Moshe Dayan as quoted in Haaretz, 4 April 1969: "Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist, not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either. Nahlal arose in the place of Mahlul; Kibbutz Gvat in the place of Jibta; Kibbutz Sarid in the place of Huneifis; and Kefar Yehushu'a in the place of Tal al-Shuman. There is not one single place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population." Nicely done. Indeed, these thieves Akhaduha Mafroosheh.
Hi i heard this yesterday and at night i said it to my husband , cause i knew without asking to be sure, that every Palestenian knows this saying and i wanted to teach it to Anyone that would listen!
Fully furnished with the afternoon tea ☕️ still warm on the table. Miko Peled’s words about the house they moved into .... fully furnished with beverage accommodations. Read/see everything Miko Peled.
الله يعطيك العافية. عمل جيد لتوصيل الرسالة الحقيقية للعالم، خصوصا الناطقين بالانحليزية. المفارقة، انو للأسف العالم تقريبا كلو بعرف هاي الحقائق بشكل مسبق وأكتر كمان. بتم السؤال: ليه الصمت المطبق الدولي ع كل حقارات وسفالات بني صهيون؟ الجواب: لإن ما حدا بدو إنو هالوجهه القبيح والقميء والدنيء تاع الصهاينة يكون بينهم. ف بالنتيجة، معلش يكونوا بفلسطين. ومش عندهم ولا بينهم. قدرنا إنو كتب على أهل بيت المقدس الجهاد ل يوم الدين. بس بإذن الله، الزمن عجلة وبتدور. والله لنعمل ببني صهيون زي لعملوه فينا بكل تفاصيلو. وحيكون مننا ناس، يحطوا قواعد الدين الإسلامي وتعاليمنا الحنيفة ع جنب. عشان لما يردوا الكيل لبني صهيون، يردوه تماما زي م انحط ومن كل فج عميق. كما تدين تدان. مسألة وقت بس لا غير.
@Itamar Canaanites are one of many ancient Arab tribes. They’re also known Phoenicians and migrated from the eastern Arabian Peninsula-at the time home to the Dilmun civilization as well; they moved due to climate crises around 6,200 BC of the hot desert (Jarius Zarins). There are Arab families to this day with the surname Canaan-which is not found in “Israel” or Europe.
اخذوها مفروشه بمساعدة الدول العربيه الخائنه ، وما زال العرب ، او ما يسمى العرب، ما زالوا يتاجرون بالقضيه الفلسطينيه . كانت هذه النكبه ، انما النكبه العظمى حصلت في القرن السابع الميلادي . تحياتي لك صديقي عامر
To bla bla lev: 1. Arab is not a race, it’s an ethnicity. Palestinians are native to Palestine they’re not immigrants. They became Arabized like most of the Middle East. 2. At least 4 different empires conquered Palestine After ancient Israel was destroyed and before Muslim arabs arrived. The two did not meet. 3. Ancient jewish immigration and subsequent establishment of ancient Israel in Palestine was just one of the many political phases Palestine went through. Definitely not the most significant one. 4. Palestine already had a native population in it before ancient Israel. Your holy book commanded you to slaughter all of them abut your ancestors couldn’t. 5. Go back to Egypt. Your truly original motherland.
there is no holy book that promotes slaughtering of other civilization, even the bible doesn't promote it but the Christian clerics do by sanding madmen to kill people in Jerusalem
I’m talking about the Old Testament. It’s full of calls for violence and genocide. Not sure why you’re including Christian clerics here. Rabbis are doing this in Isra*l not priests.
lol you actually made up an entire history for propaganda purposes.. 1. The earliest arab settling in the land you call "palestine" wasn't early to the Fatimid dynasty, although most palestinians today are descendants of later immigrants which can be easily seen in family names. Al Masri is the biggest family in the gaza strip. This saying can easily be disproved by genetic tests and history. 2. 2 empires did: the persians and the romans. Know your facts... 3. Ancient Israel was the first known native civilization created in this land in history, definitely not just "another phase". It wasn't created in "Palestine", but in canaan... Palestine is a name the romans gave the province after the Bar Kochva Revolt. It's MUCH later than the existence of ancient Israel and it's not even up for debate, Hedrianus wrote that himself. 4. Canaan's natives were canaanites, the group called "Israel" was cannanites who lived in Judah and Samaria and expanded later. 5. if a DNA test says you're mostly from the arabian desert, would you go there?
@@itamar4117 Canaanites are one of many ancient Arab tribes. They’re also known Phoenicians and migrated from the eastern Arabian Peninsula-at the time home to the Dilmun civilization as well; they moved due to climate crises around 6,200 BC of the hot desert (Jarius Zarins). There are Arab families to this day with the surname Canaan-which is not found in “Israel” or Europe.
