He loved her and so does she, but she does not understand emotions because all she has been taught were orders and military-related things. He wanted her to be free so he left. I haven't read the novels yet but I guess that he must be hiding somewhere near her, watching her and waiting for the right time to show up again when she realised what his *I love you* was.
ส่อง อย่างเดียว Don't worry lol, he does hide in order for her to fully live without thinking all she's good for is orders. They eventually reunite and he confesses. He states that he'll wait for her until she fully understands "love" even though we're aware she feels the same. And he states he wants her to be by his side from now on.
Potato Cake lolol yes it's true I've finished the novel of this anime. They reunite in the end. Throughout this time he was hiding from her all while rising up in the ranks. But he hid from her to allow her to grow as a human being and not as a weapon, but people like his brother, hodgins, etc. knew he was alive.
Although I love this anime the most yet I'd say that Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 is probably the saddest........it may not be as beautiful and gorgeous and lovely as Violet Evergarden, but according to me it's the saddest anime I've ever watched (through the harshness of nature)
Have you've seen 'Hotarubi no mori e' and 'Banana fish' and 'Devilman crybaby' and 'Your lie in april' and 'erased' and 'i want to eat your pancreas' and 'anohana' and 'the promised neverland'
So Gilberts problem was that he raised Violet and fell in love with her. But because of her age and lacks of experience in life, Gilbert worries about Violet not beeing able to live in the "normal" world he and all soldiers are trying to built. He knows that she´s stronger than any other soldier, so she can "function" in war. But he´s afraid that she couldn´t handle living in an peaceful enviroment. And how can they live a "happy married life" together, when they actually don´t know much about each other. Gilbert really wants a relationship with violet, but he´s afraid that he might get into a conflict. Violet at that time didn´t know the difference between parental love and beeing a couple (violet was raised as an orphan). So it´s like violet has to do more "normal" experiences in life before she can handle complexe things as "beeing in love" with someone. That´s why travelling and meeting all the different people is so important! She should grow into the person she want´s to be (that´s probably why all the flower references are made) and than face him again. And after that they can have their happy end *-* beautiful story!!!
I don't think their love is romantic because the show is all about her experiencing different kinds of love. Idk about the movie but as of now i don't think that its romantic love. he loves her and that what it is.
@@marinamarina1400 it was kinda confirmed in the episode with the princess and the public love letters. The princess asked Violet what she thinks abt her marrying an older man and all that because she wants an opinion from someone that's her age. The Princess was 14 in that episode, if i remember right, so Violet should also be around that age.
he didn't fall in love with her? the first time he saw her he said.. "a child?" he was shocked by the way everyone treated her and then he pitied her. but gilbert's compassion was out of love and pity. it just wasn't romantic. he couldn't resist any of this because she was a kid.
If you've read 4 love languages, you can understand where Violet is coming from. Even as she did not realize it, and Gilbert was too guilt-ridden to realize it as well, Violet's love languages are physical presence and act of service.....which ironically, is the Major's love languages too! "If I have your orders, I can go anywhere" She pretty much told the Major right there and then that she loved him with all her heart. In a way, both of them are idiots. Then again, a child with stunted emotional development and a military officer who only knows war and shuns love out of his heart (The novel described their unfortunate backgrounds in solid details), that's pretty much expected.
much like in real life, Violet's dependency on the familiar, dependency on something stable was sought after since she was traumatized so much. We burn all over. We burn and we don't understand why we're burning, but then it comes to a point where burning stops hurting and we have to ask if we are healed or just numb. Time does more than heal, sometimes it scars, and those scars are so dangerous if you hate them for what they mean. This show was one of the deepest I've ever watched with character development and realistic handling of depression, trauma, and waking up on the doorstep of you own life.
Violet in this scene was very young... But the Violet in the latest movie trailer has grown to such a fine woman and became adult. Their age gap is quite long but I still ship them.
