@@morningsminion3242 bunda mahvetmek gibi bir durumda görmüyorum. Bireysellik yapmıyoruz onlar beraber büyüdüler onlar grup üyeleri Taemin söylemesi zor bir şarkı olduğunu zaten kabul edip içinden geldiği için söylemiş büyütülcek bir durum görmüyorum ben beğendim sen beğenmeyebilirsin
@@sevennn11 Taemin is not the brightest bulb in the socket. In fact, he's most likely the dimmest bulb in any socket he might find himself screwed into. Note I did NOT say Taemin KNOWS this is a mockery. I did not say Taemin KNOWS what he did here is a mockery. He would be the LAST person to notice such a thing, because he feels has little empathy for the feelings of others, only himself. This personality trait is the only explanation for the fact that he was around Jonghyun most of the time during J's last 18 months, he saw the physical and mental deterioration, he saw the severe weight loss, the crying jags, the deep depression; he knew of the explicit suicide letter J sent to Nine9 TWO WEEKS before his death. And just like everyone from the other members to J's mother to SM, he pretended he didn't see what he saw. Either that or he KNEW and didn't care. Neither choice is a pretty one. And now here, he sings Jonghyun's song, which J performed with breathtaking passion, half-ass out the side of his mouth, looking at a screen because he's too thoughtless to memorize the words, as if he was a half-drunk Karaoke customer in a run-down alley joint in a bad part of Seoul. Perhaps the worst part of whatever this performance is supposed to be is that it is boring. And less-than-bright people like you see it as a tribute; and honor of some kind. You Taemints are disgusting.
Tu estas llorando? Porque yo si 🤧gracias Taemin por tu bellisima interpretación nuestro querido Jonghyun siempre vivirá en nuestros corazones por siempre. Shinee saranghae 💗
@@morningsminion3242 what? He was singing this js for fun and maybe a way to remember jonghyun. Its not supposed to be one of the best performances of y si fuera ella too so i dont get your point. And besides i dont think hes trying to mock Jonghyun as they have been the greatest bandmates when jonghyun was still here..
@@Kzcxinq Who, in their right mind sings a half-ass version of one of their dead-by-suicide band-mate's most iconic songs, giggling like a ditz the whole time? Jonghyun sang this magnificently, but here we have Taemin singing like a drunk Karaoke customer on a Saturday night in Gangnam. I don't think he is TRYING to mock Jonghyun deliberately. But I DO think Taemin is not the brightest bulb and has no clue as to how this comes across. Just watch him here: He is a 31-year-old, grown-ass man who acts like a 16-year-old air-head. You either not getting how this is a bad look, or worse, pretending to not get it because you're a Taemint fanatic, is obviously, another problem altogether. And yeah, he was such the "greatest of bandmates" to Jonghyun that he, along with the other three, watched Jjong deteriorate for more than a year before his death, waste away to skin and bones, and write a lengthy suicide note TWO WEEKS before he killed himself and no one, including his mother or SM, took decisive action to prevent what was clearly going to happen. With "mates" like that, who needs enemies?
Claro, porque él aún no lo va a cantar tan bien por la pérdida de su compañero de grupo que lo cantó (Jonghyun). Debió ser difícil para Taemin cantarlo, porque Taemin tiene un buen Rango vocal para interpretarlo.
Maybe consider the fact that he is singing a song that was sung by his bandmate who is no longer with us? You can't judge someone based on something like this if you want to judge his vocal skills you can watch this or many of the other live songs he has performed th-cam.com/video/G05JT4nnDAo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=MW_PLJ1KXyEfFV11
![ILLSLICK X YOUNGOHM - We're The same [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yUJNkobYR0E/mqdefault.jpg)
This shows that he is finally healing, but still loving his Hyung. This is beautiful.🥰
it warms my heart that fans sang along too, we remember
Taemin la canta bien pero la voz de jonghyun es inigualable no habrá otro como el ❤❤❤❤
Ohhh he loves his jonghyun hyung
Teşekkürler taemin onu her şekilde yaşatmaya devam ettiğin için sonsuz teşekkürler
If that was the purpose, why not just play Jonghyun's performance instead of butchering it like this? God.
@@morningsminion3242 bunda mahvetmek gibi bir durumda görmüyorum. Bireysellik yapmıyoruz onlar beraber büyüdüler onlar grup üyeleri Taemin söylemesi zor bir şarkı olduğunu zaten kabul edip içinden geldiği için söylemiş büyütülcek bir durum görmüyorum ben beğendim sen beğenmeyebilirsin
이런 노래를 불러주셔서 너무 기뻐요 종현이 생각날 때 자주 부르는데, 정말 대단한 재능을 갖고 계셨어요.... 제가 좋아하는 아티스트가 제가 좋아하는 종현 노래를 부르는 걸 들을 수 있어서 좋았어요🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠❤❤❤❤
Thank you for sharing!
Taemin, thank you!!! ❤️
중간중간 머뭇거리는게... ㅠㅜ
너무 맘 아파...
