"Are they about to kiss?" Is a solid mood for every adaptation of this musical, because they have such deep love for each other and they hurt each other in these upcoming scenes. I love this musical so much
Yo. Little late but I saw this when I was a kid and it randomly popped in my head and I think it’s really interesting. I think it’s suppose to be from Judas prospective which is really interesting and the songs kinda slap. If you do do more reactions of this could you do Pilates trial? I’d love to hear your thoughts on his voice
This is what is sometimes referred to jokingly as the “Gay Bar Version”. Judging it as a movie alone, I prefer this version over the 1973 version, but I think the soundtrack and vocal performances are better on the 1973 version, except for a few tracks like the Herods Song.
The chalice is so huge, the acting is so dramatic, it's so extra, because this is a recording of a stage show, not a movie. I saw this version of the stage show live, this is the same cast and scenery, props, costumes etc, but recorded without the audience for DVD. If you want the actual movie Then watch the 70's version. PS, this is actually my favorite version. But so many hate it. You talk about your version was modernizing it, genderbenind it. You realize that's exactly what this version tried to do and every hated it (except me)
Yes! What Colin said about a recording of a stage performance. It was always going to be different. I would have loved to have seen it as a stage performance.
I discovered the musical only recently and watched the 2018 version first, then the 1973, and then this one, and at first I totally hated it, but the more I started listening I fell in love with it and now this Judas is like my favorite because of how emotional he is. Idk, despite not quite reaching the notes (and I usually haaate that) he legit made me cry during this scene, he's the only one that made me cry, and I had already seen the scene two times already in two other different versions.
I definitely liked some parts of this version, but for me nothing compares to the 1973 one. This one certainly provides some amusement though, like when it feels like Jesus and Judas are playing tag around the table 😂
I saw Tim Minchin at the Sydney performance & it was fantastic. I've also seen the videos of the concert/arena style version with John Farnham as Jesus and a cast full of wonderful Aussie musicians. I The version with Glenn Carter & Jérôme Pradon, etc, was a rock musical theatrical version performed in a theatre, then filmed. I've also heard the Ian Gillan version. I enjoy them all , they seen to be representative of their times.I think that the acting required in theatre is different to films so this version might look overdone up close & personal rather than seen at a distance in a theatre. I don't know much about the technical side of music & singing, but I enjoyed this version as much as the others.
It's really too bad your first experience with this epic Rock Opera was with this train wreck. It really felt like a college auditorium set than an actual movie set. The 1973 version is so much better as it actually has several real locations and not just one room with different set pieces for each scene.
You keep on saying the word extra. I think theater actors need to be a little over the top on order for the audience to see them in the back row. Hence, a little bit of over-exaggeration is needed to express this. As long as the actors make different choices and not always stick with the same form of manipulation (the methodology and ways about achieving what my character wants), then that's what really matters. Besides, I think overacting is very common in college, but as you work on your craft, you begin to realize if you should act more subtle like film or bigger than life like that of the stage. Unfortunately, many of us don't really get the chance to act after college. Yes, there's always community theater and going to audition at a CC. However, the sad reality of the working world is,the centrifugal force which breaks us apart. However, if you do live in a city where there is a local film market, every once in awhile you might get the chance to be an extra or get a supporting role. Lol. I had a line in a fan film Highlander Dark Places, (which used to be a 40 minute short called Dark Beginnings). Yes. I was so "extra," but I had fun. In fact, if you want to see my c- acting, I still have a video on the bottom of The Crucible which I did for Acting for Film and Television and even another short I was in for another drama class.
You really need to watch the 1973 movie… the problem with most not all ..of the stage versions is they are all set in different types of era’s which I dislike the movie on the other hand is superb
I don’t know if you’re familiar with this one but there’s an Australian version of The Last Supper in 1992 starring John Farnham and Jon Stevens (two of our music icons); their version is awesome! th-cam.com/video/CdLmmuLqQEo/w-d-xo.html
you really fucked up you did fesus christ superstar. but not the 1973 movie version that sucks. ted nelly is the only one worth wathing and getsesem is the song and the rest are super too. im disapointer and your clearlt overthinking your part in it .watch and listen
"Are they about to kiss?" Is a solid mood for every adaptation of this musical, because they have such deep love for each other and they hurt each other in these upcoming scenes. I love this musical so much
Judas: "What if i ruined ur ambitions?!'
Me: Well, ya already ruined dinner, why not his hopes and dreams too? :/
You should see the 1973 movie of this song. It's unapologetically 70s, equally hilarious and great.
Also, just subbed!
Yes! And thank you!
Yo. Little late but I saw this when I was a kid and it randomly popped in my head and I think it’s really interesting. I think it’s suppose to be from Judas prospective which is really interesting and the songs kinda slap. If you do do more reactions of this could you do Pilates trial? I’d love to hear your thoughts on his voice
This is what is sometimes referred to jokingly as the “Gay Bar Version”. Judging it as a movie alone, I prefer this version over the 1973 version, but I think the soundtrack and vocal performances are better on the 1973 version, except for a few tracks like the Herods Song.