@@itamar4117 "Ancient Israel" was indeed another phase or "was just one of the many political phases Palestine went through" as Kristina H put it. You're also mistaken to claim that "ancient Israel was the first known native civilization", as the magnificent civilization of the Canaanites on the land of Canaan was the first known one on this land. So, it seems you're the one-possibly not knowing-who’s “making up an entire history for propaganda purposes”!! I suggest you (and the other commenter Esther Lev) google "The Origin of the Palestine-Israel Conflict" by "Jews for Justice in the Middle East". Here are some excerpts by historians worthwhile of reading from the site: “But all these [different peoples who had come to Canaan] were additions, sprigs grafted onto the parent tree...And that parent tree was Canaanite...[The Arab invaders of the 7th century A.D.] made Moslem converts of the natives, settled down as residents, and intermarried with them, with the result that all are now so completely Arabized that we cannot tell where the Canaanites leave off and the Arabs begin.” Illene Beatty, “Arab and Jew in the Land of Canaan.” “The extended kingdoms of David and Solomon, on which the Zionists base their territorial demands, endured for only about 73 years...Then it fell apart...[Even] if we allow independence to the entire life of the ancient Jewish kingdoms, from David’s conquest of Canaan in 1000 B.C. to the wiping out of Judah in 586 B.C., we arrive at [only] a 414-year Jewish rule.” Illene Beatty, “Arab and Jew in the Land of Canaan.” “Recent archeological digs have provided evidence that Jerusalem was a big and fortified city already in 1800 BCE...Findings show that the sophisticated water system heretofore attributed to the conquering Israelites pre-dated them by eight centuries and was even more sophisticated than imagined...Dr. Ronny Reich, who directed the excavation along with Eli Shuikrun, said the entire system was built as a single complex by Canaanites in the Middle Bronze Period, around 1800 BCE.” The Jewish Bulletin, July 31st, 1998.
مرحبا عامر أو عمرو. عجبني الفيديو كتير. بس كلمة يللا لا هي عبرية ولا هي عربية. هي ببساطة تركية. اكتشفتها لما حضرت مسلسل تركي.. بس يللا ماشي الحال، وصلتنا قبل ما توصلهم. وبعدين ط#$ك أشرف من أنه يلح#وها 😀
Both sides seems to have its own reasons. They seem to grab all the credits to their sides. Music, food, whatever it is, people would always say it is theirs. Everyone would always say they are the first and somebody stole their property.
Sorry, but in the world today it is not difficult for you to go and search it. Please Google it. E.g. yalla comes from the name Allah, do Jews know Allah. Etc.,
Grab the credit to both sides by music and blah blah??!!! Like dude we dont see anonymous music and food!!! A person from any part of the world can listen to this music and says yes its Arabic!! U cant debate culture !!!!!! Its not who have the credit first!! Its a robbery!!!!!! 😅 i cant claim an American country music and say its mine just coz it happens that i live by!!!
Languages take on loanwords all the time. The word for shower in Russian is "dush," taken from the French "douche." That doesn't mean it's not a Russian word. Incorporating yalla and sababa into Hebrew isn't theft, it's just bits and pieces picked up from living with Arabs. Sure, there are other words she could have chosen, like beseder (which Israeli Arabs have thoroughly incorporated into their Arabic). The same goes for taking songs and giving them a cover in your language. Israelis have made Hebrew versions of Katyusha, but I doubt you would call that theft. In Poland they made a Polish cover of the Yiddish song Tumbalalaika, and nobody is complaining about that.
If they were to incorporate bits and pieces as neighbors, nobody would complain; like the Japanese using borrowing curry from india and modifying it to better suit their palate. The problem with Israel using food that was traditionally Palestinian is the way they tie it into their land grabs + frequent use of the conspiracy theory that nobody was living on the land, or that the land was barren before the first settlers arrived. If you go to any Israeli Jewish restaurant in New York, they'll term all their dishes as israeli, NOT Arab or middle eastern; if you were to press them on it, then MAYBE they'll attribute some credit to the Mizrahim. In this way, the popular opinion, to the uninitiated, becomes "falafel/hummus/grape leaves are Israeli foods". It's like if Americans believed pizza and spaghetti were "American", foods, but in addition to that, imagine if the US literally took over Italy and tried to claim native Italians had no culture, didn't know how to grow their own crops, and have no claim to their homeland. So yeah, I agree with you; on its own, people trading cultures is usually a good thing, but particularly in this case, the intent is far more malicious.
What about all the Mizrahi Jewish Israelis who have also eaten hummus and lived in the area for generations? I completely understand and accept the Palestinian people's right to self-determination but it feels like you're erasing the history and culture of Middle Eastern Jews
Middle Eastern Jews belong to the land they are equally entitled to live there with no tiny shade of doubt! It is not a debate. But the trouble is stealing our land by zionist based on utterly flawed religious claims. Imagine that someone like Ivanka T. is entitled to come and live in Palestine as a jew convert over us who own the land as far as the history can reach. The funny part zionist don’t seem to have a definition of Israeli citizen.
