I'll often think I prefer Replicant's OST. Then I'll listen to Automata's OST again and find it better. Then I'll listen to Replicant's OST again and find it better... There's just so much incredible stuff in both that I can only agree with you. I love both, they each have their particularities that make them unique, but I can't manage to make a playlist out of pieces from only one of the two games, kind of like what Jesse said.
I think individual tracks of Nier 1's ost are better but Automata is great with how the tracks change. Don't hugely remember much of the rest of the game, or the tracks, but the carnival and how it layers depending on where you are within it is one thing that has stuck with me so far along the line.
I personally think automatas music is, as a general rule of thumb, better on a technical level, while the preference for "how it sounds" is still of course very devisive and personal. Automatas music is structured to play dynamically and therefore is more layered and loosely structured so that the songs can break apart and be built back up at a moments notice during the game. I think the best way I can phrase the games objective differences in "how good they sound", is automata has better instrumentals due to how well integrated and recorded they HAVE to be in order for the music to work as well as it does dynamically. However since replicant isn't dynamic, i think the songs are structured to be more individual and more standout. More catchy I should say. They gotta have a jingle to them to make up for being more basic. Best examples I can possibly give Automatas desert music vs replicants desert music And automatas factory music vs replicants factory music. Automatas don't stick in your head as much do they? They lack a jingle or tune to get stuck in your skull. Replicants are catchier to you aren't they right? But, automatas music is clearly "better" when comparing these songs. More impressive might be the better word. Memories of dust just destroys lost forest as a song in terms of instrumentation, vocals, pacing, story telling, atmosphere, orchestration. Same for wretched weaponry vs wretched automatons. Replicant doesn't have the same level of sheer music quality and orchestration, but it has catchy tunes and jingles because it has to be much simpler. It of course has some complex music too, but it simply didn't have the budget to be as grand and great as automatas. So it had to become catchy to stick in the players head. Automata sounds "better", replicant sounds "catchier", but thr preference of course remains subjective. I'd describe automatas music as being a feast for the ears and brain while listening, and replicants as being something your brain and ears won't be able to easily let go of once they've caught the sound of the songs. Personally I like automatas music more. But I have no trouble seeing other people's preference for replicants music, especially if they played it first before automata. Because let's be real here, music preference between these 2 games usually comes down to which one you played first.
This is absolutely one of my favorite tracks of this OST. I remember when I first entered the area where this music plays, and heard the mechanical clanging. I thought it was just atmospheric noise, but as more sounds started layering over I quickly realized it was actually a percussion. I stopped dead in my tracks and just marveled as the song kept building upon itself. I will never forget that.
It is probably my favourite OST in NieR as a whole. It's so unique, so good, even after grinding dozens of hours for the platinum, I still love both versions of this song, even tho this one is better imo
It speaks a lot to how excellent this song is that it plays in a spot that is a *major* grinding location and I'm still not tired of it after a dozen hours trying to get rare materials to spawn.
The track that first got me into NieR, the track that convinced me that this game was going to be something special, and one of my most favorite tracks in all of video games. If someone didn't already beat me to it, I would have requested this myself. The way the metallic percussion and Emi's singing plays off each other just brings me into another realm entirely.
Both soundtracks are incredible, but I feel like Automata has a bigger emphasis on big sounds, whether through Chorus or general feel of a piece, while Replicant tends to feel more intimate, with solos and less "processed" music.
One of my top tracks from the Nier ost, love the industrial sounds and the vocals are so good The really cool thing about their made up language is that you can kind of hear words you 'understand' in it
I'm one of those people who prefer Nier's music to Automata's. Not just the music, I prefer the characters and the story more. Don't get me wrong. Nier:Automata is one of my favorite games, but Nier is something else. Nier was a game that took a lot of risks in its music, story, and characters. It was a game that couldn't be pigeonholed into a specific genre. A search for identity as a game. A game where no one is right and no one is wrong. It held nothing back and paid the price of being unique. It was heavily criticized when it first came out, so many people missed out on playing it and enjoying its music. Thanks to Automata, the Nier series is starting to get the recognition and respect it deserves. Automata had excellent reviews and promotion, for the first time people were allowed to speak highly of a game by Yoko Taro and his team. I think both Nier and Automata are great games with a story and soundtrack that will stay with you forever. I can only hope that the Drakengard series starts getting some love too.
