MY GRANPARENTS WERE REMOVED FROM THEYR LANDS DURING THE 40S USSR, GRANDAD WAS SENT TO SIBERIA, GRANMOTHER WITH KIDS RELOCATED, ALL THEYR LANDS CONFISCATED. THREE GENERATIONS AFTER WE LIVE IN DIFFEREND VILAGES, DIFFERENT LANDS. OUR GRANDPARENTS NEVER THOUGHT US TO HATE THE RUSSIAN OCUPPAIERS, OR TO KILL. THEY TOUGHT US TO STUDY AND MAKE A LIFE, PLANT A TREE, BULT A HOME, RAISE A CHILED, BE GOOD TO YOUR NEIGHBOURS. ALL THIS PALESTINIAN OBSETION/VICTIM/ETERNAL REFUGY HAS NO SOLUTION BECAUSE THEY DONT WANT A SOLUTION. I STAND WITH ISRAEL
There were massive shifts in populated people in many countries after World War II including Germany, Poland, the Ukraine and India. The partition of India was particularly violent. Ironically, it was done because the Muslims refused to be in a country with Hindus and today Pakistanis are some of the most hateful critics of Israel.
Yasmine, your ability to find the guests who explain the roots of the conflict in Middle East is amazing! So sad that Mohamad lost his business, I actually realized that I was one of the donors on his GoFundMe campaign.
The more I listen to him, the more you need to read the War of Return. @Yasmine, it would be great if you can get this guy and Einat Wilf on the same show to have a discussion.
Thank you Jasmine to bring such brilliant guests every time. Thank you so much Mohammed for you clear insights and brave experiences and understanding. Prayers can enable your thoughts to spread out and reach many, many people to change their minds. May God Bless you and keep you all save...
I like this channel so much because I get to hear different real, true stories about different communities in the Middle East from people who personally experienced it. I'm tired of hearing those hypocritical "experts" in mega podcasts about issues in Middle East. It is shocking to learn about discrimination and bullying the Palestinians face in Arab countries.
I listened to this as a podcast, but had to come here to comment. Thank you again, Yasmine, for such an insightful interview! Once again, forbidden stories being shared. Thank you Mohamad for your fierce bravery and thoughtfulness and fascinating outlooks on so many topics! Your intellect is inspiring. I wish our politicians were open to speaking with people like you. Thank you Yasmine for this platform.
Yasmin I’m your new subscriber. I don’t know why I haven’t subscribed to this gem before, but I’m glad I did now. You’re beautiful, brave and an inspiration. Thank you so much for inviting such an open minded Palestinian man. I knew that not ALL Palestinian people have hatred in their hearts, but to be honest it is difficult to imagine that there are some like your guest. (Although Mossab Hussein jumps to mind too, I respect him immensely🙏) This gives me hope. I’m going to binge-listen to your previous guests. lol 😅 Is there a way to hear about your life story and what inspired you to start your channel? Thank you again. G-d Bless you!! 🙏💕🧿🪬
The guy seems like a nice and reasonable person that can help bring peace to the region, but the Arabs who fled during 1948 are not more special than any other refugees. There was no language, cultural or religious barrier for them to assimilate in Lebanese and Syrian society. It is a purely political ploy to continue to fight against Israel. Israel has no responsibility to let them back into Israel proper. Just like Moroccans and Iraqis don’t have to let Jews back in. Jews that were forced out at the same time. It’s time for the Arabs to grow up and move on. Just like the mizrachi Jews in Israel moved on. They need to care about their children’s future and not their grandfathers imagined honor. He sounds like someone who can help accomplish that.
The only minor idea I would add is that Yishai Fleischer and people like him want Israel to expel HOSTILE Arabs to Gaza, even if they are currently citizens. I'm guessing he might at the same time welcome some non-hostile Muslims, who are kinda de facto Zionists, to replace the hostile militants. I recall Yishai speaking kindly of some Muslim neighbors in Hebron. Thoughts?
Exactly as millions across the world when land was partitioned after empires collapsed and new ethno relgious border were created. The only thing that makes them unique is how they've been rewarded financially for generations on with their jihad and the fictitious bogus intergenerational "refugee" status they still have. The right of return is just a cover for war of return and 1947 2.0.
Lebanon has no responsibility either. Lebanon did not participate in the war and Lebanon has had to deal with the crap from their neighbouring states for a long time - enough. Lebanons civil war was sparked in great part because the Palestinians tried to overthrow the Christian leadership and take over Lebanon. Lebanon is the only Middle Eastern country that has christian representation - it was created to be a haven for Christians in a hostile region. Lebanon is a tiny country - he mentions that if the sunni becomes a majority, then it won't be a problem. He is either extremely naive or he is just projecting his own worldview of how he would conduct himself. It would be a disaster for the Christians. Instead of bashing on Lebanon and putting more pressure on destabilising this tiny country, the neighbours who started the problem in the first place can take up their responsibility and fix the problem. Lebanon has bigger issues.
