Having seen him twice live, i have to say it goes beyond critics. Yes, sometimes he's mumbling, yes, sometimes you struggle to recognize his own songs by the way he's changing the rythm and the tone, yes, sometimes it seems that his voice is gonna break or he sounds false. But hell, there's something in the air with this dude and his musicians, that makes you feel, deep inside your heart and mind, that you're just facing a whole piece of America's history and music in one guy, filled with poetry, death, war, love, sins and blessing, and it makes you feel sad and happy in a somehow pure and perfect balance.
I've also seen him twice on stage, and I absolutely agree with everything you said ! I remember the last (and 2d) time I saw him live, in 2012, he was already mumbling his songs, and this for quite a while, and sometimes I was like " Wow Mr no, pleaase don't trash this one!", but finally, I resolved myself and let it all go, and found myself absolutely stunned by what was happening there below (I was much farer this time than 1st time), wich was Bob Dylan "saying" his songs.. when the show was over, I also felt a subjugated crowd feeling aproximately the same ..
Wish I could agree. I took my son to see him about 20+ years ago and he couldn’t sing worth a damn then. He should be ashamed for taking peoples ticket money.
Bobby,love your voice and style from youth until now❤️ Thank you for adding so much enjoyment in our lives...and your songs that were there at exactly the right times in our lives...we love you😊❤️
I saw Mr. Dylan for the first time on March 18, 2024 and again five days later. Had he sung this, I would have died on the spot. My favorite song by my favorite artist. Thank you, Bob Dylan, for our 60 years of music. ♥️♥️♥️
@@BobDylan-091. Ha! I wish I were addressing the real Mr. Tambourine Man! I’d tell him I broke 19 years of quarantine, drove 90 miles, put on a mask and made a lifelong dream come true. I didn’t care if I got a virus and died; my dream came true. Five days later, I drove 7 hours one way to see him again. It was worth the risk. I hope to see him again. Bob Dylan’s music kept me alive during my horrendous teenage years and has sustained me through dark times since. I wonder if he has any idea what he has meant for some people. ❤
I don't see any reason to hate on one of America's greatest musical treasures. I have seen Mr. Zimmerman countless times and, regardless of whether he is singing great, he pours his heart out and shares so many countless tunes that have been such a blessing and big part of our lives. With all the craziness in this world of ours, thank goodness we still have such a great artist going out on the road to entertain us. God Bless the one and only Mr. Robert Zimmerman!
Well to all the naysayers, I saw this Outlaw Music Festival when he stopped by Boise in August. He was amazing. The musicians are top notch. He's got JIM FREAKIN' KELTNER on drums. I would have DIED hearing this song played in the setlist we heard.
@@dixiefallas7799 would you love to have a meet and greet session with myself and the band, you deserve some recognition and some VIP area treatment... you're special!
I'm sure there are deeper cuts that some believer claim the title of greatest Acid Rock songs, but the Hendrix version of this this tune is one of my very fave. The lyrics blow me away. And this version is lots of fun too. Love the loping guitar strumming
@@BobDylan-091 grazie mille io amo le sue canzoni da sempre le so a memoria su di Lei ho un libro che si intitolata " Bob Dylan poeta profeta musicista e mito" Per me è un immenso piacere che mi ha risposto si avvera un sogno avere un contatto con Lei. Le auguro tutto il bene possibile. Grazie
Wow listen to Bobby - amazing vocal - it is as if he has found the fountain of youth - the picture of Dorian Gray - he is getting younger while we all age - he is truly blessed by GOD and we are truly blessed to have Bobby in our lives!
I love the way he plays every song different every time. Otherwise you’d get bellends there who like 1 or 2 songs and think they own him. The fact he does random songs most people have never heard of keeps them away from his gigs
Dylan's and Henrick's LP vinyl records are there for those who choose to go back to the origins. Fifty plus years later, the song endures with all its shape shifting or perhaps because of it and thus become relevant to a new generation. If Jimi were still alive, doubt seriously he would be playing an exact copy of what he originally recorded and relelased. RIP Jimi, you left us too soon.
Have seen Bob Dylan live 40 or so times, dating back to 1975 on the Rolling Thunder Revue (Nov 09; Durham NH), and he sounds great here ~ nothing like what I've been reading from so-called experts on music.
