this is how i wish the song really was. the way the screams get more intense in the second chorus and the end the piano is doing the “what a waste of army dreamers”. it’s so soft at the end, like they’re trying to lull him to sleep for a peaceful final rest. like a mother would. i can practically see her son’s life from start to finish in this song. it gives you closure. but that only makes it more tragic. this could bring me to tears.
since many people forget it’s still a thing. this makes me think of child soldiers in africa.. i’ve heard many sad stories this song reminds me of them 🇨🇩🇳🇬
It's so wonderful. I can't describe it words. These sounds of the choir, like a funeral service in a church, add so much atmosphere to this track. Amazing 🌹
I’m not sure why, but this version sounds eerily hopeful. Almost as if the choir of soldiers mourn the lives they could have while also wishing their sons a brighter future.
I imagine this song like a story. The intro part is were we appear in the soldier funeral in a church where the choir, family and friends are grieving. The army dreamers part is were we see the fallen soldier leaving for the army then cuts to training. Were it builds up to conflict and death. The outro part is back to the funeral were we only see the mother. Showing a grave then many graves, to show its a graveyard full of dead soldiers.
It sounds so dreamy yet more tragic in a way as you can connect with the music more, hope it makes sense but i actually love it. The title never tells lies
OMG THE BEGINNING WAS SAMPLED FROM CHOR LEONI WASNT IT!!!! I love their version of the song. it just adds so much more soul when you hear all those voices!
My younger sister unexpectedly passed away a few years ago- she was a prodigy ACE/STEM student who wanted to become a politician and advocate for women's rights in the workplace, and she was really passionate about music, specifically singing. She passed away in her sleep at 16 due to an at the time undiagnosed Long-QT syndrome, that caused her heart to stop while she sleeped. This song makes me think about her- I knew she was going to do great things in the world, and she was a genuinely amazing person, so it hurts a lot to think about how she never had the chance to achieve her own dreams and see the fruits of her labor. A lot of my initial grief at her loss revolved around the fact that she genuinely did not deserve to die- she was kind, hard-working, and despite the harsh environments we were raised in she always did her best to be responsible and do the right thing. She wanted to make the world a better place and did all the work to have a great start in doing so, only to be robbed of the chance from initially unknown causes, and I felt angry with myself and the world for what it took- and for a while, I felt like I wasn't worthy of living in the world over her. It took a lot of grieving but I eventually did come to terms with her death, and I promised her that I would do my best to achieve my own dreams for her. I falter sometimes, and I wish I could do better, but I'm getting there, and I want to do right by her, even if she isn't here anymore. I really love this song, it hits me really hard emotionally and despite the more light airy tone, it's such a genuinely heartbreaking experience when you've gone through a loss like that. This rearrangement does a lot better of a job at the instrumental/backing elements that I felt were lacking in the original, and it comes together to be really moving. Thank you for rearranging it, and thank Kate Bush for making such a touching work of art. Sorry to vent some heavy stuff in a comment like this, but this song (and rearrangement) resonated with me really heavily and I wanted to share how it made me feel.
I haven't listened to the rest,but you missed 2 lines. Ty for ur gud work in providing the lyrics To carry home my little soldier (What could he do?) (Should have been a rockstar) But he didn't have the money for a guitar
it makes me so disgusted how people forget and demonize elderly and children who served. they were all kids. they all had families, and we still dont take care of them. i met a vet in nyc once and his story tore me apart. he lost everything, in war and after. and no one helped him. he was alone sitting in a McDonalds with teenagers threatening him. he had dreams too.
@@Maryam-xr2ht im not orginal comentor but i do wanna say that i agree with you. thats why i beleive in hating the millitary and not the vets. at the end of the day the milltary use nationalism and money to go over and destroy countries for greed. and i completely understand why you mention iraq. iraq, vietnam, phillipenes, afghanistan, syria and so many countries deserve justice. they did not deserve what happened to them, not matter what justification the goverments use. but the people in the western world are not evil (dont get me wrong there were individuals who did do henious war crimes though but not everyone), the goverments are, but not the people. most these people were tricked into defending their countries through manipulation, paying off their loans or being conspricted into wars. most people were unfortunately following orders, war and violence is unfortunately complex but all it leaves at the end of the day is broken dreams, families and communties where ever it starts and ends. from the wars now to the wars thousands of years ago. war is the most horrible disgusting act humans do.
