Ali Dawah: From Curiosity to Conviction: He Discovers His Path to Islam | Season 5, Episode 14
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- In this episode of "Getting There," host Brogan sits down with Ali Dawah, a prominent and polarising figure in the UK Muslim community. They explore Ali's personal journey into Islam, the core meaning of his faith, and the lessons he hopes to share with his children. The conversation delves into topics such as integration within British society and the challenges and opportunities Muslims face in the UK today. Whether you align with Ali’s views or not, this episode offers a unique insight into the beliefs and motivations of one of Islam's most recognisable voices in the West.
I love the curiosity of her. She asks the right questions. May Allah guide us
She explained why there was an uproar about Tommy joining the show, in comparison to Ali. It's likely due to people committing acts of terrorism inspired by Tommy.
After reading the comments, every Muslim who reads them will be grateful to Allah for Islam. Alhamdulillah.
Allah is the fake god
Alhamdulillah
Sunan Ibn Majah 3324
It was narrated that ‘Aishah said:
“My mother was trying to fatten me up when she wanted to send me to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) (when she got married), but nothing worked until I ate cucumbers with dates; then I grew plump like the best kind of plump.”
th-cam.com/video/lzXN6Mv9k8A/w-d-xo.htmlsi=BCUc2SO6lpIjHUUi
th-cam.com/video/58VckD6RoEA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=AutD7JaAJ-M0zDJ9
Alhumdulillah
May Allah guide the woman giving this interview. Held the convo with great respect and open mindedness.
@@OmarLemos22 Muslims talking about mindedness 🤣🤣🤣
@@OmarLemos22 abdul counting his 4th already
@@patriot-g3e Cry about it bro
@ASoul-j4c like aisha did when your prophet Mounted her
@@OmarLemos22Piss be upon you
This is the peaceful debate we want. We want to understand each other rather than believing the media propaganda
@@salmanulfaris7165 what media propaganda your people blowing themselves in daily basis and are threat to national security plus don't blame the media they are the ones that protect you the most Plus don't worry that's why the far right is growing and Winning across Europe
Agreed, but some people like to create division unfortunate.
Great Interview, really opened up my eyes to Islam and Muslims. I will now study Islam, I’ve been looking to fill this void and hoping Islam fills that.
May Allah (God) make it easy for you. Islam is the truth but you have to find it on your own and the best step is off course to read the Quran.
Thanks, that’s the plan.
Study it SINCERILY with an open heart and ignore everything else willing to accept the truth wherever you find it
And most of all prostrate and ask Allah (The God) to guide you❤
good luck brother , may Allah(GOD) guide and protect you
The Muslim Lantern is one of the best channels that talks about Islam
Brother Ali made a slip at 1:46:09 when he said, "In the remembrance of hearts do hearts find peace." What he meant to say was, "In the remembrance of Allah do hearts find peace," as stated in the Quran: Surah Ar-Ra'd vers 28.
Baraka Allahu feek ❤❤
Baarakallahu fiika yaa akhii.
May allah bless you brother! I wouln't have noticed that.
I started drinking at the age of 12/13. I started smoking cigarettes at 18 and a month later i started smoking weed. Shortly after i started with amphetamins. I started drinking during school, during work, i started smoking weed as soon as i wake up… alhamdulillah Allah swt saved me.
May Allah keep you steadfast on the truth and perserve you in this life and the afterlife.
@ thank you my brother. Ive been drug free for 13 years now and cigarettes free for 7 years. I dont need anything except for Allah swt. Im sick my entire life, 20+ surgeries, in pain from morning until night. Inshallah Allah swt grants me some peace in the afterlife, that’s all i need
I'm Jewish but I loved this debate and actually really enjoyed watching it. I saw some videos of Ali Dawah before but didn't know that he wasn't Muslim from birth and that he converted at University age, its very interesting to learn this and to see how much of a transformation he has had and its quite evident that Islam has had a positive impact on him. I believe that most Muslims in the UK are very nice people and we all get on with each other Jews, Muslims , Christians and atheists.
Thanks for the comment. It’s true
OPEN MINDED
As a muslim I've always wished I had more Jewish friends. We seem to be closer theologically than we are to Christians. Lots of common ground really
Great comment, we have so much in common as mentioned in the interview, it’s all about building bridges!
