Brahms: Symphony No. 3 with Alan Gilbert | NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 มี.ค. 2021
- Brahms' Third Symphony is full of "mysterious magic" and "poetry", as Clara Schumann put it. Listen to the concert recording of the NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester with Alan Gilbert in the Elbphilharmonie Hamburg.
JOHANNES BRAHMS
Symphony No. 3 in F major op.90
I. Allegro co brio 0:18
II. Andante 14:00
III. Poco Allegretto 22:16
IV. Allegro 28:23
Alan Gilbert, conductor
NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester
Excerpt from the concert recording from February 28, 2020, Elbphilharmonie Hamburg - เพลง
The turning around between the second and third movement showed how easy Alan was. Definitely a one-breath performance; a birth of "cool" performance. It has to be released on CD!
Thank you for sharing!
I can think of one word that comes to mind when listening to this great symphony that is 'inspiring". Great performance by all. Bravo...
Thank you! Much appreciated! :))
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten Tönen aller Instrumente. Der dritte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt melodisch. Der intelligente und geniale Maestro dirigiert das perfekt tranierte Orchester im fließenden doch gut betrachteten Tempo und mit sorgfältig kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrlich hörenswert!
Wir danken herzlich!
What a great performance of this wonderful symphonie.
Thank you so much!
참으로 훌륭한 영상입니다. 고맙습니다.
Thank you~!!
It's a pleasure sharing with you! Thank you for joining us!
How good was that! Unreal.
Thank you so much!!
Magnifique, merci.
Bravissimo! 🎶👏👏
Thank you very much. That was a masterful performance by everyone involved and I enjoyed it very much. The acoustics in that hall sound amazing
It is!! You have to come and visit - one day we'll be back with audience. Thank you!
@@NDRKlassik You read my mind, yes one day I hope very much to visit Hamburg to hear you all perform live. That would be amazing!
Yes! We are looking forward to it! And to playing for a live audience once again.
BEAUTIFUL !!! BRAVISSIMO !!!
Thank you so much! :)
Tom Dengler tends to be something of too carping a critic, but he does allow that Alan Gilbert is a very great conductor. One does not get to the Elbphilharmonie without being exactly that! As others have commented in this corner, I too have not yet been to the Elbphilharmonie (Wiesbaden is not exactly "um die Ecke"!), but this recording/performance does indeed display a very presentable acoustical quality, and I still hope to personally witness it someday. Dengler also said that Gilbert could use "charisma lessons"; I could name a very big name (but will not) heavily associated with "charisma," and I for one do not agree. One is walking on very thin ice with something like that...and it is the MUSIC and it's performance and interpretation that ultimately count most. This Brahms #3 is anyway an exemplary achievement. I thank NDR again. JAT
Thank you for your kind words, they are much appreciated! :) And, yes, please come and visit one day!!
19:44 😢😢😢👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏
😊
Great performance! When was this?
On February, 28th, 2020. Our last concert before the first lockdown here in Germany.
Tut mir leid, aber da finde ich Günter Wand 35 Jahre zuvor und mit dem gleichen Orchester um Längen besser.
Günter Wand gelingt es meiner Meinung nach bei Brahms, das extreme Spannungsfeld zwischen strenger Form und gleichzeitig großen Emotionen besonders deutlich werden zu lassen. Durch eine minutiös abgestufte Dynamik, die penible Befolgung von Vortragsanweisungen, das Aufeinanderhören und gegenseitige Korrespondieren aller Orchesterstimmen und -gruppen erreicht Wand bei Brahms einerseits eine strukturelle Klarheit und andererseits eine scharfe Charakterzeichnung des emotionalen Gehalts der einzelnen Sätze bzw. Satzabschnitte. Nichts wirkt bei ihm wolkig, wattig oder gar schwammig.
Wenn man nur den Anfang der Dritten bei Wand und Gilbert vergleicht, dann sorgt die extreme Spannung der ersten drei Akkorde bei Wand für eine leidenschaftliche Explosion des vollen Orchesters, während es bei Gilbert eher wie ein "Explosiönchen", wie gebremster Schaum klingt.
Hi & danke für das differenzierte Feedback! Auch für Vergleiche und Austausch darüber sind Kanäle wie dieser ein Segen.
Oh, das ist beneidenswert, daß Sie live die große Kunst von Maestro Wand erlebt haben!
where's the best fish sandwich in Hamburg?
Great performance of a hometown composer (It's not Vienna).
Indeed!! 🤩
"Concert recording from February 28, 2020." So, this was right before the pandemic. I hear the 4th movement telling, "That's it for now, folks. See you again. Take care."
This symphony always reminds me "Do you like Brahms?" movie, which I saw fifty-some years ago. I don't remember anything except for the 3rd movement leaking out from the hall when the boy follows (or, leads?) the girl on a beautiful staircase. I want to see the movie again.
@charlie Kim
I seemed to remember this movie was based on a novel of Sagan’s : Aimez-Vous Brahms? But I never saw it!
Envy you!
Yes. Our last concert before the pandemic got here. It's been more than a year now ...
THOSE APPLAUSE ARE STRANGE. THE WINDS OVERPOWERED THE STRINGS AT THE END.
GILBERT IS A NEW YORK BOY AND A VERY GREAT CONDUCTOR. HE HAS BEEN GIVEN THE NEW YORK HEAVE HO AND HE'LL PROBABLY GET THE SAME FROM HAMBURG. HE NEEDS CHARISMA LESSONS (???).
I once heard an Orchestral Player say " This guy can wave his arms all he wants he is getting the same performance !
This is either a joke or said by an incredibly unprofessional individual.
TRY RAISING THE PODIUM 6 INCHES AND MOVE IT BACK A FOOT.
ITLS NOT AS GOOD AS THE NYPO. MAYBE ALAN SHOULD WEAR A TIE AND LEARN TO SPEAK GERMAN. SOME N.Y. AUDIO ENGINEERS COULD HELP TOO.
He does speak German, he picked it up quickly! :)
Maybe you've got a problem with your earphones? The sound is excellent very realistic.
On behalf of our sound engineers: thank you!
I'm 100% sure that the Hamburg orchestra is much finer than the NYPO!
You gotta be kidding me. The sound is fantastic. These engineers do a great job. I grew up watching PBS broadcasts of NYP. No way they can beat the Hamburg sound engineers. I'm grateful there's no paywall for these broadcasts. NYC the center of the universe, I know..how trite Tom.