Same with Indians/Pakistanis, Germans in the Sudentenland, Turks and Greeks, etc...I say call what happened a "population exchange" and call it a day IMO.
@@ela7893 Lebanon from what I know sadly did in 1947 although it is true they didn't in 1967 -- makes me wonder why they just didn't stay neutral or they naively think the non-Muslim Arabs of the region would go through with their vision of secular Arab nationalism (although being a Christian majority at that time, you would think they would accept a 2 state solution there, knowing the history of the Jews of that region, unlike Muslim Arabs who sadly try to erase the Jewish national history there).
this guy brings up all the important stuff if anyone wants to find an apartheid state to rip on - Lebanon is right there. they have different living areas, different rules, different rights, for every single ethnic/religious group. for the palestinians specificaly they just gave 0 rights very famous story from the civil war is that palestinians started making checkpoints for cars in the south, and checked the passengers ID's, if the people were anything but muslim they'd get executed on the spot.
If only this guy would have represented the majority or even a sizeable minority of the people who identify themselves as Palestinians, peace would have already been accomplished. If you wish to learn about the so called “right of return” (which is not a legal right, even per International law), read the book the War of Return.
Mohamad Ghaoui may be reasonable and logical when it comes to the right of return for Palestinians but I think he is an exception. There are so many Palestinians in the United States, Canada, and Australia who are professionals or successful businessmen who are prosperous and successful with one or more generation firmly planted in the country of their diaspora yet they pine for a return to Palestine. The real numbers returning could end up even much larger than the inflated number of registered refugees; Israel as a Jewish country would collapse.
The problem is that the pine to return is in most cases principled and theoretical. Many have admitted to me that they would never want to live under Palestinian rule, and in reality prefer the freedoms they have in the West.
1:18:00 I think this is the best solution that was proposed here: 1 ) dedicate all moneies for any "palestinian" issue to countries that willing to accept them as citizens 2)allow countries to vet them out 3) require them to sign of any claim for right of return or being "palestinian refugee". 4) may be pay some money after staing in new country after 10 years, if they not participate in any support againt this country .
Right of return for refugies is very tricky proposition. Even in situations, when people stay citizens of the country, and they actually were themselves were force out. The best solution is usualy restitution to actual refugies. Also, arab countries forced out about 850 thousands of jews. These countries has to be first in paying restitutions, or accepting "palestinians" as citizens. In case of Israel situation is even more tricky. First, jews want a country where they are majority. There is no other country were jew can have national identity. Secondary, state of radicalisation of arabs who claim be decendents of refugies. No country is obligated to get new citizens, especialy those with emnity to it. I like this guy, his solution is never be accepted by any side.
The Quran can’t be disappeared in the age of technology. However, the Muzzzlim clerical system and madrassa education can be disbanded in most parts of the world using underhand methods where required.
The Qur@@@@n can’t be disappeared in the age of tech. However, the clerical and education system can be disbanded ,if required , by underhand methods. YT automatically disappeared my comment though.
Originally there were 700 Korans. Then they narrowed it down to 35, and for reasons unknown to me, Saudi Arabia got to pick the version that everyone would adopt in the Arab world. The Islamic scholars, some of whom are Christians, sourced the 35 versions and found inconsistencies were too numerous to count, including phrases that existed in one and not in another, and having different interpretations for the same phrases. So as each caliphate dynasty came and went, each one would add information to the Quran that suited their lifestyle. For example, in the 8th century (750 AD), the Abbasids added the part about having multiple wives because they were polygamists. They chose to add it, in order not to corrupt the original Torah and New Testament concepts adopted by the Quran. Arabs in one Caliphate hated Arabs from previous Caliphates, and would remove parts that were previously added. Under normal circumstances, you might argue that Islam is a progressive religion, and their believers are progressive as well, which would be considered a good thing because apparently the Quran is a living document that changes with the times. Unfortunately, knowing that at its roots, Islam is a male dominated, misogynistic, pedophilic, survival of the fittest, combat based power culture, that must constantly prove its mettle through destructive and forceful means, it became more restrictive over time, such as what we see happening in Afghanistan and elsewhere. Obviously this can’t be the direct word of Allah because of the tens of thousands of conflicting interpretations, which are all believed to be genuine, due to the severe penalties people face for questioning the authenticity, validity, and reliability of the Koran, Hadiths (life of Mohammed), and Surahs (stories). What is interesting, and Mohamed alludes to this, is where he says you have to read it in a particular dialect of Arabic. The problem is that the Quran was not written in Arabic. Arabic was invented in the 7th century. What the scholars found was that the original Koran was a book written in Syriac Aramaic. The scholars translated the Arabic Quran into Syriac Aramaic, and then translated that into Arabic. What they found was that concepts were explained in different ways, to allow certain indoctrinations to occur in a top-down fashion. For instance, the 72 white virgins who are voluptuous with sumptuous breasts, in the Syriac Aramaic version are actually firm white grapes. There are paintings of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob going into Paradise in the Islamic version being showered with white grapes. Perhaps eternal damnation is something that came in later on. This is the reason why the book lacks clarity, because it’s not the original anymore, and the only way to get people to accept all these different versions is to threaten their lives, threaten their livelihood in order to get them to keep quiet. And I think we can all agree that Facebook, Instagram, and TH-cam are doing the same thing, and I think we all need to give a big gigantic vote of thanks to Elon Musk for buying Twitter because if it wasn’t for X, we would have the exact same result that Islam gets through force. If Kamala Harris would’ve been elected, that she would’ve been able to trump up some charges on X and get rid of it as well.
