I agree (especially as Yeri is my RV bias), but no line distribution will ever be worse than Haseul getting less than one second of lines in LOONA's debut song, when she was the leader and one of the best vocalists 💀
One thing to note about red velvet songs is they they’re often singing the chorus together!! so while the individual lines might be low, the girls are still singing!
yk I think the cool thing about this is that during more recent eras is that the person in last (mostly yeri) had at least 20+ seconds which is better than like less than 10 and at some point despite being last yeri got 33 seconds?? like that's good.
I think its because they used to, and still sometimes do, sing the chorus altogether. For example, Yeri was last in Wildside and still got 33 seconds, meanwhile in cosmic, their most recent song, Joy only got 15 seconds.
It’s funny how I can always recognize Yeri’s voice, even if it’s a song she doesn’t have a lot of lines, because she has so much personality and uniqueness to her delivery. I know if we were to talk about who are the best vocalists in RV it’s Seulgi and Wendy, of course, but I really love Yeri’s voice, her parts are my favorite ones after Joy’s
@@hyuncute I suppose it is, but there’s groups like seventeen who have 13 members and people say their line distribution is fair (but I don’t know much about it, so I can’t confirm). So I usually just blame SM because I hate kpop companies 😂
Actually yeri voice is the foundation for most red velvet harmonization, for example if you listen cosmic closely, yeri vocal was all over the chorus and it sounds so good
whoever made that line distribution knew what they were doing bc they gave the rap parts to the singers, gave all members a high note, and also didn’t make everyone sing at the same time for the chorus but still managed to give them the perfect chorus distribution.
As Joy bias, it would’ve been her era 😭 but she really ate, because happy concept suits her like Irene - Elegant concept Seulgi - Any concept actually Wendy - Strong concept (also suit in sad/slow concept) Joy - Colorful concept (also suit in hot concept) Yeri - Dark concept
In cosmic she does actually sing a lot because she does a tone of vocal layering and harmonies in the entire song but she doesn’t have a lot of her own lines sadly :( her lower register is like the backbone of the entire song tho
i'm so glad their line distribution has evolved so we get to hear more of yeri's singing she has such a unique and versatile voice I hope we also get a solo album from her soon
Not hate but Wenseul is the main and lead vocalist so it's reasonable that they got the most. Everyone in Red Velvet can sing and has a unique vocal tone tho.
you can really see how yeri still manages to stand out and bring her charm. she truly was a great star found by sm, so glad my bias is here and shining brighter than ever!
Actually Irene has the least lines in Chill Kill. Every line distribution channel have distributed the lines wrong, most of them don't count the "'till the end of time, yeah yeah" as Yeri's line, but it is. You can see Yeri recording this line on the recording behind video.
@awaywiththefaeries9464 I think because it's a whispery part and therefore Yeri is talking in a muffled way and in a entonation we don't hear that often, so it may cause us to have trouble figuring out who is singing it. But I think they would have included Joy recording the whispers in the video if it was her (even if she was just harmonizing to it)
The only good thing about red velvet is that all of the members sing the chorus so even though you only have a few solo lines. You don't sing seconds of a 3 minute song
Irene and yeri get last lines but a lot of screentime, i think its fair enoough 😢 What i am sad for is wendy get a lot of lines but least screentime.. sometimes when her part, they give focus to other members 😢 Its better to be seulgi, she got enough screen time and lines 😅
Yeri and Irene may have the least amount of lines in most songs, but they are always slaying the harmonies throughout the song. They are pretty solid vocalists 💖💜💖💜💖💛💎💚💜
Ya know red velvet does a pretty good job with line distributions all things considered. The person with the least amount still getting 15-20 seconds is really good when you consider some groups will have you praying the person in last gets more than 5 lol.
