What did you guys think of Outer Range Season 1? What are you theories and predictions for Season 2? Did Joy go back in time? How did Amy turn into Autumn?
Well if they didnt have a bunch of loose ends I wouldn't mind 1 season. But too much going on for there not to be a 2nd season. Hope we can go to the future and find clues to change it.
Dude your one-liner inserts are SPOT ON. “Cowboy-naps him”, “Angering CGI-animal-lovers everywhere”, “Rhett the Rat”, to name a few. Been waiting for this, even while watching the episodes, was thinking “can’t wait for Mid-Man’s take on all this shit”. Keep up the good work, you got a lotta fans!
The person I feel the most sorry for is Cecilia. She loses literarily everything. If it is possible to go back in time, run from Royal, Cici! Or better yet, let’s have Royal just know to not shoot the deer (because he can go back in time you know and like a video game, come back to try again) and thus not shoot his dad. But then I guess there wouldn’t be a story or maybe the story is that, after all is said and done , time can be tweaked (but only by Royal and Autumn/Amy)?
Loved the show and these recaps. Amy turning into Autumn made my heart sad, I was hoping it was Royal's long-lost sister who broke down due to time travel.
You’ve got a great eye to catch all this stuff. Fantastic theories which I think are likely going to be right in some capacity. This is certainly a show where the details have been placed intentionally. Can’t wait to see how it pans out in a few days!
I found out about the show a little late and I was able to binge all episodes in a couple of days. Considering the pacing of the show, I think that may be better than watching it over 4 weeks. I really enjoyed it and hope for a sesaon 2 but will wait to binge all episodes of that too.
I dont think Autumn( older Amy)... is from the future. I think she and Rebecca escaped to the past! She grew up in the past, these last 20ish years.....with a memory gap of the fact she went back (bipolar has already confirmed physiological issues). Coming back to the farm is awakening memories and the future that Royal saw with her as a cult leader is still to come. If she was from the future, she would have at least had some idea about forming the cult if Royal's time travel was only +- 2 years from now. the time gap is too small for her to be from the future with this little direction / plan. Her little rock may have given her glimpses but thats all.
One quick thing I will mention because I just finished the series myself, is that Royal's speech to Ceci is NOT the same as in the opening. It is ALMOST identical, but for one(maybe two) words. He says "buckshot" in the opening and "bullet" in the speech to his wife. Two different versions meaning that there are two different variations already?
Well done. I really doubt Perry's dead. I think he will show up exactly 4 days later in a random spot on the land like Trevor did. This will correspond with him needing to be back for his bail hearing in four days and he may or not make it in time. If there is a season 2 i hope it opens with Karl the county assessor and the land dispute hearing that was supposed to take place. That loose end bugged me.
I think Perry was there in Royal’s vision of the future with BY9 in control….the shot was quick so I could be wrong. Wayne and Luke were there too but not Billy.
I took the sign as a more subtle "Jesus Saves" type religious ad. Also I like how you say buffalo or bison getting ahead of the "well actually" crowd who would no doubt attempt to correct you (they still might).
Been wondering if Royal's relation to the void is different from anyone else. After all, when he falls through that hole in the first episode everybody seems to have been expecting him: His wife, Rhett, Perry, Luke, Wayne, Sheriff Joy and Autumn. Question is why? Is Royal causing major issues by jumping in and out of the time stream? Is that why Celia tells him to run? When Autumn recites the myth of Chronos did she hear that from Royal originally? If so, did she recite it to jog his memory? BY9, Beta Upsilon and the number nine which could represent a completion of a life cycle after which the sequence reverts to zero, as indicated by the numbers on the clocks on the other side of the void. Questions, questions......great commentary, btw.
They were expecting him and wasn't there even a clock counting down to the event? The only way they would have known was if Autumn told them when it would be. Seems like she could have even written it down and thrown it into the hole.
I think he does. Cecilia told him to run because she knew that they were there to arrest or kill him for killing Billy. Luke immediately started shooting at him. Autumn must have known when he'd appear because she knows when she pushed him in. I want more void info in season 2. But maybe it's better if we don't understand it. I'm torn
@@themiddleman781 in his time why was he not arrested for it??????? he lived past that i dont think he gets done for that maybe self defence its obvious its because thats what is ment to happen to keep FATE in tact she knew he jumped bac k in because it was past him luke shoots him because he got away with it
i hope s02 is explaining the time shit, it was nice but so vage. awesome series tho and great explanation! You've got my subscription for sure!! keep up the ggod work!
I'd really like to hear opinions on Amy's quick exit. It's like her mom knew just when she wanted to get her away from there so was that because she knew Autumn would be going to Royal's house? It seems there are more people in on this time thing than we realize.