At that time around 1910-1910 it was normal especially with royals, people will say they have a daughter-father relationship, but they both love eachother romantically, as seen in their moves and what Gilbert said before he supposedly “died”, you also see in one of Violets Request all the Suitors are over 15+ years older then her, and she asked Violet if that was okay since they were around the same age, people need to realise it’s not like it is today, this was set in a time it was completely normal and not judged at all.
I hate the whole debate on if Gilbert has a father or a boyfriend type of love. You can just love someone without it being sexual damn it. There is a reason there are 7 types of love and this is closest to agape or philia to me. Gilbert can love Violet as a person and his wish for her happiness. Violet can love Gilbert and her need for familiarity around him. Obviously there is potential for romance, but I believe it is in the intent. Have they ever sexualized the relationship? I didn’t see it.
you can also love someone romantically without sexualizing it. i try to avoid the comments suggesting which type of love it is, because i understand it deeply without labeling it, but i think if we are going to explain it, i like to imagine that it was a caring, nurturing love just coming from a bond, eventually later blooming into something more romantic-based. not to spoil a movie, but i watched it, and while i know in the novels they are together, the movie does not strictly suggest it, just lightly hints, and i think it's the best way to take it. but still, as i said, it's understandable without labeling - a trait of well written story
But if it were to foster into a romance, in the real world, their relationship would be considered "grooming" which is a disgusting thing. But, she at least doesn't reunite with him until she's 18 years of age. Trust me, I really enjoy this anime, it's beautiful and reminds me so much of Call the Midwife TV show. There are messages in this that so profound and self aware but like most anime, it's best not to take it too seriously or personally.
Honestly from the beginning I was so interested in her backstory and army experience. I wish they made a whole movie about her upbringing from the moment she was abandoned to when Gilbert "died" and she became.a doll. I actually really liked her military demeanor and how deep of a character she was. Since orders were all Violet knew, Gilbert decided not to go back to be the Major because he wanted Violet to experience life in a peaceful environment because war is all she knew. I think that's why Violets experiences with writing letters for others to learn feelings is so important for them to be able to live a happy life together.
Actually, from what I've seen in the Violet Evergarden movie trailers, Gilbert manages to survive. He lost one of his eyes and his right arm. Anyway, Gilbert, as karmotakra mentioned, chose to stay away from Violet after the war, thinking that she would be better off living without him.
At that time around 1910-1910 (If you’re wondering how I know that it’s around that time, it’s said that it was in WW1 or around that time, also the fashion sense and style, and the cars, type writers were used with the lack of technology.) it was normal especially with royals, people will say they have a daughter-father relationship, but they both love eachother romantically, as seen in their emotions and physical moves and what Gilbert said before he supposedly “died”, you also see in one of Violets Requests (Charlotte) all the Suitors are over 15+, and she asked Violet if that was okay since they were around the same age, people need to realise it’s not like it is today, this was set in a time it was completely normal and not judged at all.
Favorite anime of all time (I loved Gilberts and Violets story) 🧡 This anime is just amazing and I absolutely loved it. I really want to read the actual Novels 📖 so badly in English (not using online to read it). Hopefully one day it will be sold in English 😭
This scene probably brought me closer to tears than anything else in a very long time but still I can’t feel anything which is probably why I have been watching this to see if I would feel something
Just watched to movie SPOILER:> He was NOT in the movie. But Violet said something like: "I am not allowed to meet him" when she was asked if she missed anyone. So does she know he is alive or did she just say that as a metaphor to state that death ( if she thinks that he is dead) parted them.
