당시에 데뷔 반 년도 안 됐을 멤버들도, 팬덤은 다 달라도 에셈 신인 여돌 나왔다고 노래 엄청 들어서 전부 다 따라 부르는 것도, 진짜 열과 성을 다해서 멤버들 라이브 하는 것도 울컥함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그립다 다시는 레드벨벳을 예전처럼 자주 볼 수는 없겠지만 오랜만에 영상 보니까 풋풋하네
Wendy really gained a lot of attention when they debuted and a lot of people thought that she was the group's visual. There's even a theory that SM probably gives wendy ugly hairstyles and outfits so that she won't outshine irene since irene is the official visual of the group.
Just because she is the least popular member doesn’t mean people don’t know her that much, it’s Red Velvet. A very popular girlgroup known by millions of people! A lot of people know about her and her amazing talent! Wendy is a very talented women and a lot of people know that!
@@kyanromansytan949 That might have been the truth some years ago when Yeri still got a lot of unnecessary hate, but nowadays her fanbase have grown incredibly so I'd agree with Wendy being the least popular :(
@@hilmaandmyweirdsoul8539 hmmmmm I honestly think all of them(the girls) aRe all equally popular it’s just that irene Get’s more attention for her looks from different fandoms and people lol
@@kyanromansytan949 I don't think they're equally popular at all - but! They are all very popular coming from Red Velvet after all. But it's obvious on social media and such that the fans favor Joy and Seulgi more, and in Korea it's been Irene. Both Yeri and Wendy have fallen a bit behind. 2019 was a good year for them all though, and with the accident the other members have had the chance to have more solo activities in 2020. I still think they got lots in store, and their popularity isn't as unequal as it is in some groups :)
she owned the debut imo and it’s weird, some even say sm changed her appearance so the spotlight would stay on irene. either way as long as she’s healthy and doing well it’s good (even if there are certain things she’s done that took me back). also i agree that sometimes it’s like she’s always the one who gets the worse looks.
Wendy’s old face...If she had stayed like this she would have been the most popular member of Red Velvet. I still remember at debut it was a debate between her and Irene for best visuals.
Ikr, she was literally shining during their early years. I think it's because of the styling that her visuals slowly started to change and I remember it after "Be Natural" era. Also, her "yoyo diet" plays a huge role in her looks as well. In some eras, she would look bomb but swollen/tired/stressed in other eras. The weight gain & weight loss, stress, and hectic schedule must be so hard for her. So Irene who kept getting prettier each era and with her consistent visuals has made her the original visual that she is today. Not saying Wendy is not but she certainly has become the "hidden visual" or like what some Korean netizens say "actually the prettiest" if you take into consideration some of the people's subjective preferences. But like in general, Irene's visuals has just become legendary and on another level now.
It's so sad she's the least popular member. She's my bias and forever will be. She's an all rounder except for the rap because I haven't heard her rap. She could do a solo.
@@frostgyu she is better rapper than Irene xD watch ICC's perfs where Irene missed. Wendy's swag is better, her flow is better. She could be main rapper, main vocalist and lead dancer if SM didn't want to give Irene almost every titles😅😅
@@hyyunjiv It's the weirdest and saddest thing ever. They dance and sing just the same with and without weight so why does it matter since that's the only reason why they're on stage? I hate it so much
An amazing fancam that has been hidden from us for 3.5 years :O ... Seems like Mera had a clean-out day in their storage :D Anyways, thank u Mera! Hope u release more of these unreleased fancams, which I'm sure u jave a lot more!
Ah the good old days.. Back when her forehead was living it's best life and free and it wasn't hidden by those CRUSTY UGLY BANGS. Fr tho I always felt like they gave her those bangs to try and degrade her visuals and style her in hideous outfits * proceeds to cough* (zimzalabim) and so that she wouldn't overshadow irene cause everyone and I mean EVERYONE thought wendy was the visual when she debuted w red velvet and to not have any irene fan crying about it I'm not saying irene isnt beautiful shes gorgeous.
