The relationship between Bonnie and Rhett is very interesting. Rhett spoils and loves Bonnie like he wants to love and spoil Scarlett if she would only let him.
Yeah, and then she dies, like Scarlett would suffocate and die if she were controlled. Scarlett is stubborn but so I'd Rhett. If he told her his feeling things could have been different.
@@belair7570 No, in the book he actually says "I took the love that you didn't want and gave it to her" and then goes on to say that Bonnie is like Scarlett was before war and trauma changed her.
It’s so frustrating knowing they both love each other during this point. Yet, they are too stubborn and or scared to admit it. Obviously Scarlett is mostly at fault for not admitting her true feelings sooner. i.e. the staircase scene where Scarlett tells Rhett she is pregnant. She was SOO happy to see him when he came back home. Then of course we have this ego war between the two. I still get agitated thinking about how they could have had a better ending only if they had admitted their love sooner…
So appreciate your comments and insights. Read the book in '73 and first saw the film in '75 when it was reissued and seen in theaters. The fascination with both is rooted in the compelling and complicated characters Ms. Mitchell created and their interactions. So amazing to me to have access to GWTW and all of your opinions right at my fingertips. Vivien Leigh's performance was phenomenal. She kept the book near to make sure she knew what Scarlett was thinking and feeling at all times. Given that the film was shot out of sequence, the script was constantly being written and the director with whom she felt comfortable, George Cukor, was let go, she needed the novel to keep her rooted in the character. A twenty-six year old Vivien Leigh did an extraordinary job of taking Scarlett from 16 to 28 and giving her so many layers. Scarlett's actions could be selfish and downright despicable, but Ms. Leigh was able to bring nuance and understanding to what made Scarlett tick.
I’ve always loved the way he says “Hello” when he first walked in. I don’t think even he expected to get as carried away by his feelings as he did. And I love the way he sits on the bed; it’s so simple but intimate.
Thank god I was born nearly 100 years after him!! To know that THIS FINE MAN was alive somewhere on earth would have ruined me for every other man and I would have ended up an old maid ahahaha
You'd have to contend with his terrible bad breath from his false teeth that he struggled with. He repelled Scarlett's actress terribly during the kissing scene because his breath stank so badly.
RIP and long live Clark Gable (February 1, 1901 - November 16, 1960), aged 59 And RIP and long live Vivien Leigh (November 5, 1913 - July 8, 1967), aged 53 And RIP and long live Cammie King (August 5, 1934 - September 1, 2010), aged 76 You will always be remembered as legends.
She was so happy till he started apologizing and saying he was just drunk .... Personally i would have been offened if a guy started to tell that to me that after we had sex
It was marital rape and even if she liked it (which in real life she probably would have been traumatized and it is just part of rape culture that women are represented as being happy after sexual violence) what he did was wrong.
I imagine he must have said all types of things that flattered her ("you're beautiful, perfect, this is wonderful etc") during sex. So when he apologizes the next day and says he was drunk it's saying he didn't mean anything he said/did before. Scarlet being vain like she is, I'm sure that must have felt like a bucket of cold water.
I’d feel sorry for him cause he was a slave and then basically a slave with human rights, but you’re right. Having Rhett bump into you is definitely the worst thing that can happen.
The thing that's so frustrating is... Rhett never even gave her a chance to explain. What happened at the lumber mill with Ashley was platonic. She'd pretty much gotten over Ashley by this point.
Well sad thar He wasn't around his real life daughter ,I wonder if He ever knew that He had a daughter ,sad that mother never told him the true so He lost time with his real daughter and his real daughter lost time with her real dad
@@katarzynamariamuszynska2811 Cammie King stated, "To have been held, and kissed, and put to bed by Clark Gable at the age of (almost 5) is one of life's cruel tricks. Having him hold me on his lap, I can remember his strong arms; I can remember a happy feeling like being with a Daddy. My Mother said that indeed he did act very much like a Daddy." Immediately following Cammie's comments, Judy Lewis, Clark's daughter, speaks sadly of Clark's being so DEAR with Cammie in these scenes and that IT IS PAINFUL TO SEE THIS knowing she never had these special interactions as little Cammie had. Cammie and Judy later attended the same Catholic Girls' School, Mary Mount High School as well as attended many of the GWTW Festivities together becoming friends, of course.
Louisa Jacqueline Holmes--th-cam.com/video/WYraMGcBOKQ/w-d-xo.html....Although this is a British biography, made by the BBC in 2003, it is pretty good, excepting the usual lapses in veracity. Robert Matzen makes an apparance to talk about Carole Lombard and a couple of workers at the 'Clark Gable Museum' in Cadiz, Ohio are on hand with a couple of stories/comments....The story is pretty much as you would except, but with a slight twist, especially in the comments that Judy Lewis makes....Maybe better than so many other of these pictorial biographies I would say...👑❤💋 Reba Brooks--It is my wish that any and everytime that LORETTA YOUNG saw or may have seen GWTW and especially THE LOVING SCENES BETWEEN LITTLE CAMMIE KING (BONNIE BLUE BUTLER) and CLARK GABLE (RHETT BUTLER--Bonnie's DADDY), that what soul she had left was deeply pierced at the thought and knowledge of her ROBBING both CLARK AND JUDY, of their rightful relationship with each other as Daddy/Daughter.