I 've seen Bob 40 Years ago... in Rotterdam, Unforgettable with Santana... When later he 'lost his voice I did not like to see him live... But I would go there Now (if he was in Holland, last time?) ... Bit it can't be No accident He starts with 'All Along the Watchtower! Masterpiece in Praag & Berlin ... In these Days where Planet Blue($) can Explode any Minute.... Still...
I made the mistake not going to Antwerp to see him this time. I thought the setlist was not for me but how was I to know he would play All along the Watchtower. Bob knew and knows Megiddo is warming up. This song has such tremendous power and prophecy under its hood.
He has this in common with Paul Simon. They don't just do carbon copies of the recorded versions of tracks. These are their songs, and they'll sing them how they like, and if you don't like it, put on a CD. Dylan is astonishing. You wonder if he was around today whether he would be able to succeed. All I know is that, like @papaniels35 says, he ain't gonna win any prizes for his voice, and all the other things you can say about him, but here he is, still doing something that transcends all of that.
Here’s Dylan Spillin and thrillin without the need to be drillin For penicillin after all Here’s the Bard playing his card over the yard Without gettin barred It must be The Fall 😎
Well i was strumming along to that (it's a straightforward set of chords, isn't it,) and seems to me it was in the same key as the original on John Wesley Harding, i only mention this because a lot of musicians change the key of a song to suit their ageing vocal chords but a guess with a voice like Bob's that just isn't an issue.🙂Saw him perform back in the early 80's with Santana and British band Lindesfarne. He must have been enjoying himself cos he did an encore, with Santana and Lindesfarne as i remember, bit of a hazy memory for some reason...🤩
Hmmmm. You're obviously not acquainted with much of his work. His imagery, wordpower and use of metaphor and other literary skills have influenced countless other great and influential writers such as Bruce Springsteen etc. Treat yourself and listen to his myriad other work. Imho I believe that much of it is indeed brilliant - certainly worthy of such an award.
![ลองสุ่มไอโฟน 990 โกงมั้ย? [ โกงมั้ยครับ ep.101 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bfsWe0j492k/mqdefault.jpg)
Having seen him twice live, i have to say it goes beyond critics. Yes, sometimes he's mumbling, yes, sometimes you struggle to recognize his own songs by the way he's changing the rythm and the tone, yes, sometimes it seems that his voice is gonna break or he sounds false. But hell, there's something in the air with this dude and his musicians, that makes you feel, deep inside your heart and mind, that you're just facing a whole piece of America's history and music in one guy, filled with poetry, death, war, love, sins and blessing, and it makes you feel sad and happy in a somehow pure and perfect balance.
I've also seen him twice on stage, and I absolutely agree with everything you said ! I remember the last (and 2d) time I saw him live, in 2012, he was already mumbling his songs, and this for quite a while, and sometimes I was like " Wow Mr no, pleaase don't trash this one!", but finally, I resolved myself and let it all go, and found myself absolutely stunned by what was happening there below (I was much farer this time than 1st time), wich was Bob Dylan "saying" his songs.. when the show was over, I also felt a subjugated crowd feeling aproximately the same ..
I saw him 20 years ago and I didn't recognise any song. It all sounded like gregorian chant to me.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Danke für den Song Danke für ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Danke für den tollen Song ❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂
Wish I could agree. I took my son to see him about 20+ years ago and he couldn’t sing worth a damn then. He should be ashamed for taking peoples ticket money.
Best thing about this song . He has lived long enough to sing it at this age. God Bless you Bob. Sounds like a lifetime
You're so sweet, thank you for still loving me❤
Bob is 83 and one of the most phenomenal songwriters of all time❤
Pozdrawiam Cię,Robercie,z Polski!🤓👏💯🎩🇵🇱
Beautiful Bob, I’m so honoured to have been able to see Bob live. The most loved man ever ❤
Thank you my sweet friend, I'm glad I still give you the spark you desire❤
Bobby,love your voice and style from youth until now❤️ Thank you for adding so much enjoyment in our lives...and your songs that were there at exactly the right times in our lives...we love you😊❤️
I love you also Mary, for been a strong fan from the inception of my career, I wish I could hug you right now!❤
I saw Mr. Dylan for the first time on March 18, 2024 and again five days later. Had he sung this, I would have died on the spot. My favorite song by my favorite artist. Thank you, Bob Dylan, for our 60 years of music. ♥️♥️♥️
I'm so honoured, you're such a sweet soul.
