ADHD Medications: Amphetamines vs. Methylphenidates - Efficacy, Risks, and Best Practices
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ส.ค. 2024
- A thorough comparison of amphetamines and methylphenidate, focusing on efficacy, tolerability, psychiatric risks, and adult ADHD diagnosis.
Content written by: Chris Aiken, MD
💡Carlat Webinars: www.thecarlatr...
📖Subscribe to The Carlat Journal: www.thecarlatr...
➡️Earn CME Credits for this video: thecarlatrepor...
================
Follow Carlat:
🔴SUBSCRIBE ► / @thecarlatreport
➡️Twitter: / CarlatPsych
================
A 30-minute webinar for CME credit by Chris Aiken, MD, Editor-in-Chief of The Carlat Psychiatry Report. Dr. Aiken is a practicing psychiatrist in Winston-Salem, NC; director of the Mood Treatment Center in North Carolina; and Assistant Professor NYU Langone Department of Psychiatry.
Highlights
🧠 Mechanism: Amphetamines release dopamine, while methylphenidate blocks its reuptake.
📊 Efficacy: Meta-analyses show amphetamines generally have a greater effect size than methylphenidate.
💊 Tolerability: Methylphenidate is better tolerated with fewer side effects compared to amphetamines.
⚠️ Psychiatric Risks: Amphetamines may pose higher risks for psychosis and mania, especially in vulnerable populations.
🔍 Diagnosis: Adult ADHD diagnosis is complex; symptoms can overlap with other psychiatric disorders.
🏥 Treatment: Methylphenidate is often preferred as first-line treatment in adults due to its safety profile.
📈 Trends: Historical data shows a shift in stimulant prescriptions from amphetamines to methylphenidate in adults.
Key Insights
⚙️ Mechanism of Action: Understanding the differing mechanisms of amphetamines and methylphenidate is crucial for effective treatment choices. Amphetamines provide a more immediate increase in dopamine, which may lead to stronger effects but also a higher potential for side effects. 🧠
📈 Efficacy Differences: While amphetamines generally demonstrate a larger effect size, individual responses vary. Some patients may find methylphenidate more effective, emphasizing the need for personalized treatment approaches. 📊
😌 Tolerability and Side Effects: Methylphenidate tends to be better tolerated than amphetamines, suggesting it may be a safer option for patients, particularly those with complex comorbidities. 💊
⚠️ Psychiatric Risks: The risk of developing psychosis or mania is a significant concern, particularly with amphetamines. This highlights the importance of closely monitoring patients with a history of psychiatric disorders. ⚠️
🧩 Complex Diagnosis: The diagnosis of adult ADHD can be challenging due to overlapping symptoms with other conditions like PTSD or bipolar disorder, necessitating thorough assessments. 🔍
🏥 First-Line Treatment: Methylphenidate is often recommended as the first-line treatment in adults due to its favorable side effect profile, reflecting a shift in prescribing practices. 🏥
📜 Historical Context: Understanding the historical prescribing trends of stimulants can inform current practices and help avoid potential biases towards amphetamines. 📈
This is what a doctor should do. People should be selected and trained to practice like Dr. Aiken.
This is exactly what I was looking for. I wanted to see which stimulant helps with GAD and social anxiety. Learned a lot more than I expected. Thank you for your detailed analysis
Thank you! I’ve been looking for information comparing methylphenidate vs amphetamine for a couple of years. I am a late middle aged adult female who has definitely had ADHD (yes little girls can be hyper active!) since early childhood. I am meeting with my psychiatrist this afternoon and I definitely want to explore switching to a Ritalin type product.
This is a very detailed report I use dexmethylphenidate and while it may not be as effective or euphoric it still does make a big difference in everyday life and I recommend it to people who want a safe stimulant that’s not gonna lead to any erratic behaviors.
This was fantastic. Exactly the kind of information I was looking for but is so hard to find. Thank you!
Very well done report. Best regards
Ritaline is like adderral, but without the smile.
an animal model is gonna give him paws
I think amphetamines are a problem for me...methy i was much happier and productive...amps i became a miserable sob addict. Problem is if they gave me the option today..I'm go with amps!! :)