![[MPD직캠] 레드벨벳 직캠 'Be Natural' (RED VELVET FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2014.10.16](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RKgR20BYN0M/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MPD직캠] 레드벨벳 직캠 'Be Natural' (RED VELVET FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2014.10.16](/img/tr.png)
![150124 레드벨벳 (Red Velvet) Be Natural [전체]직캠 Fancam (가든스테이지) by Mera](/img/n.gif)
당시에 데뷔 반 년도 안 됐을 멤버들도, 팬덤은 다 달라도 에셈 신인 여돌 나왔다고 노래 엄청 들어서 전부 다 따라 부르는 것도, 진짜 열과 성을 다해서 멤버들 라이브 하는 것도 울컥함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그립다 다시는 레드벨벳을 예전처럼 자주 볼 수는 없겠지만 오랜만에 영상 보니까 풋풋하네
Wendy needs this hair style again!!! She really shined during this era! She could easily be the group visual!
many believed she was the visual back then including me ngl
Wendy really gained a lot of attention when they debuted and a lot of people thought that she was the group's visual. There's even a theory that SM probably gives wendy ugly hairstyles and outfits so that she won't outshine irene since irene is the official visual of the group.
I love Wendy's shine on me part. Can't blame the crowd for growing wild!!!
Where did that happen?
WENDYYYY OHGOD SHES SHINING !!
While literally singibg 'Shine on me' :D
lolol mera has kept this hidden until now?? such a legendary stage
when i first get into Red Velvet, i thought Wendy was the visual because she’s so attractive and so eye catching...
same
Exactly !!!
I really miss this look of wendy,,, She is sooo fresh back then,,
oh sehun she still looks good lmao
oh sehun those puffy cheeks I guess
seulgi, wendy, irene: shoes with heels
joy: sneakers for you baby
Unnnies are shorter hehe
Lol🤣
Wendy "Shine on Me" is still legendary
I see Wendy slayed every category back then. I still can't believe she is the least popular member. Kpop fans are crazy, blind, and deaf 🤣🤣🤣
Just because she is the least popular member doesn’t mean people don’t know her that much, it’s Red Velvet. A very popular girlgroup known by millions of people! A lot of people know about her and her amazing talent! Wendy is a very talented women and a lot of people know that!
Hi! I Think Yeri is the least popular member,Wendy is actually one of the members with many stans
@@kyanromansytan949 That might have been the truth some years ago when Yeri still got a lot of unnecessary hate, but nowadays her fanbase have grown incredibly so I'd agree with Wendy being the least popular :(
@@hilmaandmyweirdsoul8539 hmmmmm I honestly think all of them(the girls) aRe all equally popular it’s just that irene Get’s more attention for her looks from different fandoms and people lol
@@kyanromansytan949 I don't think they're equally popular at all - but! They are all very popular coming from Red Velvet after all. But it's obvious on social media and such that the fans favor Joy and Seulgi more, and in Korea it's been Irene. Both Yeri and Wendy have fallen a bit behind. 2019 was a good year for them all though, and with the accident the other members have had the chance to have more solo activities in 2020. I still think they got lots in store, and their popularity isn't as unequal as it is in some groups :)
Ok. Let's talk about Baby Olaf Wendy has the best visual during this era. That's my bias!
If inly SM didnt tried to change and hide Wendy's real beauty she would easily be a beauty goddess. Her debut beauty was subpar.
she owned the debut imo and it’s weird, some even say sm changed her appearance so the spotlight would stay on irene. either way as long as she’s healthy and doing well it’s good (even if there are certain things she’s done that took me back). also i agree that sometimes it’s like she’s always the one who gets the worse looks.
Wait how did they change her? Plastic surgery?
@@jenrubyjane-r3x no, SM always give her bad outfits and bad hair style
Wendy got my attention since debut. Thank you Mera-Nim
can’t take my eyes off wendy
Wendy’s old face...If she had stayed like this she would have been the most popular member of Red Velvet. I still remember at debut it was a debate between her and Irene for best visuals.
