ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Government Planning to Rename India to Bharat? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
The Indian government is reportedly planning to rename the country from "India" to "Bharat".
The reports were triggered by a presidential invite for the G20 dinner which described Droupadi Murmu as the "President of Bharat".
Why is the government planning such a move? What is the origin of the India vs Bharat debate? Palki Sharma tells you.
India | Bharat | President's Invite | Name Debate | G20 Invitation | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#india #bharat #namedebate #g20invitation #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
#Firstpost2Million: Thank you viewers for your trust! Leave a comment and let us know what more would you like to see on the channel.
Bharath ❤️
Palkiji 🌹, Our Great Motherland has many names like Aaryavart, Bharat Varsh, Jambu Dweep, Bharat Khand.
Bharat is Most Appropriate 🇮🇳
So easily Srilanka, Myanmmar changed their names .. why can't India without legal issues
♥️Hamara Pyara Bharat ♥️
Its already named Bharat as per article 1 of the constitution which says "India, that is Bharat, shall be a union of states" .
Rather than raising differences between names.. And diverting everyone from main issues, Govt must work on them to ease life of common people.. Education.. Health.. Infrastructure.. Employment should be on top of its agenda..
Our country's name will automatically be on top in the world.
True....But when the government puts politics in front in the name of policy....the nation fails as a whole
So true brother but bjp and modi doesn't care about the youth they just wanna b in power by using hindutva iam a Christian but today itself I had prashad due to janmashtami I have no hate for Hindus but brothers n sisters who r Hindu should not come under theirs words n trying to break India
Also will the North, South, East and the West India agreed with that?
Big change doesn't come in a day it takes thousands of little changes...Bharat has changed it education policy, Bharat was the first country to provide free vaccine in COVID time ,also don't forget it latest achievement like chandrayan 3.....these all are the small changes which are the first step of the ultimate change...Bharat is one of the fastest developing country in the world.... Bharat is making it names in the world and u don't want it to be name by a meaningless word given by other rather than the meaningful word given by our own ancestors...I think it a right time to change it names to show world the actual origin of Bharat..
Don't you agree to the fact that India is the English name and Bharat is the hindi name.....ITS MOTHERINDIA....NOT MOTHER BHARAT.....ITS BHARAT MATA....NOT BHARAT MOTHER
India AND Bharat. Who is saying we aren't both? We can call others the names we know historically instead of what they chose to be called in modern times, but we have respect for others.
Hearing a country name India is more better because whole World is used to it, but when it comes to question like do you know Bharat country? Many people around the world will confused because it'll take time to be used it as Name of the country
Don't worry it's the age of internet, even if they didn't know about India they will know now, because of name change news and foreign news agenda of hindu rastra etc,, they will all know it better now..
India is a name given to us by neighbours tht too mispronounced by Greeks as Indus Our ancestors named it BHarat anytime i wld be loved to be called by name my parents kept for me rather than a neighbour...........Bharat is an emotion a Feeling its not about Jobs Economy inflation Traffic jams pollution the world or any nation will always be having such problems it will never end...........lets embrace with open heart wht we really are wht our identity is was.......its the begining of new Bharat varsh
The truth is that we are more Indian than Bharatiya. Not many, including BJP fans and leaders themselves, will go for a Gurukul education for their kids. Food, clothing, shelter, any basic need, or even wants, when one considers - not many are keen on adopting the Bharatiya lifestyle. It's always more western, i.e. Indian, in nature. Even when the benefits of the Bharatiya way is clear in some measures. The parliamentary system isn't going to go away, in favour of a national Panchayat system or anything similar! Even when Sehwag says that the cricket team's t-shirt should say Bharat, he forgets that it's a sport invented by you-know-who! While our traditional roots justifies the name "Bharat", the name "India" justifies our choices (where not all choices are forced, some Indian choices are chosen for positive reasons).
There are other problems that need to be fixed in India . But politicans are more concerned renaming India to Bharat .
They are better at name changing cities and country than developing the country
@Freebankcoaching every small.change matters. U think govt didn't do anything to develop our country
Internal problems exist in every country and will continue existing forever, so by this logic we would never be able to rename India as Bharat
Exactly
I agree. Beside development the biggest enemy of India (and Humanity) is LCF (Left, Corrupt and Fundamentalists), and Modi ji has failed in countering them. Only rising Sanatani will expose and counter them effectively.
Madam
Bharat is not from King Bharat
It refers to the Battle of the 10 Kings, where the Bharatas won the battle and banished all the other 9 Kings to Persia Greece Russia etc
We have more urgent issues to address then changing country name, nothing wrong with India which is Bharat, This is nothing but political distraction from main issues like unemployment, inflation ect!
I like India - our civilization started at the Indus Valley River. And it’s currently recorded as the oldest alongside Egypt and Sumeria. India, from Indus, shows the tremendous continuity of the country, even before the Aryan invasion or known religions.
There was no Aryan invasion.
1.Burma - Myanmar
2.Holland - Netherlands
3.Cylon - Sree Lanka
4.Siam - Thailand
5.Czech Republic - Czechia
6.Turkey - Turkiye
7.Swasiland - Eswarini
and many more countries included in it
"Bhaarath Warsh" nice good name and can rename india into "BHAARATH WARSH"
(Sindhu Rever - Indhu - hindhu - hindhusthaan named by mugals and india named by British.
Traditional and historic name is always solid and stronger and meaningful and thus need to restore our nation's historical and tradional identity than any dirty thief society of british who named the nation name !...
India also must cancel the partition of Pakistan and Bangladesh and adobt back as it was the part of india.also india must reatore back Sreelanka as the part of india and should declare Tibet and East Turkesran ( Uyigurstan) as independent nations only and must stop trade with dramatic russia who have indirec game by using china against india as if india will keep on buy weopons from Russia for china threat and also russia is making drama with india through china Pakistan relationship as if rissia dreaming to boost its bussiness of weopons trade with india !... Fooling india .
Whoever supporting to change our country name from India to Bharat. Please think about the consequences.
There are lots of government documents which has a word as India including our currency. Will they plan to replace in that too?
Another GDP growth for Modi to claim
Chinta mat Karo ..
India ki shuruvaat 1820 ke aas pass hoti hai
Bharat ki shuruvaat min 3000 saal pahle se hoti hai ..
Isliye document change karna jaroori hai
I know these people are act like changing the name is gonna be beneficial
Ceylon changed to original name Srilanka, Burma changed to original name Myanmar, Persia changed to original name Iran, Siam changed to original name Thailand
Why not India to original name Bharat.
♥️Hamara Pyara Bharat ♥️
Cant just wait to see it, proud to be an Bharatiyan🇮🇳
It does sound weird right?😂
We would call ourself bharatiya, and the world will call us bharatian, both are valid
Bharath matha ki jai🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I love my india. India is beautiful Land many people and different tribes and living. Respected Mahatma Gandhi also brought very much love for India. We can't change sun name always to be called sun☀️.. India must be always India.
In Telugu our mother tongue we call our country as Bharatadesham and constitution as Bharata rajyangam so it's our emotion to have our country name as Bharat.
I think India should be name India. I am part Gujarati, Kashmiri and Punjabi. I am Juliet Tun alias Khin-Nanda Tun alias Julana Tolia
हिंदुस्तान जिंदाबाद, भारत माता की जय, ,glory to mother bharat🇮🇳🙂🙏
One day we woke up and felt like we were in the wrong world called India, so we decided to identify as Bharat, with criticizing the British given name,.
But we would like to keep the Corruption mentality as usual. -Politicians
Great 👍. It should have been done at the time of independence only.
In the defence forces. We say.
Jai hind or Bharat mata ki jai
Jai hind or long live India in english
They also say Indian Army, Indian Airforce etc both can exist but trying to erase India is pettiness and vulgar ideology.
Jai hind is hindi for long live india, its stupid to right bharat in english language. We should use bharat in local indian language and india in english language
Bharatiye ❤🇮🇳
Bharat Mata ki Jai ❤
In every Indian language, the name is Bhaarat, Bhaarata, Bhaaratam. So the key question is do we want a foreign language (English) to be part of our core identity, or do we want to have our native identity based on our own native languages. Every other nation has its name in its own native language, not in a foreign language. Are we going to forever live in the shadow of being ruled by Britain, or are we going to assert our own identity?
I feel very enraged just thinking of them removing India because I'm very much attached with the name.
