you should trap the top 5 managers as the managers of a top team in a league like the icelandic league or the noreigen league but also make them the national team manager of the same nation. like guardiola as a manager for an icelandic side and iceland national team, klopp for a romanian team and romania national team etc and see over like 30 years how much it effects the countries national rating and results. i think it would be interesting comparing teams in the same save competing against each other and also seeing if any domestic teams can make it far in the champions leage
I think the only way to see continued growth and progress is either to give them perfect training facilities or gradual every 5 years improvement in that area, thats the only thing I would change about the experiment if you did it again.
I'd love to see a perfect recruitment set up. Perfect scouts, chief scout, DOF, Youth coaching, youth budget etc. Don't know if that's feasible without giving a non league side loads of money though.
Just about to go do something, after finishing watching one video. But then Tom's like 'What would happen if ......... well find out in this video linked on screen'. 5 video's later, at the end of every video. So now I have to watch.
"Perfect ass man" *Nice* Perhaps also add the head of youth facilities and head of scouting as well. Two important positions for the clubs to produce and identify youth players. Maybe even change their owner's stat to perfect(though you can only find them in pre game editor) so he makes a good job for them.
You should do a video where you play as Grimsby Town and rename every player ‘Fish’ and see how long it takes for you to realise that Town are better than Lincoln.
You should do an experiment with two perfect coaches (put them at clubs like Kidderminster) and look how famous and good theyll become after 50 years (like end up at Real Madrid or something) ;)
Teams In other similar experiments with real coaches, for example when you put Klopp or pep in charge of national league teams, were doing much better (even able to get to the premier league in a shorter time). So I think the hidden tactical stats (Pressing, attacking line etc.) and manager traits (Likes to use U23 players etc.), that determine the play style of the coach have a much bigger influence on the team performance, than than the non hidden base stats. Since you probably didn’t touch them they were on the standard setting which meant that the coaches would play very average tactics which is probably the reason why the development was so underwhelming.
My first Lincoln City game was our first home game of the 02/03 season, we beat Rochdale 2-0. But I still have the programme from that game and our first match that season was a 1-1 draw against Kidderminster in the old Division 3. How time flies!
Should try this with perfect DOF/GM, as well as perfect HOYD. Recruitment likely matters more than coaching, especially at lower leagues. Or maybe multiple teams, one with perfect facilities, one with perfect coaching, one with perfect recruitment,
I think the AI will not upgrade the training facilities on a non player game ounce the club has a max of 20 in all coaching arias. Plus players will leave making it a reset at the end of each season.
It wasn't that long ago that we were tanning your beloved Imps at Seamer Road, admittedly it might have been before you were born, mid to late 90's. It's taken 2 decades for us to get to National North, playing 'home' games in Bridlington for 10 years and a swindling chairman (who did the same to Exeter and got prison time) really didn't help. Up The Boro, No Battle, No Victory.
Good Coaching Staff coupled with a Perfect Scouting Staff vs Perfect Coaching Staff with a Good Scouting Staff vs Average Coaching Staff, Average Scouting, Perfect Youth Recruitment is next experiment I would like to see.
They probably didn't need to upgrade because the board felt the best coaches where getting the best out of the team with shit facilities. You do another experiment with Kidderminster with best facilities but original coaches and then best facilities and best coaches. That should show which one has the most effect on the team overall.
Do this again but one has perfect staff with 1 star facilities, an another team with 1 rated staff an 20 star facilities. An see if this affects the teams rise to the prem
I wouldn’t of expected perfect coaches to help much in this scenario.. most players are not going to stay and grow with a club this low down, don’t have nor can hold onto high potential player, and facilities are terrible. Also they probably did touch the facilities but facilities have to be invested in just to stay the same compared to other clubs.
you should trap the top 5 managers as the managers of a top team in a league like the icelandic league or the noreigen league but also make them the national team manager of the same nation. like guardiola as a manager for an icelandic side and iceland national team, klopp for a romanian team and romania national team etc and see over like 30 years how much it effects the countries national rating and results. i think it would be interesting comparing teams in the same save competing against each other and also seeing if any domestic teams can make it far in the champions leage
This sounds epic
Yes
Maybe should've done coaches with training facilities because the really good coaches can't do much with bad facilities.