That's a fair point, but you'll realise that Israel's overlap of food has more to do with Levantian food (Palestine, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon) and less to do with North Africa or the Gulf, which also had its share of Mizrahim. While some credit can certainly be attributed to the Mizrahim (and like the dude before me said, the Mizrahis have every right to that culture), the point of the video here is referring largely to the organised campaign that the right-wing Israeli government has been using to deny Palestinians of a claim to their land/culture. Often times they'll sell the idea that these dishes can ONLY be attributed to Israel (if you go to a Jewish restaurant in New York for example), but you'll be hard pressed to find someone who's willing to admit any Palestinian/arab influence. Coupled with the conspiracy theory that Israel was barren before the first settlers came, or that Palestinians were just a bunch of Bedouin tribes from surrounding Arab countries, you find that the intent is often to completely erase any claim to the land.
Furthermore, don't forget that the Mizrahis have had their share of suffering under the Israeli government; the Yemeni children incident and the ringworm incidents being the most well known.
Lod airport, the only airport before 1948, was built in 1934 by the British during the British Mandate for Palestine. Jaffa and Acre and Haifa ports existed since Bible times so built by Jews.
Fake fake fake all the picture is picture of jewish peapole, the airport was a british airport build by the british colonise or the ottoman, in israel we say sababa and yalla, beacose we have milions jewish from arabs country,like tunisia moroco iraq iran yaman libia algeria and more,
lacks integrity and impartial review of history. most obvious: no mention that in 1948 it was Palestinian leadership that declared war. if someone declares war and loses it along with land - in who's book does that count as stealing? another notable example: Lod/Lydia airport was built by the British, not Palestinians. neither Israelis nor Palestinians have been saints - anyone presenting one or the other as such is either not seeing or not telling the truth.
@@banksarenotyourfriends genuine, indeed. Palestinian leadership declared war and called its big allies to assist its small force and do its job for it. look it up. it's the thing to do, logically.
@@AvnerSenderowicz I have looked it up, that's why I'm asking the question - the historical record doesn't seem to agree with your version of events - I have to ask; did you go to school in Israel? As that might explain the different versions of history we were both taught. The idea that a small rebel army of Jews could take on the large Arab powers in the 1940's - and win - defies logic. It's like some sort of David and Goliath myth. How were the Arab powers even ready for an invasion? You can't just get an expeditionary force together overnight, it takes months to organise. There are many things about this idea that don't make any sense.
Integrity? Who are you to speak of integrity you lying two-faced viper. Who created the state of Israel? The British. What right did the British have over Palestine? Might over right? Israel was the product of Colonialism and political pressure from powerful European Jewish Zionists. In other words, the creation of Israel was illegitimate.
So what are Palestinian words? Palestinian looking city? Palestinian food? They don't exist do they? Because Palestine was Israel/Judea under occupation of empires and Arab and Ottoman caliphates and you are an Arab.
Israel is a human name, it was a prophet name, not even a place name.it stopped existing before Rome, Arabs just liberated from them and protected from the Christians madmen.
@@_elifilen God promised the land to Abraham. Abraham has a son called Isaac. Isaacs a son called Jacob. Israel is the name God gave to Jacob. That's why the land is called the land of Israel because Jacob/Israel inherited the land from his father Isaac and his grandfather Abraham. That's also why Jews are called Children of Israel because Jacob/Israel is our father (through his 12 sons). Even your Qu'ran says God gave land to the Jews.
@@estherlev2472 Not only to the Jews but to all people who worship God of Abraham, that means Jews, Christians, and Muslims. also, Qu'ran didn't motion the name of the promised.God have two holly land btw
@@estherlev2472 Why you keep denaying that Abraham(peace be upon him) had two wives at the same time, Hajjar and Sarah, polygamy was legal. and he lived in two cities one of them was Mekka where he helped to rebuild the Kaaba with Hajjar and Ismael(peace be upon him). slavery is forbidden in all Abrahamic religions. Hajjar was legally his 2nd wife and the Mother of his 1st kid and Issac (peace be upon him) was his 2nd from Sarah.
Yeah it might have been mentioned there, except it's overwritten and even if it was true, we ate it since the time we entered our land, which is before Torah.
So much nonsense - Ben Gurion airport was built by the British. Words can be imported from other languages. Are we supposed to say that 'education' isn't an English word because it was borrowed from French? People can enjoy foods from other cultures. The clip doesn't say hummus was invented by Israelis, it just says they enjoy it, which is true. It's also not clear it was invented by Palestinians - it's popular across the region. Finally, why the comment about 'white girls' saying 'literally' when something isn't literally true? Lots of people do this. Have fun with your impotent rage.
