ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Hoi4 Alternate History: What if The Ottomans Were COMPETENT in WW1?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ค. 2024
- This is a trick question actually, can you figure out why?
Travel to Germany with me trovatrip.com/trip/europe/ger...
Travel to Peru with me trovatrip.com/trip/south-amer...
We organize our MP games here:
Discord: / discord
Twitch: / stakuyi
Check the podcast and other platforms for more content here:
Podcast: historyofeverythingpodcast.com/
Patreon: / stakuyi
Try my very own coffee
tablowroastingco.com/products...
MY FRIENDS! Do you want to play hoi4 with me? Join us in discord in the description. We play every Saturday at 10am eastern. Other games are played too on different days
No
@@SinkingInTheSinkthat’s cool
@@stakuyi sir are you a sigma you were mogging us so hard in this video you have to be
the sickman is cured stakuyi is the new sick man
Unfortunate how the game is cancelled
What if there was no October Revolution
Than it'd be a stronger soviet union + trotsky would be even weaker
@@Lp-army1 how would there be a soviet union in the first place if there was no Russian civil war?
@@arataxbogiax9Lenin formed the soviet union not stalin
@@arataxbogiax9On 28 December 1922, a conference of plenipotentiary delegations from the Russian SFSR, the Transcaucasian SFSR, the Ukrainian SSR, and the Byelorussian SSR approved the Treaty on the Creation of the USSR and the Declaration of the Creation of the USSR, forming the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. These two documents were confirmed by the first Congress of Soviets of the USSR and signed by the heads of the delegations, Mikhail Kalinin, Mikhail Tskhakaya, Mikhail Frunze, Grigory Petrovsky, and Alexander Chervyakov, on 30 December 1922. The formal proclamation was made from the stage of the Bolshoi Theatre in Moscow.
The civil war was (contrary to popular belief) started by the white army after the Soviet coup, so technically without that the would have been much stronger
What if the allies declared war on the Soviets after the Invasion of Poland believing they are allied with Germany
You should watch possible history they have a video on that
@911DailyForNow ill check that out thanks
@@911DailyForNow What exactly is the video called?
@@maxbeast8834
This is not a joke. What if World War II was a three way
@@Collin790 that’s pretty cool but would our favorite hoi4 alternate history TH-camr agree to it
What if Archduke Franz Ferdinand wasn’t assassinated and lead Austria-Hungary?
Wasnt as in there wasn't an attempt? Or there was an attempt bc if they attempted assassination than the war would Still start if there wasn't an attempt and Austria Hungary survived we'd see a federation
Dreams of a Danubian federation are delusional concepts by elites to say the least, there is no reason for any minority to be in favor of, even just accept the Austrian rule and it would still collapse eventually
ww1 would still happen... altho maybe a little tiny bit later, but everyone was already preparing for war, the assassination was just the excuse to start it
@@Lp-army1They probably thought of the assassinations never being planned because they did not say that the assassinations failed
@@Reminiscence_Bacon 👍
What if Qing China never collapsed and fixed itself before/during WW1?
👍
Yes definitely do this if you’re reading this Stak.
Power house
That's hard because Qing China is such a Shit Show it wouldn't be effective anyway
The british: so, i guess you want a third Opium War then@getsomeboy321
What if Czechoslovakia refused to give up Sudetenland
this could be nicely rolled into a "What if the Little Entente hadn't collapsed"
They'd been steam rolled over and got no western support, as the Brits and French had already appeased/granted them to the Germans. Unless they somehow knew, the west would sell them out and stayed with an eastern alliance with Romania.
Gets invaded anyway
Well thats boring, they'd still lose.
@benreynolds5433 would still cost troops and equipment plus the checks had these crazy mountain forts that definitely would have slowed the german advance
What if the Pinkertons never went after the Dutch Van Der Linde gang
No red dead games.
you're my brother
Stayuki: I'm here to show how a competent Ottoman Empire would act during World War I
Franz Ferdinand: I'm about to do what the kid's call a pro-gamer move.
