Great storyteller and great game! Just a few interesting tidbits: 30:10 you can tell it’s a beginner game when Nelly poisons Phillip who she heard might be Recluse/Another Outsider/Saint. I can see why she'd want to poison the Saint if she doesn't know what the poison ability does or the Saint's ability 35:44 really unfortunate mistake by ST that confirmed to the Undertaker that Sian is 100% either a good continuous info gathering role or the spy. It happens!
I'm glad I'm not the story teller, trying to keep track of everything in my head would be difficult 😅 Thanks for the comment, you're right that we're pretty new but we'll keep on keeping on. We've got another game tonight so hopefully whatever team I'm on prevails 👍
Thanks for the kind words. Yeah I was kicking myself about that. However as a pretty new group, I'm not sure that Drew actually understood the night order well enough to Intuit that. I could be wrong though!
It sounded like Nelly thought that *Ben* was an outsider, and didn't want to keep poisoning an outsider. So Ben successfully dodged the poison by claiming outsider. :)
I still can't get over the fact that Jase called the whole game in the first 10 minutes 😄
Great storyteller and great game! Just a few interesting tidbits:
30:10 you can tell it’s a beginner game when Nelly poisons Phillip who she heard might be Recluse/Another Outsider/Saint. I can see why she'd want to poison the Saint if she doesn't know what the poison ability does or the Saint's ability
35:44 really unfortunate mistake by ST that confirmed to the Undertaker that Sian is 100% either a good continuous info gathering role or the spy. It happens!
I'm glad I'm not the story teller, trying to keep track of everything in my head would be difficult 😅
Thanks for the comment, you're right that we're pretty new but we'll keep on keeping on. We've got another game tonight so hopefully whatever team I'm on prevails 👍
Thanks for the kind words. Yeah I was kicking myself about that. However as a pretty new group, I'm not sure that Drew actually understood the night order well enough to Intuit that. I could be wrong though!
It sounded like Nelly thought that *Ben* was an outsider, and didn't want to keep poisoning an outsider. So Ben successfully dodged the poison by claiming outsider. :)
Still half convinced it was a spy game 🙄
I still haven't figured out how to combat a Spy game so hopefully we get another one soon.
@@the1benI think Good won your last Spy game. By a nose.
There's a section of the wiki page for the Spy titled "Fighting the Spy".
@MichaelDart thanks, I'll check it out