There were hardly any people in palestine. Before the jews came, in 1880, jerusalem, now home to 1,000,000 people, was a town of 40,000, most of them jews. Israelis using "arabic made words" like yalla and sababa, cry me a river.. Half of israeli jews come (fled) arabic countries, so yes, we eat humus, and many like arabic music. Big deal.. And 2.5 million arabs are citizens of israel, so yeah, there are arab cities in israel.. As for you being a "palestinian", here are some irrefutable facts about the invention of the palestinian people: th-cam.com/video/MP0zH0mJBf8/w-d-xo.html
There is a lot of misleading information here .. Oriental music for example: We have never claimed that this music is ours. Israeli music is far from sounding like this :) And as for Gal Gadot: she just came out dumb. There are no Israelis over the age of 5 who do not know that these words are in Arabic.. You are only spreading hate because every Israeli must during high school learn about the history of Israel and the occupation and the students know that they did not come to a land empty of people.
True, Sarit Hadad probably didn't steal Farid's song. It's a cover/tribute and I assume she paid the licensing fee to use it. A lot of older Israelis grew up listening to Farid, Um Kalthoum etc in their countries of origin if they are from the Arab world, and they brought that tradition with them. Farid is actually very popular in Israel. In fact, based on my channel stats, per capita, he is more popular in Israel than in any other country in the world. To me, on a basic level, enjoying music is a human right. If it touches someone's heart, I don't see how you deny this. But actually stealing music for profit, that's another issue. And in that area, the Turks are the biggest offenders when it comes to Arabic music.
@@FaridHQyour name is not the name of a terrorist so change your name to a name that fits you. Try Benjamin, a lot of terrorists have that name so it’s more befitting for you
![“อาร์ต พศุตม์” เกือบเอี่ยวทุกคดีดัง เอ๊ะไว้ก่อน ไม่มีอะไรได้มาง่ายๆ | แฉ 16 ต.ค. 67 [2/3] | GMM25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0Gx-0-kUBv8/mqdefault.jpg)
حكيت عن فلسطين ووصلت الفكره للعالم بهاد الفيديو احسن من كل كتبنا واعلامنا وقياداتنا...فلسطين خلفت رجال وانت منهم ..تستحق ان تكون قائد
يسلم تمك….. It couldn’t have been said better 👏🏻
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸Palestinians and proud 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Palestine
Akhadoha mafrosheh
اخدوها بشبابها واحلامها واحلامنا
, 💔 from Egypt we the people will never normalize .
😂😂 the 7eleh 3an tizeh was *chefs kiss* that was amazing!!
This guy should get an award for making this so hilarious and depressing at the same time.
He’s terrific! Amer Zahr, comedian @ law prof at Univ of Detroit Mercy School of Law, was Bernie Sanders team member on 2020 campaign. #BDS🇵🇸
I love this
You said and explained it in the best way
Well said brother , mad respect !
Thanks for describing the bullshit that we are going through, seriously!!!
Makes my blood boil - Israel shame on you . Peace to beautiful Palestine
You have sumund the hole conflict in this video so genius keep up the good work .( Akhaduha Mafrushe)
Where can we find your map in the background? Amazing video, thank you for this!!! 🙏🏻
اجيت من قناة الميادين ♥
The truth is wonderful to know... Peoples of the world, update your knowledge 🙏👍🙏👍🙏👍
Loved this, THANK YOU !! 🎩
mad respect brother
Moshe Dayan as quoted in Haaretz, 4 April 1969: "Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist, not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either. Nahlal arose in the place of Mahlul;
Kibbutz Gvat in the place of Jibta; Kibbutz Sarid in the place of Huneifis; and Kefar Yehushu'a in the place of Tal al-Shuman. There is not one single place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population."
Nicely done. Indeed, these thieves Akhaduha Mafroosheh.
SO WELL SAID !!
He’s always genuine 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
استمر ياعامر. لم اكن اعلم بعض هذه الامور. استمرررر. الله يقويك وبارك الله فيك
Great job, love it. Keep up the videos coming
What is he saying at the very and in Arabic ? Lmafo
(حلي عن طيزي)
Literally translates to "get away from my ass", but used similarly to "gtfo of here"
I love it, Short clear message, well done.
Love from the USA & Lebanon
Bro.. u r a God in terms of communicating your message loud and clear. Respect!
Uhh yeah I agree to some extent
رائع يا قلبي استمر
فيديو يوضح باختصار احتلال فلسطين اخدوها مفروشه كل الاحترام عامر زهر يا اصيل .
Thank you .
Hi i heard this yesterday and at night i said it to my husband , cause i knew without asking to be sure, that every Palestenian knows this saying and i wanted to teach it to Anyone that would listen!