Good thing that their line distributions have improved a lot. ❤ I love that all their tones are unique and have their own colour and character. They all go well with the concepts of their songs. ❤❤
I didn’t realize Yeri has the least amount of lines, she’s often my favorite parts of songs because her voice is so distinct. I can easily point it out in a lot of songs. Anyway the song that made the most sense here is happiness, since she debuted a year after but ice cream cakes!?! That’s literally when she debuted why didn’t they show her off a little more 🥲
Queendon line distribution is ridiculous when the mv portraits Yeri as the main character 😭 Wildside shows that it's possible to distribute the lines better, even the one with less lines won't be erased and the main vocalists can still sing (because some wenseul utts swear that if yerene get more lines, then wenseul won't sing at all 🙄). And Psycho... God, at some parts I hate that song because I remember listening to the song for the first time and genuinely not noticing if Yeri sang at all because of how ridiculous short her lines were AND THAT TERRIBLE RAP LINE, LIKE UGH. I still don't even know what the hell that should mean. Not going to talk about Power Up because back then I was so furious that I can't start talking abt it without cursing. I'm glad both Yeri and Irene have more lines now and hope that sm doesn't start giving Yeri 5 seconds of lines again when she leaves the company next year 😭 (I'm manifesting joyri out of that company so hard, you guys have no idea)
this is the video i watched for the line distribution, yeri is last but irene is soo close 😭 th-cam.com/video/pPN1oOKAep0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=BYrxm11aHEDXLWy6
Sometimes i dont know why they even added yeri to RV with this treatment (and im saying this as a yeri bias lol i love that she joined ofc just wish she was utilised more)
irene sung the first "zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zim zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zim" and irene and yeri lit own the "last place queens
Hyoyeon was the weakest vocalist in SNSD, Victoria was the weakest vocalist in f(x) by a long way (no hate because she was my bias from day one until the end) both were dancers and placed in the group for that reason, they got a lot of screen time in place of the lack of singing lines, Yeri and Aeri are both rappers but I use that loosely as they are advancing in the their careers because both have shown they can sing. There has to be a hierarchy to the group, the main vocalist/vocalists will always get the most lines, what is the point of having Taeyeon, Jessica, Luna, Wendy, Seulgi, Winter and Ningning if you are going to give all the lines to a "rapper" or "dancer"
I’m not surprised, Yeri was a terrible singer in her first years and Irene was both unstable and a bad rapper. Now they’re benefiting both from the experience as well because SM is giving them songs that fit them better.
i dont find this sad or anything bc first of all team rocket are the ones being utilized for adlibs. so the least line should fall between irene and yeri considering they are responsible for rap parts. i find it balanced tbh bc it would be weird if the rappers have more lines than vocalists like every other kpop groups out there.
Uggh people always overreact to this kind of things. There's no way a group with different level of skills in a dynamic song got the exact amount of lines hmmm. They even have position and else.
I’ve watched many line distribution videos and somehow those don’t give you as good of a feel for It like this does. Oh and it’s always great to get a flyover of how awesome Red Velvet discography is.
i don't think it's about money but recognition, i think she loves singing and maybe in their first's eras where she almost didn't sing, must have hurt 😭❤️
@@hyuncute Our Wanda has a lot of lines but still had been one of the less popular members for the longest time 🥲. I think she kinda picked up in popularity because of the radio show and musicals.
could almost name this yeri line evolution
it's so sad 😭😭
5 seconds in a song with 5 members is diabolical 😭😭
Lady’s Night by Lady
Sahara 70.3s
Yoona 34.4s
Binu 14.1s
Sinae 10.4s
ᶻ 𝗓 𐰁 .ᐟ ★
Lmao
omg?!!??!??
I agree (especially as Yeri is my RV bias), but no line distribution will ever be worse than Haseul getting less than one second of lines in LOONA's debut song, when she was the leader and one of the best vocalists 💀
to be fair everyone had very few lines in icc. they sing 90% of that song togehter
its not much but she leads the “lalalalala” in the first verse so at least she has like 7 seconds 🥲
One thing to note about red velvet songs is they they’re often singing the chorus together!! so while the individual lines might be low, the girls are still singing!