@@Maryam-xr2ht those people had dreams too, yes. my point is that, to completely demonize every person in the military is horrible. and that includes people in iraq who served and died in action. death in war is tragic no matter ethnicity.
This song revived a memory of when I watched short documentary a few years ago (I believe it was on VICE) about the process of recovering the remains of soldiers in the Russo-Ukrainian war that's STILL ongoing. The footage itself was pretty heavy, but what stuck in my mind were their ID photos, their IDs recovered from them as the only means of knowing who they were. So young, their lives cut short. So unfair. War is true horror.
Not many songs made me to get goosebumps, nor tearing up. I'm not lying but this version and song in general is just too perfect and couldn't hold my emotions back. This is definetely my favorite song and version ever
@@Gabriela-bs5yi I don’t know. I feel like she wouldn’t knowing how she posted a thank you about Running up that hill hitting number #1 on her website because she has zero social media
i'm so impressed... i've always been the kind of person that stays super faithful to the original song because, in dance, people use covers/remixes of songs that just don't hit the same way as the original yk? but this? this was perfect. thank you for making this because it's just MWAH :D
The algorithm put this in my playlist and I was like, “wait, this is so good. Why haven’t I heard this version before?” Then I saw that it’s fan made. Good job!
I've been drafted to serve 14 months starting this fall, and after hearing songs like these i kinda get to the realization that i maybe don't want to toss my life away so simply.
This song feels especially strong when there is war and dictatorship in your country. Thousands of army dreamers who are dying now are next to me, simply because the authorities wanted to play war. It destroys me every day
I found this gem at midnight and i got chills and tears The original was already beautiful and thought can this get any better You made it happen, A song already so beautiful, Singlehandedly made more ethereal My heart felt calm And the tears in my eyes were genuine to the beauty within this song and this version.
This song is honestly so calming! I have almost fallen asleep to it so many times, mainly the outro. Like, that part is so calming i could listen to it on repeat!!
oh my god i literally was thinking like. yesterday. to combine this choir with the og song and im SO glad someone else beat me to it, this is so gorgeous. thank you for elevating this song
@@isobeljames1328 yes, it did. Im not saying the whole entire tuing is better. But it enhances it more. The song actaully seems like a mother who is mourning the death of her son. So, yes, it is a bit better. this is an opinion. Thank you. (Not trying to be rude)
Came across this on accident while writing a book report on the era of terrorism (and war) in Peru. THANK YOU. This is genuinely motivating me so much omg
Great song, makes me think of something I was told from a former 2/75 dude who was in Iraq and Afghanistan just after 9/11 He thought that going to war or joining the army would make him a man. He wasn't poor, he wasn't drafted, but he thought that was his responsibility as a man. But he then explained that being a man was more. It was protecting people, not interests or ideas, and being kind, generous, compassionate and caring. I'm still planning on joining the Army. But I doubt I will forget what he said.
