As someone, who lives in a German-Speaking area, and Catrice is a staple here in Austria, because it´s a German brand, I can say that they were not intentionally duping ND. They have them in other shades as well, and they look nothing like Natasha´s other Mini palettes.
@@KellyGooch have you heard of youtubers like nostalgia critic, angry video game nerd, cinema snob, film brain, obscurus lupa, linkara, phelous, nostalgia chick, todd in the shadows, and rap critic
Another dupe for the pillow talk lipliner is the essence soft and precise in 02 happy and it’s a little softer than the nyx pencil. My only downside to the essence is that it’s not retractable, you have to sharpen it, but that’s also a downside to the CT. However, at £2 as opposed to CT’s £17 it’s an easy decision which one I’m buying. Also the flower beauty lipstick spiced petal is very close to the pillow talk lipstick, if not identical
The Milani fetish lipstick in the shade secret is a dupe for the CT lipstick in the shade pillow talk. I personally hate the CT lipstick formula but love the milani.
Some people say it's a dupe but unfortunately on me it looks completely different! I had both already when people in the comments section of Allies video kept saying its a dupe and I was like no it's not lol and I testes it again together and nope lol the Milani looks way more peachy on me. But there are so many items people say are dupes that I think are not dupes at all. I'm very picky when it comes to calling something a dupe and wish people would call it an alternative or do a buy this not that video instead of a dupes video but I'm sure calling your video a dupes video is what brings viewers!
Please label which swatch is which item, or tell us please! I never know which swatch is the one I'd like better then! :) Love these videos though! In my opinion the Catrice 5 in a Box looks more like a dupe for the Mini Nude from Natasha Denona than the Mini Glam. Its even called Golden Nude... Both have that Golden Bronze Shimmer, a Beige-y Nude Shimmer, and the dark brown matte. I feel like the very light champagne shimmer in the ND palette is represented by the lighter matte. and the last matte in the Catrice is a good but different colored transition shade than the lighter colored transition shade in the ND Mini Nude. The main difference to me is the Catrice is a mix of warm and cool tones, but it still leans closer to the more warm toned Mini Nude to me because those shimmer shades look what was mainly trying to be duped color story wise!
The color pop ritz shadow also has very slightly larger glitter particles which looks a bit less lux and elegant in my opinion. Also space cowboy looks more wet because of the smaller glitters
I think the Catrice 5 pan is closer shade-wise to the Mini Nude by ND because that one has more orangey tones. Mini glam is more yellow-gold based. But yeah, I'd say it's somewhere in the middle because the dark brown in the Catrice one is like the one in Mini Glam as the dark brown in Mini Nude is a red-ish brown. I own both minis so I can confirm haha.
Love the new hair color. I just been binge watching your videos. Like your content. I was super blown away by the essence platte. I find myself using them more than my colourpop it's a mood
Love your new hair colour!!! You should definitely try the KIKO stick eyeshadows (if you can get your hands on that brand), they are gorgeous and low budget! Highly recommend KIKO Milano in general!!! 🥰
I have the e.l.f. No Budge eyeshadow stick in Metallic Mocha. It claims to be a metallic chocolate bronze. But on me, it pulls a bit plum and I actually love it. It has a LOT of depth to it; so maybe try other shades. ❤️
I live in Fairfield County CT and the weather the past couple of weeks has just been insane. Today it was like 50 when I left and almost 80 when I got home
love this video and the new hair color!! you always look stunning! also I just wanted to say that I personally find that the catrice palette is an even closer dupe to the ND mini nude
Ahhhh I own both the UD and Colourpop shadow and you’re right they are soooo close. I like that Ritz has a little bit more back pigment but honestly I bought Ritz hoping it would be a bit cooler toned than space cowboy. I want to use it with my taupe crease colors
I have been wanting the Sigma Eyeshadow Primer Stick for awhile now, but have been avoiding it because I didn't want to shell out so much for it. Thank you for recommending an affordable dupe!! 😁 Love your Fall hair vibes by the way 😊
Love your videos Kelly! The hair is gorgeous. :) I just got the NYX Jumbo pencil in Frosting last week - it is soooo good! I especially like to use it on my inner corner because for some reason I can never get powder shadow to stay there. I also like it in the water line. I need more shades...