I want them to remake the Drakengard games, but also it frightens me. I don't want them to change the story or characters to make them more acceptable. These characters are not good boys and girls, they are very fu.... .. people. I want better graphics, combat system and gameplay in general but with the same story and characters arc. They could also add a few of the short stories that were left out.
I think Automata is a better game overall, but Replicant's has this thing... Idk how to describe it honestly... The music and the story resonate more with me I guess^^ And still, Automata is such a masterpiece that I adore... yeah hope you enjoy the game when you play it!
Replicant is more personal while Automata is more philosophical in it's execution. They are so good in their own ways, I have to weigh gameplay to decide which one I think is better.
I enjoyed both soundtracks and most of the Automata songs are basic evolutions of the Original Nier since it is a sequel , and they do have a theme and come together but the same is said with Original Nier, whenever you get a chance to play it , then it will be clear
So the thing about Nier Automata and Replicant OST difference is....Automata has a higher quality..."Spectrum" while Replicant has a more unique sound by itself, also YEAH, the gameplay. PLS play the Remake of Nier, I'll miss Papa Nier from the OG, but the gameplay is HEAVILY improved.
Thinking about it now, I think replicants music stands by itself more because there's more character themes and more repetitive music. Kaine, emil, shadowlord, song of the ancients, yonah. There's no songs in automata named after the characters except pascal. It's all so much less personal and so much more grand and larger than life (which I like) And replicant has lower quality orchestration so it's rhythm and instruments are more repetitive, so this makes then get stuck in your head easier. Like, automatas desert theme is so astounding it sounds straight out of a movie. Best desert song I've ever heard and one of the most atmospheric songs I've ever heard. Replicants is repetitive as fuck. But it's catchy, and because of that it's easier to remember than automatas desert theme.
NieR Automata's soundtrack is grand and great, but I really love the more experimental sounds of Replicant. Every area brings a different atmosphere yet everything sounds cohesive and unique. Also this is song could be called a "prequel" to Wretched Weaponry from Automata, using the same eletronic and metallic sounds but with different approaches. (Personal recommendation: The Lost Forest, original AND ver 1.22. Both are great but their progression are different. The acoustic guitar is impeccable. )
This is one of those tracks I could listen to on repeat and Never get tired of it, which is funny be cause it just so happens to play in an area you potentially need to grind for Hours if you want 100% Completion.
I prefer automata's soundtrack to replicant's (automata's is my favorite ost I've ever heard so I prefer it to any other soundtrack, not just replicant's). But I don't object to anyone preferring replicant, because there are some fabulous songs. I do think automata objectively implemented its soundtrack better. There are more versions of each song so they can make a song become ambient background, mood-setting music at times and become more dynamic or add vocals when they want to ramp things up. I found that it mostly kept the songs fresh. In replicant, I found myself getting tired of some songs (like this one especially or hills of radiant wind) even though I initially loved them.
if you still crave more from this "franchise" after you get through replicant, you should check out some of the Drakengard 1 and 3 OST (skip 2 because reasons). There is some wild stuff there.
Glad the original was picked here! The arrangement in the new 1.22 version is the one the suffered the most in the transition imo, lose a lot of impact
I GREATLY prefer Replicant’s soundtrack over Automata’s, and also as a game even if it’s clunky and weird. Actually, it is because of those same reasons. I must admit I came into NieR completely blind years before Automata was even announced so the impact it had on me is impossible to put into words. I may be very biased, but I really did not like the remake, the soundtrack even less so.