My concern with returning to Isreal is what the gentleman said. This group in Lebanon has been largely working with Hezbollah and other resistance groups and the security risks would be immense. I think first they should be given the opportunity to have regular jobs in lebanon and deradicalized then the right of return should be spoken of.
I still think he can technically "return" by applying for Israeli citizenship (he's an American citizen so he can have a chance there IMO as he seems to be one whose really pushing for peace).
@@zjzr08 I'm guessing that it would be very difficult, even impossible for him to become an Israeli citizen. If it were that easy, thousands of American citizens with Palestinian ancestry would have returned by becoming naturalized citizens of Israel. In fact, I wonder how easy it would be for them to just visit Israel.
@@stephenfisher3721 We hear a lot of stories of Palestinian Americans going to Israel for vacation and such and also in the West Bank (some even think being "discriminated" against in the airport security is a "badge of honor").
There is no right of return to someone else country. He is born in Lebanon. He is citizen there . If other countries want to accept him, good. No other country have to do it.
1:26:00 i think thats just a terminology issue although i agree it should be addressed, i think a better way to say this is "this is not what islam/muhammed meant"
The Qur@@@@n can’t be disappeared in the age of tech. However, the clerical and education systems can be disbanded ,if required , by underhand methods. It’s also enough to set apostates free in countries where that is not possible like UAE, Saudi and India. YT automatically disappears my comment though.
Another excellent interview. I didn't know that Lebanon had such an iron curtain, but it sure makes sense. Here's an idea for a future interview:Ahmad Joudeh, author of Dance or Die (Syrian male ballet dancer who survived domestic violence, civil war, and ISIS trying to murder him).
While I don't think it's still THE apartheid I do think that Lebanon is doing a horrible job in absorbing Palestinian Arabs, when I argue the Sunni Muslim there are the same as the ones in the region I call Sham (i.e. Levantine Arab). Lebanese Sunni Arabs can literally have a lot more power absorbing them and even consider "dual citizenship" with "the Palestinian state" if they want to keep being Israel's enemy. It feels weird Lebanon tries to make Palestinian Arabs miserable while apparently being in solidarity with them. They think more hate would be effective in this scenario (although it is true many Lebanese-Palestinians just seem to blame Israelis than the Lebanese for their issues).
You can't mix politics with business. It's toxic. Don't put politics on your business web site. America does have free speech, but you have to be willing to suffer the consequences of those who keep politics separate or disagree.
Never in history was palestinian poeple or nation cal palestine. Palestine was geograpic region name for the land in including jordan in the time off the british mandate. It's also cal trans jordan.palestine is latin name not arabic name.the arabs take this identity in 1964 by yasser arafat egyptian man like many off these arabs caling themself palestinian came frome.in the 19 centery 1878 the ottoman sultan bring arabs frome the suranded arab cuntry as working immigrat.the same with the british mandate in the baginnig off 20 centery.these are the arabs caling themself palestinian.you can tel wish arab cuntry the came frome by the family name el masri frome egypt.el baghdadi.frome iraq.tamimi frome saudia.jewish poeple was always in the land off israel.before 1967 west bank was jordan not palestine.the same with gaza was egypt before 1967 not palestine.is many physical evidence this land belong to the jewish poeple archeologic.in the quran israel mention 43 time palestine 0 time.
If there is a right of return for Arabs to Israel, why is there not a right of return for Jews to return to the Arab countries? Most of Israel's Jews are from Arab countries. If there is to be restitution for Arabs, there must be restitution for Jews from Arab countries. Fair for one must be fair for all.