Kelly I´m on a buying ban but I want to go to Douglas to get NYX stuff. Also I think that Catrice 5 in a Box palette that pink version is similar to elf Bize size palette in shade Rose Water. It might be like an European dupe
I wish we could get this stuff in Australia. We have Flower Beauty, Nyx, Essence and ELF but the range is extremely limited and we don't have Catrice at all!! There really aren't many options for cruelty free in the drugstore price range here except for those I mentioned and Covergirl, as well as a few aussie brands.
Blonde Kelly, brunette Kelly…I just love Kelly! I am so excited to have some Kelly videos to binge watch, as I’ve been busy getting ready to move to another state soon and keep falling asleep as soon as I have some downtime. I appreciate a good drugstore dupe way more than I used to, so im super excited about this video. I keep forgetting about those essence mini palettes, I have to pick some up! One of the things that has me so excited about where I am moving is that the Walgreens closest to my new place has so many more makeup brands than the Walgreens that’s close to me now! 😂 Kelly, have you ever tried the brand Chella Beauty? They are known for their brow products mostly, but in the last few years they branched out a little more and they came out with a gorgeous neutral palette and made it available in the most adorable mini quad and then a few months ago came out with another mini quad in rosey tones. The first one was brown tones. Anyway, I would love to see your thoughts on both of their mini palettes because I think you’d really like them. Aside from being super adorable, they are so buttery smooth and just stunning little palettes that I think are underrated gems! If you like a mini palette, these might be the smallest little palettes I’ve ever seen! The palettes come in two sizes and the bigger size isn’t that big, so if you check them out, make sure you’re looking for the super mini quads. I have never gone through an entire eyeshadow palette, but I have hit pan in every single shade in the first quad with the brown shades. I wish I could just pick them up and send them to you!!! 💕💕💕
I said it in your other video testing out CP Ritz and you really need to just lightly press it over your other eyeshadow you're topping and not swipe it. It will look almost identical to UD that way!
Try the other Elf colors! I have 5 or 6 and I have that champagne one and it's different than the others! All the other metallic ones are actually metallic! They're so good!
when you swatch the lip liners what order did you swatch them? are they swatched in the order you’re holding them at 2:22- CT on top and NYX on bottom?
You're making me want to dye my hair for fall! This is a stupid question... can anyone go back to their natural hair easily? I'm 42 y/o and I've always been scared to dye my blonde hair because I don't know if I can ever go back to my natural hair. Can I dye my hair for fall? 🍂
Never dyed my hair but from what I have heard and seen, blonde hair is high maintenance. Of course you can go back to your original hair color but would suggest talking to a hairstylist/colorist to understand your options.
It depends on the dye! Hair dye comes in semi-permanent, demi-permanent, and permanent. Semi is a temporary color and *should* fade all the way out. Some colors (especially fashion colors like blue) last longer though and might need to be stripped to be removed.
With the Charlotte Tilbury and NYX lip liners, the NYX one doesn't set down and the CT one does. The CT one has a nicer undertone in my opinion and the application and lasting power is way better so I honestly think it's worth the money! I have several of the NYX liners and I'm not a fan, they are super stiff and kinda hurt my lips to get them on.
Hey I know this is Kelly’s TH-cam and I love her so much but does anyone watch Andrea Matilliano and if so what happened to her? Is she ok? I think the last time she posted was like 2 weeks ago. I hope she’s ok although I respect any social media influencer who needs a break or leaves altogether. Her and Kelly are my favorite and I watch them religiously.
Sorry, but I think Catrice might have copied the packaging of the Natasha Denona minis, but the actual shadows don’t compare at all. You get what you’re paying for. I own the Mini Nude and bought the Catrice version at release (and decluttered it soon afterwards). Catrice has chunky, glittery shimmers that don’t apply well and need glitter glue, the mattes blend away and don’t layer well, become muddy. Personally, I just want a product that’s hassle free and just works. Eyeshadows (and foundations) have never been something that Catrice has been doing well in my opinion. Their clean beauty range is even worse.
As someone, who lives in a German-Speaking area, and Catrice is a staple here in Austria, because it´s a German brand, I can say that they were not intentionally duping ND. They have them in other shades as well, and they look nothing like Natasha´s other Mini palettes.
Hi from Austria! 😊
Hi aus Deutschland😂
Oh my gosh, your hair is gorgeous! What semi permanent brand did you use? Drug store perhaps?! Please share!