Hold on a minute, and I'll tell you the rest of the story of the thief, hypocrite and liar. As far as Judy was concerned, Loretta Young only allowed Clark to see Judy ONCE when the baby was # 3 months old where he went to the rental home of Loretta's mother by previous arrangements and was able to ever hold this precious baby that night. Loretta told Judy later (after Clark had been dead for app 6 years) after Judy forced the truth from her lying and hypocritical mother that Clark fell in love with Judy; that he could not keep his hands off the baby; that the worst mistake she ever made was not getting Clark to marry her. She told Judy that Clark could always make her laugh. When he left that night he gave Loretta $400 and told Loretta to at least buy the baby a decent bed, as she had Judy sleeping in a dresser drawer. Clark continued to call Loretta, but Loretta would not return Clark's messages and finally told him not to call her anymore. From that point forward, he was never able to have a part in his baby's life--never invited to any BD's, Christmas', etc. Clark had tried to get Loretta to start being seen in public together; however, nothing Clark could suggest, neither Loretta nor her Mother would agree to try or to do. I have read both Judy's book, Uncommon Knowledge" where Judy also reveals that when she was app 15 years old, one afternoon when she got home from school, Clark was at her home standing in the foyer talking with Loretta. This was during the time that Clark and Loretta were filming their 2nd and last film, Key to the City" together. Judy also revealed that during this visit, she had the feelings that Clark really cared about her; They went into the living room and after a few minutes, Judy realized Loretta had left the room. Judy was sitting on a couch whle Clark was sitting on another chair or couch in this room. She said Clark asked her if she would come sit beside him, and she did. Judy further stated that he asked her questions as any father would ask his daughter such as her favorite subjects in school, boyfriends, etc. They visited for what seemed like a couple of hours, and when he started to leave, he told her how much he had enjoyed this visit. She walked with him to the front door. He cupped her face with his hands, bent over and kissed her forehead and left. Judy stated that she never saw him again. I guess Loretta was offering Clark a consolation prize when she sent him an invitation to Judy's wedding even though the invitation was declined. (Never would allow them to have a relationship from Judy's birth to Clark's death but yet sent him an invitation to her wedding. No one but our Heavenly Father and Clark know how many times he thought of his baby throughout the baby's growing up years. It seems ironic that Clark's death date seems to be saying, Judy and Maria (Judy's baby and Clark's grandbaby) mattered more to him than anyone will ever know. Loretta would always tell Judy she had been adopted, never telling her any differently until about 6 years after her Daddy's death when Judy forced the truth from her mother. App two weeks before Judy was married, she told her fiance that she couldn't marry him because she did not know who she was; what she was bringing to their wedding. He told Judy that everyone knew that Clark Gable was her father. She still was afraid at this point to mention this subject to Loretta but later received counselling re; this (after Clark's death) and the counsellor suggested to Judy that she confront her mother re: this, and she did. When Judy flew home from NY about 6 years after Clark's death, she notes in her book that Loretta picked her up from the airpot and seemed to know why she was home at this particular time. After getting to Loretta's home, Judy noticed that Loretta literally got sick on her stomach, went to the bathroom and threw up. Finally, Judy told her that she had to know if Clark was her father. Loretta first asked Judy if it would make her happy if he were. Judy responded to this answer that yes it would make her happy because from all that she had been told Clark was a wonderful person. As far as Judy having already been told what a wonderful person Clark was, in the last interview with little Cammie King, who played "Rhett's" and Scarlett's little 4 year old daughter in GWTW, done 3 weeks before her death, the first question asked of her was "What was Clark Gable like?" Cammie's response was, "Only that he was like a WONDERFUL DADDY, that he was very solicitous and considerate of me, and this was affirmed by my Mother." Loretta replied to this, 'Well, yes he is your father and mentioned some of the other things referenced above. Loretta wrote a book, "Forever Young" with instructions for it not to be published until after her death. Before Loretta's death in August, 2000, she was watching a segment of Larry King Live where "Date Rape" was being discussed. An idea was formed in the witch's head. She told her daughter-in-law, Linda Lewis, Michael's wife, that this is what happened to her; that Clark Gable had date raped her after she told him no, even though she never revealed this in her book to be published after her death. Loretta was a well known "flirt" having carried on a relationship for 2 years with Spencer Tracy, his being married the entire time; however, according to Loretta they never had any sexual relationship during that time. Loretta "claimed" she was a devout Catholic; however, after listening to Larry King Live, she knew if she said Clark had raped her, she would be absolved of any wrong doing of Judy's birth in November, 1935, and the entire blame would be placed on Clark. She had Linda not to mention this until after Judy's death---that way Judy would not be here to rebuttal anything and certainly not Clark as he had died in November, 1960. The one important thing Loretta failed to realize or admit was that while she was more concerned about appearng squeaky clean before the Catholic Church, she apparently failed to realize or admit she needed to be more concerned about her decisions such as this one before our Heavenly Father. When my husband and I would discuss this subject before his death, he would always say that while Loretta had Judy on this Earth, Clark would have his daughter for the Eternity.
Mam ten film już pewnie od 30 lat,muszę przyznać,że oglądając go po raz pierwszy,zrobił na mnie ogromne wrażenie.W mojej filmotece jest na pierwszym miejscu.Wspaniałe arcydzieło.
It wasn't entirely his fault. The reason he chose to pursue her anyway was because he saw something in her and knew she had the capacity to love him but simply hid her feelings. He was actually right because she was starting to love him and realize that Ashley was just infatuation. The tragedy was that her stubborness broke him so he never saw that he was right about her. When she finally loved him, he gave up. It was all just bad timing.
@@JoshuaCastillo6309I've never heard the movie described so quickly and accurately! I've seen GWTW 3 times and struggle to give short descriptions of the plot, without writing 5 paragraph essays 😂😂😂😂
What a worthless nurse for leaving Bonnie alone in the dark like that and worse calling her cowardly. It’s true that children are afraid of the dark at a young age, they will get over it when they’re ready to sleep alone in the dark-whether too soon or later in life. She should’ve listened to Capt. Butler’s orders because Bonnie’s not her child to teach lessons like that. When she has her own children, she’ll teach them whatever she wants them to do. And who can blame Butler for discharging the nurse, too? She wasn’t worth it.
Yes, but the skill of Margaret Mitchell was that you were still rooting for her, every step of the way - Scarlett was self-centred, yet always made sure everyone was provided for, put her family and (yes) ex-slaves first, made everyone work hard but not as hard as she worked herself. Margaret Mitchell always said that in the antebellum world, the ideal of the Southern Belle died - the people who thrived after the war had “gumption”, not those who relied on family connections, grace and manners. Scarlett had gumption in spades, as did Rhett. The likes of Ashley and Melanie didn’t, that’s why they’re passively at the vicissitudes of fate; they wouldn’t have survived without Scarlett’s love, no matter how misplaced it was. Her flaw was her lack of self-awareness; her triumph of will you have to applaud.