I was waiting for your final video and ended up being late watching it. Thanks for your recaps/theories…. And all the laughs. I think I saw Perry in Royal’s vision of the future, but not Rhett… I was hoping I’d see Billy too, and somehow he’d survive, but he wasn’t there….Wayne and Luke were. I think Amy knew to get up and leave at the last rodeo the same way Ceci knew she was gone… may be related to Luke digging and opening up the portal again. I didn’t think Rebecca left because of Perry until the last episode when the show made a point about showing Perry’s uncontrollable rage from childhood. Royal accidentally killed his dad but Perry would go on deadly rages and get out acting all normal again. I loved the show and think it answered more questions than people giving it credit for….looking forward to season 2.
Thanks! It was definitely Rhett in the future. No Perry. But that doesn't mean he's dead. Could be a ton of twists with time travel being out there. A Perry or a Royal or anyone can come from any other part of the timeline and be born again...
I really love your reviews/breakdowns. Very informative yet extremely entertaining. I’m still laughing at the break to the old time whistling!! Lol! Anyway I would’ve liked some explanation of the void that wasn’t so ambiguous but that’s how they rope jokers like us in. Amazon will renew this one. They’re fine with money. Netflix is the service we have to be concerned with. One and done will become much more frequent over there. You should check out Shining Girls over on Apple +. Seems to be right up your alley. Btw, if you check out Kronos in Greek Mythology it says he came to power after killing his father(and castrating him) and stuff about swallowing his children. Could Royal be Kronos
Interesting theory, I can see Royal as Kronos… I can’t make up my mind if he’s good or bad…probably both, he said God is all good and all bad. I’m wondering about Amy/Autumn…it seems like she manipulated Perry to jump so she can get the land.
@@mattyboyb523 interesting, I didn’t connect the bison to evil warnings necessarily, but more of an ethereal messenger connected to the portal…only royal and Amy could see the bison. I got the feeling it was connected to Royal recognizing Amy…he started to shift and examined her face before he found the scar
Thank you for the recap. I was kind of falling asleep in episode seven and eight, and I wasn’t sure what happened where or how Joy ended up in the past.
Yeah watch him be the dude that gets sucked back in though cause the county needs him to help wrangle bison perhaps(?) and wondering wtf happened to Perry and his younger niece. imagine if Maria ever sees Rhett and Autumn after seeing her behavior at the bank with Billy? Wouldn't want to be Sheriff Joy either with all this mess and the death of Billy added to the mix of weirdness goings on Mastodons aside.
"And the dumba** jumps in" lmaoo Great review! My leading theory is multiple versions/dimensions because of the subtle differences throughout season 1.
@@rdel9926 I'll do The Boys season 3. And I've been watching The Shining Girls, so I may do a video on that. Westworld could be cool to cover. I try to do stuff other channels aren't really covering but those can be hard to find. So open to suggestions
@@themiddleman781 I plan to watch the shinning girls. I’m watching under the banner of heaven on Hulu…. It’s got an incredible cast (Andrew Garfield, Sam Worthington, Wyatt Russell, Daisy Edgar Jones)…and intellectual mix of theology and murder mystery…. No one else is covering it.
I thought I was going to be so clever and talk about great grandmothers and grandmothers and mothers and then right at the end your little throwaway line blue all of my theories that Amy autumn is Royal's mother and his granddaughter and there's some kind of bank robbery going on with royal and Amy's mom
Billy also said to Royal don't le something bad to your granddaughter or something like that After he made him apologize and not killing him after After seeing this video I wounder if he knew something or if it was just to intimidated
The void has taken them exactly where they need to be and then when they jump back in it brings them back to when they left pretty much. Seems to be the longer you've been gone the longer you have been gone in present so joy in season 2 was gone 4 years but real life 4 days
I know I'm late to this conversation, but I'm hoping I can get some feedback here. I find that Autumn and Billy's characters seem to be expressed as though seen through a childs perspective. Maybe both of them are children of the past (obviously Amy is one of the children) who are seeing the events play out through a childs eye view. Maybe they or just Autumn are imagining this whole story and we are seeing through their eyes?
I waited a long time for your review, and I was not disappointed. I thought there might be a better Eddie Murphy reference like, "When Billy start singing, the Bison stop charging" in reference to Mr. Murphy's quote about the Bus Boys (band) from his Delirious stand-up which you are definitely familiar with. But seriously your analysis is always dead on. You're too good. However, we need it for these low budget sci-mystery shows. Your content complements the show itself and is often well researched and hilarious. BTW. I don't mind the bad CGI, 'cause, when these shows are too expensive, they never last more than one season. It's about the crazy people with this show, and its very interesting. What to watch/review next? What about the second season of Invasion?
Cici has been jumping. When royal comes back from the future when cici tells him to run she runs first and he follows her they both disappear and royal comes back i feel like cici went somewhere else but when royal comes in the house after getting back from the future taking the bullet cici only says which Brother shot you. She heard the gun just was in front of royal and didn't see. She got up from the table bc in another choice timeline he might have died from the shot but she's jumped to change it
I actually really loved Baby Billy and his songs 😂 I hope they can time jump him back to life for s2! He's a wild card for sure. Now knowing that Autumn is Amy, it makes me think that she harbored a crush on Billy from age 9 to whenever she got back and found him, and all their WEIRD make out scenes were like... Idk just more funny. 😂 They are both a trip, can't wait for next season.