Fully furnished with the afternoon tea ☕️ still warm on the table. Miko Peled’s words about the house they moved into .... fully furnished with beverage accommodations. Read/see everything Miko Peled.
Where did he say this? I follow him on IG but never saw this
I love your work Amer
My comment keeps being removed on the video. Not sure if YT hates me or hates your channel. Anyway I love this video!
الله يعطيك العافية. عمل جيد لتوصيل الرسالة الحقيقية للعالم، خصوصا الناطقين بالانحليزية.
المفارقة، انو للأسف العالم تقريبا كلو بعرف هاي الحقائق بشكل مسبق وأكتر كمان.
بتم السؤال:
ليه الصمت المطبق الدولي ع كل حقارات وسفالات بني صهيون؟
الجواب:
لإن ما حدا بدو إنو هالوجهه القبيح والقميء والدنيء تاع الصهاينة يكون بينهم.
ف بالنتيجة، معلش يكونوا بفلسطين. ومش عندهم ولا بينهم.
قدرنا إنو كتب على أهل بيت المقدس الجهاد ل يوم الدين. بس بإذن الله، الزمن عجلة وبتدور.
والله لنعمل ببني صهيون زي لعملوه فينا بكل تفاصيلو.
وحيكون مننا ناس، يحطوا قواعد الدين الإسلامي وتعاليمنا الحنيفة ع جنب. عشان لما يردوا الكيل لبني صهيون، يردوه تماما زي م انحط ومن كل فج عميق.
كما تدين تدان. مسألة وقت بس لا غير.
Hahahaha true, my mother told us we left it furnished before the forcibly exile
He's hilarious and funny when pissed!
I love this guy
فلسطين حرة
صح وخاصه اخر جمله٫ فعلا عصبت انا كمان
Sos un genio hermano!
Well said.
👍👍👍OK
حبيبنا عامر
Now u have to take it back fully furnished!
عامر كنت اناقش كلب منهم وقلي ليش هوه كان في بلد قبلنا وبعتله اافيديو تبعك وكان طبعا بكفي وبوفي يسعدك
As you said they stole our land and our stuff
Amer Zahr really pissed about "taking " away their "stuff"!! I mean everything!
👏👏👏
The biggest robbery in history 😥😬
Hahaha...🙌 Shuk’ran!!! *zagh’riting*
say it louder for the ppl at the back :P
2:34 Yallah means ya allah يا الله not ya yahwah 🤣🤣🤣
The حلّي عن طيزي had me dying 😂😂 a7la Amer
illuminati obviously check the comment box here on TH-cam .. Palestine 4 always .. Equality and freedom for all
@Itamar Canaanites are one of many ancient Arab tribes. They’re also known Phoenicians and migrated from the eastern Arabian Peninsula-at the time home to the Dilmun civilization as well; they moved due to climate crises around 6,200 BC of the hot desert (Jarius Zarins). There are Arab families to this day with the surname Canaan-which is not found in “Israel” or Europe.
THEY CAME FROM AFRICA
I can't believe you only have less than 9k subscribers.. You need to make some silly stuff to attract the audience!!!
This shows how pathetic this guy is.
Its good to spew. Its like crying.
It cleanses the soul.
شكرا يا اخي مثل هاي الفيديوهات ضرورية للجيل الجديد من المسلمين وغير المسلمين
بارك الله فيك
Aseel Alquds انو ليش للمسلمين وغير المسلمين ؟ ليش مش للعرب وغير العرب ؟
حسبي الله ونعم الوكيل. I wish we can do something about it but we are getting fucked by our governments
اخذوها مفروشه بمساعدة الدول العربيه الخائنه ، وما زال العرب ، او ما يسمى العرب، ما زالوا يتاجرون بالقضيه الفلسطينيه . كانت هذه النكبه ، انما النكبه العظمى حصلت في القرن السابع الميلادي . تحياتي لك صديقي عامر
whats isreal?
To bla bla lev:
1. Arab is not a race, it’s an ethnicity. Palestinians are native to Palestine they’re not immigrants. They became Arabized like most of the Middle East.
2. At least 4 different empires conquered Palestine After ancient Israel was destroyed and before Muslim arabs arrived. The two did not meet.
3. Ancient jewish immigration and subsequent establishment of ancient Israel in Palestine was just one of the many political phases Palestine went through. Definitely not the most significant one.
4. Palestine already had a native population in it before ancient Israel. Your holy book commanded you to slaughter all of them abut your ancestors couldn’t.
5. Go back to Egypt. Your truly original motherland.
there is no holy book that promotes slaughtering of other civilization, even the bible doesn't promote it but the Christian clerics do by sanding madmen to kill people in Jerusalem
I’m talking about the Old Testament. It’s full of calls for violence and genocide. Not sure why you’re including Christian clerics here. Rabbis are doing this in Isra*l not priests.
lol you actually made up an entire history for propaganda purposes..