@@hamsam789Yes but they would never truly be your friends, if you read into there religious texts. It’s clear what they think of others outside there tribe, they literally get interest free loans.
Tell me another group of people that get to enjoy having interest free loans? They have massive advantages in life compared to others….
Great interview, as a young British Muslim glad to see these points are openly addressed. We can most definitely all co-exist and prosper peacefully and move past the misinformation and propaganda against Islam. Much respect to Ali and the host! 👍
@@selovayzh3853 coexist and prosperous No you don't that's why Minorities are treated at its worse in your countries second let's not talk about attacks and all plus that happened 2 days ago in America is well
@@selovayzh3853 misinformation huh when your brother's does 💥 themselves the media simply reports it so dont play victim card
This interviewer is very open minded. May Allah guide her❤
Amin i mean ameen its pronounced not amin i'm mistaken
She has announced her conversion today
@@niceguy6152u alright lad?
@@ryan6140 Muslims talking about open minded when you guys are the biggest brainwashed cult
@@niceguy6152 who again
I'm sorry Ali, I was wrong about you and misjudged you unfairly. You are an articulate beautiful Muslim man and I wish the very best for you and your family.
As for Brogan, I never watched a pod of hers before, but she is an excellent interviewer and has a very open mind, I pray that she is guided towards the truth.
أسأل الله العظيم رب العرش العظيم أن يهدي كل من يستمع الى هذا البودكاست الى الاسلام وان يجمعنا كلنا في جنات النعيم ، ربنا آتنا في الدنيا حسنة وفي الآخرة وقنا عذاب النار
I've really enjoyed this conversation, and Brogan was really respectful, and you could tell she genuinely wanted to learn.
As a Muslim I loved this!! The whole interview was conducted so respectfully and open minded. It’s SO refreshing watching two people of different faiths have dialogue like this ❤ Much respect to the host 🫡
Most comments here have no clue about Islam. Great conversation.
I do!
That the best part, maybe someone will look into Islam and read with an open heart, Inshallah
@@proudzanzibarian3134 What do you think about Allah sending black people to HELL?
(4c)Chapter: Belief in the Divine Decree - Section 3(4c)باب الإيمان بالقدر - الفصل الثالث
Abud Darda' reported God’s messenger as saying, “God created Adam when He created him and struck his right shoulder and brought forth his offspring white like small ants. And he struck his left shoulder and brought forth his offspring black as though they were charcoal. Then He said to the party on his right side, ‘To paradise, and I do not care’ and He said to the party in his left shoulder, ‘To hell, and I do not care’.”
Ahmad transmitted it.
Grade: Isnād Hasan (Zubair `Aliza'i) صَحِيح (الألباني) حكم :
إسنادہ حسن (زبیر علی زئی)
Reference : Mishkat al-Masabih 119
In-book reference : Book 1, Hadith 112
@@proudzanzibarian3134 (39)Chapter: Giving one's young children in marriage(38)باب إِنْكَاحِ الرَّجُلِ وَلَدَهُ الصِّغَارَ
Narrated `Aisha:
that the Prophet (ﷺ) married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death).
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 5133
In-book reference : Book 67, Hadith 69
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 7, Book 62, Hadith 64
@@DaveZee823 paul-e-theists don't. they twist Islam.
Islam is the true religion that has never been changed since its revelation..Even ChatGPT says it would follow Islam
Chat GPT? Hahahahaha!
Ask Sheikh-GPT about satanic verses :)
Lol these non muslims always make up excuses. Just look at the comments. Calling chat gpt Muslim lol delusional polythiests😂
ChatGPT is clearly programmed by humans who are politically correct and cautious about the potential consequences.It’s evident that ChatGPT was developed by individuals who prioritize political correctness and are wary of possible repercussions.
@@ugandan216there are none, you can fabricate Hadith all you want, but at the end of the day, they’re still lies
Invite this guy back soon. He cleared allot of the misconceptions that I had about this religion.
Absolutely glad you felt that way.