That was a theory I talked about in the video. Another commenter said it could stand for: Blue Yellow 9. Since her painting had the colors blue and yellow and she was 9 when she lost her memory
@@themiddleman781 Yes I remember you talking about that. Blue Yellow is probably a better guess. I'm still wondering where her mother is getting the money but we'll just have to wait and see.
Ok so amy got pushed to the future right which means in 15 to 20 years she'll be back at the ranch. Which also means, Amy with her cult that standing there when royal first came thru and saw the army, had either traveled again back to there or restored the property. But her whole cult would of had eaten the goo and I'm sure not all would of went to the same place even if your asking it to send you to a certain time it sends you where you need to be
I think 7&8 lost the feel that the first 6 had started to establish. Was hoping this show would be the American Western version of DARK. Fully thought out. But it feels more like Lost with an ungrounded story. I hope I'm wrong. But the 'artistic' film moments dont make it easier to get through (the singing, the making out, the bison hole).
I totally get it. I did like the singing and making out...it was so cringy in a good way. I'm hoping they know where they're going. I'll give it another season
@@themiddleman781 The singing had its place, the make-out just took me so out of the show with the Vaseline lens. It felt like TrueBlood's worst moments or something. Despite my frustration with the last 2 eps, I will tune in for s2 with some excitement.
You may me more right than you know with the "Lost" hypothesis as Outer Range ended with a Mama Cass song another of hers which became iconic with the start of Lost season 2 when the Oceanic survivors blew the top of the hatch staring down...a dark void. 😉 Would be cool as well if there was an easter egg appearance of Desmond...."See you in anotha life brotha!" or even the Swan symbol sign swimming around in the void.
I’m concerned we aren’t going to see a second season of this show…unfortunately I think there are a a lot of people that tune out as soon as thinking and paying attention are required hence why sitcoms are a thing.
@@themiddleman781 my knee jurk reaction is that something changed in time at some point In the last 2 eps and it's actually no longer called Abbott ranch/never was.but maybe just different fence as the one with the a was shown directly next too the tillisens but not here.
I would be perfectly fine with this show having only one season despite the loose threads. I hate how shows have a tendency to outstay their welcome in pursuit of the mighty dollar. That being said I still would like a season 2 because the ending was very unsatisfactory 😅
@@themiddleman781 For sure as long as the writers don't lose sight of the actual point of the story as in Breaking Bad VS Game of thrones. Where one comes full circle and the other goes to Hell in an effort to please the fans.😉
Went back and watched for the 2nd time and listened to your breakdowns afterwards. Nice to have some different points of view on the 2nd go around. Very interesting show to myself as well. I enjoy the ones that get the brain turning. I thought of the hole as a black hole due to the title opening scene where it looks like a black hole swallowing matter. Thoughts are black holes having an effect on time sorta like Interstellar. I agree and think the show gives no hints that the time loop can be broken. Everything played right into what Royal sees in the future. 2nd season would definitely have to show that autumn changes due to some sort of clarity or Royal finds a way to change how things end up. Hoping for 2nd season.
Dude, constructive chriticism here: Love your reviews, you have a great eye for details and i know you are passionate about the videos and shows you review as i have seen you commenting on other channels such as think story. But man i could do without (and im putting this lightly) the repetitive jokes, the most anoying one in this series of videos being "time is a flat circle". Just a thought from a viewer. On the other hand, love LOVE your one liners, very smart and edgy
Episodes 5&6 were making me think it was no longer worth watching, but I gotta admit they really pulled it out in 7&8. The gun fight, chase!!! Autumn and Billy kissing, looks like two people who read about kissing, but have never actually seen kissing. I think Perry is alive and Rhett isn't leaving town. Autumn probably orchestrated Rebecca's disappearance/reappearance. I've never taken the position that the Abbotts and Tillersons were particularly different in honesty or humanity. (two sides of the same coin) Both families are fracturing under pressure like a rock in a vice. Hate Cecilia for needless killing the CGI bear, just get in the truck and drive bitch!
I can't stand autumn. The actress makes me not want to watch this interesting show. She plays a very unlikable psychotic. An approach to a more likable crazy ass character would have made this show #1 for myself. With that said, From and severance tie and take the #1 spot.
I can see that. I kinda liked her, but I can see how she could rub people the wrong way (except for Billy). Check The Shining Girls on AppleTV or The Offer on Paramount Plus
I think she knew he was her grandfather…and she liked him at the beginning…but Royal tried to kill her and burned her tent…AND she couldn’t take her meds anymore…she really went bonkers without her meds.