THATS TRUE 💗💗
That's literally what was going through my mind.
yeri and irene just owning the title of 'last line queens duo' i cant😭
😪😪😪
Because they're rappers in a vocal focused group 😢
@@jeynasyfla7125 they don't even get proper Rap Wtf SM
ft. joy😭
@@RafliNurFadilah-n6m joy get good lines what u talking about? 😭
yeah their line distributions have improved a lot, going from last having 5s and now having usually 20+ seconds
yes ⭐️🫶🏻
yk I think the cool thing about this is that during more recent eras is that the person in last (mostly yeri) had at least 20+ seconds which is better than like less than 10 and at some point despite being last yeri got 33 seconds?? like that's good.
I think its because they used to, and still sometimes do, sing the chorus altogether. For example, Yeri was last in Wildside and still got 33 seconds, meanwhile in cosmic, their most recent song, Joy only got 15 seconds.
True🥺
Yesss
Yeah we don't even complain anymore if one of them are last at least 20s+ are fair
It’s funny how I can always recognize Yeri’s voice, even if it’s a song she doesn’t have a lot of lines, because she has so much personality and uniqueness to her delivery. I know if we were to talk about who are the best vocalists in RV it’s Seulgi and Wendy, of course, but I really love Yeri’s voice, her parts are my favorite ones after Joy’s
her voice is sooo good 😭😭 every rv member is so talented line distributions are hard to do 😪
@@hyuncute I suppose it is, but there’s groups like seventeen who have 13 members and people say their line distribution is fair (but I don’t know much about it, so I can’t confirm). So I usually just blame SM because I hate kpop companies 😂
@@victorias.f.honestly for how many members they have seventeen’s distributions are pretty good
Actually yeri voice is the foundation for most red velvet harmonization, for example if you listen cosmic closely, yeri vocal was all over the chorus and it sounds so good
wildside having the most yeri lines no wonder it’s my favorite song lol
is soo good 🥹💗
@@hyuncute the velvet track to end all velvet tracks but it's a japanese release so most people don't care :(
The one where everyone gets to hit the highest note and sing the chorus
whoever made that line distribution knew what they were doing bc they gave the rap parts to the singers, gave all members a high note, and also didn’t make everyone sing at the same time for the chorus but still managed to give them the perfect chorus distribution.
I feel like Yeri could have gotten more lines in bad boy, psycho and Joy in cosmic. Their voices really suit those concepts.
for reall😭😭💔
Joy really ATE in cosmic, she deserved more
As Joy bias, it would’ve been her era 😭 but she really ate, because happy concept suits her like
Irene - Elegant concept
Seulgi - Any concept actually
Wendy - Strong concept (also suit in sad/slow concept)
Joy - Colorful concept (also suit in hot concept)
Yeri - Dark concept
In cosmic she does actually sing a lot because she does a tone of vocal layering and harmonies in the entire song but she doesn’t have a lot of her own lines sadly :( her lower register is like the backbone of the entire song tho
they probably punished joy for speaking out
as a yeri ult i clicked on this ready to enjoy a compilation of my favorite girl :) ty for making this
HAHAJ 😭😭😭
i'm so glad their line distribution has evolved so we get to hear more of yeri's singing she has such a unique and versatile voice I hope we also get a solo album from her soon
lets hope for the best 💗💗💗
I know I’m waiting on her purple case version so we can complete the rainbow (along with Irene’s)
The way SM only stopped shelving irene and yeri during cosmic era to be spiteful toward joy for speaking out about their mismanagement
😭😭😭😭
Joy has been last in several songs before Cosmic so I don’t think that’s why
she spoke out during cosmic tho
You could just call this Red Velvet but it’s only Irene and Yeri and sometimes Joy 😂
😭💔
Not hate but Wenseul is the main and lead vocalist so it's reasonable that they got the most. Everyone in Red Velvet can sing and has a unique vocal tone tho.