This remix is really good, I particularly like the moments where we hear the male voices in the background, like a call for dead soldiers, it really brings some wonderful things to the song ❤
This edit really mad me feel a hint of sadness; I Imagined all these soldiers during ww1 going to war not knowing anything about what they’ll endure, and for what ? It was such a tragic war
My dads best friend joined the Rio de Janeiro state military police in the late 90s, and he died only three days later. He got ambushed by drug dealers in a favela, him and his partner died, my dad always remembers him as a great dude, i would have liked to meet him
This is actually so gorgeous I am, infact, crying this very second. This song means a lot to me and pulls on my heart strings if you couldn’t tell (I’m not joking I’m actually crying right now)
My grandad served during Vietnam, he passed nearly 4 years ago and some days I really miss him. I wish I asked more about his time in the military and what he did, he seemed like such a cool person. I really wish I wasn't so angsty back then and actually tried to connect with him. Miss you Grandad ❤
I can feel the soldier singing with Kate Bush was calm and restful, giving sounded voice for their country has been free from war. How I look at my grandpa who used to be a soldier too and had the same fate. He served in the French Fourth Republic in 1951 as a co-pilot, looking down in the window and seeing his people die and cry in pain, gun shooting trying to defend themself but fate died on them. He can't do anything but watch them suffer in the hell-less war of many casualties and feel sad and regret. After 6 years of serving, he returns to his village home. with grandma and my mom (with my aunt sliding) waiting for him. While eating dinner, still remembering the fate of his people, he cried and broke down. One night, he heard the spirit of his people (including soldiers) singing and cheering. Even though he saw it was a hallucination, he felt sad but happy, because he knew they would be free from their cycle of pain and fly up, resting their soul, knowing their true best for their country. He continued living, forgetting the past that he witnessed to let their spirit go and support another country that was stuck in warfare and homelessness. after his older self, he gave his tale to me and wished I'd respect others and soldier who fight for their country. And after a long life, he is gone...passed away, not even knowing that he's gone (I was 9 back then). Then I see a pigeon, fly toward my backyard and sing the song. Then my realization kicked in, he had gone without my goodbye. I miss him, he was kind and protected me ever since I was in kindergarten, defended me from my bully, lectured me about the meaning of life, and told his story of how he used to be. I felt I wasn't worth living in the world. It took much grieving of mental depression to my grandpa's death, I wish I could see him one last time, I want to see his smile and his determent, but I know he isn't here anymore. But when I hear the song Army Dreamers - Kate Bush in 2019 (and your song, like a remaster or something). It hits me really hard emotionally, the tome, chord background like many soldiers passed away makes me remember my grandpa. Make me want to live and continue to my destination, my dream, and my purpose to stop me from ending myself and living happily for him and for my soul. Thank you Kate Bush (and you) for making such a touching masterpiece work of beauty. .Don't worry, this comment is about my feelings about remembering my grandpa.
I know im a lil late but this is amazing! I love this version sm and this is the first "but its better" that is actually much better, it has really touched my soul ❤
Wow, this is actually heavenly, the singing of the fallen Army Dreamers, something about this rendition of the song hits hard, it pierces the heart and soul, this is absolutely perfect requiem for our fallen soldiers. Thank you for this rendition of Army dreamers.
Wow, that was the most magical version of the song! ❤ the emotional and vocal range of the singer is incredible and the musicians in the orchestra are truly experts 😮 just perfect❤
It reminds me of a mother in WW1 who sees each man going to the thresholds of the mothers next door, but her son never comes home, and all of her life with her son flashes before her eyes, realizing that her baby will never bless her eyes again.
This song... It filled my head in a way I never thought any song would, like pure dopamine, it felt like I was underwater and my brain was floating... Just like magic... I felt safe...
if anyone wants the full choir version, it's choir leoni. the video should pop up if you search up army dreamers choir or something similiar, 100% recommend listening to it.
This may be one of my favorite videos that I have come across on any platform. The way the choir compliments the main lyrical components is simply angelic, to say the least. This is a masterpiece in my eyes, melancholy and peaceful, sincere and pure. Thank you for this.