Unfortunately Tilak dharana is not respected in work places and people were laughing at them. Strong and stricter laws have to be enforced to bring back the glory of Hindus. Encourage Tilak Dharana, Hindus should form and stay as a group in the public places.
Thank god they did change the name to "Hindustan"
Hindu is the name given by british. Change that first
so is India…. You can’t give up on India… India is not just a name, it’s a sentiment.. It’s Indian army, it’s Indian navy, it’s Indian Airforce, it IIT, IIM, ISRO, it’s the chant of millions when Sachin is batting, INDIA INDIA INDIA… it’s our recognition, in United Nations, in BRICS, in the world..! And you can never take that away from us..
Tell this nonsense in your gosbells and also before making this kind of have basic common sense
Bharat is officially registered name in our constitution
You can go through article 1 where it is clearly mentioned that India that is Bharat Shall be Union of States
If renamed to Bharat .... you can be used to Bharat also it's not a problem at all
the name is given by British dude...nope no sentiment, not everyone wanna call you by ur nickname given by your bf lol
@@bionicmalicename is based on the oldest civilization of India. India and Indie are way older than Bharat 😂
@@bionicmalice India was known India from more than 3000 years cos of the Indus Valley.. It’s a name given to us by Greece ages ago… Long before Bharat… And Indian constitution is Indian constitution..!! Constitution of INDIA..!!
Here we are facing unemployment, poverty, high price of basic things, low living standards, etc. But government is busy on changing our country's name. So shameful.
Stop mugging Qur'an..learn something else..
@@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vb the fuck bro....kya khayega? Bharat? Bhukha marne se
Different issues altogether..move on..
But the only ones crying over it is you. India, Bharat, Hindustan has always been used interchangeably. Who really gives a shit?
Yes, harsh treatments to Muslims living in Uttar Pradesh. Their houses and shops are being demolished leaving no rooms for their livelyhood. Palki has blind eye
honestly politicians in India have no work. Instead of fixing issues and doing meaningful work to better people's lives, they keep pursuing useless issues like this.
To you maybe its useless, but it is extremely important to shed colonial mindset. Give the nation its identity and roots back. It is a mindset changer, it also sheds the negative impressions the west has with the word india. It shows things have changed, its not the same as before......Why do you think parents think a lot before giving their children a name,,,would you have rather your parents named you childABC and be done with it?
It will not happen, do not worry, or India has too much to lose. There are great heights awaiting your great country, which may soon move ahead of China, and best not to play with destiny too much. Mahabharata will always stay, but India, that's something!
@happyhap7207 And what about the English language, western clothes, food, media etc. Reject them too ?
@@happyhap7207 it already has an identity, what are we lacking there? What we are lacking is more education and infrastructure. This whole Bharat play is just beating a religious drum. India had already made its mark in the world. Also India stems from Indus not the British.
@@eunoia832; are we the only country using English language? 😅 what exactly is "western food"?
INDIA is a brand internationally !
Bharath is a feeling.. Nothing can replace the feeling of proudly saying 'I'm an INDIAN' in this world !!
BHARAT should always be planted inside every INDIAN but not forcefully fed..
if it's necessary to do so, everyone deserves to know the true reason behind it from the respected bodies even we know it had historical reasons.. because changing name doesn't come cheap..
#BharathIndia
Bharat Ratna
hereafter India Ratna to slave minds.
Proud to be Indian in uk
@@ilachauhan4666 ek bharati aapko namaskar kerta hai 🙏
We have to understand and rationally think about this through a 78 year prism in a 10000 year old civilization history.
Agreed
Bharat, India, Hind, and Hindustan are all valid names of this great civilization. None of these names are mutually exclusive at all. Japan is a name given to Nippon by foreigners as well, but is as valid as Yamato- the ancient name of Japan, as well as Nippon. 'India' has a huge brand name value, and should never be discarded, in the same way Bharat evokes the very soul of this great country. 'India' has a ring to it that is almost musical. Its civilizational impact is immense, and its application is immeasurable. From Apache Indians to the Indian Ocean, or the popular girl's name India, as well as the Arabic name Hind, India is everywhere. Even an international code of signals flag is 'I for India'.
I also think the same, the name India was given to us by the Greeks not the Britishers, and it has an immense brand value, so why not keep it.
Hindustan isn't valid! If you mean the northern part of India you can say so but not the rest
The name India was given by Greeks, Hindu by persians, Hind by Arabs, Hindustan by Turks. All Names given by invaders. We call our country Bharat named after King Bharat, Aryavart - land of Aryan s similar to Iran. Bharat and India cannot be same. Bharat represents Indias ancient past whereas India represents colonial past. Germany may be almania or deuchland, Japan maybe Nippon but there is big difference between India and bharat
Bharat is the only valid one at best India can be used as secondary name for international purposes.
Fuck the code of signals. Such a minor excuse to not change the name. India is kinda nickname given to the great land of Bharat, and that too not out of love to the land, but to suppress the people by all means, be it mentally, physically or otherwise.
India had several names given by several people. The Ancient Tamils, for example, named the Indian subcontinent as Nāvalan Taṇpoḻil (நாவலந் தண்பொழில்) or simply Nāvalam (நாவலம்). The name is formed with these Tamil root words: Nāval (one of the ancient Indian trees) + Am (beauty) + Taṇ (cold / cool) + Poḻil (greatness / country / forrest). So it means, "the cool beautiful country rich in Nāval trees".
Same as Jambudweepa in Sanskrit, Jambu and Naval are same fruit...
Now again stand on queues for changing name on all documents from birth certificate to educational documents to passport to death certificate .. Leave all your work and roam here n there.. Non sense. Country runs on logic not on emotions.. Seriously yaar fed up with this government..
who gave you this info ? mickey mouse ?
@@AmitSharma-sc9gg Who needs information. Bjp is so brainless they can do anything.. Since 2017 we are seeing their dramas
There are no shortage of clowns in this country 😅
God just like demonisation another stupidity
❤❤
It's not renaming. It's reclaiming our forever name "Bharat"❤ भारत 🇮🇳
Practically its renaming
It's already called Bharat AND INDIA.. Don't need a law for it.. it ll make zero difference.. jus cost a lot of tax payers money to make changes which will do nothing for the people of this country
Nope Bharat sounds horrible. India should stay😌😌😌
@@masterb0ssnot anymore. South Indian Tamil sangam literatures says bhathm and not india.
@@masterb0ss y wud South Indians have a problem with the centre favouring Hindi over English.. I understand if they favour Hindi over kannada,Tamil, telgu or malyalam and then if South Indians have an issue.. but Hindi over English sudn be a problem for the South Indians.. if it is then something wrong with the south Indians..
Btw I'm not for renaming the country.. I like it the way it is
India or Bharat? ❌
India,that is Bharat ✅
India is Bharat always.
This just another thing to deviate people’s attention to trivia but not on pressing issues ( which needs action for structural to individual level)
Because it is easy to create noise than to compose music.
Bharat, that is India
Only Bharat
@@cmukherjee6692both should be there
How Many times do you use Bharat instead of india ?
@@prathik2037bharat word is used in many regional languages
At least have some common sense while asking a question
You guys have no problem with English imposition which is purely not indian
But have problem with our own cultural heritage
INDIA
I don't see why anyone other than anglophiles or colonial lovers would oppose this. Also, if you oppose it now you are just delaying the inevitable...10 years 50 years 100 years later changing names of "indian" constitutions would be even more complicated, so as early as better. This country is experiencing a civilization reawakening and not just the name of this country, a lot will change in coming years and decades. Tough times ahead for anglophiles.
get rid of the constitution too, and the supreme court those are also anglohpile colonialism, never let anybody in out of Bharat, the outside world is filled with colonialism
You are writing in english, because you are an anglophile.
We should ban english also.
Its a product of colonialism right ?
Yas saar😡 we shud also change new delhi as capital saar because who are britisaaaars to decide our capital of our punya bhoomi😡😡😡
We should deklare nagpur as kapital with immediate effect sar and deklare cow as national animal and cow urine as national drink saar
Also we shud dismantle indian army sar as its command was structured during british sar😡😡
Yea and then Pakistan will change it's name to India, all thanks to mudiji
@@danielthomas5401
if can read you bible in malyalam and still take orders from the pope then what is wrong if praise my country in english ??
We people will always focus on things that matter the least in the lives of a common man.
That's why we are still a third world country.