All you did was the list the scenes chronologically -- This stupid confusing mess of a show CANNOT be "Explained" because it was a nonsensical disaster and I"m PISSED that I wasted 8 hours on it.
My issue with the show is they don't show the motivation of autumn enough to make me know if she's an antagonist or protagonist. I don't care about Rhetts story. It's the typical small town guy trying to make it big which has been done to death already. Perry can just stay in that whole for all I care, royals wife is just annoying and her whole crisis of faith isn't compelling. Autumn trying to kill royal came out of no where. And I only care about royal because it's Josh Brolin. The only interesting thing about the show is time travel but without knowing how it works its just a maguffin at this point.
@@themiddleman781 you are very diplomatic. :) the level of convolution and contrivance in this story leaves Damon lindelof in the dust. True Detective this surely is not.
@@themiddleman781 none of the characters behave naturally or reasonably. Everything they do is aggravating and facepalming. Things just happen to create strange atmosphere. ...And Amy doesn't look anything like Autumn so the last episode is incredibly painful to watch.
![20 Things You Didn't Know About Outer Range [2024]](/img/n.gif)
What did you guys think of Outer Range Season 1? What are you theories and predictions for Season 2? Did Joy go back in time? How did Amy turn into Autumn?
Well if they didnt have a bunch of loose ends I wouldn't mind 1 season. But too much going on for there not to be a 2nd season. Hope we can go to the future and find clues to change it.
I really like the show. I hope they make a 2nd season 🤞🏽
jesus perry
I loved the season, I also thought it was interesting how Frank had a pet raven, like Odin..
th-cam.com/video/45CuH-QZ1i4/w-d-xo.html
“She’ll explain it all in season 2” 🤣🤣🤣 I just love your sense of humor
Thanks!!
Yesss He is sooo f funnyy! Love it
“Her name may be Autumn, but she had Billy rising like a spring flower” lol 😂
Hehe :)
Dude your one-liner inserts are SPOT ON. “Cowboy-naps him”, “Angering CGI-animal-lovers everywhere”, “Rhett the Rat”, to name a few. Been waiting for this, even while watching the episodes, was thinking “can’t wait for Mid-Man’s take on all this shit”. Keep up the good work, you got a lotta fans!
Thanks! That's really cool of you to say. I always wonder if people catch all of them :)
Truth… one of my favorites was “ and the dumb ass jumped in” lol … that’s exactly what I thought…Jesus Perry…!!!
"Jesus Perry" lol. And yeah it took effort to look past the dodgy animal cgi.
And Autumn gets to experience Astroworld :))
The person I feel the most sorry for is Cecilia. She loses literarily everything. If it is possible to go back in time, run from Royal, Cici! Or better yet, let’s have Royal just know to not shoot the deer (because he can go back in time you know and like a video game, come back to try again) and thus not shoot his dad. But then I guess there wouldn’t be a story or maybe the story is that, after all is said and done , time can be tweaked (but only by Royal and Autumn/Amy)?
Totally agree! And interesting theories!
Loved the show and these recaps. Amy turning into Autumn made my heart sad, I was hoping it was Royal's long-lost sister who broke down due to time travel.
Thanks! Yeah, me too, but the Autum n is Amy clues where there all along. Hopefully the disguise the twists better next season
You’ve got a great eye to catch all this stuff. Fantastic theories which I think are likely going to be right in some capacity. This is certainly a show where the details have been placed intentionally. Can’t wait to see how it pans out in a few days!
I found out about the show a little late and I was able to binge all episodes in a couple of days. Considering the pacing of the show, I think that may be better than watching it over 4 weeks. I really enjoyed it and hope for a sesaon 2 but will wait to binge all episodes of that too.
The bison wash the land. Royal is in control.
You have a career in comedy waiting for you. Kudos Middle Man!
Thanks!!
I dont think Autumn( older Amy)... is from the future. I think she and Rebecca escaped to the past!
She grew up in the past, these last 20ish years.....with a memory gap of the fact she went back (bipolar has already confirmed physiological issues). Coming back to the farm is awakening memories and the future that Royal saw with her as a cult leader is still to come.
If she was from the future, she would have at least had some idea about forming the cult if Royal's time travel was only +- 2 years from now. the time gap is too small for her to be from the future with this little direction / plan. Her little rock may have given her glimpses but thats all.
One quick thing I will mention because I just finished the series myself, is that Royal's speech to Ceci is NOT the same as in the opening. It is ALMOST identical, but for one(maybe two) words. He says "buckshot" in the opening and "bullet" in the speech to his wife. Two different versions meaning that there are two different variations already?
Good catch. Could definitely point to variations in the timeline and that things could potentially be changed
I thought that was wierd too. He said buckshot like a shotgun first and then totally said bullet later.