Nier replicant remasters version of wretched automaton is better but I do have a soft spot for the original. The remastered goes way harder with the techno almost like daft punk which blew my ears off when I first heard it
Really? I actually prefer the original version of this song. I feel like the hammer/metal clang (whatever it is) is muted in the remaster version which makes me prefer the original one. I'm a sucker for the repetitive percussion in this song. Absolutely love it
@@SensDen I guess it depends on what you prefer out of the track, the daft punkish background or the mechanical noises. I wish you could combine the two, but the new one also has that additional segment.
@@Amitlu Totally. Everyone has different things they like. I was just surprised because this is one of the few songs that I genuinely prefer the original. Pretty much every song is so close that it's hard for me to pick a preferred version and this happens to be one that I have a solid opinion on
I'm one of those people that thinks Gestalt/Replicant's soundtrack is superior to Automata's but that's comparing masterpieces to masterpieces.
I'll often think I prefer Replicant's OST. Then I'll listen to Automata's OST again and find it better. Then I'll listen to Replicant's OST again and find it better... There's just so much incredible stuff in both that I can only agree with you. I love both, they each have their particularities that make them unique, but I can't manage to make a playlist out of pieces from only one of the two games, kind of like what Jesse said.
I think individual tracks of Nier 1's ost are better but Automata is great with how the tracks change. Don't hugely remember much of the rest of the game, or the tracks, but the carnival and how it layers depending on where you are within it is one thing that has stuck with me so far along the line.
Same. Grandma, Hills of Radiant Wind, City of Commerce, Shadowlord, etc., are some of my favorite pieces in vidya as a whole.
Idk, both have my favourite osts. Like Dark Colossus in Nier:Automata, Song Of The Ancients (all versions) in Replicant and every other nier song lmao
I personally think automatas music is, as a general rule of thumb, better on a technical level, while the preference for "how it sounds" is still of course very devisive and personal.
Automatas music is structured to play dynamically and therefore is more layered and loosely structured so that the songs can break apart and be built back up at a moments notice during the game.
I think the best way I can phrase the games objective differences in "how good they sound", is automata has better instrumentals due to how well integrated and recorded they HAVE to be in order for the music to work as well as it does dynamically.
However since replicant isn't dynamic, i think the songs are structured to be more individual and more standout. More catchy I should say. They gotta have a jingle to them to make up for being more basic.
Best examples I can possibly give
Automatas desert music vs replicants desert music
And automatas factory music vs replicants factory music.
Automatas don't stick in your head as much do they? They lack a jingle or tune to get stuck in your skull. Replicants are catchier to you aren't they right?
But, automatas music is clearly "better" when comparing these songs. More impressive might be the better word.
Memories of dust just destroys lost forest as a song in terms of instrumentation, vocals, pacing, story telling, atmosphere, orchestration.
Same for wretched weaponry vs wretched automatons.
Replicant doesn't have the same level of sheer music quality and orchestration, but it has catchy tunes and jingles because it has to be much simpler. It of course has some complex music too, but it simply didn't have the budget to be as grand and great as automatas. So it had to become catchy to stick in the players head.
Automata sounds "better", replicant sounds "catchier", but thr preference of course remains subjective.
I'd describe automatas music as being a feast for the ears and brain while listening, and replicants as being something your brain and ears won't be able to easily let go of once they've caught the sound of the songs.
Personally I like automatas music more. But I have no trouble seeing other people's preference for replicants music, especially if they played it first before automata.
Because let's be real here, music preference between these 2 games usually comes down to which one you played first.
This is absolutely one of my favorite tracks of this OST. I remember when I first entered the area where this music plays, and heard the mechanical clanging. I thought it was just atmospheric noise, but as more sounds started layering over I quickly realized it was actually a percussion. I stopped dead in my tracks and just marveled as the song kept building upon itself. I will never forget that.
It is probably my favourite OST in NieR as a whole. It's so unique, so good, even after grinding dozens of hours for the platinum, I still love both versions of this song, even tho this one is better imo
I was grinding for upgrade parts in this area constantly but this track never got old!
It speaks a lot to how excellent this song is that it plays in a spot that is a *major* grinding location and I'm still not tired of it after a dozen hours trying to get rare materials to spawn.
This is the one song the games have killed for me due to that reason, sadly.