@@JSVKK Definitely not a 3rd world country, but yeah, still in the later stages of developing.
glad to see there are still Indians that know how to think for themselves n use their brains. this is so true people dont realise this name change is not free it will cost us lot of money, money we can use in better cause. it dosent matter if its India or bharath if we still have poor uneducated people who struggle everyday for basic human needs in our country its not worth it, what is the difference? same country just different name and some billions of dollars after.
not if the party keeps distracting us from more pressing issues@@RandomKun
@@abhigyanghosh7561true bro,
Unemployment,GDP fkd, everything is ruined
Parties in India behaving like school children 😓
😂😂😜 So called news channels too😂😂😂
Its a rumour. Something big is expected from special session of Parliament
स्कूल चिल्ड्रेन आर स्टिल लर्निंग बट, स्टिल behave better than some of the politicians who are 8th standard fail... Such as लालू प्रसाद के शहजादा
Hindus name should also be changed
yes, and its sanatan dharma, i.e sanatani !@@shubhthepro
We Indians are emotionally bonded to five letter feeling " INDIA"...❤
Better Govt concentrate on development agenda rather than fulfilling their own agenda.
You want your mother should be recognized by a colonial name that was given by her oppressors to identify our motherland as a slave country????? Name is your pride, a name is your emotion...Look at Srilanka and Mayanmar, they changed their colonial name from Ceylon and Burma to Srilanka and Mayanmar respectively because they didn't want a colonial name for their land. And look at us debating here.
I sense some political agenda in your comment too.
@@BatukaBhairavaSevak_Tuhin you look for yourself not others . We are happy with the name 😂😂
@@BatukaBhairavaSevak_Tuhinif you want to abolish colonial mindset that badly then why are you not raising concerns over UPSC? The entire bureaucratic system? It was derived out of British rule then why not dissolve that too? Infact the way superiors treat/consider juniors in this civil service is the same way British considered Indians. They feel themselves as "superior humans" as compared to other less privileged people the same way British once felt.
P.S. Do you even realise the level of software gore that will happen if IND changes to BHT?
@@BatukaBhairavaSevak_Tuhin Does changing a name really change colonial mindset of a whole country? Some people don't even think about it. Its infact not named by britishers but by greeks. It's named after indus Valley so what is wrong with it?
#bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
ऋषभदेव महाराज (चतुर्थकाल में जैन धर्म के प्रथम तीर्थंकर) के सौ पुत्र हुए। इनमें जो सबसे बड़े थे वो थे भरत, वो इतने मग्न रहते थे तपस्या के अंदर कि उनको कहीं किसी चीज़ की चेतना ही नहीं रहती थी इसलिए उनको जड़ भरत का नाम दिया जाता था। वो जड़ भरत जो थे उन्हीं के नाम पर देश का नाम भारत पड़ा।
ये और दुष्यंत के पुत्र भरत दोनों ही मत कहे जाते हैं। लेकिन ज्यादा वर्णन दुष्यंत शकुंतला के पुत्र का ही पढ़ा है जो प्रतापी सम्राट हुए। शकुंतला ऋषि विश्वामित्र की बेटी थी।
@@Exiide89 th-cam.com/video/LNy1Sso1cfk/w-d-xo.html
@@Exiide89 श्रीमद्भागवत महापुराण (स्कन्ध-5, अध्याय-7, श्लोक 3)
अजनाभं नामैतद्वर्षं भारतमिति यत आरभ्य व्यपदिशन्ति ॥3॥
शब्दार्थ
अजनाभम्-अजनाभ; नाम-नाम से; एतत्-यह; वर्षम्-द्वीप; भारतम्-भारत; इति-इस प्रकार; यत:-जिससे; आरभ्य-प्रारम्भ करके; व्यपदिशन्ति-कहते हैं, पुकारते हैं।
पहले इस देश का नाम अजनाभवर्ष था, किन्तु महाराज भरत के शासन काल से इसका नाम भारतवर्ष पड़ा। यह देश पहले राजा नाभि (ऋषभदेव महाराज के पिता) के शासन के कारण अजनाभ कहलाता था। भरत महाराज के शासन काल के बाद यह भारतवर्ष कहलाया।
I would support bharatha, which makes us feel proud of our ancestory and culture. ❤
India from Sindhu river doesnt make you proud?
@venkatsusheelg9658 The sindhu River is now in pakistan. We don't even own it now
@@venkatsusheelg9658river name shouldn't be country name...
Bharat used from Vedas and Bharat khanda said by god's
Do Bharat makes you feel shame?
Do one thing, tomorrow throw out all your t-shirts and jeans and start wearing lungis. You will feel very proud of your culture and ancestry.
@@venkatsusheelg9658came from greek
Nothing is more proud for me than saying loudly that I am an Indian, 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 and in Bengali I would call myself Bhaarotiyo. India name is in my blood, how can we change it? It would be an artificial enforcement, India word is everywhere... RBI, IIT, NIT.... tends to be infinty. How much force these propagandaist people will apply!!!
Fellow Bhadralok, you would have been slapped hard by Rabindranath Thakur for your utter stupidity.
Rabindranath wrote Bharata Bhagyavidhata, not India Bhagyavidhata in our National Anthem. 😁
NIT = National Institute of technology 🥹🫂
I feel when I say Bharat institute of technology, it gives more essence of our historic background. Even though Britishers did not gave birth to India name, but feels more towards them to me personally
The Netherlands was never officially "Holand". Holand is a province of the Netherlands, and was a principality Before the formation of the Dutch republic. Americans may have confused the two names but it was never the official international name.
"The low lands" (direct translation of Netherlands) was used as a name for the whole region
Long over due name change. Name, India smacks of colonial suppression and foreign name tagging. Bharat and Bharatians sounds and glorifies the land and its people. Jai Bharat.
@@purushotmennaidoo Bharatian is as stupid as Indian. The real word is Bharati/Bharatvarshi.
@@purushotmennaidoo Bharat doesn't sound good at all. India is iconic and is here to stay
@@shreyaskumarrath721 chal be samose. .
@@jatinchauhan6009 chal be Madarchodsthani
The government shouldn't rename the country unilaterally. The decision should be made by the people through a national referendum.
Its not name change... It's just to have one name
They are trying to erase history
@@shivang551why have one name ?? So as per you for past so many years since ages back of Harappan culture were we using a wrong name?? Have we lost connection to river INDUS ??? HOW CAN WE BE SO MEAN TO MOTHER INDUS RIVER????
When “India” was kept as a name, have our people get to choose or decline name ? Don’t see to keep India as a name. It has to be one only “Bharat”
@@omnamahshivay970 were you dropped on the head as a child. did you honestly think we are named india because of the Indus River. the name india is the name the greek merchants used to refer to us in their conversations way before the British invaded us and rubbed our faces into the ground and said you are india, and tried to remove any traces of bharat from the country. by changing every name on the map that is related to our history. Indus River My foot.. do you not know that "Indus River" was originally called Sindhu river(present in the vedas) and that the Persians for their convinience for their use, came up with the name Hind river, and when that name reached the greeks it became Indos and when that reached the brits it became india. i mean the name Sindhi has been there with authentic documentation before even your birth or my birth. We always called ourselves (collective) Bharat, before the invasions, even the mogul invasions. that is the lost pride we are trying to revive. we can continue to live a false reality created by those oppressors and those that favor them or we can learn the actual facts of history and move forward with the right steps as we rebuilt our nation. if you want to have a who cares attitude, well that is up to you. but at least learn the correct facts so you won't appear as a dilettante. take care.🙏
Yes , Dr. Ambedkar wanted to give name Bharat only .
He knew that after few decades everybody will know only India
So he written :
India that is Bharat
The real name 🚩🇮🇳
Amazing how thoughtfully he has written our constitution.
Dr. Ambedkar is idiot who oppose the name bharat in place of india
Ambedkar support both bharat n india .. His debate on record .
@@aswini4222bro, people should understand that he himself didn't written constitution. It's all done by many members of committee.
Even many members of committee said that, put Bharat alone in name instead of India.
And many said that atleast put Bharat first, and India after Bharat.
But their requests were rejected by Congress committee and by Ambedkar himself due to his western approach.
Then they put India, that is Bharat instead of Bharat, that is India.
This person who commented about Ambedkar...he don't know anything about history or about constitution. He just wanted to give credit of everything to Ambedkar without knowing the facts and history.
That's how social media works...people believes in lies instead of truths.