No one can force country to accept foreign people as citizens. It may be reasonable to satisfy economic claims, but only to people who were refugies. Children who born outside have no claim.
Even the Prophet Muhammad liked jewish food. He would have eaten there🤷🏻♀️ And yes, some of the Hamas terrorists got the kidnapped israeli to cook them jewish food. Multiple times
@@stephenfisher3721You must be american since you are making this about US slavery. Muslims in the middel east are very familiar with jewish food. They buy them from jewish shops. Classic middel eastern tradition. The point being that the foods are similar and not even islamist fanatics would boicott the jewish food. People in the USA gets offended on palestinians behalf for no reason. A joint israeli/palestine resturant makes sense. They have been living together for centurys. Muslims and jews would eat at the resturant until someone makes this a negative thing.
Originally there were 700 Korans. Then they narrowed it down to 35, and for reasons unknown to me, Saudi Arabia got to pick the version that everyone would adopt in the Arab world. The Islamic scholars, some of whom are Christians, sourced the 35 versions and found inconsistencies were too numerous to count, including phrases that existed in one and not in another, and having different interpretations for the same phrases. So as each caliphate dynasty came and went, each one would add information to the Quran that suited their lifestyle. For example, in the 8th century (750 AD), the Abbasids added the part about having multiple wives because they were polygamists. They chose to add it, in order not to corrupt the original Torah and New Testament concepts adopted by the Quran. Arabs in one Caliphate hated Arabs from previous Caliphates, and would remove parts that were previously added. Under normal circumstances, you might argue that Islam is a progressive religion, and their believers are progressive as well, which would be considered a good thing because apparently the Quran is a living document that changes with the times. Unfortunately, knowing that at its roots, Islam is a male dominated, misogynistic, pedophilic, survival of the fittest, combat based power culture, that must constantly prove its mettle through destructive and forceful means, it became more restrictive over time, such as what we see happening in Afghanistan and elsewhere. Obviously this can’t be the direct word of Allah because of the tens of thousands of conflicting interpretations, which are all believed to be genuine, due to the severe penalties people face for questioning the authenticity, validity, and reliability of the Koran, Hadiths (life of Mohammed), and Surahs (stories). What is interesting, and Mohamed alludes to this, is where he says you have to read it in a particular dialect of Arabic. The problem is that the Quran was not written in Arabic. Arabic was invented in the 7th century. What the scholars found was that the original Koran was a book written in Syriac Aramaic. The scholars translated the Arabic Quran into Syriac Aramaic, and then translated that into Arabic. What they found was that concepts were explained in different ways, to allow certain indoctrinations to occur in a top-down fashion. For instance, the 72 white virgins who are voluptuous with sumptuous breasts, in the Syriac Aramaic version are actually firm white grapes. There are paintings of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob going into Paradise in the Islamic version being showered with white grapes. Perhaps eternal damnation is something that came in later on. This is the reason why the book lacks clarity, because it’s not the original anymore, and the only way to get people to accept all these different versions is to threaten their lives, threaten their livelihood in order to get them to keep quiet. And I think we can all agree that Facebook, Instagram, and TH-cam are doing the same thing, and I think we all need to give a big gigantic vote of thanks to Elon Musk for buying Twitter because if it wasn’t for X, we would have the exact same result that Islam gets through force. If Kamala Harris would’ve been elected, that she would’ve been able to trump up some charges on X and get rid of it as well.
MY GRANPARENTS WERE REMOVED FROM THEYR LANDS DURING THE 40S USSR, GRANDAD WAS SENT TO SIBERIA, GRANMOTHER WITH KIDS RELOCATED, ALL THEYR LANDS CONFISCATED. THREE GENERATIONS AFTER WE LIVE IN DIFFEREND VILAGES, DIFFERENT LANDS. OUR GRANDPARENTS NEVER THOUGHT US TO HATE THE RUSSIAN OCUPPAIERS, OR TO KILL. THEY TOUGHT US TO STUDY AND MAKE A LIFE, PLANT A TREE, BULT A HOME, RAISE A CHILED, BE GOOD TO YOUR NEIGHBOURS.
ALL THIS PALESTINIAN OBSETION/VICTIM/ETERNAL REFUGY HAS NO SOLUTION BECAUSE THEY DONT WANT A SOLUTION.
I STAND WITH ISRAEL
We all thought you stand with CapsLock.
There were massive shifts in populated people in many countries after World War II including Germany, Poland, the Ukraine and India.