If you still have questions I recommend the Muslim lantern channel he usually have some live stream in TH-cam discussing with non-Muslim
I would recommend looking into his TH-cam channel
This HAVE TO BEE one of the best podcasts i have ever listened to. I am awfully impressed by both of u and proud to recommend this to all my muslim and non muslim peers and even my teachers ❤
The fact that he wasn't a muslim before and he converted to islam puts most born muslims to shame
@@drawsaf3339 It puts humanity to shame
True, but it just shows them difference between someone seeing religion as sth obvious or as part of culture or family and someone who really experienced it, who really changed his life and is able to compare life before and after religion and who really CHOSE the religion for himself and studied it
Yas my family are Muslims but im stil learning......!!@@FrankeNamensKarim
@@maabalsheakh same. I was once a "liberal muslim", especially as a teenager, but I became more interested in religion and became more and more religious hmdl
@@FrankeNamensKarim that is nice
We need more Muslim speakers on shows and podcasts like this, like Muhammad Hijab, Hamza Tzorzist, sheikh Usman etc, so that we can decrease the gap between Muslims and the west... Afterall Islam is for the whole humanity, May Allah guide us all towards the beauty of Islam... A big Thanks from Belgium sister...
Regardless of all the uninformed comments, salute to the lady who invited Ali for an open dialogue and to answer her questions. Keep asking dear sister
I really liked this! Part 2 with Ali Dawah!
Islam makes the most sense to me
Are you already a muslim?
@@ShadiRahallShadiRahallGood luck th-cam.com/video/0yeZETaApkM/w-d-xo.htmlsi=P5RQLmhwlST1k5tY
@@ShadiRahallShadiRahall Does the sun setting in a spring of blazing hot mud make sense to you?
@@ShadiRahallShadiRahall does a 53 year old man marrying a 6 year old make sense to you 😆
@@DaveZee823 lol ok I’ll bite, what does that even mean, and what is the correlation with Islam.
وما ارسلناك الا رحمة للعالمين
And We have not sent you, [O Muhammad], except as a mercy to the worlds. Quran 21:107
OMG amazing explanation I was revert Muslim 1 year ago ❤ i love it islam isn't issue married open your eyes and heart how many peoples drinks alcohol smoking drag sleep street 😪
@@jemilseid7385 Why did you convert to Islam?
Irony when your own prophet did worse things
@@DaveZee823 Why would she do it for any other reason than that she found it to be the truth from her lord, our lord, Allah?
@@toshio-tamura But, did she fully study Islam BEFORE becoming a Muslim? If she had studied before, she would never have converted.
(23)Chapter: Green clothes(23)باب ثِيَابِ الْخُضْرِ
Narrated `Ikrima:
Rifa`a divorced his wife whereupon `AbdurRahman bin Az-Zubair Al-Qurazi married her. `Aisha said that the lady (came), wearing a green veil (and complained to her (Aisha) of her husband and showed her a green spot on her skin caused by beating). It was the habit of ladies to support each other, so when Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) came, `Aisha said, "I have not seen any woman suffering as much as the believing women. Look! Her skin is greener than her clothes!"
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 5825
In-book reference : Book 77, Hadith 42
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 7, Book 72, Hadith 715
@@DaveZee823 Dude I went to that hadith. You cherry picked a part of it, to give it a very anti Islamic narrative. This is how propaganda is created.
May Allah guide this sister as she has a genuine kind heart from what I can see .
It was an absolutely intriguing conversation. Please invite more Muslims like Ali.
I liked the host. She was kind and curious. I subscribed to follow future videos. Ali Dawah is a knowledgeable brother. And Islam is very beautiful. Actually, eventhou its hard to swallow this acknowledgment for a westerner, it has all the solutions to our problems in the west
@@RomeoSuvar all solution none of your countries aren't even better than new zealand let alone other west no thank you
Thank you Madam, for bringing Muslim for learning about my religion
This was a great discussion. Very professional podcast, great host and great guest.
Thank you for sharing the link Ali.
Haven't seen you in a while Sir.
We need part 2 !!!! Get it scheduled!!!!!!
Yesss
With polygamy, it's good to bear in mind that pre-Islam, people would marry way more than four women. So essentially, Islam capped it at four, and even capped it at one, if you can't treat them with justice. Abraham and Solomon had multiple wives in Christianity too.
Furthermore, if you really don't want to share your husband, you just add that as a clause in the marriage contract.
"If you fear you might fail to give orphan women their ˹due˺ rights ˹if you were to marry them˺, then marry other women of your choice-two, three, or four. But if you are afraid you will fail to maintain justice, then ˹content yourselves with˺ one.."
Why did muhammad have much more than 4 wives?