Not necessarily. She never bonded with Wade because she was too busy trying to just stay alive on Tara immediately after the war. She never bonded with Ella either because she's trying to keep her family safe in the Reconstruction. But as Scarlett says to Rhett "What else could I have done?" She did what she had to do to save her home and care for her family. At one point in the novel Scarlett fantasises about how one day she will be be a good mother to Wade and "read to him and teach him his letters." Bonnie was the only baby she had the freedom to spend time with. I think under different circumstances she could have been a different mother.
“Where’s Mother?” A devastating moment. Scarlett neglects her daughter horribly, especially compared to how Rhett dotes on her, yet Bonnie has no preferences. She loves both her parents equally, and is not happy when either of them is missing.
You know, and I think that I can speak for everyone, Cammie King brilliantly played the part of Bonnie. She was splendid. It was so sad to see her break her neck jumping the fence. Cammie only lived from 1935 to 1939, but she will be remembered forever.
He was getting increasingly frustrated and depressed towards her at this point. You'd be surprised how much your emotions can blind you to certain things. I don't blame him though.
Matheus Lacerda the smile was from last night's sexual advances. After Scarlett and Ashley were caught in one another's arms the whole town was talking and eventually Rhett found out. During a drunken argument Rhett admitted he always loved Scarlett and then made the most passionate love she ever felt. When she awoke in the morning she wanted it to last but Rhett, instead, tells her he is leaving for Charleston and taking bonnie with him. Feeling foolish she almost confessed her true love for him and seeing he didn't share the same feelings she is only left to believe he never really loved her at all. Never will she let him know her hearts yearning for him and never will she admit her pain as he leaves her. I'm sure you know this thought, just in case you don't I just had to explain...lol What a great love story this book is. I must have read it a million times and I'll read it a million more!
A.T.H No, it's that way in the book as well. The morning after the staircase scene Scarlett is elated by the information Rhett loves her, and begins planning how to wrap him around her finger, but part of her is thrilled because she cares. However, she doesn't officially realize her own love for Rhett until after Melly dies and there is no one for her to go to except him.
@@colineb9390 Her parents are probably right there. They probably gave the filmmakers permission to let the superstar Clark Gable kiss their little girl on the lips as if he was literally her daddy
I saa Rhett through the initial developments of the movie as a roguish man unable to settle. Yet, he did mature and in the end, was cleary right to be fed up with Scarlett.
@@abandonallhope.1040 He tried to straighten Scarlet up, as to make her cease with her follies and bad habits. I wouldn't exactly see that as trying to make someone love you. Maybe in the beginning of the movie, but not in the end.
@@williampitt1537 but you can’t change someone’s nature and that’s what he tried to do. Don’t get me wrong, Scarlett’s a flawed individual but so is he. Both made mistakes in this relationship; he admitted to Scarlett in the book that he knew very well she loved Ashley and that he thought he could wait her out. Lots of guys apparently love the ending because of the way he left her but I think that misses the complexity of the relationship.
@@abandonallhope.1040 I get your point. I do admit I did not read the book therefore my point of view of the character is biased towards the movie. I don't know what ressembled the original character.
I know! Her face at 2:37 gives you an indication on how bad it was. Evidently, his rotting teeth were never properly removed, but just cut off at the gumline so that the dentures would just cover them and fit in his mouth properly.
My guess would be it’s not the greatest idea to remove a young child from their mother at a young age. It’s that motherly thing fathers rarely if ever possess that young children respond better to.
Amor ésta película los amo a ellos son tan creíbles que te atrapan en su montaña Rusa de amor pasión discusiones disculpas inmadurez comedia y eso es " Magia "
@@nukapukaJudy Lewis is Clark Gable's illegitimate daughter with Loretta Young. Are you confusing Judy with Clark's children with his wives? Clark and Loretta were not married; Clark was married to another woman at that time. I also heard he had an affair with Joan Crawford for several years, but that could be speculation.
@@basketballisamazing2 No. She just didn't want to admit that she liked being taken in such a dominant manner. When he apologised he suggested (probably because he thought that what she wanted to hear, rather than the truth) he was only accidently dominant under the influence of alcohol. So she was disappointed that he wasn't really dominant as she desired.
In the book, before he ravishes her he drunkenly tells her he loves her. In the next morning, Scarlett is excited by this prospect; both by the possibility of her finally being able to tame him,but also because she subconsciously has grown to love him too even though she's unaware of it. "I'm as nervous as a bride," she thinks, "and about Rhett!" Both of them were actually waiting for the other to admit they were in love with eachother, and this night was proof of that. But when Rhett says he's drunk, insinuating it was all just a random act that meant nothing, she's disappointed and hurt. If they had both been honest here, things would have turned out very differently.
renarga I know but the lyrics are just so warped, and I’d imagine if it isn’t an excerpt from a real song that there were plenty of songs like that back then
@@Tsumami__ it is a real song! Made in the 1800s. The song is called “Ben Bolt” the lyrics are, “oh she wept with delight when he gave her a smile, and trembled with fear when he frowned”.
6 ปีที่แล้ว +1
Toda feliz Scarlett jejeje. Q hermosa era Vivien Leigh
Or maybe she liked it, like in the movie 50 shades of Grey! Rhett was such a drag, he should have pushed her against the wall for a long time and loved her properly! She says she doesn't love him, and she just climbs up to kiss!?
Clark Gable despised English women. He didn't care for this movie or other "women's pictures". He didn't get along with Greer Garson in the movie Adventure either, hating Garson's mandatory tea time and insistence on canvas screens. Greer Garson said he was not a ladies's man and preferred the company of other men.
Greer Garson was ladylike, calm and polite to the point of dizziness. She appreciated politeness and she was very communicative and extrovertial. Gable had that macho persona andnI believe he had some homosexual past he was ashamed of, so he projected that through toxic masculinity and manliness. I think Carole Lombard melted his worst traits a little bit, but her death made him worse than ever. Greer was the person you could talk with endlessly and in perfect English. She did not say anything offensive or ironic for anyone she ever worked with. I believe Walter Pigeon was similarly gentlemanlike and they were good friends.