The song reminds me of lullaby made for all the soldiers in really any war ever, that are being properly putted to sleep. So wonderful, touching, yet disturbing lyrics and melody, love it :)
This song reminds me of my grandmother because in 2019, she lost her son who participated in the army (he died due to a motorcycle accident) and the lyrics match that so much ❤❤
im sorry guys i tried my best but you'll just have to listen on youtube (look at recent community posts)
This version of the song is amazing! It makes it more cinematic and adds to the story of the song! You did a great job making this version! 😄
Yipee
You might be able to by posting it as a podcast episode, that’s how I’ve seen people dodge copyright
@mrbusinesss1 Yeah, that works a lot of audio on youtube, and tiktok get taken down if they're a song, so they make it into an episode on Spotify
tell me when you do so omg please
a moment for those who fell in battle soldiers, mothers, fathers, elders and kids in those forgotten battles…
:(
the war makes me so sad, it’s such a shame. 🫶
He didn't even make it to 20. 🙏🏻
I came across this around the beginning when it sounds like the Soldiers are crying out in War and I damn right started sobbing
tatakae tatakae
the first "but it's better" that is actually better
haha my like got you to a k
lol my like got you to 2 K
So true
fr
LITERALLY
The choir sounds like the souls of dead soldiers singing.
the choir is chor leoni. you should listen to their concert of army dreamers. it is truly so good!
@@L4L_LILLYlink?
whys there no replies lol
AND I FUFKIN LOVE IT (they're so cute help me)
OMG YES!!!
The fact I was expecting a incongruous trap beat or something, and instead got this masterpiece
this comment is so funny to me idk why but yeah i agree it is beautiful 😭
What I expected tbh 😭
Same 😂
Same😂
I thought they were just gonna slow it down and add reverb but this is beautiful😭
I was thinking “you can’t make Kate bush better!” but I was so wrong this is life changing
REAL
It’s sooo good ❤
my exact thoughts 😭
Same
SAME
Listening to this while staring at a picture of my grandpa who served in WW2 is a weird experience
Fr
Same (I'm German 🌚)
@@solus8685 god bless ur grandfather
@@solus8685😳
he is thanked for his service ❤️
this is how i wish the song really was. the way the screams get more intense in the second chorus and the end the piano is doing the “what a waste of army dreamers”. it’s so soft at the end, like they’re trying to lull him to sleep for a peaceful final rest. like a mother would. i can practically see her son’s life from start to finish in this song. it gives you closure. but that only makes it more tragic. this could bring me to tears.
Fr
you made me cry
since many people forget it’s still a thing.
this makes me think of child soldiers in africa.. i’ve heard many sad stories this song reminds me of them 🇨🇩🇳🇬
Never forget 🇵🇸!!
@@void14157bro he said Africa NOT fucking Palestine
@@OfficiallyZilasisn’t Palestine in Africa tho?
@@DaughterOfHephaestus9i hope ur joking😨
@@DaughterOfHephaestus9 Are you fucking joking.
It's so wonderful. I can't describe it words. These sounds of the choir, like a funeral service in a church, add so much atmosphere to this track. Amazing 🌹
Ikr!!!
it's sung by the choir Chor Leoni theyre a really talented choir
@@amysutton3352❤Jesus is coming back. . Please Get right with the Lord and read the Bible.
@@kathleenmoore9534?
It talks about an Mother wishing her Sons different paths instead of becoming an soldier
I’m not sure why, but this version sounds eerily hopeful. Almost as if the choir of soldiers mourn the lives they could have while also wishing their sons a brighter future.
Very beautiful interpretation!
They didn't even make it to their twenties
What a waste.
Of army dreamers..
I imagine this song like a story. The intro part is were we appear in the soldier funeral in a church where the choir, family and friends are grieving.
The army dreamers part is were we see the fallen soldier leaving for the army then cuts to training. Were it builds up to conflict and death.
The outro part is back to the funeral were we only see the mother. Showing a grave then many graves, to show its a graveyard full of dead soldiers.
I wanna see someone animate that
@@Ramir_officialYT i will one day 👍
OH MY GOD SAMEE
Hey this is interesting story! if I have a chance to animate it for my class would allow me from this idea? Let me know if you’re okay and allow me 🥰🤍
@@moonbites8012 oh yeah it's fine! If you have the chance to animate it , can you allow me to see the animation?