@@dullahandulla1796 That's just an additional movie. The actual movie that was actually meant to be S2 will be releasing this month on probably 24 or I don't can be next month too. You can Google it if you don't believe me. :)
I feel same way she does cause I don't understand what love means cause noone every show me love or kindness and I don't know what happiness is or how to find it I just listen to orders like her
idk why but their love was never explained so idk why people just presume everything as romantic. I don't think of their love as romantic as the show is all about her experiencing so many different kinds of love. love with a sibling, with family, with a lover, with their work and so many more so their love also is one kind. i don't think its just as simple ans cliche as romance
Ever since she left the island, she felt nothing in her heart and soul with the Major. However, she managed to express herself not as a subordinate but as a human being towards Gilbert. Regardless of the war, she still held dear to him all this time!!!!! 🤣😂
There is an 14th Episode , but i am from germany and Here it does Not exist - so... somebody can tell me were i can find it this 14th Episode That is suscribed on the official side of Violet evergarden ? In any language it is equal. Please ! theIf somebody Knows can you answer me and Send The link or sone informations of the second Movie ?! The First i bought already a Bit ago
I don’t see Violets relationship with Gilbert being romantic, as some people would see. I mean, she’s a child, that’s kind of weird if it’s like that. I see it more as Gilbert being a Father to her
Ivan De La Garza I saw in another comment that this is like the early 1800s, where child marriage was fully legal and common. Kinda like with Princess Charlotte marrying a 24 year old prince. It’s common for that era so it’s kinda plausible. It’s true love anyways so I fully support it!
@@christinatoo801 That's true, but I never *ever* saw this as romantic *at all* . Not every guy and gal put on screen needs to be romantic. "I love you" doesn't mean "I want to marry you and bang you" all the time. Love is so many things besides that
Ivan De La Garza I know but them having romantic feelings for each other has been confirmed. It’s not like I shipped Violet and Gilbert. I thought they had a father daughter relationship until I asked my older brother, who said it is confirmed that it is a romantic relationship. I actually don’t really ship them, but it’s what the creators thought so we have to go with it. But it’s fine if you disagree with it or think otherwise.
Now i came back just to tell you guys, Gilbert is still alive HAHAHAHA Cheers!✨ well obviously he still alive since you all erdy watch few in youtube 😂
It's ok..... but I think the "Cheffs" (sorry forgot his name, redhead, ponytail...you know) and Majors should have swiched .... Btw. German Dub is amazing
He loved her and so does she, but she does not understand emotions because all she has been taught were orders and military-related things. He wanted her to be free so he left. I haven't read the novels yet but I guess that he must be hiding somewhere near her, watching her and waiting for the right time to show up again when she realised what his *I love you* was.
ส่อง อย่างเดียว Don't worry lol, he does hide in order for her to fully live without thinking all she's good for is orders. They eventually reunite and he confesses. He states that he'll wait for her until she fully understands "love" even though we're aware she feels the same. And he states he wants her to be by his side from now on.
Military always change people
Especially kids
@@akina01 IS THAT TRUE?!?!?!?! OMGGGG PLS TELL ME MORE
Potato Cake lolol yes it's true I've finished the novel of this anime. They reunite in the end. Throughout this time he was hiding from her all while rising up in the ranks. But he hid from her to allow her to grow as a human being and not as a weapon, but people like his brother, hodgins, etc. knew he was alive.
@@akina01 where was he hiding????
This anime is one of the sadest animes i have ever seen
looming with roxy sad really
It's a tie between this and clannad for me
R.I.P Aidan one of the saddest deaths in the show i felt terrible for him
Although I love this anime the most yet I'd say that Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 is probably the saddest........it may not be as beautiful and gorgeous and lovely as Violet Evergarden, but according to me it's the saddest anime I've ever watched (through the harshness of nature)
Have you've seen 'Hotarubi no mori e' and 'Banana fish' and 'Devilman crybaby' and 'Your lie in april' and 'erased' and 'i want to eat your pancreas' and 'anohana' and 'the promised neverland'
So Gilberts problem was that he raised Violet and fell in love with her. But because of her age and lacks of experience in life, Gilbert worries about Violet not beeing able to live in the "normal" world he and all soldiers are trying to built. He knows that she´s stronger than any other soldier, so she can "function" in war. But he´s afraid that she couldn´t handle living in an peaceful enviroment. And how can they live a "happy married life" together, when they actually don´t know much about each other. Gilbert really wants a relationship with violet, but he´s afraid that he might get into a conflict. Violet at that time didn´t know the difference between parental love and beeing a couple (violet was raised as an orphan). So it´s like violet has to do more "normal" experiences in life before she can handle complexe things as "beeing in love" with someone. That´s why travelling and meeting all the different people is so important! She should grow into the person she want´s to be (that´s probably why all the flower references are made) and than face him again. And after that they can have their happy end *-* beautiful story!!!