Clark Gable was the best Rhett Butler ever.
I know right
What a wonderful father he was to that Bonnie!
The only other one was a Welshman.
The relationship between Bonnie and Rhett is very interesting. Rhett spoils and loves Bonnie like he wants to love and spoil Scarlett if she would only let him.
Nah, it’s just that she is his daughter, the daughter she had with the woman he loves.
@@belair7570 no she interpreted that just right, he even mentions it in the book
Yeah, and then she dies, like Scarlett would suffocate and die if she were controlled. Scarlett is stubborn but so I'd Rhett. If he told her his feeling things could have been different.
@@belair7570 No, in the book he actually says "I took the love that you didn't want and gave it to her" and then goes on to say that Bonnie is like Scarlett was before war and trauma changed her.
Men are complicated sometimes
It’s so frustrating knowing they both love each other during this point. Yet, they are too stubborn and or scared to admit it. Obviously Scarlett is mostly at fault for not admitting her true feelings sooner. i.e. the staircase scene where Scarlett tells Rhett she is pregnant. She was SOO happy to see him when he came back home. Then of course we have this ego war between the two. I still get agitated thinking about how they could have had a better ending only if they had admitted their love sooner…
100% - me too ! Makes me crazy, but I know that is how the story was written. ☹️
Its heartbreaking they don't get the love they deserve
Well said! ❤
So appreciate your comments and insights. Read the book in '73 and first saw the film in '75 when it was reissued and seen in theaters. The fascination with both is rooted in the compelling and complicated characters Ms. Mitchell created and their interactions. So amazing to me to have access to GWTW and all of your opinions right at my fingertips.
Vivien Leigh's performance was phenomenal. She kept the book near to make sure she knew what Scarlett was thinking and feeling at all times. Given that the film was shot out of sequence, the script was constantly being written and the director with whom she felt comfortable, George Cukor, was let go, she needed the novel to keep her rooted in the character. A twenty-six year old Vivien Leigh did an extraordinary job of taking Scarlett from 16 to 28 and giving her so many layers. Scarlett's actions could be selfish and downright despicable, but Ms. Leigh was able to bring nuance and understanding to what made Scarlett tick.
So why, if Scarlet really loved Rhett did she tell him that she wished that anyone but him was the father of the baby?
I’ve always loved the way he says “Hello” when he first walked in. I don’t think even he expected to get as carried away by his feelings as he did. And I love the way he sits on the bed; it’s so simple but intimate.
He was honestly a really loving father like 🥺 If only Scarlet had told him earlier how she really felt...
She wasn’t willing to get over the dream of Ashley even as she started to grow more attracted to Rhett
Nah...she wouldn't leave for Ashley after the pipe Rhett laid last night. She woke up like "Ashley who"?!
fwdthinker 😆😆😆
fwdthinker 😂😂😂😭😭😭😭
yeaaaah😂😂
Lmaooo so true!!
fwdthinker 😂😂😂
Oh Clark why was I born too late??!
My grandma was born on time and fairly good looking😂🤣 she loved him and probably wished the same.
@@rachelsunqvist6430 Plus millions of other girls around the world !
Thank god I was born nearly 100 years after him!! To know that THIS FINE MAN was alive somewhere on earth would have ruined me for every other man and I would have ended up an old maid ahahaha
You'd have to contend with his terrible bad breath from his false teeth that he struggled with. He repelled Scarlett's actress terribly during the kissing scene because his breath stank so badly.
Bonnie even got dimples like Rhett.
This scene melts my heart always.
aww that’s true! so cute 🥹
The actress who played Bonnie Blue, Cammie King, was also the voice of Faline in Bambi!
Rachel R. Interesting, never knew that.
That's so cool!!!
I heard.
*mind blown* I didnt know that until JUST now lol
@@shannamartinez9494 yeah she played Bambi girlfriend
Hottest scene in the movie...he was drunk and picked her up and carried her upstairs...that's one satisfied woman waking up lol
Ahhh I just scream inside my head when he picked her up!
😡😡😡😡😡😡
😂😂😂😂
After a highly problematic scene that strongly implies marital rape given the she struggled and repeatedly said no...
@Cap285 why?
RIP and long live Clark Gable (February 1, 1901 - November 16, 1960), aged 59
And
RIP and long live Vivien Leigh (November 5, 1913 - July 8, 1967), aged 53
And
RIP and long live Cammie King (August 5, 1934 - September 1, 2010), aged 76
You will always be remembered as legends.
In the book its Scarlett that suggests Rhett let Bonnie scream, but when the movie was made, they thought Scarlett already looked bad enough!
Beautiful designed bedrooms.
She was so happy till he started apologizing and saying he was just drunk .... Personally i would have been offened if a guy started to tell that to me that after we had sex
It was marital rape and even if she liked it (which in real life she probably would have been traumatized and it is just part of rape culture that women are represented as being happy after sexual violence) what he did was wrong.
Oh OK I haven't read it and I do agree he was wrong but still I always did feel a little bad for her
She initially resisted but I think its fair to say she came around very quickly after the last scene closed.
I imagine he must have said all types of things that flattered her ("you're beautiful, perfect, this is wonderful etc") during sex. So when he apologizes the next day and says he was drunk it's saying he didn't mean anything he said/did before. Scarlet being vain like she is, I'm sure that must have felt like a bucket of cold water.
@@DayneandtheStars It probably would've hurt the feelings of any woman, vain or not.
Omg I felt bad for that guy he bumped into. " Excuse me Mr. Rhett" :(
You'll be happy to know Clark Gable stood for black actors and fought against segregation.
@@rinzler666 bs.
I’d feel sorry for him cause he was a slave and then basically a slave with human rights, but you’re right. Having Rhett bump into you is definitely the worst thing that can happen.
@@zipperblues6714 yeah, can’t have a white man doing anything good huh?