Ion Warm Brown :)
@@KellyGooch have you heard of youtubers like nostalgia critic, angry video game nerd, cinema snob, film brain, obscurus lupa, linkara, phelous, nostalgia chick, todd in the shadows, and rap critic
Another dupe for the pillow talk lipliner is the essence soft and precise in 02 happy and it’s a little softer than the nyx pencil. My only downside to the essence is that it’s not retractable, you have to sharpen it, but that’s also a downside to the CT. However, at £2 as opposed to CT’s £17 it’s an easy decision which one I’m buying.
Also the flower beauty lipstick spiced petal is very close to the pillow talk lipstick, if not identical
Hi, I almost wish you would apply these products on each side of the face so we can see what they look like, your hair looks so nice 😀❤️
The Milani fetish lipstick in the shade secret is a dupe for the CT lipstick in the shade pillow talk. I personally hate the CT lipstick formula but love the milani.
Thank you, Sam. I’ll have to try that one!
Some people say it's a dupe but unfortunately on me it looks completely different! I had both already when people in the comments section of Allies video kept saying its a dupe and I was like no it's not lol and I testes it again together and nope lol the Milani looks way more peachy on me. But there are so many items people say are dupes that I think are not dupes at all. I'm very picky when it comes to calling something a dupe and wish people would call it an alternative or do a buy this not that video instead of a dupes video but I'm sure calling your video a dupes video is what brings viewers!
Please label which swatch is which item, or tell us please! I never know which swatch is the one I'd like better then! :) Love these videos though! In my opinion the Catrice 5 in a Box looks more like a dupe for the Mini Nude from Natasha Denona than the Mini Glam. Its even called Golden Nude... Both have that Golden Bronze Shimmer, a Beige-y Nude Shimmer, and the dark brown matte. I feel like the very light champagne shimmer in the ND palette is represented by the lighter matte. and the last matte in the Catrice is a good but different colored transition shade than the lighter colored transition shade in the ND Mini Nude. The main difference to me is the Catrice is a mix of warm and cool tones, but it still leans closer to the more warm toned Mini Nude to me because those shimmer shades look what was mainly trying to be duped color story wise!
The brown hair looks very nice on you. :) Loving it.
The color pop ritz shadow also has very slightly larger glitter particles which looks a bit less lux and elegant in my opinion. Also space cowboy looks more wet because of the smaller glitters
You’re hair is gorgeous and perfect for fall! 🧡
Thank you!!
Yes, love the color.
Your nail color is so fun!!! Its tempting to pick that one up👀
You look great with the new Auburn hair! ♥️ also, I bought the green & bronze Essence palettes and i totally agree - they're great
Thank you!
I think the Catrice 5 pan is closer shade-wise to the Mini Nude by ND because that one has more orangey tones. Mini glam is more yellow-gold based. But yeah, I'd say it's somewhere in the middle because the dark brown in the Catrice one is like the one in Mini Glam as the dark brown in Mini Nude is a red-ish brown. I own both minis so I can confirm haha.
Love the essence palettes, didnt know about bareminerals. Great video
Love your hair 😍😍
Thank you, Molly!
Love the new hair color. I just been binge watching your videos. Like your content. I was super blown away by the essence platte. I find myself using them more than my colourpop it's a mood
I think Elf Cream & Sugar is also a dupe of sorts for ND Mini Nude. (Not my discovery) ND is a little warmer and has an extra shimmer.
I just purchased this palette, and haven't tried it yet. I'm glad to hear it's a close "dupe."😉
Cream and Sugar is a great little palette for 3 bucks.
The brown hair is gorgeous! Thanks for sharing dupes!
I've love peekaboo neutral one of favorite liners. I use it almost daily! But I honestly have almost every nude neutral lip liner from Nyx.
It’s so pretty!
It is it's my favorite of all my liners.
I have every single neutral one lol I love my nyx liners!
Loving the brown, goes so well with your nail polish as well!
Thank you!
I like your hair this color. It is so pretty.
Dupe videos are my favorite ones! I love saving money!!❤❤
I love this hair colour for you, it gives you a certain glow. You're gorgeous either way, but as a fellow brunette, I'm partial lol😁💖💖💖💖💖
Love your new hair colour!!!