WE TAKING GRANDPA'S MEDALS OUT OF OUR DRAWERS WITH THIS ONE 🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
I'M TAKING MY DADS MEDALS OUT THE DRAWER FOR THIS ONE 🗣🗣‼️‼️🔥🔥
My grandpa joined the navy despite being chronically seasick, he kept a barf bucket near him at all times I hear 😂
@@toasty_7233😮
Haha what a lad! @@toasty_7233
YEAHHH 🔥🔥🔥
It sounds so dreamy yet more tragic in a way as you can connect with the music more, hope it makes sense but i actually love it. The title never tells lies
It sounds so army dreamy
@ AAA LITERALLY
I could hear “fall down” in the background, I think that’s what I’m hearing it and it keeps giving me chills-
pretty sure the dude in the background is saying "fall in"
but nearing the end he says "fall out" instead, which is a pretty cool detail
@@ProcidensSidus ah okay ty lol
@@ProcidensSidus what does it mean btw? i don't understand..
@@ifquiqthings they say during war to the soldiers I believe. (To alert them or smth)
OMG THE BEGINNING WAS SAMPLED FROM CHOR LEONI WASNT IT!!!! I love their version of the song. it just adds so much more soul when you hear all those voices!
sim ❤
0:34 transition is so ethereal.
My younger sister unexpectedly passed away a few years ago- she was a prodigy ACE/STEM student who wanted to become a politician and advocate for women's rights in the workplace, and she was really passionate about music, specifically singing. She passed away in her sleep at 16 due to an at the time undiagnosed Long-QT syndrome, that caused her heart to stop while she sleeped. This song makes me think about her- I knew she was going to do great things in the world, and she was a genuinely amazing person, so it hurts a lot to think about how she never had the chance to achieve her own dreams and see the fruits of her labor.
A lot of my initial grief at her loss revolved around the fact that she genuinely did not deserve to die- she was kind, hard-working, and despite the harsh environments we were raised in she always did her best to be responsible and do the right thing. She wanted to make the world a better place and did all the work to have a great start in doing so, only to be robbed of the chance from initially unknown causes, and I felt angry with myself and the world for what it took- and for a while, I felt like I wasn't worthy of living in the world over her. It took a lot of grieving but I eventually did come to terms with her death, and I promised her that I would do my best to achieve my own dreams for her. I falter sometimes, and I wish I could do better, but I'm getting there, and I want to do right by her, even if she isn't here anymore.
I really love this song, it hits me really hard emotionally and despite the more light airy tone, it's such a genuinely heartbreaking experience when you've gone through a loss like that. This rearrangement does a lot better of a job at the instrumental/backing elements that I felt were lacking in the original, and it comes together to be really moving. Thank you for rearranging it, and thank Kate Bush for making such a touching work of art.
Sorry to vent some heavy stuff in a comment like this, but this song (and rearrangement) resonated with me really heavily and I wanted to share how it made me feel.
sending you and your family love and healing energy, what a terrible thing to go through, I'm so sorry for your loss ❤
rest in peace to ur sister 🙏🏽
Sending you my heartfelt wishes for achieving your dream , I am rooting for you ❤ your sister will be very proud !
i know she's proud of you, I hope you all are doing well ♥
womp womp
I wasn't expecting the title to be right but it absolutely was
Lyrics
I haven't listened to the rest,but you missed 2 lines. Ty for ur gud work in providing the lyrics
To carry home my little soldier
(What could he do?)
(Should have been a rockstar)
But he didn't have the money for a guitar
The shouting at the start is actually "fall in" I believe?
@@Eepop_stuffs omg, didn't notice, thanks for telling me :)
I don't read the lyrics to sing, but thank you.
it makes me so disgusted how people forget and demonize elderly and children who served. they were all kids. they all had families, and we still dont take care of them. i met a vet in nyc once and his story tore me apart. he lost everything, in war and after. and no one helped him. he was alone sitting in a McDonalds with teenagers threatening him. he had dreams too.
Forever a hater of the military system but never the veterans.