그래도 중간에 끊지않고 끝까지 불러줘서 넘 고맙고 수고했어
역시 샤월(탬메이트)!!
Jonghyun💎💙
사랑해요 태민아 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ😭😭😭종현아, 보고싶어...
I love Taemin but…no it just made me miss Jonghyun more😢
"No" is right...this was ghastly, a mockery of Jonghyun's gorgeous performance of this song.
@@morningsminion3242 how is it a mockery??😭😭 are you okay cuz taemin is the last person to ever mock jonghyun
@@sevennn11 Taemin is not the brightest bulb in the socket. In fact, he's most likely the dimmest bulb in any socket he might find himself screwed into. Note I did NOT say Taemin KNOWS this is a mockery. I did not say Taemin KNOWS what he did here is a mockery. He would be the LAST person to notice such a thing, because he feels has little empathy for the feelings of others, only himself.
This personality trait is the only explanation for the fact that he was around Jonghyun most of the time during J's last 18 months, he saw the physical and mental deterioration, he saw the severe weight loss, the crying jags, the deep depression; he knew of the explicit suicide letter J sent to Nine9 TWO WEEKS before his death. And just like everyone from the other members to J's mother to SM, he pretended he didn't see what he saw.
Either that or he KNEW and didn't care. Neither choice is a pretty one. And now here, he sings Jonghyun's song, which J performed with breathtaking passion, half-ass out the side of his mouth, looking at a screen because he's too thoughtless to memorize the words, as if he was a half-drunk Karaoke customer in a run-down alley joint in a bad part of Seoul. Perhaps the worst part of whatever this performance is supposed to be is that it is boring.
And less-than-bright people like you see it as a tribute; and honor of some kind. You Taemints are disgusting.
늘 여전해 너의 팬이자 친구 종현아❤
태민아 사랑해❤
Gracias por honrar a tu hermano el debe mirarte muy feliz desde el cielo inolvidable eterno nuestro amado JONGHYUN ❤❤❤siempre esras en nuestro ❤
눈물이 납니다..
Great job Taemin aahh... Yeokshi, Shawol jjang 😂👏
Estoy llorando
Emotions only 😭🥲😭🥲😭😭😭😭
종현아!대견하지..태민이..하늘서잘보고있지
Tu estas llorando? Porque yo si 🤧gracias Taemin por tu bellisima interpretación nuestro querido Jonghyun siempre vivirá en nuestros corazones por siempre. Shinee saranghae 💗
Taemin ❤❤❤❤❤
Taemin singing this was beautiful. But now it makes me miss jjong more :,)
No. It was not beautiful. Why would you say that? He was off-key and half-ass the entire time.
@@morningsminion3242 what? He was singing this js for fun and maybe a way to remember jonghyun. Its not supposed to be one of the best performances of y si fuera ella too so i dont get your point. And besides i dont think hes trying to mock Jonghyun as they have been the greatest bandmates when jonghyun was still here..
@@Kzcxinq Who, in their right mind sings a half-ass version of one of their dead-by-suicide band-mate's most iconic songs, giggling like a ditz the whole time? Jonghyun sang this magnificently, but here we have Taemin singing like a drunk Karaoke customer on a Saturday night in Gangnam. I don't think he is TRYING to mock Jonghyun deliberately. But I DO think Taemin is not the brightest bulb and has no clue as to how this comes across. Just watch him here: He is a 31-year-old, grown-ass man who acts like a 16-year-old air-head.
You either not getting how this is a bad look, or worse, pretending to not get it because you're a Taemint fanatic, is obviously, another problem altogether.
And yeah, he was such the "greatest of bandmates" to Jonghyun that he, along with the other three, watched Jjong deteriorate for more than a year before his death, waste away to skin and bones, and write a lengthy suicide note TWO WEEKS before he killed himself and no one, including his mother or SM, took decisive action to prevent what was clearly going to happen. With "mates" like that, who needs enemies?
That was beautiful Taemin 🥰😍😘
❤❤
Great performance , the original song is from Spanish singer and writer
Alejandro Sanz , song name is
Si fuera ella .
the cover in Korean was recorded by his member Jonghyun in SHINee debut album, Taemin sang it because of him
Alejandro Sanz quedó gratamente sorprendido por la gran interpretación de su canción por parte de Jonghyun y le felicitó por ello.
Для меня только Джунги!!
No, no. Falta fuerza!!!
Claro, porque él aún no lo va a cantar tan bien por la pérdida de su compañero de grupo que lo cantó (Jonghyun). Debió ser difícil para Taemin cantarlo, porque Taemin tiene un buen Rango vocal para interpretarlo.
Maybe consider the fact that he is singing a song that was sung by his bandmate who is no longer with us? You can't judge someone based on something like this if you want to judge his vocal skills you can watch this or many of the other live songs he has performed th-cam.com/video/G05JT4nnDAo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=MW_PLJ1KXyEfFV11
❤❤❤
❤