@Christophe Ducas Actually Violets age was unknown and still is - people only presumed that she was 14 when they found her but never confirmed.
I don't think their love is romantic because the show is all about her experiencing different kinds of love. Idk about the movie but as of now i don't think that its romantic love. he loves her and that what it is.
@@marinamarina1400 it was kinda confirmed in the episode with the princess and the public love letters.
The princess asked Violet what she thinks abt her marrying an older man and all that because she wants an opinion from someone that's her age. The Princess was 14 in that episode, if i remember right, so Violet should also be around that age.
@@hafsakhan9021 I can say for sure that they have a romantic relationship.
he didn't fall in love with her? the first time he saw her he said.. "a child?" he was shocked by the way everyone treated her and then he pitied her. but gilbert's compassion was out of love and pity. it just wasn't romantic. he couldn't resist any of this because she was a kid.
If you've read 4 love languages, you can understand where Violet is coming from.
Even as she did not realize it, and Gilbert was too guilt-ridden to realize it as well, Violet's love languages are physical presence and act of service.....which ironically, is the Major's love languages too!
"If I have your orders, I can go anywhere"
She pretty much told the Major right there and then that she loved him with all her heart.
In a way, both of them are idiots. Then again, a child with stunted emotional development and a military officer who only knows war and shuns love out of his heart (The novel described their unfortunate backgrounds in solid details), that's pretty much expected.
Hey guys were could i find the novel?
Search up ‘Violet Evergarden Light novel’ , and there should be one website called ‘Dennou Translations’
much like in real life, Violet's dependency on the familiar, dependency on something stable was sought after since she was traumatized so much.
We burn all over. We burn and we don't understand why we're burning, but then it comes to a point where burning stops hurting and we have to ask if we are healed or just numb. Time does more than heal, sometimes it scars, and those scars are so dangerous if you hate them for what they mean. This show was one of the deepest I've ever watched with character development and realistic handling of depression, trauma, and waking up on the doorstep of you own life.
Wow... that was deep...
Violet in this scene was very young... But the Violet in the latest movie trailer has grown to such a fine woman and became adult. Their age gap is quite long but I still ship them.
Their gap is just around 12-14 years, that doesn't reallt matter in old times
At that time around 1910-1910 it was normal especially with royals, people will say they have a daughter-father relationship, but they both love eachother romantically, as seen in their moves and what Gilbert said before he supposedly “died”, you also see in one of Violets Request all the Suitors are over 15+ years older then her, and she asked Violet if that was okay since they were around the same age, people need to realise it’s not like it is today, this was set in a time it was completely normal and not judged at all.
He did not die guys. Gilbert is still alive 😭
Usui Takumi ye he is
@@mcastillo830 nah his not die yet. the book did not mention gilbert dieeeeee. so he is not die yet.
Usui Takumi ik,, oops prolly what ya meant in my past comment is hes dead,, oops sorri XDDD
can't wait for the movie and season 2
@@karen4554 no its release date is early 2020
I hate the whole debate on if Gilbert has a father or a boyfriend type of love. You can just love someone without it being sexual damn it. There is a reason there are 7 types of love and this is closest to agape or philia to me. Gilbert can love Violet as a person and his wish for her happiness. Violet can love Gilbert and her need for familiarity around him. Obviously there is potential for romance, but I believe it is in the intent. Have they ever sexualized the relationship? I didn’t see it.