1. The earliest arab settling in the land you call "palestine" wasn't early to the Fatimid dynasty, although most palestinians today are descendants of later immigrants which can be easily seen in family names. Al Masri is the biggest family in the gaza strip. This saying can easily be disproved by genetic tests and history.
2. 2 empires did: the persians and the romans. Know your facts...
3. Ancient Israel was the first known native civilization created in this land in history, definitely not just "another phase". It wasn't created in "Palestine", but in canaan... Palestine is a name the romans gave the province after the Bar Kochva Revolt. It's MUCH later than the existence of ancient Israel and it's not even up for debate, Hedrianus wrote that himself.
4. Canaan's natives were canaanites, the group called "Israel" was cannanites who lived in Judah and Samaria and expanded later.
5. if a DNA test says you're mostly from the arabian desert, would you go there?
@@itamar4117 Canaanites are one of many ancient Arab tribes. They’re also known Phoenicians and migrated from the eastern Arabian Peninsula-at the time home to the Dilmun civilization as well; they moved due to climate crises around 6,200 BC of the hot desert (Jarius Zarins). There are Arab families to this day with the surname Canaan-which is not found in “Israel” or Europe.
@@itamar4117 "Ancient Israel" was indeed another phase or "was just one of the many political phases Palestine went through" as Kristina H put it. You're also mistaken to claim that "ancient Israel was the first known native civilization", as the magnificent civilization of the Canaanites on the land of Canaan was the first known one on this land. So, it seems you're the one-possibly not knowing-who’s “making up an entire history for propaganda purposes”!! I suggest you (and the other commenter Esther Lev) google "The Origin of the Palestine-Israel Conflict" by "Jews for Justice in the Middle East". Here are some excerpts by historians worthwhile of reading from the site:
“But all these [different peoples who had come to Canaan] were additions, sprigs grafted onto the parent tree...And that parent tree was Canaanite...[The Arab invaders of the 7th century A.D.] made Moslem converts of the natives, settled down as residents, and intermarried with them, with the result that all are now so completely Arabized that we cannot tell where the Canaanites leave off and the Arabs begin.” Illene Beatty, “Arab and Jew in the Land of Canaan.”
“The extended kingdoms of David and Solomon, on which the Zionists base their territorial demands, endured for only about 73 years...Then it fell apart...[Even] if we allow independence to the entire life of the ancient Jewish kingdoms, from David’s conquest of Canaan in 1000 B.C. to the wiping out of Judah in 586 B.C., we arrive at [only] a 414-year Jewish rule.” Illene Beatty, “Arab and Jew in the Land of Canaan.”
“Recent archeological digs have provided evidence that Jerusalem was a big and fortified city already in 1800 BCE...Findings show that the sophisticated water system heretofore attributed to the conquering Israelites pre-dated them by eight centuries and was even more sophisticated than imagined...Dr. Ronny Reich, who directed the excavation along with Eli Shuikrun, said the entire system was built as a single complex by Canaanites in the Middle Bronze Period, around 1800 BCE.” The Jewish Bulletin, July 31st, 1998.
مرحبا عامر أو عمرو. عجبني الفيديو كتير. بس كلمة يللا لا هي عبرية ولا هي عربية. هي ببساطة تركية. اكتشفتها لما حضرت مسلسل تركي.. بس يللا ماشي الحال، وصلتنا قبل ما توصلهم. وبعدين ط#$ك أشرف من أنه يلح#وها 😀
semoga allah membalas kesusahan dan kesabaran anda dengan ganjaran yang lebih besar di dunia dan akhirat. amin
😂😂😂😂😂😁😀😱😱😱
Both sides seems to have its own reasons. They seem to grab all the credits to their sides. Music, food, whatever it is, people would always say it is theirs. Everyone would always say they are the first and somebody stole their property.
Sorry, but in the world today it is not difficult for you to go and search it. Please Google it.
E.g. yalla comes from the name Allah, do Jews know Allah. Etc.,
Lol
Grab the credit to both sides by music and blah blah??!!! Like dude we dont see anonymous music and food!!! A person from any part of the world can listen to this music and says yes its Arabic!! U cant debate culture !!!!!! Its not who have the credit first!! Its a robbery!!!!!! 😅 i cant claim an American country music and say its mine just coz it happens that i live by!!!
Lmfao
Languages take on loanwords all the time. The word for shower in Russian is "dush," taken from the French "douche." That doesn't mean it's not a Russian word. Incorporating yalla and sababa into Hebrew isn't theft, it's just bits and pieces picked up from living with Arabs. Sure, there are other words she could have chosen, like beseder (which Israeli Arabs have thoroughly incorporated into their Arabic).
The same goes for taking songs and giving them a cover in your language. Israelis have made Hebrew versions of Katyusha, but I doubt you would call that theft. In Poland they made a Polish cover of the Yiddish song Tumbalalaika, and nobody is complaining about that.