Thank you for your question ❤️. It is good to remember that for most of the married life of Prophet Muhammad (May Peace be Upon Him) he was married to only one woman, Khadijah RA. She was older than him and a widow.
Later on, after her passing away 25 years later, he then had several other marriages, essentially all his other marriages except one were with elder or divorcees.
From amongst the wisdom of these marriages is that they bought tribes closer together, they also increased the number of female teachers of Islam who experienced and could relate the actions and sayings of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). If you have any more sincere questions, feel free to ask, or if you would like to speak to me elsewhere, let me know.
@lightningbolt321Masha Allah brother,you have answered very respectfully as how a good Muslim should,thank you.
@@ris21imperial and since when did Solomon or David became the moral of conduct for Christians again
@@ris21imperial OK since when did david and Solomon became the moral of conduct of Christians again
May Allah bless you Ali 🤲🏻
May Allah guide all of those who watch the podcast and us as well 🤲🏻
may allah guide our kurdish nation😢
Much respect for Brogan. She has a genuine interest, and held the interview with respect and open mindedness. May God guide us all.
"..and you will find the nearest of them in affection to the believers those who say, "We are Christians." That is because among them are priests and monks and because they are not arrogant." - Quran 5:82
We have so much in common, more than many people can imagine. I hope more and more discussions like this happen.
I really like how you are honest in learning what really he believes
Inshallah this is a good start to learn more about Islam
The beauty of Islam shines through. Ali Dawah did a great job highlighting it.
@@shakeels6982 beauty 🤣🤣🤣
@@shakeels6982 beauty huh
You got a problem with that?@@patriot-g3e
Thanks to Brother Ali Dawah for explaining Islam and the word justice. And thanks to the lady and this podcast that has initiated to this. May Allah guide her and her husband and May Allah bless brother Ali❤
I really enjoyed watching this
May Allah the almighty open the hearts of the ignorant ❤️
ALHAMDULILAH for islam i never feel alone without my faith and i know my purpose and its peace in this chaotic world
The host is genuinely open minded good hearted. Great host.
I loved this podcast and the way Ali handled the answers was amazing so I wish more power to him. And I ask Allah as well to guide the lady to Islam who arrange the interview, big respect for her ✌🏻
Just finished watching, woow amazing podcast with ali dawah, new subscriber here, please get mohammed hijab also on the podcast his excellent
Despite the propaganda and Islamophobia, Islam is growing and is now the most popular religion in places like Japan and the UK. Indeed, the truth can't be hidden.
@@ilmemaab3171 Japan another false claim and no in UK it is mass immigrations from Pakistan Bangladesh india ETC
No it is not growing it is only mass immigrations
@@patriot-g3e i've looked into your other comments it's all BS and i hope you have better things to do than to hate.
It’s growing because you are invading other countries because of weak leadership. In centuries past you would have been dealt with appropriately. Clear to see you are incompatible with western civilisation as everyone wants you gone but yet you stick around and are not forced out because of our weak leadership
Amazing interview But the fact that Brogan was so fixated on the attacker on the Southport incident being a Muslim. AFTER Ali Dawah and even her partner at some point informed her he was not Muslim, was really disheartening to see. Props to Ali Dawah for handling the situation professionally it was quite impressive and his patience was superb.
FYI, the Southport attacker was a 17-year-old British-born boy. The police didn't want to reveal his identity because he was a minor. But after all the riots and attacks on the Mosques and on Muslims. The police were forced to reveal his identity. His name is Axel Rudakubana. He was born in Cardiff to Rwandan Christian parents.
Love your courage to talk without the boundaries of the mainstream media. Maintaing the energy and connection, respect and genuinity for 2 hours. Ali is great guy and worthy of respect indeed.
You got a new subscriber
The comments are vile. Stop insulting and just listen to the conversation. There’s a lot of misconceptions about Islam which the media portray for financial reasons.
You don’t have to follow Islam just stop believing the lies, Christianity and Islam are eerily similar.
In stupidity
@@dubyadubyaeee Show me where Jesus says Fight the unbeliever?
@@DaveZee823 2 Chronicles 15:12-13
@kakarote100 Jesus didn't say that. Nice try, though.
@@DaveZee823 So Jesus isn't God of the OT?
Oh, I didn't know this talk existed. Can't wait to watch it now.