That man told her cats are better mothers than her bihhhhh I died😂😂😂😂
he was like begone thott lmao
Well he wasn't entirely wrong. Cats can be better mothers than most human mothers
That's really not fair Cats make great mother's. It's just people have to do it for longer. There kittens gain independence rather quickly.
@@mahnerahmakumbhaka5924 Yeah why’d he have to insult the kitties?
Now that was one spoiled daddy's girl! A chip off the old block!
The thing that's so frustrating is... Rhett never even gave her a chance to explain. What happened at the lumber mill with Ashley was platonic. She'd pretty much gotten over Ashley by this point.
I've always felt this way myself. Scarlett was innocent of this accusation initially spread by India Wilkes who hated Scarlett and also Mrs. Meade.
Hmm… in this scene, it seems like Rhett wanted an explanation, but was asking for it in another way. And Scarlett evaded the question.
I once met an old woman with Alzheimer's and she genuinely thought I was Clark gable.
That's a funny sad situation.
CatB Well my agent did tell me should play the man someday but whoever plays Vivian Leigh will be a laugh finding out.
Older people know and love that movie. It is played in nursing homes a lot.
Seems like you're doing fine.
Where is a full shot of you, Rhett.
How did a child so young as sweet Bonnie learn to act so well!
I was thinking the same
Scarlett never seemed form a bond with her daughter or even act as a mother role. It was always rhett that doted his daughter.
So true ! It's obvious Scarlett didn't have a strong maternal instinct.....
She loved Bonnie. But she wasn't a tender nurturing doting mother.
They have such a great father-daughter chemistry, like I really believe the relationship :')
They’re lovers, not father and daughter😭
He is very avuncular indeed, that’s what you mean.
@@abrahamzaidin8483 was referring to Rhett and Bonnie..
lol
He is handsome 😍
He's no Huntz Hall, but the late great Clark Gable was indeed one dashing fellow !
@@jubalcalif9100 ha ha ha ! Hunts Hall !!😂
@@starbuono825 Huntz Hall may have been a Bowery Boy, but he certainly had a way with the ladies ! So suave....so sophisticated....so debonair !! :-)
@@jubalcalif9100 It wasn't that he was suave , sophisticated and. debonair it was that he had 💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵 !!!!
He's raising scarlet😂🤣
Best movie ever made.
@Nenethegreat W YOU DIDN'T LIKE THE MOVIE?
You got that right
I can’t see here letters g,o,d,f,a,t,h,e,r
Meh
Rhett cared more about their daughter than Scarlett did. Rhett was the only one who had the balls to bring Scarlett back down to reality.
Well sad thar He wasn't around his real life daughter ,I wonder if He ever knew that He had a daughter ,sad that mother never told him the true so He lost time with his real daughter and his real daughter lost time with her real dad
@@katarzynamariamuszynska2811 Cammie King stated, "To have been held, and kissed, and put to bed by Clark Gable at the age of (almost 5) is one of life's cruel tricks. Having him hold me on his lap, I can remember his strong arms; I can remember a happy feeling like being with a Daddy. My Mother said that indeed he did act very much like a Daddy." Immediately following Cammie's comments, Judy Lewis, Clark's daughter, speaks sadly of Clark's being so DEAR with Cammie in these scenes and that IT IS PAINFUL TO SEE THIS knowing she never had these special interactions as little Cammie had. Cammie and Judy later attended the same Catholic Girls' School, Mary Mount High School as well as attended many of the GWTW Festivities together becoming friends, of course.
Louisa Jacqueline Holmes--th-cam.com/video/WYraMGcBOKQ/w-d-xo.html....Although this is a British biography, made by the BBC in 2003, it is pretty good, excepting the usual lapses in veracity. Robert Matzen makes an apparance to talk about Carole Lombard and a couple of workers at the 'Clark Gable Museum' in Cadiz, Ohio are on hand with a couple of stories/comments....The story is pretty much as you would except, but with a slight twist, especially in the comments that Judy Lewis makes....Maybe better than so many other of these pictorial biographies I would say...👑❤💋
Reba Brooks--It is my wish that any and everytime that LORETTA YOUNG saw or may have seen GWTW and especially THE LOVING SCENES BETWEEN LITTLE CAMMIE KING (BONNIE BLUE BUTLER) and CLARK GABLE (RHETT BUTLER--Bonnie's DADDY), that what soul she had left was deeply pierced at the thought and knowledge of her ROBBING both CLARK AND JUDY, of their rightful relationship with each other as Daddy/Daughter.
Hold on a minute, and I'll tell you the rest of the story of the thief, hypocrite and liar.
As far as Judy was concerned, Loretta Young only allowed Clark to see Judy ONCE when the baby was # 3 months old where he went to the rental home of Loretta's mother by previous arrangements and was able to ever hold this precious baby that night.
Loretta told Judy later (after Clark had been dead for app 6 years) after Judy forced the truth from her lying and hypocritical mother that Clark fell in love with Judy; that he could not keep his hands off the baby; that the worst mistake she ever made was not getting Clark to marry her.
She told Judy that Clark could always make her laugh. When he left that night he gave Loretta $400 and told Loretta to at least buy the baby a decent bed, as she had Judy sleeping in a dresser drawer.
Clark continued to call Loretta, but Loretta would not return Clark's messages and finally told him not to call her anymore. From that point forward, he was never able to have a part in his baby's life--never invited to any BD's, Christmas', etc. Clark had tried to get Loretta to start being seen in public together; however, nothing Clark could suggest, neither Loretta nor her Mother would agree to try or to do.
I have read both Judy's book, Uncommon Knowledge" where Judy also reveals that when she was app 15 years old, one afternoon when she got home from school, Clark was at her home standing in the foyer talking with Loretta. This was during the time that Clark and Loretta were filming their 2nd and last film, Key to the City" together.
Judy also revealed that during this visit, she had the feelings that Clark really cared about her; They went into the living room and after a few minutes, Judy realized Loretta had left the room. Judy was sitting on a couch whle Clark was sitting on another chair or couch in this room. She said Clark asked her if she would come sit beside him, and she did. Judy further stated that he asked her questions as any father would ask his daughter such as her favorite subjects in school, boyfriends, etc. They visited for what seemed like a couple of hours, and when he started to leave, he told her how much he had enjoyed this visit. She walked with him to the front door. He cupped her face with his hands, bent over and kissed her forehead and left. Judy stated that she never saw him again.