If they were to incorporate bits and pieces as neighbors, nobody would complain; like the Japanese using borrowing curry from india and modifying it to better suit their palate.
The problem with Israel using food that was traditionally Palestinian is the way they tie it into their land grabs + frequent use of the conspiracy theory that nobody was living on the land, or that the land was barren before the first settlers arrived.
If you go to any Israeli Jewish restaurant in New York, they'll term all their dishes as israeli, NOT Arab or middle eastern; if you were to press them on it, then MAYBE they'll attribute some credit to the Mizrahim.
In this way, the popular opinion, to the uninitiated, becomes "falafel/hummus/grape leaves are Israeli foods". It's like if Americans believed pizza and spaghetti were "American", foods, but in addition to that, imagine if the US literally took over Italy and tried to claim native Italians had no culture, didn't know how to grow their own crops, and have no claim to their homeland.
So yeah, I agree with you; on its own, people trading cultures is usually a good thing, but particularly in this case, the intent is far more malicious.
Yeah right my people will come to your land and we will make it our's i don't think u will call this a theft are u?
But they didn't steal the kufiya !!!! .
They did and made it blue with the star of david and called it their traditional scarf
@@RedTDA Good one....lol.
What about all the Mizrahi Jewish Israelis who have also eaten hummus and lived in the area for generations? I completely understand and accept the Palestinian people's right to self-determination but it feels like you're erasing the history and culture of Middle Eastern Jews
But the whole of Israel should not claim these foods as their own...am I right?
Middle Eastern Jews belong to the land they are equally entitled to live there with no tiny shade of doubt! It is not a debate. But the trouble is stealing our land by zionist based on utterly flawed religious claims. Imagine that someone like Ivanka T. is entitled to come and live in Palestine as a jew convert over us who own the land as far as the history can reach. The funny part zionist don’t seem to have a definition of Israeli citizen.
That's a fair point, but you'll realise that Israel's overlap of food has more to do with Levantian food (Palestine, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon) and less to do with North Africa or the Gulf, which also had its share of Mizrahim.
While some credit can certainly be attributed to the Mizrahim (and like the dude before me said, the Mizrahis have every right to that culture), the point of the video here is referring largely to the organised campaign that the right-wing Israeli government has been using to deny Palestinians of a claim to their land/culture.
Often times they'll sell the idea that these dishes can ONLY be attributed to Israel (if you go to a Jewish restaurant in New York for example), but you'll be hard pressed to find someone who's willing to admit any Palestinian/arab influence.
Coupled with the conspiracy theory that Israel was barren before the first settlers came, or that Palestinians were just a bunch of Bedouin tribes from surrounding Arab countries, you find that the intent is often to completely erase any claim to the land.
Furthermore, don't forget that the Mizrahis have had their share of suffering under the Israeli government; the Yemeni children incident and the ringworm incidents being the most well known.
@@osamahussein3058 Yeah definitely, that's BS.
Lod airport, the only airport before 1948, was built in 1934 by the British during the British Mandate for Palestine. Jaffa and Acre and Haifa ports existed since Bible times so built by Jews.
And I live there and never know that we have a god deam airport
@@detectivemakotodate2032 Lod airport is what is now called Ben Gurion airport.
before that most was built by the turks.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Fake fake fake all the picture is picture of jewish peapole, the airport was a british airport build by the british colonise or the ottoman, in israel we say sababa and yalla, beacose we have milions jewish from arabs country,like tunisia moroco iraq iran yaman libia algeria and more,
lacks integrity and impartial review of history.
most obvious:
no mention that in 1948 it was Palestinian leadership that declared war.
if someone declares war and loses it along with land - in who's book does that count as stealing?
another notable example: Lod/Lydia airport was built by the British, not Palestinians.
neither Israelis nor Palestinians have been saints - anyone presenting one or the other as such is either not seeing or not telling the truth.
1-Palestinian were being expelled before any war was Declared
2-that's irrelevant
Hey, genuine question - how do you declare war if you don't have an army? Your story doesn't seem to add up, logically.
@@banksarenotyourfriends genuine, indeed. Palestinian leadership declared war and called its big allies to assist its small force and do its job for it. look it up. it's the thing to do, logically.
@@AvnerSenderowicz I have looked it up, that's why I'm asking the question - the historical record doesn't seem to agree with your version of events - I have to ask; did you go to school in Israel? As that might explain the different versions of history we were both taught.
The idea that a small rebel army of Jews could take on the large Arab powers in the 1940's - and win - defies logic. It's like some sort of David and Goliath myth.
How were the Arab powers even ready for an invasion? You can't just get an expeditionary force together overnight, it takes months to organise. There are many things about this idea that don't make any sense.