SM didnt let her to overshining than Irene btw... Thats why Wendy look change day by day till now
Ikr, she was literally shining during their early years. I think it's because of the styling that her visuals slowly started to change and I remember it after "Be Natural" era. Also, her "yoyo diet" plays a huge role in her looks as well. In some eras, she would look bomb but swollen/tired/stressed in other eras. The weight gain & weight loss, stress, and hectic schedule must be so hard for her. So Irene who kept getting prettier each era and with her consistent visuals has made her the original visual that she is today. Not saying Wendy is not but she certainly has become the "hidden visual" or like what some Korean netizens say "actually the prettiest" if you take into consideration some of the people's subjective preferences. But like in general, Irene's visuals has just become legendary and on another level now.
@@Riri-ni6vy yes.. Agree
It's so sad she's the least popular member. She's my bias and forever will be. She's an all rounder except for the rap because I haven't heard her rap. She could do a solo.
@@frostgyu she is better rapper than Irene xD watch ICC's perfs where Irene missed. Wendy's swag is better, her flow is better. She could be main rapper, main vocalist and lead dancer if SM didn't want to give Irene almost every titles😅😅
Since rookie days Wendy shines the brightest.
The crowd screams, fanchants and cheer 😊
진짜 너무 소중한 영상 스엠 신인 나왔다고 타팬 친구들이랑 같이 노래 듣던 게 엊그제 같은데 🥺🥺 화려한 스타일링도 넘 예쁘지만 이런 깨끗하고 청순한 느낌의 스타일링도 자주 보고 시퍼요
Wendy is so freaking gorgeous..
행복 때 의상 진짜 다 레전드다
사전제작해서 통일성 살리면서 멤버들마다 조금씩 포인트준거 완전 이쁨👍
연말 시상식 의상도 이렇게 반짝이 느낌으로 눈에 띄게 만들고 코디님 최고...
같은 디자인이라도 멤버들 키 차이 고려해서 치마길이도 조이-슬기-아이린-웬디 순임
이때 생각나서 보러왔다...애들 너무 예뻤을때...넷 다 생머리에다가 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ진짜 좋은향기날거같애 넷다 흑흑
Wendy is wearing heels and Joy isnt, yet Wendy is still shorter than Joy 😂😭💖
i really miss this kind of their good vibe music and on point choreos
Until now I can't get over with Wendy's highnotes in Happiness era
WENDY IS SHININGGGGGGGGGG
Wendy is so good in dancing. As good as Seulgi tho.
the time when they all look healthy and delicious snack
애기 조이다ㅠㅠ풋사과시절ㅠㅠ
So nostalgic 😍 I still cannot get over their costume here
I hope stylist start putting more efforts again this cb🙏
wow that's why a lot of people thought she's the visual cause she's so gorgeous here
I love all of Red Velvet but OMG Wendy’s voice is so powerful.❤️❤️❤️❤️
완전 소중한 영상이네
Wendy is my first love since day one.. missing her debut era.. 😢
my girls looks fresh pure & innocent😍
Wendy's waist is so small!!!omg
And still is. Even during the Peekaboo/Bad Boy era where they bodyshamed her, she still had a noticeably tiny waist
@@bamboleo6348 I don't get why people are bodyshaming idols so much. They are happy and healthy. It's their bodys
@@hyyunjiv It's the weirdest and saddest thing ever. They dance and sing just the same with and without weight so why does it matter since that's the only reason why they're on stage? I hate it so much
@@bamboleo6348 I hate it too. They should pay attention to their talents only.
She has the best body, small waist and her legs are petty.
I just want to point out those high heels for the unnies and then there's Joy wearing shortest heels.
ang cute ni joy 💚😍😍
Watch her singing if I ain't got you by Alicia Keys on my chanel
아 눈물 나네
Somehow i'm addicted to Seulgi doing this move lol 0:46
우와 감사합니다ㅠㅠㅠ 러비되기 전이네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Did Mera go back time and got this high quality of fancam?