You should definitely try the KIKO stick eyeshadows (if you can get your hands on that brand), they are gorgeous and low budget! Highly recommend KIKO Milano in general!!! 🥰
I have the e.l.f. No Budge eyeshadow stick in Metallic Mocha. It claims to be a metallic chocolate bronze. But on me, it pulls a bit plum and I actually love it. It has a LOT of depth to it; so maybe try other shades. ❤️
Your hair looks GREAT that color.
Thank you!
I live in Fairfield County CT and the weather the past couple of weeks has just been insane. Today it was like 50 when I left and almost 80 when I got home
LA Girl has eyeshadow primer sticks. I like them, check them out.
I will. Thank you!
Hair looks sooooo good!!!
Thank you :)
I just purchased the sigma eyeshadow stick in Ignite because you & Robert welsh rave about it
This is so great, I love dupes videos! You should do a tutorial with half the face originals and half the face with dupes! 😍
Loving your darker hair Kelly!!
I love these type of videos. I would love to see the Blue Bare Minerals palette vs Nabla blue palette because they look similar
love this video and the new hair color!! you always look stunning! also I just wanted to say that I personally find that the catrice palette is an even closer dupe to the ND mini nude
Dupe/ alternative videos are great. Thank you
Ahhhh I own both the UD and Colourpop shadow and you’re right they are soooo close. I like that Ritz has a little bit more back pigment but honestly I bought Ritz hoping it would be a bit cooler toned than space cowboy. I want to use it with my taupe crease colors
I have been wanting the Sigma Eyeshadow Primer Stick for awhile now, but have been avoiding it because I didn't want to shell out so much for it. Thank you for recommending an affordable dupe!! 😁
Love your Fall hair vibes by the way 😊
Love your videos Kelly! The hair is gorgeous. :) I just got the NYX Jumbo pencil in Frosting last week - it is soooo good! I especially like to use it on my inner corner because for some reason I can never get powder shadow to stay there. I also like it in the water line. I need more shades...
omg your hair is absolutely beautiful !! you look incredible
Kelly I´m on a buying ban but I want to go to Douglas to get NYX stuff. Also I think that Catrice 5 in a Box palette that pink version is similar to elf Bize size palette in shade Rose Water. It might be like an European dupe
Your hair is always stunning❤
Thank you :)
I adore your hair that color!
Thank you!
Loving your new color! I just did a level 6 reddish brown semi and love it!
love the hair color!!!!
Thank you!!
I wish we could get this stuff in Australia. We have Flower Beauty, Nyx, Essence and ELF but the range is extremely limited and we don't have Catrice at all!! There really aren't many options for cruelty free in the drugstore price range here except for those I mentioned and Covergirl, as well as a few aussie brands.
Blonde Kelly, brunette Kelly…I just love Kelly! I am so excited to have some Kelly videos to binge watch, as I’ve been busy getting ready to move to another state soon and keep falling asleep as soon as I have some downtime. I appreciate a good drugstore dupe way more than I used to, so im super excited about this video.
I keep forgetting about those essence mini palettes, I have to pick some up! One of the things that has me so excited about where I am moving is that the Walgreens closest to my new place has so many more makeup brands than the Walgreens that’s close to me now! 😂
Kelly, have you ever tried the brand Chella Beauty? They are known for their brow products mostly, but in the last few years they branched out a little more and they came out with a gorgeous neutral palette and made it available in the most adorable mini quad and then a few months ago came out with another mini quad in rosey tones. The first one was brown tones. Anyway, I would love to see your thoughts on both of their mini palettes because I think you’d really like them. Aside from being super adorable, they are so buttery smooth and just stunning little palettes that I think are underrated gems! If you like a mini palette, these might be the smallest little palettes I’ve ever seen! The palettes come in two sizes and the bigger size isn’t that big, so if you check them out, make sure you’re looking for the super mini quads. I have never gone through an entire eyeshadow palette, but I have hit pan in every single shade in the first quad with the brown shades. I wish I could just pick them up and send them to you!!! 💕💕💕
I love the hair! So bouncy, healthy and beautiful, tutorial please!
You're hair looks amazing! Love the color on you! Kisses from Brazil
Thank you!
YOUR HAIR LOOKS AMAZINGGGGGG!
Beautiful hair! 😍😍😍
Thank you!