Integrity? Who are you to speak of integrity you lying two-faced viper. Who created the state of Israel? The British. What right did the British have over Palestine? Might over right? Israel was the product of Colonialism and political pressure from powerful European Jewish Zionists. In other words, the creation of Israel was illegitimate.
That's Bull💩
Yes its thruth it was a empty land 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
You literally didn't get a single word from the video 😂😂💀
So what are Palestinian words? Palestinian looking city? Palestinian food? They don't exist do they? Because Palestine was Israel/Judea under occupation of empires and Arab and Ottoman caliphates and you are an Arab.
Israel is a human name, it was a prophet name, not even a place name.it stopped existing before Rome, Arabs just liberated from them and protected from the Christians madmen.
@@_elifilen God promised the land to Abraham. Abraham has a son called Isaac. Isaacs a son called Jacob. Israel is the name God gave to Jacob. That's why the land is called the land of Israel because Jacob/Israel inherited the land from his father Isaac and his grandfather Abraham. That's also why Jews are called Children of Israel because Jacob/Israel is our father (through his 12 sons).
Even your Qu'ran says God gave land to the Jews.
@@estherlev2472 Not only to the Jews but to all people who worship God of Abraham, that means Jews, Christians, and Muslims.
also, Qu'ran didn't motion the name of the promised.God have two holly land btw
@@_elifilen That's not true and you know it. The land was promised to Abraham and his descendents through his wife Sarah.
@@estherlev2472 Why you keep denaying that Abraham(peace be upon him) had two wives at the same time, Hajjar and Sarah, polygamy was legal.
and he lived in two cities one of them was Mekka where he helped to rebuild the Kaaba with Hajjar and Ismael(peace be upon him). slavery is forbidden in all Abrahamic religions.
Hajjar was legally his 2nd wife and the Mother of his 1st kid and Issac (peace be upon him) was his 2nd from Sarah.
החומוס הומצא בישראל עוד מימי התנך, יש פסוק שמספר שאכלו פה לחם וחומוס
Yeah it might have been mentioned there, except it's overwritten and even if it was true, we ate it since the time we entered our land, which is before Torah.
@@Nero-F121 beafore the torah?
So much nonsense - Ben Gurion airport was built by the British. Words can be imported from other languages. Are we supposed to say that 'education' isn't an English word because it was borrowed from French? People can enjoy foods from other cultures. The clip doesn't say hummus was invented by Israelis, it just says they enjoy it, which is true. It's also not clear it was invented by Palestinians - it's popular across the region. Finally, why the comment about 'white girls' saying 'literally' when something isn't literally true? Lots of people do this. Have fun with your impotent rage.
Stop lier
you can do a simple google search on the word ma'abarot and see all the refugee camps of middle eastern in the 1950s. How is that fully furnished?
Oh boohoo israelis use arabic words 😭😭
You stole the land of the Arabs, you stole their homes and now you are stealing their culture and language.
@@burhanhussain8697 Half of iseaeli jews come from arab countries. Its their language and culture as well
There were hardly any people in palestine. Before the jews came, in 1880, jerusalem, now home to 1,000,000 people, was a town of 40,000, most of them jews.
Israelis using "arabic made words" like yalla and sababa, cry me a river..
Half of israeli jews come (fled) arabic countries, so yes, we eat humus, and many like arabic music. Big deal..
And 2.5 million arabs are citizens of israel, so yeah, there are arab cities in israel..
As for you being a "palestinian", here are some irrefutable facts about the invention of the palestinian people:
th-cam.com/video/MP0zH0mJBf8/w-d-xo.html
There is a lot of misleading information here ..
Oriental music for example:
We have never claimed that this music is ours. Israeli music is far from sounding like this :)
And as for Gal Gadot: she just came out dumb. There are no Israelis over the age of 5 who do not know that these words are in Arabic..
You are only spreading hate because every Israeli must during high school learn about the history of Israel and the occupation and the students know that they did not come to a land empty of people.
Shut up
Lier
True, Sarit Hadad probably didn't steal Farid's song. It's a cover/tribute and I assume she paid the licensing fee to use it. A lot of older Israelis grew up listening to Farid, Um Kalthoum etc in their countries of origin if they are from the Arab world, and they brought that tradition with them. Farid is actually very popular in Israel. In fact, based on my channel stats, per capita, he is more popular in Israel than in any other country in the world. To me, on a basic level, enjoying music is a human right. If it touches someone's heart, I don't see how you deny this. But actually stealing music for profit, that's another issue. And in that area, the Turks are the biggest offenders when it comes to Arabic music.
@@FaridHQyour name is not the name of a terrorist so change your name to a name that fits you. Try Benjamin, a lot of terrorists have that name so it’s more befitting for you
تقيل دم
مين
You mean you sold it furnished
No, you stole it.
give it a few years you wont be a people too