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉watching from New York City 🌆🫶🏿🤲🏾🇸🇳🇧🇩Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Delightful, waiting for Part 2
Credit to the interviewer for not being a Piers Morgan
"SubhanAllah 🌟, the clarity and respect in this discussion are truly inspiring. May Allah 🕋 guide those seeking the truth and bless everyone involved in sharing this beautiful message of Islam 🤲. Alhamdulillah for such enlightening content ✨!"
Brother Ali answered all her questions with wisdom Masha Allah ❤ polygamy in islam also help widows and needy women to get married.
wow I watched the entire video, the topics is very interesting, and I did not notice the time for the first time I completed an hour and 50-minute video without feeling bored, a beautiful, fruitful, and purposeful dialogue
There's no way this was 1h50 just found out with your comment its was the fastest 1h50min thats whole movie i just love it
Alhamdulillah for Islam. May Allah protect us from becoming people of hatred.
@@shamasrasool6069 Where does Hate come from? Satan or Allah?
@ is this your question?
“Where does hate come from, God or Satan?”
This is exactly what I am talking about, may Allah keep the confusion away from us, hate Satan and love truth i.e God.
@@shamasrasool6069 Thank you for your reply. But you have just admitted Allah IS Satan!
Look!... Where does HATE come from? Allah.
Quran 5.14
And from those who call themselves Christians, We took their covenant, but they have abandoned a good part of the Message that was sent to them. So We planted amongst them enmity and hatred till the Day of Resurrection (when they discarded Allah's Book, disobeyed Allah's Messengers and His Orders and transgressed beyond bounds in Allah's disobedience), and Allah will inform them of what they used to do.
Thank you brother Ali for promoting Islam in such a way ...
Alot of non-muslims are spreading lies and hatred in this comments section
What do think about Allah Decreeing at the Creation of Adam ALL Black people were Created to go straight to HELL?
كتاب الإيمان1 Faith
(4c)Chapter: Belief in the Divine Decree - Section 3(4c)باب الإيمان بالقدر - الفصل الثالث
Abud Darda' reported God’s messenger as saying, “God created Adam when He created him and struck his right shoulder and brought forth his offspring white like small ants. And he struck his left shoulder and brought forth his offspring black as though they were charcoal. Then He said to the party on his right side, ‘To paradise, and I do not care’ and He said to the party in his left shoulder, ‘To hell, and I do not care’.”
Ahmad transmitted it.
Grade: Isnād Hasan (Zubair `Aliza'i) صَحِيح (الألباني) حكم :
إسنادہ حسن (زبیر علی زئی)
Reference : Mishkat al-Masabih 119
In-book reference : Book 1, Hadith 112
Years of zinist media indoctrination and misinformation. Racism feeds into the narrative too. It's a shame because if they sincerely studied Islam theyd be pleasantly surprised.
Hence the surge of English reverts to Islam, majority of them being women and alot of priests and clergy. Look it up.
Masha'Allah, the broadcaster is very cultured. I ask Allah to guide her to Islam❤
Her, NOT him
I pray for you to getting there and being a Muslim 😊 may Allah guide you and us to the right path ameen 💚
Amiin
Amin not Amen, that's what Christians say we're Muslims, not Christians.
@@cincinandmochiandzane It's actually ameen not Amin or amen. The ي makes an ee sound
@@cincinandmochiandzane it is not a big problem I forget an "e" That's it. Don't be mad I don't say Amin like the Christians. Writing is different because the origin of the word Ameen is from the Semitic languages not European So everyone writes it in a different way depending on the pronunciation.
@@cincinandmochiandzanein English there’s no right or wrong way since it’s transliteration
May Allah SWT guide this presenter to Islam with an open heart. Aameen
P.s great podcast discussion. Hope to see a part 2!
Excellent and honest interviewer, nothing but respect for her and we need more Muslims like Ali so that misconceptions can be removed and people can live with each other with peace.
Very happy to watch this amazing lovely discussion between two individuals that have differences in beliefs but yet are showing beautiful example of respect, tolerance, and decency. Keep fighting warriors.
wow one of the best podcast/interview I have seen this year. wow the interviewer is so genuinely interested in learning and Ali was there to deliver on all front in the simplest way possible.
