@@granjefecaballorecostado6132 what makes you say that men find her more beautiful during happiness and girls find her pretty during psycho? i hope that doesnt sound rude, im just genuinely curious. i personally find her in the happiness era more beautiful too although im a girl
@@lilleilei169 To be honest I find Wendy the prettiest in Psycho era. And why exactly, well.... in Happiness she looks like a gorgeous goddess who is a both basic, bland and just one of the many pretty girls out there (STRICTLY VISUAL SPEAKING), but in later eras, Psycho especially, she looks like a beauty with her own charm, she’s not just another beauty, she is THE charming and confident beauty and she’s the only one of her kind. At least that is my perception. I don’t really know, but I feel like guys like the generic beauty and therefore are more attracted to ‘the beauty standart’ Wendy rather then to ‘a unique, charming’ Wendy.
DEAR SM, I BEG U PLEASE MAKE THIS HAIRSTYLE FOR WENDY AGAIN. YES, SHE IS SO BEAUTIFUL INDEED. BUT SHE LOOKS MORE BEAUTIFUL WITHOUT BANGS. I MISS HER FOREHEAD (sorry for my bad english)
@@kamel8888 Please no salty yah.. lu ngerasa gak sih kalo RV 2014 tuh badannya sama tinggi"nya ? , kok yg skrg jadi kyk ada yg keliatan pendek , trs ada yg Tinggi sendiri.. kyk misal Joy kn udh tinggi tuh hrsnya jgn pake heels yg tinggi nah klo kek wendy sm Yeri kn ga setinggi Joy nah mereka yg hrsnya dikasi heels tinggi biar kek impang aja gtu.. Gtw knp Stylistnya keknya krg jago yah.. sumpah gw kek kesel sendiri yg pas RV di interview Luar wkt itu Wendy sm yeri keliatan pdk bgt Krn heels nya krg Tinggi malah Joy tinggi bgt jdi kyk jomplang gtu.. kek sebel aja gtu :v klo yg 2014 gtw knp gw merasa stylist saat itu bnr" pinter :( sumpah ini curahan gw agak bikin salty sorry yah xixixixixi
@@HAPPINESS-uf1yu Yah tp klo acara formal semua member pake heels trus yg joy gk pake sendiri kn ya keliatan gk bagus.. Harusnya Heels joy sedikit lebih pendek dr yg lain
it's crazy to see it's their debut song they were rookies yet so confident to perform in such big crowd. SM gave birth to 5 powerful queens. Please utilise their abilities and promote them well
Damn can we'll bring back those days were our girls were soo happy and confidence.. Also were they can wear a comfortable shoes why now they have to heels and boots like its about showing your talent sharing your music not your heights figure color we everyone is beautiful, okay at some dresses you can but not all.......please always be with red velvet they're having very bad things,ik 2021 will be our years
Honestly, the thing that I really miss is their smile. I know that their concepts are making them looking quite serious, but even on interviews or stuff like that, I don’t really feel Red Velvet happy... it’s like they seem « dead » on inside, idk how to express it, but I’m really worry for them, i just hope they will have enough rest and I hope they will comeback stronger and mostly happier than now. Sorry for my bad English. 😛
@@marinadc7540 i think they've been through a lot, especially being sm's girl group representative, they're expected to have a serious image? im not sure but i hope they'e okay
I love them even today and they have grown and expanded. I don't necessarily think it is bad. You can't replace youth and the feeling of starting out like they were in happiness. Just like a kid at Christmas. Adults still enjoy it, but it is never the same. You know what I mean? At least we have these videos to bring us back.
While I do prefer Wendy + No Bangs, Wendy is always beautiful and I refuse to acknowledge anyone who says she was “prettier during debut era” bc she’s just as pretty as she’s always been. But a little variety is nice... I hope she tries long dark hair again.
Exactly. The fact that she looks even better now even after an incident that could have very well killed her, i won't listen to anyone that tells me that her debut days were the prettiest version because that's a lie imo
I honestly really thought that Wendy is the visual during their debut and Irene is like the face of the group! But all of them are really really pretty. The power of SM visuals.
it's so fascinating to see that seulgi never lost the shine in her eyes whenever she's performing on stage. i love her so much, i love them 😭 wishing that august will come faster.
@@STR4WB3RRYM1LK35 Contracts are typically 7 years long for idols who debut. RV debuted in 2014, meaning their contract may very well be near expiration if they signed a 7 year contract (except Yeri, of course; I think she debuted in 2015).