I fuckin swear the truck that Wayne drives is one of the coyotes trucks from No Country For Old Men when Llewellyn goes back to give the yote water
Well done. I really doubt Perry's dead. I think he will show up exactly 4 days later in a random spot on the land like Trevor did. This will correspond with him needing to be back for his bail hearing in four days and he may or not make it in time. If there is a season 2 i hope it opens with Karl the county assessor and the land dispute hearing that was supposed to take place. That loose end bugged me.
Yeah, I couldnt tell what was up with Perry. He and the Assessor could be both dead or alive or neither, lol.
I think Perry was there in Royal’s vision of the future with BY9 in control….the shot was quick so I could be wrong. Wayne and Luke were there too but not Billy.
@@FarnazWallace I think i saw Perry too.
@@themiddleman781 Yeah everything was a tad higgly piggly
Lol
Great video as always!🤩🤩
Thanks Trip!
I took the sign as a more subtle "Jesus Saves" type religious ad.
Also I like how you say buffalo or bison getting ahead of the "well actually" crowd who would no doubt attempt to correct you (they still might).
“Oh, a lesson in not changing history from Mr. I'm-My-Own-Grandpa!”
Lol
Been wondering if Royal's relation to the void is different from anyone else. After all, when he falls through that hole in the first episode everybody seems to have been expecting him: His wife, Rhett, Perry, Luke, Wayne, Sheriff Joy and Autumn. Question is why? Is Royal causing major issues by jumping in and out of the time stream? Is that why Celia tells him to run? When Autumn recites the myth of Chronos did she hear that from Royal originally? If so, did she recite it to jog his memory? BY9, Beta Upsilon and the number nine which could represent a completion of a life cycle after which the sequence reverts to zero, as indicated by the numbers on the clocks on the other side of the void. Questions, questions......great commentary, btw.
They were expecting him and wasn't there even a clock counting down to the event? The only way they would have known was if Autumn told them when it would be. Seems like she could have even written it down and thrown it into the hole.
I think he does. Cecilia told him to run because she knew that they were there to arrest or kill him for killing Billy. Luke immediately started shooting at him. Autumn must have known when he'd appear because she knows when she pushed him in. I want more void info in season 2. But maybe it's better if we don't understand it. I'm torn
@@themiddleman781 in his time why was he not arrested for it??????? he lived past that i dont think he gets done for that maybe self defence its obvious its because thats what is ment to happen to keep FATE in tact she knew he jumped bac k in because it was past him
luke shoots him because he got away with it
Thank you for the awesome reviews and theories
Thanks so much!
i hope s02 is explaining the time shit, it was nice but so vage. awesome series tho and great explanation! You've got my subscription for sure!! keep up the ggod work!
I'd really like to hear opinions on Amy's quick exit. It's like her mom knew just when she wanted to get her away from there so was that because she knew Autumn would be going to Royal's house? It seems there are more people in on this time thing than we realize.
Yeah. I wondered if Autumn told her on the phone or something. Seemed weird to just get up and leave
Your intro sold me. Consider me SUBSCRIBED!
Thank you!
I was waiting for your final video and ended up being late watching it. Thanks for your recaps/theories…. And all the laughs. I think I saw Perry in Royal’s vision of the future, but not Rhett… I was hoping I’d see Billy too, and somehow he’d survive, but he wasn’t there….Wayne and Luke were. I think Amy knew to get up and leave at the last rodeo the same way Ceci knew she was gone… may be related to Luke digging and opening up the portal again. I didn’t think Rebecca left because of Perry until the last episode when the show made a point about showing Perry’s uncontrollable rage from childhood. Royal accidentally killed his dad but Perry would go on deadly rages and get out acting all normal again. I loved the show and think it answered more questions than people giving it credit for….looking forward to season 2.
Thanks! It was definitely Rhett in the future. No Perry. But that doesn't mean he's dead. Could be a ton of twists with time travel being out there. A Perry or a Royal or anyone can come from any other part of the timeline and be born again...
@@themiddleman781 ahh thanks for clarifying that … they kinda look alike…good casting. What are your thoughts about Perry’s rage as a child and adult?
Great analysis! Thank you!
Thanks so much!
I really love your reviews/breakdowns. Very informative yet extremely entertaining. I’m still laughing at the break to the old time whistling!! Lol! Anyway I would’ve liked some explanation of the void that wasn’t so ambiguous but that’s how they rope jokers like us in. Amazon will renew this one. They’re fine with money. Netflix is the service we have to be concerned with. One and done will become much more frequent over there. You should check out Shining Girls over on Apple +. Seems to be right up your alley. Btw, if you check out Kronos in Greek Mythology it says he came to power after killing his father(and castrating him) and stuff about swallowing his children. Could Royal be Kronos
Thanks! Totally agree. Would love to know more about the void. I've been watching Shining Girls. Big fan. I'll probably do some videos on it.
Interesting theory, I can see Royal as Kronos… I can’t make up my mind if he’s good or bad…probably both, he said God is all good and all bad. I’m wondering about Amy/Autumn…it seems like she manipulated Perry to jump so she can get the land.
