What led to the fall of CPI(M) in West Bengal ? - Book review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- Sourjya Bhowmick, a journalist with the TV9 Network in Calcutta in an interview with TV9 Digital talks about his book ‘Gangster State’. He talks about what led to the fall of CPI(M) in West Bengal and says that it is time for it to introspect.
#CPM #CPI(M) #GangsterState
..............................................................................................
NEWS9 is widely known to be the undisputed leader and most trusted source of news and information in Karnataka. Today, NEWS9 is the fastest-growing digital news platform in India. NEWS9 brings you thought-provoking stories from across the Globe on topics ranging from Politics, Finance, Entertainment & Sports to latest trends on Social media, Lifestyle, Tech and Wellness.
► Watch us on TH-cam : / news9live
► Like us on Facebook : / news9live
► Follow us on Instagram : / news9live
► Follow us on Twitter : / news9tweets
#NEWS9 #NEWS9live #NEWS9india #NEWS9bengaluru #breakingnews
#topnews #livenews #bignews #NEWS9karnataka #latestnews #latesttrends #news
Gangster/ Hooliganism words are more apt for present TMC regime rather than Left.
cpim were no different
TMC is the updated and worst version of CPIM
@@dwaipayanbandyopadhyay6110 But, in CPIM's time Education System was one of the best in India and CPIM under Budhhadeb Bhattacharjee's rule really brought Industries like TATA, built New Town like smart city, created IT industry in Salt Lake.
@@c.augustedupin8860 Was Operation Barga hoolinganry? Was land reform hooliganry? Was giving basic food and water hooliganry? Was ending the oppression of peasant by zamindar hooliganry? Was ending the murder of young students by INC (Siddhartha Shankar Ray) hooliganry? Was making education truly available for the masses hooliganry? Was creating the Panchayats and giving the poor a voice hooliganry? Was ending casteism, and ending the power of the jotdar class, preventing the rise of a Bengali "Yadav" community like Bihar, hooliganry? WAS ALL THIS HOOLIGANRY?
If it is, then my friend, teach me what isn't hooliganry. Is it what TMC does nowadays? Rule through terror, without any benefits for the common people. I believe in your eyes, that isn't hooliganry, isn't it?
@@dwaipayanbandyopadhyay6110 CPM did great things for Bengal as I mentioned above. No other party managed to do such complete land reforms. Even the so-called glorious Gujarat Model sees poisonous agricultural intermediaries like the Patidars, who were TOTALLY eliminated by the CPM!
When CPM was is power there was GOVT vs CRIMINALS ....
But now its not GOVT VS CRIMINALS,because now CRIMINALS ARE GIVEN POSITIONS IN GOVT ......
Left❤ CPIM is again raising today... I was a bjp supporter but bjp backstabbing us by making setting with ruling TMC... That's why anti TMC voters are again back to CPIM again.... Today tagline must be "the raise and fall of BJP in West Bengal"
cpm=0 , BJP is the only hope, people like you were never BJP supporters , CPM supporters are joke. In today's world Communist ideology is a joke. BJP is a national Party wherase CPM is a local party. Please do not say u ever supported BJP. CPM suppoters are athiest & have no ideological link with BJP.
Exactly
abar kemon lagche left are sharing bed with islamists
Intresting i am a Branch secratary of cpim in kerala its happy to know rise of red flag red salute
I was a BJP supporter before. But, after seeing them imposing Hindi on Indians I understand if BJP rule in Bengal then Hindi will literally take over Bengali in Bengal.
CPI(M) MEANS PEACE & BROTHER HOOD AND ALSO TRANSPARENCY OF GOVERNMENT ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ PLZZ DO NOT MISS GUIDE PEOPLE ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🙏❤🙏
Please you don't misguide people and upcoming generation by your comment😊. Thank you
@@arnabbiswas3671😂😂😂Chaddi spotted
Left was best , should be back again, now the rulling party in WB called tmc , ruin the bengal
I know TMC BJP are bad kintu CPM dhowa tulsi pata noy. CPM er onek dosh aache. 34yrs er modhye singur nandigram korlei hoye jeto? Baki 22 bochor jyoti basu ki Baal chireche?😊
TMC empire should be finish as soon as possible
Otherwise all honest people will suffer for the last time of their govt rule.
@@infamousfreak5914 TMC aar thakbenaa. Sob limit cross koreche.