Damn, that Shine On Me still hits the same 🔥! I never switched my bias, it's always been Wendy since day 1😭💙💙💙 I was just 14 when this song came out and Wendy unnie really caught my eye that time.
The comments annoy me, yes sm forced Wendy to change some things about her weight but that’s literally the only thing other than the on/off styling. Wendy has always shined onstage and has always been happy to be where she is. Stop internalizing idols struggles as your own people. Please stop.
OMG. This isn't just one of the best RV performances ever, I think it is *the* best performance of Happiness ever recorded. Thank you so much for sharing.
I think Wendy looks better without her bangs. Or maybe just those very basic bangs the stylists always seem to give her. Also dark hair Wendy for the wiiiin!
I want them to be this happy again while performing :( SM loves to make everything seem perfect but I love the fresh and cute vibe RV had during Happiness era... maybe it's also different now cause they've matured and have been in this industry for quite a while now but I miss those times :(
Love this video and never get tired of watching it. The girls all look so beautiful and their dance routine is off the hook.. Love how Wendy really belts out the Shine on Me part at the end. They're rookies here but knocked it out of the park!
![[#레벨업5] 햇살 가득한 제주도여~ 안녕🖐🏻✨ 오랜만에 만난 레벨이도 안녕~💗 #RedVelvet (SUB)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VpgX11BEAUA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[직캠/FANCAM] 150912 소녀시대 (SNSD) 라이언하트 (Lion Heart), 지 (Gee) 리허설 (Rehearsal) @ MBC 음악중심](/img/n.gif)
Imagine debuting and going in a world tour at the same year
And slaying it
and being queen
I mean, it’s not their tour, so pretty usual experience for all smtown juniors
Well its there companies tour SM so its a easy world tour for them even aespa did it in an few months
it's called sm privilege.
i think Happiness era Wendy is the prettiest Wendy and i still stand by that opinion
i think power up and rbb wendy is the closest to happiness wendy
For me, Psycho Wendy is the best... she looked both pretty and badass in that era 😍
i miss her old jaw :( she looked so pretty in happiness era but after her jaw shave, she just looks a bit different T_T
@@nmixx.changeupletsgo is the jaw shave some kind of cosmetic surgery? is this legit?
@@fchryssreitimothy yeah it's legit but kinda scary. a lot of sm artists do it, jessica from snsd did it and her results are good tbh.
We all agree that Wendy is most beautiful during Happiness era
Nah. I find her still the most beautiful and at her most beautiful in 2020 😁😁😁
In physco
@@eyebrowstj For men probably she was more beautiful in happiness era but for girls probably at psycho era she was more pretty
@@granjefecaballorecostado6132 what makes you say that men find her more beautiful during happiness and girls find her pretty during psycho? i hope that doesnt sound rude, im just genuinely curious. i personally find her in the happiness era more beautiful too although im a girl
@@lilleilei169 To be honest I find Wendy the prettiest in Psycho era. And why exactly, well.... in Happiness she looks like a gorgeous goddess who is a both basic, bland and just one of the many pretty girls out there (STRICTLY VISUAL SPEAKING), but in later eras, Psycho especially, she looks like a beauty with her own charm, she’s not just another beauty, she is THE charming and confident beauty and she’s the only one of her kind. At least that is my perception. I don’t really know, but I feel like guys like the generic beauty and therefore are more attracted to ‘the beauty standart’ Wendy rather then to ‘a unique, charming’ Wendy.
Wendy looked genuinely happy and healthy back then...
Edit : I did not expect a whole debate on the comment section lmao.....
Yeah and now she looks completely different
@@enasyfoto1 no idiot
:(
@@howuknowimnotbig506 she did because of that fucking accident. Fuck SBS
@@roslymedrano2840 even if I don’t like her know one deserves what happened to her
wendy looks the prettiest in this era, at first i thought she was the groups visual
She did and does look the prettiest!
She is really a top visual. She just has two disadvantages. She is so pretty.