@@aswini4222 The UK king declared that he will not recognize such a change.
Indian Ocean ka kya hoga ? Thete is only one country in the world which has ocean named with its name. Will international community agree to change its name to bharat ocean. What about Indian Subcontinent? What about indian cuisine? What about ISRO ? ISRO ko kya BSRO bologe ? IIT ? IIM ? AIIMS ? IAS ? Kis kis ko badaloge ? There is immense soft Power associated with name India, which is imprinted on the rest of the world. Name India is a brand in rest of the world.
USA main bhi "Red Indians" hain. Columbus named them Red Indians when he wanted to reach India.
Why do we want to throw away all the connections and Soft power associated with name India.
There is no need to remove name India. Padi lakdi kyu leni hai ?
Pakistan will lay claim on Name India as they are on Indus river and they will take all the brand value.
INDIA is in English...&...BHARAT is in Hindi...🙏
Politicians need to understand that English is a global language and people in this world know us by INDIA and we also feel proud by denoting ourselves INDIANS❤...they can not forcefully impose any language (hindi) in this world 🌎 ...but the lack of knowledge and illiteracy among MPs and their vote bank religious politics is causing all these nuisance.
I wish in 2024 ...we could get educated PM and ministers✍️
Bharat is already the name in the constitution. "India that is Bharat."
The official name should be "Hindu Rastra of Bharat".
India seems to just be the English name. Like how Nippon's English name is Japan or the English name for Deutschland is Germany.
This verse is one of the main and famous verses of the Hindu scripture Gita This verse is verse 7 and 8 of Adhyay 4 of Gita This verse was narrated by Lord Krishna in Mahabharata when Arjuna refused to fight in Kurukshetra
Yada Yada Hi Dharmasya Glanirbhavati Bharat.
अभ्युत्थानमधर्मस्य तादत्मनां स्र्जाम्यहम ॥4-7॥
Paritranaya sadhunam vinashay cha dushkritam.
Dharmasthapanaarthay Sambhavami Yuge Yuge ॥4-8॥
Meaning: I appear, I come, whenever there is loss of righteousness, I come, whenever unrighteousness increases, I come, I come to protect the good people, to destroy the wicked. I come for this, I come for the establishment of religion and take birth in every age🙏
@@sandysharma885
🙏🙏🙏
🛕🛕🛕
Jai Sri Krishna!
Happy Janmashtami!
It should be “Bharat, that is India.”
भारत is the real name which gives strength. India is a name modified by foreigners और Republic of Bharat सुनकर सुकून मिलता है खुशी सी महसूस होतीं है। भारत ही सही है।
Republic of Bharat स्वर्ण अक्षरों में passport पर लिखा जाए तो अलग ही उत्साह आता है।
Bhartiya Ganarajya sounds better than Republic of Bharat
@@zeref611 agreed 👍
@@zeref611 ok. But what about the other Language speaking people of our beloved country. They also want it to get translated as well then.
India सुनकर बुखार आ जाता क्या? 😂😂
So this is what the Nation needs most hn......we are free from all other problems like poverty, inflation, unemployment, religious intolerance,Rapes, Farmers suicides etc........
Expect nothing less from Media, Even though the government is not planning to change the Name....Every Media network is focussing on this based on a single letter......Way to divert people minds from real issue.... Always best at creating diversions 😂😂😂
It will ne a useless debate after 18th September, since they have something more in their Agenda.
So many problems to solve but this is what the government wants to debate on 🤦🏻♀️
This is fun activity - needs no much thinking and get people into debate, especially those who dont have much work. I will debate this in my next weekend with my friends, I am going to lose few friends due to this .. .. so much to look out for in coming week..
The government is just trying to engage the people in senseless debates. More fights and arguments among the common public. Meanwhile they’re gonna chill & not focus on real socio-economic issues. Idiots here are delusional enough to think that BJP, a political party, is doing all this to solely protect their age old culture😂
Govt did not do or say anything on this.. its the media circus and leftists shit scared of the very assumption of change of name :D
Opp call for debate not govt
@@SMCGPRA is the opposition not part of the government?
Don't play gimmick with historical names. Let our country be known by both names India & Bharat.
Is BJP so terrified 😨 by I.N.D.I.A. that it has to change name ?! Remember tomorrow opposition alliance can rename itself B.H.A.R.A.T. then what ??**
They won't
Always proud to be a Bhartiya that is an Indian 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Indian is english bharat is hindi same
@@shiba9592 bharat is sanskrit term
5000year name bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat bharat
@@RavindraSagar-sm4nm
Do you have documents of 5000 years
Let's also get rid of word Bharat as it is another name of Manu who wrote manusmriti, the one who advocated cast system in india to oppress BC/SC/ST population. How can we allow this uppercaste people who are promoting there agenda of manusmriti in name of culture.
ഭാരതത്തെ ജർമ്മൻ ഭാഷയിൽ അറിയപ്പെടുന്നത് 'Indien' എന്നാണ്. ശരിക്കും പറഞ്ഞാൽ india എന്ന വാക്ക് ഭാരതത്തിന്റെ ഇംഗ്ലീഷ് വേർഡ് ആണ്. ജർമ്മനിയെ ജർമ്മൻ ഭാഷയിൽ അറിയപ്പെടുന്നത് 'Deutscheland' (ഡെച്ഛ്ലാൻഡ്) എന്നാണ്, ഇംഗ്ലീഷിൽ ജർമ്മനിഎന്നും. ജർമ്മൻകാർ Deutscheland എന്ന് മാത്രമേ ജർമ്മനിയിൽ ഉപയോഗിക്കാറുള്ളു. 'De' എന്ന് അവരുടെ വെബ്സൈറ്റിൽ കാണാൻ പറ്റും. ഇപ്പോഴും ഇന്ത്യയെ ചില പാകിസ്ഥാനികളും ഇറാനികളും Hindustan എന്ന് മാത്രമേ വിളിക്കാറുള്ളു കാരണം പേർഷ്യൻ ഭാഷകളിൽ ഇന്ത്യ എന്നതിന് പകരം Hindustan ആണ്. ഡെച്ഛ്ലാൻഡും ജർമ്മനിയും തമ്മിലുള്ള വ്യത്യാസം ആണ് ഭാരതവും ഇന്ത്യയും തമ്മിൽ ഉള്ളത്. ഇതുപോലെ അനവധി ഉദാഹരണങ്ങൾ ഉണ്ട്. 🌹
Not really necessary to be honest. India is such a beautiful name.
There are so many other issues government should focus on and take care in the country right now.
Only for westerners not for bhartiya people
@@manthanpatel6295 Only for uneducated politician and their andhbakht have problem with it.
@@manthanpatel6295then why did before this change of name came out all of you were commenting proud to be Indian when India landed on the moon?
@@manthanpatel6295 Bharat sounds very cheap to be honest India name has a class to it
@@moonriser464 jesus name is cheap we call it sh!t , shit sounds classy ha ha ha
In my opinion govt should not change the name. It will create lots of difficulties for common man like updating documents.
also think about Indian food, Indian ocean, Indonesia, Indo-pacific, Indo-sphere, Indiana, West Indies, Indians...
Technically it wouldnt be that hard to implement, just keep previous documentations as legal but every new one that is filed or given out will have the new name. Until it has fully phased out the old documents with name of india on them.
You have assumed problems which do not exist .
@@suidowong7222West India.
American Indians.
Indiana etc have nothing to do with Bhaarat.
They were names created by Europeans
Let them deal with it. Not our problem by any means.
@@senor2930 ...which is why they want to change it. India is a name given by Europeans.
Indian Ocean
Indian army
Indian airforce
Indian Navy
Indian everything😢😢😢
Personaly i want both Bharat and India to be there.