Yeri might have the least lines but she has some of my favorite lines
she always slays 💜
Basically just a video of my ult bias singing
😭😭😭😭
this is also a good video to show the evolution of fashion and makeup trends across the years
that's true! 💞💞
I feel like this shows that it doesn’t matter your legnth in position, but more what part you get. these parts are so iconic
for reaal💗
Omg just realizing now how criminal it is to give just a few lines to Irene on Be Natural like ... She totally fits the vibe
ffrrr😭😭
you can really see how yeri still manages to stand out and bring her charm. she truly was a great star found by sm, so glad my bias is here and shining brighter than ever!
Actually Irene has the least lines in Chill Kill. Every line distribution channel have distributed the lines wrong, most of them don't count the "'till the end of time, yeah yeah" as Yeri's line, but it is. You can see Yeri recording this line on the recording behind video.
I always thought that was Joy?
@awaywiththefaeries9464 I think because it's a whispery part and therefore Yeri is talking in a muffled way and in a entonation we don't hear that often, so it may cause us to have trouble figuring out who is singing it.
But I think they would have included Joy recording the whispers in the video if it was her (even if she was just harmonizing to it)
The only good thing about red velvet is that all of the members sing the chorus so even though you only have a few solo lines. You don't sing seconds of a 3 minute song
I never noticed how few of a seconds yeri got on ICC like wtf😵
😭😭
Irene and yeri get last lines but a lot of screentime, i think its fair enoough 😢
What i am sad for is wendy get a lot of lines but least screentime.. sometimes when her part, they give focus to other members 😢
Its better to be seulgi, she got enough screen time and lines 😅
yes 😭❤️
Yeri who owned Peek A Boo with Joy and have less line it’s just legendary
yesyesyes
Yeri and Irene may have the least amount of lines in most songs, but they are always slaying the harmonies throughout the song. They are pretty solid vocalists 💖💜💖💜💖💛💎💚💜
yaaaas ❤️
sometimes the member with the least lines has the most memorable ones
yaaaaaaaaas like gaeul
this video really reminds me how underrated yeri is tbh, like her voice is so unique and her dancing + visuals are sooo good
Ya know red velvet does a pretty good job with line distributions all things considered. The person with the least amount still getting 15-20 seconds is really good when you consider some groups will have you praying the person in last gets more than 5 lol.
they got better for sure 🥹💗
Good thing that their line distributions have improved a lot. ❤
I love that all their tones are unique and have their own colour and character. They all go well with the concepts of their songs. ❤❤
yeees 💗💗
actually shocked that irene has the fewest line in russian roulette ... shes so iconic in thay era
frr 😭
This video is so nostalgic. Red Velvet were the first group I loved for years 😢 Love this so much ❤
thxzz💗💗💗
Power up was just foul
i love power up! but yes... 😭❤️
the chorus in rv's songs are sung by all members, so it's not that bad
Yup, and adding on to that, yeri’s voice is usually the one i hear more prominently in their harmonies😍
Even if Yeri get the least lines, her voice is so unique so her parts always adds a lot to the song
I didn’t realize Yeri has the least amount of lines, she’s often my favorite parts of songs because her voice is so distinct. I can easily point it out in a lot of songs. Anyway the song that made the most sense here is happiness, since she debuted a year after but ice cream cakes!?! That’s literally when she debuted why didn’t they show her off a little more 🥲
🥹🥹
The fact that joy got the least lines in cosmic when her voice suits the concept so well…🤦🏾♀️
soo sad, she's my bias ;((
I went in here expecting yeri and yk what I got? Yeri.
u got what u expected. 😭
I know this is about having the least lines but, Red Velvet truly has one of the best discographies in Kpop
frr
yeri’s literally always been my rv bias
she's soo good 🥰❤️🩹
Queendon line distribution is ridiculous when the mv portraits Yeri as the main character 😭
Wildside shows that it's possible to distribute the lines better, even the one with less lines won't be erased and the main vocalists can still sing (because some wenseul utts swear that if yerene get more lines, then wenseul won't sing at all 🙄).
And Psycho... God, at some parts I hate that song because I remember listening to the song for the first time and genuinely not noticing if Yeri sang at all because of how ridiculous short her lines were AND THAT TERRIBLE RAP LINE, LIKE UGH. I still don't even know what the hell that should mean.