@@livingmasquerade1418 100% agreed
what about those they killed, did they not have dreams to? over 200,000 Iraqis with dreams lives families futures
@@Maryam-xr2ht
im not orginal comentor but i do wanna say that i agree with you.
thats why i beleive in hating the millitary and not the vets. at the end of the day the milltary use nationalism and money to go over and destroy countries for greed. and i completely understand why you mention iraq. iraq, vietnam, phillipenes, afghanistan, syria and so many countries deserve justice. they did not deserve what happened to them, not matter what justification the goverments use.
but the people in the western world are not evil (dont get me wrong there were individuals who did do henious war crimes though but not everyone), the goverments are, but not the people.
most these people were tricked into defending their countries through manipulation, paying off their loans or being conspricted into wars.
most people were unfortunately following orders, war and violence is unfortunately complex but all it leaves at the end of the day is broken dreams, families and communties where ever it starts and ends. from the wars now to the wars thousands of years ago. war is the most horrible disgusting act humans do.
@@Maryam-xr2ht those people had dreams too, yes. my point is that, to completely demonize every person in the military is horrible. and that includes people in iraq who served and died in action. death in war is tragic no matter ethnicity.
If you listen closely you can hear soldiers screaming and yelling in battle
Yeah it was in the original too :)
This should be in a soundtrack of a war movie
If no one doing it then by damn ima do it myself!
@@umanasilos2311i'm helping you!
@@umanasilos2311 I'll help too
I love how the "but it's better" isn't a lie.
This singlehandedly made me get up and do my chores
Its magestic
literally same
this is actually helping me write my ww2 novel thanks 🙏🏾
yo! that’s cool, good luck with it! ❤
Woah good luck!!
@@blorisy thank you!
@@greeniscoollol thanks! 🤍
You got this! ❤
Kate sits among the greatest songwriters in the world, she wrote 'The Man with the Child in his eyes' at 13 years old.
1:16 goes so hard tbh this is divine
This song revived a memory of when I watched short documentary a few years ago (I believe it was on VICE) about the process of recovering the remains of soldiers in the Russo-Ukrainian war that's STILL ongoing. The footage itself was pretty heavy, but what stuck in my mind were their ID photos, their IDs recovered from them as the only means of knowing who they were. So young, their lives cut short. So unfair. War is true horror.
Not many songs made me to get goosebumps, nor tearing up. I'm not lying but this version and song in general is just too perfect and couldn't hold my emotions back. This is definetely my favorite song and version ever
I hope Kate listens to this
She probably doesn’t have TH-cam
@@jaredsmith4964 💀?
@@Gabriela-bs5yi I mean she probably doesn’t
@@jaredsmith4964 maybe she does
@@Gabriela-bs5yi I don’t know. I feel like she wouldn’t knowing how she posted a thank you about Running up that hill hitting number #1 on her website because she has zero social media
I remember hearing the choir version too, I love how u incorporated the "fall in" part so smoothly!
Me at the beginning of the song : they can't make it better Me at the end : dreamerrrrrrssssss
ty fwvhritt
I won't lie, I thought it was going to be a shitpost or something, but I was surprised that really decided to make it more majestic.
i'm so impressed... i've always been the kind of person that stays super faithful to the original song because, in dance, people use covers/remixes of songs that just don't hit the same way as the original yk?
but this? this was perfect. thank you for making this because it's just MWAH :D
The algorithm put this in my playlist and I was like, “wait, this is so good. Why haven’t I heard this version before?” Then I saw that it’s fan made. Good job!
this is beautiful not just in an audible way but also a visual way somehow
The best music is the mind that allows you to normally hear it, but also see it
when i heard the intro i knew it was heaven
I NEED this on spotify
I've been drafted to serve 14 months starting this fall, and after hearing songs like these i kinda get to the realization that i maybe don't want to toss my life away so simply.
the army is a cult.
Lol
Lol
This song feels especially strong when there is war and dictatorship in your country. Thousands of army dreamers who are dying now are next to me, simply because the authorities wanted to play war. It destroys me every day
This sounds like that I imagine a war memorial sounds like. Beautiful work.
I found this gem at midnight and i got chills and tears
The original was already beautiful and thought can this get any better
You made it happen, A song already so beautiful, Singlehandedly made more ethereal
My heart felt calm
And the tears in my eyes were genuine to the beauty within this song and this version.