As the Archduke survives, he and city residents are terrified when they all of a sudden start hearing air horns, techno music, and gamers screaming into their mics😂 oh don’t forget the COD hitmarker even though Ferdinand wasn’t actually hit in this scenario
@@andrewp8284 In the distance, like an epigraph from Hell itself, a tall skinny Somalian-looking man in baggy clothes dances with his hands twirling, and smoking a large cigar, as air horns blare. 420 is blazoned across the sky to a stupefied public.
What if, for one time only, Stakuyi got to pick the scenario he really wanted to play out?
What if the the secret peace between austria hungary and entente powers was successeful
What if Germany honored the Molotov- Ribbentrop pact, and continued their efforts against the Allies?
Soviets break it instead, in my experience.
@@KarasuInaigain your experience, bro what experience do you have, where is yo Time Machine
Soviets have a break the pact focus they always go for if Germany doesn't break it first
they can't. They just emptied out their whole oil, unless they open to trade (to soviet union or middle east if its not blockaded/embargoed). one of the reason they invaded the soviet was a hope to capture the Caucasus oil.
@@hakku9344They were trading oil from the Soviets
What if the Kerensky offensive succeeded and Kerensky stayed in power? (Great War redux)
The kerensky offensive would have succeded if it wasnt started.
Good one mate it could have only succeeded in hoi4@@FortuneZer0
What if the Indian Rebellion of 1857 actually succeeded and kicked the British out of the subcontinent?
Everything will probably fall apart after the British leave due to infighting
What if the United States joined the Central Powers?
What do you think would drive the US to join the central powers ? Three term W.Wilson ?
@@Omega343666I think this is the farthest reaching thought, but hear me out:
The German Empire becomes a democracy based on the US and establishes friendly terms with the US by trading, and giving support to things like the Spanish-American War. To gain even further sympathy, Germany could try the Bismarck strategy, and smke it seem like the triple Entente declared war on them. Germany would stay away from doing war Crimes and crimes against Humanity, so the large German population within the US would sway the government to support Germany.
This of course is as realistic as the Romans finding alien technology and conquering the planet with lazers, even if this all happened the US would most likely stay truly neutral instead of joining Germany.
What if Ireland joined the axis powers in World War II?
Would capitulate immediately there’s no passing of English Channel and English motherland was protected enough inspite of what paradox devs believe
If that happened they would turn fascist and stay neutral just like spain
Why would they do that?
@@CombatMagic a higher nationalistic government could do so in order to gain revenge against their long time oppressors the UK
@@CombatMagicMainly for seeing a possible reunification with northern ireland and revenge against the british
Still seems too far fetched to me, but with enough propaganda a far right government in Ireland could have gotten enough public support for the reunification war effort and joined the axis after seeing Germany's victory in France?
What if Puyi tried to get his throne back?
He did try he failed
@@Lp-army1 he clearly was trying to imply success
@@josephstalingaming9672 than why the try part try doesn't imply success
@@Lp-army1He was put on the throne by a monarchist officer. He didn't put the plan together.
What if Sweden and Finland united when faced with the German and Soviet threats?
extremely unrealistic
@@jes3d yeah the ottomans being competent is also very unrealistic
Cock and balls union
@@jaxon1913. well its atleast somewhat believable, finland and sweden isnt though, especially on the finnish side cause they have a history of being occupied by sweden, and are culturally and linguistically separate
Neither of these countries had german threats
Can the Sick man be cured? idk because I haven't watched the video
Well it would've been cured if the game would've recognized the Ottoman gains in the war
It would have had he actually tried to help his allies and intentionally hold on Egypt's border.
I really like how you give context for what if’s. It really sets the stage for what will happen, and I am an absolute history lover. In my opinion, to answer a “what-if” question, you have to answer the questions “how and why did (something) happen” and “why and how did (historical change) happen?”. If you don’t ask and answer these questions, then the what-if question is harder to answer.
What if Trotsky took over after Lenin
Thanks for the video man,i was waiting for this.have a good day and health.
What if Mexico reclaimed its lost territories from the US during WW1?
They'd die
@@Lp-army1 no shit its a what if
@@josephstalingaming9672 looking at what stayuki does he tries to keep some form of realism like this video he states he won't be able to control the Balkans and Libya so these scenarios need to be atleeast some form if realistic for stayuki to even do
@@Lp-army1😂
@@Lp-army1yeah its impossible the british blockade is just too strong for the germanys allience request even reach mexico
What if Austria-Hungary came back in ww2?