Dada even I will vote for CPM...but if the party ever comes back in power...we have to do it differently...how come it sustained in Kerala but not in WB...we cannot overlook the last decades of atrocities by CPM though.
@@nisthabhattacharya4854 Agreed. Evil has happened under CPM rule too, and we cannot ignore that. They too forgot the poor, the majority, when they tried to peddle the cause of the urban middle class in their attempts of industrialisation without inclusion of the people. They formed fenced Special Economic Zones instead of developing industry tha actually helps the people. We cannot overlook that...
What we truly need is a change from the grassroots, people themselves working for each other. We need a movement that can work for the common good, without government support, and without the bureaucracy of age old parties interfering. We can only hope, that we can rise to the occassion, and as brothers and sisters work for each other 🙂
Left rule was a blessing in comparison to today's right wing vagabonds
Yes it's far better than the TMC govt. Led by Mamata Banerjee
Right wing Vagabond is way way better than leftist Jihadi.
Right wing better than TMC goonda
Tell the author to review the current condition of West Bengal...if that period can be classified as "Gangster State" then he should also give his "precious" remarks about today's condition in Bengal...
Nobody can defy his misdeeds in respect of others.
Mamta is just following the infamous path of cpim shit.
@@koushikmukherjee9465 Congress did the same at 71s election. You don't exactly know that. Rigging and hooliganism was introduced by Congress. And even the height of Left rule there were many pockets in West Bengal were ruled by opposition. Just like South Kolkata, Nadia, Many blocks of Purulia, Malda, Murshidabad were predominantly Congress from the beginning.
@@Saswata_97 EXACTLY
@drshuvamghosh2employment in Bengal???
Joke of the century😂
CPIM is a political party led by honest leaders and to become a party member it is mandatory to contribute levy. That is the fundamental difference from other political parties. Because of this I support this party from the core of my heart.
What about anil biswas and his inevitable techniques of taking bribe sir?
@@xackumoonOP Complain to the present administration and they will give you proper reply . They have the probe machinery and you have the concrete evidence ready in your hand. The result will come out at once. Then people will accept your challenge graciously. Do it immediately.😂😂😂
No not at all......they destroyed WB
CPM destroyed Bengal
And these gangsters are destroying kerala now
God help west bengal of communists come back to power once again!!
After say God and pray for CPM back really
For god CPM TMC both are destroying Bengal I pray to Maa durga both never ever come back in Bengal in fact I wanted both party are finished in Bengal
Na it's going to be BJP. We want Rohingyas out of Bengal.
लेफ्ट फ्रंट उभरकर आंयेगा,क्योंकि जनता धिरे धिरे समझ रही है!
वामपंथ के लिए सत्ता मोह महत्वपूर्ण नही! मार्क्सवाद लेनिनधारा यह जनता की विचारधारा लढना महत्वपूर्ण है! लेफ्ट फ्रंट उभरकर आना ही है,जनता धीरे धीरे समझ रही है!
Wonderful book ....
What utter BS...when someone relate backwardness of Kolkata with socialist ideology ( and that mamata's hollow no-long-term freebie politics which rarely have any coherent position on Labour Codes ,Farming ,Taxation, Foreign Policy Industry , for/against Privatisation, is Socialist Politics) , and that too supposedly after having long association with a Communist Party, u gotta say : this writer has very little idea about Socialism.
socialism causes misery ,death and destruction and ruins...that's the legacy cpim left behind in bengal
Left will come back we leftist promise ✊
Left is gangster
@@vonstauffenburg4641 just like modi and mamta
Day dreaming is Good , Currently CPM=0 , HOW MUCH CAN U IMPROVE?? Communism in today's time is a joke.
@@joysen83 more than mamata will improve from telling lies
Wait a second! Are you a voter/18+?
Great Interview
Kintu Nandigram e to buddho babur order e guli chalano hoeni 😌
❤️✊🚩
TMC is an updated version of CPIM.
Exactly true all this points..
CPM IS NOW PAST, some CPM suporters may day dreaming for there return.
Come to kerala baby Boi we will show u what real communism is!
@@lofilofi831 that is the reason 1 male member of each family in kerala depends on gulf job to feed his or her family. No jobs in kerela 😀😀 long live communisme 😂😂
@@joysen83 😂😂see your terrible bengal 😂 first
@@sharad7340 See your most isis recruiting state first.