@@effortlessfury i feel you man
Keiichi Okabe is a genius.
Funny, the automata version of this, “Wretched Weaponry” is what first drew me into Keiichi Okabe’s music, so it’s got a special place to me.
I never drew the parallel oh my god
@@nicholascunningham4439 come on its in the name lol
The track that first got me into NieR, the track that convinced me that this game was going to be something special, and one of my most favorite tracks in all of video games. If someone didn't already beat me to it, I would have requested this myself. The way the metallic percussion and Emi's singing plays off each other just brings me into another realm entirely.
Both soundtracks are incredible, but I feel like Automata has a bigger emphasis on big sounds, whether through Chorus or general feel of a piece, while Replicant tends to feel more intimate, with solos and less "processed" music.
Thanks to this amazing piece of ost the farming on this area was a lot less painful, absolutely love it.
One of my top tracks from the Nier ost, love the industrial sounds and the vocals are so good
The really cool thing about their made up language is that you can kind of hear words you 'understand' in it
ahhhh!! this is one of my favorites of the tracks! I adore the way the clanging builds up and the song just becomes it and the vocals,, I adore it
This song just draws you in. Not my favorite from this ost but it is the one that gets stuck in my head
I'm one of those people who prefer Nier's music to Automata's. Not just the music, I prefer the characters and the story more.
Don't get me wrong. Nier:Automata is one of my favorite games, but Nier is something else.
Nier was a game that took a lot of risks in its music, story, and characters. It was a game that couldn't be pigeonholed into a specific genre. A search for identity as a game. A game where no one is right and no one is wrong. It held nothing back and paid the price of being unique. It was heavily criticized when it first came out, so many people missed out on playing it and enjoying its music.
Thanks to Automata, the Nier series is starting to get the recognition and respect it deserves. Automata had excellent reviews and promotion, for the first time people were allowed to speak highly of a game by Yoko Taro and his team.
I think both Nier and Automata are great games with a story and soundtrack that will stay with you forever.
I can only hope that the Drakengard series starts getting some love too.
I want them to remake the Drakengard games, but also it frightens me. I don't want them to change the story or characters to make them more acceptable. These characters are not good boys and girls, they are very fu.... .. people. I want better graphics, combat system and gameplay in general but with the same story and characters arc. They could also add a few of the short stories that were left out.
Me too,just look to my Photo
Ahh this IS a Factory Song 😊 Good Catch.
This song is released in 2010, and remaked in 2022. Awesome
I think Automata is a better game overall, but Replicant's has this thing... Idk how to describe it honestly... The music and the story resonate more with me I guess^^ And still, Automata is such a masterpiece that I adore... yeah hope you enjoy the game when you play it!
Both stories speak to the heart, but replicant just does it better.
Replicant is more personal while Automata is more philosophical in it's execution. They are so good in their own ways, I have to weigh gameplay to decide which one I think is better.
Oh boy, this game is pretty heavy. Good luck. Some of this music will stick with you in interesting ways and bring back memories years later.
Nier and its mother series Drakengard are all heavy. If I know anything about Yoko Taro, it's that he likes women and making players cry
I enjoyed both soundtracks and most of the Automata songs are basic evolutions of the Original Nier since it is a sequel , and they do have a theme and come together but the same is said with Original Nier, whenever you get a chance to play it , then it will be clear
So the thing about Nier Automata and Replicant OST difference is....Automata has a higher quality..."Spectrum" while Replicant has a more unique sound by itself, also YEAH, the gameplay. PLS play the Remake of Nier, I'll miss Papa Nier from the OG, but the gameplay is HEAVILY improved.
just go play the dlc for papa nier
Thinking about it now, I think replicants music stands by itself more because there's more character themes and more repetitive music.
Kaine, emil, shadowlord, song of the ancients, yonah.
There's no songs in automata named after the characters except pascal. It's all so much less personal and so much more grand and larger than life (which I like)
And replicant has lower quality orchestration so it's rhythm and instruments are more repetitive, so this makes then get stuck in your head easier.