This is so gorgeous, my friend sent it to me and by the end of the song we were both in tears
I like how it starts to sound like a lullaby at the end, indicating that they were just kids
GOTTA let gang know I fw with this
Real
Real
This is so soothing like hearing voices of dead people but with sweet hearts, soldiers that didn't died in regrets❤
This served the whole family dinner table
Nah this the MRE for the soldiers
TEARING AT THE BARS OF MY ENCLOSURE
that song healed my soul, thank you for this!
This song is honestly so calming! I have almost fallen asleep to it so many times, mainly the outro. Like, that part is so calming i could listen to it on repeat!!
oh my god i literally was thinking like. yesterday. to combine this choir with the og song and im SO glad someone else beat me to it, this is so gorgeous. thank you for elevating this song
The fact it actually made it better is crazy..
No, it's not.
@@isobeljames1328 yes, it did. Im not saying the whole entire tuing is better. But it enhances it more. The song actaully seems like a mother who is mourning the death of her son. So, yes, it is a bit better. this is an opinion. Thank you.
(Not trying to be rude)
Came across this on accident while writing a book report on the era of terrorism (and war) in Peru. THANK YOU. This is genuinely motivating me so much omg
2:49 i love this
Me too. 🙂
Great song, makes me think of something I was told from a former 2/75 dude who was in Iraq and Afghanistan just after 9/11
He thought that going to war or joining the army would make him a man. He wasn't poor, he wasn't drafted, but he thought that was his responsibility as a man. But he then explained that being a man was more. It was protecting people, not interests or ideas, and being kind, generous, compassionate and caring.
I'm still planning on joining the Army. But I doubt I will forget what he said.
The maggots crawling in my bones are dancing, the worms coming out my eyes are boogieing, words cant describe how heavenly this sounds.
Outro is soul touching and so beautiful
Mixing the orchestra version with the original is genuinely a gift from heaven
I did not expect this at all…. Left me speechless I’m in love
"No one is mad enough to prefer war over peace. In peace, sons bury their fathers. In war, fathers bury their sons."
~Herodotus
This remix is really good, I particularly like the moments where we hear the male voices in the background, like a call for dead soldiers, it really brings some wonderful things to the song ❤
This NEEDS to be on Spotify right now
This is such a perfect combination of audios, I swear I’ve come back to this video like 1000 times
This edit really mad me feel a hint of sadness; I Imagined all these soldiers during ww1 going to war not knowing anything about what they’ll endure, and for what ? It was such a tragic war
My dads best friend joined the Rio de Janeiro state military police in the late 90s, and he died only three days later. He got ambushed by drug dealers in a favela, him and his partner died, my dad always remembers him as a great dude, i would have liked to meet him
This is actually so gorgeous I am, infact, crying this very second. This song means a lot to me and pulls on my heart strings if you couldn’t tell (I’m not joking I’m actually crying right now)
kate bush's songs are mesmerizing you ate this
i LOVE the music box sound at the end. it really hits how these were mother's babies that were lost at the end of the day.
i love the outro so much
I love it. The flow is still the same, same lyrics but some small neat details that improve the song so much.
my ears have been blessed by this song. thanks for this amazing edit!
My grandad served during Vietnam, he passed nearly 4 years ago and some days I really miss him. I wish I asked more about his time in the military and what he did, he seemed like such a cool person. I really wish I wasn't so angsty back then and actually tried to connect with him. Miss you Grandad ❤
I can feel the soldier singing with Kate Bush was calm and restful, giving sounded voice for their country has been free from war.
How I look at my grandpa who used to be a soldier too and had the same fate.
He served in the French Fourth Republic in 1951 as a co-pilot, looking down in the window and seeing his people die and cry in pain, gun shooting trying to defend themself but fate died on them. He can't do anything but watch them suffer in the hell-less war of many casualties and feel sad and regret. After 6 years of serving, he returns to his village home. with grandma and my mom (with my aunt sliding) waiting for him. While eating dinner, still remembering the fate of his people, he cried and broke down.