Not going to talk about Power Up because back then I was so furious that I can't start talking abt it without cursing.
I'm glad both Yeri and Irene have more lines now and hope that sm doesn't start giving Yeri 5 seconds of lines again when she leaves the company next year 😭 (I'm manifesting joyri out of that company so hard, you guys have no idea)
luckily i feel like rv is a group where every member shines every comeback even if they have few lines
yyayy!! 🙃💞
as a yeri biased this STINKS
😭😭
This category is the fight between Irene and Yeri🥹
Yeri, my no lines Queen ❤ I laugh because if I don’t I’ll cry 😭
🥹🥹🥹
The high screams in RBB are made by Irene though, so Joy has even less lines indeed 😞
The way that irene always owns most of the songs but she is least to sing
i love yeris voice the most. i know wendy and seulgi are the main vocalists and are amazing but i love yeris unique voice so darn much! talented gurls
soo talented 🧡
red velvet is the best kpop group and no one will ever change my mind omg
they are top tier for sure 💗
At least they're all singing in the chorus.
that's true 🥰❤️🩹
Irene is actually last in Chill Kill but it doesn't really change anything lol
this is the video i watched for the line distribution, yeri is last but irene is soo close 😭 th-cam.com/video/pPN1oOKAep0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=BYrxm11aHEDXLWy6
It's crazy that there are songs where Joy has the least time.
a few.. but yes
sm giving yeri just 5 seconds in her “debut” pissed me off😭
frr
Yeri puede que tenga menos líneas en peekaboo pero esas para mí, son las mas icónicas
siii una de sus mejores eras sin duda😭❤️🩹
Congrats Yeri for winning the category 😭 I love Yeri’s voice tho ❤
😭😭😭😭❤️🩹
Deep and low register discrimination 😢
it's crazy how fair wildside is
the best 🥰🥰
i can't with joy got least at cosmic when she was the one making the whole gag concept lol yes for sure fvck sm
frr, she's my bias and they did her dirty in this era...
I swear my baby yeri deserves better
Joy may have the least amount of lines in "Rookie", but i absolutely _love_ the way she sings the first pre-chorus line.
SHES MY BIAS I LOVE HER SO MUCH 🧡 every line she sings is perfect
This must’ve taken tons of research! Thank you for the video! 🙏🧡👻🐈⬛🎃
I tried my best 😭😭💗
stay strong yeri ✊😔
😭😭💗
If Yeri were in another company, she would have 2nd or 3rd place in having lines 😂🥹
she's so talented 😭❤️
In defense of the them having the least lines, most if not all of the title tracks they sing the chorus together
I always thought yeri had more because her lines are so recognisable to me, like her lines stayed in my mind the best..
My girl Yeri is so I’m potent to RV harmonies. APRRECIATE HER MORE SM DANGIT
yees 💗💗
statistically yeri’s mostly last, but. getting 30 seconds and being last is a LOT better than the 5 or 10 she used to get
yeees I love seeing sm improving rv's lines distributions!!! 👑👑
Sometimes i dont know why they even added yeri to RV with this treatment (and im saying this as a yeri bias lol i love that she joined ofc just wish she was utilised more)
she sings soo good, but the groups is full of amazing vocalist it must be hard to do the line distribution 🥹
irene sung the first "zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zim zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zimzalabim zim zim"
and irene and yeri lit own the "last place queens
yeri solo mv😍 omg queen👑
😭😭
Being yeri biased is so hard
Hope Yeri gets more lines soon and I'm happy to hear Irene is solo debuting
Justice for my girly Yeri hard being Yeri biased smh 😢
😔😔❤️🩹
Now I think seeing who has the least screen time would be interesting too 🤔
pff my storage can't take that 😭
+ they still sing in chorus with other members so i think it was still fair
yesss
The silver lining in this situation is OT5 always sing the chorus as one.
what the heck?? why does she have so little lines? they only have 5 members
they usually sing all the chorus together as ot5... but yeah... so sad 😭
SNSD - Hyo
f(x) - Victoria
RV - Yeri
aespa - Giselle ?
yes :( so sad
Hyoyeon has quite a solo career at least.