@@somalichakraborty484 😂😂 lol my state tamil nadu always progressed with highest rate
Even kerela too sadly cpim rules in kerela too which need to be wiped by udf in next elections cpim fall is best thing happened in history
ভয় কি লাল রঙে?
আমাদের প্রিয় রঙ লাল!
nongra rong lal tai aar na
@@diyamishra7755
Lal rong dekhe kichu lok hoy,
Bhoy joro shoro,
Kochi kacha rao bujhi,
Eder chey boro?
Ekdom lal asbei❤
😂😂😂😂😂 BJP laughing standing in corner
@@arnabbiswas3671 বিজেপি হাসছে, কি বিজেপির ওপর বাকিরা হাসছে?
माकप जनता के संघर्षों मे सबसे आगे है! सिटों में कम आना मतलब माकप फॉल ऑफ नहीं होता!गलत निष्कर्ष! लेफ्ट को उभरकर आना ही है!
No doubt tmc is on the same process but in a more worst way than cpim.
Left will come ..
never
Communism is ❤️❤️Coming
@@diyamishra7755 Soon.
@@MBasu-km8by Diba swapna dek Refugee
@@diyamishra7755 Ei tolabaaj er baccha khotta, refugee kake bolchis re?
Among young generation be it west Bengal or any part of India may be except Kerala communism is untouchable and laughable.
Left will come one day or another ❤✊
1) No justice has been delivered on the Marijhanpi case in 1977, when thousands of refugee women were brutally raped, murdered and thrown away on the sea by harmads.
2) Remember Bantala, 1990? When Anita Dewan was raped, torch inserted in her private parts by CPM goons, and the Chief Minister Jyoti Basu said, ‘these things happen’.
3) In 1989, Cooch Behar at Fulbari on one single day, 10 Adivasis were raped by CPM harmads and yet no justice to them.
4) The CPM harmads entered Basanti Sonakhali and raped housewives. (1992)
5) Felani Basak, raped and murdered by CPM goons at Nadia in 1992, and no justice to her.
6) At Uday Narayanpur, Howrah, six housewives were raped by CPM goons in 1996. No justice has been delivered.
7) On the infamous Dhantala incident, males in the bus were tired up and CPM goons raped the females in front of them in 2003. And yes, no justice on this too.
8) Has justice being delivered to the brave martyr of Singur, Tapasi Malik, who was raped and murdered in 2006 at the TATA Nano complex, just because she fought for the right for her land?
9) Women who were inhumanly raped by the CPM harmads at Nandigram in 2007 still await justice.
Numerous commissions, not an iota of evidence. 😂😂😂
U better focus on present....where is justice for tilottwoma ?
We want cpim back
excatly the book i was looking for . would like to go deep into the details of the massacres and vengence in the rule like saibari bijon setu morichjhapi
Fake news..
@@arnabkumarghosh4279 it's not fake news
Can you say how many bullets were fired in Morichjhapi ?
@@kartickbiswas5584 no, but i do know that 9000 people are killed in morijhapi and further 1000 was displaced because of cpim atrocities.
@@c.augustedupin8860 Is there any official proof in your hand? A deep rooted conspiracy was hatched up at that time to uproot the newly installed government in west bengal. Not a single person was injured by bullet fired by police. If you have any proof in this regard you can produce it in public domain.
no CPM again West Bengal
@dead Achala bush ready ache tor jonnyo
CPM is the only hope in West Bengal.
@@MBasu-km8by Comment section somoy noshto korish na. Tor baap k bol tok kaaj dite
Even the signboard of cpm has been sold. ha ha ha.
Brain child of RSS
I strongily believe that after some years kerala left will also see this interview....
Not only keral left.If there is no strong opposition party in democracy ,The futre of any rulling party is like this
Left in CPIM will not break lol
@@sayantabanerjee3856
Yeah right
The popular front will devour cpm from inside
The rest will go to bjp
Dream on.
I suggest instead for you all to be ready for CPM to return in West Bengal, by 2036!
@@MBasu-km8by 2026**
Hegèmony ? This guy is really pedestrian and has nò idea of what he is blabbering some people think that speaking ìn English that is drenched in Bengali will pass their hohwash to intellectual observations. No you would have been çomprensible,if the interview had beeñ held in Bengali .Now you know whÿ left batted for education throùgh mother tongue .
Jai BJP
Left front is absolutely good alternative for people! CPIM will arise Finix bird!