Brother please tell me one thing are you from India or North Korea
Bharat is officially registered name in our constitution
You can go through article 1 where it is clearly mentioned that India that is Bharat Shall be Union of States
Me too
@@ilmakhanafridi9396Brother please tell me one thing are you from India or North Korea
Bharat is officially registered name in our constitution
You can go through article 1 where it is clearly mentioned that India that is Bharat Shall be Union of States
Hind/Bharat Mahasagar
Bharatiya Sena
Bharatiya Vayu Sena
Bharatiya Nausena
Have you heard these names for the 1st time?? Surely not. Just telling Bharat is already the official name of the country just as India
@@pedadasiddardha9655 In 1947, Pakistan had expected after
partition the names of the countries willbe
Pakistan and Hindustan/Bharat. They took
promise that this will be how it is done. But
then they felt betrayed when India continued
to use the name India and thus got all its
legacy and achievements. This means it
became like Pakistan sliced away from India
and became a new country rather than one
country getting divided into two. Jinaah had
a lot of arguments and protests to force
ndia to change the name to anything other
than "India". This was one of the biggest
successes of Indian govt of that time to keep
the same name
Even till today Pakistanis are pissed about
the word "India" being used at a lot of places,Even till today Pakistanis are pissed about
the word "India" being used at a lot of places,
including their history before 1947, the name
of the ocean being Indian ocean, their
country being referred as part of Indian
subcontinent and they having to teach their
kids that British Invaded India... And this is
not at all about an irrelevant country like
Pakistan. I wrote it just to bring my point that
we are losing all this clout. No other country
has an Ocean named after them.
Even US recently changed the name of this
region from Asia-Pacific to Indo-Pacific to
piss off China and include India into theWe would basically lose all our history. It
would be like Pakistan, who is constantly ir
identity crisis because they dont want to talk
about anything before 1947 that has India in
it.
LOOK at IRAN for example. They had lots of
legends and mythms and cultures all over
the world in name of Persia. But their king
nsisted on being renamed from Persia in the
last century and lost all the legacy of Persia.
Now most people dont even know Iran was
Persia. It is like end of a thousand of years of
legacy being lost for no benefit.
You can no longer claim British colonization
and its effects. British colonized India, not
Bharat or Pakistan or Bangladesh. Their
company was East India company. They
were looking for India, not Bharat.
It doesn't matter.
What matters is the cost of living.
The smoke that we breathe every day.
The cost of healthcare and housing.
The lack of justice for common man.
Healthcare is much better than so called developed nations as cost wise...
Instead you should ask for increase in per capita...
If thats the logic what are your views on kerela government suggesting name change to keralam.
@@sumitsinghbisht9579 addition of a single “m" is easy dummy 😅
U are right all ur points are valid except the 1st one it does matter what is the name of country.
I will stand with my INDIA ❤
Who the hell BJP wants to change the name?
Who the hell you say ??? You want your mother should be recognized by a colonial name that was given by her oppressors to identify our motherland as a slave country????? Name is your pride, a name is your emotion...Look at Srilanka and Mayanmar, they changed their colonial name from Ceylon and Burma to Srilanka and Mayanmar respectively because they didn't want a colonial name for their land. And look at us debating here.
India is brand on global stage so if fully irradiate this name is foolish decision...
Indo Pacific
Indian ocean etc we takes more time to rebranding Bharat ....
So according to me
India is brand on world stage.
Bharat is emotion for us
🙏
If India becomes Bharat, I bet your bottom dollar, Indian Ocean will never become Bharat Ocean.
@@Gen_X No
Hindhusagara
Stop calling a country bran … stupiditu
@@Gen_Xvery true
Good clarification.we need both names as its mentioned in our constitution.
Not all want bharath...
I hate the word India. it sounds dead and meaningless.
most of the population doesnt want Bharat, only modibhakts (not trying to be political but I couldnt find any better way to say this)
@@anandshanmugam8080ok kid
Not just India is to be renamed, even Delhi should be renamed as Indraprastha - the original name of Delhi.
Hindus name should also be changed
tar mag Hinduism pan officially change kara...te pan British ne dile aahe 😂😂😂
@@shubhtheproR u a krack head??
first people should be above poverty line and with job security with minimum wages, no corruption. after than name change can be done
@@trollthetroller2 how about changing the name of India to China for a change?
India has become a brand world over..it does not make sense to change it. Bharat is always there synonymous to India.
Exactly
Haha joke India is a brand ?
@@TitoMaximus239it is
West Bengal changed its name changed to Bangla,
Travancore-Cochin → Kerala (1st November, 1956).
Madhya Bharat → Madhya Pradesh (1st November, 1959)
Madras State → Tamil Nadu (14th January, 1969)
Mysore State → Karnataka (1st November, 1973)
Uttaranchal → Uttarakhand (1st January, 2007)
Orissa → Odisha (4th November, 2011)
North-East Frontier Agency (NEFA) → Arunachal Pradesh (20th January 1972)
Burma changed its name changed to Myanmar,
Bombay changed its name changed to Mumbai,
There are Many Examples
cities names
Cities
Jabalpur (Hindi: जबलपुर), from Jubbulpore, respelled in 1947
Jajmau (Hindi: जाजमऊ), from Jajesmow, respelled in 1948[11]
Kanpur (Hindi: कानपुर), from Cawnpore, respelled in 1948
Vadodara (Gujarati: વડોદરા), from Baroda, respelled in 1974
Thiruvananthapuram (Malayalam: തിരുവനന്തപുരം), from Trivandrum, renamed in 1991
Mumbai (Marathi: मुंबई), from Bombay, renamed in 1995[12]
Kochi (Malayalam: കൊച്ചി), from Cochin, respelled in 1996
Chennai (Tamil: சென்னை), from Madras, renamed in 1996
Kolkata (Bengali: কলকাতা), from Calcutta, respelled in 2001
Medininagar (Hindi: मेदिनीनगर), from Daltonganj, renamed in 2004
Kadapa (Telugu: కడప), from Cuddapah, respelled in 2005
Puducherry (Tamil: புதுச்சேரி), from Pondicherry, renamed in 2006
Bengaluru (Kannada: ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು), from Bangalore, respelled in 2007[13]
Belagavi (Kannada: ಬೆಳಗಾವಿ), from Belgaum in 2007[14][15]
Tumakuru (Kannada: ತುಮಕುರು), from Tumkur in 2007
Hubballi (Kannada: ಹುಬ್ಬಳ್ಳಿ), from Hubli in 2007
Hosapete (Kannada: ಹೊಸಪೇಟೆ), from Hospet in 2007
Mysuru (Kannada: ಮೈಸೂರು), from Mysore in 2007
Kalaburagi (Kannada: ಕಲಬುರಗಿ), from Gulbarga in 2007
Chikkamagaluru (Kannada: ಚಿಕ್ಕಮಗಳೂರು), from Chikmagalur in 2007
Vijayapura (Kannada: ವಿಜಯಪುರ), from Bijapur in 2007
Ballari (Kannada: ಬಳ್ಳಾರಿ), from Bellary in 2007
Mangaluru (Kannada: ಮಂಗಳೂರು), from Mangalore in 2007
Rajahmahendravaram (Telugu: రాజమహేంద్రవరం), from Rajahmundry in 2015
Gurugram (Hindi: गुरुग्राम) from Gurgaon in 2016
Prayagraj (Hindi: प्रयागराज), from Allahabad, renamed in 2018
Atal Nagar (Hindi: अटल नगर), from New Raipur, renamed in 2018
Narmadapuram (Hindi: नर्मदापुरम), from Hoshangabad, renamed in 2021
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Marathi: छत्रपती संभाजीनगर), from Aurangabad, renamed in 2023
Dharashiv (Marathi: धाराशिव), from Osmanabad, renamed in 2023
Just because opposition chose INDIA as the name for their alliance, our supreme leader decided to change the name of the whole country. This is a mad man driven by his ego and narcissism. example COVID management, Demonetization, Pulwama attacks, GST and so on.
Every citizen's passport says 'Republic of India'. Will everyone in India and abroad be forced to get new passports? What nonsense! This is note-ban all over again. Do you guarantee that everyone will get passports and Aadhar if they reapply? Or is this a move to make non-Hindus second class citizens?
Can we also change the Indian Ocean to Bharat ocean.? Because I don’t want to miss the tagline “the only country to which an ocean is named “.
Modi government is trying real hard to bring and mix religion in politics this is not really building the country but tearing it apart from the inside
I personally have since childhood grown an attachment to "India" and associate a sense of national feeling to it. I love the word BHARAT and I know the history of the word "India" but would still prefer it not be changed. Lets see how this unfolds...
@@user.undefinedshut up.. we are not going to choose.. why would we? Can u choose between ur mother and father?
@@user.undefinedkaha se ate he ye log, itna foreign se nafrat he to internet use mat karo, sab chiz slavery aur british raj nahi hoti
@@sroy7982 Identity and technology are not the same.
What u call ur self is very important - it should have meaning.