The partition of India was particularly violent. Ironically, it was done because the Muslims refused to be in a country with Hindus and today Pakistanis are some of the most hateful critics of Israel.
why are you screaming lol😅
WELL SAID. I AGREE WITH YOUR VIEWS 100 %
Yasmine, your ability to find the guests who explain the roots of the conflict in Middle East is amazing! So sad that Mohamad lost his business, I actually realized that I was one of the donors on his GoFundMe campaign.
Pls ask her to interview Brigget Gabrielle
Thank you very much ❤ from Haifa
The more I listen to him, the more you need to read the War of Return. @Yasmine, it would be great if you can get this guy and Einat Wilf on the same show to have a discussion.
She was on here 4 months ago
Thank you, Yasmin, for your tireless work ❤
Thank you Jasmine to bring such brilliant guests every time. Thank you so much Mohammed for you clear insights and brave experiences and understanding. Prayers can enable your thoughts to spread out and reach many, many people to change their minds. May God Bless you and keep you all save...
I like this channel so much because I get to hear different real, true stories about different communities in the Middle East from people who personally experienced it.
I'm tired of hearing those hypocritical "experts" in mega podcasts about issues in Middle East.
It is shocking to learn about discrimination and bullying the Palestinians face in Arab countries.
You are the best at what you do Yasmine.
I listened to this as a podcast, but had to come here to comment. Thank you again, Yasmine, for such an insightful interview! Once again, forbidden stories being shared. Thank you Mohamad for your fierce bravery and thoughtfulness and fascinating outlooks on so many topics! Your intellect is inspiring.
I wish our politicians were open to speaking with people like you. Thank you Yasmine for this platform.
Yasmin I’m your new subscriber. I don’t know why I haven’t subscribed to this gem before, but I’m glad I did now. You’re beautiful, brave and an inspiration. Thank you so much for inviting such an open minded Palestinian man. I knew that not ALL Palestinian people have hatred in their hearts, but to be honest it is difficult to imagine that there are some like your guest. (Although Mossab Hussein jumps to mind too, I respect him immensely🙏) This gives me hope. I’m going to binge-listen to your previous guests. lol 😅
Is there a way to hear about your life story and what inspired you to start your channel? Thank you again. G-d Bless you!! 🙏💕🧿🪬
Check out Yasmine’s episodes with Hamza Howidy, and Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib.
@@keeks123 thank you for your suggestions! I can’t wait to listen to those as well. 🙏
Respect to both of you 👏
Yasmine will you pls interview Brigget Gabrielle pls pls pls
she is remarkable. So much insight, energy and passion.
Thank you, Mohamad and Yasmine, for speaking the truth!
UNRWA does not want to get dissolved.
31,000 employees
Díky!
Thank you for bringing the real voices of Palestine!
Thank you for your work
Looking forward to this ❤!
Fantastic discussion. One of the best. Thank you.
I just want to give Mo a hug.
I so wish more people to listen to this.
The guy seems like a nice and reasonable person that can help bring peace to the region, but the Arabs who fled during 1948 are not more special than any other refugees. There was no language, cultural or religious barrier for them to assimilate in Lebanese and Syrian society. It is a purely political ploy to continue to fight against Israel. Israel has no responsibility to let them back into Israel proper. Just like Moroccans and Iraqis don’t have to let Jews back in. Jews that were forced out at the same time. It’s time for the Arabs to grow up and move on. Just like the mizrachi Jews in Israel moved on. They need to care about their children’s future and not their grandfathers imagined honor. He sounds like someone who can help accomplish that.
The only minor idea I would add is that Yishai Fleischer and people like him want Israel to expel HOSTILE Arabs to Gaza, even if they are currently citizens. I'm guessing he might at the same time welcome some non-hostile Muslims, who are kinda de facto Zionists, to replace the hostile militants.
I recall Yishai speaking kindly of some Muslim neighbors in Hebron.
Thoughts?
Exactly as millions across the world when land was partitioned after empires collapsed and new ethno relgious border were created.
The only thing that makes them unique is how they've been rewarded financially for generations on with their jihad and the fictitious bogus intergenerational "refugee" status they still have.
The right of return is just a cover for war of return and 1947 2.0.
Lebanon has no responsibility either. Lebanon did not participate in the war and Lebanon has had to deal with the crap from their neighbouring states for a long time - enough. Lebanons civil war was sparked in great part because the Palestinians tried to overthrow the Christian leadership and take over Lebanon. Lebanon is the only Middle Eastern country that has christian representation - it was created to be a haven for Christians in a hostile region. Lebanon is a tiny country - he mentions that if the sunni becomes a majority, then it won't be a problem. He is either extremely naive or he is just projecting his own worldview of how he would conduct himself. It would be a disaster for the Christians. Instead of bashing on Lebanon and putting more pressure on destabilising this tiny country, the neighbours who started the problem in the first place can take up their responsibility and fix the problem. Lebanon has bigger issues.