@@BobDylan-091. Ha! I wish I were addressing the real Mr. Tambourine Man! I’d tell him I broke 19 years of quarantine, drove 90 miles, put on a mask and made a lifelong dream come true. I didn’t care if I got a virus and died; my dream came true. Five days later, I drove 7 hours one way to see him again. It was worth the risk. I hope to see him again.
Bob Dylan’s music kept me alive during my horrendous teenage years and has sustained me through dark times since. I wonder if he has any idea what he has meant for some people. ❤
Saw him 21 Times. Always enjoyed it.
22 since Nürnberg
My favorite creator of music . Ever
I don't see any reason to hate on one of America's greatest musical treasures. I have seen Mr. Zimmerman countless times and, regardless of whether he is singing great, he pours his heart out and shares so many countless tunes that have been such a blessing and big part of our lives. With all the craziness in this world of ours, thank goodness we still have such a great artist going out on the road to entertain us. God Bless the one and only Mr. Robert Zimmerman!
He is name is Bob Dylan by the way, he changed his name a long time ago.
Your words are so kind❤
@@ehabitation9213I am Bob Dylan Zimmerman.... Zimmerman is my Jewish name... ❤
Those who don’t know brilliance can remain ignorant. So much love and respect to Bob Dylan
the man is a legend for all the right reasons
Well to all the naysayers, I saw this Outlaw Music Festival when he stopped by Boise in August. He was amazing. The musicians are top notch. He's got JIM FREAKIN' KELTNER on drums. I would have DIED hearing this song played in the setlist we heard.
Jim Keltner is a fantastic drummer!!!
this song changed my life.
I'm glad I make you feel this way, this is the kindest regards I've seen here so far... you're amazing❤
Simply the greatest. There will never be another. Hail Dylan
Going to see Bob 8th November Nottingham UK what a legend he is🏴🇬🇧😊
ENJOY!
@@bernielamont825 Thank you I will 🏴🇬🇧
Good on you 👍
I hope to see you there❤
@@dixiefallas7799 would you love to have a meet and greet session with myself and the band, you deserve some recognition and some VIP area treatment... you're special!
Loved this. Great to see him bopping along and on the keys.
a great piece , jimi hendrix and douzens others release, thank you so much Bob for your creation , greetings!
I'm honoured❤
Long live Bob Dylan 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
Prettiest man God ever made❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I'm sure there are deeper cuts that some believer claim the title of greatest Acid Rock songs, but the Hendrix version of this this tune is one of my very fave. The lyrics blow me away. And this version is lots of fun too. Love the loping guitar strumming
It's Bob Dylan. His voice is gone, but he's still Bob Dylan, and I 💙 him. 🎶
The only true living monument of music.
Greetings
Bravissimo come sempre ❤❤❤
I'm honoured, you're amazing❤
@@BobDylan-091 grazie mille io amo le sue canzoni da sempre le so a memoria su di Lei ho un libro che si intitolata " Bob Dylan poeta profeta musicista e mito" Per me è un immenso piacere che mi ha risposto si avvera un sogno avere un contatto con Lei. Le auguro tutto il bene possibile. Grazie
I would go see Dylan every year if possible
You're an amazing fan, I hope to meet with you some day, if that okay by you❤
@@BobDylan-091 Stop. Dylan would never use that syntax. And he most certainly wouldn't use little hearts after everything lol.
Seen him every time he comes thru & im Not hospitalized -keep rolllin man
Thank you Patricia, I'd always keep coming thru till I kick the bucket😂
Thanks love this 🎵 🎶
Wow listen to Bobby - amazing vocal - it is as if he has found the fountain of youth - the picture of Dorian Gray - he is getting younger while we all age - he is truly blessed by GOD and we are truly blessed to have Bobby in our lives!