@@mlg1279so this is where u want our taxpayers money to go anyways majority of the portion is going to salary and pension
@@ujwalkuckian What taxpayer's money? It's not going to cost anything. I don't think we will stop using India. We may start using Bharat more
BJP govt is not bother about in change of development ,educational changes, unemployment it is concerned about changing like number plates, renaming the roads, building statues and circles with decorated names, It clearly shows that our thoughts are second class." APPA BOLO BAPU BOLO DADA BOLO tho PITHGY YEE RAHEGA" These all cunning politics.
Go and eat your heart out. Happy miserable times ahead.
I understand your urging what you need is burnol
Why did you mention development are you some kind of fool, are the railways not developed, aren't the roads, the electricity (cut off) which we get in our home, because in my lifetime I remember traveling on the same train line which Britishers left and learning that there are trains which run at 600 km/h but apart from rajdhani Or shatabdi there was nothing for my great grandfather it took 12 hours to reach our village the same time it took me as well but now I reach there in 8 hours that's happened in last 5 years, wasn't it modi digital india plan, aren't you getting cylinder at your doorstep, I used to cycle about 12 km at 3 AM in morning in my village and come back home at night after getting the cylinder around 2008 but now they deliver to your home just because I booked it online, don't claim false thing one thing the BJP did is develop the nation's infrastructure and digital standing rest I don't care
over half a dozen IITS and AIIMS built in past 9 years more than 70 years of Ganduji family. from 1947 to 2014 only 1.2 Trillion dollars, but from 2014 to 2023 ,Bharath is at 3.5 trillion dollars. More roads were built under Nitin Gadkari than Ganduji family. North East finally has some roads and Over a dozen new Hugh ways and more Airports built and new Railway resources. The wealth has increased of every one and over 300 million removed from poverty.....
Let me tell you a story during the Spanish Inquisition and Goan inquisition nazi invasions they all changed the name of the places they attacked and conquered but as soon as it is they are gone. The countries and governments of the respective places changed it back to their original name.Because it symbolises slavery that you are still under control of the Invaders, Like Hyderabad original name is BhagyaNagar after nizams Destruction they named it after Razaakar and Nizam King HYDER, so many names like this TURKAmanzil, ADILabad, NIZAMabad all these are oppressors and invaders name.Lets say tomorrow some ABCD will attack and conquer your nation and calls us XYZ citizens should we call our country XYZ.....and please do not talk about Development. People are not like Tamilnadu idiots or Kerela insecure losers, Many things have changed in Bharath. The reason people gave 300 in 2014 and 250 in 2019 means almost a 2/3rd population voted for Modi and will again vote for same in 2024 and 2029 and 2034....and to be continued.
@@VikramMehta-u1sif only bjp ruled India during independence we would have become a Hindu version of Pakistan... Communal violence and Hatred would have been our theme... Thank God it didn't happen
es after rename to Bharat petrol price will be 60rs, gas cylinder 450rs, Adani returned all his scammed amount, and Mr kedi ji will deposit 15lks rupees in each and every citizen people accounts, WOW!
Endonym should always be prefered. Why would any people with self-respect and self determination subject themselves to some strange name outsiders call them by?
From Việt Nam to Bharat, with love.
TctyaDD, thanks to you I became aware of the meaning of _Endonym_ .
Absolutely true! The native name for the country should be preferred. Another example is Nippon for Japan.
Names like India given by our Colonial Master, the British!
@@SR-fs2fd , no one is opposing "Bharat" except the Intellectually Bankrupt Congress.
FYKI, "Bharat" is always used in Hindi and other regional languages. India's Constitution in Hindi mentions भारत - not India! Simple.
But yes, Indians are still Intellectual Slaves of the White people which can be seen in many other ways.
Thanks brother!
True. Indigenous names should be preferred to foreign or colonial names. On independence, many African countries adopted native names: Ghana (Gold Coast), Mali (Western Sudan), Malawi (Nyasaland), Lesotho (Basotholand), Botswana (Bechuanaland), Namibia (South West Africa), Zimbabwe (Rhodesia), Zambia (Northern Rhodesia) etc. Bharat is beautiful. India is great, too. But it has been so corrupted & misused by European colonizers of the Americas that it has become confusing: Indian = 1) a citizen of a South Asian country 2) an indigenous person of the Americas. The world will get used to Bharat. Just as we got used to Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka. The use of Bharat will also inspire other African countries, etc, to complete decolonization.
In 1947, Pakistan had expected after partition the names of the countries will be Pakistan and Hindustan/Bharat. They took promise that this will be how it is done. But then they felt betrayed when India continued to use the name India and thus got all its legacy and achievements. This means it became like Pakistan sliced away from India and became a new country rather than one country getting divided into two. Jinaah had a lot of arguments and protests to force India to change the name to anything other than "India". This was one of the biggest successes of Indian govt of that time to keep the same name.
Even till today Pakistanis are pissed about the word "India" being used at a lot of places, including their history before 1947, the name of the ocean being Indian ocean, their country being referred as part of Indian subcontinent and they having to teach their kids that British Invaded India... And this is not at all about an irrelevant country like Pakistan. I wrote it just to bring my point that we are losing all this clout. No other country has an Ocean named after them.
Even US recently changed the name of this region from Asia-Pacific to Indo-Pacific to piss off China and include India into the larger narrative.
We would basically lose all our history. It would be like Pakistan, who is constantly in identity crisis because they dont want to talk about anything before 1947 that has India in it.
LOOK at IRAN for example. They had lots of legends and mythms and cultures all over the world in name of Persia. But their king insisted on being renamed from Persia in the last century and lost all the legacy of Persia. Now most people dont even know Iran was Persia. It is like end of a thousand of years of legacy being lost for no benefit.
You can no longer claim British colonization and its effects. British colonized India, not Bharat or Pakistan or Bangladesh. Their company was East India company. They were looking for India, not Bharat.
Future generations won't feel connected with the freedom fighters and heros of the past. It would be like they all lived in different country. Like, how much do you feel connected to a Hero of Mughal Empire or Chola Empire? You will feel something, but wont feel as if it was your country. It will feel like reading history and not as if you are reading your country's past.
Foreigners have difficulty saying "' so
instead of "Bhaarath", they pronounce it as"Ba-rutt"
Let Pakistan rename itself to India. 😂 The majority will of this country wants to be recognised as Bharat.
@@sakshiupadhyay1846 yep that will be interesting to see 🤣🤣🤣
@@Kaito028 आपके अनुसार यह कौन सा वर्ष है? यदि उपनिवेशवादियों के वंशजों को भारत कहने में कोई समस्या है तो हमें इसकी परवाह नहीं है। हम औपनिवेशिक नाम भारत से छुटकारा पाने जा रहे हैं, जैसे म्यांमार और श्रीलंका ने किया था।
Absolutely. I have been writing all this for hours on various channels now. Not that it would make much difference. We are losing all the clout that comes with word India. India is the vehicle through which Bharat will perpetuate Herself into the future. As India strengthens its soul aka Bharat and becomes stronger, we would be gaining much by keeping the name. India is already Bharat. Just because some losing opposition has made changes, It is clearly spiteful of BJP to incur costs by removing it.
You are living in some dream land.
Name should be हिंदुस्तान ❤
“INDIA” is related to us due to sindu river which dates back to thousands of years
Whole World called us INDIA for thousands of years it’s a brand for us
Being Hindu I don’t think Indian should only be called by religious name “Bharat” instead central government should focus on education, jobs and development
exactly
It is civilisational not religious. Bharat that is India would have been alright not India that is Bharat which ceded precedence to the foreign- precisely the colonial- imagination of the motherland. Great is the significance of a name.
@@ananthan8951 it’s not civilisational. I agree with the name change but why now ? India is already known as Bharat. It would cost 14000 crore to change India’s name.
@@mrfive427 I am highly positive about the idea but neutral about the timing. Bharat has civilisational resonance. India is as dull as a rubber ball. Many countries including China Japan Germany and France have different names internally whilst pragmatically retaining the international names for global dealings. At least internally what name the traders and colonialists of the West called us ought not to be our criterion. Would like to know the source of the cost conversion mentioned by you.
@@ananthan8951 you got it completely wrong. India is not the name given by British. Name “India” is in use for thousands of years. There are stone inscription dating back to 2000 years
Read somewhere that the cost of changing the name of "India" to "Bharat" would cost around INR14,000 crores. I don't know if it's right or wrong, but it would cost somewhere around that figure. If so, why is the government willing to waste so much money just for a name change. There would be a lot of confusions and complexities involved if it's done. Also, a sudden thought that came to my mind is that the word "India" is in every rupee notes we have, so if at all the name is changed, will the government take back the old notes and print new notes with "Bharath" mentioned in it? If so, then it's going to be chaotic. People are not ready to go through another demonitization effect.