I think the only way to see continued growth and progress is either to give them perfect training facilities or gradual every 5 years improvement in that area, thats the only thing I would change about the experiment if you did it again.
I am beyond honored that you appointed me as the Assistant Manager.
How about having perfect backroom staff (managers, coaches, physio, technical director, head of youth development, scout, etc) in a non-league club?
What
I'd love to see a perfect recruitment set up. Perfect scouts, chief scout, DOF, Youth coaching, youth budget etc. Don't know if that's feasible without giving a non league side loads of money though.
The Perfect Assistant Manager's name was the best easter egg
You should try giving the Welsh league one billion but bring back teams playing in england (Cardiff, Swansea, Newport, Wrexham, Merthyr Town)
Honeslty very good idea, I like it
^^^^^^^
Dont you ever disrespect uncle Ian like that agian 😡
I wouldn't even give Ian Runaway 1 star and neither would a lot of fans who's teams he's left in shambles
Thanks James
Out of order!!
Ian’s work with palace and Blackpool was class
Ian's work was so bad that I'd rather get in a coma instead of being him
Just about to go do something, after finishing watching one video. But then Tom's like 'What would happen if ......... well find out in this video linked on screen'. 5 video's later, at the end of every video. So now I have to watch.
"Perfect ass man"
*Nice*
Perhaps also add the head of youth facilities and head of scouting as well. Two important positions for the clubs to produce and identify youth players.
Maybe even change their owner's stat to perfect(though you can only find them in pre game editor) so he makes a good job for them.
You should do a video where you play as Grimsby Town and rename every player ‘Fish’ and see how long it takes for you to realise that Town are better than Lincoln.
You should do an experiment with two perfect coaches (put them at clubs like Kidderminster) and look how famous and good theyll become after 50 years (like end up at Real Madrid or something) ;)
Idea : put the worst staff in the best club and the best staff in the worst club.
Make half the teams in the league have perfect coaches and then examine the combined improvement.
Teams In other similar experiments with real coaches, for example when you put Klopp or pep in charge of national league teams, were doing much better (even able to get to the premier league in a shorter time).
So I think the hidden tactical stats (Pressing, attacking line etc.) and manager traits (Likes to use U23 players etc.), that determine the play style of the coach have a much bigger influence on the team performance, than than the non hidden base stats.
Since you probably didn’t touch them they were on the standard setting which meant that the coaches would play very average tactics which is probably the reason why the development was so underwhelming.
Don't forget headhunting. In real life good coaches like them won't stay on bottom ladders for very long, especially on financial aspect.
The disrespect on Ian Holloway 😤
I did not expect a Tanzanian player to be in this video. Much love from Tanzania
A long time ago now but I remember when Kidderminster won the old conference but were denied promotion because their ground was shit.
My first Lincoln City game was our first home game of the 02/03 season, we beat Rochdale 2-0. But I still have the programme from that game and our first match that season was a 1-1 draw against Kidderminster in the old Division 3. How time flies!
Being a good side is a culmination of everything in football manager and in real life tbf
Should try this with perfect DOF/GM, as well as perfect HOYD. Recruitment likely matters more than coaching, especially at lower leagues.
Or maybe multiple teams, one with perfect facilities, one with perfect coaching, one with perfect recruitment,
Yes, isolate the variables.
Even better, run the scenarios with the same team, but each with one perfect variable and see which has the most impact.
I just had an idea . Over ur next experiments you should name ur regen subjects after subscribers
I think the AI will not upgrade the training facilities on a non player game ounce the club has a max of 20 in all coaching arias. Plus players will leave making it a reset at the end of each season.
so glad your popping off man love your stuff
It wasn't that long ago that we were tanning your beloved Imps at Seamer Road, admittedly it might have been before you were born, mid to late 90's. It's taken 2 decades for us to get to National North, playing 'home' games in Bridlington for 10 years and a swindling chairman (who did the same to Exeter and got prison time) really didn't help. Up The Boro, No Battle, No Victory.
Good Coaching Staff coupled with a Perfect Scouting Staff vs Perfect Coaching Staff with a Good Scouting Staff vs Average Coaching Staff, Average Scouting, Perfect Youth Recruitment is next experiment I would like to see.