When most hungarians didnt want to aswell, only a habsburg austria would be in place (hitler didnt like the habsburgs and despiced them)
@@rabioliman2lol602 well we could see hitler place a puppet regime in austria-hungary in order to support his wars, as also a large trading partner, for oil.
In alternate timeline with alternate stakuyi doing video about Hoi4 Alternate History: What if The Ottomans Were INCOMPETENT in WW1?
What if Nuclear Weaponry was discovered/created more rapidly(Earlier in the war or even Pre-WW2)
Eyyy, I was really excited for this one! Thanks for making it!
What if MacArthur got his way during the Korean war
Attempt 2: (Using the Great War Redux again) What if Italy honored the Triple Alliance and eventually joined the Central Powers when WWI comes around?
What if the Soviets won the cold war? Do this in 1973 scenario in the Cold War Iron Curtain Mod.
If you want the soviets to win the Cold War you would have to start right from the start of the USSR, making them more democratic-federalized, otherwise there is no way for the oppressive and authoritarian communist regime to keep power
Us would be dissolved and communism rule just like what happened in our timeline with soviets
What if Mexico accepted Germany's proposal for help against America?
That’s suicide, look up the Mexican civil war
What if the Allies never declared war on Hitler after invading Poland
What if the second Mexican empire and its backers intervened in the American civil war?
They would have to occupy all of Mexico first, in real life, the French were never able to conquer all of the country.
Stakuyi one thing about the history of the ottomans. Sultan abdulhamid was purged away before 1910 by the young turks and he was on the way of uniting the empire which was fragmenting by nationalism. If he had stayed in power a united ottoman empire may have won the war but more likely would have not even participiated in ww1 because it only participated because of enver pasha who let german ships to bomb russian ports trough the bosphorus and supplied them with the ottoman flags to force the rest of the pashas who did not want to participate to go into war
Day idfk "What if Germany was unified earlier?"(Hoi4 empire mod; play as Prussia)
This poses an interesting question for the next scenario...What if Franz Ferdinand had survived his assassination attempt?
Video #2 - What if the United Arab Republic was a success? (Egypt/Cold War mod)
Video 19 of asking stakuyi to play as the Katzenartig Imperium in equestria at war
It is an april fools collaboration between the devs from EaW and the devs from the stellaris mod Gigastructural Engineering, the nation is the kingdom of abyssinia, you play as Kaiser Kattail, who has just arrived from another reality and attempts to take over the world utilizing his knowledge of mechanized warfare and megastructures to give his empire a gigantic edge.
(for his focus tree to show up, you have to enable it at the game rules menu at the bottom)
What if japan managed to destory the US Carrier Fleet at pearl harbor and then defeat them again at midway
What if Stakuyi plays East Coast Rebirth
What if Trotsky came into power in the USSR?
"The sick man was no longer sick...achooo!" Jeez, that sneeze got me nearly spurting out my drink. x'D
Bless you from germany :D
Thank you for doing this topic!
I would love a follow-up to this video where you take us through the alt-history possibilities of WW2.
What if Nicolai II kept power in Russia?
If I could have watched these vids back in school, I would have rocked in History class. I didn't really like history back in the day, but I enjoy it now. Plus, we mixin it with gaming, which makes it more fun.
What have been waiting for this
Hey Stak, there is a lesson to be had in this: SAVE, save in every key moment so that you don't have to reset again.
What if Finland held all of their territories during the winter war and didn't sign the peace deal
What if Stakuyi's was in WW2? (How would you implement this, where would he start, how is he even in any position of power in WW2, idk. I just think it would be funny to see him try to explain and justify this on video :))
Video like 5 of asking anything for Finland in Base Game doing anything
What if Germany never lost any land after WW1
A democratic government and no ww2 (no ww2 technology)
What if Argentina had a GREAT economy (victoria 3 or HOI4)
new drinking game, every time stakuyi says "simultaneously", take a drink
we have no chance
22:30 and here is where we see the butterfly effect in action
Nice touch there putting Ataturk's picture when you imply compotent ottomans
Now I had a idea involving India, like "what if they managed to resist British rule and fight back for their autonomy?" Or something like that.