Not till she's an adult and much later in the light novel do they legitimately hook up
you can also love someone romantically without sexualizing it. i try to avoid the comments suggesting which type of love it is, because i understand it deeply without labeling it, but i think if we are going to explain it, i like to imagine that it was a caring, nurturing love just coming from a bond, eventually later blooming into something more romantic-based. not to spoil a movie, but i watched it, and while i know in the novels they are together, the movie does not strictly suggest it, just lightly hints, and i think it's the best way to take it. but still, as i said, it's understandable without labeling - a trait of well written story
But if it were to foster into a romance, in the real world, their relationship would be considered "grooming" which is a disgusting thing. But, she at least doesn't reunite with him until she's 18 years of age. Trust me, I really enjoy this anime, it's beautiful and reminds me so much of Call the Midwife TV show. There are messages in this that so profound and self aware but like most anime, it's best not to take it too seriously or personally.
50 year old Jellal makes full metal saber cry
Cant wait for the movie. A big surprise :)
@Jose Morales my bad. Actually season 2 is not confirmed yet. But movie is coming out. :)
Karan oh my god what! when??
Yes, I think it was January 2020. I hope so, because I can’t wait anymore shdhsh
@@Karan-pn7xs i think it's been confirmed
Karan heeey~ i came from 2020 lmao. İts out two days ago :`>>>
Honestly from the beginning I was so interested in her backstory and army experience. I wish they made a whole movie about her upbringing from the moment she was abandoned to when Gilbert "died" and she became.a doll. I actually really liked her military demeanor and how deep of a character she was. Since orders were all Violet knew, Gilbert decided not to go back to be the Major because he wanted Violet to experience life in a peaceful environment because war is all she knew. I think that's why Violets experiences with writing letters for others to learn feelings is so important for them to be able to live a happy life together.
Yes I wished for that too and I agree with you.
Actually, from what I've seen in the Violet Evergarden movie trailers, Gilbert manages to survive. He lost one of his eyes and his right arm. Anyway, Gilbert, as karmotakra mentioned, chose to stay away from Violet after the war, thinking that she would be better off living without him.
*THINGS I THINK ABOUT AT 3AM*
Honestly same though 💀😸
We're same
We're same
This anime made me cry and when I finished watching it the feeling really felt, and my chest felt tight seeing the sad scene
i love this anime sm honestly
At that time around 1910-1910 (If you’re wondering how I know that it’s around that time, it’s said that it was in WW1 or around that time, also the fashion sense and style, and the cars, type writers were used with the lack of technology.) it was normal especially with royals, people will say they have a daughter-father relationship, but they both love eachother romantically, as seen in their emotions and physical moves and what Gilbert said before he supposedly “died”, you also see in one of Violets Requests (Charlotte) all the Suitors are over 15+, and she asked Violet if that was okay since they were around the same age, people need to realise it’s not like it is today, this was set in a time it was completely normal and not judged at all.
Favorite anime of all time (I loved Gilberts and Violets story) 🧡 This anime is just amazing and I absolutely loved it. I really want to read the actual Novels 📖 so badly in English (not using online to read it). Hopefully one day it will be sold in English 😭
He’s alive, she has the same voice as the ruler in fate
This scene probably brought me closer to tears than anything else in a very long time but still I can’t feel anything which is probably why I have been watching this to see if I would feel something
I'm crying
Just watched to movie
SPOILER:>
He was NOT in the movie. But Violet said something like: "I am not allowed to meet him" when she was asked if she missed anyone. So does she know he is alive or did she just say that as a metaphor to state that death ( if she thinks that he is dead) parted them.
But the movie releasse is I 24.4.2020
@@claudiamm7348 Nah, its on Netflix world wide. It came out April 2nd, so today. I watched it at like 4 am
@@dullahandulla1796 That's just an additional movie. The actual movie that was actually meant to be S2 will be releasing this month on probably 24 or I don't can be next month too. You can Google it if you don't believe me. :)
Dang this is deep...