I agree with your point, to add to it all our identity documents like driving lisense , passport, Adhar voter etc mention India. It will also have to be changed , I’m assuming more money will be invested changing all documents on a mass level.
@@divyanarula6331 Even globally they have to change. The one dealing with India.
My suspicion is why is this happening before the 2024 elections?
@@hardcore_bomb5759yeah sad thing it should have happened before..
Do you know how much we spent on prostitution, gambling, pubs, and drugs?
Bharat is original name of this land since starting of our civilization which is oldest civilization on this Earth. In our Hinduism holy books thousands of years ago, it's already mentioned this country named as Bharat. Even epic MAHABHARAT ensures the name of Bharat in its name itself.
Whereas India comes from foreign languages (variation of names) as mentioned in this video. There is our river named as Sindhu river(in Sanskrit and Hindi). So Persians started calling the people as Hindu(because they couldn't pronounce S word in Sindhu correctly) who live alongwith Sindhu river. Then Hindu word became Indus by greeks, then it became India.
Indus valley civilization is actually Sindhu valley civilization in original Sanskrit terms.
India already became a brand name. We can call it Bharat inside the country but don't force the world to change. There are countries and oceans named after India. Such a powerful name.
@@arjunraj823then we should rename Indian Ocean as Sindhu sagara as mentioned in Vedas .
Original name of Shimla is Simla , Britishers pronounced it as sh so it becomes Shimla .
@@Dharmic_Republic_of_Bharat we can name it but the world won't change it since its international property. Indies, Indonesia, Indochina, Indo Pacific etc are centred around India.
I cannot accept Bharat as the official name. Present India came into being from the princely states and the British India (except Pakistan and Bangladesh). Some of these regions include those with no affiliation to the any Hindu beliefs. Bharat sounds foreign for these people while India feels more familiar and raises patriotic feelings. Bharat could be used but not as the official name.
If it change to Bharat I'm pretty sure all documents must be changed immediately to Government of Bharat.... For rich & luxurious people, it's a piece of cake but for the average & poor people going to struggle in linea
Why immediate. Existing documents can be used as it if the govt says and only new documents can be issued with new names. Over a period of old documents will eventually be phased out when you need to renew them
@@scientificidoldude it's not the way you think that's going to happen. The official name for now is india and also in government I'd like adhar card pan card there is translation in hindi or native language as Bharat. But ths time it is going to be official name as Bharat that means There will be government of Bharat. Which is looking like a small change but it is definitely large scale and to change this it will take a much sum to change older cards. And forget about I'd cards. People having lots of documents of caste, certificates and many more. There are also brand names which are associated with tagnames as India. There are thousands of things like this. People don't understand how big this thing is.
From constitution to bank notes and even one rupee coin
@@pratikbhandare3497 Disagree. if any old document says india, who is going to create a problem if the government says, feel free to use any old document, money etc as long as you want. but all new documents will come with Bharat only. literally who is going to create problem when the govt allows it.
The problem is only if the govt says all docs with India are invalid. But name change without the need to change any old documents so I don't see how your concerns are practical.
West Bengal changed its name changed to Bangla,
Travancore-Cochin → Kerala (1st November, 1956).
Madhya Bharat → Madhya Pradesh (1st November, 1959)
Madras State → Tamil Nadu (14th January, 1969)
Mysore State → Karnataka (1st November, 1973)
Uttaranchal → Uttarakhand (1st January, 2007)
Orissa → Odisha (4th November, 2011)
North-East Frontier Agency (NEFA) → Arunachal Pradesh (20th January 1972)
Burma changed its name changed to Myanmar,
Bombay changed its name changed to Mumbai,
There are Many Examples
cities names
Cities
Jabalpur (Hindi: जबलपुर), from Jubbulpore, respelled in 1947
Jajmau (Hindi: जाजमऊ), from Jajesmow, respelled in 1948[11]
Kanpur (Hindi: कानपुर), from Cawnpore, respelled in 1948
Vadodara (Gujarati: વડોદરા), from Baroda, respelled in 1974
Thiruvananthapuram (Malayalam: തിരുവനന്തപുരം), from Trivandrum, renamed in 1991
Mumbai (Marathi: मुंबई), from Bombay, renamed in 1995[12]
Kochi (Malayalam: കൊച്ചി), from Cochin, respelled in 1996
Chennai (Tamil: சென்னை), from Madras, renamed in 1996
Kolkata (Bengali: কলকাতা), from Calcutta, respelled in 2001
Medininagar (Hindi: मेदिनीनगर), from Daltonganj, renamed in 2004
Kadapa (Telugu: కడప), from Cuddapah, respelled in 2005
Puducherry (Tamil: புதுச்சேரி), from Pondicherry, renamed in 2006
Bengaluru (Kannada: ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು), from Bangalore, respelled in 2007[13]
Belagavi (Kannada: ಬೆಳಗಾವಿ), from Belgaum in 2007[14][15]
Tumakuru (Kannada: ತುಮಕುರು), from Tumkur in 2007
Hubballi (Kannada: ಹುಬ್ಬಳ್ಳಿ), from Hubli in 2007
Hosapete (Kannada: ಹೊಸಪೇಟೆ), from Hospet in 2007
Mysuru (Kannada: ಮೈಸೂರು), from Mysore in 2007
Kalaburagi (Kannada: ಕಲಬುರಗಿ), from Gulbarga in 2007
Chikkamagaluru (Kannada: ಚಿಕ್ಕಮಗಳೂರು), from Chikmagalur in 2007
Vijayapura (Kannada: ವಿಜಯಪುರ), from Bijapur in 2007
Ballari (Kannada: ಬಳ್ಳಾರಿ), from Bellary in 2007
Mangaluru (Kannada: ಮಂಗಳೂರು), from Mangalore in 2007
Rajahmahendravaram (Telugu: రాజమహేంద్రవరం), from Rajahmundry in 2015
Gurugram (Hindi: गुरुग्राम) from Gurgaon in 2016
Prayagraj (Hindi: प्रयागराज), from Allahabad, renamed in 2018
Atal Nagar (Hindi: अटल नगर), from New Raipur, renamed in 2018
Narmadapuram (Hindi: नर्मदापुरम), from Hoshangabad, renamed in 2021
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Marathi: छत्रपती संभाजीनगर), from Aurangabad, renamed in 2023
Dharashiv (Marathi: धाराशिव), from Osmanabad, renamed in 2023
Hindu is 100% Sanskrit word. Hindusthan word in Rigveda
Brihaspati Aagam :
हिमालयं समारभ्य यावत इन्दुसरोवरं ।
तं देवनिर्मितं देशं हिन्दुस्थानं प्रचक्षते ।।
Means - 'Starting from the Himalayan
Mountains and extending to the
Indian Ocean, God created
country is called Hindusthan.'
The Indus valley region was one of the earliest civilizations of the world. The Indus valley civilization started around 3300 BCE, since the Indian civilization started near the river Indus, our nation got its name “INDIA”. India was also home to an indigenous tribe called Bharata.
Modi try to focuse on the development of country and inovations not to change the name of the country instead of sitting there in air-conditioned and giving useless ideas.
@justsmileitjustsmile..you are very right but it’s tough to talk sense to people who have been brainwashed and can’t see through such tricks.
Indus River is in Pakistan india should choose a more appropriate name
@@aurangzeb1618Mount kailash is in Tibet china... should we change the abode of Lord Shiva
So now you are jealous of Modi's AC, meanwhile writing illogical comments under your own AC😅
Turkey wants to pronounce the name as it is in Turkish, the difference is minimal. The Czech Republic and Czechia are the same thing, the first variant simply designates a republic of the Czech people. It's the same with Poland and Polska, I could give many more examples, but these are just the ways we pronounce the names of our countries in our languages. Also Croatia is Hrvatska. There are also examples that are quite different, like Hungary for example, they call themselves Magyars and the country Magyarorszag, it is quite different from the world accepted name. It's the same with Germany, they call their country Deutschland... Many, many more that have different names from the world accepted ones, and you chose to set an example with the Czech Republic and Turkey?...
🙄 I do not understand people like you. Do you listen to only a few words in a video?