She’s always the prettiest for me in redvelvet! But yeah all member is pretty too❤️
same thoughts
@@a_person890 hey pls don’t hate on Irene , everyone is beautiful:)
Wendy's vocals have been top notch since day 1! She's gotten even better these days! Queen 👸👸👸
Oop girl I see you everywhere 👁👄👁
@@VimaAlvarezVlog081972
Hello 👋👋👋
Vocals aren't even prerecorded. This is straight up playback
@@arturopita8873 but like wendys voice is still top notch since day 1
@@VimaAlvarezVlog081972 Absolutely
DEAR SM, I BEG U PLEASE MAKE THIS HAIRSTYLE FOR WENDY AGAIN. YES, SHE IS SO BEAUTIFUL INDEED. BUT SHE LOOKS MORE BEAUTIFUL WITHOUT BANGS. I MISS HER FOREHEAD (sorry for my bad english)
Yup.. Dia memang cocok bgt pake hairstyle itu..
Look at my Psyco era profile pic! Wendy still looks amazing!
But blonde Wendy is a superior and that’s on period
@@kamel8888 Please no salty yah.. lu ngerasa gak sih kalo RV 2014 tuh badannya sama tinggi"nya ? , kok yg skrg jadi kyk ada yg keliatan pendek , trs ada yg Tinggi sendiri.. kyk misal Joy kn udh tinggi tuh hrsnya jgn pake heels yg tinggi nah klo kek wendy sm Yeri kn ga setinggi Joy nah mereka yg hrsnya dikasi heels tinggi biar kek impang aja gtu.. Gtw knp Stylistnya keknya krg jago yah.. sumpah gw kek kesel sendiri yg pas RV di interview Luar wkt itu Wendy sm yeri keliatan pdk bgt Krn heels nya krg Tinggi malah Joy tinggi bgt jdi kyk jomplang gtu.. kek sebel aja gtu :v klo yg 2014 gtw knp gw merasa stylist saat itu bnr" pinter :( sumpah ini curahan gw agak bikin salty sorry yah xixixixixi
@@HAPPINESS-uf1yu Yah tp klo acara formal semua member pake heels trus yg joy gk pake sendiri kn ya keliatan gk bagus.. Harusnya Heels joy sedikit lebih pendek dr yg lain
Wendy is Red velvet’s visual actually ..
She's always been mine 😁😁😁
i thought so :(
they all are
AGREE!!! EVER SINCE PREDEBUT!
@@eyebrowstj same
it's crazy to see it's their debut song they were rookies yet so confident to perform in such big crowd. SM gave birth to 5 powerful queens. Please utilise their abilities and promote them well
What
There’s four
@@gia1889 they mean including yeri:D
@@gia1889 yeri
Yeri happened after seulrene😆
Joy's smile is really big during this era
Yesssss
Damn can we'll bring back those days were our girls were soo happy and confidence.. Also were they can wear a comfortable shoes why now they have to heels and boots like its about showing your talent sharing your music not your heights figure color we everyone is beautiful, okay at some dresses you can but not all.......please always be with red velvet they're having very bad things,ik 2021 will be our years
Honestly, the thing that I really miss is their smile. I know that their concepts are making them looking quite serious, but even on interviews or stuff like that, I don’t really feel Red Velvet happy... it’s like they seem « dead » on inside, idk how to express it, but I’m really worry for them, i just hope they will have enough rest and I hope they will comeback stronger and mostly happier than now.
Sorry for my bad English. 😛
@@marinadc7540 i think they've been through a lot, especially being sm's girl group representative, they're expected to have a serious image? im not sure but i hope they'e okay
I love them even today and they have grown and expanded. I don't necessarily think it is bad. You can't replace youth and the feeling of starting out like they were in happiness. Just like a kid at Christmas. Adults still enjoy it, but it is never the same. You know what I mean? At least we have these videos to bring us back.
I miss old kpop I guess 😞
2021 will be for Red Velvet and us, their loving ReVeluvs. Let's wait for them! 🧡
Happiness era is Wendy's era.
No offense, but every era is Wendy's era 😁😁😁
@@eyebrowstj Stan Ot5
Joy era!*
@@user-bf8xk7ll1w its clearly wendys era but i respect your opinion
@@user-bf8xk7ll1w wendy era!*
I love how they all died the ends of their hair individual colours. Please bring that back it looks so good
Fun fact: they did that so it was easier for the audience to remember them. Worked for me
@@jeeveskulit oh really! that's so cool especially for new reveluvs
@@iluvuforever
It’s dyed not died
Srry if I was mean 🥺🥺
@@jeeveskulit when they debuted it was the only way for me to actually associate their names to their faces perfectly 🥺
ah the good times when we thought Wendy was the visual and Irene is the main dancer hahaha
so right😭a reveluv for almost 2 years now and watching this, irene really looks the main dancer here and wendy the visual lmao💀
@@juicyjisoox when you have a group full of aces.
and Seulgi as the main rapper 😂
2020 and here i am watching this and tearing up as wendy sang her ‘ shine one me ‘. Proud of these girls
Wendy's star power is incredible here. I just can't take my eyes off her.