Thank you
❤❤❤❤❤❤ danke für deine Musik von Anbeginn haben Sie sehr gerne und lange gehört😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤
Everybody wants to be like Bob when they Grow Up😊
Is this a metaphor? 😂
As a younger fan, I feel honored to be alive at the same time as Bob Dylan❤
Komm runter ...Robert ist ein guter Musiker unter falschem Namen, nix weiter.
@@DeD00RS Why do you randomly start speaking in that language to me?
Those with ears will HEAR 🎉🎉🎉
Yes.
most ppl know not that Bob Dylan wrote this, thxs for sharing...
I love the way he plays every song different every time. Otherwise you’d get bellends there who like 1 or 2 songs and think they own him. The fact he does random songs most people have never heard of keeps them away from his gigs
The best song ever.
I live in Batavia New York and thanks for sharing this because I did not get to attend I thought this was amazing
I believe there 'd be other time for you to come and share the floor with me❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Danke für den tollen Song 😂😂😂😂😂❤❤
Thank you for the sweet love❤
Huge huge Dylan fan here, not seeing him live in concert for over 11 years (wow, that long ago?) Never thought I'd get to see him again. THANKS!
Dylan's and Henrick's LP vinyl records are there for those who choose to go back to the origins. Fifty plus years later, the song endures with all its shape shifting or perhaps because of it and thus become relevant to a new generation. If Jimi were still alive, doubt seriously he would be playing an exact copy of what he originally recorded and relelased. RIP Jimi, you left us too soon.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Danke nochmal für. Diesen tollen Song ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤
I like his music more now than I ever did when he was young much more feeling in his voice
Is this truly how you feel, this made me melt down, even after seeing many critics, yours is amazing...❤
Have seen Bob Dylan live 40 or so times, dating back to 1975 on the Rolling Thunder Revue (Nov 09; Durham NH), and he sounds great here ~ nothing like what I've been reading from so-called experts on music.
the small venue helps.
I 've seen Bob 40 Years ago... in Rotterdam, Unforgettable with Santana... When later he 'lost his voice I did not like to see him live... But I would go there Now (if he was in Holland, last time?) ... Bit it can't be No accident He starts with 'All Along the Watchtower! Masterpiece in Praag & Berlin ... In these Days where Planet Blue($) can Explode any Minute.... Still...
I made the mistake not going to Antwerp to see him this time. I thought the setlist was not for me but how was I to know he would play All along the Watchtower. Bob knew and knows Megiddo is warming up. This song has such tremendous power and prophecy under its hood.
What a fantastic band.
Bob congratulations 👋🙋♂️👍🙏
Go Bob, go!
Lenda viva. Patamar mais alto da música mundial. Saúde Mister Dylan.🎸☮️
He has this in common with Paul Simon. They don't just do carbon copies of the recorded versions of tracks. These are their songs, and they'll sing them how they like, and if you don't like it, put on a CD. Dylan is astonishing. You wonder if he was around today whether he would be able to succeed. All I know is that, like @papaniels35 says, he ain't gonna win any prizes for his voice, and all the other things you can say about him, but here he is, still doing something that transcends all of that.
GOD'S GIFTED 144OOO. BIBLE. WRITTEN IN THE STARS AND THE GOOD BOOK. REVALATIONS. 😊❤LOVE BOB ,GOOD OLE BOY FROM MN😊❤
😂😂😂😂😂... I love you Annabelle❤
@@BobDylan-091 ANNABELLE IS MY DOG, MY NAME IS KIERSTEN 😇💯🎶🔮
@@BobDylan-091 I live in MN.
@@annabellepartnerincrime5348 oh, amazing... How would my management contact you?
@@annabellepartnerincrime5348 oh forgive me! Does that mean your dog owns this TH-cam page? 😂😂😂🤣
my favourite is knocking on heavens door could listen for hours to this song
That was my sisterss favorite song. She's gone now and that song just tears me up.😢
Old is new again…this man is a L E G E N D.
Great footage, new sub!
Thank you Catlady❤
Just wanting to end up on stage. Respect for the Poet
DANKE NOCHMAL FÜR DEN SONG ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Is that Bob in a Nutie suit jacket? Yes, he deserved the Noble prize he got.