Oh wow Seulgi looks beautiful! And those dance moves... always on point! Main dancer bear!
헐 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 진짜 추억돋아
와.. 웬디 완전 고급지고 우아하게 이쁘다
레번클로 학생같아
wendy looks so fine here
Omg! I've been so hype ever since this legendary song came! Thanks RV and thanks Mera-nim
와 대박ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ항상 감사합니다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Seulgi was wearing those high heels and still dance like nothing happened. What a queen
They all look so innocent and fresh back then, so good to see them all grown up now 🤧🥰
thank you for finally sharing this masterpiece
이때 웬디는 진짜 전설이다ㅠㅠ 성녀파트 미쳤구ㅠ💞💖💫💘
Why did you hide this from us XD?
For some reason every time i listen to Happiness i can't help to just smile this son is always going to be powerful..
i really love wendy ☹😭💙
They look so pure and innocent baby. ♡♥
Wow, the cheering for them is so loud. So proud 😍😍
The cheers on shine on me part 🥺🥺🥺
I'm rewatching Rv during their early debut..
Red Velvet is so pretty Girls.
woow i love their outfits! they look so goddamn prettyyy
wendys energy and aura here screams visual position while irene is energetic, now they switched positions lmao
the fanchants make me emotional 😢😢😢 i miss you girls!!!
NOW I BACK TO 2015 😭😭
they look so healthy 🥺
진짜 너무 좋다...
Seulgi looks so beautiful! 😍
I miss Red Velvet soooo bad :( with yerim of course :(
Happiness is wendy era ❤
The outfits are beautiful 💚
OMG The fanchant
wahahaha, Joy was so cute.
SHINE ON ME SHINE ON ME SHINE ON MEEEE
~still iconic
I love this outfit huhu
An amazing fancam that has been hidden from us for 3.5 years :O ... Seems like Mera had a clean-out day in their storage :D
Anyways, thank u Mera! Hope u release more of these unreleased fancams, which I'm sure u jave a lot more!
Woah, thank u😭
The crowd is lit. Missing this era :((
Love red velvet and love adorable irene so much always shine and always smile
I miss the old times I felt nostalgic like years ago
FROM 2014-2015 TO YOUR BEST IDOL GROUP ALIVE 💖💛💙💚💜
omygod wendy 😭 that body 😋😍
Back then when the stylists actually cared
the fanchant was insane for this rookie group back then
THANK U MERA!! u are the best!! i really miss RV in this era 😭😭
This is live guys. 😍😍😍
Surprised 😂😂 Red Velvet is the bezt 💗💛💙💚💜🔥
OMG they are all have powerful and stable vocals
Miss this era. This era was perfect
yes, but the bad thing is that yeri is not here
@@jihyotwice5056 that was a subtle shade. Smh shame on u OP.
@@jihyotwice5056 This era was Perfect bc there wasn't YERI
My babies wish Yeri was also here tho!
Nope not my wish
해피니스😍
Happiness choreography is so iconic
Hello I'm lurking in red velvet videos again 🤣
the fanchant makes me uwu
Wow seulgiyaaaa so cute
how wendy can dance with these heels :o
Ih gosshhhhh they're so pretty !!
Happiness 👏👏👏
Ah the good old days.. Back when her forehead was living it's best life and free and it wasn't hidden by those CRUSTY UGLY BANGS. Fr tho I always felt like they gave her those bangs to try and degrade her visuals and style her in hideous outfits * proceeds to cough* (zimzalabim) and so that she wouldn't overshadow irene cause everyone and I mean EVERYONE thought wendy was the visual when she debuted w red velvet and to not have any irene fan crying about it I'm not saying irene isnt beautiful shes gorgeous.
No one was and is doing it like them 💯
Yeri💖💖😭
Yeri is not there
Those fanchant!!!