I guess Loretta was offering Clark a consolation prize when she sent him an invitation to Judy's wedding even though the invitation was declined. (Never would allow them to have a relationship from Judy's birth to Clark's death but yet sent him an invitation to her wedding.
No one but our Heavenly Father and Clark know how many times he thought of his baby throughout the baby's growing up years. It seems ironic that Clark's death date seems to be saying, Judy and Maria (Judy's baby and Clark's grandbaby) mattered more to him than anyone will ever know.
Loretta would always tell Judy she had been adopted, never telling her any differently until about 6 years after her Daddy's death when Judy forced the truth from her mother. App two weeks before Judy was married, she told her fiance that she couldn't marry him because she did not know who she was; what she was bringing to their wedding. He told Judy that everyone knew that Clark Gable was her father.
She still was afraid at this point to mention this subject to Loretta but later received counselling re; this (after Clark's death) and the counsellor suggested to Judy that she confront her mother re: this, and she did. When Judy flew home from NY about 6 years after Clark's death, she notes in her book that Loretta picked her up from the airpot and seemed to know why she was home at this particular time.
After getting to Loretta's home, Judy noticed that Loretta literally got sick on her stomach, went to the bathroom and threw up. Finally, Judy told her that she had to know if Clark was her father. Loretta first asked Judy if it would make her happy if he were. Judy responded to this answer that yes it would make her happy because from all that she had been told Clark was a wonderful person.
As far as Judy having already been told what a wonderful person Clark was, in the last interview with little Cammie King, who played "Rhett's" and Scarlett's little 4 year old daughter in GWTW, done 3 weeks before her death, the first question asked of her was "What was Clark Gable like?" Cammie's response was, "Only that he was like a WONDERFUL DADDY, that he was very solicitous and considerate of me, and this was affirmed by my Mother."
Loretta replied to this, 'Well, yes he is your father and mentioned some of the other things referenced above. Loretta wrote a book, "Forever Young" with instructions for it not to be published until after her death.
Before Loretta's death in August, 2000, she was watching a segment of Larry King Live where "Date Rape" was being discussed. An idea was formed in the witch's head. She told her daughter-in-law, Linda Lewis, Michael's wife, that this is what happened to her; that Clark Gable had date raped her after she told him no, even though she never revealed this in her book to be published after her death. Loretta was a well known "flirt" having carried on a relationship for 2 years with Spencer Tracy, his being married the entire time; however, according to Loretta they never had any sexual relationship during that time.
Loretta "claimed" she was a devout Catholic; however, after listening to Larry King Live, she knew if she said Clark had raped her, she would be absolved of any wrong doing of Judy's birth in November, 1935, and the entire blame would be placed on Clark. She had Linda not to mention this until after Judy's death---that way Judy would not be here to rebuttal anything and certainly not Clark as he had died in November, 1960.
The one important thing Loretta failed to realize or admit was that while she was more concerned about appearng squeaky clean before the Catholic Church, she apparently failed to realize or admit she needed to be more concerned about her decisions such as this one before our Heavenly Father.
When my husband and I would discuss this subject before his death, he would always say that while Loretta had Judy on this Earth, Clark would have his daughter for the Eternity.
clark gable is perfect 😍
Mam ten film już pewnie od 30 lat,muszę przyznać,że oglądając go po raz pierwszy,zrobił na mnie ogromne wrażenie.W mojej filmotece jest na pierwszym miejscu.Wspaniałe arcydzieło.
Rhett did it to himself. He married her knowing she loved another and what happened happened.
It wasn't entirely his fault. The reason he chose to pursue her anyway was because he saw something in her and knew she had the capacity to love him but simply hid her feelings. He was actually right because she was starting to love him and realize that Ashley was just infatuation. The tragedy was that her stubborness broke him so he never saw that he was right about her. When she finally loved him, he gave up. It was all just bad timing.
@@JoshuaCastillo6309I've never heard the movie described so quickly and accurately!
I've seen GWTW 3 times and struggle to give short descriptions of the plot, without writing 5 paragraph essays
😂😂😂😂
@@charlieputhstan lol. I thought it through for quite a while.
What a worthless nurse for leaving Bonnie alone in the dark like that and worse calling her cowardly. It’s true that children are afraid of the dark at a young age, they will get over it when they’re ready to sleep alone in the dark-whether too soon or later in life. She should’ve listened to Capt. Butler’s orders because Bonnie’s not her child to teach lessons like that. When she has her own children, she’ll teach them whatever she wants them to do. And who can blame Butler for discharging the nurse, too? She wasn’t worth it.
Indeed ! She was Rhett's employee and it was her duty to follow his orders, not to treat Bonnie as she saw fit !
But she was right! In the end she was a spoiled brat and died knowing no discipline. Rhett basically created Scarlet part 2.
Sad that Scarlett and Rhett were afraid to standby their feelings. They each were afraid of being in love.
The other two kids by her previous marriages were ignored. In Mitchell's novel Scarlett was detestable.
She had a lot of good in her character, too. She would not dump her sisters on relatives and also took on other dependants.
Yes, but the skill of Margaret Mitchell was that you were still rooting for her, every step of the way - Scarlett was self-centred, yet always made sure everyone was provided for, put her family and (yes) ex-slaves first, made everyone work hard but not as hard as she worked herself. Margaret Mitchell always said that in the antebellum world, the ideal of the Southern Belle died - the people who thrived after the war had “gumption”, not those who relied on family connections, grace and manners. Scarlett had gumption in spades, as did Rhett. The likes of Ashley and Melanie didn’t, that’s why they’re passively at the vicissitudes of fate; they wouldn’t have survived without Scarlett’s love, no matter how misplaced it was. Her flaw was her lack of self-awareness; her triumph of will you have to applaud.
@@sarahmillard6401 yes!