Same with Indians/Pakistanis, Germans in the Sudentenland, Turks and Greeks, etc...I say call what happened a "population exchange" and call it a day IMO.
@@ela7893 Lebanon from what I know sadly did in 1947 although it is true they didn't in 1967 -- makes me wonder why they just didn't stay neutral or they naively think the non-Muslim Arabs of the region would go through with their vision of secular Arab nationalism (although being a Christian majority at that time, you would think they would accept a 2 state solution there, knowing the history of the Jews of that region, unlike Muslim Arabs who sadly try to erase the Jewish national history there).
this guy brings up all the important stuff
if anyone wants to find an apartheid state to rip on - Lebanon is right there. they have different living areas, different rules, different rights, for every single ethnic/religious group. for the palestinians specificaly they just gave 0 rights
very famous story from the civil war is that palestinians started making checkpoints for cars in the south, and checked the passengers ID's, if the people were anything but muslim they'd get executed on the spot.
Gaza has worse apartheid, Jews are not allowed even to live there NTM to own a house, property or business
If only this guy would have represented the majority or even a sizeable minority of the people who identify themselves as Palestinians, peace would have already been accomplished. If you wish to learn about the so called “right of return” (which is not a legal right, even per International law), read the book the War of Return.
Thanks for sharing. Can you get your message the people at SJP/JVP watch this and stop harrassing American Jews, not even Israelis.
Mohamad Ghaoui may be reasonable and logical when it comes to the right of return for Palestinians but I think he is an exception.
There are so many Palestinians in the United States, Canada, and Australia who are professionals or successful businessmen who are prosperous and successful with one or more generation firmly planted in the country of their diaspora yet they pine for a return to Palestine. The real numbers returning could end up even much larger than the inflated number of registered refugees; Israel as a Jewish country would collapse.
The problem is that the pine to return is in most cases principled and theoretical. Many have admitted to me that they would never want to live under Palestinian rule, and in reality prefer the freedoms they have in the West.
1:18:00 I think this is the best solution that was proposed here: 1 ) dedicate all moneies for any "palestinian" issue to countries that willing to accept them as citizens 2)allow countries to vet them out 3) require them to sign of any claim for right of return or being "palestinian refugee". 4) may be pay some money after staing in new country after 10 years, if they not participate in any support againt this country .
Right of return for refugies is very tricky proposition. Even in situations, when people stay citizens of the country, and they actually were themselves were force out. The best solution is usualy restitution to actual refugies. Also, arab countries forced out about 850 thousands of jews. These countries has to be first in paying restitutions, or accepting "palestinians" as citizens. In case of Israel situation is even more tricky. First, jews want a country where they are majority. There is no other country were jew can have national identity. Secondary, state of radicalisation of arabs who claim be decendents of refugies. No country is obligated to get new citizens, especialy those with emnity to it.
I like this guy, his solution is never be accepted by any side.
without changing the actual islamic book, the quran, nothing is going to change
The Quran can’t be disappeared in the age of technology. However, the Muzzzlim clerical system and madrassa education can be disbanded in most parts of the world using underhand methods where required.
The Qur@@@@n can’t be disappeared in the age of tech. However, the clerical and education system can be disbanded ,if required , by underhand methods.
YT automatically disappeared my comment though.
They have Jordan, which is the state of the Palestinians.
I have heard many Arab leaders saying, let’s solve the Palestinian problem first, then talk about the economic progress and education.
They do, because how they make fortune for themselves from international help .