As a Weymouth fan, it was enjoyable to see them perform very well in your experiment. League 1? That's about as high as ant Terra fan could hope.
Seeing us nearly get relegated is very on par atm xD
coaches and managers don't mean fuck all -- maybe perfect scouts?
im a grimsby town fan but i still like ur vids
I think the Real Save or Experiment we need is a Scarborough Athletic Save
Can you please Make a video on how to simulator seasons yourself? That would be fantastic, as i cant find any
In game editor to edit the necessary things, then just be a manager in game but be unemployed, then simulate into the future :)
Perfect coaches and perfect scouts
They probably didn't need to upgrade because the board felt the best coaches where getting the best out of the team with shit facilities. You do another experiment with Kidderminster with best facilities but original coaches and then best facilities and best coaches. That should show which one has the most effect on the team overall.
Mnoga making an appearance from @workthespace park to prem save 😭😭
I put guardiola in charge of qatar for the world cup and they did even worse that they did in real life
Perfect Ass Man sounds like a WCW wrestler from the 90s
Ian Holloway is 3.5 stars at very minimum. What a guy.
Tom, correct me if I’m wrong… but were you not part of the ‘Crouchfest’ (Crouchella)??? Toilet manager perhaps? :)
Only one of those managers right there got Blackpool to the prem, clearly the stars are the wrong way round
Do this again but one has perfect staff with 1 star facilities, an another team with 1 rated staff an 20 star facilities. An see if this affects the teams rise to the prem
Up the Boro! Yeah we started lower than Kidi.
Hi Tom, how did you "trap" them into this club?
I wouldn’t of expected perfect coaches to help much in this scenario.. most players are not going to stay and grow with a club this low down, don’t have nor can hold onto high potential player, and facilities are terrible. Also they probably did touch the facilities but facilities have to be invested in just to stay the same compared to other clubs.
How can you see the facilities levels in numbers as in your video?
Just found your channel, are you from lincoln? Up the imps
How about putting a perfect team (players, coaches, facilities) in non league
No.
Gotta love Scarborough Athletic....
It would be good a team the perfect manager and see how they do!
Maybe a perfect DoF as well!
Player retention also plays a big part in a teams success
"Perfect Ass Man" 😂
We need a perfect scouting team
Could you plz do Grantham Town cuz im from Grantham and we are terrible and I just wanna see some glory for spurs
is haji minoga on park to prem youtube vids
Ian Holloway > Tom FM... at everything.
Do Taunton in NLS since you did Kidderminster in NLN
Do perfect managers/coaches and perfect facilities.
scarborough found there danny cowley to guide them to league 1
Looks like perfect coaches are more like burden than help. Maybe you give perfect facilities to kidderminster?
Can you make world cup with from top countries that have never qualified for the World Cup
People forget that Blackpool team . 1 star damn
Does a team with perfect coaches and bad facilities, better than bad coaches with perfect facilities?
I'm from slough, wish they could be that good in real life.
Take a shot everytime he says perfect coaches
Do a bankrupt club with perfect facilities and coaches please😊
Funfact, I tried to win a mnoga kit
5:20
False correction lol
Put 16 Year Old Haaland And 16 Year Old Mbappe In either A National League Team Or their current Clubs Academy’s See who does better
coaches make very little difference, money is what makes a team good in FM
I know someone which loves Mnoga
Workthespace?
So then try again see if it happened again
Perfect coaches without the training facilities is useless my friend
Ian Holloway is 5stars
Would be nice to see what will happen if you give a team perfect facilities, apart from having perfect coaches.
Just downgrade after downgrade
why didn't you put a perfect manager?
Yall really disrespected blackpool legend Uncle Ian
Thumbs down for the Ian Holloway slander in the thumbnail.
Ian > Pep
I hate kidiminster harriers I support there rivals Hereford and I know that kiddy are dirty cheats
Dis Scarborough again and I’ll unsubscribe
Sorry I'm gonna have to dislike this video because of what you did to Ian Holloway.
Yet another simulation upload. No more actual real FM uploads. Unsubscribed
Can you make world cup with from top countries that have never qualified for the World Cup