One night, he heard the spirit of his people (including soldiers) singing and cheering. Even though he saw it was a hallucination, he felt sad but happy, because he knew they would be free from their cycle of pain and fly up, resting their soul, knowing their true best for their country.
He continued living, forgetting the past that he witnessed to let their spirit go and support another country that was stuck in warfare and homelessness.
after his older self, he gave his tale to me and wished I'd respect others and soldier who fight for their country.
And after a long life, he is gone...passed away, not even knowing that he's gone (I was 9 back then). Then I see a pigeon, fly toward my backyard and sing the song. Then my realization kicked in, he had gone without my goodbye.
I miss him, he was kind and protected me ever since I was in kindergarten, defended me from my bully, lectured me about the meaning of life, and told his story of how he used to be. I felt I wasn't worth living in the world. It took much grieving of mental depression to my grandpa's death, I wish I could see him one last time, I want to see his smile and his determent, but I know he isn't here anymore.
But when I hear the song Army Dreamers - Kate Bush in 2019 (and your song, like a remaster or something). It hits me really hard emotionally, the tome, chord background like many soldiers passed away makes me remember my grandpa. Make me want to live and continue to my destination, my dream, and my purpose to stop me from ending myself and living happily for him and for my soul.
Thank you Kate Bush (and you) for making such a touching masterpiece work of beauty.
.Don't worry, this comment is about my feelings about remembering my grandpa.
I know im a lil late but this is amazing! I love this version sm and this is the first "but its better" that is actually much better, it has really touched my soul ❤
I feel in heaven, such unique emotions come to me with this song, it turned out fabulous on you 🛐✨
Wow, this is actually heavenly, the singing of the fallen Army Dreamers, something about this rendition of the song hits hard, it pierces the heart and soul, this is absolutely perfect requiem for our fallen soldiers. Thank you for this rendition of Army dreamers.
oh my god the piano at the end!!!! are you kidding me?? 💕💕💕
Wow, that was the most magical version of the song! ❤ the emotional and vocal range of the singer is incredible and the musicians in the orchestra are truly experts 😮 just perfect❤
This version is so beautiful
I am begging you to make more songs like this one, i absolutly love this
ive come back to this video an outrages amount of times.
I NEED THIS IN SPOTIFY YESTERDAY
YOU ACTUALLY MADE IT EVEN BETTER
It reminds me of a mother in WW1 who sees each man going to the thresholds of the mothers next door, but her son never comes home, and all of her life with her son flashes before her eyes, realizing that her baby will never bless her eyes again.
This song... It filled my head in a way I never thought any song would, like pure dopamine, it felt like I was underwater and my brain was floating... Just like magic... I felt safe...
if anyone wants the full choir version, it's choir leoni. the video should pop up if you search up army dreamers choir or something similiar, 100% recommend listening to it.
Oh my god I love this…
This is so good that im downloading a song from youtube like the good old days
Oh my...i just listened the choir solo, but but im. Im speechless.
This is so beautiful and for what..😭
this is the best thing i’ve ever heard in my life
This is amazing!!! I'm really happy I stumbled across this, you have amazing skill!!
I can't tell you how many times I've listened to this beautiful song...
This song has me in tears everytime.
this song is heartbreaking. our world sucks.
This may be one of my favorite videos that I have come across on any platform. The way the choir compliments the main lyrical components is simply angelic, to say the least. This is a masterpiece in my eyes, melancholy and peaceful, sincere and pure. Thank you for this.
that was the cleanest intro to song transition I've heard in years. holy hell.
The song reminds me of lullaby made for all the soldiers in really any war ever, that are being properly putted to sleep. So wonderful, touching, yet disturbing lyrics and melody, love it :)
Listening to this on Remembrance Day gives me chills
This song reminds me of my grandmother because in 2019, she lost her son who participated in the army (he died due to a motorcycle accident) and the lyrics match that so much ❤❤
♡