Japan. Nippon or Nihon
Egypt. Misr
Greece. Helena
Morocco. Maghreb
......
Civilizational countries with imperial past often have many names.
@@MoorishAlliance In India
Greece = Yunan.
Burma to Myanmar is the closest relation. The British ruled them too and gave them a name. Burma was a British name. That was booted out for Myanmar.
@@Indian_Rajput Interesting, in Turkish Greece is Yunanistan
Are bharat bolo India bolo Hindustan bolo ek hi hai bs ye bjp sarkar election ke samne aisa kuch karti jisse desh ki janta rozgar bhook Mari mahengai adani ambbani ke rishte ke baare main naa puche bhadoge businessmen ka hazaro cr ka loan maaf kara hai uske baare main naa puche 9 saal desh ko kitna loota kaisa kaisa kar ke desh ki kitni property bech diye airline railway LIC iske baare main naa puche kitne college banaye kuch nahi CBI ED sirf vipaksh ke liye hai bhagode businessmen ke liye 56 inch ka Seena 2 inch ka ho jata jo loan maaf kar deta gareeb janta ka 😡 sawal karo modi se tabhi andhbhakt nahi kaheloage desh ke suchhe aur jagruk nagrik kahelaoge congress ne har City main sarkari hospital Sarkari school har City main sarkari office police station har jagha kya kuch nahi kara modi ne kya kara 9 saal Main 😡 😡😡
Indian National Development Inclusive Alliance sounds so think-tanky American. (Readable acronyms are very very American)
They are also in cahoots with George Soros and other foreign powers
Funded by American Left to make Indian Regime change . Typical Americans .
Also, King Bharat was the son of 1st Tirthankar Adinath who ruled the country and hence the name of the place was Bharat after him. Adinath bhagawan's second was Bahubali whose famous statue Gomteswara is in Karnataka. We have a rich ancient history
U r wrong... Bharat comes from the son of one of Hindu king...before mahabharat.. It is mentioned in vedic scripture as Bharatwarsh
@@monisingh771yes you are absolutely right... Dushyant son name was bharat on whome this country name is bharat
Jain is also hindu so pls stop dividing hindus. We all are one bharat vanshi.
New story??
Wasn't Bharat the son Dushyant n Shakuntala ??
We were taught this story n our
school.
@@shashimishra6973 वेदों का 9 वी शताब्दी से पहले का कोई सबूत या संदर्भ नही है ।
Name India geographically concerned to Indus Valley Civilisation. Names India, Indus, Sindhu are natural names of India for its geographical location under great river Indus/ Sindhu. It’s our pride to be called as Indians of India. Whereas name Bharat is mythical and never existed in reality. However, name Bharat is also incorporated in our constitution we are using it extensively as complementary to India. I believe name changing now India as Bharat is unwanted and politically motivated.
well put
Geographic? How?
What has Tamil Nadu or Assam got to do with Indus river?
Bharat is more appropriate geographically as it refers to the area between Himalayas and the ocean
Indus River and majority of Indus civilization is in Pakistan
@@mlg1279nothing Tamil Nadu and North east were historically independent
@@aurangzeb1618 Politically they were ruled by different rulers at different points of time. However, culturally Tamil Nadu and Assam have a lot in common, and are part of the same civilization
Bharatam is the real name. Bharat is the Hindi version. The name Hindi is also related to India thon Bharat. If you want to use native name, name should be Bharatam (in Sanskrit. The Sanskrit language is also known as Bharati). Not Bharat (in Hindi).
Jaya Bharatam. Jaya Barati.
@Cr00kedKnight See the pledge .. in KV Sanskrit textbooks
@Cr00kedKnight
It is bharatham in Malayalam not bharat
Idk if its a valid example but Korea has 2 names too, in English that is Korea and their domestic Hanguk. there is no necessity of forgoing a name which is already established and could focus on more important issues.
School pledges for example use both. ENGLISH: India is my country and HINDI: Bharat hamara desh hai.
The names are mutually exclusive only when language is a factor.
Let the world know hindi..
@@firstnamelastname847 some think it as useless, some think it as cultural revival..
If u want to learn Chinese then should be able to accept dictatorship also(I'm saying if we look some good in others , we should accept bad in them also)
I think "India" will be renamed as "Bharat" as "Quit India Movement" was launched by Mahatma Gandhi ji to end British rule.
OPINION : "Bharat" written in English is still the same, until written in Hindi : "भारत"
Yea good guess
first people should be above poverty line and with job security with minimum wages, no corruption. after than name change can be done
Kindi? What kindi? There are people who doesn't speak hindi.
Quit India movement is a hoax...a failed initiative that was launched and crushed in 1942. And congress had submitted in writing that Congress or Gandhi had nothing to do with it.
Unless you know HINDI is not the national language of India
Official Bharat , long time coming. Next step to make sanskrit as 2nd language in a schools eventually leading to a national language, this will give you a truly cultural identity of Bharat civilization.
👍
Why not Tamil then, arguably it is as ancient as Sanskrit
Not all Indians speak Hindi or Sanskrit and not all Indians are like the mainland Indians. Our culture is different from yours.
Keep your propaganda to cow belt , the south rejects it , Tamil is older and dravidians presents you a 🖕🏽
@@InnocentBoyVtamil might be old but it's a cave language
Bharat!!! 🇳🇵
Bhendcodd apna country dekh
Refugees from nepal now us citizens
When my people ran to bharat, they got citizens, and us in nepal inside Refugees camp!!
*BHARAT* since MahaBharat
INDIA has lots of names in different different timelines
Ex : JAMBUDWEEP, BHARATKHANDE, ARYAVARTH, BHARATVASHE, BHARAT, HINDUSTAN, INDIA ,DEVBHOOMI,VEDBHOOMI etc
😂hindunagri
PAKISTAN
I doubt this will bloom for real, considering Indian govt under Modi has a habit of leaving work undone. CAA is yet to implemented, only amit shah knows what happened to it!
at least they are trying. They successuly done removal of article 370.
G 20 invites have already been sent.
Modi successfully Removed article 370, bring Pakistanis economy to its knees by notebandi, bring masses to formal banking system now india preparing for our own Google type search engine , cheaper internet to masses and is reshaping massive changes for next century
Germany goes by Deutscheland internally. Can india do something like that and keep both and not do something stupid like do a whole rename? India should focus on development and not waste time
There is a Pakistani friend of mine who was born in India. Later his family moved to Pakistan and eventually he became an American citizen. He says that his US passport mentions India, where he was born, it mentions the US which he is a citizen of. But his US passport does not mention Pakistan. I would like to say to him, some day, "you and I are both Indians for we were both born in India".
😂
Why convince a Pakistani he is Indian? Home is where the heart is. Your friend left to be in their desired Islamic republic, the Land of the Pure. They struggled and got it. They threw out all religious minorities down to 2%. So, why would he care about being Indian, having got his pound of flesh???
Should Japan change its name to Nihon ?
Should Germany change its name to Deutschland ?
Should India change its name to Bharat ?
Why remain a labelled slave of the West like Germany and Japan?
Yes
I don't know about others but india will definitely replace its name to Bharat
@@sangameshpatil2096sorry to say but it's not going to be happen
@@ChaitnayJain lets see😎
We are proud as an Indian, bharat and hindustan!
Absolutely
May be modi ji ko tum pe proud nahi hai as an Indian
So you are still confused. English-medium colonial education does that.
Will you be proud if your father's name is mistakenly replaced by your neighbours name? And will you retain it just because he is a famous guy in town?
@@aliimranbhat804 in dis three names I dnt see neighbours name at all. Bro do u knw that in article 1 it clearly says bharat as an india so it means u call whatever like india hindustan and bharat name can be changed not the nation.and u dnt understand a thing it's all about politics which BJP is doing.।। Dnt think am anti BJP am just common citizen!
The only thing I find sad about this discussion is that "India" gets put down as some terrible colonial relic as if there isn't so much culture, innovation, and positive image built up in that word. People who hate on "India" don't have the courage or maturity to look in the mirror at the great country we already are. I'm not against Bharat, far from it, but also not really against "India". Perhaps we could use the names interchangeably. Many countries already do that and we too. It's not like Hindustan is going away any time soon. 😅
Mera Desh Bharat hai. Bharat Mata ki Jai ho 🙏.
Bhikarendia is a better name
@@Daddy-RIt suits our neighbour selling it's ports
How about wakanda