Love the darker hair! 🍁🍂
7:25 The NYX pencils don’t have a sharpener in the bottom 😢
In future could you label what you’re swatching on screen? Like which one is the dupe etc
Loooooove the hair❤️
Thank you!
Love the hair color...what dye did you use?
I said it in your other video testing out CP Ritz and you really need to just lightly press it over your other eyeshadow you're topping and not swipe it. It will look almost identical to UD that way!
Good tip! Thank you!
Try the other Elf colors! I have 5 or 6 and I have that champagne one and it's different than the others! All the other metallic ones are actually metallic! They're so good!
That’s good to know. Thank you!
That hair color is the one I was thinking of doing!!!! What product did you use???
Try Kiko Milano eyeshadow sticks as a dupe for Sigma ☺️
That Urban Decay single also reminds me of the Ulta Maple Pecan, at least from what I'm seeing.
Your hair looks GORGEOUS!!!!!!!! I think you should keep it like this.
Your hair omg 😍
Holy cow those nailses. Nice! Please do a brown semipermanent hair color video soon!
when you swatch the lip liners what order did you swatch them? are they swatched in the order you’re holding them at 2:22- CT on top and NYX on bottom?
Yes the CT is on top!
I have Ritz and I use it constantly. Great shadow. Colourpop always has sales too, so save ur coins ladies! 💟💗
Yes, wait for a sale!
Your hair looks gorgeous!
Could you tell where you got your necklace? I enjoy your videos. 😊
Love your hair
I love your new hair color 😍
Thank you!
i loveeee your hair!!! i always love when you go brunette. 💚💚💚
Thank you!
I think you should keep you're hair brown! It looks so good with your eyes and skin tone, so pretty!
I find the turn of phrase "carve out your eye" to be upsettingly graphic.
You're making me want to dye my hair for fall! This is a stupid question... can anyone go back to their natural hair easily? I'm 42 y/o and I've always been scared to dye my blonde hair because I don't know if I can ever go back to my natural hair. Can I dye my hair for fall? 🍂
Never dyed my hair but from what I have heard and seen, blonde hair is high maintenance. Of course you can go back to your original hair color but would suggest talking to a hairstylist/colorist to understand your options.
It depends on the dye! Hair dye comes in semi-permanent, demi-permanent, and permanent. Semi is a temporary color and *should* fade all the way out. Some colors (especially fashion colors like blue) last longer though and might need to be stripped to be removed.
First time subscriber, can you please write down the dupes in the description?
Hey Donna! Thanks for watching. The dupes are in the description. I always link the products that I discuss :)
I always say if Cheap S* works it aint Cheap S* - "dupe" or not Rimmel is still my fave Mascara
With the Charlotte Tilbury and NYX lip liners, the NYX one doesn't set down and the CT one does. The CT one has a nicer undertone in my opinion and the application and lasting power is way better so I honestly think it's worth the money! I have several of the NYX liners and I'm not a fan, they are super stiff and kinda hurt my lips to get them on.
Kelly is sweating at 77 and I’m just wishing it would get that cool where I live 🥲😂
Hey I know this is Kelly’s TH-cam and I love her so much but does anyone watch Andrea Matilliano and if so what happened to her? Is she ok? I think the last time she posted was like 2 weeks ago. I hope she’s ok although I respect any social media influencer who needs a break or leaves altogether. Her and Kelly are my favorite and I watch them religiously.
I was a bit disappointed that so many of these were not exact dupes. That’s what I usually expect from videos advertising dupes.
Hi! The title says “dupes and alternatives” :)
Once I discovered NYX Lipliners…. I’ll never buy a high end lipliner again, ever.
Brunettes have fun too! 😉
💜🎃💜
Sorry, but I think Catrice might have copied the packaging of the Natasha Denona minis, but the actual shadows don’t compare at all. You get what you’re paying for. I own the Mini Nude and bought the Catrice version at release (and decluttered it soon afterwards). Catrice has chunky, glittery shimmers that don’t apply well and need glitter glue, the mattes blend away and don’t layer well, become muddy.
Personally, I just want a product that’s hassle free and just works. Eyeshadows (and foundations) have never been something that Catrice has been doing well in my opinion. Their clean beauty range is even worse.
😘❤️🩹
💖💙💜
Your hair and nails are gorgeous. Take yourself out on a date.
Thank you! :)
I love your hair!
Thank you!