❤
Originally there were 700 Korans. Then they narrowed it down to 35, and for reasons unknown to me, Saudi Arabia got to pick the version that everyone would adopt in the Arab world. The Islamic scholars, some of whom are Christians, sourced the 35 versions and found inconsistencies were too numerous to count, including phrases that existed in one and not in another, and having different interpretations for the same phrases. So as each caliphate dynasty came and went, each one would add information to the Quran that suited their lifestyle. For example, in the 8th century (750 AD), the Abbasids added the part about having multiple wives because they were polygamists. They chose to add it, in order not to corrupt the original Torah and New Testament concepts adopted by the Quran. Arabs in one Caliphate hated Arabs from previous Caliphates, and would remove parts that were previously added. Under normal circumstances, you might argue that Islam is a progressive religion, and their believers are progressive as well, which would be considered a good thing because apparently the Quran is a living document that changes with the times. Unfortunately, knowing that at its roots, Islam is a male dominated, misogynistic, pedophilic, survival of the fittest, combat based power culture, that must constantly prove its mettle through destructive and forceful means, it became more restrictive over time, such as what we see happening in Afghanistan and elsewhere. Obviously this can’t be the direct word of Allah because of the tens of thousands of conflicting interpretations, which are all believed to be genuine, due to the severe penalties people face for questioning the authenticity, validity, and reliability of the Koran, Hadiths (life of Mohammed), and Surahs (stories). What is interesting, and Mohamed alludes to this, is where he says you have to read it in a particular dialect of Arabic. The problem is that the Quran was not written in Arabic. Arabic was invented in the 7th century. What the scholars found was that the original Koran was a book written in Syriac Aramaic. The scholars translated the Arabic Quran into Syriac Aramaic, and then translated that into Arabic. What they found was that concepts were explained in different ways, to allow certain indoctrinations to occur in a top-down fashion. For instance, the 72 white virgins who are voluptuous with sumptuous breasts, in the Syriac Aramaic version are actually firm white grapes. There are paintings of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob going into Paradise in the Islamic version being showered with white grapes. Perhaps eternal damnation is something that came in later on. This is the reason why the book lacks clarity, because it’s not the original anymore, and the only way to get people to accept all these different versions is to threaten their lives, threaten their livelihood in order to get them to keep quiet. And I think we can all agree that Facebook, Instagram, and TH-cam are doing the same thing, and I think we all need to give a big gigantic vote of thanks to Elon Musk for buying Twitter because if it wasn’t for X, we would have the exact same result that Islam gets through force. If Kamala Harris would’ve been elected, that she would’ve been able to trump up some charges on X and get rid of it as well.
My concern with returning to Isreal is what the gentleman said. This group in Lebanon has been largely working with Hezbollah and other resistance groups and the security risks would be immense. I think first they should be given the opportunity to have regular jobs in lebanon and deradicalized then the right of return should be spoken of.
I still think he can technically "return" by applying for Israeli citizenship (he's an American citizen so he can have a chance there IMO as he seems to be one whose really pushing for peace).
@@zjzr08
I'm guessing that it would be very difficult, even impossible for him to become an Israeli citizen.
If it were that easy, thousands of American citizens with Palestinian ancestry would have returned by becoming naturalized citizens of Israel. In fact, I wonder how easy it would be for them to just visit Israel.
@@stephenfisher3721 We hear a lot of stories of Palestinian Americans going to Israel for vacation and such and also in the West Bank (some even think being "discriminated" against in the airport security is a "badge of honor").
There is no right of return to someone else country. He is born in Lebanon. He is citizen there . If other countries want to accept him, good. No other country have to do it.
1:26:00 i think thats just a terminology issue although i agree it should be addressed, i think a better way to say this is "this is not what islam/muhammed meant"
She was born in Lebanon
The Qur@@@@n can’t be disappeared in the age of tech. However, the clerical and education systems can be disbanded ,if required , by underhand methods.
It’s also enough to set apostates free in countries where that is not possible like UAE, Saudi and India.
YT automatically disappears my comment though.
Another excellent interview. I didn't know that Lebanon had such an iron curtain, but it sure makes sense.
Here's an idea for a future interview:Ahmad Joudeh, author of Dance or Die (Syrian male ballet dancer who survived domestic violence, civil war, and ISIS trying to murder him).
Iron curtain usually refers to the communist countries under the influence of the Soviet Union. Why do you say "iron curtain"?
While I don't think it's still THE apartheid I do think that Lebanon is doing a horrible job in absorbing Palestinian Arabs, when I argue the Sunni Muslim there are the same as the ones in the region I call Sham (i.e. Levantine Arab). Lebanese Sunni Arabs can literally have a lot more power absorbing them and even consider "dual citizenship" with "the Palestinian state" if they want to keep being Israel's enemy. It feels weird Lebanon tries to make Palestinian Arabs miserable while apparently being in solidarity with them. They think more hate would be effective in this scenario (although it is true many Lebanese-Palestinians just seem to blame Israelis than the Lebanese for their issues).
You can't mix politics with business. It's toxic. Don't put politics on your business web site. America does have free speech, but you have to be willing to suffer the consequences of those who keep politics separate or disagree.
I leave in Israel, do you know how many different kinds of Homos we have?