Islam is the best
*_He is an ex-Christain-revert & im ex-hindu-revert ✌️_*
I’m a Muslim woman who has worked in multiple jobs in America and have found just how unloyal many men and women are in the workplace. A phrase called “work wife and work husband”. Basically cheating on their spouses. So let me ask the host here a question, would you rather your husband continue to cheat or get the second wife? Which would make him more loyal and just? Definitely not the cheating husband. When polygamy is done right, it is successful. Not saying jealousy and emotions don’t get involved, but in some cases it’s a necessity for some men to have more than 1 wife if he can be just with all of them. Allah swt knows and we know not.
The respect the sister showed in this interview should be taught!
May God bless her!
Thank you so much for your integrity ,your hard work, your open minded discussion , hope u & your family always safe and sound.
We pray to Allah Almighty and hope that we can all be the best versions of ourselves as human beings.
Gratitude
If you don't believe Islam is that truth, Read the Quran, that it, you will see yourself
What is true about Islam?
Dumbest book I've ever read, the chapters aren't even in the right order
You’re blinded by your ignorance I hope you heal
It is the only monotheism religion on the planet as of right now.
Name any other religion and i will pull out the paganism from it.
@@Nightfly76 What's wrong with u ? 🤣🤣🤣 Are u drunk or something?
Really liked this open-minded chat! I really hope we can find a way to live together peacefully someday, away from the political drama. Social media isn’t helping, it feels like there’s so much hate floating around. I want to be more accepting of Muslims, and part of me has been thinking about God in a way I haven't before. I think I recognise that a lot of our own struggles like rising divorce rates, OnlyFans, casual sex, gambling, drinking, etc come from drifting from our Christian roots. Seriously, how many of us go to church nowadays? I know I dont! We still celebrate Easter and Christmas, but it feels hollowed out of us true essence. I’ll be honest, some parts of Islam make me uneasy, but after picking up the Bible for the first time since childhood, I notice a lot of similar themes. Muslim countries have faced a lot, it’s hard not to admire their strength, poise and unwavering love, and love for God, through all the challenges.
@DominoSmith-d7b what faced a lot dude they got Destroyed for their trrorism
May Allah guide you good sir :)
Please try and read the Quran with open mind
The host was very gracious and gave appropriate time for Ali to give his point ot view across. Keep it up.
may Allah bless Ali dawah ☝🏾
May Allah guide you to Islam and bring you a precious part of the biggest family on earth my sister, amin. You're very sincere and respectful.. everyhing you need to see the truth, inshaAllah.
May Allah guide this woman. I believe she is smart and will accept the truth.
Love this video. May Allah keep us steadfast.
17:27 Thank You Brother Ali.
May Allah reward you for the reminder.
Great podcast! Thank you to both sides for such a kind and respectful conversation. Really enjoyed this 😊
Brother Ali responded to her challenging questions realllllyy well mashAllah
I am watching your channel because of this man , love from India 🇮🇳😎🙌
Amazing interview we need more people to interview from islamic world to clearify misconceptions about islam and muslims...
Absolutely loved this! Spoke with respect and open-mindedness to say what needs to be said about the truth; eagerly waiting for part 2!
This was an excellent interview, loved watchin & listening to the conversation. Can’t wait for part 2
What a podcast. Couldnt think of a better person to discuss Islam👊
May peace be upon you and on Ali Dawah for spreading the eternal great message of Islam
@@ibrahimhomsi3008 Is it true Allah has two right hands and a shin?
Thank you very much for inviting Ali Dawah. Great session 👍🏻
Ali Dawah strong debater with strong arguments
He has so many supporters and of course there is people who don’t like him winning debates
Alhamdulillah for Islam!! ❤️☝️
He is my favourite Islamic preacher ❤
May Allah bless him ❤
@abdulkarimahmed6161 You need a better role model in your life
Great podcast man! glad that you invited Ali Dawah here. Looking forward for more content like that!
I hope and wish the best for her. She'll get there. Once she reads the Quran, she'll understand her arguments. Will surely wait for part 2.
Islam is the Way of life and the way to paradise
What a great and respectful host
Great interview from both sides enjoyed it very much need more discussions like this.
Loved both the interviewer and the guest!! Part 2 please
Allah bless you Ali dawah❤
Please interview Timothy Winters and Paul Williams. Great British Muslims shaping Islamic thought .