@@FarnazWallace
I agree. Amy may be evil. Btw, that Bison seemed to show up when evil was at hand. I’m thinking Royal is bad
@@mattyboyb523 interesting, I didn’t connect the bison to evil warnings necessarily, but more of an ethereal messenger connected to the portal…only royal and Amy could see the bison. I got the feeling it was connected to Royal recognizing Amy…he started to shift and examined her face before he found the scar
Thank you for the recap. I was kind of falling asleep in episode seven and eight, and I wasn’t sure what happened where or how Joy ended up in the past.
Yeah..she just kind of walked there...lol
Thanks for posting vid. I’d like a season 2 too but not sure there are enough weirdos like me who enjoyed the show lol
I hope there are enough weirdos like US :)
Who WOULDN'T enjoy this show? I need to question these people at a roller rink.
Season 2 is coming but not til 2024 prolly
Calling it now-- Perry goes back in time and founds the Tillerson or Abbot family and settles on the land.
Could happen!
I was thinking that 2. He may jus go back to 1886
Welp, Rhett is the smartest member of the family. I would get the hell out too.😂
Yup!
Yeah watch him be the dude that gets sucked back in though cause the county needs him to help wrangle bison perhaps(?) and wondering wtf happened to Perry and his younger niece. imagine if Maria ever sees Rhett and Autumn after seeing her behavior at the bank with Billy? Wouldn't want to be Sheriff Joy either with all this mess and the death of Billy added to the mix of weirdness goings on Mastodons aside.
"And the dumba** jumps in" lmaoo
Great review! My leading theory is multiple versions/dimensions because of the subtle differences throughout season 1.
Hehe. .ooh. I like that theory a lot
What is with the WEIRD KISSING!?!?
Her mom was calling her Amy...
Thanks for the content
Thanks! Glad you like it.
Been excited for this video thanks!
Thanks!!
@@themiddleman781 what are the next shows you are covering? I am hoping Stranger things season 4 and West World season 4
@@rdel9926 I'll do The Boys season 3. And I've been watching The Shining Girls, so I may do a video on that. Westworld could be cool to cover. I try to do stuff other channels aren't really covering but those can be hard to find. So open to suggestions
@@themiddleman781 sounds good I forgot about the boys excited for that and havent heard of The Shining Girls will have to check that out
@@themiddleman781 I plan to watch the shinning girls. I’m watching under the banner of heaven on Hulu…. It’s got an incredible cast (Andrew Garfield, Sam Worthington, Wyatt Russell, Daisy Edgar Jones)…and intellectual mix of theology and murder mystery…. No one else is covering it.
I thought I was going to be so clever and talk about great grandmothers and grandmothers and mothers and then right at the end your little throwaway line blue all of my theories that Amy autumn is Royal's mother and his granddaughter and there's some kind of bank robbery going on with royal and Amy's mom
Lol. It's all possible!
Billy also said to Royal don't le something bad to your granddaughter or something like that
After he made him apologize and not killing him after
After seeing this video I wounder if he knew something or if it was just to intimidated
I hope reveals per minute is going to rise in the season 2 :(
Don't want the show to be Lost-like
For sure!
The void has taken them exactly where they need to be and then when they jump back in it brings them back to when they left pretty much. Seems to be the longer you've been gone the longer you have been gone in present so joy in season 2 was gone 4 years but real life 4 days
I know I'm late to this conversation, but I'm hoping I can get some feedback here. I find that Autumn and Billy's characters seem to be expressed as though seen through a childs perspective. Maybe both of them are children of the past (obviously Amy is one of the children) who are seeing the events play out through a childs eye view. Maybe they or just Autumn are imagining this whole story and we are seeing through their eyes?
I waited a long time for your review, and I was not disappointed. I thought there might be a better Eddie Murphy reference like, "When Billy start singing, the Bison stop charging" in reference to Mr. Murphy's quote about the Bus Boys (band) from his Delirious stand-up which you are definitely familiar with. But seriously your analysis is always dead on. You're too good. However, we need it for these low budget sci-mystery shows. Your content complements the show itself and is often well researched and hilarious. BTW. I don't mind the bad CGI, 'cause, when these shows are too expensive, they never last more than one season. It's about the crazy people with this show, and its very interesting. What to watch/review next? What about the second season of Invasion?
Thanks!! I havent watched Invasion. I'm thinking about do some videos on The Shining Girls on AppleTV. Open to other suggestions too
@@themiddleman781 Shining girls it is.
It's really good
Oh and if you haven’t checked out Shining Girls on Apple TV you should check it out!
Been watching. It's great! I'll probably do a video or 2 on it
“Lil Wayne”😂😂😂😂
Hehe
Cici has been jumping. When royal comes back from the future when cici tells him to run she runs first and he follows her they both disappear and royal comes back i feel like cici went somewhere else but when royal comes in the house after getting back from the future taking the bullet cici only says which Brother shot you. She heard the gun just was in front of royal and didn't see. She got up from the table bc in another choice timeline he might have died from the shot but she's jumped to change it
I actually really loved Baby Billy and his songs 😂 I hope they can time jump him back to life for s2! He's a wild card for sure.