Never in history was palestinian poeple or nation cal palestine. Palestine was geograpic region name for the land in including jordan in the time off the british mandate. It's also cal trans jordan.palestine is latin name not arabic name.the arabs take this identity in 1964 by yasser arafat egyptian man like many off these arabs caling themself palestinian came frome.in the 19 centery 1878 the ottoman sultan bring arabs frome the suranded arab cuntry as working immigrat.the same with the british mandate in the baginnig off 20 centery.these are the arabs caling themself palestinian.you can tel wish arab cuntry the came frome by the family name el masri frome egypt.el baghdadi.frome iraq.tamimi frome saudia.jewish poeple was always in the land off israel.before 1967 west bank was jordan not palestine.the same with gaza was egypt before 1967 not palestine.is many physical evidence this land belong to the jewish poeple archeologic.in the quran israel mention 43 time palestine 0 time.
im all for the right of return for arabs only it should be to mecca
Comments like that help no one.
Pointing out the obvious is always helpful
There is no national identity or language to differentiate them from any other Arab
You are so much because you have so much childrens even if want to return you can not because Palestine is so much little
If there is a right of return for Arabs to Israel, why is there not a right of return for Jews to return to the Arab countries? Most of Israel's Jews are from Arab countries.
If there is to be restitution for Arabs, there must be restitution for Jews from Arab countries.
Fair for one must be fair for all.
The amount of wealth looted by the Arabs at that time should be calculable and reparations be made
No one can force country to accept foreign people as citizens. It may be reasonable to satisfy economic claims, but only to people who were refugies. Children who born outside have no claim.
Even the Prophet Muhammad liked jewish food. He would have eaten there🤷🏻♀️
And yes, some of the Hamas terrorists got the kidnapped israeli to cook them jewish food. Multiple times
What is your point?
During times of slavery in the United States, black slaves cooked all the food.
@@stephenfisher3721You must be american since you are making this about US slavery. Muslims in the middel east are very familiar with jewish food. They buy them from jewish shops. Classic middel eastern tradition.
The point being that the foods are similar and not even islamist fanatics would boicott the jewish food. People in the USA gets offended on palestinians behalf for no reason. A joint israeli/palestine resturant makes sense. They have been living together for centurys. Muslims and jews would eat at the resturant until someone makes this a negative thing.
The quest is twisting the quran verses, we all know Arabic very well brother,,
brother, your explanation about inheritance doesn't make sense, brother we don't Arabic very very well...
Originally there were 700 Korans. Then they narrowed it down to 35, and for reasons unknown to me, Saudi Arabia got to pick the version that everyone would adopt in the Arab world. The Islamic scholars, some of whom are Christians, sourced the 35 versions and found inconsistencies were too numerous to count, including phrases that existed in one and not in another, and having different interpretations for the same phrases. So as each caliphate dynasty came and went, each one would add information to the Quran that suited their lifestyle. For example, in the 8th century (750 AD), the Abbasids added the part about having multiple wives because they were polygamists. They chose to add it, in order not to corrupt the original Torah and New Testament concepts adopted by the Quran. Arabs in one Caliphate hated Arabs from previous Caliphates, and would remove parts that were previously added. Under normal circumstances, you might argue that Islam is a progressive religion, and their believers are progressive as well, which would be considered a good thing because apparently the Quran is a living document that changes with the times. Unfortunately, knowing that at its roots, Islam is a male dominated, misogynistic, pedophilic, survival of the fittest, combat based power culture, that must constantly prove its mettle through destructive and forceful means, it became more restrictive over time, such as what we see happening in Afghanistan and elsewhere. Obviously this can’t be the direct word of Allah because of the tens of thousands of conflicting interpretations, which are all believed to be genuine, due to the severe penalties people face for questioning the authenticity, validity, and reliability of the Koran, Hadiths (life of Mohammed), and Surahs (stories). What is interesting, and Mohamed alludes to this, is where he says you have to read it in a particular dialect of Arabic. The problem is that the Quran was not written in Arabic. Arabic was invented in the 7th century. What the scholars found was that the original Koran was a book written in Syriac Aramaic. The scholars translated the Arabic Quran into Syriac Aramaic, and then translated that into Arabic. What they found was that concepts were explained in different ways, to allow certain indoctrinations to occur in a top-down fashion. For instance, the 72 white virgins who are voluptuous with sumptuous breasts, in the Syriac Aramaic version are actually firm white grapes. There are paintings of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob going into Paradise in the Islamic version being showered with white grapes. Perhaps eternal damnation is something that came in later on. This is the reason why the book lacks clarity, because it’s not the original anymore, and the only way to get people to accept all these different versions is to threaten their lives, threaten their livelihood in order to get them to keep quiet. And I think we can all agree that Facebook, Instagram, and TH-cam are doing the same thing, and I think we all need to give a big gigantic vote of thanks to Elon Musk for buying Twitter because if it wasn’t for X, we would have the exact same result that Islam gets through force. If Kamala Harris would’ve been elected, that she would’ve been able to trump up some charges on X and get rid of it as well.