I absolutely love Bob Dylan, but this performance is a disservice to his art & inspiration
Dylan, please never die
The original song and dance man.
Bob Dylan - Forever young
Jaysus, Bob is a legend, time to give it up, sit back, put on the slippers and chill😊
He's still got something. He is a bit sleepy but he hasn't gone the full Biden yet.
The best version of this is circa 2002 they had some wild riffs in that cycle
Great bob, go bob go..
Na das Singen war noch nie seine stärke, aber gute Lieder hat er geschrieben.😉
I love you Bobby
I love you also... ❤❤❤
@@BobDylan-091
Will you be my Huckleberry?
@@pollyvaughnzimmerman1699 Yes Honey, I'd gladly be your Huckleberry😅
Bob Dylan....and everyone else
I'd like to have a meal and a chat with Bob.
@mellow With the right ammount of money,its possible..he likes money,do ya know?
Old guy ready to meet his father aka “The Chief Commander. 👿
Hey Joe Public, good luck in your singing and songwriting.
One day i’m gonna write a song like this one
I love 'Hurricane'!
Very nice musik L.K.
Dude reeeeeeeeally likes touring
The Story Teller....One and Only..
Nice audio 🙂
Bob Dyilan eterno
Somehow 🔸🔸he surpasses himself every time ---- -- -----
Dont forget the LEGEND Jim Keltner on Drums!
This has the Jimi Hendrix vibe. It sounded completely different when he played it on the European tour in October/November.
Yeah Europe version not as good. The upside is he actually played the guitar in the Europe leg for that song
@Outlaw-b7w
I'm not saying one version is better than the other. I just love how Dylans music keeps evolving.
Bob - Thanks for being you! The best!
Disfrutalo y no pienses en chorradas.....
say no more
Sounds like Dire Strait Sultans of swing
Here’s Dylan
Spillin
and thrillin without the need to be drillin
For penicillin after all
Here’s the Bard
playing his card over the yard
Without gettin barred
It must be The Fall
😎
Is he singing ? 😄
Well i was strumming along to that (it's a straightforward set of chords, isn't it,) and seems to me it was in the same key as the original on John Wesley Harding, i only mention this because a lot of musicians change the key of a song to suit their ageing vocal chords but a guess with a voice like Bob's that just isn't an issue.🙂Saw him perform back in the early 80's with Santana and British band Lindesfarne. He must have been enjoying himself cos he did an encore, with Santana and Lindesfarne as i remember, bit of a hazy memory for some reason...🤩
Like
Way to go bob!
Sounds a bit like Rhiannon by Fleetwood Mac.
❤❤❤❤❤
🌹Dziękuję serdecznie 🌹
If your nostalgia can carry you that far...
😂 "🎤🎵meh meh mehhh! Mmm meh meh!" 😂
Hey Bob, if you want me to sing back up, let me know. I'm 75. Let's do it. Thanks, Thailand Paul/Bangkok
Rock on, Mate
Bob never played that song again after Jimi released his version in the the same way
Old guys can dye their all they want, doesn't change the fact,
That they are still, a d look,
Old.
sharp axe can remember the songs
I thought cell phones are banned at Dylan concerts.
Correct. However this was the Outlaw Festival (also feat. John Mellencamp and Willie Nelson), so cameras/video generally allowed.
Jimi says he's a Poet
I think this song is the basic of the Dire Straits song "Sultans of swing" .
Looks like Frankie Howard in the thumbnail
Kako je žalosno da ljudi koji su pjevali o prolaznosti života se sad tome opiru.
he's definitely not miming
ich freue mich für ihn, daß er noch vor Publikum auftreten kann, allerdings frage ich auch, warum ausgerechnet er einen Nobelpreis bekam
bob dylan erhielt den literatur-nobelpreis für sein lebenswerk als bedeutendster lyriker der rock-musik.
For having created new poetic expressions within the great american song tradition
Hmmmm. You're obviously not acquainted with much of his work. His imagery, wordpower and use of metaphor and other literary skills have influenced countless other great and influential writers such as Bruce Springsteen etc. Treat yourself and listen to his myriad other work. Imho I believe that much of it is indeed brilliant - certainly worthy of such an award.
Retire with a shred of dignity