Now knowing that Autumn is Amy, it makes me think that she harbored a crush on Billy from age 9 to whenever she got back and found him, and all their WEIRD make out scenes were like... Idk just more funny. 😂 They are both a trip, can't wait for next season.
Totally was a crush. She didn't know why, she just liked him. I liked Billy too. Good attitude towards life
Billy was the most interesting character… hope he comes back.
@@FarnazWallace Billy and Sheriff Joy were my two favourites. I hope both come back.
Man i feel life billy is Wayne from the past to keep him alive
Red and Yellow will kill a fellow.
Them showing billy bow hunting i how he jumps back in time to when they had wooden arrows and he's the one that put them arrows in that bison
The hot ones are always psychotic
Yup
BY9 = Before Year 9 ? Could Autumn or her mother be the owners of the mining company?
That was a theory I talked about in the video. Another commenter said it could stand for: Blue Yellow 9. Since her painting had the colors blue and yellow and she was 9 when she lost her memory
@@themiddleman781 Yes I remember you talking about that. Blue Yellow is probably a better guess. I'm still wondering where her mother is getting the money but we'll just have to wait and see.
I do think it has something to do with the company or knowing the future
Ok so amy got pushed to the future right which means in 15 to 20 years she'll be back at the ranch. Which also means, Amy with her cult that standing there when royal first came thru and saw the army, had either traveled again back to there or restored the property. But her whole cult would of had eaten the goo and I'm sure not all would of went to the same place even if your asking it to send you to a certain time it sends you where you need to be
I think 7&8 lost the feel that the first 6 had started to establish. Was hoping this show would be the American Western version of DARK. Fully thought out. But it feels more like Lost with an ungrounded story. I hope I'm wrong. But the 'artistic' film moments dont make it easier to get through (the singing, the making out, the bison hole).
I totally get it. I did like the singing and making out...it was so cringy in a good way. I'm hoping they know where they're going. I'll give it another season
@@themiddleman781 The singing had its place, the make-out just took me so out of the show with the Vaseline lens. It felt like TrueBlood's worst moments or something. Despite my frustration with the last 2 eps, I will tune in for s2 with some excitement.
@@themiddleman781 Also love you videos fwiw. As a fellow middle, I see you :)
Yeah, once I just looked at it as intentionally cheesey I liked it more. But did feel off a bit from the show's tone
You may me more right than you know with the "Lost" hypothesis as Outer Range ended with a Mama Cass song another of hers which became iconic with the start of Lost season 2 when the Oceanic survivors blew the top of the hatch staring down...a dark void. 😉 Would be cool as well if there was an easter egg appearance of Desmond...."See you in anotha life brotha!" or even the Swan symbol sign swimming around in the void.
I’m concerned we aren’t going to see a second season of this show…unfortunately I think there are a a lot of people that tune out as soon as thinking and paying attention are required hence why sitcoms are a thing.
I hope you're wrong, but what you're saying is right :/
💯
Time travel aint for the simple minded
S2 confirmed
I would jump forward figure out how i die and jump back
I swear i was thinking wonder if their sons of cronos
🤣🤣🤣 I am behind in the videos, my friend. This show had us lost all over the place! What’s up? What else are we watching?
The Shining Girls on AppleTV
Billy 😢
Now who’s gonna spontaneously sing in season 2 !!!!!!😂
If there is a season two they'd have said so by now. Some of the stars may not want to come back
Sometimes they wait to announce it. I'm hoping they do
I want so much for Tom pelphrey character to reappear and the time line change to Trevor being alive. Oh well, we'll see.
They announced a s2
i definitely noticed the A missing from the gate.it must mean something.
Right? What's up with that?
@@themiddleman781 my knee jurk reaction is that something changed in time at some point In the last 2 eps and it's actually no longer called Abbott ranch/never was.but maybe just different fence as the one with the a was shown directly next too the tillisens but not here.
I would be perfectly fine with this show having only one season despite the loose threads. I hate how shows have a tendency to outstay their welcome in pursuit of the mighty dollar. That being said I still would like a season 2 because the ending was very unsatisfactory 😅
Yeah. Very true. I'm good with a 4 or 5 season show with a thought out arc tho
@@themiddleman781 For sure as long as the writers don't lose sight of the actual point of the story as in Breaking Bad VS Game of thrones. Where one comes full circle and the other goes to Hell in an effort to please the fans.😉
@@themiddleman781 like raised by wolves has a plan put in place already. But most shows if not all are going in with only the current season in mind
… or at least a 2 hour movie to conclude the story
I didn't like it that Billy died.
