Til I Hear You Sing Comparison (Ramin Karimloo vs Ben Lewis vs Norm Lewis) - Love Never Dies
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Disclaimer I did not film the content in this video I simply share it for the sake of theatre history
Featuring Ramin Karimloo and Norm Lewis in the London West End and Ben Lewis in Australia
#loveneverdies #thephantomoftheopera #phantomoftheopera #andrewlloydwebber #normlewis #raminkarimloo #benlewis #celindeSchoenmaker #sierraboggess #westend #broadway #musicaltheatre #phantom #musicaltheater #theater #theatre #musicofthenight #tilihearyousing #comparison
Everyone has their own talent. But I think Ben Lewis when he acted in the movie "LND" in 2012 opened the new version the best. From the costumes, vocals, gestures, and appearance, everything is wonderful. His image is perfect for an adult Phantom after 10 years. Like how calm he speaks and acts and with his deep "Baritone" voice. When Christine dies, the camera closes up on him shedding a lot of tears.✨
Ben Lewis isn’t a baritone the phantom at least in love never dies is very much written for a tenor
@@huntermiller8731You can look up his biography on websites and they all say he has a baritone voice. And when he was interviewed he said he had that voice. And tenor or baritone are both good as long as they have a good voice.
But his reaction when Christine died was flat
@@scotthamp384 That scene was actually one of my first introductions to Phantom. I saw Ramin's video of Till I Hear You Sing and I was blown away by his voice. I didn't realize it was not from Phantom (I had told an FB friend I loved the music from Phantom (took awhile to find the show, I realize) and she sent me the video. So I started looking for Phantom stuff on YT. When I saw the death scene, all I could say was "Oh, she died." Seriously. Both he and Anna O'byrne left me cold. Then I saw clips from RAH25. In seeing Ben in LND all I can remember are his pop-eyes. I have a bootleg of Ramin and Sierra in London and it's simply wonderful.
@@huntermiller8731 actually, he is a baritone
I like both Ramin Karimloo and Ben Lewis...Their performance styles are different, but they each bring something to the role that is unique and mesmerizing. I would happily watch either of them (but I must confess that Ramin is my favorite Phantom).
I’m use to the professional recording of Bens performance of Till I hear her sing, he even does well in this raw recording with the stage echo
Love Ben’s interpretation! 🎭
Ben Lewis beats everyone down, NON PAREIL!
End of arguments.
They're all good but OMG the range the Aussie pride of Ben has!!!
Aussie pride!!!
Sincerely, an American!
💕👏🏻🇦🇺🇺🇸
Taking nothing from the others, Ben Lewis is my favorite!
Ben Lewis as an amazing voice!
I love Romin's voice, but I think he moves too much on stage. But "de gustibus". I love that there are different interpreters, so.... more (slight different) Phantoms to enjoy :-)
looking at the stage size, ramin had a lot more to play with them bens and having to fill the stage as an actor is a hard thing to do but ramin does it with purpose
Norm was a miscast. Casting a bass-baritone in a pure tenor role going up to C5. You can hear him strain, it sounded as if it was hurting him
I disagree
bass-baritones can sing this role well easily, just not dramatic ones. Norm's voice has too much weight to sound good up there.
@@Mrs.Magix58 I thought the only bass baritone there is was Timothy Nolen
@@scotthamp384 after Timothy, there were three other bass baritones; Shuler Hensley, Norm Lewis, and Fred Johanson
@@FelizNAVIDad293 I've never heard of Shuler. But Fred Johanson? He doesn't sound like a bass baritone to me
Ramin will always be my favorite.
Ramin is the best🎉
I think Ramin's is good, coming from that it was filmed before the 25th, so his singing to who saw it in person was a preview of what was to come. Ben Lewis, phew his version is just so good with all the louds and the soft, as a well as the vibratos given to long belts and singing, just gives it so much more life. Now for Norm this is my first time hearing it, but i think its good, despite not being able to reach those higher octaves without some struggle I'm sure, but he pulled it off nicely and perfectly with his baritone range!
Agree, 100%
Always Ben 😍
RAMIN RAMIN RAMIN! ALWAYS RAMIN!!! NO COMPARISON IN ANY ROLE HE PLAYS!!! what a gift to this words!!! BRAVOOOOOOOOOO
Those are my best...Ramin in 1rst place,and Ben in2cond place...nobody more
Norm was a miscast; this is a tenor role. His bass baritone voice obviously struggled
Ben Lewis is the best phantom!! I love his voice so much ❤
Ramin is the most realistic and heartfelt
I have nothing against the other two they’re good in their own right but there’s just something about the way norm place the phantom I don’t care if it’s in Lebanon Verdes or if it’s in the Phantom of the opera just something about his performance you believe it you just believe it.
Ben all the way.
Ben Lewis is the best!
Ben lewis are the best
I’m not a Ramin stan but he definitely did it best. Norman was also good but he struggles claiming the notes.
Ben Lewis overacted the whole show especially with the anime eyes 👀.
I own a copy of the Australian proshot but actively watch bootlegs of Ramin and Luke’s versions
you can add luke mccall now❤
Ignoring ramin cracking on till I he’s is still the best
To be fair to him that is a really difficult note to hit
There is no nuance in Ramin’s voice. He just belts the song without any layers or complexity. Ben Lewis’ performance is simply exceptional, so multi faceted. Norm, bless him - it’s like listening to your Grandad singing.
I imagine Lon Chaney's Phantom singing with Lewis Norm's voice, cause that would be the correct age.
Actually he has the most nuanced voice of the three. The song was pretty much written for him. Ben is fine. Norm's voice is all wrong.
listen to the cast recording verison.
You cannot simply say Ben’s performance is multifaceted and Ramin’s isn’t then think you did something. What do you mean about Ben’s? That it’s layered? What other layers does one need in the song other than “Christine I miss you.”
(I sound really mocking about it but I’m genuine: What are the different “facets” making up Ben’s performance that makes it better than Ramin’s? They seem the same to me; just one simply sounds nicer to listen to)