Omooo Joy looks sooo cuteee she looks really fresh and pretty and her body portions are so nice
0:12 Irene's "booyah" is so cute
Happiness - Wendy's era
Ice cream cake - Yeri's
Russian Roulette - Irene's
Peek a Boo - Joy's
Bad Boy - Seulgi's
Yesss
While I do prefer Wendy + No Bangs, Wendy is always beautiful and I refuse to acknowledge anyone who says she was “prettier during debut era” bc she’s just as pretty as she’s always been.
But a little variety is nice... I hope she tries long dark hair again.
have you seen her long dark hair in queendom era so far? :D
WE GOT IT NOW IN QUEENDOM
Exactly. The fact that she looks even better now even after an incident that could have very well killed her, i won't listen to anyone that tells me that her debut days were the prettiest version because that's a lie imo
irene and seulgi were slaying the dance
I honestly really thought that Wendy is the visual during their debut and Irene is like the face of the group! But all of them are really really pretty. The power of SM visuals.
아 저때로 내인생 돌아가고 싶다
ㄹㅇ
나도
ㄹㅇ 다시 살고시픔
wendy smile is the brightest smile i see
2020 still watching this
Meeeeeeeeeee this never gets boring 🥰
2020 is almost overrrrrrrrr :(
Same
2020 is over sm stylish pls do a no bangs hairstyle like happiness era to wendy in the next comeback
Having my throwback marathon legends since the beginning.
저 때 스타일링 너무 좋다 ㅠㅠ 조이 웬디 특히 너무 잘 어울리고 사랑스러움...
Irene´s stage presense in here is so bright, I love her so much
SM PLEASE BRING BACK THIS HAIRSTYLES FOR THEIR 7TH ANNIV SPECIALLY WENDY I MISS THIS HAIR FOR HER
it's so fascinating to see that seulgi never lost the shine in her eyes whenever she's performing on stage. i love her so much, i love them 😭 wishing that august will come faster.
Joy shined then too...
She always did💚💚💚
Seulgi rap is everything her voice is so deep
나 이때 좋았어 스엠 엔시티랑 에스파만 세계관 해 가만히 있던 선배들까지 세계관 통합은 아닌것 같아 왜 슈주가 우주여행이야
Wendy is prettier without bangs. She is so cute
WENDY & SEULGI VOCALS!!! ❤😍❤
I remember when RV debuted I was confused who the visual was between Irene and Wendy 😂
추억이다… 이노래만 들으면 나자신한테 잘해보자라는 소리가 나옴 왠지는 몰라 그냥 자신감이 생기고 뭐라도 해야할것만 같음 느낌? 그럼으로 지금 공부하러 가겠습니다
Wendy in happiness was so beautiful already. I love her she’s still my visual but she was already beautiful
irene and wendy slammed in this stage
3:00 Wendy main character 🔥
Dang, it's 2021. That means RV's 7 year contract is almost over. I hope they re-sign and keep giving us the 🔥🔥🔥!!!
What do you mean red velvet contract is almost over?
@@STR4WB3RRYM1LK35 Contracts are typically 7 years long for idols who debut. RV debuted in 2014, meaning their contract may very well be near expiration if they signed a 7 year contract (except Yeri, of course; I think she debuted in 2015).
와 다 풋풋한거보ㅓ....진짜 개귀엽다.....
omg joy was such a baby, she grew up in front of our eyes😔😔❤️😍😍😍
Irene is such a cutie and I really love how bubbly she was, while seulgi kinda looks like sandara park.
와 지금도 예쁘지만 행복 승완 진짜 너무 예쁘다 하이틴 영화에 나올거 같아
i love how all comments gave happiness era wendy the recognition she deserved and plss wendy looks so matured here
WENDY'S SHINE ON ME REMAINS TO BE ICONIC
This is 6 years ago. Wow, they don't get old 🙃
Omg that pink shoes on Irene & Seulgi's was a hint for their sub-unit from the beginning
Lmao 🤣
wendy’s vocals 😳😳😳😳
Joy is looking soo cutee....my god ....was she born cute.....all my girls are the original visual 💜💜💜
The time where Wendy was on par with Irene's visuals :(
She was superior in that era. She stood out the most and made irene's visual position not obvious.
wendy's vocals and visuals tho!!! im in love!!! shes absolutely gorgeous!