@@cactiguide Yep. Victoria is also making Banks in China
Hyoyeon was the weakest vocalist in SNSD, Victoria was the weakest vocalist in f(x) by a long way (no hate because she was my bias from day one until the end) both were dancers and placed in the group for that reason, they got a lot of screen time in place of the lack of singing lines, Yeri and Aeri are both rappers but I use that loosely as they are advancing in the their careers because both have shown they can sing. There has to be a hierarchy to the group, the main vocalist/vocalists will always get the most lines, what is the point of having Taeyeon, Jessica, Luna, Wendy, Seulgi, Winter and Ningning if you are going to give all the lines to a "rapper" or "dancer"
@@OsakaDrift11 good discussion. But how is yeri a rapper? What songs does she rap in? I thought Irene and joy did most of it.
All of Red Velvet's vocals are the best expecially Wendy
yess 🧡🧡
Yeri😢😢😢
🥹💗
Im guessing this is a Yeri solo video
u guessed right 🥹💗
yeri nailed every part she got though😊❤
YASS 🥹💗
I’m not surprised, Yeri was a terrible singer in her first years and Irene was both unstable and a bad rapper. Now they’re benefiting both from the experience as well because SM is giving them songs that fit them better.
yeri is not a terrible singeeer 😭
@@hyuncuteThey said was? It is in the past tense.
i dont find this sad or anything bc first of all team rocket are the ones being utilized for adlibs. so the least line should fall between irene and yeri considering they are responsible for rap parts. i find it balanced tbh bc it would be weird if the rappers have more lines than vocalists like every other kpop groups out there.
Yeri really isn’t a rapper though. After Irene, it’s Joy.
Uggh people always overreact to this kind of things. There's no way a group with different level of skills in a dynamic song got the exact amount of lines hmmm. They even have position and else.
no one said is wrong, ofc someone has to be the one that sings less
The erasure of joy is so cruel
despite having the least lines, irenes parts in zimzalabim r so iconic
Yeri and Irene deserved better ❤
frrr 😪
Irene is the centre, fotg, the most popular member, has the most screen time. Wdym she deserves better?
@@TheFlowerbeastseulgi is most popular member lmao
@@WomensIconn me when I'm delusional
I’ve watched many line distribution videos and somehow those don’t give you as good of a feel for It like this does.
Oh and it’s always great to get a flyover of how awesome Red Velvet discography is.
😭😭❤️❤️
SM doing my girl Yeri dirty
😭😭
What did u expect from sub vocalist lmao
Isnt she a rapper as well though?@@WomensIconn
@@WomensIconn Lisa from Blackpink is a sub vocalist, but gets more lines than Jisoo who is a lead vocalist
yeriii :((
❤️🩹😭
As long as she's getting paid, I don't see it as a problem for Yeri to almost always be last.
i don't think it's about money but recognition, i think she loves singing and maybe in their first's eras where she almost didn't sing, must have hurt 😭❤️
@@hyuncute Our Wanda has a lot of lines but still had been one of the less popular members for the longest time 🥲. I think she kinda picked up in popularity because of the radio show and musicals.
Just write yeri’s name in the title 🫡
that soo saaad☹️
You seem to like Yeri a lot.
sm doesnt like her 😭
yeri is last in zzb
getting 33 seconds and being last is killing me
we are getting better... but it was not like that in their firsts eras...😭😭
Wait where is feel my rhythm?
4:58
@@villain__9 oh thank you i didnt see😣 maybe i was focusing on other song
Yeri feat. Irene (with Joy)
frrr 🥹🥹
i mean least lines being 33 secs its okay i guess
at least we get something 😭
idk why yall are shocked at yeri and irene having the least more often.. they have the least vocal skill
Yes😭 irene and yeri are sub vocalist. What y’all expect from sub vocalist ijbol
isn't she also a rapper?
@@hyuncute yeah and RV is a vocal group
Yeri and Irene own this😭
sad reality 😭😭