Like, automatas desert theme is so astounding it sounds straight out of a movie. Best desert song I've ever heard and one of the most atmospheric songs I've ever heard.
Replicants is repetitive as fuck. But it's catchy, and because of that it's easier to remember than automatas desert theme.
Recommending the worse version for shame
This (original version) or the lost forest (remake version) is probably my favorite track in the ost
NieR Automata's soundtrack is grand and great, but I really love the more experimental sounds of Replicant. Every area brings a different atmosphere yet everything sounds cohesive and unique.
Also this is song could be called a "prequel" to Wretched Weaponry from Automata, using the same eletronic and metallic sounds but with different approaches.
(Personal recommendation: The Lost Forest, original AND ver 1.22. Both are great but their progression are different. The acoustic guitar is impeccable. )
Snow in Summer and Shadowlord are pretty good too
This is one of those tracks I could listen to on repeat and Never get tired of it, which is funny be cause it just so happens to play in an area you potentially need to grind for Hours if you want 100% Completion.
This song just reminds me of endless grinding sessions.
Memory/Titanium Alloy moment
I prefer automata's soundtrack to replicant's (automata's is my favorite ost I've ever heard so I prefer it to any other soundtrack, not just replicant's). But I don't object to anyone preferring replicant, because there are some fabulous songs.
I do think automata objectively implemented its soundtrack better. There are more versions of each song so they can make a song become ambient background, mood-setting music at times and become more dynamic or add vocals when they want to ramp things up. I found that it mostly kept the songs fresh. In replicant, I found myself getting tired of some songs (like this one especially or hills of radiant wind) even though I initially loved them.
I loooooooove this song!
the insane amount of time ive spent in this dungeon in the original game was only worthit for this music 🔥
if you still crave more from this "franchise" after you get through replicant, you should check out some of the Drakengard 1 and 3 OST (skip 2 because reasons).
There is some wild stuff there.
What is a drakengard 2? 🤭
@@sararapotata Drakengard 2, no comment
This song screams Steam-Punk!
nier gestalt is the goat man. possibly one the best bgms ever man. k.obake is godlike man!
All of those are the original soundtrack actually not the new ones (apart from fleeting summer and snow in summer)
IS THAT THE DELAY LAMA PLUG-IN
You need to listen to Ashes of dreams and The Ultimate weapon (not the nightmare version)
Que grande es el keiichi
I prefer automata music, but it's a close thing. There really is something like an overarching theme that just resonates with me, in that game.
I still think Automata has better OSTs than Replicant. You said it before, "How can you beat greatness?" But Replicant is still amazing.
Glad the original was picked here! The arrangement in the new 1.22 version is the one the suffered the most in the transition imo, lose a lot of impact
yep. i couldnt finish the game, the ost was too different man. it lost A LOT of power man.
I GREATLY prefer Replicant’s soundtrack over Automata’s, and also as a game even if it’s clunky and weird. Actually, it is because of those same reasons. I must admit I came into NieR completely blind years before Automata was even announced so the impact it had on me is impossible to put into words. I may be very biased, but I really did not like the remake, the soundtrack even less so.
Just a heads up Jesse, after your first playthrough you just scratched the surface of the game.
They prefer replicant? I'm sorry but i'll have to disagree, automata is superior :3
Nier replicant remasters version of wretched automaton is better but I do have a soft spot for the original. The remastered goes way harder with the techno almost like daft punk which blew my ears off when I first heard it
Really? I actually prefer the original version of this song. I feel like the hammer/metal clang (whatever it is) is muted in the remaster version which makes me prefer the original one. I'm a sucker for the repetitive percussion in this song. Absolutely love it
@@SensDen I guess it depends on what you prefer out of the track, the daft punkish background or the mechanical noises.
I wish you could combine the two, but the new one also has that additional segment.
@@Amitlu Totally. Everyone has different things they like. I was just surprised because this is one of the few songs that I genuinely prefer the original. Pretty much every song is so close that it's hard for me to pick a preferred version and this happens to be one that I have a solid opinion on