awkward pausing to take breathers) and even plays the microtones as they were originally written
@@sneddypie The later part gets harder. Especially when you have to do many crossings while keeping the 5ths in tune, meaning that your fingers have to flatten slightly in an awkward manner
![ถามตรงๆ กับ อาจตุพร ทำไม ประเทศไทย ใครเป็นนายก ก็โดนด่า พอออกเเล้วคนคิดถึง!!?? l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3YFLMXxBGAs/mqdefault.jpg)
I've been reading "Light from Uncommon Stars" by Ryka Aoki and this piece is brought up quite a bit in it, so I had to find it and listen.
I’m reading it now. 😊 Listening to this while I read.
Same!! Just finished it yesterday!
I just came here from reading it! Lol.
That's literally why I'm here, it's such a good book
same here!
One of the hardest works for the violin.
Wdym it's easy! I can play it...
... the video I mean.
Maciej Marcinowicz agrees
Thanks for this. I love Bartok and regard him as a genius, but I must say I find this piece rather difficult.
Wow...Menuhin ... no wonder, Such a GOOD sound .
Thanks lots for uploading ! 😍 Been searching TH-cam for years for Nigel Kennedy's .
Thx so much for synchronizing this score with the rendition by Yehudi Menuhin, GR8 work you have done! 5* :)
...and it's so helpful for studying this masterpiece! I still admire the effort by Yehudi who did interprete the incredibly complex score for the first time.
Agradecida. Muito linda e melancólica . Bravo 👏👏.
In one of Menuhin's recorded performances, he changes the score in the first movement (this is not the famous change he made which so irritated Kolisch). I asked about it, and he remarked, "You have a good ear." I still don't know of anyone else who has noticed it. He said he did it for thematic reasons.
Thanks so much! I've never gotten to see the score for this one despite it being one of my favourite works for solo violin.
Awesome! I've been listening to Nigel Kennedy's version non-stop
His rendition of the fourth movement was by far one of my favorites, but I can’t find the video; if anyone can find it, please let me know
I thought playing 3 notes together made a choice, but Bartok proved me wrong.
A near 30-minute sonata? I can't believe Violinmasterclass put this on the same level with Ysaye... this looks way harder.
This is so mind-fuck-y for my Common Practice-trained brain to wrap around lol
For me it seems like only Menuhin can really make art out of this sonata by Bartok
Ludwig Dorner check Gitlis, the recorded version in the 50/60s
@@marzannaclassics3347 Gitlis’s is not quite the same, it’s nice, but not like Menuhin‘s.
Menuhin‘s is on another level speaking of musicality and understanding
I personnally think that the best version is by Laurent Korcia
The best version is by Barnabas Kelemen hands down. He follows all the performance and tempo directions (no awkward pausing to take breathers) and even plays the microtones as they were originally written
Nigel Kennedy's version.
6:43 string quatet no 5 quote?
Menuhin demanded Bartók make this piece easier.
Which version of the score uses microtones in the fourth movement?
Is this atonal? Modal?
Modal.
is this a joke? someone told me i should play it and i took one look at the sheet music and saw this...
3:58
23:05 !!!
its not that hard
@@sneddypie The later part gets harder. Especially when you have to do many crossings while keeping the 5ths in tune, meaning that your fingers have to flatten slightly in an awkward manner
Is it C major, please?
Yes
It's in G not C.
@@remomazzetti8757 thank you
where did you find the score?
Javier Vera The score can be found on ScorSer. I think the specific scan I used was en.scorser.com/I/Sheet+music/300224991.html