Why it hurts so much.. ... .. 🖤
I feel same way she does cause I don't understand what love means cause noone every show me love or kindness and I don't know what happiness is or how to find it I just listen to orders like her
Gilberrrttt😭😭
idk why but their love was never explained so idk why people just presume everything as romantic. I don't think of their love as romantic as the show is all about her experiencing so many different kinds of love. love with a sibling, with family, with a lover, with their work and so many more so their love also is one kind. i don't think its just as simple ans cliche as romance
it's definitely not a cliche romance, but Gilbert is alive and Violet is his wife canonically
Yes
Ever since she left the island, she felt nothing in her heart and soul with the Major. However, she managed to express herself not as a subordinate but as a human being towards Gilbert. Regardless of the war, she still held dear to him all this time!!!!! 🤣😂
EVERYONE IS TALKING ABOUT A NOVEL!!! WHAT NOVEL AND WHERE CAN I FIND IT!?!
Don't yell at him Gilbert🙊🥺😭
My heart is crying.
Hermosisisisisisima pareja como sé separaron 😭😭😭😭que tristeza ❤💋
There is an 14th Episode , but i am from germany and Here it does Not exist - so... somebody can tell me were i can find it this 14th Episode That is suscribed on the official side of Violet evergarden ? In any language it is equal. Please ! theIf somebody Knows can you answer me and Send The link or sone informations of the second Movie ?! The First i bought already a Bit ago
There is a 14th episode?? Is it the OVA?
I don’t see Violets relationship with Gilbert being romantic, as some people would see. I mean, she’s a child, that’s kind of weird if it’s like that. I see it more as Gilbert being a Father to her
In the novel its explicitly explained they're romantically involved
@@anishabegum2056 Really? That's...no...
Ivan De La Garza I saw in another comment that this is like the early 1800s, where child marriage was fully legal and common. Kinda like with Princess Charlotte marrying a 24 year old prince. It’s common for that era so it’s kinda plausible. It’s true love anyways so I fully support it!
@@christinatoo801 That's true, but I never *ever* saw this as romantic *at all* . Not every guy and gal put on screen needs to be romantic. "I love you" doesn't mean "I want to marry you and bang you" all the time. Love is so many things besides that
Ivan De La Garza I know but them having romantic feelings for each other has been confirmed. It’s not like I shipped Violet and Gilbert. I thought they had a father daughter relationship until I asked my older brother, who said it is confirmed that it is a romantic relationship. I actually don’t really ship them, but it’s what the creators thought so we have to go with it. But it’s fine if you disagree with it or think otherwise.
She cries too much for a living weapon
In the novel the only time she cried during the war was when Gil told her he loved her in his dying moments
Is this the new movie? Im sorryyyy im so confused.. where can i watch this
I feel bad that your videos get so many immature comments that complain about the dub.
Seriously, just leave and go read some subtitles =_=
I know, I hate the dub haters so much i wish they could just Shut up. 😠
I'm sick of it
Does anyone knows the song ?
The sub was sooooooo much better like fr
I don't think so
WWAIT BUT IS HE ALIVE IN THE MOVIE OR WHAT IS GOING ON
While episode?
Now i came back just to tell you guys, Gilbert is still alive HAHAHAHA Cheers!✨ well obviously he still alive since you all erdy watch few in youtube 😂
Don't like the Dub voices....ugh!
YUKI SAGA I do
This is one of the best dubs I've heard so far
There are some anime’s that have great duds this is close to #1
It's ok..... but I think the "Cheffs" (sorry forgot his name, redhead, ponytail...you know) and Majors should have swiched ....
Btw. German Dub is amazing
YUKI SAGA I literally clicked on the video, heard the dub voices and had to watch with captions instead of audio
Jesus clicked this dub on accident, weird.
You guy need to watch sub
eeeeeeeeeeeew, sorry but the english dub is completely destroying the anime.