Damn, that Shine On Me still hits the same 🔥! I never switched my bias, it's always been Wendy since day 1😭💙💙💙 I was just 14 when this song came out and Wendy unnie really caught my eye that time.
Same! She's been my bias since first sight in 2015 💙💙💙💙💙
Dang! Same here. Never bias wrecked. HAHAHA
Glad am not the only one😂.By the way guys, See you on January 1st!!! We'll see our Wannie perform with the girls again. 😍💙😭🤧
@@JB-od7te Sure! Let's cheer for her! :)
The comments annoy me, yes sm forced Wendy to change some things about her weight but that’s literally the only thing other than the on/off styling. Wendy has always shined onstage and has always been happy to be where she is. Stop internalizing idols struggles as your own people. Please stop.
delusional
화장법 때문인지 조이 저때 이미지가 약간 오마이걸 효정이 비슷하네요ㅋㅋㅋ 지금도 예쁘지만 신인시절의 풋풋 레벨이들 넘나 상큼ㅠㅠㅋ
The excitement I felt when SM finally gave us RV ❤ Babies!
Seulgi sooo beautiful 😻
♥️♥️
Woah Wendy vocal is no joke I FREAKING GOT GOOSEBUMPS
I miss this Joy and I love Wendy no matter what she is ❤️💛💙💚💜
OMG. This isn't just one of the best RV performances ever, I think it is *the* best performance of Happiness ever recorded. Thank you so much for sharing.
Joy literally has a baby face 😭
Yesssss
벨순이들 이때 의상 신발 스니커즈 갖춘거 상큼하게 이뻤다
The time everyone thought Wendy was the Visual
maybe this is the last day jessica met rv coz in this world tour she had her last performance as gg
I miss redvelvet so i watch this video😭💫 i need they comeback
That part *SHINE ON ME!* gave me an iconic GOOSEBUMPS!!! ❤❤❤
Still can't move on how pretty wendy is
They are so energetic with their dance
Love them...redvelvet
I don't know why Wendy feels she looks ugly in this era, I mean this is what made her my first bias in RV.
everyone thought that she was the visual during this era
@@gugsu righttt, she stood out in that era!
I think Wendy looks better without her bangs. Or maybe just those very basic bangs the stylists always seem to give her. Also dark hair Wendy for the wiiiin!
Jesus i never realized how tall joy is but she’s really towering over them 😳
They r really pretty
They’re voices are so clean
Wendy and Irene best visuals.
저때도 조이 얼굴이랑 목소리 미쳤네
풋사과 옥구슬 역수,ㅣ
They were GLOWING! And omg my baby seulgi 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
This will always be my go to happy song to cheer me up 💗💛💙💚💜
Came back here after release of FMR, they’ve come so far :,)
The hair color , this performence redvelvet "iconic"
I want them to be this happy again while performing :( SM loves to make everything seem perfect but I love the fresh and cute vibe RV had during Happiness era... maybe it's also different now cause they've matured and have been in this industry for quite a while now but I miss those times :(
rookie red velvet
Seulgi talking in the beginning made it for me 😂
Iconic. Wendy slay.
*this reminded how my childhood(grade 5) was and now I'm a senior highschool student watching makes me tear up and dance lol why*
Wendy looks like completely different person here :( I miss her looks here
She is just so young and wears a simple make up here 😊
This is very old so of course she looks different
yeah she didn’t need that jaw shave, she’s always been beautiful. she’s still very pretty though.
i love how they smile for all time performance
Love this video and never get tired of watching it. The girls all look so beautiful and their dance routine is off the hook.. Love how Wendy really belts out the Shine on Me part at the end. They're rookies here but knocked it out of the park!
Seulgi so pretty in here
Visual queen wendyyyyyyyyyyy💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💥
조이 진짜 풋사과 그 자체다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 언니 사랑해
i miss red velvet
#OT5REDVELVET
Seulgi's twintails are so cute with the curls and yellow ends💛
Miss them af
wendy has changed so much
Yeah :((
Red Velvet legendary song.
Okay but Irene’s foot work here 👀 subtle yet clean
Irene really said Blackpink since 2014
Wendy visual grrr