Me either
Same
get to experience astro-world 😂👏
Hehe
Astro world! I lost it
Hehe
Her mom probably called her amy
I wonder if it's really Rebecca calling amy the rebecca that let aytumn take amy
Why does Autumm/Amy hate Royal so much? Any theories?
She didn't hate him at first. She started hating him after he tried to kill her on the ATV and then burned her tent
@@themiddleman781 you are right, thanks
@The Middle Man you content sounds exactly like @Think Story.
Who's that?
Another content creator on TH-cam, same vibe as your videos.
@@themiddleman781 lol 😂
Royal shot the buck Billy and not the doe Autumn
Went back and watched for the 2nd time and listened to your breakdowns afterwards. Nice to have some different points of view on the 2nd go around. Very interesting show to myself as well. I enjoy the ones that get the brain turning.
I thought of the hole as a black hole due to the title opening scene where it looks like a black hole swallowing matter. Thoughts are black holes having an effect on time sorta like Interstellar. I agree and think the show gives no hints that the time loop can be broken. Everything played right into what Royal sees in the future. 2nd season would definitely have to show that autumn changes due to some sort of clarity or Royal finds a way to change how things end up. Hoping for 2nd season.
Whatever is going on it has to be a thing that the shosone know about or know what it is just don't know it's come back
Dude, constructive chriticism here: Love your reviews, you have a great eye for details and i know you are passionate about the videos and shows you review as i have seen you commenting on other channels such as think story. But man i could do without (and im putting this lightly) the repetitive jokes, the most anoying one in this series of videos being "time is a flat circle". Just a thought from a viewer. On the other hand, love LOVE your one liners, very smart and edgy
Appreciate the feedback and the love. Will definitely keep it in mind. Thanks for watching!
Episodes 5&6 were making me think it was no longer worth watching, but I gotta admit they really pulled it out in 7&8. The gun fight, chase!!!
Autumn and Billy kissing, looks like two people who read about kissing, but have never actually seen kissing.
I think Perry is alive and Rhett isn't leaving town. Autumn probably orchestrated Rebecca's disappearance/reappearance.
I've never taken the position that the Abbotts and Tillersons were particularly different in honesty or humanity. (two sides of the same coin)
Both families are fracturing under pressure like a rock in a vice.
Hate Cecilia for needless killing the CGI bear, just get in the truck and drive bitch!
I can't stand autumn. The actress makes me not want to watch this interesting show. She plays a very unlikable psychotic. An approach to a more likable crazy ass character would have made this show #1 for myself. With that said, From and severance tie and take the #1 spot.
I can see that. I kinda liked her, but I can see how she could rub people the wrong way (except for Billy). Check The Shining Girls on AppleTV or The Offer on Paramount Plus
Why would granddaughter try and kill grandfather?
If granddaughter didnt know she was granddaughter and thought the guy was trying to kill her..
@@themiddleman781 if she travels back in time how would she not know
I think she knew he was her grandfather…and she liked him at the beginning…but Royal tried to kill her and burned her tent…AND she couldn’t take her meds anymore…she really went bonkers without her meds.
Gawd I hate Perry. Hated him in Ozark too.
All you did was the list the scenes chronologically -- This stupid confusing mess of a show CANNOT be "Explained" because it was a nonsensical disaster and I"m PISSED that I wasted 8 hours on it.
I like to think I added some opinions and jokes in there...lol. I can see why people didnt like the show
How's rodeo still a big thing 😄
In Wyoming, it is still a big deal.
It's huge. I was in Las Vegas when they had a big rodeo tournament and it was like the super bowl for cowboys
Astro world lmao
Hehe
Haha. AstroWorld.
So Billy's a groomer?
My issue with the show is they don't show the motivation of autumn enough to make me know if she's an antagonist or protagonist. I don't care about Rhetts story. It's the typical small town guy trying to make it big which has been done to death already. Perry can just stay in that whole for all I care, royals wife is just annoying and her whole crisis of faith isn't compelling. Autumn trying to kill royal came out of no where. And I only care about royal because it's Josh Brolin. The only interesting thing about the show is time travel but without knowing how it works its just a maguffin at this point.
Agree with all those points.
I missed the last two episodes. It was so bad, prime took it off, PRONTO.
Prime took it off your list? I enjoyed it, but I'm not that picky. Lol
This show is so bad. Thanks for summarizing it and making me laugh as i was reminded that it was actually as bad as I remember it.
It was definitely uneven
@@themiddleman781 you are very diplomatic. :) the level of convolution and contrivance in this story leaves Damon lindelof in the dust. True Detective this surely is not.
@@bradojacko8247 I'm easily entertained...have to be to watch all the shows I do
@@themiddleman781 none of the characters behave naturally or reasonably. Everything they do is aggravating and facepalming. Things just happen to create strange atmosphere.
...And Amy doesn't look anything like Autumn so the last episode is incredibly painful to watch.
There's a timeless void in the guy's field...lol