What if Himmler and the SS managed to overthrow moustache man either before or during the early stages of ww2.
It would just be incredibly cool just to see this history continued, but that might need it's own mod with extensive changes to focus trees
Drinking game where every time he says “simultaneously” you take a shot
Dam railway system and it’s dozens of different railway gages
This has probably been done but what if Germany didn't break the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact? and never invaded the USSR?
Love this. Please, make more, feel free to explore other games.
Day 14 of asking Stakuyi to continue playing Kaiserredux A to Z, so he can reach Malta and hopefully plays Mintoff
What if the netherlands became monarchist before ww1 and joined germany to reclaim the benelux
What if Portugal honored the Old Alliance militarily during WW2?
What if D-Day failed? Could they have pushed through Italy or would they just naval invade somewhere else?
Lore of Hoi4 Alternate History: What if The Ottomans Were COMPETENT in WW1? Momentum 100
I love these alternate history episodes.
Operation unthinkable perhaps?
What if italy stayed with the central powers in ww1
What if the Qing Dynasty didn’t collapse. Edit: 16:24 I noticed that Albania got Kosovo, I’m sure that won’t piss off any Serbs.
Great Videa and Great lore which can provide the basis for a mod.
Business plot had been a success
What if the ABDA-com defense was more cohesive and the British managed to hold Singapore?
This is cool! Have you played any games of Old World Blues for these videos?
what if italy joined the central power?
What if Gaddafi managed to unite Africa
Class as per usual
What if WWI started as a result of the Agadir crisis in 1911?
What if warsaw uprising was successful part two WE WANT A SECOND CHANCE PLZ
What if Germany launched operation Barbarossa before dealing with the allies?
Amazing video
What if the Greeks were successful in the Greco-Turkish War (1919-1922)? Good way to flop from onside of the proverbial Mediterranean Sea coin to the other.
overall not a whole lot would realistically change for greece. Greece would of course be in a theoretically better position (debatable due to how devastating the war actually was esspecially for greece compared to what Greece actually obtained) due to winning the conflict but overall much of what happened in our timeline would remain in the one where Greece defeats the Ottoman empire/Turkey. Additionally with a loss in the greco-turkish war The Treaty of Sèvres likely would have remained at least in some capacity.
It only particularly gets interesting in ww2 in which the Turkish/ottoman government would likely be significantly more inclined to join the Axis (with concessions by italy in removing it's zone of control). Of course the Allies still remain victorious in such a timeline albiet the war likely finds itself dragged out by a few months at least but presumably not much more than that.
I can notice the sadness in his voice when the Central Powers lose
What if Herbert Hoover was elected a third term (Kaiserredux)
What if the Nazis focused on building U-boats to fully wipe out British supply lines
You can set a guarantee he either dies or survives in the mod's settings
I'd like to see another challenge video. I don't know the game well enough for a good challenge, maybe try to survive as Poland in WW2?
What if South American countries collaborated to a greater extent against the axis. (Brazil or Mexico). Or for the axis (Argentina and chile)
Would love to see the Spanish speaking nations join together to over throw Brazil. And thus, creating their own version of the USA.
What if tanks/ armor were never invented
What if Trotsky overthrew Stalin
Very well explained. It always annoys me how so many people think that the Ottomans just lost every battle and had no strategy at all going into the war
What if the allies immediately declared war against the Soviet Union after the Potsdam conference?
What if Puerto Rico gained independence during its 50’s revolts?🇵🇷
Great job stak.
Yo i hope you have a lot of fun in Peru and Germany if i could i would join you in Germany but i live in the North so i sadly cant join.
Still hope you have a really nice time in my Homecountry.
Good vid stak
what if germany caused scandinavia to unify out of fear from german hostility?
What if Beria got power in the Soviet Union after Stalin died - Cold War Iron Curtain mod
What if Portugal joined the allies once England started getting bombed the Germans due to the old defensive pact they have?
What if the Austro-Hungarian empire survived after a German victory in the Great War?