I’d like to think she would have treated them better after Rhett left her
Not necessarily. She never bonded with Wade because she was too busy trying to just stay alive on Tara immediately after the war. She never bonded with Ella either because she's trying to keep her family safe in the Reconstruction. But as Scarlett says to Rhett "What else could I have done?" She did what she had to do to save her home and care for her family. At one point in the novel Scarlett fantasises about how one day she will be be a good mother to Wade and "read to him and teach him his letters." Bonnie was the only baby she had the freedom to spend time with. I think under different circumstances she could have been a different mother.
This is my mother's favorite film
“Where’s Mother?” A devastating moment. Scarlett neglects her daughter horribly, especially compared to how Rhett dotes on her, yet Bonnie has no preferences. She loves both her parents equally, and is not happy when either of them is missing.
You know, and I think that I can speak for everyone, Cammie King brilliantly played the part of Bonnie. She was splendid. It was so sad to see her break her neck jumping the fence. Cammie only lived from 1935 to 1939, but she will be remembered forever.
She died in 2010
@@staticcharm3808🙄think @superfly3990 is confused 😂🙄
Cammie was born August 5, 1934 and died Sept 1, 2010.
omg...I want to watch this movie.
It's a classic. But it is quite a long film at almost 4 full hours.
@@thomasbaron5367 it can be watched as a series bc of the intermissions
@@thomasbaron5367 YES, BUT TO ME IT WENT FAST.
Scarlett smiled at Rhett when you came into the room...twice, actually. Why didn't he pick up on it ?!
He was getting increasingly frustrated and depressed towards her at this point. You'd be surprised how much your emotions can blind you to certain things. I don't blame him though.
Scarlett was loved by everyone 💕 but only Rhett confronted her when she was being insensible
really? She was loved by everyone? Have we seen the same movie or read the same book?
@@Scheherasad lol
Oh, Rhett!! :)
This reminds me of the relationship I had with my dad.😢
Me too
That cape is lit🔥
When she woke up with such a smile i was like "WHADA HECK"
Matheus Lacerda the smile was from last night's sexual advances. After Scarlett and Ashley were caught in one another's arms the whole town was talking and eventually Rhett found out. During a drunken argument Rhett admitted he always loved Scarlett and then made the most passionate love she ever felt. When she awoke in the morning she wanted it to last but Rhett, instead, tells her he is leaving for Charleston and taking bonnie with him. Feeling foolish she almost confessed her true love for him and seeing he didn't share the same feelings she is only left to believe he never really loved her at all. Never will she let him know her hearts yearning for him and never will she admit her pain as he leaves her. I'm sure you know this thought, just in case you don't I just had to explain...lol What a great love story this book is. I must have read it a million times and I'll read it a million more!
Is that how it is in the book? Because i think in the movie she only started to realize she loves him when Melanie died.
A.T.H No, it's that way in the book as well. The morning after the staircase scene Scarlett is elated by the information Rhett loves her, and begins planning how to wrap him around her finger, but part of her is thrilled because she cares. However, she doesn't officially realize her own love for Rhett until after Melly dies and there is no one for her to go to except him.
@Nenethegreat W Exactly, it's the real world, so there's ambiguity in the event.
@@sallyperdue3185 sounds more like scarcity than love
Scarlett got her world rocked.
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
Bonnie is so precious
Its interesting that he wanted to show the Tower of London for the "little princes" considering what happened to them
Bonnie looked so much like Scarlett 💗
I know right
Such a handsome man!
2:34 that shit wouldnt fly today. lol
Um... my dad gave me kisses on the lips. I agree that we should protect our children but....
@@LukeLovesRoseBut they are actors so they just forced a little girl to kiss an adult on the lips, that's absolutely not okay
@@colineb9390 Her parents are probably right there. They probably gave the filmmakers permission to let the superstar Clark Gable kiss their little girl on the lips as if he was literally her daddy
Boy: "What about meh?...."
Scarlet sings a little of musical hall song 'Ben Bolt'
"Oh but Rhett."
Fiddle de dee
I remember Bonnie having many nightmares.. then sadly breaking her neck... sadly sometimes these nightmares may be prophetic, like in Bonnie's case
Rhett said he would break Scarlett’s neck if she were a man. Whenever Rhett wishes harm, something happens to someone.
Best movie ever
Anybody else think Rhett was maybe secretly working for the Union?
Ashley who?
0:45 oh but she was surprised when he swept her up the stairs
Wishing both Mr Rhett and Miss Scarlette have a happy ending and living happily ever after and baby Bonnie Blue hadn’t falling dead from the horse .
I saa Rhett through the initial developments of the movie as a roguish man unable to settle. Yet, he did mature and in the end, was cleary right to be fed up with Scarlett.
Did he though? You can’t make someone love you and that’s what he tried to do
@@abandonallhope.1040 He tried to straighten Scarlet up, as to make her cease with her follies and bad habits. I wouldn't exactly see that as trying to make someone love you. Maybe in the beginning of the movie, but not in the end.
@@williampitt1537 but you can’t change someone’s nature and that’s what he tried to do. Don’t get me wrong, Scarlett’s a flawed individual but so is he. Both made mistakes in this relationship; he admitted to Scarlett in the book that he knew very well she loved Ashley and that he thought he could wait her out. Lots of guys apparently love the ending because of the way he left her but I think that misses the complexity of the relationship.
@@abandonallhope.1040 I get your point. I do admit I did not read the book therefore my point of view of the character is biased towards the movie. I don't know what ressembled the original character.
Lord knows I loved my father... but there's no one like Mom. 😚🤗❤🌹
Lol Bonnie's nanny was hardcore AF 😅😅😅
It’s so sad she dies. He really loved her
CLARK GABEL WAS
VERY CHARISMATIC MANN
❤️❤️❤️💛💛💛💚💚💚🤎🤎🤎💜💜💜🧡🧡🧡💙💙💙💙🩵🩵🩵🩵
Scarlett seems, at first, mighty love-hungover. She and Rhett are just never on the same page, though.
Kako oholost ,nepromisljenost i ponos mogu upropastiti jedan ceo zivot ....
Tako je.