Soul Dreamer I totally get that. There’s a lot more vibrancy to this version but something so nostalgic and special about the 1973 version ❤️
@@rachel.ann.thomas the 1973 version is the best one in my opinio
CARTER'S PERFORMANCE FOR THAT SONG WAS AMAZING....BUT HIS BELIEFS ARE MORE BIZARRE THAN A JESUS WHO DID LIVE AND WALK THIS EARTH
I love this version. 🤷🏻♀️ Sue me! 😂
Marie Kermeur it’s actually so entertaining
The chalice is so huge, the acting is so dramatic, it's so extra, because this is a recording of a stage show, not a movie. I saw this version of the stage show live, this is the same cast and scenery, props, costumes etc, but recorded without the audience for DVD. If you want the actual movie Then watch the 70's version. PS, this is actually my favorite version. But so many hate it. You talk about your version was modernizing it, genderbenind it. You realize that's exactly what this version tried to do and every hated it (except me)
Yes! What Colin said about a recording of a stage performance. It was always going to be different. I would have loved to have seen it as a stage performance.
The 1973 jesus is SO superior for me... 😂
I discovered the musical only recently and watched the 2018 version first, then the 1973, and then this one, and at first I totally hated it, but the more I started listening I fell in love with it and now this Judas is like my favorite because of how emotional he is.
Idk, despite not quite reaching the notes (and I usually haaate that) he legit made me cry during this scene, he's the only one that made me cry, and I had already seen the scene two times already in two other different versions.
Gotta say the 1973 versions of Jesus and Judas both are spectacular. It’s the only version I think of as the “real” Jesus Christ Superstar!
Please please PLEASE react to Glenn Carter singing Gethsemane!
9:27 DID ME IN OH MY LORD
HAHAHA ME TOOOOOO
Nice work rach :)
No way...original album and 1973 movie for me.
I thought the film was better both in terms of the music and the scenery. Brilliant
I definitely liked some parts of this version, but for me nothing compares to the 1973 one. This one certainly provides some amusement though, like when it feels like Jesus and Judas are playing tag around the table 😂
Opera Rock. From Spain please. React to Camilo Sesto: Getsemani ( live 1977 ).
Great idea :) can’t wait to check it out
The funniest thing to me is when Christians talk bad about paganism and I'm like.... Jesus makes people drink his blood lol
I love this play btw
Jerome Padron, the best Judas of all time.
You need to watch the arena version. Tim Minchin is brilliant.
I tried to do a reaction video and it wouldn't let me post cause of copyright !
I saw Tim Minchin at the Sydney performance & it was fantastic. I've also seen the videos of the concert/arena style version with John Farnham as Jesus and a cast full of wonderful Aussie musicians. I The version with Glenn Carter & Jérôme Pradon, etc, was a rock musical theatrical version performed in a theatre, then filmed. I've also heard the Ian Gillan version. I enjoy them all , they seen to be representative of their times.I think that the acting required in theatre is different to films so this version might look overdone up close & personal rather than seen at a distance in a theatre. I don't know much about the technical side of music & singing, but I enjoyed this version as much as the others.
It's really too bad your first experience with this epic Rock Opera was with this train wreck. It really felt like a college auditorium set than an actual movie set. The 1973 version is so much better as it actually has several real locations and not just one room with different set pieces for each scene.
You keep on saying the word extra. I think theater actors need to be a little over the top on order for the audience to see them in the back row. Hence, a little bit of over-exaggeration is needed to express this. As long as the actors make different choices and not always stick with the same form of manipulation (the methodology and ways about achieving what my character wants), then that's what really matters. Besides, I think overacting is very common in college, but as you work on your craft, you begin to realize if you should act more subtle like film or bigger than life like that of the stage.
Unfortunately, many of us don't really get the chance to act after college. Yes, there's always community theater and going to audition at a CC. However, the sad reality of the working world is,the centrifugal force which breaks us apart.
However, if you do live in a city where there is a local film market, every once in awhile you might get the chance to be an extra or get a supporting role. Lol. I had a line in a fan film Highlander Dark Places, (which used to be a 40 minute short called Dark Beginnings). Yes. I was so "extra," but I had fun.
In fact, if you want to see my c- acting, I still have a video on the bottom of The Crucible which I did for Acting for Film and Television and even another short I was in for another drama class.
Love this musical and seen many different productions, such a classic. Confused by your recatoin. Not sure if you liked this or not.
I have mixed feelings about it haha
THERE IS "NEWER ONE: FIND IT.. LIVE ON STAGE..DON'T KNOW HOW THEY PULLED IT OFF.THEN SHARE IT!!!!
You really need to watch the 1973 movie… the problem with most not all ..of the stage versions is they are all set in different types of era’s which I dislike the movie on the other hand is superb
Because He’s about to be crucified my dear. That’s why He’s so dramatic.
Prefer Herod and Pilate in this version but other than that, the 1973 version is better
Fiddler on the roof too please
Welcome to 2024 😂
IT IS BEING HIDDEN FROM YOU....THE ENDING ..HOW THEY DO IT..WILL SURPRISE YOU... SHARE IT...
I don’t know if you’re familiar with this one but there’s an Australian version of The Last Supper in 1992 starring John Farnham and Jon Stevens (two of our music icons); their version is awesome!
th-cam.com/video/CdLmmuLqQEo/w-d-xo.html
I can't watch bloggers who stop the vids too much and try to sing along. Sorry.
you really fucked up you did fesus christ superstar. but not the 1973 movie version that sucks. ted nelly is the only one worth wathing and getsesem is the song and the rest are super too. im disapointer and your clearlt overthinking your part in it .watch and listen
musicals always over act
Yes, they tend to act bigger
@@rachel.ann.thomas that's a better term
Ngl this was a little cringey to watch.
That’s what I was going for!
React to 1973 version this one was crap