According to Tabari, all four daughters of Abu Bakr, including Aisha, were born before the revelation of Islam in 610AD. The marriage of Aisha to Prophet Muhammad ﷺ took place one year after the migration around 624AD. Even if Aisha was born 1 year before the revelation of Islam in 609AD, this puts her age at around 15 -18 years old during the marriage.
@@AdaLovelace-c8n She was 18 when Muhammad died!
@@DaveZee823 Aisha wasnt 6 when the Prophet PBUH married her.
This hadith contradicts the Quran. Any hadith which contradicts the Quran is false.
The Quran sits in judgement of the hadith not the other way round since the Quran is the primary text of Islam not the hadiths! The Quranic verses which Aisha's age contradicts is
“And if you fear that you will not deal justly with the orphans, then marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four.” Quran 4:3
Marry a woman it says not a child! Aisha was, according to this hadith, a child not a woman at the age of 6 no girl is a woman ready for marriage at the age of 6. The prophet PBUH was a walking talking Quran. So, he wouldn’t do anything that contradicts it. As he doesn’t speak (nor acts out) from his own desires.
“He (Muhammed PBUH) doesn’t speak from his own whims” Quran 53:3
Another Quranic verse which this hadith is in blatant conflict with is:
"Your wives are your tilth; go, then, unto your tilth as you may desire, but first provide something for your souls, and remain conscious of God, and know that you are destined to meet Him. And give glad tidings unto those who believe" Quran 2:223
This hadith describes wives as "tilths" thus we conclude for a women to be a wife she must qualify to be a tilth I.e must be over the age of puberty! No child at the age of 9 qualifies to be a tilth! No child at the age of 9 is ready for sexual relations!
As i have stated before and will do so again Muhammad pbuh was the walking talking Quran therefore wouldn't do anything that contradicts it.
Shame and disgrace be upon the majority of the scholars of Islam and thus muslims who blindly accept this hadith.
Only the Quran is the undisputed, inflammable word of Allah. If the age of Aisha RA was in the Quran then fair enough, however it isnt! Those of you who blindly accept this hadith, your making a mockery of the greatest of Mankind.
We can also use the hadith to reach the same conclusion by speculating Aisha's elders sister Asmah's age and the hijrah period. The hijra as well because it was around this period when she was promised to the prophet PBUH. According to Imam ibn Kathir and the majority of Islamic scholars, Aisha’s older sister Asmah was 10 years older than her, Asmah had died at 73 years after hijra (AH), at the age of 100. If Asmah had died at 73 AH and was a 100, she
was therefore 27 when the prophet PBUH had made the hijra. So, if Asmah was 10 years older than Aisha, this therefore makes Aisha 17 when the hijra had taken place. Aisha was promised to the prophet (PBUH) a year or 2 before hijra meaning she was probably around 15/16 roughly. So, a few years down the line after when the marriage was consummated, she was roughly around 18-20+
Lest we forget the prophet Muhammed PBUH reigned over the lands of Arabia and could’ve had over 1000 wives who were pre-pubesent girls as well as women, if he wanted. Yet he didn’t marry any other little girl like Aisha (RA) supposedly was.
Thank you for taking time out and reading. Peace be upon you.
I don't bothers if Aisha was "underage" in the 7 century. In 7 century, life expectation are 35 years old. Those are not an era where if you thirsty, you just open the tap water. If you're sick, you can call a doctor and give you miracle drugs that can save your life. Teen age girl marriage are common on every side of the world during this period, the priority are to procreate. In modern world, we should change the minimal age of marriage because the priority now are education and make the world a better place. And increase the minimal age of marriage is not forbid in Islam. But, let say WW3 and WW4 destroyed our "modern" world and we all back to the age of sword and sandals, then we should lower the age of marriage again to teen age, for both gender, as the purpose are to procreate and increasing work force.
@@bendegorro754 classic Muslim defending child marriage
@@bendegorro754 age of Constant even in the pre 1st century roman empire also was 15 so even by that standards your prophet will be a criminal
Wish the sister in podcast guide to islam . May Allah give sister hidayah . Waiting for ep.2 .😊
Mash Allah, The whole interview was very great The host was professional and very open minded and Ali did a great job with answers.
Thank you so much for a great interview.
This lady seems open minded and has a good way of asking interesting questions.
May Allah guide all the lost souls to Islam 1:47:57
Good conversation. Next bring on The Muslim Lantern please.