Haha... To nije cijela poanta filma(ali pogotovo ne knjige)....
when lana del rey said "I am your little scarlett" i really felt that 🥲
I hated her. She was really toxic and used him. And at the end she realised she loved him but it was too late.
Beautiful couple...outside at least 😅
2:06 damn bro, chill.
Let's not deny Scarletts role in making him so angry and nuts
Clearly Scarlett loved what happened to them that night ❤😅
Is Bonnie child of Frank or Rhett? I have just finished the book
She's Rhett's daughter
Ooooh. She got some
Omg that poor little girl must have suffered so with old stank breath Clark Gable saying all those H words right in her face. Poor tyke.
I know! Her face at 2:37 gives you an indication on how bad it was. Evidently, his rotting teeth were never properly removed, but just cut off at the gumline so that the dentures would just cover them and fit in his mouth properly.
trinigyul
Bit rude?
trinigyul. Hes breath never smelled hater ...
OMG that comment made me laugh!
Yes. They did and it was a well known fact. He had very bad dentures. I can't even imagine what they were like in the 1930s.
My guess would be it’s not the greatest idea to remove a young child from their mother at a young age. It’s that motherly thing fathers rarely if ever possess that young children respond better to.
Amor ésta película los amo a ellos son tan creíbles que te atrapan en su montaña Rusa de amor pasión discusiones disculpas inmadurez comedia y eso es " Magia "
Classic movie 🇰🇿
My grandpa was sooo not alive back then
Then how old are you?
This movie was released in 1939.
Beatiful Daugther Bonnie....she's so cut.....but terribilless accident with his horse
I love movie
Clark Gable’s daughter recalled being jealous of Bonnie and he had to tell her when he did the scenes with Bonnie he was thinking of her.
Not true. They never met.
@@nukapukaJudy Lewis is Clark Gable's illegitimate daughter with Loretta Young.
Are you confusing Judy with Clark's children with his wives?
Clark and Loretta were not married; Clark was married to another woman at that time.
I also heard he had an affair with Joan Crawford for several years, but that could be speculation.
@@charlieputhstan No.
I think u r.
Judy never met Cłark.
Well, only once.
Someone explain to me why Scarlett got upset that he apoloziged. I never understood that part.
Abused Peanut Scarlett was offended. He basically said he only had sex with her the previous night because he was drunk
@@basketballisamazing2 No. She just didn't want to admit that she liked being taken in such a dominant manner. When he apologised he suggested (probably because he thought that what she wanted to hear, rather than the truth) he was only accidently dominant under the influence of alcohol. So she was disappointed that he wasn't really dominant as she desired.
In the book, before he ravishes her he drunkenly tells her he loves her. In the next morning, Scarlett is excited by this prospect; both by the possibility of her finally being able to tame him,but also because she subconsciously has grown to love him too even though she's unaware of it. "I'm as nervous as a bride," she thinks, "and about Rhett!"
Both of them were actually waiting for the other to admit they were in love with eachother, and this night was proof of that. But when Rhett says he's drunk, insinuating it was all just a random act that meant nothing, she's disappointed and hurt. If they had both been honest here, things would have turned out very differently.
She's been telling Rhett from day one that he was nothing to her! He should've not given a damn from the beginning and let her alone !!!
I think rhett only loved bonnie ❤️
"Sorry for raping, you but you made me do it, being so hot and all, saying no, struggling..."
right...
Emma Hipster that was the good ole days
...too bad his breath was so bad. Bonnie's face at 2:37 says it all,....phew!
Emma Hipster oh but Rhett...I enjoyed it.
who cares :)
I v always thought a good lashing with a buggy whip d benefit you immensely..
Did Rhett and Scarlett have more kids in the book?
شكد احب هذا الفلم
the older i gte the more happier I get that he left her, she used him so much omg
Has anyone actually listened to the words of the song she briefly sings at the beginning of this part? lol it's so fucked up
I thhink that was done intentionally.
renarga I know but the lyrics are just so warped, and I’d imagine if it isn’t an excerpt from a real song that there were plenty of songs like that back then
@@Tsumami__ it is a real song! Made in the 1800s. The song is called “Ben Bolt” the lyrics are, “oh she wept with delight when he gave her a smile, and trembled with fear when he frowned”.
Toda feliz Scarlett jejeje. Q hermosa era Vivien Leigh
Wait a second scarlett and Rhett had a baby wattttt
Hahaha ha the way she woke up 😁 and there is people who says He raped her.
Most women wish their husbands left them feeling that good and satisfied
Scarlett is an expletive deleted
I've said this same thing but in my tone it sounds like I'm saying "the f*** you want me to say?"
Y can’t men b gentlemen anymore 🙈😭😭😭😭😭oh rhett! Oh Rhett 😭😭😉where art thou Rhett 🤔☹️☹️☹️
Jasmine Love lmao!!
He told her off! After all, she is spoiled but it makes me upset that he wants to take the child
Or maybe she liked it, like in the movie 50 shades of Grey! Rhett was such a drag, he should have pushed her against the wall for a long time and loved her properly! She says she doesn't love him, and she just climbs up to kiss!?
Clark Gable despised English women. He didn't care for this movie or other "women's pictures". He didn't get along with Greer Garson in the movie Adventure either, hating Garson's mandatory tea time and insistence on canvas screens. Greer Garson said he was not a ladies's man and preferred the company of other men.
Interesting info... since Vivian Leigh was English I wonder how he felt about her.
Greer Garson was ladylike, calm and polite to the point of dizziness. She appreciated politeness and she was very communicative and extrovertial. Gable had that macho persona andnI believe he had some homosexual past he was ashamed of, so he projected that through toxic masculinity and manliness. I think Carole Lombard melted his worst traits a little bit, but her death made him worse than ever. Greer was the person you could talk with endlessly and in perfect English. She did not say anything offensive or ironic for anyone she ever worked with. I believe Walter Pigeon was similarly gentlemanlike and they were good friends.
MAGNIFICOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Why would Rhett say he'll pay anything to her in a divorce. Seems very out of character.
To be rid of her
Actually it was totally in character. He was paying her to give up Bonnie